Structure of the receptive fields of bipolar cells in the salamander retina

Hierarchical retinal computations rely on hybrid chemical-electrical signaling

Bipolar cells (BCs) are integral to the retinal circuits that extract diverse features from the visual environment. They bridge photoreceptors to ganglion cells, the source of retinal output. Understanding how such circuits encode visual features requires an accounting of the mechanisms that control glutamate release from bipolar cell axons. Here, we demonstrate orientation selectivity in a specific genetically identifiable type of mouse bipolar cell-type 5A (BC5A). Their synaptic terminals respond best when stimulated with vertical bars that are far larger than their dendritic fields. We provide evidence that this selectivity involves enhanced excitation for vertical stimuli that requires gap junctional coupling through connexin36. We also show that this orientation selectivity is detectable postsynaptically in direction-selective ganglion cells, which were not previously thought to be selective for orientation. Together, these results demonstrate how multiple features are extracted by a single hierarchical network, engaging distinct electrical and chemical synaptic pathways.

Position of rhodopsin photoisomerization on the disk surface confers variability to the rising phase of the single photon response in vertebrate rod photoreceptors

Retinal rods function as accurate photon counters to provide for vision under very dim light. To do so, rods must generate highly amplified, reproducible responses to single photons, yet outer segment architecture and randomness in the location of rhodopsin photoisomerization on the surface of an internal disk introduce variability to the rising phase of the photon response. Soon after a photoisomerization at a disk rim, depletion of cGMP near the plasma membrane closes ion channels and hyperpolarizes the rod. But with a photoisomerization in the center of a disk, local depletion of cGMP is distant from the channels in the plasma membrane. Thus, channel closure is delayed by the time required for the reduction of cGMP concentration to reach the plasma membrane. Moreover, the local fall in cGMP dissipates over a larger volume before affecting the channels, so response amplitude is reduced. This source of variability increases with disk radius. Using a fully space-resolved biophysical model of rod phototransduction, we quantified the variability attributable to randomness in the location of photoisomerization as a function of disk structure. In mouse rods that have small disks bearing a single incisure, this variability was negligible in the absence of the incisure. Variability was increased slightly by the incisure, but randomness in the shutoff of rhodopsin emerged as the main source of single photon response variability at all but the earliest times. Variability arising from randomness in the transverse location of photoisomerization increased in magnitude and persisted over a longer period in the photon response of large salamander rods. A symmetric arrangement of multiple incisures in the disks of salamander rods greatly reduced this variability during the rising phase, but the incisures had the opposite effect on variability arising from randomness in rhodopsin shutoff at later times.

Neural Circuit Inference from Function to Structure

Advances in technology are opening new windows on the structural connectivity and functional dynamics of brain circuits. Quantitative frameworks are needed that integrate these data from anatomy and physiology. Here, we present a modeling approach that creates such a link. The goal is to infer the structure of a neural circuit from sparse neural recordings, using partial knowledge of its anatomy as a regularizing constraint. We recorded visual responses from the output neurons of the retina, the ganglion cells. We then generated a systematic sequence of circuit models that represents retinal neurons and connections and fitted them to the experimental data. The optimal models faithfully recapitulated the ganglion cell outputs. More importantly, they made predictions about dynamics and connectivity among unobserved neurons internal to the circuit, and these were subsequently confirmed by experiment. This circuit inference framework promises to facilitate the integration and understanding of big data in neuroscience.

Receptive fields of retinal bipolar cells are mediated by heterogeneous synaptic circuitry

Center-surround antagonistic receptive field (CSARF) organization is the basic synaptic circuit that serves as elementary building blocks for spatial information processing in the visual system. Cells with such receptive fields converge into higher-order visual neurons to form more complex receptive fields. Retinal bipolar cells (BCs) are the first neurons along the visual pathway that exhibit CSARF organization. BCs have been classified according to their response polarities and rod/cone inputs, and they project signals to target cells at different sublaminae of the inner plexiform layer. On the other hand, CSARFs of various types of BCs have been assumed be organized the same way. Here we examined center and surround responses of over 250 salamander BCs, and demonstrated that different types of BCs exhibit different patterns of dye coupling, receptive field center size, surround response strength, and conductance changes associated with center and surround responses. We show that BC receptive field center sizes varied with the degree of BC-BC coupling, and that surround responses of different BCs are mediated by different combinations of five lateral synaptic pathways mediated by the horizontal cells and amacrine cells. The finding of heterogeneous receptive field circuitry fundamentally challenges the common assumption that CSARFs of different subtypes of visual neurons are mediated by the same synaptic pathways. BCs carrying different visual signals use different synaptic circuits to process spatial information, allowing shape and contrast computation be differentially modulated by various lighting and adaptation conditions.

Immunocytochemical analysis of GABA-positive and calretinin-positive horizontal cells in the tiger salamander retina

By using immunocytochemical techniques, we demonstrate that there are two distinct, nonoverlapping populations of horizontal cells (HCs) in the tiger salamander retina: GABA-positive cells account for about 72% and GABA-negative (calretinin-positive) cells account for 28% of the total HC somas. The calretinin-positive HCs have relatively sparse and thick dendrites: soma diameter of 19.72 +/- 0.29 microm, and soma density of 140 +/- 13 cells/mm(2), morphological features very much like the A-type HCs described in the accompanying article. The GABA-positive HCs have thinner dendritic and coarse axon-terminal-like processes of higher density: soma diameter of 18 +/- 0.18 microm, and soma density of 364 +/- 18 cells/mm(2), features that very much resemble the B-type HCs and B-type HC axon terminals in the accompanying article. By using double and triple immunostaining techniques we found that only 18% of the non-GABAergic HC dendritic clusters contact rods, whereas the remaining 82% of the dendritic clusters contact cones. This is consistent with the physiological finding in the accompanying article that the A-type HCs are cone-dominated. On the other hand, 32% of GABAergic HC dendrites contact rod pedicles and 68% contact cone pedicles, consistent with the physiological finding that B-type HCs and B-type HC axon terminals receive mixed rod/cone inputs. Detailed confocal microscope analysis shows that 4% rods, 6% principal double cones/single cones, and 100% accessory double cones contact calretinin-positive HCs, and 79% rods, 100% principal double cones, 14% accessory double cones, and 82% single cones contact GABAergic HCs. These results suggest that GABAergic and non-GABAergic HC input/output synapses differ and they may mediate different functional pathways in the outer retina.

Electrical coupling, receptive fields, and relative rod/cone inputs of horizontal cells in the tiger salamander retina

Light responses, dendritic/axonal morphology, receptive field diameters, patterns of dye coupling, and relative rod/cone inputs of various types of horizontal cells (HCs) were studied using intracellular recording and Lucifer yellow/neurobiotin dye injection methods in the flatmount tiger salamander retina. Three physiologically and morphologically distinct types of HC entities were identified. 1) The A-type HCs are somas that do not bear axons, with average (+/-SE) soma diameters of 20.01 +/- 0.59 microm, relatively sparse and thick dendrites, and they resemble the A-type HC in mammals. The average receptive field diameter of these cells is 529.6 +/- 10.87 microm and they receive inputs predominantly from cones. 2) The B-type HCs are broad-field somas that bear thin and long axons, with average soma diameters of 17.67 +/- 0.38 microm, thinner dendrites of higher density, and they resemble the B-type HC in mammals. The average receptive field diameter of these cells is 1,633.55 +/- 37.34 microm and they receive mixed inputs from rods and cones. 3) The B-type HC axon terminals are broad-field, coarse axon terminal processes and they resemble the B-type HC axon terminal in rabbits. The average receptive field diameter of these axon terminals is 1,291.67 +/- 24.02 microm and they receive mixed inputs from rods and cones. All these types of HC are dye-coupled with adjacent HCs of the same type. Additionally, B-type HCs and axon terminals are dye-coupled with subpopulations of bipolar cells whose axon terminals ramify in the proximal half of the inner plexiform layer, raising the possibility that these HCs may send feedforward antagonistic surround responses to depolarizing bipolar cells through electrical synapses.

Signal transmission from cones to amacrine cells in dark- and light-adapted tiger salamander retina

Amacrine cells (ACs) are third-order interneurons in the retina that mediate antagonistic surround inputs to retinal ganglion cells and motion-related signals in the inner retina. Previous studies have revealed that rod-to-AC signals in dark-adapted retina are mediated by a nonlinear high-gain synaptic pathway. In this study, we investigated how cone signals are transmitted to ACs under dark- and light-adapted conditions. By using the spectral subtraction method, we found that the voltage gain of the cone-AC synaptic pathway in dark-adapted salamander retina (GD) is between 28 and 72, which is about one order of magnitude lower than the voltage gain of the rod-AC pathway. This suggests that, in darkness, rod signals are more efficiently transmitted to the ACs than cone signals. The voltage gain of the cone-AC synaptic pathway in the presence of 500 nm/-2.4 background light, GL, ranges between 28 and 56. Linear regression analysis indicates that GD and GL are strongly, positively, and linearly correlated. The average GL/GD ratio is 0.73, suggesting that, on average, GL in any given AC is about 73% of GD. This adaptation-induced change in cone-AC voltage gain exemplifies use-dependent modulations of synaptic transmission in the retina, and possible mechanisms underlying light-mediated alterations of retinal synaptic function are discussed.

Electrical synapses: a dynamic signaling system that shapes the activity of neuronal networks

Gap junctions consist of intercellular channels dedicated to providing a direct pathway for ionic and biochemical communication between contacting cells. After an initial burst of publications describing electrical coupling in the brain, gap junctions progressively became less fashionable among neurobiologists, as the consensus was that this form of synaptic transmission would play a minimal role in shaping neuronal activity in higher vertebrates. Several new findings over the last decade (e.g. the implication of connexins in genetic diseases of the nervous system, in processing sensory information and in synchronizing the activity of neuronal networks) have brought gap junctions back into the spotlight. The appearance of gap junctional coupling in the nervous system is developmentally regulated, restricted to distinct cell types and persists after the establishment of chemical synapses, thus suggesting that this form of cell-cell signaling may be functionally interrelated with, rather than alternative to chemical transmission. This review focuses on gap junctions between neurons and summarizes the available data, derived from molecular, biological, electrophysiological, and genetic approaches, that are contributing to a new appreciation of their role in brain function.

Goalpha labels ON bipolar cells in the tiger salamander retina

By using double-label immunocytochemistry and confocal microscopy, we studied rod and cone synaptic contacts, photoreceptor-bipolar cell convergence, and patterns of axon terminal ramification of ON bipolar cells in the tiger salamander retina. An antibody to recoverin, a calcium-binding protein found in photoreceptors and other retinal neurons in various vertebrates, differentially labeled rods and cones by lightly staining rod cell bodies, axons, and synaptic pedicles and heavily staining cone cell bodies and pedicles. An antibody to G(oalpha) labeled most ON bipolar cells, with axon terminals ramified mainly in strata 6-9 and a minor band in stratum 3 of the inner plexiform layer (IPL). Stratum 10 of the IPL was G(oalpha) negative, and previous studies showed that axon terminals of rod-dominated ON bipolar cells are monostratified in that stratum. The axonal morphology of G(oalpha)-positive cells resembled that of the cone-dominated (DBC(C)) or mixed rod and cone ON (DBC(M)) bipolar cells. The G(oalpha)-positive dendritic processes made close contact with all cone pedicles and superficial contact with some rod pedicles, consistent with the idea that G(oalpha) subunits are present in DBC(C)s and DBC(M)s. The size and density of these cells were analyzed, and their spatial distributions were determined. To our knowledge, this is the first study to characterize photoreceptor inputs and axon terminal morphology of a population of ON bipolar cell with the use of a G(oalpha) antibody as an immunomarker in the salamander retina.

Functional properties, developmental regulation, and chromosomal localization of murine connexin36, a gap-junctional protein expressed preferentially in retina and brain

Retinal neurons of virtually every type are coupled by gap-junctional channels whose pharmacological and gating properties have been studied extensively. We have begun to identify the molecular composition and functional properties of the connexins that form these 'electrical synapses,' and have cloned several that constitute a new subclass (gamma) of the connexin family expressed predominantly in retina and brain. In this paper, we present a series of experiments characterizing connexin36 (Cx36), a member of the gamma subclass that was cloned from a mouse retinal cDNA library. Cx36 has been localized to mouse chromosome 2, in a region syntenic to human chromosome 5, and immunocytochemistry showed strong labeling in the ganglion cell and inner nuclear layers of the mouse retina. Comparison of the developmental time course of Cx36 expression in mouse retina with the genesis of the various classes of retinal cells suggests that the expression of Cx36 occurs primarily after cellular differentiation is complete. Because photic stimulation can affect the gap-junctional coupling between retinal neurons, we determined whether lighting conditions might influence the steady state levels of Cx36 transcript in the mouse retina. Steady-state levels of Cx36 transcript were significantly higher in animals reared under typical cyclic-light conditions; exposure either to constant darkness or to continuous illumination reduced the steady-state level of mRNA approximately 40%. Injection of Cx36 cRNA into pairs of Xenopus oocytes induced intercellular conductances that were relatively insensitive to transjunctional voltage, a property shared with other members of the gamma subclass of connexins. Like skate Cx35, mouse Cx36 was unable to form heterotypic gap-junctional channels when paired with two other rodent connexins. In addition, mouse Cx36 failed to form voltage-activated hemichannels, whereas both skate and perch Cx35 displayed quinine-sensitive hemichannel activity. The conservation of intercellular channel gating contrasts with the failure of Cx36 to make hemichannels, suggesting that the voltage-gating mechanisms of hemichannels may be distinct from those of intact intercellular channels.

Response sensitivity and voltage gain of the rod- and cone-bipolar cell synapses in dark-adapted tiger salamander retina

Response sensitivity and voltage gain of the rod- and cone-bipolar cell synapses in dark-adapted tiger salamander retina. J. Neurophysiol. 78: 2662-2673, 1997. Rods, cones, and bipolar cells were recorded in superfused, flat-mounted isolated retinas of the larval tiger salamander, Ambystoma tigrinum, under dark-adapted conditions. Voltage responses of 24 rods, 15 cones, and 41 bipolar cells in dark-adapted retinas to 500 nm light steps of various intensities were listed and fitted with hyperbolic functions, and their step sensitivities and relative sensitivities (log sigma) were estimated. In the linear response-intensity ranges, the step sensitivity of rods, SS(rod), is -1.0 mV photon-1 micron2 s or 0.034 mV Rh*-1 s rod and that of the cones, SS(cone), is approximately 0. 00146 mV photon-1 micron2 s or 0.000048 mV Rh*-1 s rod. The rod and cone responses were relatively homogenous with little variations in response amplitude and sensitivity. In contrast, bipolar cell responses were heterogenous with large variations in response amplitude and sensitivity. The maximum response amplitude of bipolar cells varied from 5 to 25 mV, and the relative response sensitivity (log sigma) varied >6 log units (-8.11 to -2.32). The step sensitivity of bipolar cells in the linear response-intensity range varied from 0.0000438 to 51.82 mV photon-1 micron2 s. Bipolar cells in dark-adapted tiger salamander retinas fell into two groups according to their relative sensitivities with very few cells falling in the intermediate light intensity region. The mixed bipolar cells (DBCM and HBCM) exhibited relative response sensitivity ranged from -8.11 to -5.54, and step sensitivity ranged from 1.22 to 51.82 mV photon-1 micron2 s. The cone-driven bipolar cells (DBCC and HBCC) exhibited relative response sensitivity ranged from -3.45 to -2.32, and step sensitivity ranged from 0.0000438 to 0. 00201 mV photon-1 micron2 sec. The chord voltage gain of the rod-DBCM or rod-HBCM synapses near the rod dark membrane potential ranged from 1.14 to 48.43 and that of the cone-DBCC or cone-HBCC synaptic gain near the cone dark membrane potential ranged from 0.03 to 1.38. The highest voltage gains were found near the rod or cone dark membrane potentials. By the use of linear subtraction method, we studied the synaptic inputs from cones to five mixed bipolar cells, and the voltage gains of the cone synapses in each of the bipolar cells were very close to the voltage gain of the rod synapses. This result suggests that although the responses of mixed bipolar cells are mediated mainly by rods when lights of short and medium wavelengths are used, their responses to long wavelength lights (>650 nm) are mediated by both rods and cones with comparable synaptic gains. Functional roles of the mixed and cone-driven bipolar cells in information processing in dark-adapted retinas are discussed.

Syncytial integration by a network of coupled bipolar cells in the retina

A model system for syncytial integration is the outer vertebrate retina, where graded signals or electrotonic potentials interact laterally via gap junctions to form an integrated response that is relayed by chemical synapses to the next layer of interconnected cells. Morphological and physiological experiments confirm that bipolar cells form quasisyncytial lattices, and so this review will aim to address two important issues: the function of coupling in visual information processing and the construction of a robust mathematical model that can adequately simulate signal spread in the bipolar cell syncytium. It is shown that the role of coupling in bipolar cells differs from that associated in the presynaptic networks, namely, loss in spatial resolution in order to increase the signal-to-noise ratio. The intrinsic membrane properties of bipolar cells which give rise to voltage-dependent currents are inactive over the normal in vivo operating range of membrane potential and may be shunted as a direct result of electrotonic coupling, suppressing any possibility of action potential propagation in the bipolar cell syncytium. It is therefore speculated that the mechanisms underlying processing of information in bipolar networks are dependent on the structure of bipolar cells and in particular, on the presence of gap junctions. It is proposed that a three-dimensional model which incorporates the spatial properties of each bipolar cell in the network in the form of a leaky cable is the most likely model to simulate signal spread in the bipolar cell syncytium in vivo. This is because discrete network models represent each bipolar cell in the syncytium as isopotential units without any spatial structure, and thus are unable to reproduce the temporal characteristics of electrotonic potential spread within the central receptive field of bipolar cells.

Dual component in receptive field centre of bipolar cells in carp retina

Receptive field centre profiles of depolarizing (ON-) and hyperpolarizing (OFF-) bipolar cells in dark adapted carp retina were determined by using a narrow slit of light. The spatial decline of the photoresponse was found to consist of double exponential function with small and large length constants, about 100 microns and 1 mm, respectively. These were only observed in dark adapted retinae where antagonistic surround responses were not observed. These findings suggest dual sites of electrical coupling, one among dendrites and the other among axon terminals. The gap junctional conductance of the axon terminals was estimated to be 100 times larger than that of the dendrites.

How neural interactions form neural responses in the salamander retina

A wide range of experimental data characterizing properties of individual salamander retinal cells and synaptic interactions are integrated to form a quantitative computational model of visual function in the salamander retina. The model is used to show how specific interactions between neurons and between networks of neurons can lead-to the integrated response behavior of individual cells deep in the retina. The model is also used to illustrate how the representation of moving and stationary stimuli is encoded in a series of layer-by-layer transformations leading to the final retinal output at the ganglion cell layer.

Similar effects of carbachol and dopamine on neurons in the distal retina of the tiger salamander

Though there is considerable evidence that dopamine is an important retinal neuromodulator that mediates many of the changes in the properties of retinal neurons that are normally seen during light adaptation, the mechanism by which dopamine release is controlled remains poorly understood. In this paper, we present evidence which indicates that dopamine release in the retina of the tiger salamander, Ambystoma tigrinum, is driven excitatorily by a cholinergic input. We compared the effects of applying carbachol to those of dopamine application on the responses of rods, horizontal cells, and bipolar cells recorded intracellularly from the isolated, perfused retina of the tiger salamander. Micromolar concentrations of dopamine reduced the amplitudes of rod responses throughout the rods' operating range. The ratio of amplitudes of the cone-driven to rod-driven components of the responses of both horizontal and bipolar cells was increased by activation of both D1 and D2 dopamine receptors. Dopamine acted to uncouple horizontal cells and also off-center bipolar cells, the mechanism in the case of horizontal cells depending only upon activation of D1 receptors. Carbachol, a specific cholinomimetic, applied in five- to ten-fold higher concentrations, produced effects that were essentially identical to those of dopamine. These effects of carbachol were blocked by application of specific dopamine blockers, however, indicating that they are mediated secondarily by dopamine. We propose that the dopamine-releasing amacrine cells in the salamander are under the control of cells, probably amacrine cells, which secrete acetylcholine as their transmitter.

The network properties of bipolar-bipolar cell coupling in the retina of teleost fishes

Retinal bipolar cells exhibit a center-surround antagonistic receptive field to a light stimulus (Werblin & Dowling, 1969; Kaneko, 1970), and thus constitute an early stage of spatial information processing. We injected Lucifer Yellow and a small biotinylated tracer, biocytin, into bipolar cells of the teleost retina to examine electrical coupling in these cells. Lucifer-Yellow coupling was observed in one of 55 stained bipolar cells; the coupling pattern was one injected bipolar cell and three surrounding cells. Biocytin coupling was observed in 16 of 55 stained bipolar cells, six of which were ON center and ten OFF center. Although biocytin usually coupled to three to six bipolar cells, some OFF-center bipolar cells showed strong coupling to more than 20 cells. The biocytin-coupled bipolar cells were morphologically homologous. Membrane appositions resembling gap junctions were found between dendrites and between axon terminals of neighboring bipolar cells. In the strongest biocytin-coupled bipolar cells, the contacts between bipolar cells and cone photoreceptor cells were examined after reconstruction of the dendritic trees of five well-stained, serially sectioned OFF-center bipolar cells. Each of these bipolar cells was in contact with different numbers of cones: 11 to 20 for twin cones and two to four for single cones. This implies that, although these bipolar cells belong to the same category, the signal inputs differ among bipolar cells. Numerical simulation conducted on a hexagonal array network model demonstrated that the electrical coupling of bipolar cells can decrease the difference in input (approximately 80%) without causing significant loss of spatial resolution. Our results suggest that electrical coupling of bipolar cells has the advantage of decreasing the dispersion of input signals from cones, and permits bipolar cells of the same class to respond to light with similar properties.

Localization and modulatory actions of zinc in vertebrate retina

Zinc ions are colocalized with glutamatergic synaptic vesicles in vertebrate photoreceptors and may act as a diffusible molecular switch regulating neurotransmitter signaling at two distinct sites in the outer retina. In the dark, extracellular zinc acts presynaptically at rods and cones to minimize the depletion of tonically released glutamate, and selectively reduces GABA-mediated depolarization in horizontal cells, accelerating the response kinetics of the second-order cells. The discovery of zinc ions in photoreceptors provides a mechanism for gain control, kinetics modulation, and the balance of rod vs cone output at the first synapse in the visual system.

Modulation of transmission gain by protons at the photoreceptor output synapse

Synaptic transmission of the light response from photoreceptors to second-order cells of the retina was studied with the whole-cell patch-clamp technique in tiger salamander (Ambystoma tigrinum) retinal slices. Synaptic strength is modulated by extracellular pH in a striking manner: Light-sensitive postsynaptic currents in horizontal and bipolar cells were found to be exponential functions of pH, exhibiting an e-fold increase per 0.23 pH unit over the pH range from 7 to 8. Calcium channel currents in isolated photoreceptors were measured and also exhibited proton sensitivity. External alkalinization from pH 7 to 8 shifted the voltage dependence of channel activation negative by 12 mV. A model of the synaptic transfer function suggested that presynaptic Ca channels could be the primary sites of proton action. Increased Ca influx and transmitter release brought about by alkalinization give rise to larger postsynaptic currents. These results suggest that activity-dependent interstitial pH changes known to occur in the retina, while not alleviating signal clipping at this synapse, may provide an adaptative mechanism controlling gain at the photoreceptor output synapse.

Synaptic transmission in the retina

A recent highlight in the study of the retina has been the publication of evidence that the response of the ON bipolar cells is generated by a cGMP-mediated second messenger system. This GTP-binding protein mechanism is activated by the binding of glutamate, the photoreceptor neurotransmitter, to the 2-amino-4-phosphonobutyrate (APB) class of receptor.