Efectividad del tratamiento con bromuro de tiotropio en pacientes con enfermedad pulmonar obstructiva crónica

[Individually-tailored treatment of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a proposed change]

Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is a highly prevalent but poorly defined disease and there is wide confusion regarding its treatment. The available knowledge should allow guidelines for specific treatment to be established according to each patient's clinical features. The present article describes a proposal for individually-tailored treatment. Long-acting bronchodilators, alone or in various combinations, would be the basis of treatment and inhaled corticosteroids (IC) should be used in a subgroup with well-defined characteristics. The latest studies indicate that the benefits of IC are limited in COPD and that the risks are not inconsiderable. Consequently, these drugs should be limited to "responders" and should always be administered in association with a long-acting beta(2) bronchodilator. The pathogenesis of this disease should be studied in greater depth and patients should be classified according to their severity, the frequency of acute exacerbations, their reversibility, comorbidity and concomitant medication in order to choose the most appropriate treatment.

[Calculation of morbidity, use of resources and costs of patients treated with tiotropium bromide for COPD in a Spanish population]

OBJECTIVE

To determine the co-morbidity and economic impact of treatment with tiotropium bromide (TB) for COPD, in a population cared for by Spanish primary care teams (PCTs) and specialist physicians, in the context of routine clinical practice.

DESIGN

Retrospective multi-centre study.

SETTING

Four PCTs and 2 urban hospitals.

PARTICIPANTS

Patients with COPD receiving regular treatment with TB, during 2004.

MAIN MEASUREMENTS

Age and sex, episodes of co-morbidity, clinical parameters, resource use, and pharmacological groups. The costs model was established by differentiating semi-fixed from variable costs (pharmacy, tests, referrals) in the PCTs, as well as the visits, emergencies and hospital admissions occurring in the hospitals. A logistical regression analysis was made to correct the model. The costs were contrasted by analysis of covariance (ANCOVA), with the estimation of marginal means (Bonferroni adjustment).

RESULTS

Of 900 patients with COPD, 14.3% (n=129) received treatment with TB (95% CI, 12.0%-16.6%). The mean episodes/patient/year was 2.1 (1.4) versus 1.8 (1.3) (NS), seriousness/severity 41.3% versus 26.3% (P =.001), defined daily dose (DDD) 5928.5 (9624.1) versus 6187.7 (12471.3) (NS) and number visits/patient/year 15.1 (9.4) versus 17.3(11.9) (P=.044). After adjustments for age and sex, TB use was associated with Diabetes Mellitus (OR=1.6; 95% CI, 1.0-2.5; P=.034) and severity of patients' illness (OR=1.8; 95% CI, 1.2-2.8; P=.004). Quantification of unit cost/year was 2793.16 (3166.30) euros (3359.27 [3423.25] euros versus 2703.09 [3113.75] euros; P=.001). The adjusted patient cost/year was 2831.23 euros (SE, 217.32) with TB versus 2786.86 euros (SE, 88.53) without TB (NS).

CONCLUSIONS

TB is associated, as therapy complementing routine treatment, with the presence of Diabetes, and with the severity of the disease. The costs of COPD entail high resource consumption. The prescription of TB does not imply greater overall cost of the disease.

Management and analysis of out-of-hospital health-related responses to simultaneous railway explosions in Madrid, Spain

OBJECTIVES

On 11 March 2004, 10 simultaneous explosions at four different locations of the rail network in Madrid caused 198 deaths and 2312 persons were injured. The aim of this manuscript is to describe the prehospital health-related activities from the Emergency Medical Service of Madrid and to analyze the responses, the major conclusions, and the lessons learned.

METHODS

Three meetings were held with professionals from the Emergency Medical Service of Madrid who were involved in the catastrophe. Two experts in quality management chaired the meetings. Detailed data were gathered on what occurred at the sites following the explosions. Additional data were gathered from professionals from the Coordination Service of Urgencies and from those who assisted relatives and friends of victims in the days following the bombings. All of the data were collected and were included in the final report.

RESULTS

We describe the activities carried out by the Coordination Service of Urgencies at each site immediately after the explosions and during the 11 days following the catastrophe. The successful performances and those that need to be improved at the four sites and elsewhere are detailed.

CONCLUSIONS

The main reasons for the 'positive responses' are the number of resources that acted, the professional abilities, and the flexibility of the services. The 'areas to be improved' are communications, the establishment of the top of the command at each site, and the organization of supplies for catastrophic assistance. From the analysis, we describe the main lessons learned and we present proposals for improvement, should a future catastrophe occur.

[Evaluation of the care of the elderly program in frail elderly individuals with COPD in primary care centers in Sabadell (Spain)]

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the effectiveness of the "Care of the Elderly" program developed by primary care teams in improving the quality of life of frail elderly individuals with a diagnosis of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) living in Sabadell (Spain) compared with that of patients receiving routine care.

METHOD

A quasi-experimental study with an experimental and a control group was performed in the nursing consultation service of 6 randomly selected primary care centers in Sabadell. The variables studied were quality of life measured by the EuroQuol (EQ-5D), the impact of COPD on health status measured by the St. George's respiratory questionnaire (SGRQ), the number of visits to the center and the emergency department, and hospital admissions. The study was performed over a 2-year period.

RESULTS

The mean age of the 203 patients studied was 74.94 years (standard deviation [SD] = 6.11). The intervention was not effective in improving quality of life as measured by the EQ-5D, or in reducing the impact of COPD on health status measured by the SGRQ, or the number of visits to the center and hospital admissions. A statistically significant impact was found on the number of visits to the emergency department (p = 0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

The "Care of the Elderly" program in frail elderly individuals with COPD was not effective. The present study is of use in identifying aspects that are ineffective so that nurses designing future programs and studies can include new aspects such as treatment adherence, smoking cessation, and patient satisfaction.