Optimising the use of tazarotene in clinical practice: consensus statement from the European advisory panel for tazarotene (Zorac TM)

Managing Scalp Psoriasis: An Evidence-Based Review

BACKGROUND

Scalp psoriasis is commonly the initial presentation of psoriasis, and almost 80 % of patients with psoriasis will eventually experience it.

OBJECTIVE

Although several systematic reviews and guidelines exist, an up-to-date evidence-based review including more recent progress on the use of biologics and new oral small molecules was timely.

METHODS

Of the 475 studies initially retrieved from PubMed and the 845 from Embase (up to May 2016), this review includes 27 clinical trials, four papers reporting pooled analyses of other clinical trials, ten open-label trials, one case series, and two case reports after excluding non-English literature.

RESULTS

To our knowledge, few randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are conducted specifically in scalp psoriasis. Topical corticosteroids provide good effects and are usually recommended as first-line treatment. Calcipotriol-betamethasone dipropionate is well tolerated and more effective than either of its individual components. Localized phototherapy is better than generalized phototherapy on hair-bearing areas. Methotrexate, cyclosporine, fumaric acid esters, and acitretin are well-recognized agents in the treatment of psoriasis, but we found no published RCTs evaluating these agents specifically in scalp psoriasis. Biologics and new small-molecule agents show excellent effects on scalp psoriasis, but the high cost of these treatments mean they may be limited to use in extensive scalp psoriasis.

CONCLUSIONS

More controlled studies are needed for an evidence-based approach to scalp psoriasis.

Management of psoriasis: the position of retinoid drugs

Oral synthetic retinoids have been established as effective systemic therapy for psoriasis since their introduction for clinical use in the 1970s; a compound for topical use, tazarotene has been recently marketed. Despite the demonstrated clinical success of retinoid therapy in psoriasis, its mechanism of action has not been fully elucidated, and investigators are confronted with two paradoxes. One is that the binding of retinoids to nuclear retinoic acid receptors (RARs) does not match their therapeutic efficacy: acitretin activates the three receptor subtypes, RAR-alpha, -beta and -gamma, without measurable receptor binding, whereas tazarotene preferentially binds to and activates RAR-beta and -gamma in preference to RAR-alpha. The other is that there is already increased formation of retinoic acid in the psoriatic lesion. Answering these questions should result in better use of these drugs in the treatment of psoriasis. Oral administration of acitretin remains one of the first therapeutic choices for severe psoriasis, particularly in association with ultraviolet light therapy, of which it may decrease the carcinogenic risk. Topical tazarotene is suitable for moderate plaque psoriasis. Its efficacy and tolerability can be enhanced by the addition of topical corticosteroids; its irritative potential is counterbalanced by a sustained therapeutic effect after the treatment is stopped.

Psoriasis of the face and flexures

Facial and flexural psoriasis may impair the quality of life of psoriatic patients considerably. For the adequate management of psoriasis it is important to pay attention to lesions at these sensitive sites, which require an approach different to that for lesions on other sites in several respects. An extensive literature search was carried out to collect evidence-based data on facial and flexural psoriasis with respect to epidemiology, clinical aspects, pathogenetic factors and various treatments. Subsequently, a panel of experts, the Copenhagen Psoriasis Working Group (CPWG), discussed these aspects and several recommendations were formulated reconciling the evidence-based data. Facial psoriasis occurs in 17-46% of psoriatics and flexural psoriasis is experienced by 6.8-36% of patients with psoriasis. Therefore, psoriasis at these sites cannot be regarded as a rare manifestation. Facial psoriasis is a prognostic marker indicating a poor prognosis of psoriasis. Facial and flexural psoriasis cannot be regarded as distinct disease entities but rather as site variations. The clinical features of facial psoriasis suggest that there are three subtypes: hairline psoriasis, sebo-psoriasis and true facial psoriasis. Otitis externa and ocular manifestations should not be neglected. Evidence that microbiological factors may be relevant to facial and flexural psoriasis is virtually absent. For facial psoriasis the response to UV radiation is variable. At least 5% of psoriatics have photosensitive psoriasis. In these patients photosensitive diseases such as lupus erythematodes and polymorphic light eruption have to be excluded. Based on the literature assessment and working group discussions the CPWG concluded the following. (1) Low-potency topical corticosteroids, vitamin D3 analogues and calcineurin inhibitors are first choice treatments in facial and flexural psoriasis. Evidence for the efficacy of the first two modalities is at level 3 while it is at level 1 for the third one. An individualized approach is indicated; for example, in case of corticosteroid side effects in the past the other two modalities should be selected and in unstable psoriasis prone to irritation, monotherapy with vitamin D3 analogues should be avoided. (2) Antimicrobial treatments are not indicated for facial and flexural psoriasis. (3) Dithranol and tar treatment are not indicated as first-line treatment but only if the first-line options fail. (4) In case topical therapies are not effective, phototherapy and systemic treatments are indicated. (5) For future drug development the combination of vitamin D3 analogues with low strength corticosteroids is recommended.

Comparison of Tazarotene 0.1% Gel Plus Petrolatum Once Daily Versus Calcipotriol 0.005% Ointment Twice Daily in the Treatment of Plaque Psoriasis

Tazarotene and calcipotriol are both effective in the treatment of psoriasis. An investigator-blind, bilateral comparison of 44 lesion pairs in 19 patients was conducted to evaluate the efficacy, side effects and duration of therapeutic effects of once-daily tazarotene 0.1% gel plus petrolatum with twice-daily calcipotriol 0.005% ointment in plaque psoriasis. It consisted of a 12-week treatment phase, followed by a 4-week post-treatment observation phase. At the end of the treatment phase, tazarotene-petrolatum was as effective as calcipotriol in both objective and subjective overall efficacy assessment. Calcipotriol had a significantly greater effect in reducing erythema than tazarotene-petrolatum at weeks 2-8. At week 16, tazarotene-petrolatum demonstrated a significantly better maintenance effect in all parameters. Local irritation was noted only in tazarotene-petrolatum-treated lesions. Once-daily tazarotene 0.1% gel plus petrolatum was as effective as twice-daily calcipotriol 0.005% ointment in the treatment of plaque psoriasis, but had a better maintenance effect after the cessation of therapy.

Instrumental evaluation of retinoid-induced skin irritation

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

Retinoids like tazarotene are approved for the treatment of chronic plaque psoriasis. In the beginning of topical retinoid therapy, 15-20% of the patients suffer from mild to moderate adverse reactions with burning and erythema. The aim of the study was to find predicative parameters of the individual irritative potential and to suggest options to reduce these initial irritations.

METHODS

Twenty in-patients with different skin types (1 + 2: 11, 3 + 4: 9), with chronic plaque psoriasis were included in this open study. In each patient, 7 randomized plaques on the forearm were treated for 14 days on different ways: test area 1: morning (m) and evening (e) placebo, test area 2: placebo (m) and tazarotene 0.05% (e), test area 3: placebo (m) and tazarotene 0.1% (e), test area 4: calcipotriol (m) and calcípotriol (e), test area 5: mometasone furoate (m) and tazarotene 0.05% (e), test area 6: mometasone furoate (m) and tazarotene 0,1% (e), test area 7: placebo (m) and tazarotene in increasing concentrations (e), test area 8: healthy skin for control. Before and after therapy, skin barrier function, blood flow and plaque thickness in 20-MHz sonography were assessed in different test areas intraindividually by non- invasive biophysical measurements.

RESULTS

After 14 days of therapy, tazarotene 0.05% and 0.1% produced a stronger increase of laser Doppler flow in patients with skin type 1 and 2 than in patients with skin type 3 and 4. When using the combination therapy of tazarotene and mometasone, the laser Doppler flow was significantly lower than in tazarotene as monotherapy. 20-MHz-ultrasound showed a significant decrease in the thickness of the echo-poor band in all topical therapy regimens compared to placebo. Patients of skin type 1 and 2 reached a higher density of the dermis than patients of skin type 3 and 4, meaning a stronger decrease of inflammatory infiltration and acanthosis.

CONCLUSION

Adapting retinoid therapy to the patient's skin type can reduce the initial irritative side-effects. During the first days, patients with skin type 1 or 2 should add a medium potency corticosteroid. Stronger skin irritation caused by tazarotene therapy increases therapy effects.

Management of scalp psoriasis: guidelines for corticosteroid use in combination treatment

Scalp psoriasis is a frequent expression of the common skin disease psoriasis, and scaling and itching are the two major complaints. Topical treatments are the mainstay of the treatment of psoriasis of the scalp, with the vehicle as well as the active ingredient relevant to efficacy, tolerability and compliance. Vehicles can be shampoos, lotions, gels, foams, creams and more greasy ointments. Active ingredients are keratolytics, coal tar (liquor carbonis detergens), dithranol, corticosteroids and vitamin D3 analogues. Some effect has also been described from topical or systemic imidazole derivatives. Topical corticosteroids remain the mainstay in the treatment of scalp psoriasis. The effects are rapid, the formulations are patient friendly and the adverse effects seem limited, although no data are available to support safety during prolonged use (more than 4 weeks). Topical vitamin D3 analogues have been available for the treatment of psoriasis since 1992. In the lotion formulation in particular, vitamin D3 analogues are a patient friendly, tolerable and effective alternative to corticosteroids, although the effects are optimal after 8 weeks, in contrast to 2-3 weeks for topical corticosteroids. Facial irritation (often temporary) can also be a disadvantage of vitamin D3 analogues, although only a small proportion of patients stop treatment for this reason. All other treatment options for psoriasis, such as tazarotene, phototherapy and systemic treatment with methotrexate, acitretin and cyclosporin are often not indicated or not suitable for treatment of the scalp. In daily practice, to make a choice from the available therapeutic arsenal for psoriasis, each patient should be examined individually. Deteriorating factors have to be excluded. For scaling, keratolysis is the first step. Subsequently, active treatment can be chosen depending on the clinical picture. When the psoriatic lesions are mainly characterised by inflammation, anti-inflammatory drugs such as topical corticosteroids are indicated. When scaling is the more important clinical feature, vitamin D3 analogues are indicated. Generally, intermittently used topical corticosteroids alternating with vitamin D3 derivatives either combined or not with liquor carbonis detergens containing shampoo is the most suitable treatment for most patients. Because psoriasis capitis is a chronic disease, long term treatment should, in addition to medical advice, also provide patient support and motivation.

Tazarotene induces epidermal cell differentiation in the mouse tail test used as an animal model for psoriasis

Disturbed epidermal proliferation and keratinization are major features of psoriatic skin lesions. The so-called mouse tail test is known as an animal model to evaluate the antipsoriatic efficacy of topical drugs with regard to the induction of orthokeratosis. The purpose of the present study was to investigate the effect of tazarotene, a novel, receptor-specific retinoid, by the mouse tail test in a direct comparison to dithranol representing a classical topical antipsoriatic compound. The tails of CFLP mice were treated with tazarotene gel (0.1%, 0.05%), dithranol ointment (1.0%), tretinoin cream (0.05%) and methylcellulose (5%) hydrogel (vehicle control) for 2 weeks. Longitudinal histological sections were prepared from the tail skin, and the degree of orthokeratosis was determined by measuring the horizontal length of the fully developed granular layer within an individual scale in relation to its total length according to a method originally described by Bosman and co-authors. The degree of orthokeratosis was significantly (p < or = 0.05) increased by 0.1% tazarotene (87+/-20%), 1.0% dithranol (75+/-26%), 0.05% tazarotene (59+/-27%), and 0.05% tretinoin (23+/-13%) as compared to untreated (11+/-6%) and methylcellulose hydrogel-treated (13+/-6%) controls. Under the conditions of the mouse tail test, tazarotene showed a strong potency to induce orthokeratosis. With regard to clinically relevant concentrations this effect was even more pronounced than that observed for dithranol.

New drugs in the treatment of psoriasis

Psoriasis is one of the most common skin disorders affecting approximately 2% of the population; the disease is recurrent and can be very debilitating. The cause of psoriasis is unknown, although it appears to be an autoimmune disease with a genetic component to its aetiology. Past topical treatments such as emollients, coal tar and dithranol have been messy, cosmetically unacceptable or of low efficacy, while older systemic therapies have suffered from significant side effects. Newer drugs with better therapeutic indexes and new antiproliferative/immunomodulatory therapies based on an increased understanding of the origins of psoriasis have brought us closer to the goal of safely and efficaciously treating the disease. This review will cover the newest topical and systemic drugs currently in use, in clinical trials or preclinical development.