Regulation of immune responses by E3 ubiquitin-protein ligases

How GRAIL controls Treg function to maintain self-tolerance

Regulatory T cells (Tregs) normally maintain self-tolerance. Tregs recognize "self" such that when they are not working properly, such as in autoimmunity, the immune system can attack and destroy one's own tissues. Current therapies for autoimmunity rely on relatively ineffective and too often toxic therapies to "treat" the destructive inflammation. Restoring defective endogenous immune regulation (self-tolerance) would represent a paradigm shift in the therapy of these diseases. One recent approach to restore self-tolerance is to use "low dose IL-2" as a therapy to increase the number of circulating Tregs. However, studies to-date have not demonstrated that low-dose IL-2 therapy can restore concomitant Treg function, and phase 2 studies in low dose IL-2 treated patients with autoimmune diseases have failed to demonstrate significant clinical benefit. We hypothesize that the defect in self-tolerance seen in autoimmunity is not due to an insufficient number of available Tregs, but rather, due to defects in second messengers downstream of the IL-2R that normally control Treg function and stability. Previous studies from our lab and others have demonstrated that GRAIL (a ubiquitin E3 ligase) is important in Treg function. GRAIL expression is markedly diminished in Tregs from patients with autoimmune diseases and allergic asthma and is also diminished in Tregs of mice that are considered autoimmune prone. In the relevant pathway in Tregs, GRAIL normally blocks cullin ring ligase activity, which inhibits IL-2R desensitization in Tregs and consequently promotes Treg function. As a result of this defect in GRAIL expression, the Tregs of patients with autoimmune diseases and allergic asthma degrade IL-2R-associated pJAK1 following activation with low dose IL-2, and thus cannot maintain pSTAT5 expression. pSTAT5 controls the transcription of genes required for Treg function. Additionally, the GRAIL-mediated defect may also allow the degradation of the mTOR inhibitor, DEP domain-containing mTOR interacting protein (Deptor). This can lead to IL-2R activation of mTOR and loss of Treg stability in autoimmune patients. Using a monoclonal antibody to the remnant di-glycine tag on ubiquitinated proteins after trypsin digestion, we identified a protein that was ubiquitinated by GRAIL that is important in Treg function, cullin5. Our data demonstrate that GRAIL acts a negative regulator of IL-2R desensitization by ubiquitinating a lysine on cullin5 that must be neddylated to allow cullin5 cullin ring ligase activity. We hypothesize that a neddylation inhibitor in combination with low dose IL-2 activation could be used to substitute for GRAIL and restore Treg function and stability in the Tregs of autoimmune and allergic asthma patients. However, the neddylation activating enzyme inhibitors (NAEi) are toxic when given systemically. By generating a protein drug conjugate (PDC) consisting of a NAEi bound, via cleavable linkers, to a fusion protein of murine IL-2 (to target the drug to Tregs), we were able to use 1000-fold less of the neddylation inhibitor drug than the amount required for therapeutically effective systemic delivery. The PDC was effective in blocking the onset or the progression of disease in several mouse models of autoimmunity (type 1 diabetes, systemic lupus erythematosus, and multiple sclerosis) and a mouse model of allergic asthma in the absence of detectable toxicity. This PDC strategy represents targeted drug delivery at its best where the defect causing the disease was identified, a drug was designed and developed to correct the defect, and the drug was targeted and delivered only to cells that needed it, maximizing safety and efficacy.

Regulation of immune system development and function by Cbl-mediated ubiquitination

Ubiquitination is a form of posttranslational protein modification that affects the activity of target proteins by regulating their intracellular degradation, trafficking, localization, and association with other regulators. Recent studies have placed protein ubiquitination as an important regulatory mode to control immune system development, function, and pathogenesis. In this review, we will mainly update the research progress from our laboratory on the roles of the Cbl family of E3 ubiquitin ligases in the development and function of lymphocytes and non-lymphoid cells. In addition, we will highlight our current understanding of the mechanisms used by this family of proteins, especially Cbl and Cbl-b, to co-ordinately regulate the function of various receptors and transcription factors in the context of immune regulation and diseases.

Genomic compartmentalization of gene families encoding core components of metazoan signaling systems

To investigate the role of gene localization and genome organization in cell-cell signalling and regulation, we mapped the distribution pattern of gene families that comprise core components of intercellular communication networks. Our study is centered on the distinct evolutionarily conserved metazoan signalling pathways that employ proteins in the receptor tyrosine kinase, WNT, hedgehog, NOTCH, Janus kinase/STAT, transforming growth factor beta, and nuclear hormone receptor protein families. Aberrant activity of these signalling pathways is closely associated with the promotion and maintenance of human cancers. The cataloguing and mapping of genes encoding these signalling proteins and comparisons across species has led us to propose that the genome can be subdivided into six genome-wide primary linkage groups (PLGs). PLGs are composed of assemblages of gene families that are often mutually exclusive, raising the possibility of unique functional identities for each group. Examination of the localization patterns of genes with distinct functions in signal transduction demonstrates dichotomous segregation patterns. For example, gene families of cell-surface receptors localize to genomic compartments that are distinct from the locations of their cognate ligand gene families. Additionally, genes encoding negative-acting components of signalling pathways (inhibitors and antagonists) are topologically separated from their positive regulators and other signal transducer genes. We, therefore, propose the existence of conserved genomic territories that encode key proteins required for the proper activity of metazoan signaling and regulatory systems. Disruption in this pattern of topologic genomic organization may contribute to aberrant regulation in hereditary or acquired diseases such as cancer. We further propose that long-range looping genomic regulatory interactions may provide a mechanism favouring the remarkable retention of these conserved gene clusters during chordate evolution.

T cell Receptor Signal Transduction in T lymphocytes

The T cell receptor (TCR) recognizes self or foreign antigens presented by major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. Engagement of the TCR triggers the formation of multi-molecular signalosomes that lead to the generation of second messengers and subsequent activation of multiple distal signaling cascades, such as the Ca+2-calcineurin-NFAT, RasGRP1-Ras-Erk1/2, PKCθ-IKK-NFκB, and TSC1/2-mTOR pathways. These signaling cascades control many aspects of T cell biology. Mechanisms have been evolved to fine-tune TCR signaling to maintain T cell homeostasis and self-tolerance, and to properly mount effective responses to microbial infection. Defects or deregulation of TCR signaling has been implicated in the pathogenesis of multiple human diseases.

How ubiquitination regulates the TGF-β signalling pathway: new insights and new players: new isoforms of ubiquitin-activating enzymes in the E1-E3 families join the game

Ubiquitination of protein species in regulating signal transduction pathways is universally accepted as of fundamental importance for normal development, and defects in this process have been implicated in the progression of many human diseases. One pathway that has received much attention in this context is transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-β) signalling, particularly during the regulation of epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT) and tumour progression. While E3-ubiquitin ligases offer themselves as potential therapeutic targets, much remains to be unveiled regarding mechanisms that culminate in their regulation. With this in mind, the focus of this review highlights the regulation of the ubiquitination pathway and the significance of a recently described group of NEDD4 E3-ubiquitin ligase isoforms in the context of TGF-β pathway regulation. Moreover, we now broaden these observations to incorporate a growing number of protein isoforms within the ubiquitin ligase superfamily as a whole, and discuss their relevance in defining a new 'iso-ubiquitinome'.

The role of E3 ligases in autoimmunity and the regulation of autoreactive T cells

The ubiquitination of proteins by E3 ligases has become an important regulatory mechanism for a variety of immune functions, including the maintenance of self tolerance and suppression of autoreactive T cell development. This review highlights recent advances in our knowledge of the functions in this context of known and potential E3 ligases, including autoimmune regulator (AIRE), TNF receptor-associated factor 6 (TRAF6), Casitas B cell lymphoma b (Cbl-b), gene related to anergy in lymphocytes (GRAIL), Itch, and Roquin. We discuss how disruptions to these molecules may contribute to the loss of T cell homeostasis and the pathogenesis of autoimmunity. We also report on the implications of the potential coordinated actions of these molecules for T cell anergy and regulatory T cell (Treg) functions. The great diversity of E3 ligases and the growing list of cellular processes in which ubiquitination plays a role make for an exciting field of research. Findings emerging from these investigations may suggest ways to exploit the therapeutic potential of manipulating ubiquitination, particularly for autoimmune disorders.

A Leishmania major response locus identified by interval-specific congenic mapping of a T helper type 2 cell bias-controlling quantitative trait locus

The propensity of naive CD4 T cells to become T helper (Th) type 2 cells correlates with susceptibility to infection by the protozoal parasite Leishmania major. Using genetic linkage analysis, we earlier identified Dice1 as a Th2 cell bias-controlling quantitative trait locus on chromosome 16. Using interval-specific congenic mapping, we now resolve Dice1 into two independent genetic loci, Dice1.1 and Dice1.2, which control Il4 expression from naive Th cells and thereby indirectly control Th2 cell bias. Interestingly, only one of the two congenic intervals containing Dice1.1 and Dice1.2, respectively, also contained an L. major response locus, indicating that L. major responsiveness can be insensitive to determinants that influence Th2 cell bias by controlling naive T cell Il4 expression. These results lay the groundwork for identifying the Dice1.1 and Dice1.2 genes controlling naive T cell Il4 expression and L. major responses, and for testing whether these control other Th2 cell–dependent processes such as worm expulsion, allergic asthma, and dermatitis.

Ubiquitin ligases in T cell activation and autoimmunity

Ubiquitination-mediated protein modifications are increasingly recognized as key regulatory events in many basic cell biology processes. A key class of enzymes called ubiquitin ligases, which has been shown to play a crucial role in the ubiquitination process, can positively or negatively regulate T cell responses. This review summarizes the recent advances defining the roles of several ubiquitin ligases in T cell activation and autoimmunity.

Degradation of Bcl10 induced by T-cell activation negatively regulates NF-kappa B signaling

Bcl10 is a critical regulator of NF-kappa B activity in T and B cells, coupling antigen receptor signaling to NF-kappa B activation via protein kinase C (PKC). Here we show that PKC or T-cell receptor (TCR)/CD28 signaling results in downregulation of Bcl10 protein levels, thereby attenuating NF-kappa B transcriptional activity. Bcl10 degradation requires an intact caspase recruitment domain and is not observed after stimulation with tumor necrosis factor alpha or lipopolysaccharides. Bcl10 downregulation is not affected by proteasome inhibitors but is accompanied by transient localization to lysosomal vesicles, suggesting involvement of the lysosomal pathway rather than the proteasome. The HECT domain ubiquitin ligases NEDD4 and Itch promote ubiquitination and degradation of Bcl10, thus downmodulating NF-kappa B activation. Since CD3/CD28-induced activation of JNK is not affected by the decline of Bcl10, degradation of Bcl10 selectively terminates IKK/NF-kappa B signaling in response to TCR stimulation. Together, these results suggest a new mechanism of negative signaling in which TCR/PKC signaling initially activates Bcl10 but later promotes its degradation.