Similarities and differences in design considerations for cell therapy and pharmacologic cardiovascular clinical trials

Stem Cell Therapy in Acute Myocardial Infarction: A Pot of Gold or Pandora's Box

Stem cell therapy for conditions characterized by myocyte loss in myocardial infarction and heart failure is intuitively appealing. Stem cells from various sources, including heart itself in preclinical and animal studies, have shown the potential to improve the function of ventricular muscle after ischaemic injury. The clinical experience from worldwide studies have indicated the safety profile but with modest benefits. The predominant mechanisms of transplanted cells for improving cardiac function have pointed towards paracrine effects rather than transdifferentiation into cardiomyocytes. Thus, further investigations should be encouraged towards bench side and bedside to resolve various issues for ensuring the correct type and dosing of cells, time, and method of delivery and identify correct mechanism of functional improvement. An interdisciplinary effort at the scientific, clinical, and the government front will bring successful realization of this therapy for healing the heart and may convert what seems now a Pandora's Box into a Pot of Gold.

Cardiac cell repair therapy: a clinical perspective

From bone marrow transplants 5 decades ago to the most recent stem cell-derived organ transplants, regenerative medicine is increasingly recognized as an emerging core component of modern practice. In cardiovascular medicine, innovation in stem cell biology has created curative solutions for the treatment of both ischemic and nonischemic cardiomyopathy. Multiple cell-based platforms have been developed, harnessing the regenerative potential of various natural and bioengineered sources. Clinical experience from the first 1000 patients (approximately) who have received stem cell therapy worldwide indicates a favorable safety profile with modest improvement in cardiac function and structural remodeling in the setting of acute myocardial infarction or chronic heart failure. Further investigation is required before early adoption and is ongoing. Broader application in practice will require continuous scientific advances to match each patient with the most effective reparative phenotype, while ensuring optimal cell delivery, dosing, and timing of intervention. An interdisciplinary effort across the scientific and clinical community within academia, biotechnology, and government will drive the successful realization of this next generation of therapeutic agents for the "broken" heart.

Cardiac cell repair therapy: a clinical perspective

From bone marrow transplants 5 decades ago to the most recent stem cell-derived organ transplants, regenerative medicine is increasingly recognized as an emerging core component of modern practice. In cardiovascular medicine, innovation in stem cell biology has created curative solutions for the treatment of both ischemic and nonischemic cardiomyopathy. Multiple cell-based platforms have been developed, harnessing the regenerative potential of various natural and bioengineered sources. Clinical experience from the first 1000 patients (approximately) who have received stem cell therapy worldwide indicates a favorable safety profile with modest improvement in cardiac function and structural remodeling in the setting of acute myocardial infarction or chronic heart failure. Further investigation is required before early adoption and is ongoing. Broader application in practice will require continuous scientific advances to match each patient with the most effective reparative phenotype, while ensuring optimal cell delivery, dosing, and timing of intervention. An interdisciplinary effort across the scientific and clinical community within academia, biotechnology, and government will drive the successful realization of this next generation of therapeutic agents for the "broken" heart.