Cartilage formation from perichondrium in a weight-bearing joint. An experimental study

Clinical feasibility of a novel biphasic osteochondral composite for matrix-associated autologous chondrocyte implantation

OBJECTIVE

Matrix-associated autologous chondrocyte implantation has been used to treat cartilage defects. We developed a biphasic cylindrical osteochondral composite construct for such use, and conducted this study to determine its feasibility for treating osteochondral lesions in human knees.

METHOD

Ten patients with symptomatic osteochondral lesions at femoral condyles were treated by replacing pathological tissue with the construct of dl-poly-lactide-co-glycolide, whose lower body was impregnated with β-tricalcium phosphate and served as osseous phase. The construct had a chamber to load double-minced autologous cartilage, serving as source of chondrocytes. Osteochondral lesion was drill-fashioned a pit of identical dimension as the construct. Chondrocyte-laden construct was press-fit to fill the pit. Postoperative outcome was evaluated using Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS) scale up to 24 months. Magnetic resonance image was taken, and sample tissue was collected with second-look arthroscopic needle biopsy at 12 months. Outcome parameters were primarily safety of surgery, and secondarily postoperative change in KOOS and regeneration of hyaline cartilage and cancellous bone.

RESULTS

No patient experienced serious adverse events. Postoperative mean KOOS in "symptoms" subscale had not changed significantly from pre-operation until 24 months; whereas those in the other four subscales were significantly higher than pre-operation at 12 and 24 months. Second-look arthroscopy showed completely filled grafted sites, with regenerate cartilaginous surfaces flushed with surrounding native joint surface. Microscopically, regenerated cartilage appeared hyaline.

CONCLUSION

This novel construct for chondrocyte implantation is safe for surgical application in knee. It repairs osteochondral lesions of femoral condyles by successful regeneration of hyaline cartilage.

REPAIR OF ARTICULAR CARTILAGE INJURY

Articular cartilage defects heal poorly and lead to consequences as osteoarthritis. Clinical experience has indicated that no existing medication would substantially promote the healing process, and the cartilage defect requires surgical replacement. Allograft decays quickly for multiple reasons including the preparation process and immune reaction, and the outcome is disappointing. The extreme shortage of sparing in articular cartilage has much discouraged the use of autograft, which requires modification. The concept that constructs a chondral or osteochondral construct for the replacement of injured native tissue introduces that of tissue engineering. Limited number of cells are expanded either in vitro or in vivo, and resided temporally on a scaffold of biomaterial, which also acts as a vehicle to transfer the cells to the recipient site. Three core elements constitute this technique: the cell, a biodegradable scaffold, and an environment suitable for cells to present their proposed activity. Modern researches have kept updating those elements for a better performance of such cultivation of living tissue.

The healing effect of bioglue in articular cartilage defect of femoral condyle in experimental rabbit model

Background

The full-thickness articular cartilage defects of knee have a poor healing capacity that may progress to osteoarthritis and need a knee replacement. This study determines the healing effect of bioglue in fullthickness articular cartilage defect of femoral condyle in rabbit.

Methods

Forty-eight male rabbits were randomly divided into four equal groups. In group A, 4 mm articular cartilage defects were created in the right and left medial femoral condyles. Then a graft from xiphoid cartilage was transferred into the defect together with a designed bioglue and the knees were closed. In group B, an articular cartilage defect was created identical to group A, but the defect size was 6 mm. In group C, 4 and 6 mm articular cartilage defects were created in the right and left medial femoral condyles respectively. The graft was transferred into the defect and the knees were stitched. In group D, articular cartilage defects were created similar to group C, just filled with bioglue and closed. The rabbits were euthanized and subgroups were defined as A1, B1, C1 and D1 after 30 days and A2, B2, C2 and D2 after 60 days. The cartilages were macroscopically and histologically investigated for any changes.

Results

Microscopic and macroscopic investigations showed that bioglue had a significant healing effect in the femoral condyle.

Conclusion

Addition of bioglue can effectively promote the healing of articular cartilage defects.

Repair of articular cartilage defects: review and perspectives

Articular cartilage defects heal poorly and lead to catastrophic degenerative arthritis. Clinical experience has indicated that no existing medication substantially promotes the healing process and the cartilage defect requires surgical replacement, preferably with an autograft. However, there is a shortage of articular cartilage that can be donated for autografting. A review of previous unsuccessful experiences reveals the reason for the current strategy to graft cartilage defects with regenerated cartilage. Autologous cartilage regeneration is a cell-based therapy in which autogenous chondrocytes or other chondrogenic cells are cultured to constitute cartilaginous tissue according to the principles of tissue engineering. Current studies are concentrating on improving such techniques from the three elements of tissue engineering, namely the cells, biomaterial scaffolds, and culture conditions. Some models of articular cartilage regeneration have yielded good repair of cartilage defects, in animal models and clinical settings, but the overall results suggest that there is room for improvement of this technique before its routine clinical application. Autologous cartilage regeneration remains the mainstay for repairing articular cartilage defects but more studies are required to optimize the efficacy of regeneration. A more abundant supply of more stable cells, i.e. capable of maintaining the phenotype of chondrogenesis, has to be identified. Porous scaffolds of biocompatible, biodegradable materials that maintain and support the presentation of the chondrogenic cells need to be fabricated. If the cells are not implanted early to allow their in vivo constitution of cartilage, a suitable in vitro cultivation method has to be devised for a consistent yield of regenerative cartilage.

Repair of porcine articular cartilage defect with a biphasic osteochondral composite

Autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI) has been recently used to treat cartilage defects. Partly because of the success of mosaicplasty, a procedure that involves the implantation of native osteochondral plugs, it is of potential significance to consider the application of ACI in the form of biphasic osteochondral composites. To test the clinical applicability of such composite construct, we repaired osteochondral defect with ACI at low cell-seeding density on a biphasic scaffold, and combined graft harvest and implantation in a single surgery. We fabricated a biphasic cylindrical porous plug of DL-poly-lactide-co-glycolide, with its lower body impregnated with beta-tricalcium phosphate as the osseous phase. Osteochondral defects were surgically created at the weight-bearing surface of femoral condyles of Lee-Sung mini-pigs. Autologous chondrocytes isolated from the cartilage were seeded into the upper, chondral phase of the plug, which was inserted by press-fitting to fill the defect. Defects treated with cell-free plugs served as control. Outcome of repair was examined 6 months after surgery. In the osseous phase, the biomaterial retained in the center and cancellous bone formed in the periphery, integrating well with native subchondral bone with extensive remodeling, as depicted on X-ray roentgenography by higher radiolucency. In the chondral phase, collagen type II immunohistochemistry and Safranin O histological staining showed hyaline cartilage regeneration in the experimental group, whereas only fibrous tissue formed in the control group. On the International Cartilage Repair Society Scale, the experimental group had higher mean scores in surface, matrix, cell distribution, and cell viability than control, but was comparable with the control group in subchondral bone and mineralization. Tensile stress-relaxation behavior determined by uni-axial indentation test revealed similar creep property between the surface of the experimental specimen and native cartilage, but not the control specimen. Implanted autologous chondrocytes could survive and could yield hyaline-like cartilage in vivo in the biphasic biomaterial construct. Pre-seeding of osteogenic cells did not appear to be necessary to regenerate subchondral bone.

Fibroblast growth factor-18 stimulates chondrogenesis and cartilage repair in a rat model of injury-induced osteoarthritis

OBJECTIVE

Osteoarthritis (OA) is the most common form of arthritis and a primary cause of disability, however, there are no treatments that can slow disease progression or repair damaged joint cartilage. Fibroblast growth factor-18 (FGF18) has been reported to have significant anabolic effects on cartilage. We therefore examined its effects on repair of cartilage damage in a rat meniscal tear model of OA.

DESIGN

Surgical damage to the meniscus in rats leads to joint instability and significant damage to the articular cartilage at 3 weeks post-surgery. At this time, animals received bi-weekly intra-articular injections of FGF18 for 3 weeks, and the knee joints were then harvested for histologic examination.

RESULTS

FGF18-induced dose-dependent increases in cartilage thickness of the tibial plateau, due to new cartilage formation at the articular surface and the joint periphery. The generation of new cartilage resulted in significant reductions in cartilage degeneration scores. The highest dose of FGF18 also induced an increase in chondrophyte size and increased remodeling of the subchondral bone.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study demonstrate that FGF18 can stimulate repair of damaged cartilage in a setting of rapidly progressive OA in rats.

Repair of porcine articular cartilage defect with autologous chondrocyte transplantation

Articular cartilage is known to have poor healing capacity after injury. Autologous chondral grafting remains the mainstay to treat well-defined, full-thickness, symptomatic cartilage defects. We demonstrated the utilization of gelatin microbeads to deliver autologous chondrocytes for in vivo cartilage generation. Chondrocytes were harvested from the left forelimbs of 12 Lee-Sung pigs. The cells were expanded in monolayer culture and then seeded onto gelatin microbeads or left in monolayer. Shortly before implantation, the cell-laden beads were mixed with collagen type I gel, while the cells in monolayer culture were collected and re-suspended in culture medium. Full-thickness cartilage defects were surgically created in the weight-bearing surface of the femoral condyles of both knees, covered by periosteal patches taken from proximal tibia, and sealed with a porcine fibrin glue. In total, 48 condyles were equally allotted to experimental, control, and null groups that were filled beneath the patch with chondrocyte-laden beads in gel, chondrocytes in plain medium solution, or nothing, respectively. The repair was examined 6 months post-surgery on the basis of macroscopic appearance, histological scores based on the International Cartilage Repair Society Scale, and the proportion of characteristic chondrocytes. Tensile stress-relaxation behavior was determined from uniaxial indentation tests. The experimental group scored higher than the control group in the categories of matrix nature, cell distribution pattern, and absence of mineralization, with similar surface smoothness. Both the experimental and control groups were superior to the null group in the above-mentioned categories. Viable cell populations were equal in all groups, but the proportion of characteristic chondrocytes was highest in the experimental group. Matrix stiffness was ranked as null > native cartilage > control > experimental group. Transplanted autologous chondrocytes survive and could yield hyaline-like cartilage. The application of beads and gel for transplantation helped to retain the transferred cells in situ and maintain a better chondrocyte phenotype.

The dual role of perichondrium in cartilage wound healing

Cartilage structures from the head and neck possess a certain but limited capacity to heal after injury. This capacity is accredited to the perichondrium. In this study, the role of the inner (cambium) and the outer (fibrous) layers of the perichondrium in cartilage wound healing in vitro is investigated. For the first time, the possibility of selectively removing the outer perichondrium layer is presented. Using rabbit ears, three different conditions were created: cartilage explants with both perichondrium layers intact, cartilage explants with only the outer perichondrium layer dissected, and cartilage explants with both perichondrium layers removed. The explants were studied after 0, 3, 7, 14, and 21 days of in vitro culturing using histochemistry and immunohistochemistry for Ki-67, collagen type II, transforming growth factor beta 1 (TGFbeta1), and fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF2). When both perichondrium layers were not disturbed, fibrous cells grew over the cut edges of the explants from day 3 of culture on. New cartilage formation was never observed in this condition. When only the outer perichondrium layer was dissected from the cartilage explants, new cartilage formation was observed around the whole explant at day 21. When both perichondrium layers were removed, no alterations were observed at the wound surfaces. The growth factors TGFbeta1 and FGF2 were expressed in the entire perichondrium immediately after explantation. The expression gradually decreased with time in culture. However, the expression of TGFbeta1 remained high in the outer perichondrium layer and the layer of cells growing over the explant. This indicates a role for TGFbeta1 in the enhancement of fibrous overgrowth during the cartilage wound-healing process. The results of this experimental in vitro study demonstrate the dual role of perichondrium in cartilage wound healing. On the one hand, the inner layer of the perichondrium, adjacent to the cartilage, provides (in time) cells for new cartilage formation. On the other hand, the outer layer rapidly produces fibrous overgrowth, preventing the good cartilage-to-cartilage connection necessary to restore the mechanical function of the structure.

A retrospective analysis of two independent prospective cartilage repair studies: autogenous perichondrial grafting versus subchondral drilling 10 years post-surgery

BACKGROUND

Experimental data indicate that perichondrial grafting to restore articular cartilage defects will result in repair with hyaline-like cartilage. In contrast. debridement and drilling results in repair with fibro-cartilage. In this retrospective study the long-term clinical results of both procedures were compared to evaluate the theoretical benefit of repair with hyaline-like tissue.

METHODS

From two independent studies patients were selected with a cartilage defect in their knee. The selection was performed using strict inclusion criteria published elsewhere [Bouwmeester et al. Int. Orthop. 21 (1997) 313]. The patients were treated with either a perichondrium transplantation (PT group, n = 14) or with an 'open' debridement and drilling procedure (DD group, n = 11). The results of both procedures after 10-11 years were evaluated using the Hospital for Special Surgery Knee Score (HSSS), X-ray examination, clinical examination and visual analogue scales (VAS) for pain during walking and at rest.

RESULTS

Both procedures resulted in a general improvement compared to the situation before the operation. After an average of 10 years in the PT group there were three failures, in the DD group none, success rates were 78% and 100%, respectively. When comparing the successful PT patients with the DD patients, there were no differences in HSSS and VAS data. Both groups showed an equal number of irregular operation surface sites on X-ray (PT 9/11 versus DD 8/10).

CONCLUSIONS

This study shows that clinically at 10 years follow-up no difference was observed between debridement and drilling and perichondrium transplantation for treatment of an isolated cartilage defect. This raises questions about ongoing research to develop methods in order to improve the results of debridement and drilling as therapy for an isolated cartilage defect in a young patient (< or = 40 years).

The role of periosteum in cartilage repair

Periosteum, which can be grown in cell and whole tissue cultures, may meet one or more of the three prerequisites for tissue engineered cartilage repair. Periosteum contains pluripotential mesenchymal stem cells with the potential to form either cartilage or bone. Because it can be transplanted as a whole tissue, it can serve as its own scaffold or a matrix onto which other cells and/or growth factors can be adhered. Finally, it produces bioactive factors that are known to be chondrogenic. The chondrocyte precursor cells reside in the cambium layer. These vary in total density and volume with age and in different donor sites. The advantages of whole tissue periosteal transplants for cartilage repair include the fact that this tissue meets the three primary requirements for tissue engineering: a source of cells, a scaffold for delivering and retaining them, and a source of local growth factors. Many growth factors that regulate chondrocytes and cartilage development are synthesized by periosteum in conditions conducive to chondrogenesis. These include transforming growth factor-beta 1, insulinlike growth factor-1, growth and differentiation factor-5, bone morphogenetic protein-2, integrins, and the receptors for these molecules. By additional study of the molecular events in periosteal chondrogenesis, it may be possible to optimize its capacity for articular cartilage repair.

Technical considerations in periosteal grafting for osteochondral injuries

Periosteum has been used clinically for biologic resurfacing arthroplasty in small series of patients for almost two decades. The author's own experience with this technique in multiple joints, including the knee, has been similar to that already reported in the literature. Observations and considerations are discussed that might help avoid failure in future applications of this technique. Indications and surgical technique, including graft procurement and fixation, and postoperative treatment and possible complications are also described. The rationale for using periosteum as a chondrogenic tissue and the factors affecting its cartilage production are also outlined.

The effect of a TCP-collagen implant on the healing of articular cartilage defects in the rabbit knee joint

Osteochondral defects in the rabbit knee were filled with a TCP-collagen mixture. In the femoral condyles a fibrous tissue was formed in the defects similar to that seen in control defects. In the tibial plateau defects were made with penetration of the underlying epiphysis. Repair tissue was formed resembling articular cartilage.

Autologous rib perichondrial grafts in experimentally induced osteochondral lesions in the sheep-knee joint: morphological results

The purpose of the present study was to examine the fate of autologous perichondrial grafts after transplantation into cartilage lesions in weight-bearing joints. Osteochondral lesions were made in the articular surface of knee joints in 36 sheep. The defects were filled with autologous rib perichondrial grafts which were secured by either collagen sponges (12 animals) or fibrin glue (12 animals). Defects without perichondrial grafts served as controls (12 animals). Following 1 week of immobilization of the operated leg, the plaster was removed and the animals were allowed to move freely. Animals were sacrificed after 4, 8, 12 and 16 weeks. The grafts were removed and investigated histologically. In contrast to weight-bearing areas and control defects, hyaline-like cartilage formation was seen in non-weight-bearing areas after 4 weeks. This newly formed cartilage revealed strong metachromasia following staining with acidic toluidine blue and reacted positively with periodic acid-Schiff, indicating de novo synthesis of proteoglycans and glycoproteins. Scanning electron microscopy and examinations with polarized light confirmed a hyaline cartilage-like architecture for the surface area as well as for the fibre orientation of the whole graft. Enzyme histochemistry for alkaline and acid phosphatase activity showed positive reactivity only at the base of the transplants.

Culture-expanded human periosteal-derived cells exhibit osteochondral potential in vivo

Periosteal cells were enzymatically liberated from human rib periostea obtained from autopsies of 37 donors with an age distribution ranging from 25 weeks of gestation to 88 years old. These cells were introduced into cell culture and subcultured when they reached confluence. After subculture, the adherent periosteal-derived cells showed a nondescript, fibroblast-like morphology in cell culture. The cells from various passages of each donor were tested for in vivo osteochondrogenic potential with three different assay methods in athymic mice: (a) inoculation assay--the cells were directly inoculated into a subcutaneous site, (b) porous ceramics assay--the cells were combined with porous calcium phosphate ceramics, and this composite graft was implanted into a subcutaneous site, and (c) diffusion chamber assay--the cells were loaded into diffusion chambers and cultured in the peritoneal cavity. Frozen-preserved and recultured periosteal-derived cells were also assayed in the same way. In cases of donors younger than 19 years old, cultured, periosteal-derived cells from up to several passages consistently formed bone and/or cartilage in each of the three assays. Frozen-preserved and recultured cells from these donors also formed bone and/or cartilage after introduction into the three in vivo assays. In cases of donors older than 22 years of age, cultured, periosteal-derived cells formed neither bone nor cartilage in vivo. Cultured muscle fibroblasts from some of the same donors did not form bone or cartilage when assayed in vivo under identical conditions. These results suggest that periosteal cells with osteochondrogenic potentials can be liberated from the periosteum of a rib of human donors up to a certain age. Importantly, this potential is retained after enzymatic liberation, cell culture, subculturing, and freeze preservation. The present results suggest that culture-expanded human periosteal-derived cells from young donors may be useful in the repair of skeletal defects to foster cell-mediated regeneration of skeletal tissues, and that this methodology can be used to elucidate cellular, molecular, and genetic disorders in various metabolic bone diseases and skeletal dysplasias.

Cartilage resurfacing of the rabbit knee. The use of an allogeneic demineralized bone matrix-autogeneic perichondrium composite implant

A full-thickness articular-cartilage defect was created in the medial femoral condyles of 32 adult rabbits. The defects were filled with demineralized bone or a composite of demineralized bone and perichondrium. Results of cartilage repair were assessed after 12 weeks of implantation. We conclude that demineralized bone matrix used as a subchondral matrix in a cartilage repair model 1) stimulates and induces subchondral bone ingrowth, 2) provides a surface on which cartilage repair can proceed, and 3) can be utilized as a platform on which perichondrium can be fixed to provide a cellular source for cartilage repair. Repair tissue that developed from perichondrium was thicker, more closely resembled normal articular cartilage, and was of a less fibrous nature than the repair tissue that developed de novo on the demineralized bone matrix.

The potential of adult human perichondrium to form hyalin cartilage in vitro

The usefulness of adult human perichondrium for the restoration of articular cartilage defects depends on the potential to form hyalin cartilage. In order to evaluate the capacity of adult human perichondrium to form hyalin cartilage in vitro, perichondrium of the rib of eight adult human beings was cultured in vitro. After removal of residual cartilage, perichondrial explants were cultured for 7 or 10 days. The explants were histologically examined using specific stains to prove the presence of glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) normal for hyalin cartilage. Clear differentiation of perichondrial cells towards chondrocytes was noted. The chondrocytes synthesized new matrix substances normally present in hyalin cartilage. This investigation supports the usefulness of adult human rib perichondrium for the restoration of cartilage defects. Due to the enormous potential of the rib perichondrium to form hyalin cartilage in vitro, even defects in joints with a rather thick cartilage layer might be restored using this biological material.

Regenerating hyaline cartilage in articular defects of old chickens using implants of embryonal chick chondrocytes embedded in a new natural delivery substance

Partial and full thickness defects were created mechanically in articular cartilage and subchondral bone of the tibiotarsal joint condyles of 3-year-old chickens. The wounds were then repaired using embryonal chick chondrocytes embedded in a new biocompatible, hyaluronic acid-based delivery substance. Controls were similarly operated on but received either no treatment or implants of the delivery substance only. Animals were killed from 1 week to 6 months postoperatively. Sections from the two groups were examined and compared macroscopically, histologically, and histochemically. Results of 6-month follow-up showed that only the defects of the experimental chickens were completely filled with reparative hyaline cartilage tissue, with no signs of inflammation or immunologic rejection. Initially the entire defect cavity, whether partial thickness or full thickness up to the deep regions in the subchondral bone, was filled with cartilaginous reparative tissue. Relatively rapid maturation occurred under the tidemark; chondrocytes hypertrophied, were invaded with vascular elements and ossified. In the superficial areas, the reparative tissue remained cartilaginous and matured as typical hyaline cartilage tissue. These results indicate that aged chicken cartilage and its accompanying thin and spongy osteoporotic bone offer a favorable host environment for embryonal cell implants.

Repair of articular defects by perichondrial grafts. Experiments in the rabbit

A defect was created in the articular cartilage of the rabbit knee leaving the subchondral bone intact. The lesion was repaired by an autologous graft of costal perichondrium and fixed with fibrin glue. The result was compared with a nontreated defect in the contralateral knee. In 26 out of 30 knees, graft fixation proved to be adequate. In the grafted group the perichondrium developed macroscopically and histologically into normal hyaline cartilage. The nongrafted defects showed only limited repair.