Thyroid paraganglioma: diagnostic pitfall in fine needle aspiration biopsy

Thyroid Paraganglioma: Our Experience and Systematic Review of the Literature on a Rare Tumor

INTRODUCTION

Primary paraganglioma (PG) of the thyroid gland is an extremely rare neuroendocrine tumor with potential for misdiagnosis. We describe 2 cases of thyroid PG, suggest a possible diagnostic and therapeutic management strategy, and present a systematic review of the literature.

CASE REPORTS

Two 67-year-old women presented similarly with asymptomatic but rapidly growing thyroid nodules in which malignancy was suspected after fine needle aspiration biopsy, "THY 4" according to the 2014 SIAPEC classification, both undergoing total thyroidectomy. Unexpectedly, immunohistochemistry showed neuroendocrine cellular architecture that was negative for common markers of well-differentiated follicular neoplasms, thyroglobulin, thyroid transcription factor 1, cytokeratins and medullary thyroid cancer, calcitonin, carcinoembryonic antigen, whereas neuron-specific enolase, synaptophysin, chromogranin A, and S-100 protein were highly expressed, confirming the diagnosis of primary thyroid PG. The patients were both discharged on postoperative day 2, without any other therapy and are currently well without evidence of local recurrence of metastatic disease, after 4 years and 3 months of follow-up, respectively.

DISCUSSION

These are the only 2 cases of thyroid PG experienced in our center which specializes in thyroid surgery. Thyroid PG is a rare neuroendocrine neoplasm first described by Van Miert in 1964 with just over 50 cases reported in the literature. Our experience is concordant with the literature that the diagnosis of the primary PG of the thyroid is challenging, due to its low prevalence and the cytologic and histopathologic similarities with other more frequently diagnosed benign and malignant thyroid tumors. Immunohistochemistry is required for definitive diagnosis but gross tumor characteristics are also helpful for diagnosis. Surgical resection is the recommended standard treatment.

The Management of Locally Invasive Primary Thyroid Paraganglioma: A Case Report and Review of the Literature

Paragangliomas (PG) are very rare neuroendocrine tumours, arising from neural crest derived paraganglia of the autonomic nervous system. Primary thyroid paraganglioma (PTPG) is a rare site of PG and only 45 cases have been previously reported. The preoperative diagnosis of PTPGs presents a challenge as the clinical, cytological and histological features overlap with more common primary thyroid cancers. A 55 year old male was found to have significant enlargement of the left lobe of his thyroid. Following lobectomy, the thyroid lobe showed unencapsulated tumour which was positive for synaptophysin, CD56 and S100 (sustentacular cells). Post-operative imaging demonstrated incomplete resection. There was no post-operative radiotherapy and monitoring was by 6-12 monthly MRI. 48 months after his surgery he is alive and well with no evidence of disease progression. The diagnosis of PTPG was only made postoperatively, and although rare should be considered in the differential diagnosis of a hypervascular thyroid nodule.

Primary Paraganglioma of the Thyroid Gland: Clinical and Immunohistological Analysis with a Literature Review

Primary paraganglioma of the thyroid is a rare neuroendocrine tumour, often mistaken for other thyroid neoplasms. Here, we describe a case of initially misdiagnosed primary paraganglioma of the thyroid and study its clinical presentation, management, investigation, and immunohistological findings. A 72-year-old male presented with a left-sided solitary thyroid lobe and isthmus nodule. Ultrasound, fine needle aspiration, and computed tomography did not provide a clear diagnosis and subsequently, a left lobectomy and isthmusectomy were performed. The initial histopathological findings of the tumour revealed positivity to chromogranin and calcitonin, suggesting a medullary carcinoma replacing the left lobe of the thyroid. In a second histopathological review at an external laboratory, the tumour cells showed positive focal staining for chromogranin, but were negative for both calcitonin and monoclonal carcinoembryonic antigen, suggesting thyroid paraganglioma. This case highlights the importance of accurate histopathological diagnosis and the need to be aware of the possibility of thyroid paraganglioma initially presenting as a thyroid nodule.

Thyroid paragangliomas are locally aggressive

BACKGROUND

Thyroid paraganglioma (TP) is a very rare neoplasm that can be misdiagnosed. We evaluated the clinical and pathologic characteristics of three patients with TP.

PATIENT FINDINGS

The records of all patients from 1981 to 2008 who had thyroidectomy with a final histologic diagnosis of TP were retrieved, and histology was reviewed by a single pathologist. Head and neck paragangliomas arising outside of the thyroid were excluded. TP accounted for 3 of all 6782 (0.04%) patients undergoing thyroidectomy during three decades. One patient has been previously reported and will not be discussed. In the remaining two patients and a surgical pathology consult case that we also describe herein, the mean age at diagnosis was 56 years (40-67) and two patients were men. Presenting features were indicative of advanced local invasion, including stridor, tracheal invasion, compression of the great vessels, and hemoptysis. The diagnosis of TP was not suspected preoperatively; in two patients, fine-needle aspiration (FNA) cytology was inadequate for diagnosis because of excessive blood. Intraoperative frozen section analysis suggested medullary thyroid cancer in two patients and oncocytic (Hurthle) cell carcinoma in one patient. Local invasion was common, requiring concurrent tracheal resection in two of three patients, and present histologically in all three patients. In all three cases, immunohistochemical analysis was negative for cytokeratin AE1/3, calcitonin, and thyroglobulin but positive for S100, highlighting sustentacular cells. After resection of a large TP with tracheal and vascular invasion, a 67-year-old woman experienced a 7-year disease-free interval.

CONCLUSIONS

Primary TP is indeed rare. It does occur in men, frequently presents with compressive symptoms, and is typically locally aggressive, but does not appear to cause symptoms suggestive of catecholamine excess. Despite invasion of adjacent structures, aggressive resection can achieve a long disease-free interval.

Thyroid paraganglioma. Report of 3 cases and description of an immunohistochemical profile useful in the differential diagnosis with medullary thyroid carcinoma, based on complementary DNA array results

Thyroid paraganglioma is a rare disorder that sometimes poses problems in differential diagnosis with medullary thyroid carcinoma. So far, differential diagnosis is solved with the help of some markers that are frequently expressed in medullary thyroid carcinoma (thyroid transcription factor 1, calcitonin, and carcinoembryonic antigen). However, some of these markers are not absolutely specific of medullary thyroid carcinoma and may be expressed in other tumors. Here we report 3 new cases of thyroid paraganglioma and describe our strategy to design a diagnostic immunohistochemical battery. First, we performed a comparative analysis of the expression profile of head and neck paragangliomas and medullary thyroid carcinoma, obtained after complementary DNA array analysis of 2 series of fresh-frozen samples of paragangliomas and medullary thyroid carcinoma, respectively. Seven biomarkers showing differential expression were selected (nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide dehydrogenase 1 alpha subcomplex, 4-like 2, NDUFA4L2; cytochrome c oxidase subunit IV isoform 2; vesicular monoamine transporter 2; calcitonin gene-related protein/calcitonin; carcinoembryonic antigen; and thyroid transcription factor 1) for immunohistochemical analysis. Two tissue microarrays were constructed from 2 different series of paraffin-embedded samples of paragangliomas and medullary thyroid carcinoma. We provide a classifying rule for differential diagnosis that combines negativity or low staining for calcitonin gene-related protein (histologic score, <10) or calcitonin (histologic score, <50) together with positivity of any of NADH dehydrogenase 1 alpha subcomplex, 4-like 2; cytochrome c oxidase subunit IV isoform 2; or vesicular monoamine transporter 2 to predict paragangliomas, showing a prediction error of 0%. Finally, the immunohistochemical battery was checked in paraffin-embedded blocks from 4 examples of thyroid paraganglioma (1 previously reported case and 3 new cases), showing also a prediction error of 0%. Our results suggest that the comparative expression profile, obtained by complementary DNA arrays, seems to be a good tool to design immunohistochemical batteries used in differential diagnosis.