Two global haemostatic assays as additional tools to monitor treatment in cases of haemophilia A

Thromboelastography and thrombin generation assessments for pediatric severe hemophilia A patients are highly variable and not predictive of clinical phenotypes

Background

Severe hemophilia A (SHA) patients vary in severity of bleeding, arthropathy, and requirements for replacement factor VIII (FVIII). Baseline hemostatic activity assays using calibrated automated thrombography (CAT) and thromboelastography (TEG) may offer insights into the physiological basis of clinical heterogeneity.

Objectives

Use CAT and TEG to measure baseline hemostatic activity in a cohort of 30 pediatric SHA patients with available clinical data. Determine effect of contact activation inhibition with corn trypsin inhibitor (CTI). Assess heterogeneity among patients for baseline hemostatic activity and examine correlations between assay results and clinical parameters including FVIII dosing regimen, von Willebrand factor level, and Pettersson arthropathy score.

Methods

SHA blood after FVIII washout was subjected to TEG, and platelet‐rich (PRP) and platelet‐poor plasma was used for CAT assays. Varying concentrations of tissue factor (TF) were used. Statistical analysis examined relationships between assay results, and clinical parameters.

Results

CTI treatment was required to obtain TEG and CAT results representative of baseline hemostatic activity. Weak activity was observed in assays with low TF concentrations (0.5–2 pM), and most but not all samples approached normal activity levels at high TF concentrations (10–20 pM). A significant positive correlation was observed between results of TEG and CAT‐PRP assays. Correlations were not detected between hemostatic assay results and clinical parameters.

Conclusions

In vitro hemostatic assay results of samples containing platelets showed concordance. Assay results were not predictive of FVIII requirements or correlated with other clinical parameters. SHA patient heterogeneity is influenced by factors other than baseline hemostatic activity.

Association of Global Coagulation Profiles With Cardiovascular Risk Factors and Atherosclerosis: A Sex Disaggregated Analysis From the BioHEART-CT Study

Background

Although the association between dysregulated coagulation and atherosclerosis is well recognized, individual assays have been of minimal value in understanding disease susceptibility. Here we investigated the association of global coagulation profiles with coronary artery disease with consideration of sex differences.

Methods and Results

The study included patients from the BioHEART‐CT (The BioHEART Study: Assessing Patients With Suspected Cardiovascular Disease for New Disease Markers and Risk Factors) biobank who had computed tomography coronary angiograms scored for coronary artery calcium score (CACS) and Gensini score. The cohort included 206 adult patients who were referred for clinically indicated computed tomography coronary angiography and had a median of 2 major cardiac risk factors; 50% were women and the average age was 62.6 years (±9.9 years). The overall hemostatic potential (OHP) and calibrated automated thrombography generation assays were performed on platelet‐poor plasma. CACS and Gensini score in men were significantly correlated in bivariate analysis with measures from the OHP assay, and regression models predicting disease severity by CACS or Gensini score were improved by adding the OHP assay variables in men but not in women. The calibrated automated thrombography generation assay demonstrated a more hypercoagulable profile in women than in men. The OHP assay showed hypercoagulable profiles in women with hyperlipidemia and men with obesity.

Conclusions

The OHP assay identified hypercoagulable profiles associated with different risk factors for each sex and was associated with CACS and Gensini score severity in men, emphasizing the associations between increased fibrin generation and reduced fibrinolysis with cardiac risk factors and early atherosclerosis.

Registration Information

www.anzctr.org.au. Identifier: ACTRN12618001322224.

Effects of rivaroxaban and dabigatran on global hemostasis in patients with atrial fibrillation

: The study was aimed to evaluate the effects of two standard doses of rivaroxaban and dabigatran on global hemostatic assays in patients with atrial fibrillation. The study included 52 patients treated with rivaroxaban (15/20 mg), 50 on dabigatran (110/150 mg) and 20 healthy individuals. Platelet-poor plasma was used for determination of three global hemostatic assays, namely endogenous thrombin potential (ETP), calibrated automated thrombogram (CAT) and overall hemostasis potential (OHP). Rivaroxaban and dabigatran reduced ETP (P < 0.01) although OHP (P < 0.05) was diminished only by dabigatran. Strong correlations were noticed between ETP parameters and the plasma concentrations of rivaroxaban (ETP, r = -0.51; c-max, r = -0.85; t-lag, r = 0.83; t-max, r = 0.66) as well as with plasma concentration of dabigatran (ETP, r = -0.75; c-max, r = -0.74; t-lag, r = 0.73; t-max, r = 0.52). Analysis of dabigatran concentrations under 50 ng/ml showed that ETP parameter has area under the concentration-time curve-receiver operating characteristic value of 0.879 (95% confidence interval 0.776-0.980). Dabigatran treatment paradoxically increased area under the concentration-time curve and peak values although rivaroxaban decreased peak values (P < 0.01). However, significant correlation between CAT parameters and plasma concentration of both direct oral anticoagulants was not observed. We confirmed that the CAT assay is inappropriate for estimation of dabigatran effects and is not fully sensitive as regards rivaroxaban. The ETP assay can potentially be the appropriate method for estimation of global hemostatic capacity as regards both direct oral anticoagulants. The role of OHP needs to be confirmed in additional studies. ETP parameter of chromogenic assay has promising potential in exclusion of high plasma concentrations of dabigatran.

The Clotting Trigger Is an Important Determinant for the Coagulation Pathway In Vivo or In Vitro-Inference from Data Review

Blood coagulation comprises a series of enzymatic reactions leading to thrombin generation and fibrin formation. This process is commonly illustrated in a waterfall-like manner, referred to as the coagulation cascade. In vivo, this "cascade" is initiated through the tissue factor (TF) pathway, once subendothelial TF is exposed and bound to coagulation factor VII (FVII) in blood. In vitro, a diminutive concentration of recombinant TF (rTF) is used as a clotting trigger in various global hemostasis assays such as the calibrated automated thrombogram, methods that assess fibrin turbidity and fibrin viscoelasticity tests such as rotational thromboelastometry. These assays aim to mimic in vivo global coagulation, and are useful in assessing hyper-/hypocoagulable disorders or monitoring therapies with hemostatic agents. An excess of rTF, a sufficient amount of negatively charged surfaces, various concentrations of exogenous thrombin, recombinant activated FVII, or recombinant activated FIXa are also used to initiate activation of specific sub-processes of the coagulation cascade in vitro. These approaches offer important information on certain specific coagulation pathways, while alterations in pro-/anticoagulants not participating in these pathways remain undetectable by these methods. Reviewing available data, we sought to enhance our knowledge of how choice of clotting trigger affects the outcome of hemostasis assays, and address the call for further investigations on this topic.

Overall hemostasis potential and aPTT-clot waveform analysis as powerful laboratory diagnostic tools for identification of hemophilia A patients with unexpected bleeding phenotype

INTRODUCTION

Traditionally used laboratory methods do not always accurately reflect bleeding severity in hemophilia A (HA) patients. The ability of three global assays for identifying patients with unexpected bleeding phenotype was investigated.

METHODS

Overall hemostasis potential (OHP), aPTT-clot waveform analysis (aPTT-CWA), endogenous thrombin potential (ETP), FVIII activities, and prothrombin fragment 1 + 2 concentrations were measured in 62 HA patients (30 severe and 32 non-severe) and 27 male controls. Bleeding phenotype was determined using our proposed scoring system including age at first joint bleed, number of target joints, and number of joint/muscle bleeds per year. Bleeding score ≤ 4 defined patients with mild bleeding phenotype (N = 27); score ≥ 5 defined severe bleeding phenotype (N = 35).

RESULTS

The receiver operating characteristic analysis performed for distinguishing patients with severe and mild bleeding phenotype yielded following values of area under the curve: 0.910 (FVIII); 0.891 (aPTT-CWA parameter DELTA); 0.769 (OHP); and 0.634 (ETP). Unexpected bleeding phenotype was identified in 11/62 HA patients: 8/32 (25%) non-severe HA patients had severe, while 3/30 (10%) severe HA patients had mild bleeding phenotype, and global assays enabled the identification of all these patients. OHP and DELTA were revealed as the most reliable parameters for bleeding phenotype determination (10/11 and 9/11 unexpected results, respectively).

CONCLUSION

This study emphasizes OHP and aPTT-CWA as a powerful laboratory diagnostic tool in identifying HA patients with unexpected bleeding presentations, with the best results achieved by combining both assays. Global assays should not completely replace FVIII activity measurement but should be a part of the HA diagnostic algorithm.

Diagnostic Accuracy in Acute Venous Thromboembolism: Comparing D-Dimer, Thrombin Generation, Overall Hemostatic Potential, and Fibrin Monomers

Introduction  For acute venous thromboembolism (VTE), a biomarker with higher specificity than D-dimer would be of great clinical use. Thrombin generation and overall hemostatic potential (OHP) reflect the hemostatic balance by globally assessing multiple coagulation factors and inhibitors. These tests discriminate between healthy controls and patients with a prothrombotic tendency but have yet to be established as clinical biomarkers of VTE.

Objective  This study compares endogenous thrombin potential (ETP) and OHP to D-dimer and fibrin monomers (FM) in outpatients with suspected VTE.

Methods  A cross-sectional diagnostic study where 954 patients with suspected pulmonary embolism or deep venous thrombosis were recruited consecutively from the medical emergency department at Karolinska University Hospital. D-dimer, FM, OHP, and ETP were analyzed in a subpopulation of 60 patients with VTE and 98 matched controls without VTE. VTE was verified either by ultrasonography or computed tomography and clinical data were collected from medical records.

Results  Compared with healthy controls, both VTE and non-VTE patients displayed prothrombotic profiles in OHP and ETP. D-dimer, FM, ETP area under the curve (AUC), and ETP T _lag were significantly different between patients with VTE and non-VTE. The largest receiver-operating characteristic AUCs for discrimination between VTE and non-VTE, were found in D-dimer with 0.94, FM 0.77, and ETP AUC 0.65. No useful cutoff could be identified for the ETP or the OHP assay.

Conclusion  Compared with D-dimer, neither ETP nor OHP were clinically viable biomarkers of acute venous thrombosis. The data indicated that a large portion of the emergency patients with suspected VTE were in a prothrombotic state.

Genetics and Hemostatic Potential in Persons with Mild to Moderate Hemophilia A with a Discrepancy between One-Stage and Chromogenic FVIII Assays

BACKGROUND

 Factor VIII (FVIII) activity (FVIII:C) can be measured by different methods including one-stage clotting assays (OSAs) and chromogenic assays (CSAs). Discrepancy between FVIII:C assays is known and associated with genetic variations causing mild and moderate hemophilia A (HA). We aimed to study the discrepancy phenomenon and to identify associated genetic alterations. Further, we investigated if hemostatic global assays could discriminate the group with discrepant FVIII:C from them.

METHODS

 The study contained plasma samples from 45 patients with HA (PwHA) from Hemophilia Centers in Stockholm, Sweden, and Belgrade, Serbia. We measured FVIII:C with OSA and CSA, sequenced the F8 gene, and performed two global hemostatic assays; endogenous thrombin potential and overall hemostatic potential.

RESULTS

 Nineteen of 45 PwHA had a more than twofold higher FVIII:C using OSA compared to CSA and were considered discrepant. Thirty-four causal mutations were detected, where of five had not previously been associated with assay discrepancy. These novel mutations were p.Tyr25Cys, p.Phe698Leu, p.Met699Leu, p.Ile1698Thr, and Ala2070Val. We found no difference between discrepant and nondiscrepant cases with either of the global assays.

CONCLUSION

 There was a discrepancy between FVIII:C assays in almost half of the PwHA, which for some could lead to missed HA diagnoses or misclassification of severity. Genotyping confirmed that mutations associated with FVIII:C discrepancy cluster in the A domains of F8, and five mutations not previously associated with FVIII:C discrepancy was identified. Global hemostatic assays did not contribute to distinguish assay discrepancy in PwHA.

Evaluation of recombinant factor VIII Fc (Eloctate) activity by thromboelastometry in a multicenter phase 3 clinical trial and correlation with bleeding phenotype

The aim of this study was to compare the hemostatic efficacy of recombinant factor VIII Fc (rFVIIIFc) (Eloctate) and Advate by ex-vivo rotation thromboelastometry (ROTEM) of whole blood and to explore potential ROTEM parameters that may be more predictive of a patient's bleeding tendency than plasma FVIII activity. Thirteen clinical sites were selected to perform ROTEM on freshly collected blood samples from 44 patients in the phase 3 study for rFVIIIFc, including 16 patients undergoing sequential pharmacokinetic assessment of Advate and rFVIIIFc. Equivalent hemostatic activity was observed for rFVIIIFc and Advate in postinfusion samples, followed by improvements for rFVIIIFc in clotting time, clot formation time and alpha angle (α) for a longer duration than Advate, consistent with the pharmacokinetic improvements reported previously for rFVIIIFc. Our study did not demonstrate a statistical correlation between a patient's ROTEM activity at baseline or at trough and the occurrence of spontaneous bleeds while on prophylactic therapy. However, an association was observed between postinfusion clotting time and the occurrence of one or more spontaneous bleeds vs. no bleeds over a follow-up period of 1 year (P = 0.003). How well a patient's whole blood clotting deficiency is corrected after a dose of FVIII may be an indicator of subsequent bleeding tendency in patients with otherwise equivalent FVIII peak and trough levels. The technical challenges of standardizing the ROTEM, largely overcome in the current study, may however preclude the use of this method for widespread assessment of global hemostasis unless additional assay controls or normalization procedures prove to be effective.

Correlation to FVIII:C in Two Thrombin Generation Tests: TGA-CAT and INNOVANCE ETP

Introduction

Several thrombin-generation tests are available, but few have been directly compared. Our primary aim was to investigate the correlation of two thrombin generation tests, thrombin generation assay-calibrated automated thrombogram (TGA-CAT) and INNOVANCE ETP, to factor VIII levels (FVIII:C) in a group of patients with hemophilia A. The secondary aim was to investigate inter-laboratory variation for the TGA-CAT method.

Methods

Blood samples were taken from 45 patients with mild, moderate and severe hemophilia A. The TGA-CAT method was performed at both centers while the INNOVANCE ETP was only performed at the Stockholm center. Correlation between parameters was evaluated using Spearman's rank correlation test. For determination of the TGA-CAT inter-laboratory variability, Bland-Altman plots were used.

Results

The correlation for the INNOVANCE ETP and TGA-CAT methods with FVIII:C in persons with hemophilia (PWH) was r=0.701 and r=0.734 respectively.The correlation between the two methods was r=0.546.When dividing the study material into disease severity groups (mild, moderate and severe) based on FVIII levels, both methods fail to discriminate between them.The variability of the TGA-CAT results performed at the two centers was reduced after normalization; before normalization, 29% of values showed less than ±10% difference while after normalization the number increased to 41%.

Conclusions

Both methods correlate in an equal manner to FVIII:C in PWH but show a poor correlation with each other. The level of agreement for the TGA-CAT method was poor though slightly improved after normalization of data. Further improvement of standardization of these methods is warranted.

Comparing thrombin generation in patients with hemophilia A and patients on vitamin K antagonists

Essentials It is unknown if hemophilia patients with atrial fibrillation need anticoagulation. Endogenous thrombin potentials (ETP) in hemophilia patients and patients on coumarins were compared. Severe hemophilia patients had comparable ETP to therapeutic international normalized ratio (INR). In non-severe hemophilia, 33% had higher ETP than therapeutic INR and may need anticoagulation. Click to hear Dr Negrier's perspective on global assays for assessing coagulation SUMMARY: Background It is unknown whether patients with hemophilia A with atrial fibrillation require treatment with vitamin K antagonists (VKAs) to the same extent as the normal population. Objective To compare hemostatic potential in hemophilia patients and patients on VKAs using thrombin generation (TG). Methods In this cross-sectional study, TG, initiated with 1pM tissue factor, was measured in 133 patients with severe (FVIII < 1%, n = 15) and non-severe (FVIII 1-50%, n = 118) hemophilia A, 97 patients on a VKA with an international normalized ratio (INR) ≥ 1.5 and healthy controls. Endogenous thrombin potential (ETP) (nm*min) was compared according to FVIII level (< 1%, 1-19% and 20-50%) with healthy controls and patients with sub-therapeutic INR (1.5-1.9) and therapeutic INR (≥ 2.0). Medians and interquartile ranges (IQRs) were calculated. Results Compared with healthy controls (898 [IQR 803-1004]), both hemophilia patients and patients on VKAs had lower median ETPs at 304 (196-449) and 176 (100-250), respectively. ETP was quite similar in severe hemophilia patients (185 [116-307]) and patients with a therapeutic INR (156 [90-225]). Compared with patients with therapeutic INR, ETP in patients with FVIII 1-19% and patients with FVIII 20-50% was higher at 296 (203-430) and 397 (219-632), respectively. All patients with therapeutic INR had an ETP < 400. Considering this threshold, 93% of severe hemophilia patients, 70% of patients with FVIII 1-19% and 52% of patients with FVIII 20-50% had an ETP < 400. Conclusion In severe hemophilia patients, TG was comparable to that in patients with a therapeutic INR. In one-third of non-severe hemophilia patients, TG was higher. These results suggest that anticoagulation therapy should be considered in a substantial proportion of non-severe hemophilia patients.

Improvement of fibrin clot structure after factor VIII injection in haemophilia A patients treated on demand

Patients with haemophilia A have seriously impaired thrombin generation due to an inherited deficiency of factor (F)VIII, making them form unstable fibrin clots that are unable to maintain haemostasis. Data on fibrin structure in haemophilia patients remain limited. Fibrin permeability, assessed by a flow measurement technique, was investigated in plasma from 20 patients with severe haemophilia A treated on demand, before and 30 minutes after FVIII injection. The results were correlated with concentrations of fibrinogen, FVIII and thrombin-activatable fibrinolysis inhibitor (TAFI), and global haemostatic markers: endogenous thrombin potential (ETP) and overall haemostatic potential (OHP). Fibrin structure was visualised using scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The permeability coefficient Ks decreased significantly after FVIII treatment. Ks correlated significantly with FVIII levels and dosage, and with ETP, OHP and levels of TAFI. SEM images revealed irregular, porous fibrin clots composed of thick and short fibers before FVIII treatment. The clots had recovered after FVIII replacement almost to levels in control samples, revealing compact fibrin with smaller intrinsic pores. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first description of fibrin porosity and structure before and after FVIII treatment of selected haemophilia patients. It seems that thrombin generation is the main determinant of fibrin structure in haemophilic plasma.

Is a decrease of microparticles related to improvement of hemostasis after FVIII injection in hemophilia A patients treated on demand?

BACKGROUND

Microparticles (MPs) are small membrane vesicles (0.1-1 μm) released from various cells after activation and/or apoptosis. There are limited data about their role in hemophilia A.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Blood samples were taken before and 30 min after FVIII injection in 18 patients with severe hemophilia A treated on demand. Flow-cytometric determination of total MPs (TMPs) using lactadherin, platelet MPs (PMPs) (CD42a), endothelial MPs (EMPs) (CD144) and leukocyte MPs (LMPs) (CD45) was performed. The results were compared with data on endogenous thrombin potential (ETP), overall hemostatic potential (OHP), fibrin gel permeability and thrombin-activatable fibrinolysis inhibitor (TAFI).

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

TMPs and PMPs decreased after treatment (to 1015 ± 221 [SEM] and 602 ± 134 × 10(6)  L(-1) ) in comparison with values before treatment (2373 ± 618 and 1316 ± 331; P < 0.01). EMPs also decreased after treatment (78 ± 12 vs. 107 ± 13; P < 0.05) while LMPs were not influenced. Both TMP and PMP counts were inversely correlated, moderately but statistically significantly, with data on OHP, ETP, fibrin network permeability and TAFI/TAFIi (P < 0.05 for all). EMP counts were correlated only with ETP (P < 0.05), while LMP counts did not show any correlation. TMP and PMP counts were also inversely correlated with FVIII levels (P < 0.05). TMP, PMP and EMP counts decreased after on-demand treatment with FVIII concentrate in hemophilia A patients. The decrease in circulating MPs, which were inversely correlated with hemostatic activation, may imply that MPs are incorporated in the hemostatic plug formed after FVIII substitution at the site of injury.

Plasmatic tissue factor pathway inhibitor is a major determinant of clotting in factor VIII inhibited plasma or blood

Tissue factor pathway inhibitor (TFPI) is a major inhibitor of coagulation. We therefore hypothesised that high plasmatic TFPI levels are associated with impaired ex vivo clotting in a model of acquired haemophilia. Blood samples were collected in a prospective clinical study from 30 healthy volunteers. Coagulation in normal or factor VIII (FVIII)-inhibited human blood or plasma was measured by the calibrated automated thrombogram (CAT) and rotational thromboelastometry (ROTEM). Both methods are global haemostatic assays that provide insight into the whole coagulation process. Monoclonal mouse antibodies raised against either the C-terminus or the Kunitz domain 2 of TFPI were used to determine full-length (fl-) and total TFPI by an enzyme-immunoassay. Clotting times and parameters of thrombin generation correlated with TFPI levels. Subjects with low fl-TFPI levels had significantly shorter clotting times and a higher endogenous thrombin potential (ETP) compared to those with high fl-TFPI levels (p≤0.005 for all). An even stronger effect was seen in FVIII-inhibited blood/plasma: ROTEM clotting time was 26% shorter (p=0.01) and the ETP assessed by CAT was >2-fold higher in subjects with low fl-TFPI levels (p≤0.0001). Plasmatic TFPI is a major determinant of coagulation in global haemostatic tests particularly when FVIII is missing. Thus, inhibition of TFPI might be a promising novel treatment approach, especially in haemophilia patients with FVIII inhibitors.