Target Indices for Clinical Ablation in Atrial Fibrillation

Role of impedance drop and lesion size index (LSI) to guide catheter ablation for atrial fibrillation

BACKGROUND

When using lesion size index (LSI) to guide catheter ablation, it is unclear what combination of power, contact force and time would be preferable to use and what LSI target value to aim for. This study aimed at identifying desirable ablation settings and LSI targets by using tissue impedance drop as indicator of lesion formation.

METHODS

Consecutive patients, undergoing their first left atrial (LA) catheter ablation for atrial fibrillation, with radiofrequency energy (RF) powers of 20, 30 and 40 W were enrolled. Tissue impedance, contact force (CF), Force Time Integral (FTI) and LSI values were continuously recorded during ablation and sampled at 100 Hz. Mean CF and Contact Force Variability (CFV) were calculated for every lesion. The effect of RF power, ablation time, CF and CFV on impedance drop and LSI were assessed.

RESULTS

A total of 3258 lesions were included in the analysis. For any target LSI value, use of higher RF powers translated into progressively higher impedance drops. The impact of lower CF and higher CFV on impedance drop was more relevant when using lower powers. Target LSI values corresponding to maximum impedance drop were identified depending on RF power, mean CF and CFV used.

CONCLUSIONS

Even in the context of an LSI-guided ablation strategy, use of lower or higher powers might lead to different lesion sizes. Different LSI targets might be needed depending on the combination of RF power, CF and CFV used for ablation. Incorporating indicators of catheter stability, like CFV, in the LSI formula could improve the predictive value of LSI for lesion size. Studies with clinical outcomes are required to confirm the clinical relevance of these findings.

Very high-power short-duration catheter ablation for treatment of cardiac arrhythmias: Insights from the FAST and FURIOUS study series

The QDOT MICRO™ Catheter is a novel open-irrigated contact force-sensing radiofrequency ablation catheter. It offers very high-power short-duration (vHPSD) ablation with 90 W for 4 s to improve safety and efficacy of catheter ablation procedures. Although the QDOT MICRO™ Catheter was mainly designed for pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) its versatility to treat atrial fibrillation (AF) and other types of arrhythmias was recently evaluated by the FAST and FURIOUS study series and other studies and will be presented in this article. Available study and registry data as well as case reports concerning utilization of the QDOT MICRO™ Catheter for the treatment of cardiac arrhythmias including AF, focal and macroreentry atrial tachycardia, typical atrial flutter by cavotricuspid isthmus block, premature ventricular contractions, and accessory pathways were reviewed and summarized. In summary, the QDOT MICRO™ Catheter showed safety and efficacy for PVI and is able to treat also other types of arrhythmias as is was recently evaluated by case reports and the FAST and FURIOUS studies.

Novel tissue-pressure sensing technology using a wide-band dielectric imaging system: An in vivo study

BACKGROUND

A novel dielectric wide-band imaging system with tissue pressure (TP) technology provides real-time contact force (CF) monitoring using non-CF catheters. This study sought to investigate the feasibility, safety, and efficacy of ablation with TP technology.

METHODS

Eighty-five patients with supraventricular tachycardia (SVT) were ablated with real-time monitoring of CF by TP technology and compared with 85 patients who underwent ablation with a conventional non-TP approach. Baseline characteristics, procedural data, and TP data were analyzed in the study. Ablation applications in the TP group were then subdivided into good contact and poor contact groups according to the TP level for analysis.

RESULTS

The TP group had a significantly shorter procedural time (16.2 ± 6.9 min vs. 19.9 ± 10.0 min, p = 0.033), shorter ablation time (334.6 ± 166.9 s vs. 391.3 ± 195.7 s, p = 0.049), and fewer mean numbers of radiofrequency catheter ablation (RFCA) deliveries (6.2 ± 3.2 vs. 7.6 ± 5.2, p = 0.047) than the non-TP group. The achieved average percentage of TP >3 g was significantly higher in the good-contact group (97.94% vs. 15.48%, p < 0.001). The median impedance decreases during RFCA in the good contact group and poor contact group were 4.10 (0.30-6.88) Ω and 2.60 (-0.05-4.98) Ω at 10 s, 4.45 (0.58-8.25) Ω and 2.88 (0.23-5.70) Ω at 20 s, and 4.67 (1.95-9.08) Ω and 2.97 (-0.26-6.33) Ω at 30 s, respectively (p < 0.05 for comparisons between categories). All patients achieved acute success, and no complications were observed. Two patients in the TP group and one patient in the non-TP group experienced recurrence during follow-up.

CONCLUSION

TP-technology guided ablation of SVT is feasible, efficient, and safe.

Catheter contact area strongly correlates with lesion area in radiofrequency cardiac ablation: an ex vivo porcine heart study

PURPOSE

Our previous study confirmed that not only force but also the catheter contact angle substantially impacted the contact area and its morphology. Therefore, in this study, we aimed to further investigate the relationship between the catheter contact area and the dimensions of the ablation lesion area as a function of catheter contact angle and force in radiofrequency catheter ablation.

METHODS

The radiofrequency catheter ablation test was performed for 5 contact angles and 8 contact forces at a fixed ablation time of 30 s. The initial impedance was 92.5 ± 2.5 Ω, the temperature during ablation was 30 °C, and the power was 30 W. The irrigation rate during ablation was set to 17 mL/min. Each experiment was repeated 6 times.

RESULTS

The catheter contact area showed a strong correlation with the ablation lesion area (r = 0.8507). When the contact area was increased, the lesion area also increased linearly in a monotonic manner. The relationships between catheter contact force and ablation lesion area and between catheter contact force and ablation lesion depth are logarithmic functions in which increased contact force was associated with increased lesion area and depth. The catheter contact angle is also an important determinant of the lesion area. The lesion area progressively increased when the contact angle was decreased. In contrast, the lesion depth progressively increased when the contact angle was increased.

CONCLUSIONS

The catheter contact area was strongly correlated with the ablation lesion area. Additionally, catheter contact force and contact angle significantly impacted the dimensions of the lesion in radiofrequency catheter ablation procedures.

Cavotricuspid isthmus ablation guided by force-time integral - A randomized study

Background

Force‐time integral (FTI) is an ablation marker of lesion quality and transmurality. A target FTI of 400 gram‐seconds (gs) has been shown to improve durability of pulmonary vein isolation, following atrial fibrillation ablation. However, relevant targets for cavotricuspid isthmus (CTI) ablation are lacking.

Hypothesis

We sought to investigate whether CTI ablation with 600 gs FTI lesions is associated with reduced rate of transisthmus conduction recovery compared to 400 gs lesions.

Methods

Fifty patients with CTI‐dependent flutter were randomized to ablation using 400 gs (FTI400 group, n = 26) or 600 gs FTI lesions (FTI600 group, n = 24). The study endpoint was spontaneous or adenosine‐mediated recovery of transisthmus conduction, after a 20‐min waiting period.

Results

The study endpoint occurred in five patients (19.2%) in group FTI400 and in four patients (16.7%) in group FTI600, p = .81. First‐pass CTI block was similar in both groups (50% in FTI400 vs. 54.2% in FTI600, p = .77). There were no differences in the total number of lesions, total ablation time, procedure time and fluoroscopy duration between the two groups. There were no major complications in any group. In the total population, patients not achieving first‐pass CTI block had significantly higher rate of acute CTI conduction recovery, compared to those with first‐pass block (29.2% vs. 7.7% respectively, p = .048).

Conclusions

CTI ablation using 600 gs FTI lesions is not associated with reduced spontaneous or adenosine‐mediated recurrence of transisthmus conduction, compared to 400 gs lesions.

Local impedance for the optimization of radiofrequency lesion delivery: A review of bench and clinical data

INTRODUCTION

Radiofrequency catheter ablation is a cornerstone of treatment for many cardiac arrhythmias. Progression in three-dimensional mapping and contact-force sensing technologies have improved our capability to achieve success, but challenges still remain.

METHODS

In this article, we discuss the importance of overall circuit impedance in radiofrequency lesion formation. This is followed by a review of the literature regarding recently developed "local impedance" technology and its current and future potential applications and limitations, in the context of established surrogate markers currently used to infer effective ablation.

RESULTS

We discuss the role of local impedance in assessing myocardial substrate, as well as its role in clinical studies of ablation. We also discuss safety considerations, limitations and ongoing research.

CONCLUSION

Local impedance is a novel tool which has the potential to tailor ablation in a manner distinct from other established metrics.

Impact of a formula combining local impedance and conventional parameters on lesion size prediction

BACKGROUND

Although ablation energy (AE) and force-time integral (FTI) are well-known active predictors of lesion characteristics, these parameters do not reflect passive tissue reactions during ablation, which may instead be represented by drops in local impedance (LI). This study aimed to investigate if additional LI data improves predicting lesion characteristics and steam pops.

METHODS

RF applications at a range of powers (30 W, 40 W, and 50 W), contact forces (8 g, 15 g, 25 g, and 35 g), and durations (10-180 s) using perpendicular/parallel catheter orientations were performed in excised porcine hearts (N = 30). The correlation between AE, FTI, and lesion characteristics was examined, and the impact of LI (%LI drop (%LID) defined by the ΔLI divided by the initial LI) was additionally assessed.

RESULTS

Three hundred seventy-five lesions without steam pops were examined. Ablation energy (W × s) and FTI (g × s) showed a positive correlation with lesion depth (ρ = 0.824:P < 0.0001 and ρ = 0.708:P < 0.0001), surface area (ρ = 0.507:P < 0.0001 and ρ = 0.562:P < 0.0001), and volume (ρ = 0.807:P < 0.0001 and ρ = 0.685:P < 0.0001). %LID also showed a positive correlation individually with lesion depth (ρ = 0.643:P < 0.0001), surface area (ρ = 0.547:P < 0.0001), and volume (ρ = 0.733:P < 0.0001). However, the combined indices of AE × %LID (AE multiplied by %LID) and FTI × %LID (FTI multiplied by %LID) provided significantly stronger correlation with lesion depth (ρ = 0.834:P < 0.0001 and ρ = 0.809:P < 0.0001), surface area (ρ = 0.529:P < 0.0001 and ρ = 0.656:P < 0.0001), and volume (ρ = 0.864:P < 0.0001 and ρ = 0.838:P < 0.0001). This tendency was observed regardless of the catheter placement (parallel/perpendicular). AE (P = 0.02) and %LID (P = 0.002) independently remained as significant predictors to predict steam pops (N = 27). However, the AE × %LID did not increase the predictive power of steam pops compared to the AE alone.

CONCLUSION

LI, when combined with conventional parameters (AE and FTI), may provide stronger correlation with lesion characteristics.

Contact force sensors in minimally invasive catheters: current and future applications

INTRODUCTION

Advances in catheter design for minimally invasive surgery have brought about the incorporation of contact force (CF) sensors in catheters. Two main approaches to achieve CF sensing at the catheter end-effector consist of fiber optic or magnetic solutions. CF sensing feedback can be used to assist in ablation procedures, mapping cardiac regions, identifying tissue characteristics, and enhancing robotic catheter control.

AREAS COVERED

This review covers the technological and clinical aspects of CFS in catheters. Contact force and force-time integral thresholds for ablation procedures, procedural complications, and electroanatomical mapping strategies are discussed. Future applications of improving catheter control, minimizing complications, and enhancing mapping techniques through CF are examined.

EXPERT OPINION

Fiber optic CF catheters may be more desirable compared to magnetic modalities due to the lower cost, compactness, and higher accuracy. In ablation procedures, complications due to higher ablation duration, power, contact force, and force time can be reduced through practical experience and informed training for catheter operators. Future prospects consist of the incorporation of CF sensors with remote catheter systems to assist in catheter control. We propose that CF can also be used in machine learning decision-making algorithms to prevent complications or improve tissue characterization.

The impacts of contact force, power and application time on ablation effect indicated by serial measurements of impedance drop in both conventional and high-power short-duration ablation settings of atrial fibrillation

Background

This study aimed to clarify the interrelationship and additive effects of contact force (CF), power and application time in both conventional and high-power short-duration (HPSD) settings.

Methods

Among 38 patients with paroxysmal atrial fibrillation who underwent first-time pulmonary vein isolation, 787 ablation points were collected at the beginning of the procedure at separate sites. Energy was applied for 60 s under power outputs of 25, 30 or 35 W (conventional group), or 10 s when using 50 W (HPSD group). An impedance drop (ID) of 10 Ω was regarded as a marker of adequate lesion formation.

Results

ID ≥ 10 Ω could not be achieved with CF < 5 g under any power setting. With CF ≥ 5 g, ID could be enhanced by increasing power output or prolonging ablation time. ID for 30 and 35 W was greater than for 25 W (p < 0.05). Ablation with 35 W resulted in greater ID than with 30 W only when CF of 10–20 g was applied for 20–40 s (p < 0.05). Under the same power output, ID increased with CF level at different time points. The higher the CF, the shorter the time needed to reach ID of 10 Ω and maximal ID. ID correlated well with ablation index under each power, except for lower ID values at 25 W. ID with 50 W for 10 s was equivalent to that with 25 W for 40 s, but lower than that with 30 W for 40 s or 35 W for 30 s.

Conclusions

CF of at least 5 g is required for adequate ablation effect. With CF ≥ 5g, CF, power output, and ablation time can compensate for each other. Time to reach maximal ablation effect can be shortened by increasing CF or power. The effect of HPSD ablation with 50 W for 10 s is equivalent to conventional ablation with 25 W for 40 s and 30–35 W for 20–30 s in terms of ID.

Impact of interruptions in radiofrequency energy delivery on lesion characteristics

BACKGROUND

During catheter ablation, delivery of radiofrequency (RF) energy to a target site is sometimes interrupted by catheter instability and clinical factors. The impact of interruption of RF delivery on lesion characteristics has not been characterized.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to determine the impact of interruption of RF application on lesion size.

METHODS

Forty-two RF ablation lesions (21 left ventricle, 21 right ventricle) were created in the ventricles of 6 swine using power control mode (30 W; target contact force 15g) with 1 of 3 conditions: 15-second ablation (15s), 30-second ablation (30s), or two 15-second ablations (15s×2) at the same site separated by a 2-minute pause.

RESULTS

Lesion volume was significantly larger for 30s lesions (501 ± 146 mm³) compared to both 15s×2 (314 ± 98 mm³) and 15s (242 ± 104 mm³) lesions (P <.001 for both pairwise comparisons). Compared to 15s lesions, lesion volume was numerically greater for 15s×2 lesions, but this did not reach statistical significance (P = .087). Differences in lesion volume between 30s and 15s×2 lesions were driven mainly by differences in lesion width (10.7 ± 1.1 mm vs 9.1 ± 1.7 mm; P = .04) rather than depth (9 ± 1.2 mm vs 8.4 ± 1.2 mm; P = .29). There were no differences in mean contact force by group. There was no difference in total force-time integral for the 30s and 15s×2 lesion groups [median 444 (interquartile range 312) g∙s vs 380 (164) g∙s; P = 1].

CONCLUSION

Compared to lesions resulting from continuous RF ablation, lesions resulting from interrupted ablation have a smaller overall lesion volume, predominantly due to smaller lesion width. These data suggest that if disruption in energy delivery occurs, lesions may need closer spacing to avoid gaps.

Benefit of Contact Force-Guided Catheter Ablation for Treating Premature Ventricular Contractions

We evaluated whether an irrigated contact force-sensing catheter would improve the safety and effectiveness of radiofrequency ablation of premature ventricular contractions originating from the right ventricular outflow tract. We retrospectively reviewed the charts of patients with symptomatic premature ventricular contractions who underwent ablation with a contact force-sensing catheter (56 patients, SmartTouch) or conventional catheter (59 patients, ThermoCool) at our hospital from August 2013 through December 2015. During a mean follow-up of 16 ± 5 months, 3 patients in the conventional group had recurrences, compared with none in the contact force group. Complications occurred only in the conventional group (one steam pop; 2 ablations suspended because of significantly increasing impedance). In the contact force group, the median contact force during ablation was 10 g (interquartile range, 7-14 g). Times for overall procedure (36.9 ± 5 min), fluoroscopy (86.3 ± 22.7 s), and ablation (60.3 ± 21.4 s) were significantly shorter in the contact force group than in the conventional group (46.2 ± 6.2 min, 107.7 ± 30 s, and 88.7 ± 32.3 s, respectively; P <0.001). In the contact force group, cases with a force-time integral <560 gram-seconds (g-s) had significantly longer procedure and fluoroscopy times (both P <0.001) than did those with a force-time integral ≥560 g-s. These findings suggest that ablation of premature ventricular contractions originating from the right ventricular outflow tract with an irrigated contact force-sensing catheter instead of a conventional catheter shortens overall procedure, fluoroscopy, and ablation times without increasing risk of recurrence or complications.

Contact-force radiofrequency ablation of non-paroxysmal atrial fibrillation: improved outcomes with increased experience

INTRODUCTION

Clinical trials have failed to reliably show improved outcomes with utilization of contact-force sensing (CFS) radiofrequency (RF) ablation catheters. It is unknown whether the unfavorable outcomes observed in these trials are attributable to inexperience with CFS technology.

OBJECTIVES

To compare catheter ablation outcomes of stepwise linear ablation with versus without CFS technology and to assess the impact of operator experience with CFS technology on procedural outcomes.

METHODS

Clinical outcomes were evaluated in 228 consecutive NPAF patients undergoing first-time left atrial ablation using a stepwise linear approach. Arrhythmia recurrence was assessed using 2-week event monitors at 3-month intervals following index ablation.

RESULTS

A total of 228 patients were included in our study. There was no statistically significant difference in risk of recurrent atrial arrhythmias at 12 and 24 months between CFS and non-CFS patients (p = 0.5 and p = 0.169). The time to recurrence of atrial arrhythmias at 24 months in the second half of CFS patients was significantly lower when compared to both the first half of CFS patients (p = 0.002) and non-CFS patients (p = 0.005).

CONCLUSION

While there was no difference in overall outcomes between CFS and non-CFS ablation using a stepwise linear approach in patients with NPAF, procedural efficacy of the second half of CFS patients was significantly improved compared to both the first half of CFS patients and all non-CFS patients. Lack of benefit seen in clinical trials using CFS technology may be related to operator inexperience with CFS ablation catheters at the time of the trials.

Role of Contact Force Sensing in Catheter Ablation of Cardiac Arrhythmias: Evolution or History Repeating Itself?

Adequate catheter-tissue contact facilitates efficient heat energy transfer to target tissue. Tissue contact is thus critical to achieving lesion transmurality and success of radiofrequency (RF) ablation procedures, a fact recognized more than 2 decades ago. The availability of real-time contact force (CF)-sensing catheters has reinvigorated the field of ablation biophysics and optimized lesion formation. The ability to measure and display CF came with the promise of dramatic improvement in safety and efficacy; however, CF quality was noted to have just as important an influence on lesion formation as absolute CF quantity. Multiple other factors have emerged as key elements influencing effective lesion formation, including catheter stability, lesion contiguity and continuity, lesion density, contact homogeneity across a line of ablation, spatiotemporal dynamics of contact governed by cardiac and respiratory motion, contact directionality, and anatomic wall thickness, in addition to traditional ablation indices of power and RF duration. There is greater appreciation of surrogate markers as a guide to lesion formation, such as impedance fall, loss of pace capture, and change in unipolar electrogram morphology. In contrast, other surrogates such as tactile feedback, catheter motion, and electrogram amplitude are notably poor predictors of actual contact and lesion formation. This review aims to contextualize the role of CF sensing in lesion formation with respect of the fundamental principles of biophysics of RF ablation and summarize the state-of-the-art evidence behind the role of CF in optimizing lesion formation.

Efficacy of adjunctive measures used to assist pulmonary vein isolation for atrial fibrillation: a systematic review

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Pulmonary vein reconnection leading to recurrence of atrial arrhythmias after pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) for atrial fibrillation remains a significant challenge. A number of adjunctive measures during PVI have been used to attempt to reduce pulmonary vein reconnection and recurrence of atrial arrhythmias. We performed a systematic review of the literature and meta-analysis of studies evaluating the efficacy of adjunctive measures used during PVI in reducing recurrent atrial arrhythmias.

RECENT FINDINGS

Our literature search found four interventions that met the prespecified definition of adjunctive measure: adenosine testing post-PVI, contact force-guided PVI, pacing inexcitability of the ablation line during PVI and additional ablation based on the computed tomography thickness of the pulmonary vein-left atrial appendage ridge. Sixteen studies enrolling 3507 patients met all inclusion and exclusion criteria. PVI performed with adjunctive measures was shown to reduce the 1-year recurrence rate of atrial arrhythmias. The point estimate for the combined relative risk of atrial arrhythmia recurrence was 0.56 [95% confidence interval (CI): 0.43-0.73; P value <0.001] in the PVI with adjunctive measures group.

SUMMARY

PVI for atrial fibrillation assisted by adjunctive measures results in clinically significant reduction of recurrent atrial arrhythmias. Additional research is required to assess the relative efficacy of individual or combined adjunctive strategies used during PVI for atrial fibrillation.

Impact of impedance decrease during radiofrequency current application for atrial fibrillation ablation on myocardial lesion and gap formation

BACKGROUND

The clinical impact of a decrease in impedance during radiofrequency catheter ablation (RFCA) has not been fully clarified. The aim of the study was to analyze the impact of impedance decrease and to determine its optimal cutoff value during RFCA.

METHODS

We evaluated 34 consecutive patients (total 3264 lesions, mean age 66 ± 8.7 years, 10 females) who underwent their first ablation for atrial fibrillation (AF). The impedance decrease, average contact force (CF), application time, force-time integral (FTI), product of impedance decrease and application time (PIT), and the product of impedance decrease and FTI (PIFT) were measured for all lesions. Levels of cardiac troponin I (TrpI) were measured for assessment of myocardial injury. The incidence of intraprocedural pulmonary vein-left atrium reconnection or dormant conduction (reconnection) was determined. The relationships between the ablation parameters and the increase in TrpI (ΔTrpI) were evaluated. The predictive value of the parameters for reconnection was assessed using receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis.

RESULTS

Reconnection was detected in 18 patients. Average FTI and PIT were significantly correlated with ΔTrpI (FTI: r2 = .19, P = .0090, PIT: r2 = .21, P = .0058). PIFT was correlated with ΔTrpI and was the best of the three indexes (PIFT: r2 = .29, P = .0010). In ROC curve analysis, the area under the curve for predicting reconnection was 0.71 and the optimal cutoff value was 5200 for PIFT (sensitivity 78%, specificity 63%).

CONCLUSION

The combination of CF and a decrease in impedance could be important in the evaluation of myocardial lesions and reconnection during RFCA.

Ablation index, a novel marker of ablation lesion quality: prediction of pulmonary vein reconnection at repeat electrophysiology study and regional differences in target values

Aims

Force-Time Integral (FTI) is commonly used as a marker of ablation lesion quality during pulmonary vein isolation (PVI), but does not incorporate power. Ablation Index (AI) is a novel lesion quality marker that utilizes contact force, time, and power in a weighted formula. Furthermore, only a single FTI target value has been suggested despite regional variation in left atrial wall thickness. We aimed to study AI's and FTI's relationships with PV reconnection at repeat electrophysiology study, and regional threshold values that predicted no reconnection.

Methods and results

Forty paroxysmal atrial fibrillation patients underwent contact force-guided PVI, and the minimum and mean AI and FTI values for each segment were identified according to a 12-segment model. All patients underwent repeat electrophysiology study at 2 months, regardless of symptoms, to identify sites of PV reconnection. Late PV reconnection was seen in 53 (11%) segments in 25 (62%) patients. Reconnected segments had significantly lower minimum AI [308 (252-336) vs. 373 (323-423), P < 0.0001] and FTI [137 (92-182) vs. 228 (157-334), P < 0.0001] compared with non-reconnected segments. Minimum AI and FTI were both independently predictive, but AI had a smaller P value. Higher minimum AI and FTI values were required to avoid reconnection in anterior/roof segments than for posterior/inferior segments (P < 0.0001). No reconnection was seen where the minimum AI value was ≥370 for posterior/inferior segments and ≥480 for anterior/roof segments.

Conclusion

The minimum AI value in a PVI segment is independently predictive of reconnection of that segment at repeat electrophysiology study. Higher AI and FTI values are required for anterior/roof segments than for posterior/inferior segments to prevent reconnection.

Three-year outcomes and reconnection patterns after initial contact force guided pulmonary vein isolation for paroxysmal atrial fibrillation

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Contact force (CF) sensing is a novel technology used for catheter ablation of atrial fibrillation (AF). We compared the single procedure success of CF-guided pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) with that of non-CF guided PVI during a 3-year (1,095 days) follow up period and analyzed the pattern of pulmonary vein (PV) reconnection.

METHODS

A cohort of 167 subjects (68 CF vs. 99 non-CF) with paroxysmal AF were included in the study. Atrial arrhythmia (AA) recurrence was defined as documented AF, atrial flutter, or atrial tachycardia lasting >30 seconds and occurring after 90 days.

RESULTS

Subjects in the CF group showed a statistically nonsignificant improvement in AA free survival compared to those in the non-CF group (66.2% vs. 51.5%; P value: 0.06). A greater propensity for reconnection was noted around the right-sided PVs compared to left-sided PVs related in both catheter ablation groups. For example, in the CF group 36% of right-sided segments reconnected compared to 16% of left-sided segments (P value <0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

A greater propensity for reconnection was noted around the right sided PV segments in both the CF and non-CF groups. The explanation for this finding was related to greater catheter instability around the right sided veins. Further research is needed to explore the utility of a "real-time" composite indicator that includes RF energy, CF and catheter stability in predicting transmural lesion formation during catheter ablation.

Prospective use of Ablation Index targets improves clinical outcomes following ablation for atrial fibrillation

AIMS

Late recovery of ablated tissue leading to reconnection of pulmonary veins remains common following radiofrequency catheter ablation for AF. Ablation Index (AI), a novel ablation quality marker, incorporates contact force (CF), time, and power in a weighted formula. We hypothesized that prospective use of our previously published derived AI targets would result in better outcomes when compared to CF-guided ablation.

METHODS

Eighty-nine consecutive drug-refractory AF patients (49% paroxysmal) underwent AI-guided ablation (AI-group). AI targets were 550 for anterior/roof and 400 for posterior/inferior left atrial segments. Procedural and clinical outcomes of these patients were compared to 89 propensity-matched controls who underwent CF-guided ablation (CF-group). All 178 procedures were otherwise similar, and both groups were followed-up for 12 months. The last 25 patients from each group underwent analysis of all VisiTags™ for ablation duration, CF, Force-Time Integral, and impedance drop.

RESULTS

First-pass pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) was more frequent in AI-group than in CF-group (173 [97%] vs. 149 [84%] circles, P < 0.001), and acute PV reconnection was lower (11 [6%] vs. 24 [13%] circles, P = 0.02). Mean PVI ablation time was similar (AI-group: 42 ± 9 vs. CF-group: 45 ± 14 minutes, P = 0.14). Median impedance drop for AI-group was significantly higher than in CF-group (13.7 [9-19] Ω vs. 8.8 [5.2-13] Ω, P < 0.001). Two major complications occurred in CF-group and none in AI-group. Atrial tachyarrhythmia recurrence was significantly lower in AI-group (15 of 89 [17%]) than in CF-group (33 of 89 [37%], P = 0.002).

CONCLUSION

AI-guided ablation is associated with significant improvements in the incidence of acute PV reconnection and atrial tachyarrhythmia recurrence rate compared to CF-guided ablation, potentially due to creation of better quality lesions as suggested by greater impedance drop.

Ablation Index and Surround Flow Catheter Irrigation: Impedance-Based Appraisal in Clinical Ablation

OBJECTIVES

This study sought to assess the impact of ablation power and catheter irrigation during clinical radiofrequency ablation using impedance drop.

BACKGROUND

In preclinical studies, ablation power and catheter irrigation are determinants of ablation efficacy.

METHODS

Static 30-s left atrial ablations were delivered in patients undergoing their first atrial fibrillation ablation. Impedance drop during ablation (as a measure of efficacy) was compared using the following: the force time integral (FTI); the FTI-P (a cumulative multiple FTI and ablation power), and ablation index (AI), a weighted algorithm including contact force, power, and duration. Comparison was also made between a conventionally irrigated (SmartTouch [ST]) versus surround flow (STSF) contact force-sensing catheter.

RESULTS

We analyzed 1,013 ablations. For both catheters, the Spearman correlation was higher between impedance drop and AI (rho = 0.89 ST, 0.84 STSF) than FTI-P (rho = 0.71 ST, 0.53 STSF) or FTI (rho = 0.77 ST, 0.52 STSF); p < 0.0005 for each. STSF ablations had lower minimum catheter tip temperatures (25°C [interquartile range (IQR): 25°C to 27°C] vs. 35°C [IQR: 34°C to 36°C]; p < 0.005), and lesser impedance drop per FTI or AI (p < 0.005 for both). For STSF, impedance drop plateaued sooner than for ST with respect to FTI (184g.s vs. 463g.s) and AI (370 AI vs. 430 AI).

CONCLUSIONS

AI is a more complete ablation descriptor than is FTI or FTI-P, reflected by a stronger correlation with impedance drop. STSF ablations have lower impedance drop per AI or FTI than ST ablations do, suggesting different targets should be used if ablating guided by impedance drop with STSF. With ST, ablation beyond 430 AI provides minimal additional biophysical efficacy, suggesting an upper limit to use for clinical ablation.

Radiofrequency catheter ablation of atrial fibrillation: Electrical modification suggesting transmurality is faster achieved with remote magnetic catheter in comparison with contact force use

BACKGROUND

Remote magnetic navigation (RMN) and contact force (CF) sensing catheters are available technologies for radiofrequency (RF) catheter ablation of atrial fibrillation (AF). Our purpose was to compare time to electrogram (EGM) modification suggesting transmural lesions between RMN and CF-guided AF ablation.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A total of 1,008 RF applications were analyzed in 21 patients undergoing RMN (n = 11) or CF-guided ablation (n = 10) for paroxysmal AF. All procedures were performed in sinus rhythm during general anesthesia. Time to EGM modification was measured until transmurality criteria were fulfilled: (1) complete disappearance of R if initial QR morphology; (2) diminution > 75% of R if initial QRS morphology; (3) complete disappearance of R' of initial RSR' morphology. Impedance drop as well as force time integral (FTI) were also assessed for each application. Mean CF at the beginning of each RF application in the CF group was 11 ± 2 g and mean FTI per application was 488 ± 163 gs. Time to EGM modification was significantly shorter in the RMN group (4.52 ± 0.1 seconds vs. 5.6 ± 0.09 seconds; P < 0.00001). There was no significant difference between other procedural parameters.

CONCLUSION

Remote magnetic AF ablation is associated with faster EGM modification suggesting transmurality than optimized CF and FTI-guided catheter ablation.

Contact force technology integrated with 3D navigation system for atrial fibrillation ablation: improving results?

INTRODUCTION

Pulmonary veins isolation (PVI) by radiofrequency (RF) ablation is currently an established treatment for symptomatic, drug-resistant paroxysmal atrial fibrillation. Although the effectiveness of the therapy has been clearly demonstrated, success rate after a single procedure is still sub-optimal. The main reason for recurrences after PVI is electrical pulmonary vein-atrium reconnection. In order to increase the likelihood of permanent PVI, the creation of a transmural, durable lesion is mandatory. The main determinants of lesion size and transmurality are power, stability, duration and contact-force during RF application. In recent times, catheters with contact-force sensors have been developed and released for clinical use. Areas covered: The present review summarizes rational and clinical evidences for efficacy and safety of contact force (CF) technology integrated into 3D navigation systems for AF ablation. Expert commentary Although CF technology has a strong rational, clinical data on the superior safety and efficacy of CF technology over traditional non-CF catheters are still conflicting. The reason for that is very likely to rely on the lack of definite data on how to optimize CF parameters and how to integrate CF data with power, duration of RF applications and information on catheter stability.

Contact Force and Atrial Fibrillation Ablation

Catheters able to measure the force and vector of contact between the catheter tip and myocardium are now available. Pre-clinical work has established that the degree of contact between the radiofrequency ablation catheter and myocardium correlates with the size of the delivered lesion. Excess contact is associated with steam pops and perforation. Catheter contact varies within the left atrium secondary to factors including respiration, location, atrial rhythm and the trans-septal catheter delivery technology used. Compared with procedures performed without contact force (CF)-sensing, the use of this technology has, in some studies, been found to improve complication rates, procedure and fluoroscopy times, and success rates. However, for each of these parameters there are also studies suggesting a lack of difference from the availability of CF data. Nevertheless, CF-sensing technology has been adopted as a standard of care in many institutions. It is likely that use of CF-sensing technology will allow for the optimization of each individual radiofrequency application to maximize efficacy and procedural safety. Recent work has attempted to define what these optimal targets should be, and approaches to do this include assessing for sites of pulmonary vein reconnection after ablation, or comparing the impedance response to ablation. Based on such work, it is apparent that factors including mean CF, force time integral (the area under the force-time curve) and contact stability are important determinants of ablation efficacy. Multicenter prospective randomized data are lacking in this field and required to define the CF parameters required to produce optimal ablation.

Randomized trial comparing pulmonary vein isolation using the SmartTouch catheter with or without real-time contact force data

BACKGROUND

Contact force (CF) information may improve the safety and efficacy of ablation for paroxysmal atrial fibrillation (PAF).

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to assess the impact of CF data on ablation for PAF.

METHODS

Patients undergoing first-time PAF ablation were randomized at 7 UK centers to ablation with (CF-on) or without (CF-off) CF data available to the operator, using the same ablation catheter and mapping system. An ablation CF of 5-40g was targeted. Pulmonary vein (PV) reconnection was assessed with adenosine at 60 minutes. Follow-up for arrhythmia recurrence was for 1 year with 7-day Holter recordings at 6 and 12 months.

RESULTS

One hundred seventeen patients were studied (59 CF-on, 58 CF-off). In the CF-on group, a reduction in acute PV reconnection rates (22% vs 32%, P = .03) but no significant difference in 1-year success rates off antiarrhythmic drugs (49% vs 52%, P = .9) was observed. There was no difference in major complication rates: 2 of 59 (3%) CF-on, 3 of 58 (5%) CF-off (P = .7). Procedural and fluoroscopy times were not significantly different (P>.5). Overall mean CFs per ablation were not different between groups (13.4 [9.1-19.6]g CF-on, 13.4 [7.4-22.4]g CF-off, P = .5), but a greater proportion of readings in the CF-on group were in the target range (80% vs 68%, P<.001).

CONCLUSION

This randomized multicenter study demonstrated that CF data availability was associated with reduced acute PV reconnection but not improved 1-year success rates, procedural and fluoroscopy times, or complication rates. There was a reduction in extremes of CF, above and below the study target range, suggesting greater CF control during ablation.

Optimal Force-Time Integral for Pulmonary Vein Isolation According to Anatomical Wall Thickness Under the Ablation Line

Background

Low contact force and force–time integral (FTI) during catheter ablation are associated with ineffective lesion formation, whereas excessively high contact force and FTI may increase the risk of complications. We sought to evaluate the optimal FTI for pulmonary vein (PV) isolation based on atrial wall thickness under the ablation line.

Methods and Results

Contact force parameters and FTI during anatomical ipsilateral PV isolation for atrial fibrillation and atrial wall thickness were assessed retrospectively in 59 consecutive patients for their first PV isolation procedure. The PV antrum was divided into 8 segments, and the wall thickness of each segment under the ablation line was determined using multidetector computed tomography. The FTI for each ablation point was divided by the wall thickness of the PV antrum segment where each point was located to obtain FTI/wall thickness. In total, 5335 radiofrequency applications were delivered, and 85 gaps in PV isolation ablation lines and 15 dormant conductions induced by adenosine were detected. The gaps or dormant conductions were significantly associated with low contact force, radiofrequency duration, FTI, and FTI/wall thickness. Among them, FTI/wall thickness had the best prediction value for gaps or dormant conductions by receiver operating characteristic curve analysis. FTI/wall thickness of <76.4 gram‐seconds per millimeter (gs/mm) predicted gaps or dormant conductions with sensitivity (88.0%) and specificity (83.6%), and FTI/wall thickness of <101.1 gs/mm was highly predictive (sensitivity 97.0%; specificity 69.6%).

Conclusions

FTI/wall thickness is a strong predictor of gap and dormant conduction formation in PV isolation. An FTI/wall thickness ≈100 gs/mm could be a suitable target for effective ablation.

Optimizing contact force during ablation of atrial fibrillation: available technologies and a look to the future

In a select atrial fibrillation population, catheter ablation is considered first-line therapy. Prevention of early reconnection of the isolated pulmonary veins is an important goal for a successful treatment. Here, adequate catheter–tissue contact is crucial. One of the most promising new advances, therefore, is contact force (CF) sensing technology. The aim of this review is to provide an overview of innovations regarding catheter ablation of atrial fibrillation with a special focus on CF optimization. Both experimental and human studies show how CF sensing catheters lead to a reduction of fluoroscopy time, increased procedural safety and a better clinical outcome. Possible future developments include new parameters combining real-time ablation data, direct visualization of lesion formation and incorporation of robotics.

Electroanatomic mapping systems (CARTO/EnSite NavX) vs. conventional mapping for ablation procedures in a training program

BACKGROUND

Three-dimensional electroanatomic mapping (EAM) systems reduce radiation exposure when radio frequency catheter ablation (RFCA) procedures are performed by well-trained senior operators. Given the steep learning curve associated with complex RFCA, trainees and their mentors must rely on multiple imaging modalities to maximize safety and success, which might increase procedure and fluoroscopy times. The objective of the present study is to determine if 3-D EAM (CARTO and ESI-NavX) improves procedural outcomes (fluoroscopy time, radio frequency time, procedure duration, complication, and success rates) during CA procedures as compared to fluoroscopically guided conventional mapping alone in an academic teaching hospital.

METHODS

We analyzed a total of 1070 consecutive RFCA procedures over an 8-year period for fluoroscopic time stratified by ablation target and mapping system. Multivariate logistic regression and adjusted odds ratios were calculated for each variable.

RESULTS

No statistically significant differences in acute success rates were noted between conventional and 3-D mapping cases [CARTO (p = 0.68) or ESI-NavX (p = 0.20)]. Moreover, complication rates were also not significantly different between CARTO (p = 0.23) and ESI-NavX (p = 0.53) when compared to conventional mapping. Procedure, radio frequency, and fluoroscopy times were significantly longer with CARTO and ESI-NavX versus conventional mapping [fluoroscopy time: CARTO, 28.3 min; ESI, 28.5 min; and conventional, 24.3 min; p < 0.001)].

CONCLUSIONS

The use of 3-D EAM systems during teaching cases significantly increases radiation exposure when compared with conventional mapping. These findings suggest a need to develop alternative training strategies that enhance confidence and safety during catheter manipulation and allow for reduced fluoroscopy and procedure times during RFCA.

The symbiosis of contact force catheter use for hybrid ablation for atrial fibrillation

OBJECTIVE

Reconduction across an ablation line is a common reason for arrhythmia recurrence over time. The hybrid procedure combines epicardial ablation of the pulmonary vein (PV) and creation of a box lesion with endocardial touch-ups for any electrical gaps. A high contact force (CF) between the ablation tip and cardiac tissue may increase the risk of thrombus formation, catheter tip charring, steam pop formation, and even cardiac perforation. CF monitoring is a significant new parameter for titration of the CF for creating an adequate lesion.

METHODS

Thirty-eight consecutive patients underwent epicardial ablation using bipolar radiofrequency devices. After checking electrical bidirectional block of the ablation lines, an endocardial CF catheter was used for further ablation (if needed) to complete the isolation of PVs, box lesion, cavotricuspid isthmus (CTI), and complex fractionated atrial electrograms (CFAE).

RESULTS

Endocardial touch-up was needed for 2 PVs (1.3 %) and 10 (26.3 %) box lesions. It was also used for the CTI line in 7 (18.4 %) patients, atrial tachycardia in 3 (7.9 %) patients, and additional CFAE ablation in 17 (44.7 %) patients. All 5 patients with arrhythmia recurrence had a mean CF < 10 g (p = 0.03). Procedure duration was significantly shorter in the CF group (223 ± 57 vs. 256 ± 60 min, p = 0.03) compared with control group.

CONCLUSION

Use of CF catheters is safe, feasible, and complementary to a hybrid procedure setup for atrial fibrillation ablation. Its real-time monitoring may predict future arrhythmia recurrence, and decrease procedure time.