A Life-Course Approach to the Neurodevelopmental Trajectory of Congenital Heart Disease

A guide to prenatal counseling regarding neurodevelopment in congenital heart disease

Advances in cardiac surgical techniques taking place over the past 50 years have resulted in the vast majority of children born with congenital cardiac malformations now surviving into adulthood. As the focus shifts from survival to the functional outcomes of our patients, it is increasingly being recognized that a significant proportion of patients undergoing infant cardiac repair experience adverse neurodevelopmental (ND) outcomes. The etiology of abnormal brain development in the setting of congenital heart disease is poorly understood, complex, and likely multifactorial. Furthermore, the efficacy of therapies available for the learning disabilities, attention deficit, and hyperactivity disorders and other ND deficits complicating congenital heart disease is currently uncertain. This situation presents a challenge for prenatal counseling as current antenatal testing does not usually provide prognostic information regarding the likely ND trajectories of individual patients. However, we believe it is important for parents to be informed about potential issues with child development when a new diagnosis of congenital heart disease is disclosed. Parents deserve a comprehensive and thoughtful approach to this subject, which conveys the uncertainties involved in predicting the severity of any developmental disorders encountered, while emphasizing the improvements in outcomes that have already been achieved in infants with congenital heart disease. A balanced approach to counseling should also discuss what local arrangements are in place for ND follow-up. This review presents an up-to-date overview of ND outcomes in patients with congenital heart disease, providing possible approaches to communicating this information to parents during prenatal counseling in a sensitive and accurate manner.

Brainstem and cerebellar volumes at magnetic resonance imaging are smaller in fetuses with congenital heart disease

BACKGROUND

Congenital heart disease is associated with an increased risk of smaller brain volumes and structural brain damage, and impaired growth of supratentorial brain structures in utero has been linked to poor neurodevelopmental outcomes. However, little is known on brainstem and cerebellar volumes in fetuses with congenital heart disease. Moreover, it is not clear whether impaired infratentorial growth, if present, is associated with only certain types of fetal cardiac defects or with supratentorial brain growth, and whether altered biometry is already present before the third trimester.

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to investigate brainstem and cerebellar volumes in fetuses with congenital heart disease and to compare them to infratentorial brain volumes in fetuses with normal hearts. Secondarily, the study aimed to identify associations between infratentorial brain biometry and the type of cardiac defects, supratentorial brain volumes, and gestational age.

STUDY DESIGN

In this retrospective case-control study, 141 magnetic resonance imaging studies of 135 fetuses with congenital heart disease and 141 magnetic resonance imaging studies of 125 controls with normal hearts at 20 to 37 gestational weeks (median, 25 weeks) were evaluated. All cases and controls had normal birthweight and no evidence of structural brain disease or genetic syndrome. Six types of congenital heart disease were included: tetralogy of Fallot (n=32); double-outlet right ventricle (n=22); transposition of the great arteries (n=27); aortic obstruction (n=24); hypoplastic left heart syndrome (n=22); and hypoplastic right heart syndrome (n=14). First, brainstem and cerebellar volumes of each fetus were segmented and compared between cases and controls. In addition, transverse cerebellar diameters, vermian areas, and supratentorial brain and cerebrospinal fluid volumes were quantified and differences assessed between cases and controls. Volumetric differences were further analyzed according to types of cardiac defects and supratentorial brain volumes. Finally, volume ratios were created for each brain structure ([volume in fetus with congenital heart disease/respective volume in control fetus] × 100) and correlated to gestational age.

RESULTS

Brainstem (cases, 2.1 cm³ vs controls, 2.4 cm³; P<.001) and cerebellar (cases, 3.2 cm³ vs controls, 3.4 cm³; P<.001) volumes were smaller in fetuses with congenital heart disease than in controls, whereas transverse cerebellar diameters (P=.681) and vermian areas (P=.947) did not differ between groups. Brainstem and cerebellar volumes differed between types of cardiac defects. Overall, the volume ratio of cases to controls was 80.8% for the brainstem, 90.5% for the cerebellum, and 90.1% for the supratentorial brain. Fetuses with tetralogy of Fallot and transposition of the great arteries were most severely affected by total brain volume reduction. Gestational age had no effect on volume ratios.

CONCLUSION

The volume of the infratentorial brain, which contains structures considered crucial to brain function, is significantly smaller in fetuses with congenital heart disease than in controls from midgestation onward. These findings suggest that impaired growth of both supra- and infratentorial brain structures in fetuses with congenital heart disease occurs in the second trimester. Further research is needed to elucidate associations between fetal brain volumes and neurodevelopmental outcomes in congenital heart disease.