A Simple Subjective Evaluation of Enface OCT Reflectance Images Distinguishes Glaucoma From Healthy Eyes

Predicting perimetric defects from en face maps of retinal nerve fibre layer reflectance

PURPOSE

To develop criteria to predict visual hemifields with deep perimetric defects based on retinal nerve fibre layer (RNFL) reflectance, in a transparent process whose components can be assessed by independent laboratories analysing data from their own small groups.

METHODS

The analysis was carried out in four stages, using three independent groups of patients-30, 33 and 62 participants-with glaucoma and age-similar controls. The first stage used Group 1 to develop a criterion for RNFL reflectance images at 24, 36 or 48 μm below the inner limiting membrane (ILM). The second stage evaluated the criterion using Group 2. The third stage developed a second criterion to improve performance for Groups 1 and 2 combined. The fourth stage evaluated the second criterion with Group 3. Confidence intervals for sensitivity and specificity were then computed by combining results from all three groups.

RESULTS

The first criterion identified all hemifields with deep defects and no hemifields from controls, using a within-eye reference for healthy RNFL. For Group 2, specificity remained high but sensitivity was reduced. The second criterion improved sensitivity by using location-specific reference values. For Group 3, sensitivity remained high but reduced specificity was found. Confidence intervals showed substantial overlap for the two criteria.

CONCLUSIONS

We developed two criteria to identify patients with deep perimetric defects with high specificity and sensitivity. Several improvements are warranted: automated identification of the fovea-disc angle and optic disc locations, evaluation of normal variation in patterns of RNFL thickness, improved segmentation of ILM and major vasculature, reduction of within-eye variability in RNFL reflectance of healthy eyes, assessment of effects of image quality, assessment of effects of comorbidity and effectiveness of other devices.

Comparison of the Circumpapillary Structure-Function and Vasculature-Function Relationships at Different Glaucoma Stages Using Longitudinal Data

Purpose

This study investigated the global and regional correlations between longitudinal structure-function (S-F) and vasculature-function (V-F) data using circumpapillary retinal nerve fiber layer thickness (cpRNFLT) measurements from optical coherence tomography (OCT), circumpapillary vessel density (cpVD) from OCT angiography (OCTA), and the corresponding visual field mean sensitivities at different glaucoma stages.

Methods

A total of 107 eyes from 107 glaucoma patients with progressive visual field (VF) changes followed up for an average of 3.33 ± 1.39 years were enrolled, including early-to-moderate (51 eyes) and advanced (56 eyes) stages. The rates of longitudinal change in the VF mean deviation (MD), cpRNFLT, and cpVD were evaluated using linear mixed-effects models and compared between different glaucoma stages. Longitudinal global and regional S-F and V-F relationships were assessed by repeated measures correlation analysis by glaucoma stage.

Results

No significant differences were found in the rates of VF MD and cpVD changes (P > 0.05) between the two glaucoma stage groups. CpRNFLT decreased more rapidly in the early-to-moderate stage group (P < 0.001) in which significant longitudinal global and regional correlations were found in both S-F and V-F relationships (all P < 0.05), except for the nasal sector. Significant global and regional correlations were only found in V-F relationship in advanced stage cases (all P < 0.05).

Conclusions

Significant longitudinal V-F relationships exist globally and regionally regardless of glaucoma stage but no longitudinal S-F relationship is present in advanced glaucoma. Longitudinal follow-up of cpVD parameters may be useful for monitoring glaucomatous VF progression at all disease stages.

Structure-function assessment in glaucoma based on perimetric sensitivity and en face optical coherence tomography images of retinal nerve fiber bundles

Many studies have assessed structure-function relations in glaucoma, but most without topographical comparison across the central 30°. We present a method for assessing structure-function relations with en face images of retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) bundles allowing topographical comparison across much of this retinal area. Forty-four patients with glaucoma (median age 61 years) were recruited and tested with Optical Coherence Tomography (OCT) and perimetry. Six rectangular volume scans were gathered, and then montaged to provide en face views of the RNFL bundles. We calculated the proportion of locations showing a perimetric defect that also showed an en face RNFL defect; and the proportion of locations falling on an RNFL defect that also showed a perimetric defect. A perimetric defect for a location was defined as a total deviation (TD) value equal to or deeper than -4 dB. We found that the median (IQR) number of locations with abnormal RNFL bundle reflectance that also had abnormal TD was 78% (60%) and for locations with abnormal TD that also had abnormal RNFL bundle reflectance was 75% (44%). We demonstrated a potential approach for structure-function assessment in glaucoma by presenting a topographic reflectance map, confirming results of previous studies and including larger retinal regions.

Concordance of Objectively Detected Retinal Nerve Fiber Bundle Defects in En Face OCT Images with Conventional Structural and Functional Changes in Glaucoma

PURPOSE

To assess how objectively detected defects in retinal nerve fiber bundle (RNFB) reflectance on en face OCT images relate to circumpapillary retinal nerve fiber layer thickness (cpRNFLT) and visual field defects.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional study.

PARTICIPANTS

Sixteen participants with early glaucoma and 29 age-matched healthy controls, of whom 22 had usable en face images for the establishment of normative levels of RNFB reflectance.

METHODS

All the participants underwent cpRNFLT scans, visual field examination, and wide-field OCT. En face reflectivity was assessed objectively using the Summary of Multiple Anatomically Adjusted Slabs method. En face defects were deemed concordant with cpRNFLT when they had at least 1 cpRNFLT point with P < 0.01, within ± 15° of the predicted insertion on the optic disc. Visual fields were examined using custom suprathreshold perimetry and SITA Standard 24-2. For each visual field location, the corresponding reflectance was deemed abnormal if any en face superpixel within ± 1° was abnormal. The overall, positive, and negative agreements were measured in each participant.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Proportion of concordant defects between en face reflectance analysis and cpRNFLT (%) as well as overall, positive, and negative agreements between en face reflectance analysis and visual field results.

RESULTS

Most en face abnormalities had concordant cpRNFLT defects in the mapped sector (median proportion concordant, 0.85; interquartile range, 0.74-0.95). In eyes with glaucoma, a median of 8.1% (range, 2.4%-23.7%) and 14.9% (range, 3.5%-29.1%) locations showed corresponding en face and visual field defects using 24-2 and custom perimetry, respectively. Both the perimetric strategies had moderate-to-good raw agreement with en face analysis (0.66-0.68), with stronger agreement on normal findings than on defects (0.77-0.78 and 0.4-0.44).

CONCLUSIONS

Objectively extracted reflectance defects showed strong concordance with conventional cpRNFLT damage and good agreement with perimetry, which could be enhanced by further minimization of image artifacts.

Within-eye and between-subject variability for reflectance of the retinal nerve fibre layer

PURPOSE

Reflectance of retinal nerve fibre layer (RNFL) can contribute to detecting the presence of glaucomatous damage and defining its extent. As a step towards developing a normative database for RNFL reflectance, we assessed within-eye and between-subject variability for RNFL reflectance in healthy eyes.

METHODS

Vertical 30° × 15° volume scans at the optic disc were gathered using SD-OCT (Spectralis OCT) from people free of eye disease. Scans were gathered for both eyes of 30 younger adults (mean ± SD = 27 ± 3 years) and for one eye of 30 older adults (68 ± 8 years). Reflectance was quantified for each voxel as the depth-resolved attenuation coefficient (AC). Values for AC were extracted for four slabs (0-52, 24-52, 24-36 and 36-60 μm) and at depths from 24 to 60 μm below the inner limiting membrane (ILM) in 4 μm steps.

RESULTS

Between-subject and within-eye standard deviations (SDs) for the logarithm of AC were similar; median differences were 0.02-0.03 log unit across all four slabs and depths from 24 to 48 μm. Means for the logarithm of AC were higher for younger than older eyes by ~0.1 log unit; this age effect was not due to differences in the raw reflectance of the RNFL, but rather to age-related changes in reflectance of deeper retina affecting the calculation of AC.

CONCLUSIONS

In both groups, within-eye variability in RNFL reflectance near the optic disc was similar to between-subject variability. A better understanding of within-eye variability would be useful for developing normative databases.

Enhanced Objective Detection of Retinal Nerve Fiber Bundle Defects in Glaucoma With a Novel Method for En Face OCT Slab Image Construction and Analysis

Purpose

To introduce and evaluate the performance in detecting glaucomatous abnormalities of a novel method for extracting en face slab images (SMAS), which considers varying individual anatomy and configuration of retinal nerve fiber bundles.

Methods

Dense central retinal spectral domain optical coherence tomography scans were acquired in 16 participants with glaucoma and 19 age-similar controls. Slab images were generated by averaging reflectivity over different depths below the inner limiting membrane according to several methods. SMAS considered multiple 16 µm thick slabs from 8 to 116 µm below the inner limiting membrane, whereas 5 alternative methods considered single summary slabs of various thicknesses and depths. Superpixels in eyes with glaucoma were considered abnormal if below the first percentile of distributions fitted to control data for each method. The ability to detect glaucoma defects was measured by the proportion of abnormal superpixels. Proportion of superpixels below the fitted first percentile in controls was used as a surrogate false-positive rate. The effects of slab methods on performance measures were evaluated with linear mixed models.

Results

The ability to detect glaucoma defects varied between slab methods, χ2(5) = 120.9, P < 0.0001, with SMAS showing proportion of abnormal superpixels 0.05 to 0.09 greater than alternatives (all P < 0.0001). No slab method found abnormal superpixels in controls.

Conclusions

SMAS outperformed alternatives in detecting abnormalities in eyes with glaucoma. SMAS evaluates all depths with potential retinal nerve fiber bundle presence by combining multiple slabs, resulting in greater detection of reflectance abnormalities with no increase in surrogate false positives.

Translational Relevance

SMAS may be used to objectively detect glaucoma defects in en face optical coherence tomography images.