Repeatability and Reproducibility of Corneal Biometric Measurements Using the Visante Omni and a Rabbit Experimental Model of Post-Surgical Corneal Ectasia

Establishment and evaluation of rabbit model for corneal ectasia by photorefractive keratectomy

The study aimed to compare the effects of different types of excimer laser keratectomy on rabbit corneas and to identify the optimal disease model for corneal ectasia. Additionally, investigating the structural and molecular alterations in the novel disease model helped explore the mechanisms underlying biomechanical cues in corneal ectasia. 2.0-2.5 kg New Zealand white rabbits were treated with different types of excimer laser keratectomy, including comparisons between photorefractive keratectomy (PRK) and phototherapeutic keratectomy (PTK) surgeries, as well as comparisons of different ablation depths of PRK. Detailed tests on post-surgery corneas included pentacam analyzer, H&E staining and optical coherence tomography (OCT), transmission electron microscopy (TEM), raman spectroscopy and uniaxial tensile tests. Later, tandem mass tag-labeled proteomics and multiply statistic analysis were performed on post-PRK75 corneas. Western blot was used to validate protein expression. Herein, we found that tapered corneal thinning in post-PRK corneas predisposed to corneal ectasia. Greater ablation depth increased ectasia risk. PRK75 (ablation of 75% of corneal thickness using PRK mode) emerged as the optimal modeling approach, evidenced by significant and sustained corneal ectasia for 4 weeks. The 4-week post-PRK75 corneas were evaluated by changes in stromal cell microstructure, basement membrane, collagen lamellae, collagen covalent bonds and decreased corneal biomechanical strength. Additionally, PRK75 surgery induced 109 differentially expressed proteins (DEPs), with 51 previously linked to human corneal ectasia. The statistic analysis demonstrated the dysregulation of immue response was involved in the post-PRK75 corneas, and identified nine core proteins involved in corneal ectasia, including SERPINH1, ALDH1A1, MMP10, A2M, GSTM3, CD44, CLU, C3, and ITGB2. Therefore, we concluded that PRK75 was a novel and reliable modeling method for corneal ectasia, resemble human corneal ectasia. The intrinsic structural remodeling and molecular alteration in post-PRK75 corneas could shed lights on understanding the mechanism of biomechanical cues in corneal ectasia in the future.

Experimental models for keratoconus: Insights and challenges

Keratoconus, a progressive corneal disorder characterized by the thinning and conical protrusion of the cornea because of collagen degradation, poses significant challenges to both clinicians and researchers. Most successful animal models of keratoconus are based on genetic mutations and knock-outs in mice and rats that hinder normal corneal stromal architecture, thickness, or strength. While mice and rat models are suitable to study the molecular mechanism and physiological changes to the cornea, they are not suitable for experimental research; especially for surgical interventions like: deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty (DALK), stromal lenticule addition keratoplasty, and other advanced therapies. This review article comprehensively examines recent advancements in experimental models for keratoconus, focusing on their potential for translational research and the challenges ahead. It explores the historical context of experimental models, focusing on animal-based models, mainly rabbits in particular. These advancements enable researchers to mimic the biomechanical and biochemical alterations observed in keratoconic corneas. While these models offer valuable insights into disease mechanisms and treatment development, several challenges remain in transforming experimental findings into clinical applications.

Revisiting rabbit models for keratoconus: A long-term study on collagenase-induced disease progression

Keratoconus (KC) is a degenerative disorder resulting from the degradation of the stromal collagen fibril network in the cornea, leading to its thinning and conical deformation. Various studies have established animal models of KC by using the collagenase type II enzyme to gain a better understanding of the pathogenesis, however, long-term monitoring or follow-up of the models have not been reported so far. This study evaluates the long-term stability of collagenase type II-induced KC in a rabbit model. Six New Zealand rabbits were divided into 4 study groups with 3 eyes per group. The groups were control (group 1), 0.5% proparacaine + 5 min collagenase treatment on day 0 and day 30 (group 2), 0.5% proparacaine + 10 min collagenase treatment on day 0 (group 3) and, mechanical debridement + 2 min collagenase treatment on day 0 (group 4). Inflammation was observed in group 4 till week 10. Significant decrease in the central corneal thickness was observed in group 3 by week 4 (p < 0.001) however, the thickness was regained in the subsequent follow-ups in all the groups. Keratography results showed no changes in Km values but an increased astigmatic power in all groups. Scanning electron microscopy images revealed thinner collagen fibrils arranged in a mesh-like pattern above the uniform layer of the collagen lamellae in the central part of the treated corneas. Similarly, histological staining revealed loosely packed stromal fibrils in the anterior portion of the cornea which corroborates with the immunofluorescent staining results. This study revealed the remodeling of the corneal structure by eight weeks of collagenase treatment. Consequently, the possibility of creating a rabbit keratoconus model induced by collagenase may warrant further consideration.

Combination of violet light irradiation and collagenase treatments in a rabbit model of keratoconus

Purpose

We evaluated the use of collagenase treatment to generate a rabbit model of keratoconus and the impact of violet light (VL) irradiation on the disease model in six Japanese White rabbits.

Methods

After epithelial debridement, the collagenase group was treated with a collagenase type II solution for 30 min; the control group was treated with a solution without collagenase. Three rabbits also underwent VL irradiation (375 nm, irradiance 310 μW/cm²) for 3 h daily for 7 days after topical collagenase application. Slit-lamp microscopy results, steep keratometry (Ks), corneal astigmatism, central corneal thickness, and axial length were examined before and after the procedure. The corneas were obtained on day 7 for biomechanical evaluation.

Results

A significant increase in Ks and corneal astigmatism was observed in the collagenase and VL irradiation groups compared with the control group on day 7. No significant difference was found in the change in corneal thickness between the groups. The elastic modulus at 3, 5, and 10% strain was significantly lower in the collagenase group than in the control group. There was no significant difference in the elastic modulus at any level of strain between the collagenase and VL irradiation groups. The average axial length at day 7 was significantly longer in the collagenase and VL irradiation groups than in the control group. Collagenase treatment induced a model of keratoconus by steepening the keratometric and astigmatic values. There was no significant difference in the observed elastic behavior of normal and ectatic corneas under physiologically relevant stress levels.

Conclusion

VL irradiation did not cause regression of corneal steepening in a collagenase-induced model during short-term observation.

Combination of violet light irradiation and collagenase treatments in a rabbit model

PURPOSE

To investigate the use of collagenase type II for generating a rabbit model of keratoconus and to evaluate the impact of violet light (VL) irradiation on the disease model.

METHODS

Six Japanese White rabbits were used. After epithelial debridement, the collagenase group was treated with a collagenase type II solution for 30 min; the control group was treated with a solution without collagenase. Three rabbits also underwent VL irradiation (375 nm, irradiance 310 μW/cm2) for 3 h daily for 7 days after topical collagenase application. Slit-lamp microscopy, steep keratometry (Ks), corneal astigmatism, central corneal thickness, and axial length were examined before and after the procedure. The corneas were obtained on day 7 for biomechanical evaluation.

RESULTS

A significant increase in Ks and corneal astigmatism was observed in the collagenase and VL irradiation groups compared with the control group at day 7. No significant difference was found in the change in corneal thickness between the groups. The elastic modulus at 10% strain but not at 3% and 5% strain in the collagenase group was significantly lower than that in the control group. There was no significant difference in the elastic modulus at each level of strain between the collagenase and VL irradiation groups. The average axial length at day 7 in the collagenase group was significantly longer than that in the control group.

CONCLUSIONS

Collagenase type II treatment can mimic keratoconus with increased corneal keratometry and astigmatism. There was no significant difference in the observed elastic behaviour of normal and ectatic corneas under physiologically relevant stress levels. VL irradiation did not cause regression of corneal steepening in this model with short-term observation.

Validation of the Use of Automated and Manual Quantitative Analysis of Corneal Nerve Plexus Following Refractive Surgery

Following refractive surgery, the cornea is denervated and re-innervated, hence a reproducible tool to objectively quantify this change is warranted. This study aimed to determine the repeatability and reproducibility of corneal nerve quantification between automated (ACCMetrics) and manual software (CCMetrics) following refractive surgery. A total of 1007 in vivo confocal microscopy images from 20 post-small incision lenticule extraction (SMILE) or post-laser-assisted in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) patients were evaluated by two independent observers using CCMetrics for corneal nerve fibre density (CNFD), corneal nerve branch density (CNBD), and corneal nerve fibre length (CNFL). Intra-observer and inter-observer reproducibility and repeatability, as well as agreement and correlation between the measurements obtained by ACCMetrics and CCMetrics, were assessed. We found that CNFL demonstrated the best intra- and inter-observer agreement followed by CNFD (intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC) = 0.799 and 0.740, respectively for CNFL; 0.757 and 0.728 for CNFD). CNBD demonstrated poorest intra- and inter-observer ICC. There was an underestimation in ACCMetrics measurements compared to CCMetrics measurements, although the differences were not significant. Our data suggested that both automated and manual methods can be used as reliable tools for the evaluation of corneal nerve status following refractive surgery. However, the measurements obtained with different methods are not interchangeable.

Corneal Stability of LASIK and SMILE When Combined With Collagen Cross-Linking

Purpose

We investigate whether small incision lenticule extraction (SMILE) is associated with less ectasia than laser-assisted in-situ keratomileusis (LASIK) and whether concomitant collagen cross-linking (CXL) is protective in SMILE Xtra and LASIK Xtra.

Methods

Using an established LASIK rabbit ectasia model, we performed −5 diopter (D) LASIK on six eyes and −5 D SMILE on six eyes; five eyes had −5 D LASIK Xtra, five eyes −5 D SMILE Xtra. Anterior segment optical coherence tomography and corneal topography were performed preoperatively and 2, 4, and 6 weeks postoperatively. Mean (standard deviation [SD]) values of postoperative keratometry (K), maximum posterior elevation (MPE) and minimum corneal thickness (CT) were compared to preoperatively and among the surgical groups (paired t-test, analysis of variance).

Results

Mean (SD) K values decreased significantly following SMILE, SMILE Xtra, LASIK, and LASIK Xtra. The MPE increased significantly (P < 0.05) following LASIK, SMILE, and SMILE Xtra, but not following LASIK Xtra (P = 0.12). The MPE was less following SMILE than LASIK, but not statistically significant (week 2, 17.73 [5.77] vs. 22.75 [5.05] μm; P = 0.13); post-LASIK Xtra MPE was less than that following LASIK (week 2. 13.39 [3.05] vs. 22.75 [5.05] μm; P < 0.001). CT decreased significantly in all surgical groups; no differences were detected among the groups.

Conclusions

SMILE may have less potential than LASIK to induce ectasia. LASIK Xtra and SMILE Xtra showed the smallest increase in MPE.

Translational Relevance

Concomitant CXL may be protective following keratorefractive surgery and may reduce further the risk of ectasia.

Pentacam® Corneal Tomography for Screening of Refractive Surgery Candidates: A Review of the Literature, Part I

Corneal tomography and Scheimpflug imaging are frequently used to analyze the corneal surface, especially in the field of cataract and refractive surgery. The Pentacam system is one of the most commonly used commercially available systems for this purpose. Through a rotating Scheimpflug camera, the system is capable of creating a three-dimensional map of the cornea. These advances in tomography have simultaneously enhanced the ability of clinicians to screen surgical candidates and detect subtle corneal changes in diseases such as keratoconus. However, there remains a need to enhance diagnosis in order to recognize mild and early forms of corneal ectasia. As iatrogenic ectasia and keratoconus are dreaded complications of refractive surgery, it is imperative to screen patients appropriately prior to surgery. The Pentacam is one of many systems utilized in the screening process, but the literature has not identified specific protocol nor parameters that are capable of carrying out this process appropriately. Post-operative keratoconus continues to occur despite the advances in technology seen in corneal imaging. Therefore, clear indices for screening are required in order to diagnose early forms of keratoconus and other corneal diseases that may exclude the seemingly asymptomatic patient from undergoing refractive surgery. This article aims to summarize the indices available on the Pentacam system and to identify the most accurate parameters for screening of the refractive surgery candidate.

A rabbit model of corneal Ectasia generated by treatment with collagenase type II

BACKGROUND

To investigate use of collagenase type II for generating a rabbit model of corneal ectasia.

METHODS

Ten New Zealand white rabbits were used with right eyes treated as the experimental group and left eyes treated as the control group. After epithelial debridement, a collagenase type II solution (200 μL of 5 mg/mL) was applied in the experimental group at room temperature (24 °C) for 30 min, and a 200 μL solution without collagenase was applied in the control group. Slit-lamp microscopy, the mean keratometry (Km), and central cornea thickness (CCT) were examined before and after the procedure. Corneas were obtained on day 14 for biomechanical evaluation.

RESULTS

No obvious inflammatory reaction was observed in all eyes after the procedure. A statistically significant increase in Km (1.54 ± 1.29D vs - 0.82 ± 0.44D at day7 and 0.89 ± 0.89D vs - 2.11 ± 1.02D at day14) and a statistically significant decrease in CCT (- 23.10 ± 12.17 μm vs 6.20 ± 16.51 μm at day7 and - 16.10 ± 10.46 μm vs 11.60 ± 0.88 μm at day14) were observed in the experimental group compared with the control group. The mean stresses and elastic modulus at 5%, 10%, 15%, and 20% deformities in the experimental group decreased and the differences in elastic modulus between the two groups were statistically significant at 10% and 15% deformities.

CONCLUSIONS

Collagenase type II treatment results in mimic KC with increased corneal keratometry and corneal thinning and a lower elastic modulus. An animal model for corneal ectasia can be generated by treatment with collagenase type II.

Biological corneal inlay for presbyopia derived from small incision lenticule extraction (SMILE)

Corneal inlays are a relatively new treatment option for presbyopia. Using biological inlays, derived from lenticules extracted from small incision lenticule extraction, may offer advantages over commercialized synthetic inlays in the aspect of biocompatibility. We conducted a non-human primate study to evaluate the safety, predictability, efficacy and tissue response after autogeneic, decellularized xenogeneic and xenogeneic lenticule implantation. The lenticule implantation effectively resulted in central corneal steepening (simulated keratometric values increased by 1.8–2.3 diopters), central hyper-prolate changes (asphericity Q values changed by −0.26 to −0.36), corneal anterior surface elevation (7.7–9.3 μm) and reasonable effective zone (1.5–1.8 times of the lenticule physical diameter), with no differences among the three groups. Slit lamp microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, confocal microscopy, histology and immunohistochemistry analyses confirmed the biocompatibility of the autogeneic and decellularized lenticules, whereas one eye in the xenogeneic group developed corneal stromal rejection during the study period. Our results showed that lenticule implantation has the potential for the management of presbyopia, and provide the basis for future clinical studies. The decellularization process may increase the potential utilization of lenticules without changing the efficacy.

Wound healing profiles of hyperopic-small incision lenticule extraction (SMILE)

Refractive surgical treatment of hyperopia still remains a challenge for refractive surgeons. A new nomogram of small incision lenticule extraction (SMILE) procedure has recently been developed for the treatment of hyperopia. In the present study, we aimed to evaluate the wound healing and inflammatory responses of this new nomogram (hyperopic-SMILE), and compared them to those of hyperopic-laser-assisted in situ keratomileusis (LASIK), using a rabbit model. A total of 26 rabbits were used, and slit lamp biomicroscopy, autorefractor/keratometer, intraocular pressure measurement, anterior segment optical coherence tomography, corneal topography, and in vivo confocal microscopy examinations were performed during the study period of 4 weeks. The corneas were then harvested and subject to immunofluorescence of markers for inflammation (CD11b), wound healing (fibronectin) and keratocyte response (HSP47). The lenticule ultrastructual changes were also analyzed by transmission electron microscopy. Out results showed that hyperopic-SMILE effectively steepened the cornea. Compared to hyperopic-LASIK, hyperopic-SMILE had less postoperative wound healing response and stromal interface reaction, especially in higher refractive correction. However, compared to myopic-SMILE, hyperopic-SMILE resulted in more central deranged collagen fibrils. These results provide more perspective into this new treatment option for hyperopia, and evidence for future laser nomogram modification.

Effect of Intraoperative Corneal Stromal Pocket Irrigation in Small Incision Lenticule Extraction

This study aimed at evaluating the effect of intraoperative corneal pocket irrigation in small incision lenticule extraction (SMILE) and compares it to that in femtosecond laser-assisted in situ keratomileusis (FS-LASIK). Sixteen rabbit eyes underwent a SMILE procedure, with 8 eyes having corneal pocket irrigation, while the other 8 eyes were without irrigation. Another 16 eyes underwent a FS-LASIK procedure for comparison, with 8 eyes having flap irrigation, while the other 8 eyes were without irrigation. The results showed that the changes in the total corneal thickness, anterior and posterior lamellar thickness, measured by the anterior segment optical coherence tomography, were comparable between the SMILE with and without irrigation groups, suggesting that the irrigation did not lead to significant changes in the corneal thickness. However, at postoperative 8 hours, in vivo confocal microscopy showed that the interface reflectivity in the SMILE with irrigation group was significantly higher than that in other three groups. The presence of interface fluid was further confirmed by the identification of fluid pockets with undulated collagen shown on histological section in the post-SMILE with irrigation eyes. Our findings might contribute to the occurrence of post-SMILE delayed immediate visual quality recovery and further clinical study is required.