Activation of clones producing self-reactive antibodies by foreign antigen and antiidiotype antibody carrying the internal image of the antigen

Evidence for multiple mechanisms of polyclonal T cell activation in murine lupus

Individuals with systemic autoantibody-mediated diseases such as lupus have polyclonal T and B cell activation. Yet, autoantibody production is restricted to certain autoantigens. The mechanisms underlying this phenomenon remain unclear. We propose three potential mechanisms by which autoreactive helper T cell responses diversify to become polyclonal, yet are restricted to certain antigens. First, using a model where self-Ig peptides spontaneously activate T cells and modulate disease in lupus mice, we demonstrate that the numbers of autoantibody-augmenting T helper peptides increased across the Ig molecule as mice aged ("intramolecular determinant spreading"). Secondly, a single T cell hybridoma established from a (NZB x NZW)F1 mouse immunized with one self-Ig peptide recognized several Ig-derived determinants, which had little sequence homology with the immunizing peptide. Such determinant degeneracy can lead to polyclonality. To explore a mechanism for restriction to certain autoantigens, a protein database search was done for homologies with sequences of selected stimulatory Ig peptides. Identical sequences of such determinants were not found in murine proteins other than Ig. These occurred infrequently in nonautoantibody Ig, but quite commonly in lupus-related autoantibodies such as antibodies to DNA, cardiolipin, and erythrocytes. Thus, determinant spreading and degenerate recognition in T cells coupled with recurring use of T cell determinant sequences among autoantibodies result in polyclonality that is restricted to certain autoantigens.

Induction of anti-polycation antibodies in H-2s mice by immunization with nuclear antigens

Following administration of certain chemicals (heavy metals or lupus-inducing drugs), H-2s mice produce autoantibodies reacting with various nuclear antigens such as fibrillarin in the nucleolus and histones in chromatin. In the present study, we have immunized A.SW (H-2s) mice and their congenic counterparts A.BY (H-2b) mice with bovine thymus nuclei in Freund's adjuvant. As was previously observed with lupus-prone mice, such active immunization did not elicit antinuclear antibodies in any of the experimental groups. Surprisingly, the A.SW immunized with nuclei in adjuvant developed high titers of IgG antibodies that reacted exclusively with synthetic polycations. We obtained several monoclonal IgG antibodies from these mice and verified that these polycation-reactive antibodies were not directed against a specific nuclear antigen. The genetic analysis of the monoclonal antibodies further confirmed their clonal diversity. The mechanisms leading to the appearance of antibodies reactive with highly basic molecules in A.SW mice may be related to their predisposition to produce autoantibodies to cationic nuclear antigens (fibrillarin, histones) during chemically-induced autoimmunity.

Rapid detection of recombinant antibody fragments directed against cell-surface antigens by flow cytometry

Cloning the correct genes coding for antibody variable domains (especially VL kappa) from hybridomas is often complicated by the presence of several immunoglobulin transcripts, some of them arising from the myeloma cell line. Indeed, four different VL genes were obtained after the amplification of immunoglobulin genes by PCR from the hybridoma HD37, which produces an antibody against the human CD19 B cell differentiation antigen. Most of the variants (eight out of 15) were derived from the kappa chain of the myeloma MOPC-21. For the rapid functional evaluation of recombinant antibody fragments against cell surface antigens, we established an efficient expression and detection system. First, deleted and mutated genes were eliminated by a colony screening procedure. Bacteria from picked colonies were then induced and grown in the presence of 0.4 M sucrose to increase the accumulation of soluble scFv in the periplasm (5-10 micrograms per ml of bacterial shake-tube culture). Finally, the cell-specific binding of scFv in crude periplasmic extracts was detected by flow cytometry. This procedure facilitated the efficient cloning of a functional anti-CD19 VH/VL combination from the hybridoma cDNA.

Study of self reactive antibodies in kappa-light chain deficient mice

The kappa chain deficient mouse strain represents an excellent experimental system for studying the contribution of lambda light chains to the antibody repertoire. Here, we have studied the contribution of lambda chains to the generation of self reactive antibodies including RFs in kappa deficient mice with 129/sv background. These mutant mice produce rheumatoid factors similar to 129/sv mice and these antibodies are primarily encoded by lambda 2. This may be due to the production of RF by peritoneal B lymphocytes which belong to Ly1 B subset. Peritoneal B cell selectively produce lambda 2 and lambda 3 isotypes. Though lambda 1 positive RF is not detectable in the sera, lambda 1 positive specific precursor B cells are present in these mice and they can be activated by T-independent antigens. Our studies show that these mice also spontaneously produce anti-dsDNA antibodies bearing lambda 1 light chain but do not produce self reactive antibodies specific for eight different autoantigens. However, B cell precursors expressing lambda chains specific for autoantigens like collagen II, III, IV and histone 2A are present in the B cell repertoire of kappa-deficient mice. Thus, our results demonstrate that lambda light chain can compensate, to some extent, the lack of kappa chain repertoire, not only against foreign antigens, as observed previously, but also against a number of autoantigens.

The role of VL gene structural determinants in the fine specificity of anti-DNA antibodies

To investigate the structural contribution of the light chain of anti-DNA antibodies to fine specificity, the VKappa genes of two monoclonal anti-DNA antibodies, termed H241 and H102, were cloned and sequenced. H102 and H241 are independently derived from MRL-lpr/lpr mice and differ in their fine specificity: H241 binds dsDNA and normal glomeruli in vitro and deposits in the kidney in vivo, whereas H102 binds only ssDNA and does not deposit in the kidney. Both are encoded by nearly identical VH genes but different N and D regions. Our previous results have demonstrated that the VH gene for H102 and H241 encodes eight other anti-DNA antibodies that also differed in fine specificity. This suggested that the gene product encoded by the VH 102/241 gene, may have intrinsic affinity for DNA, but is unlikely to determine fine specificity or nephritogenicity. In the present study we examined whether the VKappa gene might account for the difference in nephritogenicity. The complete nucleotide and deduced amino acid sequence of VK 102 and VK241 revealed that they are very dissimilar to each other (< 60% homology). VK 241 defined a new member of the VKappa gene family and was moderately homologous to two other VK genes encoding anti-DNA antibodies and to one VK gene encoding an anti-histone antibody all from lupus strains of mice. In addition, sequence diversity in the VK CDR1 region and position 96 of the CDR3 region was observed that may be of significance in determining fine specificity. VK 102 was highly homologous to two other VKappa genes, VKs17.2 and VK C8.5, both encoding anti-DNA antibodies and members of the VK20 gene family. It was striking that all three members of the VK 20 gene family code for DNA reactivity. This suggests that certain VKappa genes may also be used to repeatedly code for anti-DNA reactivity.

Variable region sequences of autoantibodies from mice with experimental systemic lupus erythematosus

We have sequenced nine monoclonal antibodies (mAb) derived from C3H.SW mice in which experimental systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) was induced. The hybridomas were selected for binding to DNA or to HeLa nuclear extract (NE). Three mAb were found to bind DNA, and are shown to exhibit sequence characteristics of pathogenic anti-DNA antibodies. One, mAb 2C4C2, is shown to use a heavy chain V region gene (VH) identical to the VH of anti-DNA mAb isolated from other lupus-prone mice, namely (NZB x NZW)F1. The light chain V region gene (VL) of mAb 2C4C2 is 98% homologous to the VL of another anti-DNA mAb, also isolated from (NZB x NZW)F1 mice. The other two anti-DNA mAb, 5G12-4 and 5G12-6, share 93% of their VH sequences with that of mAb 2C4C2. Six mAb bound proteins of HeLa NE. Four of these six antibodies were found to use the VH124 VH and V-L7 VL. The nine mAb use a total of five VH and four VL germ-line genes, demonstrating that the autoantibodies induced in mice with experimental SLE do not originate from one B cell clone. Three of these nine VH and VL were identical in sequence to germ-line genes, while at least three others had somatic mutations. The latter suggests that the above autoantibodies arise in mice by both usage of existing (pre-immune) B cells, and through an antigen-driven process. Furthermore, it appears that autoantibodies found in mice with experimental SLE use genetic elements similar to those used by mAb that were isolated from mouse strains which develop lupus spontaneously.

Abnormalities in the regulation of variable region genes that encode for antibodies to DNA may be a central factor in the pathogenesis of systemic lupus erythematosus

Systemic lupus erythematosus (lupus) is characterised by the excessive and spontaneous production of antibodies to DNA. In animal models of lupus, and in humans, antibodies to DNA have been directly implicated in pathogenesis. The variable region genes that encode for reactivity of antibodies to DNA have, in general, not been regarded as a risk factor in lupus. Recent evidence from several workers, including ourselves, does not sustain this dogma. Individual autoreactive V genes appear to be repeatedly used and to have an affinity for DNA. These genes are present in subjects with the disease and in some, but not all, normal subjects. Presumably, in some subjects carrying autoreactive V genes in their germline, these genes are normally silenced by regulatory factors, including cytokines, and in others with disease there is a breakdown in regulation. Experimental evidence suggests that multiple cytokines may have a role and that this role is complex.

Independently derived murine glomerular immune deposit-forming anti-DNA antibodies are encoded by near-identical VH gene sequences

To examine the influence of variable region sequences on the capacity of individual lupus autoantibodies (autoAb) to form glomerular immune deposits, the complete VH and VL region sequences of three anti-DNA mAb that produced morphologically similar immune deposits after administration to normal mice were determined. The Ig were independently derived from 1-mo-old (H238, IgM), 3-mo-old (H8, IgG2a), and 6-mo-old (H161, IgG3) MRL-lpr/lpr mice, and they all produced subendothelial and mesangial immune deposits after passive transfer to normal mice. In addition, H238 and H161 produced granular deposits in small extraglomerular vessels. The mAb had nearly identical VH gene sequences; H8 differed from H238 and H161 by a single nucleotide in FR1 that resulted in a histidine for glutamine substitution. This VH gene sequence was also > 99% homologous to another anti-DNA Ab (termed H241), that we previously reported to produce glomerular immune deposits in a similar morphologic pattern. H161 and H238 were encoded by DFL16 and JH2 genes, whereas H8 was encoded by a JH4 gene. Different Vk family genes were used to encode the three mAb, however H161 and H238 both used a Jk5 gene. The results indicate that an identical or highly related VH gene is used to encode a subgroup of murine lupus autoAb that share immune deposit forming properties. Furthermore, they raise the possibility that amino acid residues independent from those encoded by VH genes may be influential in immune deposit formation at extraglomerular sites.

Variable regions of antibodies to synthetic polypeptides--III. Antibodies arising in response to administration of anti-idiotope

Antibodies elicited by the synthetic polypeptide antigen (T,G)-A-L are directed against two distinct epitopes. The majority of antibodies bind to a GT containing epitope and bear an idiotope defined by monoclonal antibodies I7 and I9. In this study, we have examined the effect of in vivo administration of the I7 and I9 antibodies to mice. Administration of anti-idiotope elicits anti-(T,G)-A-L antibodies in all strains of mice tested, including genetic non-responders to (T,G)-A-L. These antibodies bind to GT and express the idiotope. Additionally, idiotope expressing antibodies that fail to bind to antigen are also produced. Monoclonal anti-(anti-idiotope) antibodies were made. One antibody bound to (T,G)-A-L, the other did not. Sequence analysis was performed and the V-regions of (T,G)-A-L binding antibodies were compared to those of the antibody that failed to bind antigen. Both sets of antibodies are derived from the same germline V-genes as the anti-(T,G)-A-L antibodies. These results have implications for understanding the nature of network regulation of the immune system and for those attempting idiotypic vaccination.

Autoantibodies and autoantigens: a conserved system that may shape a primary immunoglobulin gene pool

Formation of certain autoantibodies is associated with a variety of autoimmune diseases, but the production of small amounts of autoantibodies also occurs in the normal immune system. Germline-encoded IgM antibodies that are autoreactive and bind to diverse antigen structures with low affinity are prominent in the primary antibody repertoire. Many IgG disease-related autoantibodies differ in structure and binding properties from these normally occurring IgM autoantibodies. The two sets may arise independently, but some properties, such as shared idiotypes, link some members of the two populations. Many autoantigen targets of both sets of autoantibodies are structurally conserved among species, as are certain features of the autoantibodies themselves. These elements, interacting before exposure of the system to foreign antigens, may constitute a conserved system that contributes to shaping and maintaining a primary immunoglobulin gene pool.

Autoantibodies, LY-1, and immunoglobulin V gene expression in hybridomas obtained from young and from old New Zealand black mice

We obtained a large number of hybridomas from 1-month-old and 16-month-old New Zealand black mice to study the fine specificities of the autoantibodies produced, the expression of Ly-1, and the expression of the immunoglobulin V gene families in this autoimmune strain. Analysis of the autoantibody specificities yielded 2 major classifications: those specific for a single autoantigen and those that exhibited multispecific binding. Among the multispecific antibodies, 2 categories were found: an antigen-inhibitable group and an antigen-noninhibitable group. A large proportion of VHJ558 and VH7183 gene families was observed in hybridomas obtained from 1-month-old mice, and in hybridomas obtained from 16-month-old mice, there was a large proportion of VHJ558 and VH36-60 gene families. Among the autoantibody kappa chains secreted by the hybridomas, there was a higher frequency of the V kappa 1, V kappa 8, and V kappa 9 gene families. Autoantibodies were produced by both the Ly-1+ and the Ly-1- B cell subsets.

Pathogenic anti-DNA antibodies in SLE: idiotypic families and genetic origins

We have adopted an idiotypic approach to study the double stranded DNA (dsDNA) binding antibodies of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Three anti-idiotypic reagents, 8.12, 3I, and F4, identify cross reactive idiotypes that are each expressed on anti-dsDNA antibodies in the sera of many patients with SLE. These idiotypic antibodies are implicated in the pathogenesis of SLE as they are present in immune complex deposits in the kidneys of patients with SLE glomerulonephritis. The autoantibody associated idiotypes are also expressed on antibodies that do not bind DNA. We are investigating the origin of the pathogenic anti-dsDNA antibodies of SLE by comparing the autoantibodies, the antibodies to foreign antigens, and the myeloma proteins that express each SLE associated idiotype. In conjunction with serological analysis of these idiotypic systems, molecular genetic studies indicate that both the 8.12 and the 3I autoantibody associated idiotypes may be germline encoded, while the F4 idiotype is generated by somatic mutation. The data further suggest that the antigenic specificity of the pathogenic anti-DNA antibodies of SLE is acquired through somatic mutation of germline immunoglobulin genes. By studying the regulation of genes capable of encoding pathogenic autoantibodies, in both SLE patients and non-autoimmune individuals, we may be able to elucidate the pathogenesis of autoimmune disease and begin to design more effective therapeutic interventions.

The LY-1 gene expression in murine hybridomas producing autoantibodies

Studies presented here demonstrate the expression of the Ly-1 gene and the detection of the Ly-1 cytodifferentiation antigen in murine hybridomas producing autoantibodies. We examined the transcription of the Ly-1 gene in thymocytes and 140 hybridomas producing autoantibodies of various specificities which were obtained from normal and autoimmune disease prone mouse strains. As previously demonstrated thymocytes stain brightly for Ly-1 by immunofluorescence and express Ly-1 transcripts. In our panel of hybridomas producing autoantibodies Ly-1 transcripts were detected in 31 (45%) out of 69 NZB hybridomas and 7 (88%) out of 8 viable motheaten hybridomas. S1 nuclease protection experiments showed that Ly-1 transcripts detected in thymocytes and B cells are the product of the same gene. The B cell transcripts are functional since immunofluorescence and Western data presented here detected the Ly-1 protein in hybridomas cells which were found to transcribe the Ly-1 gene. Interestingly a polymorphic transcription of the Ly-1 gene was observed in B cells and B cell hybridomas as compared to thymocytes. Our results obtained in the hybridoma system firmly establish a major contribution of the Ly-1 B cell subset to the production of DNA specific autoantibodies and a smaller contribution to the production of rheumatoid factors and "natural", multispecific autoantibodies.