Outcomes After Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy in Hyperkinetic Biliary Dyskinesia

Biliary Dyskinesia-Controversies, Diagnosis, and Management: A Review

Importance

Biliary dyskinesia is a disorder characterized by biliary pain, a sonographically normal gallbladder, and a reduced gallbladder ejection fraction on cholecystokinin-cholescintigraphy (CCK-HIDA) scan. Laparoscopic cholecystectomy remains a common treatment for biliary dyskinesia despite a lack of high-quality evidence supporting the practice. The following review summarizes the current biliary dyskinesia outcomes data, the diagnostic strategies and their limitations, biliary dyskinesia in the pediatric population, the emerging phenomenon of the hyperkinetic gallbladder, and suggestions for addressing identified knowledge gaps.

Observations

The majority of studies on the topic are retrospective, with wide variations in inclusion criteria and definition of biliary pain. Most report a very short follow-up interval, often a single office visit, with variable and nonstandardized definitions of a satisfactory outcome. Despite a published Society of Nuclear Medicine guideline for its performance, CCK-HIDA scan protocols vary among institutions, which has led to considerable variability in the consistency and reproducibility of CCK-HIDA results. The few prospective studies available, although small and heterogeneous, support a role for cholecystectomy in the treatment of adult biliary dyskinesia. Despite these knowledge gaps, biliary dyskinesia is now the number 1 indication for cholecystectomy in children. Cholecystectomy for the hyperkinetic gallbladder appears to be an emerging phenomenon, despite, as in biliary dyskinesia, a lack of quality data supporting this practice. Randomized trials addressing these gaps are needed but have been difficult to conduct owing to strong clinician and patient bias toward surgery and the lack of a criterion-standard nonsurgical treatment for the control arm.

Conclusions and Relevance

The use of cholecystectomy for adult biliary dyskinesia is reasonable based on the available data. Insufficient data exist regarding laparoscopic cholecystectomy for pediatric dyskinesia and the hyperkinetic gallbladder population. Large-scale prospective studies, either randomized trials or large prospectively followed cohort studies, are needed to address the knowledge gaps surrounding this controversial diagnosis.

Hyperkinetic Biliary Dyskinesia: An Underrecognized Problem With Good Surgical Outcomes After Cholecystectomy

Introduction While surgical indications for symptomatic cholelithiasis and biliary hypokinesia are clear, hyperkinetic biliary dyskinesia (HBD) is an underrecognized condition with poorly defined symptomology and management guidelines. HBD is typically defined as a gallbladder ejection fraction (EF) ≥ 80% on a hepatobiliary iminodiacetic acid (HIDA) scan. We aimed to identify the prevalence and radiographic reporting of HBD, physician referral patterns, and clinical outcomes following cholecystectomy. Methods  A retrospective cohort study of patients with HIDA scans completed over 21 years at our tertiary care hospital was performed. Demographics, symptomatology, referral patterns, and operative data were collected. HBD was defined as HIDA EF ≥80%. Patients with HBD who underwent cholecystectomy were analyzed. ANOVA and chi-square tests were used to compare variables among patients with or without symptom improvement using Statistical Product and Service Solutions (SPSS; IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows, Armonk, NY). Results Of 1,997 patients (73% female, mean age 51.7 years) who had HIDA scans with reported EF, 730 (36.6%) had an EF≥80%. Only 13.7% of HIDA scans with EF≥80% were reported as hyperkinetic, and the rest are "normal". Cholecystectomy was performed in 57 (7.8%) patients with EF≥80%, most being elective (89.5%) and all minimally invasive. Primary care physicians (PCPs) referred most elective cases to surgery (61.4%). The median time from HIDA to cholecystectomy was 146 days. Chronic cholecystitis was common in pathology (82.5%), while 38.6% had cholelithiasis. Overall, 53 patients (93.0%) reported symptom improvement at a median follow-up of 17.0 days. Patients without improvement had a higher prevalence of chronic gastrointestinal conditions (p<0.05), but not significantly more cholelithiasis, cholecystitis, time to surgery, or elective surgery status. Conclusions HBD is common but often underdiagnosed and thus likely underrecognized by treating physicians. Most HBD patients benefit from cholecystectomy, regardless of cholelithiasis. Patients with persistent symptoms after cholecystectomy may have confounding gastrointestinal diagnoses. Increased awareness among radiologists, referring PCPs, gastroenterologists, and surgeons about HBD and postoperative outcomes is needed to ensure that HBD is adequately treated.

The gallbladder: what's new in 2022?

This review focuses mainly on the imaging diagnosis, treatment, and complications of acute cholecystitis which is the most common benign disease of the gallbladder. The American College of Radiology appropriateness criteria for the imaging evaluation of patients with right upper quadrant pain and the Tokyo Guidelines for evaluating patients with acute cholecystitis and acute cholangitis are presented. The recent articles for using US, CT, MR, and HIDA in the evaluation of patients with suspected acute cholecystitis are reviewed in detail. The clinical management and postoperative complications are described. Because gallbladder polyps and adenomyomatosis can mimic gallbladder malignancies and acute cholecystitis, their imaging findings and management are presented. Finally, due the recent literature reporting better results with CT than US in the diagnosis of acute cholecystitis, a suggested approach for imaging patients with right upper quadrant pain and possible acute cholecystitis is presented in an addendum.

The Role of Cholecystectomy in Hyperkinetic Gallbladder: A Retrospective Cohort Study in a Rural Hospital

Background Biliary dyskinesia is a functional gallbladder disorder in which there is an absence of a structural or mechanical cause for biliary pain. A cholecystokinin-hepatobiliary iminodiacetic acid (CCK-HIDA) scan is typically performed during workup, and cholecystectomy is the accepted treatment for low ejection fraction (EF) (less than 33%, as defined by the literature). However, few studies have examined the role of cholecystectomy in hyperkinetic gallbladder (EF ≥80%). The aim of our study was to examine symptom resolution following minimally invasive cholecystectomy in patients with hyperkinetic gallbladder. Methodology A retrospective chart review was conducted at Robert Packer Hospital in Sayre, PA. Patients who underwent minimally invasive cholecystectomy for biliary colic with EF ≥80% and who were without cholelithiasis on preoperative imaging or on final pathology were included in this study. The main outcome was symptom resolution at the postoperative visit. Data collected included age, gender, EF, body mass index, symptoms with CCK infusion, and pathology. Results A total of 48 patients were included. The mean age of patients was 41.2 years (standard deviation = 14.4), and the median age of patients was 42.2 years, with a range of 17-71 years. The majority of patients were female (83.3%). Overall, 58.3% of patients had replication of symptoms with CCK infusion. The mean gallbladder EF was 87.3%, with a median of 87.0 and a range of 80-98. In total, 33 (68.8%) patients had chronic cholecystitis on final pathology reports. There was a 95.9% symptom resolution rate among our patients two weeks postoperatively. Conclusions The overwhelming majority of patients experienced symptom resolution prior to their two-week postoperative visit following minimally invasive cholecystectomy for hyperkinetic gallbladder. These results strongly suggest a role of surgical management in patients with high EF.