Bedside screening for venous thrombosis using occlusive impedance phlebography

Deep Vein Thrombosis in Intravenous Drug Users: An Invisible Global Health Burden

The prevalence of intravenous drug use has increased in the past decade and it represents an important risk factor for deep vein thrombosis. Intravenous drug use is a global problem, with the main culprit being heroin. Peer pressure and poverty in high-risk groups such as sex workers, females, and young adults raise the risk of intravenous drug use, which expresses itself in the form of venous thromboembolism eventually. Deep vein thrombosis typically manifests itself eight years after the initial intravenous drug administration, rendering it a silent killer. Aiming to review and summarize existing articles in this context, we performed an exhaustive literature search online on PubMed and Google Scholar indexes using the keywords "Deep Venous Thrombosis (DVT)" and "Intravenous Drug Users (IVDU)." English articles that addressed epidemiology, pathogenesis, clinical manifestations, diagnosis, differential diagnosis, management, and outcomes of DVT, including those in IVDU, were selected and analyzed. The pathogenesis of DVT development in IVDU is mainly attributed to the interplay of trauma to the vessel by repeated injection and the injected drug itself. The right-sided femoral vein is the most common vein affected. Prevalent clinical presentations include local pain, swelling, and redness with typical systemic symptoms including fever, cough, dyspnea, and chest pain on top of addiction features. There appeared to be a delay in reporting symptoms, which was most likely due to the social stigma attached to IVDU. There are over 50 conditions that present with swollen and painful limbs comparable to DVT in IVDU, making precise diagnosis critical for timely treatment. Venous ultrasound is the method of choice for diagnosing DVT. Extended anticoagulant therapy with low-molecular-weight heparin combined with warfarin is the recommended treatment. Intravenous drug abusers having DVT are affected by multiple complications and poorer outcomes such as slower recovery, recurrent venous thromboembolism (VTE), and a longer hospital stay, which put them at higher risk of morbidity, mortality, reduced productivity, and economic burden.

Developments in diagnosis and classification of venous disorders: non-invasive diagnosis

PURPOSE

This review examines the many techniques that have been used for the non-invasive diagnosis of acute and chronic venous disease and was conducted by members of the Committee on Research of the American Venous Forum. It proposes to identify those techniques with the greatest clinical potential, to suggest algorithms for the clinical application of non-invasive techniques in the identification of acute deep venous thrombosis and chronic venous insufficiency, and to identify areas of deficient knowledge and potential areas for future research initiatives.

METHODS

Review of pertinent clinical and research material.

RESULTS

Impedance plethysmography and ultrasonic imaging are the primary non-invasive tools used in the diagnosis of acute deep venous thrombosis. At present, ultrasonic imaging techniques are recommended on the basis of greater diagnostic accuracy in recent comparative clinical trials. Data would suggest that serial evaluation should probably be viewed as the preferred option for symptomatic patients with a negative initial examination and the presence of risk factors or physical findings suggesting a proximal deep venous obstruction/thrombosis. Chronic venous disease is the result of valvular incompetence, with or without associated venous obstruction. Duplex imaging can be used to determine the location and extent of reflux; however, there are reported procedural variations in the performance and interpretation of such studies. Recent innovations in air plethysmography may provide a means of quantifying volume changes, and permit an objective characterization of venous reflux and calf pump efficiency.

CONCLUSIONS

There are still significant questions that need to be answered by well-designed research initiatives. Research applications that incorporate non-invasive diagnostic techniques may involve the diagnosis, treatment and natural history of acute deep venous obstruction/thrombosis and chronic venous insufficiency, assessment prior to and following venous reconstruction, and the basic science aspects of acute and chronic venous disease. At present, a lack of common standards is, by far, the greatest impediment to an organized research approach to venous disease.

Diagnostic management of venous thromboembolism

The accuracy of diagnostic methods for the diagnosis of deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism in symptomatic patients is critically reviewed. In addition, the safety of withholding anticoagulant therapy from patients with suspected deep vein thrombosis or pulmonary embolism in whom the qualified diagnostic strategy was normal is evaluated by determining the frequency of venous thromboembolic complications during 3 months of follow-up. It is shown that the currently used available diagnostic techniques for deep vein thrombosis are all able to identify the majority of patients who indeed have venous thrombosis. However, as result of its accuracy and practical advantages, compression ultrasound is the test of choice in the evaluation of symptomatic patients. Patients with a normal test outcome should be re-tested to detect the small proportion of patients with proximally extending calf vein thrombosis. In the strategy of repeated diagnostic testing, impedance plethysmography could be used as an alternative to ultrasonography. To obtain a reduction in repeat tests various diagnostic strategies have been evaluated and it was shown that these strategies, using non-invasive tests, can be as accurate and safe as the invasive reference strategy. The safeties of the various strategies were very similar; however, important differences were observed with respect to the practical implementation of the various diagnostic strategies. Simplification of the repeated testing strategy by using a D-dimer assay and/or a clinical decision rule seems to be promising. The reference standard for the diagnosis of pulmonary embolism remains pulmonary angiography. Several strategies based on non-invasive diagnostic methods have been evaluated for their safety and complexability. Perfusion-ventilation lung scanning is the most thoroughly evaluated non-invasive technique so far. It seems safe to withhold anticoagulant therapy in patients suspected of pulmonary embolism with a normal perfusion lung scan result; however, further testing is needed in the case of a non-diagnostic perfusion-ventilation lung scan result. At this moment angiography is the method of choice in this category of patients. D-dimer assays, clinical decision rules and ultrasound examinations of the legs seem to have a high potential to limit the need for angiography. Also, spiral computerized tomography and magnetic resonance imaging are promising techniques, but their role in the diagnostic management of pulmonary embolism is still uncertain.

Clinical features and diagnosis of venous thrombosis

The clinical diagnosis of venous thrombosis is inaccurate because the clinical findings are both insensitive and nonspecific. The sensitivity of clinical diagnosis is low because many potentially dangerous venous thrombi are clinically silent. The specificity of clinical diagnosis is low because the symptoms or signs of venous thrombosis all can be caused by nonthrombotic disorders. For these reasons, a practical approach for the diagnosis of venous thrombosis is important. A current approach to the diagnosis of clinically suspected venous thrombosis favors the use of impedance plethysmography over Doppler ultrasonography as the main test for this disorder. This is because impedance plethysmography is precise and objective, whereas the interpretation of Doppler ultrasonography is subjective and requires considerable skill and experience to form reliable diagnoses. The use of serial impedance plethysmography has been evaluated recently in a prospective study. The rationale of repeated impedance plethysmography evaluation is based on the premise that calf vein thrombi are only clinically important when they extend into the proximal veins, at which point detection with impedance plethysmography is possible. Therefore, by performing repeated examinations with impedance plethysmography in patients with clinically suspected venous thrombosis, it is possible to identify patients with extending calf vein thrombosis who can be treated appropriately. Impedance plethysmography is performed immediately on referral; if it is positive in the absence of clinical conditions that are known to produce falsely positive results, the diagnosis of venous thrombosis is established, and the patient is treated accordingly. If the result of the initial impedance plethysmography evaluation is negative, anticoagulant therapy is withheld, and impedance plethysmography is repeated the following day, again on day 5 to 7 and on day 10 to 14. If impedance plethysmography becomes positive during this time, a diagnosis of venous thrombosis is made and anticoagulant therapy is commenced. Positive impedance plethysmography in the presence of conditions known to produce a false positive result (for example, congestive cardiac failure) should be confirmed by venography. If noninvasive tests for the diagnosis of venous thrombosis are not available, a clinical suspicion of venous thrombosis should be objectively confirmed or excluded by performing ascending venography.

Management of symptomatic deep venous thrombosis and pulmonary embolism on a neurosurgical service

The authors present a retrospective analysis of the management of deep vein thrombosis (DVT) and pulmonary embolism (PE) in neurosurgical patients at the Massachusetts General Hospital from January, 1978, through June, 1982. There were 44 cases of DVT and 13 cases of PE. Management modalities included observation only, femoral vein ligation, inferior vena cava clipping, transvenous placement of an inferior vena cava filter or umbrella, and anticoagulation therapy. Six (75%) of eight patients with symptomatic DVT who were managed by observation alone had subsequent pulmonary emboli, and three (38%) died. Femoral vein ligation was followed by PE in one of four cases and led to significant leg swelling in two others. Neither observation alone nor femoral vein ligation can be recommended as routine management options. Partial inferior vena cava interruption with a De Weese clip, Kim-Ray Greenfield filter, or Mobin-Uddin umbrella all successfully prevented pulmonary emboli. The major problem associated with these methods was leg edema, which occurred in 47% of patients with clip placement, 25% with filter placement, and 21% with a Mobin-Uddin umbrella. Anticoagulation therapy was associated with a complication rate of 29% and a mortality rate of 15%. Fatal PE and paradoxical hypercoagulability with gangrene of a lower extremity were the causes of death. In one patient, hemorrhage into a glioblastoma occurred following discontinuation of anticoagulation therapy when the coagulation parameters were normal. The authors conclude that: 1) management with observation alone of patients with symptomatic DVT places the patient at risk for the development of life-threatening pulmonary emboli; 2) the safety and timing of therapeutic anticoagulation in postoperative neurosurgical patients or patients with tumors is unclear; and 3) partial interruption of the inferior vena cava with a transvenous filter successfully prevents PE and may represent a safer alternative to anticoagulation therapy.

Deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary emboli in neurosurgical patients: a review

This review examines the incidence, natural history, diagnosis, prophylaxis, and management of deep vein thrombosis (DVT) and pulmonary embolism (PE) in neurosurgical patients. Recent studies estimate the incidence of postoperative DVT detected by fibrinogen scanning in neurosurgical patients to be 29% to 43%. Specific factors that enhance the risk of venous thromboembolism include previous DVT, surgery, immobilization, advanced age, obesity, limb weakness, heart failure, and lower extremity trauma. Clinical diagnosis of venous thromboembolism is unreliable but can be augmented by noninvasive screening tests such as iodine-125-fibrinogen scanning, Doppler ultrasonography, and impedance plethysmography. As prophylactic measures, mini-dose heparin and external pneumatic compression of the legs have decreased the incidence of DVT in clinical studies of neurosurgical patients. However, no prophylactic measure has been convincingly shown to prevent PE in neurosurgical patients. Thrombi involving the popliteal, deep femoral, and iliac veins appear most likely to cause significant PE. Anticoagulation therapy constitutes standard management of DVT and PE; however, in neurosurgical patients the potential for precipitating intracranial or intraspinal hemorrhage may necessitate vena caval interruption. This appears to be an effective alternative to anticoagulation.

Pitfall of venous occlusion plethysmography

The supposition that the lower limb expands uniformly in circumference during venous occlusion has been investigated. The 3 compartments of the calf were found to be expand to differing degrees depending on the volume of muscle within the compartment. The effect of this phenomenon on the measurement of venous outflow and capacitance using an overlapping strain gauge was assessed. When using an overlapping strain gauge, the anatomical site of overlap was found to alter the measured values of outflow and capacitance by as much as 50%. These errors do not arise with strain gauges designed to fit a small range of limb circumferences, so that no overlap occurs. The reproducibility of plethysmography may be enhanced by attention to the site and degree of overlap of gauges which are designed to fit all sizes of limb. Technicians performing venous occlusion plethysmography should be aware of these variations, so that the examination technique can be standardized.

Value of impedance plethysmography in suspected venous disease of the lower extremity

We tested the correlation between impedance plethysmography (IPG) and venography (VG) in evaluating patients with suspected venous thrombosis of the lower extremity. Three hundred and eight limbs in 205 such patients were evaluated by both IPG and VG. With the results of the venograms as standards, 169 limbs (55%) were classified as "normal" and 139 limbs (45%) as "abnormal." Acute deep venous thrombosis (DVT) was present in 65 limbs, 47 of which had DVT of the major veins, popliteal and above. The correlated IPG was positive in 43 limbs, with a sensitivity of 91%, a specificity of 89%, and P < 0.001.

Thrombophlebitis: diagnostic techniques

A review of the extensive literature on the diagnosis of deep vein thrombophlebitis (DVT) is presented. DVT affects approximately 10% of all patients with superficial thrombophlebitis. Many authors have shown that the clinical finding of DVT are unreliable. Although pulmonary emboli are relatively frequent in all patients with calf DVT, these emboli are generally not associated with clincial events. Venography is the "gold standard" of diagnostic tests, but it is too cumbersome to be practical as a screening procedure. Radioisotope-labeled fibrinogen is reasonable accurate in diagnosing calf DVT, but much less so in proximal lesions. The results of Doppler ultrasound and impedance plethysmography (IPG) agree with those of venography in 90% of the cases of proximal DVT.

The influence of limb elevation, examination technique, and outflow system design on venous plethysmography

The effect of limb elevation and the design of the thigh cuff outflow system on venous capacitance and venous outflow, as determined by strain gauge plethysmography, was reviewed in a group of normal limbs without evidence of deep venous thrombosis. We improved the reliability of plethysmography in evaluating venous outflow, particularly in the early period after cuff deflation, by using uniform leg elevation, large diameter outflow tubing, and single rather than simultaneous limb examinations. Based on this experience, an optimum technique of examination emphasizing precise limb elevation, sequential limb examination and proper design of the cuff outflow system was used to evaluate 21 patients with acute venous thrombosis. The results obtained were compared with previously reported results of strain gauge plethysmography in patients with acute venous thrombosis. This technique significantly reduced the incidence of false-positive results.

Detection of deep venous thrombosis by impedance plethysmography

Ninety-eight limbs in sixty-seven patients supected of having lower extremity deep venous thrombosis were evaluated by physical examination, venous impedance plethysmography (IPG), and venography. Diagnosis based on physical signs commonly associated with deep venous thrombosis was false-positive in 43 to 66 per cent and false-negative in 26 to 73 per cent when compared with evidence obtained by venography. The overall accuracy of IPG was 94 per cent, with false-positive results occurring in 10 per cent and false-negative results in 4 per cent. IPG is sufficiently accurate to be considered a reliable screening test for lower extremity deep venous thrombosis.

Position artifacts in occlusive impedance phlebography (plethysmography)

The accuracy of occlusive impedance phlebography (IPG) depends on recognition of the artifacts that produce false-positive results. Fifty per cent of a series of studies of patients with normal legs showed abnormal results when the recording was made with the leg held straight. We therefore recommend that the patient's leg position be carefully monitored when an IPG test is being administered.

Invasive and noninvasive techniques in the detection and evaluation of acute venous thrombosis

There are a variety of noninvasive testing procedures which can be used to establish the diagnosis of acute venous thrombosis with a high degree of certainty. For prospective screening of patients at risk, only 125I-labelled fibrinogen is of value, but does have a false positive rate of 21%. Its greatest problem is that it must be given prior to the event and, furthermore, it is not accurate in the upper thigh or the region of the iliac veins. Doppler ultrasound, plethysmography and phleborheography are accurate methods of detecting thrombi which involve the major veins of the limb from the level of the tibial veins below the knee to the level of the iliac veins in the abdomen. If properly performed, the sensitivity and specificity should exceed 90% in experienced laboratories. Contrast phlebography remains the best method of demonstrating venous thrombosis but does have limitations with regard to costs, pain to the patient and the production of thrombosis in a small percentage of patients. Furthermore, if the injections are done at the foot level, at least 18% will have inadequate visualization of the iliac veins, a critically important venous segment. It use must be restricted to those situations in which the noninvasive tests are equivocal or the information is absolutely essential for a therapeutic decision.