Controversies and Criticisms on Designs for Experimental Autoimmune Labyrinthitis

l-Thyroxine does not prevent immunemediated sensorineural hearing loss in autoimmune thyroid diseases

OBJECTIVE

This is the first report dealing with immune-mediated inner ear disease (IMIED) hearing loss in a group of patients affected with autoimmune thyroid disease (AITD), whose treatment required corticosteroids, despite being treated with levothyroxine. Immunopathology linking the inner ear and the thyroid gland is also presented.

PATIENTS

A total of 220 patients were selected with sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) of causes other than presbycusis. Audiometry was performed and pure tone average was calculated before and after treatment with corticosteroids.

RESULTS

Eighty-four (84) patients had SNHL of autoimmune origin, and 15 patients were diagnosed with AITD (Hashimoto's disease). Bilateral hearing loss was observed in 10 patients (66.5%). Sudden sensorineural hearing loss was the most frequent clinical form of presentation. Nine patients showed a hearing recovery greater than 10dB after corticosteroid treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Acquired hypothyroidism is thought to affect hearing due to different mechanisms. Although specific hormonal therapy may improve peripheral or central auditory disorders associated with hypothyroidism, the presence of IMIED in AITD patients requires another approach. Altered immune regulatory mechanisms involving Treg cells and CD4+CD45RO cells have been suggested in patients with AITD and IMIED. In the present study, although all the patients with hypothyroidism and subclinical hypothyroidism were being treated with levothyroxine, immune-mediated hearing loss was observed. Therapy with corticosteroids could achieve hearing recovery. Since inner ear and thyroid gland share possible antigen targets, we highlight the existence of IMIED in AITD patients and the importance of implementing appropriate therapy with corticosteroids.

Examination of Hearing in a Rheumatoid Arthritis Population: Role of Extended-High-Frequency Audiometry in the Diagnosis of Subclinical Involvement

Objective. The aim of this study is to analyze the high-frequency hearing levels in patients with rheumatoid arthritis and to determine the relationship between hearing loss, disease duration, and immunological parameters. Materials and Methods. A descriptive cross-sectional study including fifty-three patients with rheumatoid arthritis was performed. The control group consisted of 71 age- and sex-matched patients from the study population (consecutively recruited in Madrid "Area 9," from January 2010 to February 2011). Both a pure tone audiometry and an extended-high-frequency audiometry were performed. Results. Extended-high-frequency audiometry diagnosed sensorineural hearing loss in 69.8% of the patients which exceeded the results obtained with pure tone audiometry (43% of the patients). This study found significant correlations in patients with sensorineural hearing loss related to age, sex, and serum anti-cardiolipin (aCL) antibody levels. Conclusion. Sensorineural hearing loss must be considered within the clinical context of rheumatoid arthritis. Our results demonstrated that an extended-high-frequency audiometry is a useful audiological test that must be performed within the diagnostic and follow-up testing of patients with rheumatoid arthritis, providing further insight into a disease-modifying treatment or a hearing loss preventive treatment.

Current understanding of the pathogenesis of autoimmune inner ear disease: a review

BACKGROUND

Autoimmune inner ear disease (AIED) is a poorly understood form of sensorineural hearing loss that causes bilateral, asymmetric, progressive hearing loss, sometimes with vestibular symptoms, often associated with a systemic autoimmune disease, which is noteworthy as the only sensorineural loss responsive to medical therapy. Despite much research interest of the past 25 years, its aetiopathogenesis is still unproven.

OBJECTIVE OF REVIEW

To succinctly consolidate research and opinion regarding the pathogenesis of autoimmune inner ear disease, in ongoing efforts to elucidate the molecular and intracellular pathways that lead to inner ear damage, which may identify new targets for pharmacotherapy.

TYPE OF REVIEW

Systematic review

SEARCH STRATEGY

PubMed/MEDLINE search using key terms to identify articles published between January 1980 and Apr 2014. Additionally, any landmark works discussed in this body of literature were obtained and relevant information extracted as necessary.

EVALUATION METHOD

Inclusion criterion was any information from animal or human studies with information relevant to possible aetiopathogenesis of AIED. Studies that focused on diagnosis, ameliorating symptoms or treatment, without specific information relevant to mechanisms of immune-mediated injury were excluded from this work. Articles meeting the inclusion criteria were digested and summarised.

RESULTS

A proposed pathogenic mechanism of AIED involves inflammation and immune-mediated attack of specific inner ear structures, leading to an excessive Th1 immune response with vascular changes and tissue damage in the cochlea. Studies have identified self-reactive T cells and immunoglobulins, and have variously implicated immune-complex deposition, microthrombosis and electrochemical disturbances causing impaired neurosignalling in the pathogenesis of AIED. Research has also demonstrated abnormalities in the cytokine milieu in subjects with AIED, which may prove a target for therapy in the future.

CONCLUSION

Ongoing research is needed to further elucidate the aetiopathogenesis of AIED and discern between various mechanisms of tissue injury. Large-cohort clinical studies employing IL-1 receptor blockade are warranted to determine its potential for future therapy.

The role of allergy in the etiopathogenesis of idiopathic sudden sensorineural hearing loss

To evaluate the role of allergy in the etiopathogenesis of sudden hearing loss using cytokine profile, allergic parameters, and lymphocyte subgroups, a total of 31 patients aged between 30 and 62 years (mean age: 42.48 ± 15.86 years) with the diagnosis of sudden hearing loss were enrolled in the study between 2008 and 2011. The control group comprised 30 age-matched adult subjects accepted as clinically healthy individuals living in the same region with comparable socioeconomic parameters. The patient and the control group were questioned for history of allergy. Lymphocyte subgroups in the peripheral blood were evaluated using Becton-Dickinson monoclonal CD4, CD8, CD19, and CD23 antibodies. In the patient and control groups, the levels of IFN- γ, IL4, IL10, and total IgE were measured and compared between the groups. Skin test was used for detection of inhaler allergens in the patient and the control groups, and specific IgE tests were performed using the RAST method for food allergens. The Spearman's rho correlation, the unpaired t test, the Mann-Whitney U test, and the Shapiro-Wilk test were used to determine the differences between the groups. The limit for statistical significance was p < 0.05. When the patient and the control group were compared, the differences between CD4, CD23, IL4, IL10, and IgE were statistically significant. On analyses of the patients' serum samples, strongly positive correlations were determined between IgE and CD23, IL10, IL4; IL4 and IL10, CD23, CD4; IL10 and CD23, CD4 (Spearman rho, p = 0.000), while a weakly positive correlation was found between IgE and CD4 (Spearman rho, p = 0.020). A correlation between IFN-γ and CD4 was weakly negative (Spearman rho, p = 0.040). The total IgE levels were estimated to be above the normal reference ranges (0-100 IU/ml) in 25.8 % of the cases in the patient group. History of allergy was found in 61.9 % of the patients. The results of this study substantiate the role of allergy in the etiopathogenesis of sudden hearing loss. We think that during the diagnostic work-up of these patients allergy should be interrogated seriously, necessary tests should be performed, and allergy should be considered in the decision-making process of the treatment of sudden hearing loss.

High dose combination pertussis toxin induces autoimmune inner ear disease in Sprague-Dawley rats

CONCLUSION

A better animal model of autoimmune inner ear disease (AIED) in Sprague-Dawley rats has been developed by combination with high dose of pertussis toxin. This study also indicated that inner ear-specific antigens can be involved in autoimmune reactions. Cell-mediated immune injury can play an important role in the induction of AIED, at least in the earlier stage.

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to develop a more suitable rat model that demonstrated closer resemblance to the pathophysiological process in AIED.

METHODS

Ninety-six female Sprague-Dawley rats were divided into four groups. They were subcutaneously immunized with crude inner ear antigen/complete Freund's adjuvant (CIEAg/CFA), or intraperitoneal injection of 500 ng pertussis toxin (PT), or injection of CIEAg/CFA+PT, or phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) alone. The auditory function, histopathology of the inner ear, and autoantibodies were examined.

RESULTS

Significant differences in the time course of auditory brainstem response (ABR) threshold and mean score of cellular infiltration were demonstrated in the CIEAg/CFA+PT group of animals. Missing hair cells, degeneration of the spiral ganglion cells, endolymphatic hydrops, and autoantibodies were all noted after immunization. There were no significant differences in ABR threshold or histopathology in any other group of animals.

Immunosuppressive therapy for autoimmune inner ear disease

Autoimmune inner ear disease (AIED) is a rare disease that is diagnosed after clinical suspicion and response to corticosteroids. AIED manifests as progressive, bilateral, although often asynchronous, sensorineural hearing loss and can be associated with vestibular symptoms. Since its description as a defined disease entity in 1979, the initial mainstay of treatment remains high-dose corticosteroids. Several animal models have been developed to assist in determining efficacy of immunosuppression in AIED, and several clinical studies have also investigated the role of both steroid and steroid-sparing treatments. Here we discuss the basic science and clinical research surrounding the history of immunosuppressive therapy in AIED.

Diagnostic tests for immunomediated hearing loss: a systematic review

OBJECTIVE

To quantitatively evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of diagnostic tests for immunomediated hearing loss.

DATA SOURCES

We searched Medline and the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews for potentially relevant studies.

STUDY SELECTION

Twenty-five studies met the inclusion criteria of this systematic review. The diagnosis of immunomediated hearing loss was based on the clinical presentation and the response to corticosteroid administration.

DATA EXTRACTION

The following data were extracted from the selected studies and entered into a standardised database: population demographics; exclusion and inclusion criteria; diagnostic tests; sensitivity; specificity; the number of true positive, true negative, false positive and false negative values; therapy used, including dose and duration; and delay between symptom onset and therapy commencement.

DATA SYNTHESIS

This systematic review combined data from 679 patients with immunomediated hearing loss, reported by 22 research teams. Substantial heterogeneity was found among the included studies; for this reason, summary sensitivity and specificity values were not computed.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of diagnostic tests for immunomediated hearing loss depend on many factors, and there is a risk of potential bias. This is the first time that such a systematic review has been presented; such a review is a more rigorous method of demonstrating the utility of the available diagnostic tests.

Otosyphilis mimics immune disorders of the inner ear

Syphilis is a well established cause of hearing loss. Sensorineural hearing loss may develop in the congenital or acquired form. The clinical course of the early acquired and late congenital forms are similar: sudden or rapidly progressive bilateral sensorineural hearing loss with mild vestibular symptoms. Cochleovestibular involvement in early acquired syphilis has been related to a basilar meningitis with lymphocytic infiltration of the labyrinth and VIIIth nerve. However, neurosyphilis and inner ear syphilis are not the same disease. Prompt diagnosis and treatment with corticosteroids and penicillin are mandatory to reduce the immune response and fibrosis of the labyrinth and the endolymphatic sac. Unfortunately, early acquired syphilis is frequently overlooked in the differential diagnosis of other forms of sensorineural hearing loss, particularly autoimmune inner ear disease. Given the increasing number of luetic infection cases, especially in immunocompromised patients, this condition should be considered in any sexually active patients affected by sudden hearing loss. Cases of inner ear syphilis are presented. Immunopathology of luetic inner ear infection is discussed and compared with immune disorders of the inner ear.

Central role of supporting cells in cochlear homeostasis and pathology

HYPOTHESIS

Supporting cells have a crucial role in degenerative and regenerative events of primary sensorial hair cells of the organ of Corti. This new role should determine future studies about pathophysiology of hearing loss and its regenerative treatment.

SUPPORTING EVIDENCE

Recent findings suggest an active role of supporting cells in the maintenance of hair cell function and structure. Evidences of high energy consumption and close proximity to auditory nervous fibers suggesting K+ active exchange, preferential expression of specific proteins and antigens, presence of glucocorticoids receptors, affinity for cisplatin and regenerative potential give the supporting cells an important role in homeostasis of the organ of Corti and in some specific diseases affecting this structure.

CONCLUSION

As well as glial cells provide protection and regeneration to neural tissues, supporting cells may provide the necessary metabolic and electrolitic conditions for hair cells mechanical and bioelectrical function. This opens new possibilities for the treatment of apparently "irreversible" destruction of the inner ear.

TNFα blockers do not improve the hearing recovery obtained with glucocorticoid therapy in an autoimmune experimental labyrinthitis

The effectiveness of etanercept [tumour necrosis factor-alpha (TNFalpha) blocker] and corticoids in treating immuno-mediated inner ear disease (IMIED) was compared in an animal model of autoimmune labyrinthitis. IMIED is one of the few forms of sensorineural hearing loss that is reversible with proper medical treatment. While the effectiveness and usefulness of immunomodulating agents (corticosteroids) in treating IMIED have been demonstrated, TNFalpha antagonists, which inhibit granuloma formation in rheumatoid arthritis and other autoimmune diseases, have been considered as an alternative therapy. The efficacy of etanercept (anti-TNFalpha) was evaluated in a guinea pig model of experimental autoimmune labyrinthitis in which 25 guinea pigs were divided in a control group, which was used to document the rise in hearing thresholds following immunisation, and two experimental groups, which were treated with steroids (6-methylprednisolone) and anti-TNFalpha (etanercept), respectively, after the immunisation. Comparison of the auditory thresholds obtained by means of auditory brainstem response (ABR) revealed that the auditory thresholds of the two experimental groups were not statistically different (6-methylprednisolone: 41.5 dB, SD: 8.51; etanercept: 37.5 dB, SD: 7.91) and that both compared favourably with that of the control group (60 dB, SD: 7.91) at p=0.001. We therefore conclude that etanercept is as effective as glucocorticoids in an animal model of autoimmune labyrinthitis; however, the potential adverse effects and high price of the former advise against its use as an initial therapy for IMIED.

Immune-mediated inner-ear disorders in neuro-otology

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Immune-mediated inner-ear disorders may present to different medical disciplines and new research findings emerge rapidly. The purpose of this review is to draw the different strands together to produce an overview describing the clinical presentation of immune-mediated inner-ear disorders and to discuss useful diagnostic criteria with a focus on tissue-specific and tissue-non-specific antibodies.

RECENT FINDINGS

The importance of diagnosing an immune-mediated inner-ear disorder is highlighted in the context of it being one of few forms of treatable inner-ear disorder with a good response to immunosuppressive therapy. Due to a lack of reliable tests, the criteria upon which the diagnosis of immune-mediated inner-ear disease is based are often arbitrary. Previous and current research focuses mainly on the investigation of the aetiology of immune-mediated disorders, studying the presence of autoantibodies and the antigens responsible for their production. The prognostic and therapeutic values of inner-ear-specific antibodies are still unclear. Various antigens have been suggested. However, most antigens identified have been ubiquitous proteins not specific to the inner ear and therefore lack logical association with localized inner-ear pathology.

SUMMARY

Early diagnosis of immune-mediated inner-ear disorders with prompt treatment may prevent irreversible damage to inner-ear structures. Accordingly, it is important to include immune-mediated inner-ear disorders in the differential diagnosis of patients presenting with 'idiopathic' audiovestibular dysfunction. To enable early diagnosis, we recommend that the current available routine immunological laboratory tests (antinuclear, antineutrophil cytoplasmic, antiendothelial cell, antiphospholipid/anticardiolipin and antithyroid antibodies) are used when assessing a patient with suspected immune-mediated inner-ear disorder.

Surdités brusques idiopathiques

Idiopathic Sudden Sensorineural Hearing Loss (ISSHL) remains one of the major unsolved otologic emergencies. It is characterized by the onset of an unilateral sensorineural hearing loss developing within 24 hours, and averaging on pure tone audiogram at least 30 dB HL for three subsequent octave steps, with no marked vestibular symptoms and no identifiable cause. ISSHL is a syndrome covering several heterogeneous entities resulting from different pathogenetic mechanisms. At this time, the audiogram is the unique tool which may help clinicians to identify these entities and provide a classification based on 5 types of hearing loss. Numerous experimental and clinical studies have investigated the mechanisms by which infectious, ischemic, mechanic or immunologic insults may induce cochlear dysfunction. However, extrapolation to humans and rationale therapeutic approaches to ISSHL remain uncertain. SSHL being a diagnosis of exclusion, retrocochlear and neurologic etiologies should be eliminated. No argument allows to consider ISSHL a therapeutic emergency. More precisely, the experimental data presently available on cochlear physiology suggests that a treatment could have some chance to be effective if undertaken within minutes following the onset of ISSHL, a condition never encountered in daily practice. Conversely, it is not justifiable to impute the absence of hearing recovery to a delay in therapy. The various therapeutic strategies currently recommended are highly empirical and should be questionned in terms of cost-effectiveness, the most common being high-dose corticosteroids. New investigation tests are required for improving our approach to ISSHL.

Titulación de anticuerpos anticocleares mediante western-blot y grado de recuperación auditiva tras corticoterapia en pacientes con sordera súbita

OBJECTIVES

Detection of antichoclear antibodies in patients with sudden deafness (SD) ranges from five to forty one percent depending on authors. We tried to correlate the level of antibodies measured by Western-blot (WB) and hearing loss.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Forty nine subjects bearing of SD and a positive WB for bovine cochlear antigen. Hearing loss average was measured at the onset and after treatment with deflazacort 1 mg/kg per day by means of audiometry, and antibody titles were quantified in the diluted sera.

RESULTS

Initial loss was 49.4+/-20.6%, and after corticotherapy it was 15.9+/-18.0%. There was no statistically significative correlation titles-hearing loss (y=0.1122x+30.613; R2=0.7552) nor titles-recovery (y=-0.0818x+8.,65; R2=0.3229).

CONCLUSIONS

Although predictive capability for treatment response is accepted for WB, quantifying of the antibody titles in patients with SD does not allow to make a prognosis about the average hearing recovery.