A Review Over the Past 15 Years of the Management of the Internal Piriform Apex Sinus Tract of a Branchial Pouch Anomaly and Case Description

A novel and efficient surgical procedure for pyriform sinus fistulas in children

Objective

This study aims to evaluate the efficacy of a novel surgical procedure for pyriform sinus fistulas in children via the external cervical approach through the hypopharynx.

Methods

A retrospective analysis was conducted on 71 pediatric patients with pyriform sinus fistula (PSF) who underwent treatment at the Department of Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery, Shanghai Children's Hospital, from 2012 July to 2022 July. Surgical treatment of PSF was performed via the external cervical approach through the hypopharynx, with dye instilled through the internal opening to serve as a guide for tract identification.

Results

All the internal orifices were found in the pyriform sinus by direct laryngoscopy in all 71 patients under general anesthesia. Two patients had a postoperative temporary hoarseness that resolved after 3 months. The other patients had no complications such as parapharyngeal abscess and incision infection. All patients were followed up for 23 months-70 months, and no recurrence was found.

Conclusion

The novel surgical procedure of PSF performed via the hypopharynx has advantages such as a short operation path, quick recovery, fewer complications, and a low recurrence rate. This method is a better choice for managing recurrence cases after repeated cauterization endoscopic surgeries, as well as for patients with visible cervical surgical scars or masses.

Endoscopic Suture With Chemocauterization: An Effective Treatment of Congenital Pyriform Sinus Fistula

OBJECTIVE

Endoscopic cauterization is an effective method for treating pyriform sinus fistula (PSF). However, these approaches sometimes result in a higher failure rate. We present an effective technique utilizing suture combined with chemocauterization as first-line treatment in patients with PSF and evaluate the safety and efficacy of its use in 126 patients.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective study.

SETTING

Tertiary referral center.

METHODS

Retrospective case review of patients treated between March 2012 and June 2021 at our institution with descriptive statistical analysis.

RESULTS

A total of 126 patients with PSF were included in this study with a mean age of 14.7 years. There was no sex predilection. The majority of patients presented with a left-sided neck lesion (89.7%). Ten patients presented following prior attempts at the surgery of the PSF at another institution; 8 via open surgery and 2 following endoscopic CO2 laser cauterization; other patients only had a history of repeat incision and drainage or antibiotic treatment. The success rate of obliteration of the internal opening was 96.83% after a single treatment without complications. Following reoperation, a successful outcome was achieved in the remaining 4 patients. Length of stay ranged from 10 to 14 days. No recurrences occurred within 12 to 120 months followed-up.

CONCLUSION

Endoscopic suture combined with chemocauterization is a safe and effective treatment of PSF. Surgery can be performed during the acute cervical inflammatory period without increased risk of complication or recurrence, however, patients found to have acute changes affecting the pyriform sinus should be treated with a staged surgery strategy.

A safe and effective surgical method for complex pyriform sinus fistula

Objective

This article aims to propose a new surgical method for the treatment of pyriform fistula, especially for the complex pyriform fistula.

Methods

A total of 36 patients with pyriform fistula underwent the procedure between August 2017 to October 2020. Surgery was performed by the senior authors using the same technique at the same clinical center for all patients. The median follow-up time was 33 months. Meantime, we collected information on patients with pyriform fistula using traditional surgical methods in our hospital from April 2015 to November 2018 for comparison.

Results

The surgery was successfully completed in 36 patients. In all, 32 patients had a history of multiple incisions and drainage, 16 patients had a history of surgical resections, and two patients had a history of cauterization of the internal fistula. Compared with traditional surgical methods, our new surgical method greatly shortens the length of the surgical incision (4.3 vs. 5.5, p < 0.0001), reduces the operation time (8.1 vs. 27.1, p < 0.0001), and reduces the blood loss (103.2 vs. 196.8, p < 0.0001). None of the 36 patients in this study had complications such as pharyngeal fistula, recurrent laryngeal nerve paralysis, or hypothyroidism. The mean follow-up duration after the excision of the lesion was 34.1 months. To date, no patients have relapsed.

Conclusion

Our experience showed that this surgical technique could be used to completely remove the fistula, and it was easier to perform than the conventional strategies. These treatment options result in less trauma and reliable results, especially for complex pyriform fistulas.

Level of evidence

IV.

Experience performing partial fistulectomy through a single incision to treat pyriform sinus fistula in children

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

The surgical treatment of pyriform sinus fistula (PSF) is improving. The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of partial fistula excision in children with PSF assisted by using methylene blue.

METHODS

According to the method used to treat PSF infection, the patients were divided into a conservative treatment group, a single incision group (the children drained the abscess through the incision at the dermatoglyph of the cricothyroid joint), and a non single incision group (the children drained the abscess through the incision in the most obvious area of the abscess or ulceration). The data were retrieved from the electronic medical records (EMRs) and hospital information system （HIS）. The patient and observer scar assessment scale (POSAS) scores at 6 months after fistula resection were compared.

RESULTS

A total of 239 patients diagnosed with PSF underwent partial resection of the fistula through cervical approach with methylene blue. The success rate of the operation was 100%. The average operation time was 32 ± 13.2 min. The average hospital stay was 1 ± 0.2 days. There were 2 cases of transient hoarseness and 6 cases of wound infection. There were 17 patients in the conservative treatment group, 81 patients in the single incision group and 145 patients in the nonsingle incision group. The average POSAS scores of the three groups were 2.56 ± 0.6, 3.12 ± 0.84 and 4.56 ± 1.56, respectively, with significant differences among the three groups (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Partial fistulectomy assisted by using methylene blue through a single incision in the neck for the treatment of PSF in children yields a high success rate, fewer postoperative complications and greater comfort than traditional surgery. This alternative surgery can be used to treat PSF in children.

Neonatal respiratory distress due to a third or fourth branchial pouch sinus: A systematic review

OBJECTIVES

Third and fourth branchial pouch sinuses can be rare causes of respiratory distress in neonates. An overview of this distinct clinical entity is missing in literature. To aid clinicians in recognizing and adequately treating this unique entity, we conducted a systematic review to discuss patient characteristics, diagnostic considerations and treatment strategy.

METHODS

MEDLINE and EMBASE were searched from inception to December 29th^, 2020. Original studies concerning patients with respiratory symptoms as a result of a third or fourth branchial pouch sinus, as confirmed with rigid endoscopy, videofluoroscopy or during surgery.

RESULTS

Thirty-nine studies describing 56 patients (66% male, aged 0-30 days) were analyzed. Symptoms included cervical mass (76.8%), stridor (55.4%), dyspnea (35.7%) and cyanosis (17.9%) due to a third (39.3%) or fourth (60.7%) branchial pouch sinus. Intubation was performed before treatment in 31.3%. The piriform sinus opening was identified with rigid endoscopy in 81.1%. Surgery was the treatment of choice in the majority of patients (85.7%), with a success rate of 100% and a complication rate of 10.7%. Endoscopic cauterization was successful in 40% and endoscopic cauterization followed by sclerotherapy was successful 100%, with no complications.

CONCLUSION

Third or fourth branchial pouch sinuses can lead to respiratory distress in neonates. It is important to recognize this distinct clinical picture for adequate diagnosis and treatment. Rigid endoscopy is indicated to demonstrate an opening in the piriform sinus and provides the opportunity to directly perform treatment with endoscopic cauterization. If this is insufficient to relief respiratory symptoms due to a persistent cyst, sclerotherapy or surgical excision should be considered.

Suppurative thyroiditis: Systematic review and clinical guidance

OBJECTIVE

Acute suppurative thyroiditis (AST) is a rare but potentially fatal condition which can initially be difficult to distinguish from the more common subacute thyroiditis (SAT). We aim to update understanding of this medical emergency.

DESIGN

A systematic review over the past 20 years was performed on the epidemiology, clinical features, investigations, management and outcomes of AST. All full-text cases of microscopy or culture- proven AST in the English literature were included.

RESULTS

200 cases of AST have been described in 148 articles from January 2000 - January 2020. Bacterial AST is most common, often presenting with neck pain (89%) and fever (82%). Immunosuppression and pyriform sinus fistula are the most common causes, most often due to gram-positive aerobes. Transient hyperthyroidism is common (42%). Aspiration and antibiotics are becoming a more common treatment. Overall mortality was 7.8%. Tuberculous and fungal AST are less likely to present with fever and neck pain. Fungal AST is more common in immunosuppressed individuals (31%) and has a high overall mortality (33%). Tuberculous AST is more common in TB endemic areas.

CONCLUSION

The symptoms and signs of AST commonly overlap with SAT and initially can be hard to diagnose. AST can be rapidly morbid or even fatal. Clinicians need to consider AST when they assess patients with thyroiditis who are systemically unwell, have high fever, high white cell count and c-reactive protein, tender neck and abnormal neck imaging. An investigative and treatment strategy is described based on a systematic review of the literature.

Two Different Tracts and Origin of Pyriform Sinus Fistula

OBJECTIVE

Suppurative acute thyroiditis is caused by pyriform sinus fistula (PSF), and PSF frequently elicits deep neck abscess. However, complete fistulectomy is the ideal management of PSF, and studies on surgical findings of PSF are exceedingly rare. This study aimed to reveal the origins of PSF, each route, and clinical presentation.

METHODS

This is a multicenter study. We have conducted 19 complete fistulectomies of PSF in Japan, analyzed routes of the fistulas, estimated the origins, and investigated their histological and clinical findings.

RESULTS

No recurrence was observed in all cases. Five of 12 cases showed thymic and/or parathyroid tissues around the fistulas, passing inside the inferior horn of thyroid cartilage, were regarded as having 3rd pouch origin, and tended to have low frequency of severe deep neck abscess. The remaining 7 cases originated from the 4th pouch running outside of the horn and showed frequent severe infection.

CONCLUSION

PSF have 2 different routes depending on their generation and may present different clinical manifestations.

Resection of Second, Third, and Fourth Branchial Cleft Anomalies with Recurrent or Repeated Neck Infection Using the Selective Neck Dissection Technique

PURPOSE

To explore the applied value of the selective neck dissection to treat second, third, and fourth branchial cleft anomalies with recurrent or repeated neck infections.

METHOD

We made a retrospective study about 29 patients with the second, third, and fourth branchial cleft anomalies with recurrent or repeated neck infections who were treated by surgery from 2002 to 2018 in Sichuan Province Cancer Hospital. According to the characteristics of branchial cleft anomaly on embryology and anatomy, different types of selective neck dissection were chosen to remove pathological scar tissue or inflammatory tissue en bloc.

RESULT

Of 29 cases, 28 had primary healing, and 1 had local infection, healing after dressing change for a long time. In 1 case, branchial cleft anomalies adhered to the internal jugular vein, which was ruptured and sutured. During the follow-up time of 12∼195 months with an average of 91.76 months, there were no recurrent cases.

CONCLUSION

The selective neck dissection technique is safe and effective in the treatment of branchial cleft anomalies with recurrent or repeated neck infection.

Resection of recurrent third branchial cleft fistulas assisted by flexible pharyngotomy

BACKGROUND

Treatment of fistulas arising from the third branchial cleft includes endoscopic cauterization or open cervical fistulectomy. Both approaches are associated with recurrence rates of 14%-18%, and possibly greater rates when the fistula has been treated operatively beforehand. Treatment of fistulas arising from the third branchial cleft is associated with an inordinate recurrence rate. Recurrence may be multifactorial and related to incomplete resection of all of the anatomical elements of the fistula.

AIM

To present a new approach that involves complete resection of the recurrent fistula by a combined therapeutic approach.

METHODS

Here, 12 adult patients diagnosed with recurrent third branchial cleft fistulas underwent a combined therapy assisted by flexible fiber-optic pharyngoscopy to identify and resect the entry site of the fistula into the pyriform sinus. The fistulous opening into the pyriform sinus was identified by flexible fiber-optic pharyngoscopy. The application of intubation with a guidewire by pharyngoscopy, in addition to the removal of the partial excision of the thyroid cartilage, allowed complete resection of the opening and all parts of the fistula tract.

RESULTS

All of the internal openings of the fistulas in the pharynx were found and easily identified by flexible fiber-optic pharyngoscopy. All of the 12 patients underwent complete resection of the recurrent fistula by the combined therapeutic approach. There were no postoperative complications such as parapharyngeal abscess or wound infection, injury or dysfunction of the recurrent laryngeal or superior laryngeal nerves. The pharyngeal edema had degraded, and the pharyngeal wound healed postoperatively within 1 wk. Laryngeal endoscopy and voice analysis were performed on the 14th d post-operatively. Vocal cord movements did not change. The characters of voice for jitter, shimmer, and normalized noise energy were all within normal limits. In addition, no recurrences were observed during the 13-60 mo follow-up period.

CONCLUSION

It can be concluded that the proposed combined therapy is associated with excellent results, minimal morbidity, and no recurrence.

Third or fourth branchial pouch sinus lesions: a case series and management algorithm

Background

The purpose of this study was to develop an effective management algorithm for lesions of third or fourth branchial sinuses.

Study design

Case series with chart review.

Methods

Data from patients who were identified as having third or fourth branchial pouch sinus lesions in a single institution between January 2014 and December 2018 were retrospectively collected.

Results

All 67 patients underwent fistulectomy. First, we classified the patients into five types based on their anatomic features. Then, we considered four optimized surgical methods and adopted the appropriate method with full consideration of the patient’s clinical characteristics. The great majority of cases occurred on the left side of the neck (68.7%) and most commonly presented as either a recurrent low-neck abscess or cutaneous discharging fistula with neck infection. Effective preoperative examination included administering contrast agent prior to a computed tomography (CT) scan and in-office laryngoscopy during the quiescent period of inflammation. Ultrasound was also very helpful in determining the presence of thyroiditis. The mean follow-up duration after excision of the lesion was 25.8 months. To date, only 1 (1.5%) recurrence and no obvious complications have been observed.

Conclusion

Refining fistula subtypes and adopting corresponding treatment measures can reduce the recurrence rate and improve curative effects. We propose and advocate this treatment algorithm for all third and fourth branchial pouch lesions.

Fourth branchial anomalies: Predictive factors of therapeutic success

PURPOSE

The purpose of this work was to determine the epidemiology and the predictive factors of success of the surgical management of fourth branchial anomalies.

METHODS

This is a multicentric retrospective review from 1998 to 2016 of patients who presented with an endoscopically-confirmed fourth branchial pouch anomaly. Data were analyzed according to sex, age, clinical features, number of recurrences, treatment modalities (endoscopic and/or cervicotomy), post-operative complications and follow-up.

RESULTS

Fifty-two children have been included. The average age at diagnosis was 4.5 years. Among them, 73.1% were female, 11.4% were neonatal forms; 94.2% of lesions were left-sided; 75% of patients presented a cervical abscess as first symptom, and 7.7% of children presented with dyspnea. Average time between first symptoms and management was 9.5 months. Management was endoscopic in 73.1% of patients (laser in 84.2%, coagulation in 15.8%) with about a third of recurrence after one procedure. Overall success of endoscopic procedures reached 84.2%. A cervical open surgery was performed in 26.9% as first line treatment. Overall success of cervicotomy reached 85.7%. No complications of endoscopic surgery have been identified. There were 35.7% complications of cervicotomy (2 recurrent nerve palsy, 2 keloid scars, 1 pharyngostoma). An association was proved between recurrences and initial abscess (OR = 2.44), and with age between 3 and 5 (OR = 4).

CONCLUSION

Endoscopic treatments appear to be effective in first line approach in the management of fourth branchial anomalies, offering an excellent efficiency with rare complications. We identified two risk factors of recurrence: age between 3 and 5 years old and history of cervical abscesses.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV.

Bilateral Piriform sinus fistulas: a case study and review of management options

BACKGROUND

Piriform sinus fistulas occur due to developmental abnormalities of the third and fourth branchial arches, and almost always occur unilaterally. They generally present as recurrent abscesses in the anterior-inferior neck, with concurrent thyroiditis. They have conventionally been managed with complete removal of the sinus tract, and thyroidectomy if required; however, endoscopic approaches have been increasingly favored. Herein we describe a case of bilateral piriform sinus fistulas, and present a review of the literature concerning their endoscopic management.

CASE PRESENTATION

Our patient was determined to have bilateral piriform sinus fistulas based on computer tomography, magnetic resonance imaging and microlaryngoscopy. We performed electrocauterization of the proximal fistula tracts, followed by injection of fibrin sealent. Our patient has not had a recurrence in the ten months since his procedure. There were no complications. Twenty-three articles describing an endoscopic approach to these fistulas were identified through PubMed, and a search through the references of related articles was completed.

CONCLUSION

Of one hundred and ninety-five patient cases we reviewed, an endoscopic procedure success rate of 82% and complication rate of 5.6% was determined. Piriform sinus fistulas that occur bilaterally are a rare congenital abnormality of the neck. Endoscopic approaches are an acceptable alternative option to open procedures, with similar success and a lower rate of complications.

Endoscopic electrocautery and fibrin obliteration of an acutely complicated pyriform fossa sinus tract in a septuagenarian

Background:

Pyriform fossa sinus tracts classically present with neck abscess, recurrent infections and suppurative thyroiditis in children; acute presentation in a geriatric patient is rare.

Methods:

Case report and Medline literature review.

Case report:

A 79-year-old female presented with a left-sided neck mass and severe odynophagia of 3 days’ duration. Magnetic resonance imaging revealed a large-volume, loculated fluid collection extending throughout the deep spaces of the neck on the left, within and around the thyroid gland capsule. There was radiological evidence of internal jugular vein thrombophlebitis. Abscess incision and drainage, and endoscopic evaluation, were performed. A deeply penetrating sinus was seen in the left pyriform apex, the entrance of which was circumferentially cauterised and the lumen obliterated with fibrin glue. Following post-operative intravenous antibiotics, the patient made a complete recovery.

Conclusion:

This paper describes the first use of fibrin glue to obliterate a pyriform fossa sinus tract in an adult.