Matrix-mineral relationships--a morphologist's viewpoint

Ahead of her time: The multidimensional impact of Marie Ussing Nylen

Marie Ussing Nylen was a trail blazing scientist and administrative leader at the US National Institutes of Health. She accomplished this when it was extremely difficult for a woman to do so. She was also a whole person - a wife, mother, and talented athlete, that is, a well-rounded person by any definition. She was a gift to dental and oral science, as well as to those fortunate enough to know and work with her.

Regaining enamel color quality using enamel matrix derivative

This study aimed to demonstrate and compare the accuracy of tooth shade selection due to the remineralized enamel crystal with enamel matrix derivative (EMD) in vitro. Etched enamel slices were immersed in four types of mineralization buffers for 16 h. Sodium fluoride (NaF) was added to final concentrations of 1-100 ppm with the mineralization buffer that demonstrated the highest mineralization efficiency. EMD was added to the mineralization buffer containing NaF to see if it has any remineralization capacities. The remineralized enamel crystal was analyzed by SEM and XRD. The tooth shade was evaluated by CIE L*a*b*. The results showed that, without NaF, plate-like nanocrystals were formed on the enamel surface, but with NaF, needle-like nanocrystals were formed. By adding EMD, a layer of well-compacted hydroxyapatite crystals was successfully precipitated onto the natural enamel surface. No significant differences were observed in the L* value of the mineralization surface pre-etching and after mineralization buffer containing NaF and EMD. A new method has been developed to recover the color quality of enamel, as well as to mineralize the tooth enamel by constructing hydroxyapatite crystals with mineralization buffers containing NaF and EMD on the etched tooth surface.

A Brief History of the Discovery of Amelogenin Nanoribbons In Vitro and In Vivo

Without evidence for an organic framework, biological and biochemical processes observed during amelogenesis provided limited information on how extracellular matrix proteins control the development of the complex fibrous architecture of human enamel. Over a decade ago, amelogenin nanoribbons were first observed from recombinant proteins during in vitro mineralization experiments in our laboratory. In enamel from mice lacking the enzyme kallikrein 4 (KLK4), we later uncovered ribbon-like protein structures that matched the morphology, width, and thickness of the nanoribbons assembled by recombinant proteins. Interestingly, similar structures had already been described since the 1960s, when enamel sections from various mammals were demineralized and stained for transmission electron microscopy analysis. However, at that time, researchers were not aware of the ability of amelogenin to form nanoribbons and instead associated the filamentous nanostructures with possible imprints of mineral ribbons in the gel-like matrix of developing enamel. Further evidence for the significance of amelogenin nanoribbons for enamel development was stipulated when recent mineralization experiments succeeded in templating and orienting the growth of apatite ribbons along the protein nanoribbon framework. This article provides a brief historical review of the discovery of amelogenin nanoribbons in our laboratory in the context of reports by others on similar structures in the developing enamel matrix.

Nature's design solutions in dental enamel: Uniting high strength and extreme damage resistance

The most important demand of today's high-performance materials is to unite high strength with extreme fracture toughness. The combination of withstanding large forces (strength) and resistance to fracture (toughness), especially preventing catastrophic material failure by cracking, is of utmost importance when it comes to structural applications of these materials. However, these two properties are commonly found to be mutually exclusive: strong materials are brittle and tough materials are soft. In dental enamel, nature has combined both properties with outstanding success - despite a limited number of available constituents. Made up of brittle mineral crystals arranged in a sophisticated hierarchical microstructure, enamel exhibits high stiffness and excellent toughness. Different species exhibit a variety of structural adaptations on varying scales in their dental enamel which optimise not only fracture toughness, but also hardness and abrasion behaviour. Nature's materials still outperform their synthetic counterparts due to these complex structure-property relationships that are not yet fully understood. By analysing structure variations and the underlying mechanical mechanisms systematically, design principles which are the key for the development of advanced synthetic materials uniting high strength and toughness can be formulated. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Dental enamel is a hard protective tissue that combines high strength with an exceptional resistance to catastrophic fracture, properties that in classical materials are commonly found to be mutually exclusive. The biological material is able to outperform its synthetic counterparts due to a sophisticated hierarchical microstructure. Between different species, microstructural adaptations can vary significantly. In this contribution, the different types of dental enamel present in different species are reviewed and connections between microstructure and (mechanical) properties are drawn. By consolidating available information for various species and reviewing it from a materials science point of view, design principles for the development of advanced biomimetic materials uniting high strength and toughness can be formulated.

Posttranslational Amelogenin Processing and Changes in Matrix Assembly during Enamel Development

The extracellular tooth enamel matrix is a unique, protein-rich environment that provides the structural basis for the growth of long and parallel oriented enamel crystals. Here we have conducted a series of in vivo and in vitro studies to characterize the changes in matrix shape and organization that take place during the transition from ameloblast intravesicular matrices to extracellular subunit compartments and pericrystalline sheath proteins, and correlated these changes with stages of amelogenin matrix protein posttranslational processing. Our transmission electron microscopic studies revealed a 2.5-fold difference in matrix subunit compartment dimensions between secretory vesicle and extracellular enamel protein matrix as well as conformational changes in matrix structure between vesicles, stippled materials, and pericrystalline matrix. Enamel crystal growth in organ culture demonstrated granular mineral deposits associated with the enamel matrix framework, dot-like mineral deposits along elongating initial enamel crystallites, and dramatic changes in enamel matrix configuration following the onset of enamel crystal formation. Atomic force micrographs provided evidence for the presence of both linear and hexagonal/ring-shaped full-length recombinant amelogenin protein assemblies on mica surfaces, while nickel-staining of the N-terminal amelogenin N92 His-tag revealed 20 nm diameter oval and globular amelogenin assemblies in N92 amelogenin matrices. Western blot analysis comparing loosely bound and mineral-associated protein fractions of developing porcine enamel organs, superficial and deep enamel layers demonstrated (i) a single, full-length amelogenin band in the enamel organ followed by 3 kDa cleavage upon entry into the enamel layer, (ii) a close association of 8–16 kDa C-terminal amelogenin cleavage products with the growing enamel apatite crystal surface, and (iii) a remaining pool of N-terminal amelogenin fragments loosely retained between the crystalline phases of the deep enamel layer. Together, our data establish a temporo-spatial correlation between amelogenin protein processing and the changes in enamel matrix configuration that take place during the transition from intracellular vesicle compartments to extracellular matrix assemblies and the formation of protein coats along elongating apatite crystal surfaces. In conclusion, our study suggests that enzymatic cleavage of the amelogenin enamel matrix protein plays a key role in the patterning of the organic matrix framework as it affects enamel apatite crystal growth and habit.

Influence of structural hierarchy on the fracture behaviour of tooth enamel

Tooth enamel has the critical role of enabling the mastication of food and also of protecting the underlying vital dentin and pulp structure. Unlike most vital tissue, enamel has no ability to repair or remodel and as such has had to develop robust damage tolerance to withstand contact fatigue events throughout the lifetime of a species. To achieve such behaviour, enamel has evolved a complex hierarchical structure that varies slightly between different species. The major component of enamel is apatite in the form of crystallite fibres with a nanometre-sized diameter that extend from the dentin-enamel junction to the oral surface. These crystallites are bound together by proteins and peptides into a range of hierarchical structures from micrometre diameter prisms to 50-100 μm diameter bundles of prisms known as Hunter-Schreger bands. As a consequence of such complex structural organization, the damage tolerance of enamel increases through various toughening mechanisms in the hierarchy but at the expense of fracture strength. This review critically evaluates the role of hierarchy on the development of the R-curve and the stress-strain behaviour. It attempts to identify and quantify the multiple mechanisms responsible for this behaviour as well as their impact on damage tolerance.

Characterization of lipid in mature enamel using confocal laser scanning microscopy

OBJECTIVE

To characterize the lipid components of organic matrix in mature human enamel using Confocal Laser Scanning Microscopy (CLSM) coupled with a hydrophobic fluorescent probe.

METHODS

Twenty-four longitudinal sections of human enamel were fixed with 3.7% paraformaldehyde (PFA), partially decalcified with 0.5 M of EDTA, and labelled with a fluorescent probe (Nile red) before CLSM characterization. Based on the fluorescence spectra of Nile red in ethanol (1 microgram/ml), each enamel section was evaluated with 543 nm light source and with 590 nm long pass filter. Spectrophotometric analysis was carried out to characterize the autofluorescence and Nile red lipid fluorescence in mature enamel. Special optical parameters of the microscope were chosen to rule out the intrinsic fluorescence of the samples, and that induced by PFA.

RESULTS

The intensity of autofluorescence and PFA-induced fluorescence were negligible above 565 nm; whereas the fluorescence of Nile red peaked at around 600 nm. Lipid material was identified in the cross-striations, the lines of Retzius, the Hunter-Schreger bands, inter-prismatic spaces, and inter-prismatic spaces in the mature human enamel.

CONCLUSIONS

This technique successfully revealed the distribution of lipid components of organic matrix in mature human enamel and may be promising in assessing the changes of enamel organic elements in the developmental, pathological or experimental conditions.

Failure to demonstrate a protein coat on enamel crystallites by morphological means

Phosphotungstic acid (PTA) treatment of section of Epon-embedded enamel dissolves the crystallites and stains material postulated to be crystal-bound proteins. Alternative, capillarity forces within the channels left after crystallite removal may draw in PTA. This prediction was tested on three systems. (1) Protein free synthetic hydroxyapatite was embedded in Epon; treatment of thin sections with PTA removed most crystals, leaving empty holes outlined by stain that could not represent protein. (2) Sections of rat incisor enamel were treated with PTA and then re-embedded in Epon and sectioned at 90 degrees to the original plane. In these sections-of-section the cut ends of dissolved crystallite profiles were coated with stain. To determine if stained protein coats can be detected in the absence of the crystallite profiles, Epon sections were partially demineralized with formic acid, re-embedded in Epon and sections-of section were PTA treated. Previously extracted crystallites left no stained coats, and only the crystallites that were not removed by formic acid left PTA-stained outlines. (3) PTA-treated sections of dogfish shark enameloid were flooded with 5-nm colloidal gold particles and sections-of-section were prepared. The presence of gold particles on the section surface and in holes previously occupied by crystallites suggested that PTA solution could also be sucked into similar holes. It is concluded that PTA outlines are not crystal-bound proteins but artefacts caused by stain lining holes left in the section when the crystallites have been extracted.

Molecular mechanisms of dental enamel formation

Tooth enamel is a unique mineralized tissue in that it is acellular, is more highly mineralized, and is comprised of individual crystallites that are larger and more oriented than other mineralized tissues. Dental enamel forms by matrix-mediated biomineralization. Enamel crystallites precipitate from a supersaturated solution within a well-delineated biological compartment. Mature enamel crystallites are comprised of non-stoichiometric carbonated calcium hydroxyapatite. The earliest crystallites appear suddenly at the dentino-enamel junction (DEJ) as rapidly growing thin ribbons. The shape and growth patterns of these crystallites can be interpreted as evidence for a precursor phase of octacalcium phosphate (OCP). An OCP crystal displays on its (100) face a surface that may act as a template for hydroxyapatite (OHAp) precipitation. Octacalcium phosphate is less stable than hydroxyapatite and can hydrolyze to OHAp. During this process, one unit cell of octacalcium phosphate is converted into two unit cells of hydroxyapatite. During the precipitation of the mineral phase, the degree of saturation of the enamel fluid is regulated. Proteins in the enamel matrix may buffer calcium and hydrogen ion concentrations as a strategy to preclude the precipitation of competing calcium phosphate solid phases. Tuftelin is an acidic enamel protein that concentrates at the DEJ and may participate in the nucleation of enamel crystals. Other enamel proteins may regulate crystal habit by binding to specific faces of the mineral and inhibiting growth. Structural analyses of recombinant amelogenin are consistent with a functional role in establishing and maintaining the spacing between enamel crystallites.

Ultrastructural organic-inorganic relationships in calcified tissues: cartilage and bone vs. enamel

Close organic-inorganic relationships exist in all calcified tissues, the inorganic substance being linked to crystal ghosts (CGs). These are organic, crystal-like structures present in areas of initial calcification. In cartilage and bone, they form aggregates with the same morphology and distribution as the calcification nodules; in enamel, they consist of long filament- and ribbon-like structures, having the same arrangement as untreated crystals. CGs of cartilage and bone are acidic structures with histochemical properties of proteoglycans; CGs of enamel probably correspond to enamelins. The close morphologic similarity between CGs and crystals suggests that the former have a role in the formation of the latter.

Antisense inhibition of AMEL translation demonstrates supramolecular controls for enamel HAP crystal growth during embryonic mouse molar development

During tooth development, enamel organ epithelial cells express a tissue-specific gene product (amelogenin) which presumably functions to control calcium hydroxyapatite crystal growth patterns during enamel biomineralization. The present studies were designed to test the hypothesis that amelogenin as a supramolecular aggregate regulates crystal growth during enamel biomineralization. Antisense oligodeoxynucleotide strategy was used in a simple organ culture system to inhibit amelogenin translation. Under these experimental conditions, antisense treatment prior to and during amelogenin expression resulted in inhibition of amelogenin translation products within immunoprecipitated [35S]methionine metabolically labeled proteins. To determine the efficiency of antisense treatment in this model system, digoxigenin-labeled oligodeoxynucleotides were observed to diffuse throughout the tooth explants including the target ameloblast cells within 24 hours. Ultrastructural analyses of amelogenin supramolecular assembly as electron-dense stippled materials in antisense treated cultures demonstrated dysmorphology of the extracellular enamel matrix with a significant reduction in crystal length and width. We conclude that secreted extracellular proteins form a supramolecular aggregate, which controls both the orientation and dimensions of enamel crystal formation during tooth development.

Fine structure of the organic matrix remaining in the mature cap enameloid in Halichoeres poecilopterus, teleost

Crystals and the organic matrix in both the enameloid and the maturation stage in this teleost fish were viewed by scanning and transmission electron microscopy. For transmission electron microscopy, specimens were demineralized by basic chromium (III) sulphate or phosphotungstic acid. Large numbers of defined compartments, thought to represent the outline of enameloid crystals, were seen in the outer layer of mature cap enameloid after this demineralization. However, the compartments were both less numerous and less well defined in the inner layer. These compartments suggest the existence of an organic enameloid matrix, which may correspond to the enamelins in mammalian enamel. As these defined compartments occurred in the areas of the tooth where large enameloid crystals were present, it is possible that the organic matrix constituting these compartments is involved in the production of large crystals.

The dentino-enamel junction: a structural and microanalytical study of early mineralization

The spatial localization of enamel and dentin apatite crystals of the rat tooth has been studied by electron microscopic methods--bright field, selected-area dark field, and electron spectroscopic imaging. The sequential events of dentin calcification followed by the formation and growth of enamel crystals were determined and compared to previous studies. In dentin, initial sites of mineral deposition occur in areas subjacent to the dentino-enamel junction (DEJ). The subsequent expansion of these deposits progresses towards the DEJ to the terminal ends of dentin collagen fibrils. Concomitantly, an electron-dense enamel matrix is released by ameloblasts; with the presence of this matrix, the growth of enamel crystals occurs from the underlying calcified dentin. Enamel crystal growth continues to within close proximity of the plasma membrane of ameloblasts. A close spatial relationship between enamel and the crystals of calcified dentin collagen fibrils was observed by selected-area dark field imaging. Such areas of crystal intimacy show a co-localization of calcium and phosphorus extending from calcified collagen fibrils to enamel sheaths which encase enamel crystals. A working model of the spatial relationship between crystals of dentin and enamel is presented and discussed in light of mechanisms by which calcified dentin may promote the formation of enamel crystals.

Structure and function of enamel gene products

The present paper reviews the main features of amelogenin and enamelin biochemistry, molecular biology, structural and ultrastructural localization, and immunology. It also examines recent studies concerning the origin, chemical characterization, suggested role, and participation of these two major classes of extracellular developing enamel matrix proteins in the complex process of "matrix-mediated" mineralization.

Effect of fluoride in the apatitic lattice on adsorption of enamel proteins onto calcium apatites

The selective adsorption of enamel proteins onto crystalline calcium apatites having different specific surface areas and various degrees of fluoride substitution was investigated. The proteins were obtained from the outer (close to the ameloblast) layer of secretory enamel of porcine permanent incisors. The adsorption of the enamel proteins was not affected markedly by the variation of specific surface area of the hydroxyapatites used as adsorbents, but it was enhanced substantially with increasing fluoride content in the crystalline lattice. Through the use of SDS- and two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, it was shown that the originally secreted amelogenin (25 kd) as well as 60-90-kd and 5-6-kd molecules adsorbed most selectively onto the hydroxyapatites and that additional moieties having 21-23-kd and 14-18-kd molecular masses commenced to adsorb onto the apatitic surfaces with increasing degrees of fluoride substitution in the lattice. In contrast, the 20-kd amelogenin, a product partially degraded from the 25-kd amelogenin, showed no significant adsorption, even onto the fluoridated apatites. These results suggest that the retention of proteinaceous matrix in the developing enamel might be affected by the nature of the forming crystals.

The in vitro uptake of fluoride by secretory and maturation stage bovine enamel

The objectives of this study were to determine the specific surface area of secretory-stage and of maturation-stage enamel, to compare the fluoride uptake by isolated enamel at these two stages on a surface-area basis, and to examine the effect of the organic matrix on the fluoride uptake by whole enamel. Fetal bovine secretory and maturation stage enamel samples were collected, and a portion of the enamel at each developmental stage was treated with hydrazine for removal of the organic matrix. The specific surface areas of the enamel mineral, as determined by the multi-point BET method, were 59.3 m2/g in the secretory stage and 37.9 m2/g in the maturation stage. Whole and deproteinated enamel samples were equilibrated in buffered solutions containing 10(-5) to 10(-3) mol/L fluoride, and the uptake was measured with a fluoride specific electrode. The results indicate that the in vitro fluoride uptake was controlled solely by the surface area of the apatitic mineral and that the organic matrix did not contribute to the fluoride uptake.

Production of monoclonal antibodies against enamelin and against amelogenin proteins of developing enamel matrix

The extracellular matrix of developing enamel contains two major classes of proteins, the hydrophobic proline-rich amelogenins and the acidic serine-, glycine-, and aspartic-rich enamelins. These proteins have been postulated as playing a major role in the mineralization and structural organization of developing enamel. To identify and further characterize these different proteins and their possible role in this complex process of biological mineralization, we have in recent years been concerned with the production of specific probes for these proteins. Previously, we have reported on the successful production of specific polyclonal antibodies against enamelin proteins, which did not cross-react with amelogenins, and against amelogenin proteins, which did not cross-react with enamelins (Deutsch et al., 1986, 1987). We now report the production of monoclonal antibodies against a major bovine amelogenin protein (28 kDa) and against a major bovine enamelin protein (66 kDa). One monoclonal antibody against amelogenin and one against enamelin are described. The results showed that the monoclonal antibody against the amelogenin protein reacted strongly with the 28-kDa amelogenin protein band but did not cross-react with enamelins, and the one against the enamelin protein reacted with the 66-kDa enamelin protein but did not cross-react with amelogenins. These monoclonal antibodies provide a specific and powerful tool to distinguish between and further characterize these different classes of proteins, and to improve our understanding of the process of enamel formation.

Analysis of crystallite shape in rat incisor enamel

The hydroxyapatite crystallites of mammalian enamel appear as hexagons when seen in cross-sections examined with the transmission electron microscope. Using goniometric transmission electron microscopy, stereo-pair electron micrographs and freeze-fracture replicas, two models have been proposed to explain the hexagonal crystallite profile. The "hexagonal ribbon" model proposes that hexagonal profiles are true cross-sections of elongated hexagonal ribbons. The "rectangular ribbon"model proposes that crystallite profiles are three-dimensional rectangular segments (parallelepipeds), which are contained in the Epon sections and project as opaque hexagons in routine transmission electron micrographs. Morphological observations together with predictions from models indicate that the crystallites in rat incisor enamel are flat ribbons with rectangular cross-sectional profiles. The hexagonal images seen in electron micrographs of thin sections of enamel result from viewing parallelepiped-shaped segments of these crystallites as two-dimensional shadows.

Ultrastructure of in-vitro recovery of mineralization capacity of fluorotic enamel matrix in hamster tooth germs pre-exposed to fluoride in organ culture during the secretory phase of amelogenesis

The recovery of mineralization capacity of fluorotic enamel matrix was investigated in 3-day-old hamster first molar tooth germs already pre-exposed in organ culture to 10 parts/10(6) F- for 24 h during the secretory phase. The germs were then cultured for another 24 h in a fresh medium without F-. The unmineralized fluorotic enamel matrix secreted in vitro eventually mineralized in the absence of F- but the orientation of the crystals compared to those in the fluorotic enamel was disturbed, especially in the younger regions of the enamel nearest cervical-loop in which the underlaying fluorotic enamel was most hypermineralized; but least disturbed in the more mature parts of the enamel organ in which the fluorotic enamel was less hypermineralized. The subsequent culture in F(-)-free medium did not abolish or reduce the degree of hypermineralization induced by F- treatment during the initial 24 h of culture. It seems that in vitro the inhibitory effect of F- on enamel matrix mineralization during the secretory phase is completely reversible when the ion is removed from the matrix environment, i.e. F(-)-induced synthesis and secretion of defective enamel matrix is not the cause of the lack of matrix mineralization. The F(-)-induced hypermineralization seems to be irreversible.

Crystal-associated matrix components in rat incisor enamel. An electron-microscopic study

Sections of glutaraldehyde-OsO4-fixed, plastic-embedded rat incisor enamel were left untreated, stained, decalcified (1% formic acid in 10% sodium citrate), or decalcified-stained. The presence of apatite crystals was monitored with electron diffraction. After brief decalcification and staining, apatite crystals and matrix components were visualized in the same field. The ghost was continuous with crystal fragments, and the coat appeared as a dense line next to crystals and ghosts. Position of ghosts and crystals at the ameloblast-enamel junction (AEJ) of the secretion zone suggested that there may be a lag of no more than 1/5 min between the elaboration of ghost and crystal. A major change in enamel morphology occurs between the AEJ and the deep enamel of the secretion zone. The ghost becomes thinner, the coat more pronounced, and the crystal enlarges. There is only little change from the deep secretion to the maturation zone enamel.

Ultrastructure of altered rat enamel beneath fluoride-induced cysts

The effect of a single injection of sodium fluoride (60 mg/kg) on the development of rat molar enamel beneath fluoride-induced subameloblastic cysts was studied by transmission electron microscopy using undecalcified sections. Three bands of altered enamel were identified and defined as the cyst surface band, the hypoplastic band, and the hypercalcified band. The irregular cyst surface band, not previously described, was found to have two components: electron-dense enamel globules and organic spherules. The electron-dense globules consisted of small, randomly arranged crystals (confirmed by selected area electron diffraction) occurring within a stippled organic matrix. The organic spherules have staining properties similar to stippled material and lack a crystalline component. They may be a form of organic material being extruded from the underlying developing enamel. The critical role of normal matrix production and ameloblast Tomes' process structure on the development of the crystal orientation and rod pattern is discussed.

Ultrastructural study of fluoride-induced in-vitro hypermineralization of enamel in hamster tooth germs explanted during the secretory phase of amelogenesis

The effects of fluoride (5, 10 and 20 parts/10(6) F-) were studied in vitro with light and electron microscopy in 5-day-old hamster maxillary second molar tooth germs explanted when most of the ameloblasts are in the secretory phase, and cultured for 24 h in the presence of F-. F- at all doses investigated induced hypermineralization of that enamel which had been secreted in vivo just prior to exposure to F-. The most intense hypermineralization was in the aprismatic enamel near the cervical loop region, where the in-vivo enamel layer was thinnest and gradually decreased (but was not abolished) with the increasing thickness of in-vivo formed enamel in the more mature parts of the enamel organ. The fluoride-induced hypermineralization in the aprismatic enamel layer did not stain at all with dilute toluidine blue solution and was therefore indistinguishable from the underlying dentine in light micrographs. The hypermineralization was due to growth in thickness of the enamel crystals, which in the aprismatic enamel layer resulted in a lateral fusion of all the enamel crystals. Thus fluoride administered during the secretory phase of enamel formation decontrols or even abolishes enamel crystal growth in length and promotes crystal growth in thickness so producing the hypermineralization of the pre-fluoride enamel. Enamel matrix secreted in the presence of fluoride did not mineralize.

Organization of extracellularly mineralized tissues: a comparative study of biological crystal growth

Biological mineralization processes are extremely diverse and, to date, it is an act of faith rather than an established principle that organisms utilize common mechanisms for forming crystals. A systematic analysis of the structural organization, as far as possible at the molecular level, of five different extracellularly mineralized tissues is presented to demonstrate that at least these mineralization processes are all part of the same continuum. The degrees of control exercised over crystal nucleation and crystal growth modulation are the basic variables. The five tissues, extracellularly mineralizing algae, radial and granular foraminifera, mammalian bone, mammalian enamel, and mollusk shell nacre, probably span the entire spectrum. Their crystal shapes, sizes, and the relations between the mineral phase and the organic phase, are primarily used to assess probable degrees of control exercised over crystal nucleation and modulation. Three different types of nucleation processes can be recognized: nonspecific, stereochemical, and epitaxial. Modulation of crystal growth after nucleation is either absent, achieved by adsorption of macromolecules onto specific crystal faces, or occurs by the prepositioning of matrix surfaces which interrupt crystal growth. The tissues in which active control is exercised over crystal growth all contain similar types of acidic matrix macromolecules. Significantly, the framework matrix macromolecules are all quite different and hence probably perform some tissue-specific functions. The study shows that there is a common basis for understanding these mineralization processes which is reflected in the nature of the protein-crystal interactions which occur in each tissue.

Morphological studies on the distribution of enamel matrix proteins using routine electron microscopy and freeze-fracture replicas in the rat incisor

Enamel contains two categories of biochemically characterized proteins. Amelogenins are dissociated from enamel without physical disruption of the tissue whereas enamelins are obtained only when the crystallites are dissolved. Ultrastructural visualization of these proteins was attempted using routine electron microscopy and freeze-fracture replicas. Fresh, fixed, and 4.0 M guanidine-HCl-extracted samples of enamel from the secretory (young) and maturation (maturing) stages were compared. Decalcified and stained thin sections of fixed enamel revealed intercrystallite particulate material and "crystallite ghosts" which were identical to the crystallites themselves in young enamel and which corresponded to the periphery of the crystallites in maturing enamel. In contrast, 4.0 M guanidine-extracted enamel contained no intercrystallite particulate material but only "crystallite ghosts." Globular particles observed in freeze-fracture replicas of fresh and fixed enamel samples were also removed by 4.0 M guanidine extraction. Incubation of guanidine-extracted enamel with albumin and ovalbumin solutions restored the globular particles. It was concluded that amelogenins are the nonstructural, heterodispersed particulate material in the intercrystallite space. Enamelins constitute the integral template protein which initially provides for elongation of enamel crystallites. They then regulate the continuous growth in width and thickness during maturation and are progressively displaced to the periphery. The illusion that these "protein ghosts" are contained within the crystallite profile can be explained by the parallelepiped shape of the crystallite segment in thin sections.

Aqueous density fractionation of mineralizing tissues: an efficient method applied to the preparation of enamel fractions suitable for crystal and protein studies

An aqueous density fractionation for calcifying tissues was tested for its ability to prepare fractions corresponding to precise mineralization stages, suitable for further protein and crystal studies. Two fractions of immature enamel corresponding to different densities were prepared, using cooled cesium salt saturated solutions, and compared for crystal size and amelogenin molecular weight distribution. For the first time, a steep increase in crystal width was directly correlated to protein degradation in keeping with increasing mineralization. Thus, this paper describes a method for obtaining an accurate fractionation of a calcifying tissue according to its true density heterogeneity. The recovered fractions are shown to be suitable for both crystal and protein studies.

Length and shape of enamel crystals

An original method for fractionating and preparing isolated crystals of homogeneous size was developed. It was demonstrated that enamel apatite crystals are at least 100 micron long. The flexibility of the very long crystallites was demonstrated. Crystal curvatures, accounting for the irregular course of the prisms through the enamel thickness, were visualized and measured. It was shown that in the deep forming enamel layer, lateral branches may grow out of the crystals and crystal fusing often occurs, inducing the crystallites to assume pyramidal shapes with their wide bases pointing toward the dentino-enamel junction and one or two tops toward Tomes' processes. During the maturation process, the two tops of the still immature crystals also fuse so that the mature crystals acquire a rodlike aspect, with parallel faces and steplike graduations along the c axis, allowing a close contact between the crystals. These results support the hypothesis that the crystallites would be continuous from the dentino-enamel junction to the surface.

Inhibition of seeded growth of enamel apatite crystals by amelogenin and enamelin proteins in vitro

The effect of enamel matrix proteins on the seeded growth of enamel apatite crystals was studied in stable supersaturated solutions at pH 7.4 and 37 degrees C. Of the two major protein classes in the enamel matrix, the enamelins were considerably more effective than the amelogenins in retarding seeded growth. However, the amelogenin species that did show significant inhibitory activity are those known to be lost first from the enamel matrix during the rapid mineralization stage of enamel maturation.

Ultrastructural study of the effects of fixation and fluoride injection on stippled material during amelogenesis in the rat

Perfusion with a variety of commonly-used fixatives was used. Quality of cell preservation and occurrence of stippled material between the mineralization front and the secretory ameloblasts were compared in normal animals and in ones injected with fluoride. There was no relationship between the formation of stippled material and the ultrastructural preservation of the cells. However, some types of fixatives were more likely than others to reveal the presence of stippled material in normal specimens. Most animals receiving fluoride showed substantial accumulations of stippled material, irrespective of the fixative used.

The effect of osmium postfixation and uranyl and lead staining on the ultrastructure of young enamel in the rat incisor

Enamel crystallites are electron opaque without osmium or heavy metal staining and give a crystalline electron diffraction pattern. Since the opacity and diffraction pattern are abolished from ultrathin sections of young enamel by floating on distilled water (Bishop and Warshawsky, 1982), the possibility that aqueous staining may also remove crystallites was tested. In addition, the effect of osmium postfixation on crystallite structure was examined. Rat incisors fixed by perfusion with a mixture of aldehydes were either nonosmicated or osmicated prior to dehydration. Incisor segments in the region of inner enamel secretion were embedded in the same Epon block to ensure reliable comparison. Osmicated enamel was more intensely stained with toluidine blue and more electron opaque than nonosmicated enamel. No other structural differences were seen. However, crystallites in osmicated enamel were more resistant to grid demineralization and electron beam damage. Routine staining was done by floating sections on solutions of uranyl acetate and lead citrate; sections were also floated on similar solutions from which the heavy metals were omitted. These solutions removed the electron opaque crystallites from the youngest enamel. Stained sections showed electron opaque crystallite-like structures similar to unstained enamel. When sections that were extracted by the solutions from which the metals were omitted were restained, they appeared identical to routinely stained enamel. It was concluded that staining of young enamel removes the crystallites and reveals only the organic matrix.

Amelogenins. Sequence homologies in enamel-matrix proteins from three mammalian species

Partial amino acid sequences for selected amelogenin polypeptides isolated from the developing enamel of cow, pig and human foetuses are reported. It was found that there was an identity of sequence for the initial 28 residues of the polypeptides analysed, irrespective of their origin or size. A tyrosine-rich polypeptide was shown to be the N-terminal fragment of the principal higher-molecular-weight amelogenins, although a leucine-rich polypeptide of similar size was not identified in any other amelogenin structure. The findings demonstrate a striking degree of sequence conservation for the amelogenin proteins of the extracellular enamel matrix and support the concept of a discrete fragmentation of an initial 30 000 Da amelogenin molecule during the mineralization of the enamel.

The eosinophilic and amyloid-like materials in adenomatoid odontogenic tumor

This paper is concerned with the relationship between eosinophilic material (EM) and amyloid-like material and adenomatoid odontogenic tumors. In duct-like structures between opposing rows of tall columnar cells, EM did not stain for amyloid. Under electron microscopy, EM was composed of fibrillar and granular materials, and the fibrillar material was not amyloid. Two different kinds of EM were found in solid cell masses. Lesions from cases 2, 3, 4 and part of case 1 contained small droplet-shaped EM and these EM did not stain for amyloid. Case 1 also contained EM that stained positively for amyloid. The structure of amyloid positive EM resembled developing enamel of human tooth germs. This material was tubular and finely granular. The tubular material resembled enamel matrix fibers rather then amyloid and the fine granular material was stippled. The cells surrounding EM appeared similar to ameloblasts between secretory and maturation stages.

Electron microscopic studies on the potential loss of crystallites from routinely processed sections of young enamel in the rat incisor

Newly formed rat incisor enamel was fixed aqueously by perfusion with glutaraldehyde and anhydrously by immersion in ethylene glycol. Ultrathin sections were studied using transmission electron microscopy and electron diffraction. Aqueously processed enamel was shown to lose its mineral content when sectioned on distilled water. This mineral loss was minimized by limiting the exposure of sections to the water. In such preparations, enamel crystallites were seen by virtue of their intrinsic electron density only. Selected area electron diffraction provided corroborative evidence for the presence or absence of crystallites in the sections. Observations on mineralized sections and on stained mineralized and distilled-water-demineralized sections revealed organic material apparently in the same location as the crystallites. Anhydrously processed enamel which was sectioned on ethylene glycol showed a similar appearance of the crystallites. This appearance was not obviously altered after staining despite evidence that organelles in the ameloblasts were stained. In view of the observations that both methods yielded similar crystallite morphology, it was concluded that aqueous techniques can be used to study the relationship between organic and inorganic components. However, valid description of crystallites in such preparations requires minimal exposure of ultrathin sections to water.

Ultrastructural features of the epithelial-mesenchymal interface in an ameloblastic fibro-odontoma

The ultrastructural features of the epithelial-mesenchymal interface in a case of an ameloblastic fibro-odontoma was studied with special reference to possible signs of "inductive" processes. In most parts of the tumor, the odontogenic epithelium was separated from the connective tissue by a thick rim of a finely filamentous meshwork in which a basal lamina was occasionally observed. Mesenchymal cells were seen to touch the filamentous meshwork but no membrane bound matrix vesicles were recorded. Small areas of dentin-like tissue were found in the juxtaepithelial connective tissue while enamel-like areas and spherical calcified masses were encountered in epithelial islands. The organic matrix in relation to the enamel-like tissue consisted of either tubular fibers or a fine-granular material. It was assumed that the tubular matrix component directed the formation of long enamel-like crystals, and that the fine-granular matrix was degraded tubular fibers in which spherical calcified masses might arise. Spherical calcified masses could be found in separate follicles also where they were related to a fine-fibrillar matrix or collagenous material. The cell layers forming the wall of the islands had a great resemblance to those of an enamel organ, but the findings of dentin-free, enamel-like areas are not compatible with the inductive theory of normal odontogenesis.