An analysis of clinical studies on resin-bonded bridges

Comparison of Stress Distribution in Fixed Partial Prosthesis Restored with Different Combination of Support: A Finite Element Study

AIM

This study was conducted to evaluate the distribution of stress in the bone around the natural tooth, endodontically treated tooth having post and core, and implant as an abutment in different combinations in fixed partial prosthesis using two-dimensional finite element analysis (FEA).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Six models were simulated using ANSYS Modeller19. All six models were divided into 12 zones and 4 lines, and stress values were calculated and compared. The study combinations were - tooth supported fixed partial prosthesis, fixed partial prosthesis having the combination of tooth and post- and core-treated tooth, fixed partial prosthesis with the combination of tooth and implant, fixed partial prosthesis having the combination of implant and post- and core-treated tooth, fixed partial prosthesis with the combination of post- and core-treated tooth on both sides, and fixed partial prosthesis having the combination of implant on both sides.

RESULT

On comparing the stress values, the maximum stress value was observed in fixed partial prosthesis having the combination of implant on both sides (306.2434 MPa) followed by Model 4 (223.1255 MPa), Model 3 (154.3952 MPa), Model 5 (136.9041 MPa), Model 2 (116.2034 MPa), and least stress seen in Model 1 (99.6209 MPa), and minimum in tooth supported fixed partial prosthesis (99.6209 MPa).

CONCLUSION

This study concluded that stress concentration in bone was maximum when the implant was used as an abutment in fixed partial prosthesis. The least stress was seen in bone around the natural tooth due to the dampening effect of the periodontal ligament. Further, the modulus of elasticity of a post acts as a vital parameter in the distribution of stress in post- and core-treated tooth.

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE

The stress concentration in the bone around the abutments affects the longevity of the prosthesis, hence, the clinically appropriate combination of the abutments should be considered for a fixed partial prosthesis.

Longevity of resin-bonded fixed partial dentures made of metal alloys: A review of the literature

Purpose In this review, we evaluate the survival rate of resin-bonded fixed partial dentures (RBFPDs) made of metal alloys.Methods An electronic search of English peer-reviewed dental literature on PubMed was conducted to identify all publications reporting on RBFPDs made of metal alloys until March 2019. The searched keywords were: bridge OR fixed partial denture OR fixed prosthesis OR fixed prostheses AND resin bonded AND metal OR alloy AND survival OR longevity (RBFPD was not included). Furthermore, the "Related Articles" feature of PubMed was used to identify further references of interest during the primary search. A definitive list of articles was screened to extract qualitative data after the application of the inclusion and exclusion criteria, and the results were analyzed.Results Overall, 977 publications were found through an electronic and manual search, out of which 130 articles were selected after screening based on title and abstract. A total of 52 publications passed the second review phase after assessment for eligibility, from which 24 studies were excluded after full-text screening. Finally, a total of 28 studies were selected.Conclusions The survival rate of RBFPDs differed greatly depending on the type of metal alloy, adhesion system, and observation period assessed, e.g. the 10-year survival rate ranged from 18% to 88%. The wide range of survival rates of the RBFPDs reported indicates that though RBFPD is a reliable prosthesis, it is prone to failure if some processes are not completed.

Load bearing capacity and Weibull characteristics of inlay-retained resin-bonded fixed dental prosthesis made of all-ceramic, fiber-reinforced composite and metal-ceramic after cyclic loading

PURPOSE

The objectives of this study were to evaluate the load bearing capacity of RBFDPs made of different materials after cyclic loading, and classify the failure types after loading.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Sound human mandibular first premolars and first molar pairs (N = 60 per tooth type, n = 10 per group) were randomly divided into six experimental groups to receive one of the following inlay-retained RBFDP types: RC: Resin composite only, DFRC: Direct E-glass fiber-reinforced composite (FRC), IFRC: Indirect E-glass FRC, LS: Lithium disilicate glass-ceramic, ZR: Yttria-stabilized tetragonal zirconia, MC: Metal-ceramic. Box preparations were made in abutment teeth using diamond burs followed by standardized ultrasonic burs. The teeth were conditioned employing an etch-and-rinse adhesive system and the indirect RBFDPs were cemented adhesively. The specimens were subjected to cyclic loading for x1.200.000 in distilled water alternating between 5 and 55 °C (Zurich Chewing Simulator). They were then loaded to failure from the occlusal surface in the Universal Testing Machine (cross-head speed: 1 mm/min). Failure types were classified as repairable or irreparable depending on the location and size. Data were analyzed using Welch and Tamhane's T2 post-hoc tests (α = 0.05). Weibull modulus for each group was calculated based on parametric distribution analysis of censored data for maximum fracture load.

RESULTS

Mean load bearing capacity (N) of Groups LS (1274 ± 270), ZR (1567 ± 363) and MC (1544 ± 787) were significantly higher than those of other groups (p < 0.05). RC, DFRC, IFRC (601 ± 130 - 819 ± 270) and MC did not show significant difference (p > 0.05). Weibull modulus (m) was the highest in Group LS (m = 5.3) followed by Group RC (m = 5.1). Other groups presented Weibull moduli ranging between 1.4 and 3.3. Only in Group ZR, 2 early debonding occurred during cyclic loading. While in this group predominantly irreparable failures (debonding with without tooth fracture) were observed (8 out of 10), all other groups presented mainly single or a combination of repairable failures (chipping in the veneering material). DFRC, IDRC and MC did not show any debonding from the abutment teeth.

CONCLUSION

Considering load bearing capacity, repairable failure types and Weibull moduli, lithium disilicate seem to be more durable than those of other material options for posterior inlay-retained RBFDPs. Due to early debondings and catastrophic irreparable failure types, zirconia RBFDPs should be indicated with caution in the posterior region.

Longevity of resin-bonded fixed partial dental prostheses made with metal alloys

Objectives

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the clinical performance of resin-bonded fixed partial dental prostheses (RBFPDPs) made with metal alloys.

Materials and methods

The retention of 311 RBFPDPs from 226 patients fabricated from 1983 to 2013 using an adhesive resin was clinically evaluated. Partial or complete debonding of the RBFPDP or framework fracture was considered a treatment failure. All data were obtained from clinical examinations, and missing data were censored at the date of the last available information. The effect of the following factors on survival rate were investigated: patient gender, location (maxilla/mandible and anterior/posterior), number of missing teeth, number of abutment teeth, framework structure, type of metal alloy, patient age at the point of cementation, cement type, and distinction of the treating dentist. Data were analyzed with the Kaplan–Meier survival tests, log-rank tests, and Cox regression analyses (α = 0.05).

Results

The Kaplan–Meier survival rate was 41.2 % ± 6.5 % (standard error) at 28.8 years (last outcome event). Significant differences were found for patient age and treating dentist (p < 0.05). The risk of failure in younger patients was 1.7 times greater than that in older patients and that of inexperienced dentists was 2.0 times greater than that of dentist experienced and specialized in adhesive dentistry.

Conclusions

When fabricating RBFPDPs for younger patients, mechanical preparation for bonding may be necessary in consideration of the risk for debonding. Experienced dentists may achieve better results.

Clinical relevance

Mastery of skills is necessary to ensure excellent prognoses for RBFPDPs.

A review of the success and failure characteristics of resin-bonded bridges

OBJECTIVES

This literature review was designed to assess and compare the success rates and modes of failure of metal-framed, fibre-reinforced composite and all-ceramic resin-bonded bridges.

MATERIALS AND METHOD

A Medline search (Ovid), supplemented by hand searching, was conducted to identify prospective and retrospective cohort studies on different resin-bonded bridges within the last 16 years. A total of 49 studies met the pre-set inclusion criteria. Success rates of 25 studies on metal-framed, 17 studies on fibre-reinforced composite and 7 studies on all-ceramic resin-bonded bridges were analysed and characteristics of failures were identified.

RESULTS

The analysis of the studies indicated an estimation of annual failure rates per year to be 4.6% (±1.3%, 95% CI) for metal-framed, 4.1% (±2.1%, 95% CI) for fibre-reinforced and 11.7% (±1.8%, 95% CI) for all-ceramic resin-bonded bridges. The most frequent complications were: debonding for metal-framed, resin-bonded bridges (93% of all failures); delamination of the composite veneering material for the fibre-reinforced bridges (41%) and fracture of the framework for the all-ceramic bridges (57%).

CONCLUSIONS

All types of resin-bonded bridges provide an effective short- to medium-term option, with all-ceramic performing least well and having the least favourable mode of failure. The methods of failures were different for different bridges with metal frameworks performing the best over time.

Methodological quality and descriptive characteristics of prosthodontic-related systematic reviews

Ideally, healthcare systematic reviews (SRs) should be beneficial to practicing professionals in making evidence-based clinical decisions. However, the conclusions drawn from SRs are directly related to the quality of the SR and of the included studies. The aim was to investigate the methodological quality and key descriptive characteristics of SRs published in prosthodontics. Methodological quality was analysed using the Assessment of Multiple Reviews (AMSTAR) tool. Several electronic resources (MEDLINE, EMBASE, Web of Science and American Dental Association's Evidence-based Dentistry website) were searched. In total 106 SRs were located. Key descriptive characteristics and methodological quality features were gathered and assessed, and descriptive and inferential statistical testing performed. Most SRs in this sample originated from the European continent followed by North America. Two to five authors conducted most SRs; the majority was affiliated with academic institutions and had prior experience publishing SRs. The majority of SRs were published in specialty dentistry journals, with implant or implant-related topics, the primary topics of interest for most. According to AMSTAR, most quality aspects were adequately fulfilled by less than half of the reviews. Publication bias and grey literature searches were the most poorly adhered components. Overall, the methodological quality of the prosthodontic-related systematic was deemed limited. Future recommendations would include authors to have prior training in conducting SRs and for journals to include a universal checklist that should be adhered to address all key characteristics of an unbiased SR process.

Fixed partial dentures in an up to 8-year follow-up

Information on the longevity of fiber-reinforced composite fixed partial dentures (inlay FPDs) should be considered in the selection of materials, operative techniques and patient instructions related to prognosis and long-term cost-effectiveness.

Fiber-reinforced fixed partial dentures: a preliminary retrospective clinical study

The aim of this study was to evaluate the clinical performance (retention rate) of fiber-reinforced composite fixed partial dentures (FPDs). Polyethylene fiber (Ribbond®) was used combined with restorative composite during FPDs fabrication. FPDs were placed in thirteen patients in a private clinic. Nineteen FPDS were evaluated. The prosthetic space was filled with only one pontic using extracted teeth (2 cases), acrylic resin teeth (11 cases), or with composite resin (6 cases), combined with Polyethylene fiber. The clinical criterion used was based on retention rate of FPDs. If FPDs were in function in the mouth at the time of examination without previous repair they were classified as Complete Survival (CS) restorations. A classification of Survival with Rebonding (SR) was assigned in the event of an adhesive failure, but after rebonding the FPD still remained under evaluation. Treatment was classified as a Failure (F) if the FPD restoration was lost. The time of evaluation was 41.15 months (±15.13). The FPDs evaluated were retained (CS=94.75%), and no failure was found except for in one situation which required rebonding (SR=5.25%). According to the survival estimation method of Kaplan-Meyer the mean survival time was 42.3 months. At the time of evaluation investigated, polyethylene-reinforced FPDs showed a favorable retention rate in preliminary data.

Biomechanical Response in Mandibular Bone due to Mastication Loading on 3-Unit Fixed Partial Dentures

An understanding of functional responses in oral bone is a crucial component of dental biomechanics. The purpose of this study was to investigate the potential biological remodelling response during mastication on the mandibular pre- and post-insertion of a fixed partial denture (FPD). A series of three-dimensional (3D) finite element analysis (FEA) models were presented pre- and postextraction to determine the biomechanical responses to masticatory loading in the anterior mandible. Equivalent strains were analysed at lingual/buccal and mesial/distal areas of the premolar to molar region and quantified to anticipate bone remodelling response. Mandibular bone incorporating an FPD experienced substantially greater stress/strain magnitudes than that prior to placement of fixed prosthodontics, which is suggestive of engagements of bone remodelling. The results suggest similar outcomes to those reported clinically. Developing a simulation reflecting the outcomes of restorative treatment can provide meaningful insight into restorative treatment planning, clinical outcomes, and fixed prosthodontics designs.

Concepts for the treatment of adolescent patients with missing permanent teeth

INTRODUCTION

Missing permanent teeth is observed with syndromes or is frequently hereditarily propagated in families. The treatment of these patients is a multi-task of specialists of oral surgery, orthodontics and prosthodontics.

DISCUSSION

Despite functional and aesthetic considerations, the main problem of all treatment is that it had to be performed in a growing child. This article discusses the conventional and implant-driven concepts to treat patients from childhood to adolescence with selective or multiple missing permanent teeth.

In vitro exploration and finite element analysis of failure mechanisms of resin-bonded fixed partial dentures

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to explore the debonding mechanisms of two-unit cantilevered and straight and bent three-unit fixed-fixed resin-bonded fixed partial dentures (RBFPDs) and to measure the failure loads needed for debonding.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Failure load tests were performed using Bondiloy beams simulating both cantilevered and fixed-fixed RBFPDs, luted onto flat-ground buccal surfaces of bovine teeth with RelyX ARC, Panavia F2.0, and UniFix resin cements. The failure loads were recorded, and the debonded surfaces of both the enamel and the restorations were examined for details of interest. Finite element analysis (FEA) was used to calculate the stress concentrations within the cement layers at failure.

RESULTS

Simulated two-unit cantilevered and straight three-unit fixed-fixed RBFPDs showed a significantly higher failure load than the simulated three-unit fixed-fixed RBFPDs with a curved appearance. The FEA models revealed the magnitude and stress locations within the cement layer, resulting in an explanation of the different failure modes.

CONCLUSIONS

The low failure loads for the three-unit bent fixed-fixed RPFPDs, compared with their straight counterparts and the two-unit cantilevered RBFPDs, indicate that clinically a reserved attitude needs to be maintained with regard to three-unit fixed-fixed RBFPDs spanning a clearly curved part of the dental arch. The FEA results make it clear which part of the tooth restoration interface is subject to the highest stress levels, making it possible to design abutment preparations that avoid high interfacial stresses to help prevent debonding.

A systematic review of single crowns on endodontically treated teeth

OBJECTIVES

To test the hypothesis that the placement of a crown is associated with improved (long term) survival of root canal treated teeth, using a systematic review process of clinical studies.

DATA SOURCES

Papers referring to single crowns on endodontically treated teeth were located by a MEDLINE search and hand searching. One thousand six hundred and nine references were found, and they were subjected to a systematic review procedure.

STUDY SELECTION

A three-step inclusion-exclusion procedure was applied to identify papers that represented; good scientific practice (GSP), reported results of all patients, restorations on root canal treated teeth (RCT) for more than 2 years and had sufficient data to generate life table analyses. The outcomes were 'survival of RCT restored with crowns' and 'survival of RCT with direct restorations'. Ten studies survived. These data showed an overall mean GSP of 0.605 with a 10-year survival of 81% for crowned RCT and a 10-year survival of 63% for RCT with direct restorations (resin composites, amalgam, cements).

CONCLUSION

RCTs restored with crowns show an acceptable long-term survival of 10 years, while direct restorations have a satisfactory survival only for a short period.

The clinical performance of hybrid bridges delivered by undergraduate dental students: a retrospective study

The aim of this study was to retrospectively analyse the clinical performance of hybrid bridges and their effect on periodontal health. All the bridges in this study were delivered by undergraduate dental students at the University Dental School and Hospital Cork. The recall protocol took the form of a questionnaire and a full clinical examination of the abutments, retainers and contra lateral control teeth. In all, 22 patients with 25 bridges were examined. The periodontal response was generally favourable and soft tissue alteration was minimal. The outcome of the performance hybrid bridges is not encouraging, as 32% (8) of the bridges failed and 68% (17) were in service with a mean duration of clinical service of 48 months.

Prevalence of single-tooth gaps in a population-based study and the potential for dental implants – data from the Study of Health in Pomerania (SHIP-0)

INTRODUCTION

The aim of this study was to show the prevalence of single-tooth gaps in a population-based study.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The data of 3989 subjects (20-74 years of age) were taken from the Study of Health in Pomerania (SHIP-0) and classified by age, gender, and level of education. A single-tooth gap was defined as a gap of one tooth missing bordered by one or more natural teeth on either side.

RESULTS

The tooth missing most in all age groups was the first molar. There were more single-tooth gaps in the maxilla than in the mandible. The lowest single-tooth gaps were found in the mandibular anterior region (<1.1%). There were no significant differences in gender (p > 0.05). The highest frequency of single-tooth gaps among all groups was found in subjects with a medium level of education and the lowest frequency was found in subjects with a high level of education. One single-tooth gap was found in 25%, whereas 16% of all subjects had 2 single-tooth gaps. The prevalence of having 1 single-tooth gap was between 3.8% and 13.1% whereas it was less than 0.5% for subjects with 5 and more single-tooth gaps.

CONCLUSION

There was a high potential for dental implants to fill single tooth gaps.

Improved retention of anterior cantilever resin-bonded prostheses by design alteration: an experimental and finite element study

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Anterior cantilever resin-bonded prostheses fail as a result of a labio-lingual peeling action, which creates a stress concentration within the adhesive layer.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to identify the factors that determine the retention of an anterior resin-bonded prosthesis and to seek to eliminate the stress concentration within the adhesive layer by fundamentally altering the prosthesis design.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The first experiment involved 40 Ni/Cr (Wiron 99) beams with a width of 5 mm, thickness of 0.5 mm, and lengths ranging from to 13 to 22 mm. The beams were cemented onto a block of the same material using an adhesive resin luting agent (Panavia 21). The length of the beam that was bonded ranged from 1 to 10 mm, resulting in a bonded area ranging from 5 to 50 mm(2). A load was applied onto the cantilevered portion of the beam 2 mm from the end, causing a peeling action. The force (N) required to debond these beams was measured using a pull-to-fracture test. Subsequently, a second experiment was undertaken, and 7 beams with an altered point of attachment (new design) were tested. The new design had the point of attachment of the cantilevered portion located centrally on the bonded area of the beam. Implementing this new design clinically would result in a cantilevered resin-bonded fixed partial denture that would have the connector arm attached more centrally on the retainer wing. The data were analyzed using a 1-way analysis of variance (alpha = .05), and a Tukey pairwise comparison test was used when the results was statistically significant. Two finite element analysis (FEA) models, one simulating the first experimental design and the other simulating the new design, were created. A load was then applied on the cantilevered portion of the beams similar to the experimental models, and the stress patterns were examined. The numerical values of these resultant stresses were plotted graphically.

RESULTS

The direction of load application, which may be transferred to a clinical setting as labio-lingual forces, was identified as the dominant force responsible for debonding. The new design, which addressed this problem, showed a significant increase (P < .001) in retention. The FEA models identified the stress concentrations within the adhesive layer of the traditional design, which were eliminated when the new design was tested.

CONCLUSIONS

For the in vitro model, loads that may be interpreted clinically as labio-lingual forces resulted in the lowest forces required to cause debonding, and these forces were independent of the surface area of bonding. Altering the point of attachment of the cantilevered portion onto the retainer caused a significant increase in the forces needed to cause debonding.

Influence of Molecular Weight of PMMA in PMMA/MMA-TBB Resin on Durability of Adhesion to Titanium against Thermal Stress in Water

The present study examined the effect of the molecular weight of poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) used in PMMA/ MMA-tributylborane (TBB) resin cement on the durability of adhesion to titanium against repeated thermal stress in water. PMMA beads with the same diameter and molecular weights of 1427, 239, 116, 78, and 66 (x 10(3)) were used. Titanium disks bonded to stainless steel or acrylic rods with the PMMA/MMA-TBB resin were subjected to a thermal cycling test (500 and 2,000 cycles) in water followed by tensile testing. Change in molecular weight of the resin cements collected after thermocycling and tensile testing was examined using size exclusion chromatography (SEC). The acrylic specimens exhibited a significant decrease in post-thermocycling bond strength as compared to the stainless steel specimens. It was also found that the molecular weight of PMMA powder in PMMA/MMA-TBB resin had little influence on adhesion durability to titanium. In terms of the molecular weight of resin cements, they decreased and then increased after 500 and 2,000 cycles respectively.

Replacement of two mandibular central incisors using a zirconium resin-bonded fixed partial denture: A clinical report

Maxillary and mandibular anterior tooth loss may cause esthetic and functional problems. Successful treatment for these situations may necessitate a minimally invasive technique to preserve sound remaining abutment tooth structure. This article describes the use of zirconium resin-bonded fixed partial denture as a conservative treatment option for the replacement of 2 mandibular central incisors.

Measurements of Soft Tissue Volume in Association with Single-Implant Restorations: A 1-Year Comparative Study after Abutment Connection Surgery

BACKGROUND

Patients with buccal defects due to tooth extraction seem to regain some of the contour at the time of abutment surgery and connection of single-implant crown restorations. It can then be assumed that different abutment systems could restore the buccal contour to different degrees.

PURPOSE

To measure changes in buccal tissue volume after placing restorations with single-implant crowns using two different abutment systems and to measure soft tissue change during the 1 year after single-implant treatment.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Eighteen patients were provided with single-implant restorations in the central incisor area. Nine patients in each group were treated with single-implant crowns supported by either CeraOne abutments (Nobel Biocare AB, Göteborg, Sweden) or customized Procera ceramic abutments (Nobel Biocare AB). Study casts were made before abutment connection, at crown placement, and after 1 year. After the casts were scanned, they were analyzed with a computer, using the model before abutment as a reference. In the area of the single implant, sagittal projections provided images of the models that allowed measurements between the contours at the different situations. Radiography and photography for measuring papillary volume were also performed.

RESULTS

All patients exhibited increased "buccal volume" after abutment connection and crown placement (p < .01). A trend to greater increase was observed for the Procera group. Both groups also showed a reduction of buccal tissue 1 year later (p < .05-.01), leaving on average more volume in the Procera group. The papillae recovered spontaneously, and no relationship was observed between the presence of papilla and underlying bone support (p > .05).

CONCLUSIONS

The buccal tissue increased significantly after placement of the abutment cylinder and the implant crown. This increase of buccal contour was reduced after 1 year. Furthermore, no relationship was established between the presence of papillae and the distance between the contact point and the underlying bone crest.

Survey of systematic reviews in dentistry

BACKGROUND

Although systematic reviews are the backbone of evidence-based dentistry, they have appeared infrequently in the clinical dental literature and their importance may not be recognized by dentists. The authors describe the steps taken in systematic reviews and perform a literature survey to identify published systematic reviews of topics relevant to clinical dentistry.

METHODS

The authors searched MEDLINE and the Cochrane databases of systematic reviews and abstracts of reviews of effectiveness, as well as identified reviews that were known to the authors but not found in the searches. Systematic reviews included in this survey stated the intention to identify all relevant articles within predefined limitations, applied defined exclusion and inclusion criteria, and presented complete raw or synthesized data from included studies.

RESULTS

This literature survey identified 131 systematic reviews, 96 of which had direct clinical relevance. During the past 14 years, clinically relevant systematic reviews have been published with increasing frequency. These reviews vary in the types of studies included and the assessment of those studies. The results of the reviews also varied in their definitiveness, with 17 percent finding the evidence to be insufficient to answer the key question. An additional 50 percent of the 96 reviews hedged in answering the key question, by noting that the supporting evidence was weak in quality or limited in quantity.

CONCLUSION

The number of systematic reviews that address clinical topics in dentistry is small but growing. However, the authors of more than one-half of these reviews believed that the evidence available to answer the key question was not strong.

CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS

As systematic reviews continue to grow, dentistry will become better informed about the adequacy and congruence of the scientific evidence underpinning clinical practice.

Survival rates of resin-bonded, glass fiber–reinforced composite fixed partial dentures with a mean follow-up of 42 months: A pilot study

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Although short-term clinical data exist for resin-bonded, glass fiber-reinforced composite fixed partial dentures (FPDs), long-term data are needed.

PURPOSE

The survival rates of 29 resin-bonded, glass fiber-reinforced composite fixed partial dentures were evaluated in this clinical study for periods of up to 42 months.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

FPDs were fabricated to replace 1 to 3 missing maxillary or mandibular teeth of 29 patients not able to be treated with conventional FPDs. Originally, there were 37 patients (the drop-out rate was 22%). The FPDs were retained with wings, inlays, complete coverage crowns, or combinations of these that were bonded to tooth structure. The FPD frameworks were made of continuous unidirectional E-glass fibers with a multiphase polymer matrix and light-polymerized particulate composite veneer. The patients were recalled for examinations, where a general dental examination was performed, 1 to 3 times per year for up to 63 months (minimum 24 months, mean 42 months). Partial or complete total debonding of the FPD or the framework fracture was considered a treatment failure. The data were analyzed with the Kaplan-Meier survival test (alpha=.05).

RESULTS

Two resin frameworks fractured, and 3 frameworks were debonded. Kaplan-Meier survival probability at 63 months was 75%. Three of the failed FPDs were rebonded or repaired in situ, producing a functional survival rate of 93% after rebonding or repairing (mean survival time was 55 months).

CONCLUSION

The results of this clinical study of 29 prostheses suggest that glass fiber-reinforced FPDs may be a possible alternative to cast metal resin-bonded FPDs. These restorations were successfully used as multiple-unit prostheses that employed a variety of abutment tooth preparation designs.

Clinical complications in fixed prosthodontics

The purpose of this article is to identify the incidence of complications and the most common complications associated with single crowns, fixed partial dentures, all-ceramic crowns, resin-bonded prostheses, and posts and cores. A Medline and an extensive hand search were performed on English-language publications covering the last 50 years. The searches focused on publications that contained clinical data regarding success/failure/complications. Within each type of prosthesis, raw data were combined from multiple studies and mean values calculated to determine what trends were noted in the studies. The lowest incidence of clinical complications was associated with all-ceramic crowns (8%). Posts and cores (10%) and conventional single crowns (11%) had comparable clinical complications incidences. Resin-bonded prostheses (26%) and conventional fixed partial dentures (27%) were found to have comparable clinical complications incidences. The 3 most common complications encountered with all-ceramic crowns were crown fracture (7%), loss of retention (2%), and need for endodontic treatment (1%). The 3 most common complications associated with posts and cores were post loosening (5%), root fracture (3%), and caries (2%). With single crowns, the 3 most common complications were need for endodontic treatment (3%), porcelain veneer fracture (3%), and loss of retention (2%). When fixed partial denture studies were reviewed, the 3 most commonly reported complications were caries (18% of abutments), need for endodontic treatment (11% of abutments), and loss of retention (7% of prostheses). The 3 most common complications associated with resin-bonded prostheses were prosthesis debonding (21%), tooth discoloration (18%), and caries (7%).

Clinical evaluation of fiber-reinforced fixed bridges

BACKGROUND

This study evaluated the clinical performance of 39 light and heat polymerized fixed partial bridges made with a substructure of preimpregnated, unidirectional fiber-reinforced composite, or FRC, veneered with a hybrid particu late composite.

METHODS

The authors evaluated 22 extracoronal, full-coverage retainer prostheses and 17 intracoronal, partial-coverage retainer prostheses placed over a 37-month period. All substructures initially were fabricated with a low-volume FRC. The authors reevaluated this design after early failures occurred, leading to a substructure with a higher volume of FRC. All prostheses were assessed for surface integrity, anatomical contour, marginal integrity and structural integrity at several intervals.

RESULTS

The data show that survival was associated primarily with substructure design volume. When patients with severe parafunctional habits were excluded, the survival rate was 95 percent for prostheses made with a high-volume substructure (survival range, 2.77 to 4.30 years; mean +/- standard deviation survival, 3.75 +/- 0.4 years). Retainer configuration did not have a statistically significant influence on clinical survival. For all surviving prostheses, the authors observed few changes in any clinical parameters from baseline to 48 months. A loss of surface luster was observed in the majority of cases. Repairable surface defects were detected on two prostheses at 24 months. Scanning electron microscopic analyses indicated no exposed fibers on the occlusal surface and minimal wear.

CONCLUSIONS

This study shows that a unidirectional, preimpregnated FRC can be used successfully to make bridges of variable retainer designs that last up to four or more years when a high-volume substructure is used.

CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS

Short-span polymer prostheses made with particulate composite and unidirectional glass FRC can be used in certain clinical situations in which a metal substructure is not desired.

The single-tooth implant: a viable alternative for single-tooth replacement

BACKGROUND

The use of dental implants for single-tooth replacement cases introduces a challenge to the performance of these restorations. Clinical data suggest that single-tooth implant restorations do not benefit from lateral support from the surrounding dentition as do bridged implants, and that these restorations are subjected to greater masticatory forces. Therefore, single-tooth implants are exposed to an increased risk of failure. This prospective clinical trial was designed to evaluate the cumulative success rate of dual acid-etched single-tooth replacement implants in two clinical centers.

METHODS

The study protocol included 59 patients between 19 and 73 years. Implants were evaluated for mobility, infection, and crestal bone loss from 30.9 to 60 months.

RESULTS

Seventy-one (71) implants were placed in 59 patients, 20 male and 39 female. Forty-seven (47) were placed in the maxilla and 24 in the mandible. The percentages of anterior and posterior implants were 45.1% and 54.9%, respectively. A total of 13 (18.4%) implants were placed in soft, poor quality (Type IV) bone. Beginning 1 month post-implant placement, cases were followed for 30.9 to 60 months with a mean follow-up of 45.9 months. One implant failed (peri-implant infection) yielding an overall success rate of 98.6%.

CONCLUSIONS

This success rate for single-tooth replacement dual acid-etched implants compares favorably with bridged implants and with success rates of other single-tooth implant studies. Dual acid-etched implants performed well even under conditions of poor quality bone, where concomitant bone augmentation was performed, and when used for immediate replacement of extracted teeth.

A systematic review of single-tooth restorations supported by implants

OBJECTIVES

To make an inventory of clinical studies on single-tooth restorations supported by implants using a systematic review procedure and to aggregate overall survival results.

DATA SOURCES

Papers referring to single-tooth implants were located by a MEDLINE search 1990 to April 1998. Three hundred and twenty references were found, and they were subjected to a systematic review procedure.

STUDY SELECTION

A three-step inclusion/exclusion procedure was applied to identify papers that represented: good scientific practice (GSP), reported results of all patients, implants and crowns for more than 2years, and had sufficient data to generate life-table analyses. The outcomes were 'implant failure' and 'crown completion'. Nine studies survived. These data showed an overall mean GSP of 0.37 with a predicted 4year implant survival of 97% (n=459), and an uncomplicated crown maintenance of 83% (n=240).

CONCLUSION

Single-tooth implants show an acceptable short-term survival of 4years, but crown complications are common.

Comparison of resin-bonded prosthesis groove parallelism with the use of four tooth preparation methods

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

A precise preparation is required to develop resistance form resulting in mechanical stability of the framework for resin-bonded prostheses (RBPs).

PURPOSE

The effects of 4 methods of tooth preparation (freehand, guiding pin, extraoral parallelometer, and intraoral parallelometer) on the deviation of proximal grooves from a preestablished path of insertion (guide planes) were investigated under clinical conditions.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Tooth preparation of proximal grooves was performed by 32 dentists on resin substitutes of posterior segments intraorally with a single test patient. A Latin-square randomized cross-over design was selected as the experimental design.

RESULTS

The significant least angular deviation of proximal grooves from path of insertion was achieved with an intraoral parallelometer (mean +/- SD 3.15 +/- 1.67 degrees). Compared with freehand tooth preparations (4.37 +/- 2. 11 degrees), neither use of a guiding pin (4.10 +/- 1.62 degrees) nor an extraoral parallelometer (5.06 +/- 2.33 degrees) improved the results.

CONCLUSION

Divergence of guiding grooves from path of insertion was reduced with the use of an intra-oral parallelometer. This should improve mechanical stability of posterior RBPs.

Mechanical properties of dental luting cements

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Dental luting cements fail by microcrack formation and bacterial ingress or by gross failure and crown dislodgment. Both of these failure modes are related to mechanical properties and deformation.

PURPOSE

This study evaluated those mechanical properties of cements. METHODS AND MATERIAL. Elastic modulus for 8 representative cements (zinc phosphate, polycarboxylate, glass ionomer, encapsulated glass ionomer, resin-modified glass ionomer, resin composite, and adhesive resin composite) was measured by using a nondestructive technique and evaluated for cement type and storage time (1 hour, 1 day, 1 week, 1 month, 1 year) by 2-way ANOVA (P <.05). Compressive properties (proportional limit, resilience, and toughness), ultimate strengths (compressive, diametral tensile, and flexural), and flexural toughness were determined and evaluated by 2-way ANOVA for 2 crosshead testing rates (5 and 0.5 mm/min) and cement type (P <.05).

RESULTS

Cements varied with respect to elastic moduli, compressive proportional limit, compressive resilience, compressive strength, compressive toughness, diametral tensile strength, flexural strength, and flexural toughness. Storage time affected the elastic moduli of different materials in different ways. Elastic moduli of polycarboxylate and glass ionomer cements increased over time, whereas the other materials changed little after the first day. Crosshead rate only significantly affected compressive proportional limit and resilience.

CONCLUSIONS

Luting cements differed considerably with respect to mechanical properties.

Water resistance of resin-bonded joints with time related to alloy surface treatment

OBJECTIVES

This paper attempts to study the resistance of resin-bonded metallic joints to damage in water with time.

METHODS

Unlike the shear or tensile test, a cleavage test (Double Cantilever Beam test) allows us to follow the crack propagation in water, according to the fracture mechanics concept. Moreover, it is possible to follow the kinetic degradation of the metal/resin interface because this test is not totally destructive to the assembly. We have worked on 18 batches according to the nature of the alloys (Pd, Pd-Ag, Au, Co-Cr and Ni-Cr) and the surface treatment (sandblasting, Silicoater MD, Rocatec, V-Primer). The crack length was measured over a period of 20 days. The results are expressed in terms of adherence energy.

RESULTS

The adherence energy dramatically decreased with time in water. The slope of the regression straight line appears to be a good criterion for evaluating the durability of the alloy/adhesive interface. We have demonstrated the importance of silica coating and, especially, the effectiveness of the Rocatec system upon the degree of hydrolytic degradation, and have shown how the development of cracks depends upon surface treatment.

Alternative therapies: abuses of scientific method and challenges to dental research

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Alternative health practitioners compete with established dentistry and medicine for the treatment of many conditions. Their popularity accrues because of deficiencies of current treatments, increased acceptance of self-treatment, and a highly individualized approach. Ineffective alternative therapies can appear effective because of the placebo effect, symptom variability, short-term observations, combination with established treatments, and reporting bias. Alternative therapies often lack a rational basis. A sound theory underlying a treatment enables the approach to be integrated with other areas of science and leads to progressive research.

PURPOSE

This article argues that alternative therapies can best be considered bad science that commonly violates normal scientific norms or criteria for acceptance including comprehensiveness, falsifiability, openness, and objectivity.

CONCLUSIONS

The claims of alternative therapists are useful in identifying perceived deficiencies in conventional treatments. Suggestions for countering alternative practitioners' claims include targeted research and improved access to and evaluation of the dental research literature.

Risk factors and multiple failures in posterior resin-bonded bridges in a 5-year multi-practice clinical trial

OBJECTIVES

A randomized controlled clinical trial was undertaken, to study the influence of some patient- and operator-dependent variables on the survival of posterior resin-bonded bridges (PRBBs) and to assess the survival of replacement' PRBBs. This report contains some of the results of the 5-year analysis.

METHODS

Survival was defined at three levels: (1) complete survival (without any debonding), (2) functional survival (i.e. survival after one loss of retention) and (3) replacement survival (survival of 'replacement' PRBBs, inserted after rebonded bridges suffered a second dislodgement). Potential risk factors were analysed with Cox's proportional hazards model and differences were tested for significance with the Breslow test. Observed effects are expressed as conditional-relative-risk (CRR). Survival of 'replacement' PRBBs was assessed with the Kaplan-Meier method.

RESULTS

Factors showing significant influences on complete survival were: 'location' (highest risk for mandibular PRBBs: CRR = 2.2), 'aetiology' (higher risk in treatment of aplasia: CRR = 2.9), and 'time of existence' (open spaces existing less than 2 years before insertion of PRBB: CRR: 2.0). The factor 'large open spaces in the mandible' was a risk for both complete and functional survival (CCR values 3.1 and 3.5, respectively). The survival of mandibular and maxillary 'replacement' PRBBs after 5 years was 19 +/- 7% and 31 +/- 18%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Risk factors for PRBBs were: 'location', 'aetiology', 'time of existence', 'isolation method' and 'large open spaces in the mandible'. Mandibular 'replacement' PRBBs showed such an unacceptably low survival rate that fabrication is not recommended.

Posterior resin-bonded fixed partial denture with a modified retentive design: a clinical report

A uncomplicated clinical procedure to enhance the retention of posterior resin-bonded fixed partial dentures was described. This method involves some modifications to the preparation and casting design and requires slightly more time and attention at the cementation stage of the prosthetic treatment.

Meta-analysis of anterior veneer restorations in clinical studies

OBJECTIVES

To make an inventory of clinical studies on veneer restorations (VRs) using a meta-analysis review procedure and to aggregate an overall survival result for four types of VRs.

METHODS

From the dental literature published from 1983 to November 1996, papers were selected using an in- and exclusion protocol in a two-step procedure. Additionally, the papers selected were subjected to a quality assessment. Although not all studies used an identical definition of 'failure of a restoration', this item was chosen to be the common study outcome. After a homogeneity test, cumulative survival curves were constructed by pooling the data from the studies.

RESULTS

On a 0-1 scale, the weighted overall mean quality score of the studies was 0.57 (s.e. 0.09). There was adequate agreement between the independent assessors. The results of the quality assessment could not be used as weights for the survivals, but the quality outcome supports the description of the sample of studies. From the nine studies on porcelain VRs, the pooled cumulative proportion of survival after 3 years was 0.92 (s.e. 0.01) and from three studies on preformed acrylic VRs this figure was 0.74 (s.e. 0.03). From both direct and indirect resin composite VRs, data from only one study were available after 2.5 and 2 years, respectively.

CONCLUSION

The evaluative and statistical basis of clinical VR studies may be improved to obtain an effective inference of the results. Furthermore, porcelain VRs show acceptable longevity after 3 years, which appears to be better than that of preformed acrylic VRs.

Clinical performance of resin-bonded fixed partial dentures and extracoronal attachments for removable prostheses

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

It is important to evaluate the long-term clinical performance of resin-bonded fixed partial dentures and extracoronal attachments for removable prostheses.

PURPOSE

A prospective, long-term clinical study was conducted to evaluate the success of resin-bonded fixed partial dentures since 1985 and of resin-bonded extracoronal attachments from 1987.

METHODS

Until 1993, a total of 130 resin-bonded fixed partial dentures had been seated in 101 patients, as well as 12 removable partial dentures (RPDs) with 24 extracoronal retainers in 10 patients. The clinical treatment protocol and the laboratory procedures were standardized. By the end of 1993, it was possible to reexamine 98 patients with a total of 127 resin-bonded fixed partial dentures and all 10 patients with removable partial dentures. The average time in function for the resin-bonded fixed partial dentures at the time of examination was 3.4 years and 2.3 years for the removable restorations.

RESULTS

During the period of observation, one retainer failed on six of the resin-bonded fixed partial dentures, which represents a failure rate of 4.7%. Debonding of extracoronal attachments was recorded for 8.3% of the total number of retainers.

CONCLUSION

The resin-bonded fixed partial denture technique can be considered to be a clinically reliable method of treatment, and permits the expansion of indications beyond a classical three-unit resin-bonded fixed partial denture. Long-term clinical success of removable partial dentures with resin-bonded extracoronal retainers warrants additional clinical studies.

The influence of the amalgam alloy on the survival of amalgam restorations: a secondary analysis of multiple controlled clinical trials

Data from 14 independent controlled clinical trials on the oral behavior of Classes 1 and 2 amalgam restorations, with a follow-up between five and 15 years, were re-evaluated by secondary analysis for the influence of alloy composition on the survival of amalgam restorations. For the analysis, 3119 restorations were available, which were made from 24 different alloys by a group of seven operators. The alloys were divided into four groups according to their zinc content (zinc-containing and zinc-free) and their copper content (conventional and high-copper). During the follow-up of the trials, the restorations were annually assessed for failures, which were classified as to (1) restoration-, (2) restorative process-, and (3) patient-related reasons. With the restoration-related failures, survival functions of the restorations were estimated by alloy and alloy group. The total number of failed restorations was 481, of which 77% were restoration-related and 14% process-related. Eighty percent of the restoration-related failures were due to some form of fracture of the amalgam. Restorations of conventional zinc-free alloys had the shortest survival. After 13 years, only 25% survived. Zinc and a high copper content had an equally favorable influence on the survival rate, which was 70% after 13 years when either was present. The highest survival rates were of restorations of zinc-containing high-copper alloys: 85% after 13 years. The zinc and copper contents of the alloy contributed to the corrosion resistance of the amalgams, which in turn influenced the survival of the restoration. The current ISO Standard 1559 on alloys for dental amalgam should be modified to account for these factors that influence the survival of amalgam restorations.

Resin-bonded fixed partial dentures: a review of three decades of progress

The resin-bonded fixed partial denture has undergone significant changes in design, materials and tooth preparation since its development in 1973. The selection of resin cement and micromechanical retention have closely paralleled alloy-resin-bonding research. Despite impressive in vitro research results, only 74 percent of the prostheses are still functional at the end of four years. Understanding the limitations, indications and design of resin-bonded fixed partial dentures will result in improved longevity and patient satisfaction.

A longitudinal study of resin-bonded prostheses

Resin-bonded fixed partial dentures, without definitive tooth preparation and current resinous cements and perceptive treatment, have had an inordinate number of dislodgments in initial restorative efforts. A longitudinal examination of resin-bonded prostheses was performed after a mean observation time exceeding 6 years. To prevent stress fatigue fractures of the cement bondings, one proximal groove was prepared in dentin for each anterior abutment and the inner surfaces of the frameworks were silicoated. Five of 34 prostheses debonded, and the bond strength between resin and high gold alloys was too low to resist fatigue fractures during this study. The results of this study and other reports suggested a need for increased retention and resistance form of the frameworks to improve longevity of resin-bonded prostheses.

The clinical performance of cantilevered resin-bonded bridgework

OBJECTIVES

The technique of resin-bonded bridgework is a well-accepted clinical technique to replace missing teeth. This study assesses the clinical performance of cantilevered resin-bonded bridgework provided in a university teaching hospital environment.

METHODS

One-hundred and twelve patients who had a total of 142 cantilevered bridges were either examined or completed a questionnaire regarding their bridgework. The following data were recorded for each resin-bonded bridge: gender of patient, age at bridge cementation, date of initial cementation, tooth replaced, abutment(s) involved, and grade of clinician responsible for the provision of the bridge. Details of the incidence of debonding with date(s) and the subsequent treatment in relation to the debonded resin-bonded bridge were recorded. The subjects examined indicated their degree of satisfaction with their bridgework on a visual analogue scale.

RESULTS

There were 112 patients with a total of 142 bridges, 116 (82%) maxillary and 26 (18%) mandibular. The mean length of clinical service was 36.2 months (s.d. 17.2 months). Only single pontics were included in the bridges, with almost half (49%) replacing a lateral incisor. Of the cantilever resin-bonded bridges studied, 88% remained bonded over the period of the study. A success rate of 94% is reported.

CONCLUSION

This study confirms the clinical success of cantilever resin-bonded bridges particularly in the replacement of maxillary lateral incisors, maxillary premolar and permanent mandibular teeth.

Risk of debonding in three-unit resin-bonded fixed partial dentures

Resin-bonded fixed partial dentures are considered practical and conservative but have not always enjoyed longitudinal success. The long-term survival of 1637 three-unit resin-bonded fixed partial dentures was analyzed. A multistate analysis that included parameters such as debonding, rebonding, or renewal of the restoration was used. Five years after insertion 66.1% (+/- 3.7%) of the originally inserted prostheses remained in place. If additional rebonding was computed, the probability of survival was 82.0% (+/- 3.0%). Reconstruction of the metal frame after one or more dislodgements raised the success rate to 87.1% (+/- 2.6%). Rebonded resin-bonded fixed partial dentures developed a greater risk of debonding. The risk of failure for refabricated fixed partial dentures was similar to that of the originally inserted resin-bonded fixed partial dentures. There were no signs of greater caries incidence after multiple recementation procedures.

Long-term clinical performance of resin-bonded fixed partial dentures placed in a developing country

PURPOSE

This study assesses the clinical performance of 92 resin-bonded fixed partial dentures (FPDs) placed at four private practices in Karachi, Pakistan, between 1982 and 1991.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The distribution of the FPDs was 9 perforated, 45 electrolytically etched, and 38 silicoated. Twenty-five FPDs replaced anterior teeth and 67 replaced posterior teeth. There were 66 FPDs with single pontics and 26 with multiple pontics. The perforated designs used a restorative composite for cementation, whereas the electrolytically etched and silicoated designs used a composite luting cement. The observation periods for the perforated, electrolytically etched and silicoated FPDs were 114, 99, and 30 months respectively.

RESULTS

During the evaluation period, 27 FPDs (29%) failed; of these, 4 were perforated, 18 were electrolytically etched, and 5 were silicoated. The mean (+/-SD) duration of the successful clinical service for all FPDs was 41 +/- 26 months. The mean time to failure for the FPDs that did not survive was 35 +/- 23 months. The silicoated FPDs tended to have early failure, as did the FPDs with multiple pontics and those in the mandibular arch. Anterior and posterior FPDs performed equally well.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings, in conjunction with those from Europe and North America, show that resin-bonded FPD technology is as successful in a developing country as in industrialized areas of the world.

Primer for bonding resin to metal

OBJECTIVES

The purpose was to examine the effect on the bond strength and durability of a resin bond to metal of modification of a primer consisting of thiophosphoric methacrylate with phosphoric methacrylates and/or benzoyl peroxide.

METHODS

Acrylic rods were bonded with a luting resin consisting of poly(methyl methacrylate) powder and a mixture of methyl methacrylate and tributylborane initiator to silver-palladium alloy (Ag-Pd), gold-silver alloy (Au-Ag), cobalt-chromium alloy (Co-Cr), and titanium (Ti) surfaces treated with various primers. The bonded samples were thermocycled for 2,000 cycles and the mean bond strengths were compared using one-way ANOVA and Duncan's new multiple range test at p < 0.05.

RESULTS

Using primers of thiophosphoric methacrylate or phosphoric methacrylates alone, the bond strengths of Ag-Pd decreased significantly (p < 0.05) after thermocycling. The durability was significantly improved (p < 0.05) when thiophosphoric methocrylate was used in combination with the phosphate monomers. The additional use of benzoyl peroxide and heat treatment resulted in a significant increase (p < 0.05) in the durability of two groups; the mean bond strengths over 20 MPa and the lowest values remained unchanged even after 2,000 thermocycles.

SIGNIFICANCE

The highest level of bond strength and durability to dental noble metals was achieved using a mixture of thiophosphoric and phosphoric methacrylates and benzoyl peroxide. These bond strength results are comparable to values obtained for base metals.