Tuberculosis control in less developed countries: can culture explain the whole picture?

TB perspectives among a sample of Mexicans in the United States: results from an ethnographic study

OBJECTIVE

A study was conducted to describe the sociocultural aspects of tuberculosis (TB) among Mexicans in the U.S. and to provide TB programs with practical recommendations for serving this population.

METHODS

In-depth, structured, open-ended interviews were conducted with 50 persons from Mexico living in the U.S. Local bilingual, bicultural researchers conducted the interviews with respondents recruited from TB clinics and surrounding communities. Both qualitative and quantitative strategies were used to analyze the data.

RESULTS

We found diverse TB perceptions and attitudes, but few were associated with specific participant characteristics. We detected widespread misperceptions about TB transmission and low perceptions of risk. Anticipated TB stigma among those with no history of disease was qualitatively greater than reported stigma among those who had TB disease. We also detected missed opportunities for TB education. Reported barriers to care included lack of transportation, limited clinic hours, cost of services, inconvenient clinic location, and communication problems with staff.

CONCLUSIONS

To address the diverse needs of Mexican-born clients, we recommend that TB programs provide culturally-appropriate, patient-centered care. We suggest several strategies aimed at raising risk awareness and reducing stigma. Finally, we encourage programs to facilitate access by providing language-appropriate services, extending clinic hours, and facilitating transportation.

A literature review of the problems of delayed presentation for treatment and non-completion of treatment for tuberculosis in less developed countries and ways of addressing these problems using particular implementations of the DOTS strategy

Tuberculosis is the cause of a large burden of disease in less developed countries. With the development of drug resistance and the co-epidemic of HIV, tuberculosis has already started to make a comeback in wealthier countries. The WHO's solution to this global tuberculosis epidemic is the DOTS strategy, the implementation of which presents many problems. The two issues most common to the majority of locations are delay in presentation for treatment and non-completion of treatment. This review looks at the reasons for these problems in the less developed world, and addresses some solutions. The main reasons for delayed presentation are: a lack of understanding about TB; the stigma associated with the disease; the inaccessibility of treatment; and a preference for private practitioners. The main reasons for non-completion of treatment are: the stigma of the disease; a lack of information; dissatisfaction with the treatment and its delivery; and inaccessibility of treatment. Successful implementations of the DOTS strategy need to address all these issues. There is little evidence that DOT enhances treatment completion unless combined with other strategies. Community-based, patient-orientated DOTS appears to be an appropriate way of addressing many of these issues. The involvement of volunteers in community-based strategies is common, but needs more research in order for this strategy to realise its full potential.

Attitudes toward tuberculosis of final year medical students from Canada, India, and Uganda

BACKGROUND

Tuberculosis, although both preventable and treatable, continues to be the world's leading cause of death from an infectious agent.

PURPOSE

To extend the results of our previous study of knowledge and practices of final year medical students regarding tuberculosis at three medical schools from endemic and nonendemic areas and to describe their attitudes.

METHODS

Eight statements assessing attitudes, as part of a larger survey, were administered to final year medical students at McMaster University in Canada, Christian Medical College in India, and Makerere University in Uganda.

RESULTS

One hundred sixty surveys were returned with 155 completed attitude responses. The response rate was 68.4% (65 of 95) for McMaster University, 39.7% (23 of 58) for the Christian Medical College, and 78.3% (72 of 92) for Makerere University. Analysis showed that six of eight attitude items were slightly statistically different among the schools with minimal effect of curriculum time and patient exposure.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite quite varied exposure to tuberculosis, students from endemic and nonendemic areas responded similarly on statements addressing attitudes toward tuberculosis.

Encompassing treatment with prevention: the path for a lasting control of tuberculosis

Tuberculosis is an important cause of death, mainly in the less developed countries. Thus far the strategy for its control had relied on the diagnosis of sick individuals and provision of chemotherapy. However, this strategy is problematic for several reasons: poor education about the disease and the low income of people with tuberculosis are important barriers for them to have access to early diagnosis and to keep adherence to treatment; provision of 'preventive therapy' to the enormous pool of people infected with tuberculosis is not feasible in less developed countries; and finally, long-term political commitment with the strategy is unlikely. Several facts indicate that tuberculosis patterns in different populations are shaped by biological, behavioral and socio-economic factors. This paper argues that a lasting control of tuberculosis requires a strategy based on a broader model of causality, which takes account of all these three causal factors.