Comparison of maxillary sinus specimens removed during Caldwell-Luc procedures and traditional maxillary sinus antrostomies

Evaluation of Caldwell-Luc Operation in the Endoscopic Era: Experience From Past 7 Years

PURPOSE

We wished to draw attention to the changes in the surgical method and indications for the Caldwell-Luc (CL) operation in the endoscopic era.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The patients who had undergone the CL operation in the previous 7 years were included in the present study. All operations had been performed by otolaryngologists. The CL operation was performed as 2 types of antrostomy: radical canine fossa antrostomy (RA) and mini-canine fossa antrostomy (MA). The surgical methods were grouped as follows: RA alone, endoscopic sinus surgery (ESS) plus RA, and ESS plus MA.

RESULTS

RA alone, ESS plus RA, and ESS plus MA had been performed in 24 (25.5%), 6 (6.3%), and 64 (68.1%) patients, respectively. RA had been used for a total of 30 patients and had been combined with ESS for only 6 patients. The indications were categorized as mucosal sinus disease and odontogenic lesions. A statistically significant difference was found between the rates of the preferred antrostomy type for the treatment of sinus mucosal disease and odontogenic lesions (P < .001).

CONCLUSIONS

In otorhinolaryngology practice, the CL procedure has mostly been required to provide easy access to the maxillary sinus when ESS alone would be inadequate. However, the formal CL operation, including RA, could still be considered a main surgical technique in oral and maxillofacial surgery practice.

Caldwell Luc Surgery: Revisited

Caldwell Luc surgery (CWS) is almost 120 years old now and it still enjoys an important place in ENT Surgeons armamentarium. The logic behind this surgery is to replace the diseased and scarred mucosa from maxillary sinus with new mucosa. In the initial period of this long journey the surgery gained many other important indications which also includes approach to surrounding structures which makes us to think if it's really a radical surgery as it is used just an approach to other structure. This was a retrospective study of CWS done during period of 2002-2014 in Sri Venkateshwara ENT Institute and Bowring & Lady Harding Hospital both of these attached to Bangalore Medical College & Research Institute. In this study we have tried to analyze the indications and surgical procedure adapted and complications. Even though it has synonym of radical antrostomy the complications were minor and temporary, except for permanent tooth anesthesia and nasal vestibular stenosis. With reasonable expertise if this surgery is done for proper indication: its worth to face these complications and it's a versatile surgery even today.

Five 'nontraditional' techniques for use in patients with recalcitrant sinusitis

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Although endoscopic sinus surgery remains the mainstay of surgical approaches to treating paranasal sinus disease, some disease may require alternative approaches. We review here five techniques: endoscopic middle turbinectomy, maxillary sinoscopy, the Caldwell-Luc procedure, intranasal inflammatory polyp steroid injection, and frontal sinus trephine.

RECENT FINDINGS

Recent findings suggest that endoscopic sinus surgery is limited in certain cases to access particular anatomic sites that may contain disease. The anterior, inferior maxillary wall and the frontal sinus may be accessed externally with minimal morbidity, and this access may be critical to treating the disease. The middle turbinate can contribute to preoperative and postoperative obstruction of sinus drainage, and resection of it can benefit the patient in many ways. Finally, the management of intranasal inflammatory polyps remains a challenge. In both preoperative and postoperative patients, the polyps may not respond to standard and even aggressive topical therapies. Intrapolyp steroid injection can provide a substantial anti-inflammatory effect and may avoid surgery for some patients.

SUMMARY

This article will review five ancillary procedures that add to the rhinologist's skill set to treat difficult or recalcitrant paranasal sinus disease.