Titanium Ossicular Chain Reconstruction Revision Success and Preoperative Factors Predicting Success

Primary ossiculoplasties provide better hearing results than revisions: a retrospective cohort study

PURPOSE

To evaluate the efficacy of ossicular chain reconstruction (OCR) in primary and revision surgeries, and to investigate the impact of the number of previous surgeries on hearing outcomes.

METHODS

Retrospective analysis of cases with OCR due to chronic otitis in a tertiary center between January 2018 and September 2021.

RESULTS

Altogether, 147 cases of ossicle involvement were assessed. In 91.83% (n = 135) OCR was performed, 96.26% of them with titanium TORP/PORP (n = 130), two cases with autologous prosthesis and three with piston. Mean follow-up was 8.8 months. The ABG significantly improved in the total group (TORP/PORP) from a mean (SD) of 30.94 (15.55) to 19.76 (13.36) dB (p < 0.0001) with 60.86% success. The best results were achieved in primary OCR with PORP implantation without cholesteatoma (89.47%). Primary cases have a significantly higher success rate in contrary to revision surgeries (72.27%, vs. 52.00%, p = 0.032). The only relevant predictive factor proved to be the fact of revision (p = 0.029). A statistically significant correlation between the number of previous surgeries and hearing results could not be proved. There was no difference in hearing outcomes between patients with only one or more than one previous surgeries in the revision groups. Neither the presence of cholesteatoma, nor the type of OCR (TOPR/PORP) and the indication of revision had an impact on postoperative ABG.

CONCLUSIONS

Titanium prostheses are effective in OCR both in primary and revision cases. It is not the number of previous surgeries, but the fact of revision that influences postoperative hearing results.

Comparison of partial vs. total ossicular chain reconstruction using titanium prosthesis: a retrospective cohort study

PURPOSE

Comparison of the hearing outcomes of titanium partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP) vs. titanium total ossicular replacement prosthesis (TORP) with footplate shoe (Omega Connector) in second stage ossicular chain reconstruction surgeries.

METHODS

In this retrospective cohort study in a tertiary hospital, we compared the hearing outcomes in 248 patients who had undergone ossicular chain reconstruction with titanium prostheses PORP (n = 115) vs. TORP (n = 133) from August 2017 to June 2021. Pre-and post-operative audiometric data were assessed.

RESULTS

In general, we found that there were no significant differences between PORP and TORP groups in gains of BC (P = 0.080), AC (P = 0.454), ABG (P = 0.928), SRT (P = 0.065), and SDS (P = 0.363). There were no significant differences in terms of ABG gain between the two groups. Regarding ABG gains frequency-specific analysis in the ears with pre-operative conductive hearing loss, there were no significant differences between low-frequencies (P = 0.260) and high-frequencies (P = 0.973) between the two groups.

CONCLUSION

To sum up, this research provided additional evidence with respect to hearing outcomes after staged ossicular chain reconstruction with PORP and TORP. The practical application of our study is that TORP with footplate shoe (Omega Connector) is comparable with PORP in staged ossiculoplasty.

Healthcare consumption among subjects with otitis media undergoing middle ear surgery-analysis of cost drivers

PURPOSE

To map healthcare utilized by subjects with chronic otitis media, with or without cholesteatoma and perform a cost analysis to determine key drivers of healthcare expenditure.

METHODS

A registry study of 656 adult subjects with chronic otitis media that underwent a middle ear surgery between 2014 and 2018. Healthcare contacts related to all publicly funded specialist ENT care, audiological care and primary care for a disease of the ear and mastoid process were extracted. The data are extracted from the Swedish National Patient Registry on subjects that reside in western Sweden.

RESULTS

Subjects made 13,782 healthcare contacts at a total cost 61.1 million SEK (6.0 million EUR) between 2014 and 2018. The mean cost per subject was 93,075 SEK (9071 EUR) and ranged between 3971 SEK (387 EUR) and 468,711 SEK (45,683 EUR) per individual. In the most expensive quartile of subjects, mean cost was 192,353 SEK (18,747 EUR) over the 5-year period. These subjects made 3227 ENT contacts (roughly four each year) and 60% of total costs were associated with in-patient ENT care.

CONCLUSION

Patients with chronic otitis media are associated with high ENT resource utilization that does not diminish after surgical intervention and the disease places a long-term burden on healthcare systems. Significant costs are attributed to revision surgeries, indicating that these patients could be managed more effectively. In many such cases, reoperation cannot be avoided, especially due to recurrence of cholesteatoma. However, in some patients, when the indication for subsequent surgery is only hearing improvement, alternative options, such as hearing aids or implants, should also be considered. This is especially true in difficult cases, where revision ossiculoplasty is likely.

Total ossicular chain reconstruction using a titanium prosthesis: functional results

PURPOSE

To evaluate the efficacy and safety of a titanium total prosthesis (TORP) in ossicular chain reconstruction.

METHODS

Retrospective analysis of 113 cases of total ossicular chain reconstruction performed by a single surgeon between 2006 and 2018. Follow-up lasted until January 2020. Participants were patients with chronic otitis media, cholesteatoma, or ossicular chain disruption.

RESULTS

Mean preoperative air-bone gap (± standard deviation) was 32.74 dB (± 11.62). Mean postoperative air-bone gap was 21.68 (± 11.29). Mean air-bone gap improvement was 11.06 dB (± 14.99) (p < 0.001). 57 cases had a post-operative air-bone gap smaller than or equal to 20 dB (50.44%). In four cases, prosthesis dislocation was observed (12.39%). Mean prosthesis length in this group was 5.29 mm (± 0.86) versus 4.36 mm (± 1.02) in cases without prosthesis dislocation (p = 0.002).

CONCLUSIONS

Total ossicular reconstruction using a titanium prosthesis yields favorable functional results, also during prolonged follow-up. Prosthesis length was significantly longer in cases with prosthesis dislocation.

Long-Term Hearing Results of Endoskeletal Ossicular Reconstruction in Chronic Ears Using Titanium Prostheses Having a Helical Coil: Part 1-Kraus K-Helix Crown, Incus to Stapes

OBJECTIVES

1) To assess long-term hearing results after endoskeletal ossicular chain reconstruction (eOCR) using the titanium Kraus K-Helix Crown prosthesis, implanted incus to stapes, with glass-ionomer cement (GIC) in chronic ears and 2) to determine safety of the prosthesis and cement.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective, nonrandomized, sequential, single center, single surgeon.

SETTING

Private practice, ambulatory surgical center.

PATIENTS

N = 15 males (42%) and 21 females (58%). Mean age was 40.4 years (range, 6-81 years); 38 ears (22 right ears [58%] and 16 left ears [42%]).

INTERVENTIONS

eOCR in chronic ears. Comprehensive preoperative and postoperative hearing measurements were performed for up to 9 years.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Postoperative hearing results at 1 year showed statistically significant improvement as compared with preoperative hearing. Long-term hearing results remained stable and showed no statistically significant change over 9 years.

RESULTS

Estimated mean pure-tone air conduction average improved by 14.5 dB (95% confidence interval = 10.3-18.7). Estimated mean speech reception thresholds improved by 15.5 dB (10.8-20.2). Word recognition scores improved by -2.2% (-5.3 to 1.0). The estimated mean postoperative air-bone gap was 10.5 dB (7.2-13.8). The estimated mean calculated air-bone gap was 11.3 dB (8.0-14.5). The estimated mean change in high-tone bone conduction (HTBC) average was +3.5 dB (0.9-6.0). Two prostheses extruded (5%). No patients experienced any unanticipated serious adverse effects or events.

CONCLUSION

eOCR using the K-Helix Crown prosthesis, incus to stapes, and GIC can significantly improve hearing at 1 year and maintain stable hearing over 9 years. Both prosthesis and cement are safe.

Comparison of Titanium versus Polycel as Partial Ossicular Replacement Prosthesis: A Randomized Clinical Trial

INTRODUCTION

Each type of prosthesis for ossiculoplasty has its advantages and disadvantages, and the choice of the best material has been a matter of various studies. The present study aimed to make a comparison between the hearing outcomes of partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP) using titanium versus Polycel prosthesis.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A total of 106 patients undergoing PORP as a second stage ossiculoplasty were analyzed in this study. Following that, they were randomly assigned to two groups of titanium (n=54) and Polycel (n=52) prosthesis. Subsequently, pre-and post-operative audiometric data were assessed based on the aim of the study.

RESULTS

In general, the post-operative air-bone gap within 20 dB was given to 63.5% and 55.6% of all ears in the Polycel and titanium groups, respectively, indicating a non-significant difference (P=0.407). Finally, no SNHL was observed in the groups.

CONCLUSION

Overall, the hearing outcomes and the success rate of PORP are comparable between titanium and Polycel prostheses. Therefore, the selection of these prostheses could be based on the surgeons' preferences, availability, and cost.

Evaluation of Outcomes Related to Hearing and Tinnitus After Ossicular Chain Reconstruction

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to evaluate both audiological and tinnitus related results in patients with tinnitus undergoing ossicular chain reconstruction (OCR) for ossicular chain injury.

METHODS

Between January 2015 and January 2019, patients who underwent OCR due to ossicular chain pathology and developed tinnitus symptoms were included in the study group. Middle ear pathologies were standardized using the middle ear risk index (MERI) scoring system and the tinnitus handicap inventory (THI) was used to determine the severity of tinnitus. The surgical methods used for reconstruction were partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP) or total ossicular replacement prosthesis (TORP), depending on the patient's pathology.

RESULTS

The study group consisted of 43 patients aged between 34 and 65 years. Mean MERI score of the patients was 6.42 ± 2.52. When assessed categorically, 18.6% of the study group was identified in the 'mild', 46.5% were in the 'moderate', and 34.5% were in the 'severe' MERI category. Patients in the TORP group and those who were undergoing second session OCR had higher MERI and preop THI scores. Post-operative tinnitus levels were higher in patients who had OCR in the second session and were in the severe risk group. The ABG and tinnitus scores of patients were found to improve with OCR. In patients who underwent TORP, both ABG and tinnitus scores decreased significantly. Whereas, in patients who underwent PORP, only ABG values decreased significantly. After OCR, both ABG value and tinnitus scores significantly decreased compared to pre-operative results. ABG recovery rate was 100% in the study group.

CONCLUSION

It can be said that OCR positively changes both audiological parameters and tinnitus levels in ossicular chain pathologies.

Long-Term Hearing Outcomes following Total Ossicular Reconstruction with Titanium Prostheses

Objective

(1) Characterize a large cohort of patients undergoing total ossicular chain reconstruction with titanium prosthesis. (2) Analyze long-term hearing outcomes of the same cohort.

Study Design

Case series with chart review.

Setting

Tertiary care center.

Subject and Methods

This study reviews patients who underwent total ossicular chain reconstruction (OCR) with titanium prostheses (TORPs) at a single tertiary care center from 2005 to 2015. Patient charts were reviewed for demographic data, diagnosis, and operative details. Patients were included in statistical analysis if length of follow-up was 2 years or more. Evaluation of hearing improvement was made by comparing preoperative air-bone gap (ABG) and ABG at follow-up at 2 years.

Results

In total, 153 patients were identified who met inclusion criteria. The mean age of included patients was 40 years (range, 6-89 years). Sixty patients (39%) had a history of OCR, and 120 patients (78%) had a diagnosis of cholesteatoma at the time of OCR. Preoperatively, the mean ABG was 36 ± 12, whereas the mean ABG at 2-year follow-up improved to 26 ± 13. This was statistically significant ( P < .0001) using a Wilcoxon matched-pairs signed rank test. Twelve patients (8%) required revision OCR. Two revisions were performed due to prosthesis extrusion (<1%).

Conclusion

Titanium prostheses lead to significant improvement in hearing over long periods. The results are sustained as far out as 5 years following surgery. In addition, rates of revision surgery with titanium TORPs are low. Based on this series, there are no readily identifiable predictors for outcomes following total OCR.