Animals and Alternatives: Societal Expectations and Scientific Need

The use of in vivo zebrafish assays in drug toxicity screening

Anecdotal evidence has long suggested that zebrafish may be a good model to predict toxicity of human drugs. As summarized in this review, several groups have recently conducted systematic evaluations of zebrafish toxicity end points using large numbers of pharmacologically relevant compounds. Assays of particular interest include those for cardiotoxicity, ototoxicity, seizure liability, developmental toxicity and gastrointestinal motility. Results suggest that zebrafish assays can attain an acceptable level of predictivity, ranging from "sufficient" (65 - 75% predictivity) to "good" (75 - 85% predictivity) based on guidelines established for novel in vitro tests by the European Centre for the Validation of Alternative Methods. Further validation will probably be required to definitely establish zebrafish as a standard model for toxicity testing.

Comparative in vitro cytotoxicity assessment of selected gaseous compounds in human alveolar epithelial cells

Exposure to airborne contaminants is significantly associated with human health risks, ranging from bronchial reactivity to morbidity and mortality due to acute intense or long term low level repeated exposures. However, the precise mechanisms that derive such effects are not always understood. Although inhalation studies are technologically complicated, correct hazard characterisation is essential for comparable risk assessment of inhaled materials. The aim of this study was to investigate the comparative in vitro cytotoxicity of selected gaseous contaminants in human lung cells. The cytotoxicity of nitrogen dioxide (NO(2)), sulphur dioxide (SO(2)) and ammonia (NH(3)) was investigated in A549- human pulmonary type II-like epithelial cell lines cultured on porous membranes in Snapwell inserts. A dynamic direct exposure method was established by utilizing the horizontal diffusion chamber system (Harvard Apparatus Inc, USA) for delivery of test atmospheres. Test atmospheres were generated using a dynamic direct dilution method and the concentration monitored by appropriate analytical methods. A diversified battery of in vitro assays including the MTS (tetrazolium salt; Promega), NRU (neutral red uptake; Sigma) and ATP (adenosine triphosphate; Promega) assays was implemented. Airborne IC(50) (50% inhibitory concentration) values were calculated based on the most sensitive assay for each test gas including NO(2) (IC(50)=11+/-3.54 ppm; NRU)>SO(2) (IC(50)=48+/-2.83 ppm; ATP)> and NH(3) (IC(50)=199+/-1.41 ppm; MTS). However, all in vitro assays revealed similar toxicity ranking for selected gaseous contaminants. Identical toxicity ranking was achieved using both in vitro and published in vivo data. This comparison suggests that results of in vitro methods are comparable to in vivo data and may provide greater sensitivity for respiratory toxicity studies of gaseous contaminants.

Virulence characterization ofAvibacterium paragallinarumisolates from Uganda

Avibacterium paragallinarum isolates from Uganda were characterized for their virulence by comparison of their pathogenicity and their resistance to serum. Pathogenicity was evaluated using commercial Hisex Brown layer chickens, local indigenous chickens, local turkeys and local guineafowls inoculated with 108 colony-forming units of Av. paragallinarum and comparing their overall mean disease scores over a period of 20 days. Persistence of the bacteria in the host and water was also investigated for a 60-day period by culture and polymerase chain reaction as well as use of sentinel chickens. Serum resistance was measured by comparison of the growth kinetics and survival indices at 3 and 6 h. There was no difference in the virulence of the isolates. Commercial layer chickens and local indigenous chickens were equally susceptible to challenge, while turkeys and guineafowls only showed transient mild signs and did not transmit infection. Turkeys and guineafowls did not acquire the infection when placed in contact with infected chickens. The isolates were resistant in normal chicken serum at both 3 and 6 h of incubation but were resistant at 3 h and sensitive at 6 h in turkey and guineafowl sera. The resistance of the isolates to serum correlated with their pathogenicity in the different hosts. No carrier status was demonstrated in this study using polymerase chain reaction and culture. The present study demonstrates that Ugandan Av. paragallinarum isolates are pathogenic to chickens with only transient signs in turkeys and guineafowls, and that serum resistance could be a subject for further investigation as a predictor of virulence of these bacteria. The role of turkeys and guineafowls in transmission of Av. paragallinarum was not demonstrated in the present investigation.