The use of leucocyte-depleting and conventional arterial line filters in cardiac surgery: a systematic review of clinical studies

Blood cell adhesion to arterial filters analysis by scanning electron microscopy and real-time PCR assay: observational clinical study in cardiac surgery patients

INTRODUCTION

Arterial filter is the part of the cardiopulmonary bypass circuit where blood cells are exposed to high mechanical stress and where cellular aggregates may fasten in large quantities. The aim of this study was to analyse blood cell adhesiveness in the arterial filter through scanning electron microscopy and real-time PCR assay.

METHODS

Prospective, clinical and observational study performed on 28 patients undergoing cardiac surgery with cardiopulmonary bypass. Arterial filters were analysed by scanning electron microscopy. Real-time PCR assay was performed in extracted material from the arterial filters for analysis of platelet GPIb and CD45 leucocyte gene expression. Blood coagulation was analysed during cardiopulmonary bypass. Patients were followed until hospital discharge or 28 days after surgery.

RESULTS

All studied arterial filters used in the subject patients showed a degree of adhesion from blood elements at scanning electron microscopy. All studied filters were positive for platelets GPIb gene expression and 15% had CD45 leucocyte gene expression. The GPIb platelet gene expression in blood lowered at the end of cardiopulmonary bypass (p = 0.019). There was negative correlation between blood GPIb platelet gene expression and Clot SR (HEPSCREEN2 ReoRox^®) (rho = 0.635; p = 0.027). The filter fields count was correlated to the D-dimer dosage (rho = 0.828; p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

There was adhesion of blood elements, especially nucleated platelets, on all arterial filters studied. Although the arterial filter worked as a safety device, that possibly prevented arterial embolisation, it may also have caused greater hyperfibrinolysis during cardiopulmonary bypass.

The Great Britain and Ireland perspective: current perfusion safety issues, preparing for the future

The Great Britain and Ireland (GBI) recommendations for standards of monitoring and alarms during cardio-pulmonary bypass (CPB) came into force in January 2004. While perfusion departments in Great Britain and Ireland should now have a good baseline level of safety, it is important that department-specific safety is also considered. Patient safety is paramount, but safety within our speciality must also take into account the protection of the perfusionists’ health and the protection of their careers. These different aspects of safety are fundamentally interrelated.

This paper focuses on the importance of careful assessment, implementation and documentation when a new component or technique is being introduced to the CPB circuit, even when the aim is to increase safety.

Knowledge of the civil justice system and the trends in medical negligence claims are an integral part of perfusionist safety. Perfusion in Great Britain and Ireland is rightly striving for professional recognition from the Health Professions Council (HPC). As we raise the profile of perfusion, we educate more people about the importance of our role and level of responsibility within the cardiac operating team. This will increase the potential for medical negligence claims to be directed specifically at our speciality. All these issues are discussed in detail.

A prospective clinical study of cerebral microemboli and neuropsychological outcome comparing vent-line and auto-venting arterial line filters: both filters are equally safe

Introduction: Microemboli are the main implicated cause of neuropsychological (NP) impairment after cardiac surgery. This prospective clinical trial compared the effect of an auto-venting arterial line filter on intraoperative cerebral microemboli and NP outcome compared to an arterial line filter with a vent line, in patients undergoing elective coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery.

Methods: One hundred and ten patients received either an Avecor Affinity ( n = 73) or Pall AV-6 ( n = 37) control filter. Cerebral microemboli during cardiopulmonary bypass were recorded by transcranial Doppler monitoring of the right middle cerebral artery. Evidence of cerebral impairment was obtained by comparing patients’ performance in a NP test battery (nine tests) administered 6-8 weeks postoperatively with their pre-operative scores.

Results: During cardiopulmonary bypass, the median number and range of microemboli were 67 (5-846) and 55 (2-773) for the Avecor and AV-6 groups, respectively ( p = 0.47). There was no difference in NP outcome.

Conclusion: There is no difference in the filtering ability of vent-line and auto-vent filters as assessed by cerebral microemboli. This, together with the similar NP outcome, suggests that both types of filter are equally safe for clinical use.

Pharmacological Neuroprotection During Cardiac Surgery

Despite more than 30 years of aggressive neuroprotective research by many investigators, neuropsychological deficit after cardiac surgery remains an important cause of postoperative morbidity. Although the neurological outcome is a result of a multifactorial etiology, many physicians world-wide have recognized the importance of this problem, and extensive efforts have been made in attempting to minimize the incidence of neurological and neurocognitive dysfunction. Pharmacological intervention is one of the important potential methods of neuroprotection during cardiac surgery. In vitro studies have identified drugs that are effective protectants against focal cerebral ischemia, hemorrhage, and global ischemia. However, at present there is no solid agreement on the need for prophylactic neuroprotectants in cardiac surgery. Researchers and clinicians must become more cognizant of the pitfalls and paradoxes that have arisen in attempting to translate the results of animal studies into clinical trial, with regard to neuroprotective therapy during cardiac surgery. There is an extensive need for new pharmacological approaches directed at reducing neurologic and neurocognitive injury during cardiac surgery. This article reviews past and present neuroprotective efforts and interventions during cardiac surgery.

Leukocyte depletion during CPB: effects on inflammation and lung function

Cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) is related to inflammatory response and pulmonary dysfunction. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of CPB leukocyte filtration on inflammation and lung function after coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG). A prospective randomized study was performed to compare CABG patients undergoing CPB leukocyte filtration (n = 9) or standard CPB (n = 11). Computed tomography, oxygenation, leukocyte count, hemodynamic data, PaO2/FiO2, shunt fraction, interleukins, elastase, and myeloperoxidase were evaluated. Data were analyzed using two-factor ANOVA for repeated measurements. The filtered group showed lower neutrophil counts up to 50 min of CPB, lower shunt fraction up to 6 h after surgery, and lower levels of IL-10 at the end of surgery (p < 0.05). There was no statistically significant difference between groups related to other parameters. Leukodepletion during CPB results in neutrophil sequestration by a short time, decreased IL-10 serum levels, and lower worsening of lung function only temporarily.

Leukodepletion for patients undergoing heart valve surgery

BACKGROUND

There is some evidence for the benefits of leukodepletion in patients undergoing coronary artery surgery. Its effectiveness in higher risk patients, such as those undergoing heart valve surgery, particularly in terms of overall clinical outcomes, is currently unclear.

OBJECTIVES

To assess the beneficial and harmful effects of leukodepletion on clinical, patient-reported and economic outcomes in patients undergoing heart valve surgery.

SEARCH METHODS

We searched the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL) (2013, Issue 3 of 12) in The Cochrane Library, the NHS Economic Evaluations Database (1960 to April 2013), MEDLINE Ovid (1946 to April week 2 2013), EMBASE Ovid (1947 to Week 15 2013), CINAHL (1982 to April 2013) and Web of Science (1970 to 17 April 2013) on 19 April 2013. We also searched the World Health Organization (WHO) International Clinical Trials Registry Platform (ICTRP), the US National Institutes of Health (NIH) clinical trials database and the International Standard Randomised Controlled Trial Number Register (ISRCTN) in April 2013 for ongoing studies. No language or time period restrictions were applied. We examined the reference lists of all included randomised controlled trials and contacted authors of identified trials. We searched the 'grey' literature at OpenGrey and handsearched relevant conference proceedings.

SELECTION CRITERIA

Randomised controlled trials comparing a leukocyte-depleting arterial line filter with a standard arterial line filter, on the arterial outflow of the heart-lung bypass circuit, in elective patients undergoing heart valve surgery.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Data were collected on the study characteristics, three primary outcomes (1. post-operative in-hospital all-cause mortality within three months, 2. post-operative all-cause mortality excluding inpatient mortality < 30 days, 3. length of stay in hospital, 4. adverse events and serious adverse events) and seven secondary outcomes (1. tubular or glomerular kidney injury, 2. validated health-related quality of life scales, 3. validated renal injury scales, 4. use of continuous veno-venous haemo-filtration, 5. length of stay in intensive care, 6. costs of care). Data were extracted by one author and verified by a second author. Insufficient data were available to perform a meta-analysis or sensitivity analysis.

MAIN RESULTS

Eight studies were eligible for inclusion in the review but data on prespecified review outcomes were available from only one, modestly powered (24 participants) study (Hurst 1997). There were no differences between a leuko-depleting versus standard filter in length of stay in the intensive care unit (ICU) (mean difference (MD) 0.80 days; 95% confidence interval (CI) -0.24 to 1.84) or length of hospital stay (MD 0.20 days; 95% CI -1.78 to 2.18).

AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS

There are currently insufficient good quality trials with valve surgery patients to inform recommendations for changes in clinical practice. A future National Institute for Health Research (NIHR)-funded feasibility study (recruiting mid-year 2013) comparing leukodepletion with a standard arterial line filter in patients undergoing elective heart valve surgery (the ROLO trial) will be the largest study to date and will make a significant contribution to future updates of this review.

Leukocyte depletion during cardiopulmonary bypass in routine adult cardiac surgery

OBJECTIVES

Cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) elicits an inflammatory response which is potentially harmful and that is partly caused by activation of leukocytes. Despite promise from earlier studies, however, the value of intraoperative leukocyte-depletion (LD) remains equivocal. We studied the effect of LD during routine cardiac surgery.

METHODS

For a short period (2.5 months), all operations at our institution were performed with leukocyte filters (Pall, East Hills, NY, USA) in the arterial and cardioplegia lines of the CPB. Those patients operated immediately before and after this period served as controls.

RESULTS

In each group, 266 predominantly male (70%) patients were studied. A broad spectrum of operations including emergency surgery was evaluated, which was comparable between the groups (P=0.41). There were no significant differences regarding the preoperative data, but the preoperative leukocyte count tended to be lower in the leukodepletion-group (7961±2415 vs. 8444±2951, P=0.050). Despite this, no difference between the groups regarding the postoperative leukocyte count was observed. Significantly more LD-patients were extubated within 12 h postoperatively (69% vs. 60% in the control-group, P=0.029), but there were no significant differences regarding 30-day mortality (0.4% vs. 1.1%, P=0.37), transfusion requirements or major morbidity.

CONCLUSIONS

In a retrospective study on adding LD filters to all cardiac operations with CPB in adults, we did not observe a clear benefit of intraoperative LD with the strategy used (continuous filtration plus filtration of cardioplegia).

The effects of various leukocyte filtration strategies in cardiac surgery

It is known that cardiopulmonary bypass causes an inflammatory reaction with an associated morbidity and mortality. Several anti-inflammatory strategies have been implemented to reduce this response, including leukocyte removal from the circulation using specialised filters. The aim of this study is to systematically review the available evidence on leukocyte filtration in cardiac surgery, focusing on its effect on systemic inflammation and whether this has influenced clinical outcomes. Five electronic databases were systematically searched for studies reporting the effect of leukocyte filtration at any point within the cardiopulmonary bypass circuit in humans. Reference lists of all identified studies were checked for any missing publications. Two authors independently extracted the data from the included studies. Whilst systemic leukodepleting filters do not appear to consistently lower leukocyte counts, they may preferentially remove activated leukocytes. Small improvements in early post-operative lung function in patients receiving systemic leukodepletion have been reported, but this does not lead to reduced hospital stay or decreased mortality. There is substantial evidence that cardioplegic leukocyte filtration attenuates the reperfusion injury at a cellular level, but this has not been translated into clinical improvements. Finally, whilst various strategies involving multiple leukocyte filters, or the incorporation of pharmacological agents into leukocyte-depleting protocols have been evaluated, the current available results are not conclusive. Our study suggests that there is not enough high quality or consistent evidence to draw guidelines regarding the use of leukocyte-depleting filters within routine cardiac surgical practice.

First Clinical Experience With the Air Purge Control and Electrical Remote-controlled Tubing Clamp in Mini Bypass

Most mini bypass systems do not contain a venous and cardiotomy reservoir in the cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) circuit and lack the capability to remove venous air. In conjunction with the manufacturer the air purge control system, a system which automatically removes air that is captured in a venous bubble trap, has been developed. This system is combined with an electrical remote clamp, which automatically clamps the arterial line in case air leaves the bubble trap. Twenty consecutive patients undergoing surgery with CPB were included in this clinical validation. Venous air was removed by the air purge control during bypass. The electrical remote clamp was never activated by the system, confirming that the air purge control adequately removed venous air during these cases. The air purge control, in conjunction with the electrical remote clamp, is a valuable safety feature in mini bypass, enhancing patient safety and user friendliness while providing a level of safety equivalent to those of conventional bypass systems.

Strain-specific differences in sensitivity to ischemia-reperfusion lung injury in mice

Ischemia-reperfusion (I/R) lung injury is characterized by increased pulmonary endothelial permeability and edema, but the genetic basis for this injury is unknown. We utilized an in vivo mouse preparation of unilateral lung I/R to evaluate the genetic determinants of I/R lung injury. An index of pulmonary vascular protein permeability was measured by the ratio of left-to-right lung Evans blue dye of eight inbred mouse strains after 30 min of left lung ischemia and 150 min of reperfusion. The order of strain-specific sensitivity to I/R lung injury was BALB/c < SJL/J < CBA/J < C57BL/6J < 129/J < A/J < C3H/H3J < SWR/J. The reciprocal F1 offspring of the BALB/c and SWR/J progenitor strains had intermediate phenotypes but a differing variance. A similar pattern of right lung Evans blue dye content suggested the presence of contralateral injury because baseline vascular permeability was not different. Lung I/R injury was attenuated by NADPH oxidase inhibition, indicating a role for NADPH oxidase-derived reactive oxygen species (ROS). There was no strain-dependent difference in lung NADPH oxidase expression. Strain-related differences in zymosan-stimulated neutrophil ROS production did not correlate with I/R lung injury in that neutrophil ROS production in SWR/J mice was greater than C57BL/6J but not different from BALB/c mice. These data indicate the presence of a genetic sensitivity to lung I/R injury that involves multiple genes including a maternal-related factor. Although neutrophil-derived ROS production is also modulated by genetic factors, the pattern did not explain the genetic sensitivity to lung I/R injury.

Neuroprotection during cardiac surgery: strategies to reduce cognitive decline

Although the population receiving cardiac surgery is older and therefore more prone to cognitive deterioration, these difficulties have declined over the last ten years. It is likely that the multiple changes introduced to cardiac surgery over time have had a cumulative benefit in protecting the brain. The most likely causes of cognitive difficulties are microemboli delivered to the brain during surgery, altered cerebral perfusion and an inflammatory response. The interventions that have been implemented can be divided into those which have attempted to reduce the potential causes of damage and those aimed at reducing the impact by attempting to protect the brain. The evidence for three main types of intervention (equipment, techniques and drugs) is reviewed in this paper. Although many interventions are available only a few have shown a clear benefit. Progress in the future will require larger studies to address this multifactorial problem.