Flow characterization of Maquet and Bio-Medicus multi-stage drainage cannulae during venoarterial extracorporeal membrane oxygenation

BACKGROUND

Drainage cannulae extract blood from a patient during venoarterial extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (VA ECMO), a treatment that temporarily supports patients undergoing severe heart and/or lung dysfunction. Currently, the two most commonly used multi-stage drainage cannulae are manufactured by Maquet and Bio-Medicus, but their designs vary in many aspects which impacts the generated flow dynamics. Therefore, this study aimed to use computational fluid dynamics (CFD) to explore the flow characteristics of the aforementioned cannulae and their impact on complications such as thrombosis.

METHODS

The Maquet and Bio-Medicus cannulae were 3D modelled within a patient-specific geometry of the venous vasculature taken from a computed tomography scan of a patient undergoing VA ECMO. A drainage flow rate of 4 L/min was assigned to each cannula. Lastly, a stress blended eddy simulation turbulence model was employed to resolve bulk flow turbulence.

RESULTS

The proximal row of side holes in both cannulae generated high intensity counter-rotating vortices, thus generating supraphysiological shear. These proximal rows were also responsible for the majority of flow extraction in both cannulae (>1.6 L/min). Despite identical simulation settings, each cannulae had differing impacts on global flow dynamics. For instance, the Bio-Medicus model produced a total stagnant blood volume of 25.6 ml, compared to 17.8 ml the Maquet cannula, thereby increasing the risk of thrombosis.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, our results demonstrate that differences in design clearly impact flow dynamics and risk of complications. Therefore, further work in optimizing cannula design may be beneficial to prevent harmful flow characteristics.

Improving Trendelenburg position effectiveness by varying cardiopulmonary bypass flow

INTRODUCTION

Trendelenburg position (TP) is used to transport gaseous emboli away from the cerebral region during cardiac surgery. However, TP effectiveness has not been fully considered when combined with varying the cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) flow. This study simulated the supine and TP at different pump flows and assessed the trapped emboli and embolic load entering the aortic arch branch arteries (AABA).

METHODS

A computational fluid dynamics (CFD) approach used a centrally cannulated adult patient-specific aorta model replicating a CPB circuit. Air emboli of 0.1 mm, 0.5 mm, and 1.0 mm (n = 700 each) were injected into the aorta placed in the supine position (0°) and the TP (-20°) at 2 L/min and 5 L/min. The number of emboli entering the AABA were compared. An aortic phantom flow experiment was performed to validate air bubble behaviour.

RESULTS

TP at 5 L/min had the lowest 0.1 mm mean (±SD) embolic load compared to the supine 2 L/min (55.3 ± 30.8 vs 64.3 ± 35.4). For both the supine and TP, the lower flow of 2 L/min had the highest number of simulated trapped emboli in higher elevated regions than at 5 L/min (541 ± 185 and 548 ± 191 vs 520 ± 159 and 512 ± 174), respectively. The flow experiment demonstrated that 2 L/min promoted bubble coalescence and high amounts of trapped emboli and 5 L/min transported air emboli away from the AABA.

CONCLUSIONS

TP effectiveness was improved by using CPB flow to manage air emboli. These results provide insights for predicting emboli behaviour and improving emboli de-airing procedures.

The effect of drainage cannula tip position on risk of thrombosis during venoarterial extracorporeal membrane oxygenation

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Venoarterial extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (VA ECMO) is able to support critically ill patients undergoing refractory cardiopulmonary failure. It relies on drainage cannulae to extract venous blood from the patient, but cannula features and tip position may impact flow dynamics and thrombosis risk. Therefore, this study aimed to investigate the effect of tip position of single-stage (SS) and multi-stage (MS) VA ECMO drainage cannulae on the risk of thrombosis.

METHODS

Computational fluid dynamics was used to model flow dynamics within patient-specific geometry of the venous vasculature. The tip of the SS and MS cannula was placed in the superior vena cava (SVC), SVC-Right atrium (RA) junction, mid-RA, inferior vena cava (IVC)-RA junction, and IVC. The risk of thrombosis was assessed by measuring several factors. Blood residence time was measured via an Eulerian approach through the use of a scalar source term. Regions of stagnant volume were recognised by identifying regions of low fluid velocity and shear rate. Rate of blood washout was calculated by patching the domain with a scalar value and measuring the rate of fluid displacement. Lastly, wall shear stress values were determined to provide a qualitative understanding of potential blood trauma.

RESULTS

Thrombosis risk varied substantially with position changes of the SS cannula, which was less evident with the MS cannula. The SS cannula showed reduced thrombosis risk arising from stagnant regions when placed in the SVC or SVC-RA junction, whereas an MS cannula was predicted to create stagnant regions during all tip positions. When positioned in the IVC-RA junction or IVC, the risk of thrombosis was higher in the SS cannula than in the MS cannula due to both high and low shear flow.

CONCLUSION

Tip position of the drainage cannula impacts cannula flow dynamics and, subsequently, the risk of thrombosis. The use of MS cannulae can reduce high shear-related thrombosis, but SS cannulae can eliminate stagnant regions when advanced into the SVC. Therefore, the choice of cannula design and tip position should be carefully considered during cannulation.

Improved Drainage Cannula Design to Reduce Thrombosis in Veno-Arterial Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation

Thrombosis is a potentially life-threatening complication in veno-arterial extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) circuits, which may originate from the drainage cannula due to unfavorable blood flow dynamics. This study aims to numerically investigate the effect of cannula design parameters on local fluid dynamics, and thus thrombosis potential, within ECMO drainage cannulas. A control cannula based on the geometry of a 17 Fr Medtronic drainage cannula concentrically placed in an idealized, rigid-walled geometry of the right atrium and superior and inferior vena cava was numerically modeled. Simulated flow dynamics in the control cannula were systematically compared with 10 unique cannula designs which incorporated changes to side hole diameter, the spacing between side holes, and side hole angles. Local blood velocities, maximum wall shear stress (WSS), and blood residence time were used to predict the risk of thrombosis. Numerical results were experimentally validated using particle image velocimetry. The control cannula exhibited low blood velocities (59 mm/s) at the cannula tip, which may promote thrombosis. Through a reduction in the side hole diameter (2 mm), the spacing between the side holes (3 mm) and alteration in the side hole angle (30° relative to the flow direction), WSS was reduced by 52%, and cannula tip blood velocity was increased by 560% compared to the control cannula. This study suggests that simple geometrical changes can significantly alter the risk of thrombosis in ECMO drainage cannulas.

Determination of local flow ratios and velocities in a femoral venous cannula with computational fluid dynamics and 4D flow-sensitive magnetic resonance imaging: A method validation

Cannulas with multi-staged side holes are the method of choice for femoral cannulation in extracorporeal therapies today. A variety of differently designed products is available on the market. While the preferred tool for the performance assessment of such cannulas are pressure-flow curves, little is known about the flow and velocity distribution. Within this work flow and velocity patterns of a femoral venous cannula with multi-staged side holes were investigated. A mock circulation loop for cannula performance evaluation was built and reproduced using a computer-aided design system. With computational fluid dynamics, volume flows and fluid velocities were determined quantitatively and visually with hole-based precision. In order to ensure the correctness of the flow simulation, the results were subsequently validated by determining the same parameters with four-dimensional flow-sensitive magnetic resonance imaging. Measurement data and numerical solution differed 7% on average throughout the data set for the examined parameters. The highest inflow and velocity were detected at the most proximal holes, where half of the total volume flow enters the cannula. At every hole stage a Y-shaped inflow profile was detected, forming a centered stream in the middle of the cannula. Simultaneously, flow separation creates zones with significant lower flow velocities. Numerical simulation, validated with four-dimensional flow-sensitive magnetic resonance imaging, is a valuable tool to examine flow and velocity distributions of femoral venous cannulas with hole-based accuracy. Flow and velocity distribution in such cannulas are not ideal. Based on this work future cannulas can be effectively optimized.

Aortic cannula orientation and flow impacts embolic trajectories: computational cardiopulmonary bypass

INTRODUCTION

Emboli events are associated with the aortic cannula insertion and final position in the ascending aorta. However, the impact of subtle changes in aortic cannula movement and flow influencing embolic transport throughout the aortic arch is not well understood. The present study evaluated the aortic cannula's outflow and orientation effect on emboli entering the aortic branch arteries.

METHODS

A simplified aortic computational model was anteriorly cannulated in the distal ascending aorta with a 21-French straight aortic cannula, and two orientations were analysed by injecting gaseous and solid emboli at pump flows 2, 3 and 5 L/minute. The first aortic cannula orientation (forward flow cannula) was directed towards the lesser curvature. The second aortic cannula orientation (rear flow cannula) was tilted slightly backwards by 15°, providing flow in the retrograde direction.

RESULTS

Forward flow cannula produced a primary arch flow, whereas rear flow cannula produced a secondary arch flow resulting in four times longer emboli arch resident times than forward flow cannula. The rear flow cannula had the highest percentage of gaseous emboli entering the brachiocephalic artery of 8%, 12% and 36% (at 2, 3 and 5 L/minute, respectively). Rear flow cannula provided a positive aortic branch arterial flow at all pump flows, whereas at forward flow cannula, the brachiocephalic artery experienced retrograde flows of -1.0% (3 L/minute) and -4.0% (5 L/minute), with the left common carotid -0.23% (5 L/minute). No significant number of solid emboli entered the aortic branch arteries.

CONCLUSION

This numerical study illustrated distinct trajectory behaviours between gaseous and solid emboli where slight changes in aortic cannula orientation influenced idealised emboli direction with higher pump flows magnifying the effects.