Microembolism during cardiopulmonary bypass: a comparison of bubble oxygenator with arterial line filter and membrane oxygenator alone

Microemboli can be detected in the cerebral circulation during cardiopulmonary bypass with transcranial Doppler. They are likely to be responsible for the microvascular occlusions that have been seen in the retina and they may contribute to neuropsychological damage that has been demonstrated after cardiac surgery. Twenty patients undergoing routine coronary artery bypass graft surgery were allocated to either a Harvey 1700 bubble oxygenatorwith a Pall 40μ arterial line filter or a Harvey 4000 membrane oxygenator with no arterial line filter. All cases received pulsatile flow perfusion with core cooling to 28°C. A standard surgical technique was used with distal anastomoses performed during cold cardioplegic arrest and proximal anastomoses performed with coronary perfusion during systemic rewarming. Microembolic events were measured by the counting of flow disturbances over the pattern of pulsatile flow as detected by Doppler. Median bypass time was 69 minutes (range 45-95) for the bubbler group and 79 minutes (range 50-115) for the membrane group. The microembolic event count was normalized to the number of events per 15 minute period of bypass. The median number of microembolic events per 15 minute period of bypass was 28 (range 6-54) for the bubble group and 21 (range 10-65) for the membrane group. There were no significant differences between the lengths of bypass between the two groups (Mann-Whitney p = 0.202) or the number of microemboli recorded per 15 minute period of bypass (Mann-Whitney p = 0.224). We conclude that the previously demonstrated excess generation of gaseous microemboli from bubble oxygenators over membrane oxygenators is negated by the use of a 40μ arterial line filter with the bubble oxygenator.

Cerebral dysfunction after cardiopulmonary bypass: aetiology, manifestations and interventions

Central nervous system dysfunction following cardiac surgery remains a significant cause of morbidity and mortality, with the reported incidence of dysfunction varying widely between studies. Microemboli and global cerebral hypoperfusion are implicated as the major aetiologies of CNS impairment. Preoperative and intraoperative variables influencing the patient's risk of complications remain controversial. Based on a review of previous studies, this paper outlines the major causes and manifestations of CNS impairment as well as the intraoperative interventions currently advocated to improve the cerebral outcome of cardiac patients.

Doppler ultrasound estimation of microbubbles in the arterial line during extracorporeal circulation

A pulsed Doppler ultrasound system was used to analyse microbubble intensity and size in the arterial line during extracorporeal circulation (ECC). Thirty male patients, younger than 70 (range 28-69) years, underwent isolated coronary artery bypass grafting with either a bubble oxygenator (Shiley S-100) without (group 1, n = 10) or with (group 2, n = 10) a depth adsorption arterial line filter (Swank High Flow 6000); or with a membrane oxygenator (Shiley M-2000) without a filter (group 3, n = 10). Mean ECC and aortic crossclamp times were similar in the three groups. Measurements were performed during the initial five minutes of cooling, after 30-40 minutes of ECC and after 10 minutes of rewarming. Microbubble intensity and size did not differ significantly in the three groups at the different intervals. Significantly more and larger bubbles were detected in group 1 (15-150μm) compared to group 2 (< 35μm) (p< 0.001). In group 3 only a minimal number of small bubbles (< 65μm) were observed. An arterial line filter significantly reduced the number and size of microbubbles detected in the arterial line during ECC. A membrane oxygenator was associated with a further reduction of microbubble intensity.

Bubble tracking through computational fluid dynamics in arterial line filters for cardiopulmonary bypass

Gaseous embolism is still a concern in cardiopulmonary bypass, and the use of arterial line filters (ALFs) is widespread because of their recognized role in increasing safety. Currently, the methods used for the optimization/evaluation of ALF designs are based on a trial-and-error approach. In this work, we propose a method to objectively assess the air-handling capabilities of ALFs, using computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations to track the trajectory of large numbers of bubbles traversing the device under examination. We applied the CFD method to ALF prototypes, whose design featured the classical purge/screen configuration, to establish the relative roles of the bubble-trap and bubble-barrier deairing effects. Simulations were run at the maximum rated blood flows. Clusters of hundred bubbles in the micro- to macroembolic size range (10-1,000 microm diameter) were tracked. The results quantified the relative amount of bubbles whose fate is either to reach the purge line or to be intercepted by the filter screen. For microbubbles, the analysis detailed how the screen barrier is exploited, mapping the percent distribution of the intercepted bubbles along the screen surface. We conclude that the method proposed increases knowledge and awareness in designing an optimal exploitation of the filtration mechanisms involved in ALFs.

Dynamic bubble trap can replace an arterial filter during cardiopulmonary bypass surgery

Objective: The arterial filter (AF) and the dynamic bubble trap (DBT) reduce the number of air microbubbles passing through these devices. The aim of the study was to confirm that the DBT diminishes microbubbles in the arterial line similar to, or better than, the AF, and can replace it.

Methods: In a clinical study, we evaluated 60 patients undergoing cardiopulmonary bypass surgery, divided into two groups (30 patients each). In the first group, we used an open extracorporeal system, and in the second group, a closed system. For 15 patients in each group, the AF was incorporated, the other 15 patients received the DBT. The microbubbles were counted before and after the AF or DBT, using two-channel-ultrasonic Doppler devices.

Results: The exposure of patients to small bubbles (<45μm) is significantly higher in the AF than in the DBT group. The DBT reduces large bubbles (<45μm) better than the AF, with a rate exceeding 16%.

Conclusion: The use of the DBT instead of the AF yields higher air micro-bubble removal efficacy, allowing replacement of the AF, assuming the AF is used for air removal purpose only.

Investigation on the ability of an ultrasound bubble detector to deliver size measurements of gaseous bubbles in fluid lines by using a glass bead model

Detectors based on ultrasonic principles are today's state of the art devices to detect gaseous bubbles that may be present in extracorporeal circuits (ECC) for various reasons. Referring to theoretical considerations and other studies, it also seems possible to use this technology to measure the size of detected bubbles, thus offering the chance to evaluate their potential hazardous effect if introduced into a patient's circulation. Based on these considerations, a commercially available ultrasound bubble detector has been developed by Hatteland Instrumentering, Norway, to deliver bubble size measurements by means of supplementary software. This device consists of an ultrasound sensor that can be clamped onto the ECC tubing, and the necessary electronic equipment to amplify and rectify the received signals. It is supplemented by software that processes these signals and presents them as specific data. On the basis of our knowledge and experience with bubble detection by ultrasound technology, we believe it is particularly difficult to meet all the requirements for size measurements, especially if these are to be achieved by using a mathematical procedure rather than exact devices. Therefore, we tried to evaluate the quality of the offered bubble detector in measuring bubble sizes. After establishing a standardized test stand, including a roller pump and a temperature sensor, we performed several sets of experiments using the manufacturers software and a program specifically designed at our department for this purpose. The first set revealed that the manufacturer's recommended calibration material did not meet essential requirements as established by other authors. Having solved that problem, we could actually demonstrate that the ultrasonic field, as generated by the bubble detector, has been correctly calculated by the manufacturer. Simply, it is a field having the strongest reflecting region in the center, subsequently losing strength toward the ECC tubing's edge. The following set of experiments revealed that the supplementary software not only does not compensate for the ultrasonic field's inhomogeneity, but, furthermore, delivers results that are inappropriate to the applied calibration material. In the last set of experiments, we were able to demonstrate that the signals as recorded by the bubble detector heavily depend upon the circulating fluid's temperature, a fact that the manufacturer does not address. Therefore, it seems impossible to resolve all these sensor related problems by ever-increasing mathematical intervention. We believe it is more appropriate to develop a new kind of ultrasound device, free of these shortcomings. This seems to be particularly useful, because the problem of determining the size of gaseous bubbles in ECC is not yet solved.

Can an oxygenator design potentially contribute to air embolism in cardiopulmonary bypass? A novel method for the determination of the air removal capabilities of neonatal membrane oxygenators

At present, air handling of a membrane oxygenator is generally studied by using an ultrasonic sound bubble counter. However, this is not a quantitative method and it does not give any information on where air was entrapped in the oxygenator and if it eventually was removed through the membrane for gas exchange. The study presented here gives a novel technique for the determination of the air-handling characteristics of a membrane oxygenator. The study aimed at defining not only the amount of air released by the oxygenator, but also the amount of air trapped within the oxygenator and/or removed through the gas exchange membrane. Two neonatal membrane oxygenators without the use of an arterial filter were investigated: the Polystan Microsafe and the Dideco Lilliput. Although the air trap function of both oxygenators when challenged with a bolus of air was similar, the Microsafe obtained this effect mainly by capturing the air in the heat exchanger compartment while the Lilliput did remove a large amount of air through the membrane. In conclusion, the difference in trap function was most striking during continuous infusion of air. Immediate contact with a microporous membrane, avoidance of high velocities within the oxygenator, pressure drop, transit time and construction of the fibre mat all contribute to the air-handling characteristics of a membrane oxygenator.

A comparison of gaseous emboli release in five membrane oxygenators

The purpose of this study was to compare the air handling capability of five currently used membrane oxygenators: the Avecor Affinity, the Bentley SpiralGold, the Medtronic Maxima Plus, the Sarns Turbo and the Sorin Monolyth M. A circuit was constructed to include a hardshell venous reservoir and roller pump. Pressure monitoring sites and ultrasonic microbubble detection probes were located proximal and distal to the oxygenator. An air injection/infusion site was provided proximal to the roller pump inlet. Each circuit was primed with fresh anticoagulated bovine blood, adjusted to a haematocrit of 25% and maintained at 38 +/- 1 degree C. Three different bolus amounts of air (10, 20 and 40 cm3) were injected at three blood flow rates (3, 4.5 and 6 l/min). A 1-min infusion of air delivered at 1 ml/s was also administered at three blood flow rates (3, 4.5 and 6 l/min). The hardshell reservoir was also completely emptied at each flow rate to simulate a massive air infusion. At any given blood flow, outlet microbubble counts were usually higher with greater bolus amounts of air. When indexed to the inlet bubble counts, the following average percent microbubbles were released from the outlet: Turbo 25%, Affinity 7%, Monolyth 5%, Maxima 3% and SpiralGold 1%. With a constant air infusion of 1 ml/s, greater outlet microbubble counts were associated with higher blood flow rates. Again, when indexed to the inlet bubble counts, the following average percent microbubbles were released from the outlet: Turbo 44%, Affinity 25%, Maxima 19%, Monolyth 16% and SpiralGold 0%. All oxygenators deprimed when the hardshell reservoir was emptied and all shed microbubbles into the outlet blood except the SpiralGold. The results of this study indicate that air handling is not a simple function of blood flow pattern (i.e. top to bottom versus bottom to top), but also includes dynamics associated with oxygenator design, fibre arrangement and flow resistance.

Magnetic resonance imaging of the brain before and after open heart operations

Magnetic resonance imaging of the brain was performed in 29 adult male patients before and 1 week after elective coronary artery bypass grafting to study the cerebral effect of cardiopulmonary bypass. The mean age of the patients was 60 years (range, 45 to 69 years). During cardiopulmonary bypass, either a bubble oxygenator without an arterial line filter (n = 9), a bubble oxygenator with a depth adsorption filter (n = 10), or a flat-sheet membrane oxygenator without a filter (n = 10) was used. The mean bypass time was 88 minutes (standard deviation, 31 minutes) and did not differ significantly between the three groups. Preoperative magnetic resonance imaging revealed high signal intensity foci on T2-weighted images (white matter abnormalities) in 17 (59%; 95% confidence limits, 39% to 76%) of the 29 patients, all of which were nonspecific and of the common type considered to be related to aging, and all were unchanged at the postoperative examination. Preoperative and postoperative frontal horn indices, bicaudate diameters, and third ventricle widths did not differ significantly regardless of oxygenator type or whether or not an arterial line filter was used during cardiopulmonary bypass. Two patients (7%; 95% confidence limits, 1% to 23%), both receiving bubble oxygenation (1 without a filter and 1 with an arterial line filter) sustained a cerebral infarction during cardiopulmonary bypass.

The effect of high pressure on microporous membrane oxygenator failure

A retrospective study to determine the relationship between early microporous membrane oxygenator (MMO) failure and blood pressure at the MMO outlet (Pmo) was conducted using data collected with 19 dogs (22 +/- 1 kg, mean +/- SEM) undergoing routine normothermic cardiopulmonary bypass. Because gas flow was maintained at a high level, it could not be used to control CO2 exchange. Instead, blood PCO2 was controlled by adding CO2 to the sweep gas. Blood PO2 was controlled as suggested by the manufacturer, by adjusting the %O2 in the gas phase (g). Blood flow was 2575 +/- 54 ml/min; Pmo ranged from 173 to 790 mm Hg; and hematocrit was 33 +/- 1%. O2 exchange was calculated from blood gas parameters. Changes in the diffusion potential of O2 (delta PO2) and CO2 (delta PCO2) and MMO performance (P, taken as oxygen exchange normalized to a diffusion potential of 100 mm Hg) indicated MMO failure. Initial values, taken within 60 min of bypass initiation, were compared to final values taken at 226 +/- 9 min of bypass. Despite higher final delta PO2 (411 +/- 9 vs. 538 +/- 19 mm Hg, p less than 0.0001 paired t-test) and delta PCO2 (18.6 +/- 2.4 vs. 30.5 +/- 4.7 mm Hg, p less than 0.0017), arterial blood PO2 decreased (159 +/- 15 to 89 +/- 6 mm Hg, p less than 0.0005) and PCO2 increased (36.4 +/- 1.5 to 46.1 +/- 3.0 mm Hg, p less than 0.0039), and the performance decreased [24.5 +/- 1.1 to 20.1 +/- 0.7 (ml/min)/(100 mm Hg), p less than 0.0001].(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)