Comparative analysis of endovenous laser ablation versus ultrasound-guided foam sclerotherapy for the treatment of venous leg ulcers

BACKGROUND

Endovenous thermal and non-thermal therapeutic approaches have become standard of care for the treatment of venous insufficiency. However, comparative studies on its use in the population of venous leg ulcer patients are scarce.

METHODS

The present study aimed at a comparison of the efficacy of endovenous laser ablation (EVLA) and ultrasound-guided foam sclerotherapy (UGFS) for the treatment of venous leg ulcers (VUs). We retrospectively analyzed patient records of 68 patients with active VUs (C6 of the CEAP-classification), who underwent EVLA (n=33) or UGFS (n=35) between January 2001 and January 2021.

RESULTS

In 68 patients, 97 venous segments (GSV: 43, SSV: 17:, NSV: 37) were treated. Ulcer surface area at initial presentation did not differ significantly between both treatment groups (EVLA: 7.7±10.7 vs. UGFS: 8.5±16.3 cm² ; p=0.73). No significant difference regarding patient characteristics was found, with the exception of age, as patients receiving UGFS treatment were significantly older (EVLA: 61±17 vs. UGFS: 70±14 years; p=0.018). The rate of ulcer resolution was not significantly different between EVLA and UGFS groups (97.0% vs. 85.7%; p=0.20). Also, the mean time to complete ulcer healing after endovenous intervention was comparable (EVLA: 59±37 vs. UGFS: 63±41 days; p=0.68). However, the relapse rate was significantly higher for UGFS than for EVLA treated patients (31.4% vs. 3.0%; p=0.002).

CONCLUSION

Rates of ulcer resolution and ulcer healing time after endovenous intervention were comparable between both treatment modalities. However, a significantly higher relapse rate was observed in UGFS treated patients.

Catheter-directed foam sclerotherapy, an alternative to ultrasound-guided foam sclerotherapy for varicose vein treatment: A systematic review and meta-analysis

PURPOSE

Catheter-directed foam sclerotherapy is a new addition to the treatment modalities available for varicose veins. As a modification of ultrasound-guided foam sclerotherapy, catheter-directed foam sclerotherapy has been purported to offer higher complete ablation rates and an improved safety profile. The aim of this study is to appraise the current literature on the outcomes of catheter-directed foam sclerotherapy compared to ultrasound-guided foam sclerotherapy in chronic venous insufficiency.

METHODS

The review of the literature was conducted using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. Data from studies that reported the outcomes of catheter-directed foam sclerotherapy and ultrasound-guided foam sclerotherapy were extracted, to determine the pooled proportion of complete ablation rates, using a random effect meta-analysis model.

RESULTS

A total of 62 studies, involving 3689 patients, were included in the systematic review. Higher rates of complete ablation were reported in catheter-directed foam sclerotherapy compared to ultrasound-guided foam sclerotherapy during the short- and medium-term follow-ups (Relative Risk = 1.06, Relative Risk = 1.15, Relative Risk = 1.19, p < 0.05). Fewer major and minor complications were also reported in patients who underwent catheter-directed foam sclerotherapy (Relative Risk = 0.23, Relative Risk= 0.43-0.76, p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Catheter-directed foam sclerotherapy has been demonstrated to have many advantages over ultrasound-guided foam sclerotherapy, offering superior complete ablation rates in the short-, medium- and long-term follow-ups. It also has a better safety profile, conferring a lower risk of major and minor complications. The conclusions should however be viewed in the context of significant limitations imposed by limited study data.

Transilluminated powered phlebectomy in the treatment of large area venous leg ulcers: A case-control study with 3 years follow-up

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the efficacy, safety and long-term outcome of TIPP for the adjunct therapy of superficial venous reflux-related VLUs.

METHODS

A total of 93 consecutive patients (104 legs) with superficial venous insufficiency-related VLUs who underwent TIPP (53 legs) or conventional phlebectomy (51 legs) between January 2010 and December 2013 were retrospectively studied.

RESULTS

Compared to patients in the conventional phlebectomy group, TIPP patients had larger ulcer areas before surgery (P < 0.005). However, TIPP group required a significantly shorter operation time (P < 0.005), fewer incisions (P < 0.005) but less ulcer healing time (1.25 month vs 2.5 months, P < 0.05). No significant difference in in-hospital and follow-up complications was found between the two groups. For long-term outcome, TIPP group leaded a lower ulcer recurrence rate at 36 months (13.2% vs 29.4%, P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

TIPP may be an adjunct surgical method contributes to healing of VLUs, especially for large ulcer areas.

Impacto da escleroterapia com espuma de polidocanol guiada por ultrassom em pacientes com úlcera venosa

Contexto

A escleroterapia com espuma de polidocanol guiada por ultrassom tem sido utilizada no tratamento de pacientes com úlceras venosas. É um procedimento minimamente invasivo e de fácil execução, porém apresenta taxas de recidiva elevadas.

Objetivos

Relatar a evolução a curto e médio prazo de pacientes com úlcera venosa tratados com escleroterapia com espuma de polidocanol guiada por ultrassom.

Métodos

Foram reavaliados 19 pacientes submetidos ao tratamento de escleroterapia com espuma de polidocanol guiada por ultrassom no período de janeiro de 2013 a dezembro de 2014. Foram analisados tempo de cicatrização da úlcera, melhora de sintomas clínicos, recanalização das veias tratadas, recidiva dos sintomas e da úlcera venosa.

Resultados

Foram analisados 15 pacientes do sexo feminino (78,9%) e quatro do sexo masculino (21,1%). A média geral de idade foi de 53 anos. O tempo de seguimento dos pacientes variou de 448 dias a 1.276 dias (média de 791 dias). O tempo médio de presença das úlceras foi de 53 meses. Na avaliação pós-procedimento, foram observadas recanalização total em 15,7%, recanalização parcial em 21% e oclusão em 47,3% das veias tratadas. Apenas em um caso foi observada recidiva da úlcera. Pela avaliação das médias do Venous Clinical Severity Score (VCSS), houve diferença significativa antes e após o procedimento, com variação entre os grupos de 11,2 (p < 0,01).

Conclusões

A escleroterapia por espuma guiada por ultrassom apresenta altas taxas de sucesso terapêutico, com índices de cicatrização de úlceras venosas elevados.

Clarivein® mechano-chemical ablation an interim analysis of a randomized controlled trial dose-finding study

Objectives

The ClariVein® system is an endovenous technique that uses mechano-chemical ablation to treat incompetent truncal veins. This study was conducted to identify the ideal Polidocanol dosage and form for mechano-chemical ablation in order to occlude the great saphenous vein. When adhering to safe dosage levels, sclerosants with higher concentrations potentially limit the extent of treatment. It has been demonstrated that this problem may be overcome by using Polidocanol as a microfoam. This paper was established on findings of a preliminary analysis.

Material and methods

The initial study was a single-blinded multicenter randomized controlled trial where patients are allocated to three treatment arms. Group 1 consisted of mechano-chemical ablation +2% Polidocanol liquid, group 2: mechano-chemical ablation +3% Polidocanol liquid and group 3: mechano-chemical ablation +1% Polidocanol foam

Results

Eighty-seven, 34 males and 53 females (60.9%), mean age 55 years s.d. 16.0 (range 24–84), were enrolled in the study. Treatment length was 30 cm (range 10–30) for 95.2% of the patients. Mean operating time was 16 minutes (range 5–70). The mean saphenofemoral junction diameter (7.7 mm) was similar in all three groups. At 6 weeks post-treatment duplex ultrasound showed that 25 out of 25 = 100%, 27 out of 28 = 96.4% and 13 out of 23 = 56.5% were occluded in the mechano-chemical ablation + 2% Polidocanol liquid, mechano-chemical ablation + 3% Polidocanol liquid and mechano-chemical ablation + 1% Polidocanol microfoam respectively ( p < 0.001). However, stricter scrutiny showed that the anatomical success rate defined as occlusion of at least 85% of the treated length to be 88.0%, 85.7% and 30.4% respectively ( p < 0.001).

Conclusion

Mechano-chemical ablation using ClariVein® combined with 1% Polidocanol microfoam is significantly less effective and should not be considered as a treatment option of incompetent truncal veins. Further investigation to determine the ideal Polidocanol liquid dosage with mechano-chemical ablation is advocated and is being conducted accordingly.