Mapping the Journey: Family Carers’ Perceptions of Issues Related to End-Stage Care of Individuals with Muscular Dystrophy or Motor Neurone Disease

Progress in medical technology and treatment has resulted in more people with neurodegenerative conditions surviving for longer periods of time. This increased lifespan means that these individuals have a longer period of dependency on others, with a heightened need to maintain quality of life for both the individual and the family. Our paper reports on the findings of a study involving in-depth interviews with 16 carers to determine their perceived needs during the final stage of caring for someone with muscular dystrophy (MD) or motor neurone disease. Results suggest that the palliative care model has much to offer individuals with degenerative neuromuscular conditions and their families, but it is not yet recognized as an important part of care for young people with MD. Three major themes emerged in the analysis: reactions and responses, health system crossing points, reaching forward.

A review of psychosocial aspects of motor neurone disease

Motor neurone disease (MND) is an illness involving the progressive degeneration of upper and lower motor neurones. There is no known cause or cure. The physical aspects of MND frequently receive the majority of attention, with psychosocial aspects accorded secondary importance. We undertook a comprehensive search of the available literature published between 1966 and 2006 on the psychosocial aspects of MND, including quality of life (QoL), depression, social support, life sustaining treatment (LST), coping, spirituality and current practice. The literature identified that QoL correlated more strongly with measures of suffering, social support and hopelessness than with the physical state of the patient. Depression is relatively common (prevalence rates up to 50%), as are other forms of psychological distress in the MND population, and is not associated with illness severity and functional status. Depression strongly correlates with QoL. Social support is often limited for MND patients and this also influences QoL. Hope and hopelessness are important issues for MND patients with hopelessness contributing significantly to suffering and, for some, a desire for hastened death. Choices and decisions about life sustaining treatments pose a burden for patients and carers. Despite the physical and emotional suffering associated with MND, a significant number cope well and find positive meaning in life. Many patients opting for life sustaining treatment report a satisfactory QoL. In conclusion, psychosocial aspects of life are important for patients with MND. Depression and other expressions of distress require recognition and treatment. Issues of hope, spirituality and life and death also require attention in clinical practice. Although guidelines exist to direct physicians to attend to the physical care, there is a distinct lack of guidance to attend to the psychological state of the MND patient.

A Review: carers, MND and service provision

Carers of people with MND may experience changes to their health and lifestyle. Statutory and voluntary organizations are able to support the carer in various ways. This review investigates the personal impact on carers and their experiences of service provision. A systematic search of online and grey literature was made for the period 1994-2004. Thirty-two key texts were retrieved and a narrative synthesis conducted. The main themes were: 1) Impact on carer: general health, emotional state, life satisfaction, socio-economic concerns, relationships, and protective factors; 2) Experience of service provision: primary care, health professionals, social care, written information, and voluntary organizations. There is a paucity of written documentation on the experience of assisting someone with MND. Data collected are diverse and sometimes contradictory. Sample sizes are often small and generalization difficult. Main findings show that maintenance of social support, activities, and a positive outlook may lessen the chance of ill health arising from long hours spent caring, and having a named coordinator may assist with access to resources, and provide practical and emotional support during and after the caring role. Carers may become ill themselves unless adequate support is given to them throughout the course of the disease.

Respect for autonomy: issues in neurological rehabilitation

OBJECTIVE

To examine the ethical principle of respect for autonomy within the context of neurological rehabilitation.

DISCUSSION

The nature of the principle of respect for autonomy is examined, and specific difficulties to which it may give rise in this area of practice are identified. These concern difficulties of communication with neurologically impaired patients, issues of competence related to patient decision-making, problems of consensus between patient and professional, and the role of the patient's family in the rehabilitation process.

CONCLUSION

A number of strategies, based on a client-centred model of practice, are suggested which may counteract these difficulties and assist in respecting the patient's autonomy to the appropriate degree, while seeking to attain high-quality clinical outcomes.

Epidemiology of disabling neurological disease: how and why does disability occur?

Images