Integration of surface electromyographic sensors with the transfemoral amputee socket: a comparison of four differing configurations

Recent trends and challenges of surface electromyography in prosthetic applications

Surface electromyography (sEMG) meets extensive applications in the field of prosthesis in the current period. The effectiveness of sEMG in prosthesis applications has been verified by numerous revolutionary developments and extensive research attempts. A large volume of research and literature works have explored and validated the vast use of these signals in prostheses as an assistive technology. The objective of this paper is to conduct a systematic review and offer a detailed overview of the work record in the prosthesis and myoelectric interfaces framework. This review utilized a systematic search strategy to identify published articles discussing the state-of-the-art applications of sEMG in prostheses (including upper limb prosthesis and lower limb prostheses). Relevant studies were identified using electronic databases such as PubMed, IEEE Explore, SCOPUS, ScienceDirect, Google Scholar and Web of Science. Out of 3791 studies retrieved from the databases, 188 articles were found to be potentially relevant (after screening of abstracts and application of inclusion-exclusion criteria) and included in this review. This review presents an investigative analysis of sEMG-based prosthetic applications to assist the readers in making further advancements in this field. It also discusses the fundamental advantages and disadvantages of using sEMG in prosthetic applications. It also includes some important guidelines to follow in order to improve the performance of sEMG-based prosthesis. The findings of this study support the widespread use of sEMG in prosthetics. It is concluded that sEMG-based prosthesis technology, still in its sprouting phase, requires significant explorations for further development. Supplementary investigations are necessary in the direction of making a seamless mechanism of biomechatronics for sEMG-based prosthesis by cohesive efforts of robotic researchers and biomedical engineers.

Flexible & Stretchable EMG Sensor for Lower Extremity Amputee

EMG signals can be widely used for indicators of muscle activity, and it can be used for robot control. However, the practical use of the EMG sensor for the amputee has been limited due to harsh conditions in the socket where strong pressure and friction exist. In this paper, thus we suggested a flexible and stretchable EMG Sensor. It is designed to withstand the pressure of the socket and to be used repeatedly with soft adhesive material. The performance of mechanical and electrical properties is investigated, and the muscle signals are recorded in static and dynamic (jump and gait) conditions. The selectivity of the recorded muscle signals during dorsiflexion and plantar flexion shows better than that of commercial electrodes indicating that it could be used for control of robotic legs in the future.Clinical Relevance- The flexible material and stretchable electrode pattern could be helpful in clinical research for an amputee.

Performance of Sonomyographic and Electromyographic Sensing for Continuous Estimation of Joint Torque During Ambulation on Multiple Terrains

Advances in powered assistive device technology, including the ability to provide net mechanical power to multiple joints within a single device, have the potential to dramatically improve the mobility and restore independence to their users. However, these devices rely on the ability of their users to continuously control multiple powered lower-limb joints simultaneously. Success of such approaches rely on robust sensing of user intent and accurate mapping to device control parameters. Here, we compare two non-invasive sensing modalities: surface electromyography and sonomyography, (i.e., ultrasound imaging of skeletal muscle), as inputs to Gaussian process regression models trained to estimate hip, knee and ankle joint moments during varying forms of ambulation. Experiments were performed with ten non-disabled individuals instrumented with surface electromyography and sonomyography sensors while completing trials of level, incline (10°) and decline (10°) walking. Results suggest sonomyography of muscles on the anterior and posterior thigh can be used to estimate hip, knee and ankle joint moments more accurately than surface electromyography. Furthermore, these results can be achieved by training Gaussian process regression models in a task-independent manner; i.e., incorporating features of level and ramp walking within the same predictive framework. These findings support the integration of sonomyographic and electromyographic sensing within powered assistive devices to continuously control joint torque.

Design of an open-source transfemoral, bypass socket

The development of control algorithms and prosthetic hardware for lower limb prostheses involves an iterative testing process. Here, we present the design and validation of a bypass socket to enable able-bodied researchers to wear a leg prosthesis for evaluation purposes. The bypass socket can be made using a 3D-printer and standard household tools. It has an open-socket design that allows for electromyography recordings. It was designed for people with a height of 160 - 190 cm and extra caution should be observed with users above 80 kg. The use of a safety harness when wearing a prosthesis with the bypass socket is also recommended for additional safety.Clinical Relevance-This makes the development process of transfemoral prosthetic components more time- and cost-efficient.

Flexible Dry Electrodes for EMG Acquisition within Lower Extremity Prosthetic Sockets

Acquisition of surface electromyography (sEMG) from a person with an amputated lower extremity (LE) during prosthesis-assisted walking remains a significant challenge due to the dynamic nature of the gait cycle. Current solutions to sEMG-based neural control of active LE prostheses involve a combination of customized electrodes, prosthetic sockets, and liners. These technologies are generally: (i) incompatible with a subject's existing prosthetic socket and liners; (ii) uncomfortable to use; and (iii) expensive. This paper presents a flexible dry electrode design for sEMG acquisition within LE prosthetic sockets which seeks to address these issues. Design criteria and corresponding design decisions are explained and a proposed flexible electrode prototype is presented. Performances of the proposed electrode and commercial Ag/AgCl electrodes are compared in seated subjects without amputations. Quantitative analyses suggest comparable signal qualities for the proposed novel electrode and commercial electrodes. The proposed electrode is demonstrated in a subject with a unilateral transtibial amputation wearing her own liner, socket, and the portable sEMG processing platform in a preliminary standing and level ground walking study. Qualitative analyses suggest the feasibility of real-time sEMG data collection from load-bearing, ambulatory subjects.

Acquisition of Surface EMG Using Flexible and Low-Profile Electrodes for Lower Extremity Neuroprosthetic Control

For persons with lower extremity (LE) amputation, acquisition of surface electromyography (sEMG) from within the prosthetic socket remains a significant challenge due to the dynamic loads experienced during the gait cycle. However, these signals are critical for both understanding the clinical effects of LE amputation and determining the desired control trajectories of active LE prostheses. Current solutions for collecting within-socket sEMG are generally (i) incompatible with a subject's prescribed prosthetic socket and liners, (ii) uncomfortable, and (iii) expensive. This study presents an alternative within-socket sEMG acquisition paradigm using a novel flexible and low-profile electrode. First, the practical performance of this Sub-Liner Interface for Prosthetics (SLIP) electrode is compared to that of commercial Ag/AgCl electrodes within a cohort of subjects without amputation. Then, the corresponding SLIP electrode sEMG acquisition paradigm is implemented in a single subject with unilateral transtibial amputation performing unconstrained movements and walking on level ground. Finally, a quantitative questionnaire characterizes subjective comfort for SLIP electrode and commercial Ag/AgCl electrode instrumentation setups. Quantitative analyses suggest comparable signal qualities between SLIP and Ag/AgCl electrodes while qualitative analyses suggest the feasibility of using the SLIP electrode for real-time sEMG data collection from load-bearing, ambulatory subjects with LE amputation.

Myoelectric control of robotic lower limb prostheses: a review of electromyography interfaces, control paradigms, challenges and future directions

Objective.Advanced robotic lower limb prostheses are mainly controlled autonomously. Although the existing control can assist cyclic movements during locomotion of amputee users, the function of these modern devices is still limited due to the lack of neuromuscular control (i.e. control based on human efferent neural signals from the central nervous system to peripheral muscles for movement production). Neuromuscular control signals can be recorded from muscles, called electromyographic (EMG) or myoelectric signals. In fact, using EMG signals for robotic lower limb prostheses control has been an emerging research topic in the field for the past decade to address novel prosthesis functionality and adaptability to different environments and task contexts. The objective of this paper is to review robotic lower limb Prosthesis control via EMG signals recorded from residual muscles in individuals with lower limb amputations.Approach.We performed a literature review on surgical techniques for enhanced EMG interfaces, EMG sensors, decoding algorithms, and control paradigms for robotic lower limb prostheses.Main results.This review highlights the promise of EMG control for enabling new functionalities in robotic lower limb prostheses, as well as the existing challenges, knowledge gaps, and opportunities on this research topic from human motor control and clinical practice perspectives.Significance.This review may guide the future collaborations among researchers in neuromechanics, neural engineering, assistive technologies, and amputee clinics in order to build and translate true bionic lower limbs to individuals with lower limb amputations for improved motor function.

Classification of standing and sitting phases based on in-socket piezoelectric sensors in a transfemoral amputee

A transfemoral prosthesis is required to assist amputees to perform the activity of daily living (ADL). The passive prosthesis has some drawbacks such as utilization of high metabolic energy. In contrast, the active prosthesis consumes less metabolic energy and offers better performance. However, the recent active prosthesis uses surface electromyography as its sensory system which has weak signals with microvolt-level intensity and requires a lot of computation to extract features. This paper focuses on recognizing different phases of sitting and standing of a transfemoral amputee using in-socket piezoelectric-based sensors. 15 piezoelectric film sensors were embedded in the inner socket wall adjacent to the most active regions of the agonist and antagonist knee extensor and flexor muscles, i. e. region with the highest level of muscle contractions of the quadriceps and hamstring. A male transfemoral amputee wore the instrumented socket and was instructed to perform several sitting and standing phases using an armless chair. Data was collected from the 15 embedded sensors and went through signal conditioning circuits. The overlapping analysis window technique was used to segment the data using different window lengths. Fifteen time-domain and frequency-domain features were extracted and new feature sets were obtained based on the feature performance. Eight of the common pattern recognition multiclass classifiers were evaluated and compared. Regression analysis was used to investigate the impact of the number of features and the window lengths on the classifiers’ accuracies, and Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) was used to test significant differences in the classifiers’ performances. The classification accuracy was calculated using k-fold cross-validation method, and 20% of the data set was held out for testing the optimal classifier. The results showed that the feature set (FS-5) consisting of the root mean square (RMS) and the number of peaks (NP) achieved the highest classification accuracy in five classifiers. Support vector machine (SVM) with cubic kernel proved to be the optimal classifier, and it achieved a classification accuracy of 98.33 % using the test data set. Obtaining high classification accuracy using only two time-domain features would significantly reduce the processing time of controlling a prosthesis and eliminate substantial delay. The proposed in-socket sensors used to detect sit-to-stand and stand-to-sit movements could be further integrated with an active knee joint actuation system to produce powered assistance during energy-demanding activities such as sit-to-stand and stair climbing. In future, the system could also be used to accurately predict the intended movement based on their residual limb’s muscle and mechanical behaviour as detected by the in-socket sensory system.

A Comparison of Control Strategies in Commercial and Research Knee Prostheses

GOAL

To provide an overview of control strategies in commercial and research microprocessor-controlled prosthetic knees (MPKs).

METHODS

Five commercially available MPKs described in patents, and five research MPKs reported in scientific literature were compared. Their working principles, intent recognition, and walking controller were analyzed. Speed and slope adaptability of the walking controller was considered as well.

RESULTS

Whereas commercial MPKs are mostly passive, i.e., do not inject energy in the system, and employ heuristic rule-based intent classifiers, research MPKs are all powered and often utilize machine learning algorithms for intention detection. Both commercial and research MPKs rely on finite state machine impedance controllers for walking. Yet while commercial MPKs require a prosthetist to adjust impedance settings, scientific research is focused on reducing the tunable parameter space and developing unified controllers, independent of subject anthropometrics, walking speed, and ground slope.

CONCLUSION

The main challenges in the field of powered, active MPKs (A-MPKs) to boost commercial viability are first to demonstrate the benefit of A-MPKs compared to passive MPKs or mechanical non-microprocessor knees using biomechanical, performance-based and patient-reported metrics. Second, to evaluate control strategies and intent recognition in an uncontrolled environment, preferably outside the laboratory setting. And third, even though research MPKs favor sophisticated algorithms, to maintain the possibility of practical and comprehensible tuning of control parameters, considering optimal control cannot be known a priori.

SIGNIFICANCE

This review identifies main challenges in the development of A-MPKs, which have thus far hindered their broad availability on the market.

Motor unit drive: a neural interface for real-time upper limb prosthetic control

OBJECTIVE

Modern prosthetic limbs have made strident gains in recent years, incorporating terminal electromechanical devices that are capable of mimicking the human hand. However, access to these advanced control capabilities has been prevented by fundamental limitations of amplitude-based myoelectric neural interfaces, which have remained virtually unchanged for over four decades. Consequently, nearly 23% of adults and 32% of children with major traumatic or congenital upper-limb loss abandon regular use of their myoelectric prosthesis. To address this healthcare need, we have developed a noninvasive neural interface technology that maps natural motor unit increments of neural control and force into biomechanically informed signals for improved prosthetic control.

APPROACH

Our technology, referred to as motor unit drive (MU Drive), utilizes real-time machine learning algorithms for directly measuring motor unit firings from surface electromyographic signals recorded from residual muscles of an amputated or congenitally missing limb. The extracted firings are transformed into biomechanically informed signals based on the force generating properties of individual motor units to provide a control source that represents the intended movement.

MAIN RESULTS

We evaluated the characteristics of the MU Drive control signals and compared them to conventional amplitude-based myoelectric signals in healthy subjects as well as subjects with congenital or traumatic trans-radial limb-loss. Our analysis established a vital proof-of-concept: MU Drive provides a more responsive real-time signal with improved smoothness and more faithful replication of intended limb movement that overcomes the trade-off between performance and latency inherent to amplitude-based myoelectric methods.

SIGNIFICANCE

MU Drive is the first neural interface for prosthetic control that provides noninvasive real-time access to the natural motor control mechanisms of the human nervous system. This new neural interface holds promise for improving prosthetic function by achieving advanced control that better reflects the user intent. Beyond the immediate advantages in the field of prosthetics, MU Drive provides an innovative alternative for advancing the control of exoskeletons, assistive devices, and other robotic rehabilitation applications.

Identifying classifier input signals to predict a cross-slope during transtibial amputee walking

Advanced prosthetic foot designs often incorporate mechanisms that adapt to terrain changes in real-time to improve mobility. Early identification of terrain (e.g., cross-slopes) is critical to appropriate adaptation. This study suggests that a simple classifier based on linear discriminant analysis can accurately predict a cross-slope encountered (0°, -15°, 15°) using measurements from the residual limb, primarily from the prosthesis itself. The classifier was trained and tested offline using motion capture and in-pylon sensor data collected during walking trials in mid-swing and early stance. Residual limb kinematics, especially measurements from the foot, shank and ankle, successfully predicted the cross-slope terrain with high accuracy (99%). Although accuracy decreased when predictions were made for test data instead of the training data, the accuracy was still relatively high for one input signal set (>89%) and moderate for three others (>71%). This suggests that classifiers can be designed and generalized to be effective for new conditions and/or subjects. While measurements of shank acceleration and angular velocity from only in-pylon sensors were insufficient to accurately predict the cross-slope terrain, the addition of foot and ankle kinematics from motion capture data allowed accurate terrain prediction. Inversion angular velocity and foot vertical velocity were particularly useful. As in-pylon sensor data and shank kinematics from motion capture appeared interchangeable, combining foot and ankle kinematics from prosthesis-mounted sensors with shank kinematics from in-pylon sensors may provide enough information to accurately predict the terrain.

Turn Intent Detection For Control of a Lower Limb Prosthesis

OBJECTIVE

An adaptable lower limb prosthesis with variable stiffness in the transverse plane requires a control method to effect changes in real time during amputee turning. This study aimed to identify classification algorithms that can accurately predict turning using inertial measurement unit (IMU) signals from the shank with adequate time to enact a change in stiffness during the swing phase of gait when the prosthesis is unloaded.

METHODS

To identify if a turning step is imminent, classification models were developed around activities of daily living including 90° spin turns, 90° step turns, 180° turns, and straight walking using simulated IMU data from the prosthesis shank. Three classifiers were tested: support vector machine (SVM), K nearest neighbors (KNN), and a bagged decision tree ensemble (Ensemble).

RESULTS

Individual training gave superior results over training on a pooled set of users. Coupled with a simple control scheme, the SVM, KNN, and Ensemble classifiers achieved 96%, 93%, and 91% accuracy (no significant difference), respectively, predicting an upcoming turn 400 ± 70 ms prior to the heel strike of the turn. However, classification of straight walking transition steps varied between classifiers at 85%, 82%, 97% (Ensemble significantly different, ), respectively.

CONCLUSION

The Ensemble model produced the best result overall; however, depending on the priority of identifying turning versus transition steps and processor performance, the SVM or KNN might still be considered.

SIGNIFICANCE

This research would be useful to help determine a classifier strategy for any lower limb device seeking to predict turn intent.

A Method for Locomotion Mode Identification Using Muscle Synergies

Active lower limb transfemoral prostheses have enabled amputees to perform different locomotion modes such as walking, stair ascent, stair descent, ramp ascent and ramp descent. To achieve seamless mode transitions, these devices either rely on neural information from the amputee's residual limbs or sensors attached to the prosthesis to identify the intended locomotion modes or both. We present an approach for classification of locomotion modes based on the framework of muscle synergies underlying electromyography signals. Neural information at the critical instances (e.g., heel contact and toe-off) was decoded for this purpose. Non-negative matrix factorization was used to extract the muscles synergies from the muscle feature matrix. The estimation of the neural command was done using non-negative least squares. The muscle synergy approach was compared with linear discriminant analysis (LDA), support vector machine (SVM), and neural network (NN) and was tested on seven able-bodied subjects. There was no significant difference ( p > 0.05 ) in transitional and steady state classification errors during stance phase. The muscle synergy approach performed significantly better ( ) than NN and LDA during swing phase while results were similar to SVM. These results suggest that the muscle synergy approach can be used to discriminate between locomotion modes involving transitions.

Detection of Prosthetic Knee Movement Phases via In-Socket Sensors: A Feasibility Study

This paper presents an approach of identifying prosthetic knee movements through pattern recognition of mechanical responses at the internal socket's wall. A quadrilateral double socket was custom made and instrumented with two force sensing resistors (FSR) attached to specific anterior and posterior sites of the socket's wall. A second setup was established by attaching three piezoelectric sensors at the anterior distal, anterior proximal, and posterior sites. Gait cycle and locomotion movements such as stair ascent and sit to stand were adopted to characterize the validity of the technique. FSR and piezoelectric outputs were measured with reference to the knee angle during each phase. Piezoelectric sensors could identify the movement of midswing and terminal swing, pre-full standing, pull-up at gait, sit to stand, and stair ascent. In contrast, FSR could estimate the gait cycle stance and swing phases and identify the pre-full standing at sit to stand. FSR showed less variation during sit to stand and stair ascent to sensitively represent the different movement states. The study highlighted the capacity of using in-socket sensors for knee movement identification. In addition, it validated the efficacy of the system and warrants further investigation with more amputee subjects and different sockets types.

Piezoelectric bimorphs' characteristics as in-socket sensors for transfemoral amputees

Alternative sensory systems for the development of prosthetic knees are being increasingly highlighted nowadays, due to the rapid advancements in the field of lower limb prosthetics. This study presents the use of piezoelectric bimorphs as in-socket sensors for transfemoral amputees. An Instron machine was used in the calibration procedure and the corresponding output data were further analyzed to determine the static and dynamic characteristics of the piezoelectric bimorph. The piezoelectric bimorph showed appropriate static operating range, repeatability, hysteresis, and frequency response for application in lower prosthesis, with a force range of 0–100 N. To further validate this finding, an experiment was conducted with a single transfemoral amputee subject to measure the stump/socket pressure using the piezoelectric bimorph embedded inside the socket. The results showed that a maximum interface pressure of about 27 kPa occurred at the anterior proximal site compared to the anterior distal and posterior sites, consistent with values published in other studies. This paper highlighted the capacity of piezoelectric bimorphs to perform as in-socket sensors for transfemoral amputees. However, further experiments are recommended to be conducted with different amputees with different socket types.