Individual and Combined Anatomic Risk Factors for the Development of an Anterior Cruciate Ligament Rupture in Men: A Multiple Factor Analysis Case-Control Study

Evaluation of the relationship between non-contact anterior cruciate ligament rupture and eminential morphometry: a cross-sectional and MRI based study

BACKGROUND

The literature does not clearly convey the relationship between eminential morphometry and non-contact anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) ruptures. This study attempts to reveal whether there is a relationship between non-contact ACL ruptures and eminential morphometry.

METHODS

Knee magnetic resonance images (MRIs) taken for the various indications between January 2022 and June 2023 were retrospectively scanned. The patients were categorized into 2 groups: those with an ACL rupture and those with an intact ACL. For each patient, eminential angle 1, eminential angle 2, medial eminential height, lateral eminential height, total eminential height, eminential width, and the ratio of tibial plateau width and eminential width to the tibial plateau width were measured by 2 different orthopedists. Patients whose MRIs were used for measurement were evaluated and grouped according to their age, sex, and injury side.

RESULTS

In total, 400 MRIs of 400 patients were included in the study. While 200 patients had an ACL rupture, 200 had an intact ACL. The total eminential height in the ACL rupture group was measured at 16.1 ± 2.6 mm and 15.5 ± 2.7 mm (p = 0.035) in the ACL intact group. Eminental width in the ACL rupture group was measured at 12.1 ± 1.9 mm and 13.0 ± 2.0 mm in the ACL intact group (p = 0.0001). The tibial plateau width was 75.4 ± 15.7 mm in the ACL rupture group and 73.6 ± 5.8 mm in the ACL intact group (p = 0.002). According to the logistic regression analysis, the p-value for males was 0.0001, and for eminential width, the p-value was 0.0001.

CONCLUSIONS

A significant difference was found between the ACL rupture and the ACL intact groups regarding eminential height, eminential width, and tibial plateau width parameters. Being male and having a low eminential width were identified as independent risk factors for non-contact ACL.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

Not applicable.

Primary Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury: Extrinsic and Intrinsic Risk Factors

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries continue to increase in incidence despite extensive research into prevention strategies. Many extrinsic and intrinsic risk factors for sustaining ACL injuries have been identified and continue to be investigated. Extrinsic risk factors for ACL injury relate to the athlete's environment, such as the shoe-surface interaction, weather conditions, and sport played. Intrinsic risk factors relate to the athlete's sex, hormones, knee anatomy, landing and pivoting biomechanics, and neuromuscular control. Recent research has highlighted the role of the bony morphology of the proximal tibia and distal femur on primary ACL injury risk, as well as the risk for ACL graft failure. Sex differences in bony and ligamentous morphology of the knee, neuromuscular control, and hormonal factors, such as serum relaxin levels and variations within the menstrual cycle, have been correlated with a higher risk of noncontact primary ACL injuries in female athletes compared with male athletes.

Decreased sagittal slope of the medial tibial spine and deep concavity of the lateral tibial spine are risk factors for noncontact anterior cruciate ligament injury

PURPOSE

This study aimed to assess the relationship between the geometric features of tibial eminence and susceptibility to noncontact anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries.

METHODS

Patients with unilateral noncontact knee injuries between 2015 and 2021 were consecutively enroled in this study. Based on knee magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and arthroscopic visualisation, patients were categorised into the case group (ACL rupture) and control group (ACL intact). Using MRI, the geometric features of tibial eminence were characterised by measuring the sagittal slopes, depth of concavity and coronal slopes of the inclined surfaces of the tibial spines. Univariate and multivariate logistic regressions were conducted to explore independent associations between quantified geometric indices of tibial eminence and the risk of noncontact ACL injuries.

RESULTS

This study included 187 cases and 199 controls. A decreased sagittal slope of the medial tibial spine (MTSSS) (combined group: odds ratio [OR]: 0.87 [0.82, 0.92], p < 0.001; females: OR: 0.88 [0.80, 0.98], p = 0.020; males: OR: 0.87 [0.81, 0.93], p < 0.001) and an increased depth of concavity in the lateral tibial spine (LTSD) (combined group: OR: 1.51 [1.24, 1.85], p < 0.001; females: OR: 1.65 [1.12, 2.43], p = 0.012; males: OR: 1.44 [1.11, 1.89], p = 0.007) were independent risk factors for noncontact ACL injuries. Moreover, a steeper coronal slope of the inclined surface of the medial tibial spine was a significant predictor of noncontact ACL injuries for males (MTSCS: OR: 1.04 [1.01, 1.08], p = 0.015) but not for females.

CONCLUSION

Geometric features of tibial eminence, particularly a decreased MTSSS and an increased LTSD, were identified as independent risk factors for noncontact ACL injuries. These findings will help clinicians identify individuals at high risk of ACL injury and facilitate the development of targeted prevention strategies.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III.

The relationship between lateral femoral condyle ratio measured by MRI and anterior cruciate ligament injury

Background

Previous studies have shown that the lateral femoral condyle ratio (LFCR) measured by X-ray has a significant relationship with the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury. However, few relevant studies have been performed on LFCR measured by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).

Purpose

(1) To evaluate the relationship between LFCR measured by MRI and ACL injury or rerupture. (2) To compare the LFCR measured by MRI with existing bony morphological risk factors and screen out the most predictive risk factors for primary ACL injury or rerupture.

Study Design

Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3.

Methods

Totally 147 patients who underwent knee arthroscopic surgery from 2015 to 2019 with minimum follow-up of 48 months were retrospectively evaluated. Patients were placed into three groups: 1) the control group of patients with simple meniscus tears without ligament injury; 2) the primary noncontact ACL injury group; 3) ACL rerupture group (ACL reconstruction failure). The LFCR measured by MRI and other previous known risk factors associated with MRI (notch width index, medial tibial slope, lateral tibial slope, medial tibial depth, lateral tibial height) were performed to evaluate their predictive value for ACL injury and rerupture. All the risk factors with p < 0.01 according to univariate analysis were included in the logistic regression models. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves were analyzed for sensitivity, specificity, cut-off, and area under the curve (AUC). Z tests were used to compare the AUC values.

Results

The LFCR measured by MRI was obviously higher in primary ACL injury group (0.628 ± 0.020) and in ACL rerupture group (0.625 ± 0.021) than that in the control group (0.593 ± 0.030). The best risk factor was the LFCR with a cut-off of 0.602 (AUC, 0.818; 95% CI, 0.748-0.878; sensitivity, 90%; specificity, 66%). When combined with lateral tibial slope (cutoff, 7°) and lateral tibial height (cutoff, 3.6 mm), the diagnostic performance was improved significantly (AUC, 0.896; 95% CI, 0.890-0.950; sensitivity, 87%; specificity, 80%).

Conclusion

The increased LFCR measured by MRI was associated with a significantly higher risk for ACL injury or rerupture. The combination of LFCR, lateral tibial slope and lateral tibial height were the most predictive risk factors. This may help clinicians identify susceptible individuals and allow precision approaches for better prevention, treatment and management of this disease.

Bone morphology features associated with knee kinematics may not be predictive of ACL elongation during high-demand activities

PURPOSE

Bony morphology has been proposed as a potential risk factor for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury. The relationship between bony morphology, knee kinematics, and ACL elongation during high-demand activities remains unclear. The purpose of this study was to determine if bone morphology features that have been associated with ACL injury risk and knee kinematics are also predictive of ACL elongation during fast running and double-legged drop jump.

METHODS

Nineteen healthy athletes performed fast running and double-legged drop jump within a biplane radiography imaging system. Knee kinematics and ACL elongation were measured bilaterally after using a validated registration process to track bone motion in the radiographs and after identifying ACL attachment sites on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Bony morphological features of lateral posterior tibial slope (LPTS), medial tibial plateau (MTP) depth, and lateral femoral condyle anteroposterior width (LCAP)/lateral tibial plateau anteroposterior width (TPAP) were measured on MRI. Relationships between bony morphology and knee kinematics or ACL elongation were identified using multiple linear regression analysis.

RESULTS

No associations between bony morphology and knee kinematics or ACL elongation were observed during fast running. During double-legged drop jump, a greater range of tibiofemoral rotation was associated with a steeper LPTS (β = 0.382, p = 0.012) and a deeper MTP depth (β = 0.331, p = 0.028), and a greater range of anterior tibial translation was associated with a shallower MTP depth (β = - 0.352, p = 0.018) and a larger LCAP/ TPAP (β = 0.441, p = 0.005); however, greater ACL elongation was only associated with a deeper MTP depth (β = 0.456, p = 0.006) at toe-off.

CONCLUSION

These findings indicate that observed relationships between bony morphology and kinematics should not be extrapolated to imply a relationship also exists between those bone morphology features and ACL elongation during high-demand activities. These new findings deepen our understanding of the relationship between bony morphology and ACL elongation during high-demand activities. This knowledge can help identify high-risk patients for whom additional procedures during ACL reconstruction are most appropriate.

Effect of Anterior Tibial Closing Wedge Osteotomy on Coronal Tibial Alignment in Relation to Preoperative Medial Proximal Tibial Angle and Wedge Height

BACKGROUND

The posterior tibial slope has been identified as an anatomic risk factor for anterior cruciate ligament insufficiency and reruptures after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Anterior tibial closing wedge osteotomy for correction of sagittal plane deformities has the potential to cause an unintended change in coronal plane alignment.

PURPOSE

To evaluate the effects of anterior tibial closing wedge osteotomies for correction of posterior tibial slope on coronal plane alignment using an infratuberosity surgical approach and to identify predictive factors for a change in medial proximal tibial angle (MPTA).

STUDY DESIGN

Case series; Level of evidence, 4.

METHODS

This study reports on retrospectively obtained data from radiographic measurements of 38 anterior tibial closing wedge osteotomies. All patients underwent revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction and had undergone ≥1 previous anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. In all patients, an infratuberosity approach was used with angular stable plate fixation. Pre- and postoperative radiographs were examined retrospectively to detect changes in the sagittal and coronal plane alignment (posterior tibial slope and MPTA). A multivariate regression analysis was used to identify predictors for a change in MPTA.

RESULTS

The study group consisted of 14 women and 24 men whose mean ± SD age at the index procedure was 31.6 ± 8.7 years (range, 17-51 years). Posterior tibial slope decreased significantly (by 7.2° ± 2.3°; P < .001) from 14.6° ± 2.0° preoperatively to 7.4° ± 2.1° postoperatively. MPTA decreased significantly by 1.3° ± 1.5° (P = .005) from pre- to postoperative measurement. Mean wedge height was 9.3 ± 1.1 mm. A lower preoperative MPTA (coefficient = 0.32; P = .017; 95% CI, 0.06-0.59) and larger wedge height (coefficient = 0.48; P = .029; 95% CI, 0.05-0.9) were significant predictive factors for a decrease in MPTA.

CONCLUSION

Anterior tibial closing wedge osteotomy for posterior tibial slope reduction resulted in a slight but significant decrease of the MPTA in the coronal plane. These changes were dependent on the preoperative MPTA and the wedge height.

Bone Morphological Characteristics as Risk Factors for Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury: Comparison Between Contact and Noncontact Injury

Background

Altered bone morphologies are considered risk factors for noncontact anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries.

Purpose/Hypothesis

This study aimed to investigate bone morphological characteristics as risk factors for ACL tears in contact injuries and compare these factors with those for noncontact ACL injuries. We hypothesized that altered bone morphologies would also be risk factors for contact ACL injury.

Study Design

Cross-sectional study; Level of evidence, 3.

Methods

Enrolled were patients who underwent primary ACL reconstructions between January 2000 and December 2021 within 6 weeks after injury. Patients in the ACL group were classified according to injury mechanism (contact vs noncontact). During the same period, a control group of patients matched by age, height, and body mass index to the ACL group was selected. The lateral femoral condylar ratio (LFCR), notch width index (NWI), and lateral posterior tibial slope (PTS) were measured. Measured parameters were compared between the control, contact, and noncontact groups using analysis of variance.

Results

There were 86 patients in the control group, 102 patients in the contact ACL group, and 105 patients in the noncontact ACL group. The demographic characteristics of the 3 groups did not differ significantly. The contact group had significantly higher LFCRs and lower NWIs compared with the control group (P < .001 and P = .001, respectively). The noncontact group had significantly higher LFCRs and PTSs and lower NWIs compared with the control group (P = .031; P < .001; and P < .001, respectively). The noncontact group had significantly higher PTSs and lower NWIs compared with the contact group (P = .003 and P =.014, respectively). In the contact group, the LFCR, PTS, and NWI were significant risk factors for ACL tears (odds ratio [OR], 1.25 [P < .001]; OR, 1.16 [P = .008]; and OR, 1.27 [P = .001], respectively), and in the noncontact group, the PTS and NWI were significant risk factors for ACL tears (OR, 1.20 [P < .001]; OR, 1.59 [P < .001], respectively).

Conclusion

Altered bone morphological characteristics of the knee were found to be risk factors for ACL tears in contact injuries as well as noncontact injuries. Altered morphology has a more significant effect in noncontact ACL injuries.

New Considerations in ACL Surgery: When Is Anatomic Reconstruction Not Enough?

➤ Clinicians should be careful to assess for associated injuries including anterolateral complex and medial meniscal ramp lesions or lateral meniscal posterior root tears.➤ Consideration of lateral extra-articular augmentation should be given for patients with >12° of posterior tibial slope.➤ Patients with preoperative knee hyperextension (>5°) or other nonmodifiable risk factors, including high-risk osseous geometry, may benefit from a concomitant anterolateral augmentation procedure to improve rotational stability.➤ Meniscal lesions should be addressed at the time of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with meniscal root or ramp repair.

Anatomic Factors Associated With the Development of an Anterior Cruciate Ligament Rerupture in Men: A Case-Control Study

BACKGROUND

Although several factors are associated with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) rerupture, the effect of anatomic factors associated with ACL rupture on ACL rerupture development has not been evaluated.

PURPOSE

To determine individual anatomic parameters independently associated with ACL rerupture and the diagnostic values of these parameters.

STUDY DESIGN

Case-control study; Level of evidence, 3.

METHODS

A total of 91 male patients with ACL rerupture and 182 age-, sex-, body mass index-, and side dominance-matched patients without rerupture who underwent ACL reconstruction with a 5-year follow-up were included. In all, 35 parameters that were previously defined as risk factors for primary ACL rupture were compared between the 2 groups. Uni- and multivariate logistic regression models were created to evaluate independently associated factors. Receiver operating characteristic curve analysis was performed for independently associated parameters to predict sensitivity, specificity, and cutoff values.

RESULTS

The mean ± standard deviation age of patients at the time of index surgery was 26.5 ± 6.7 years. Notch shape index (P = .014), tibial proximal anteroposterior (AP) distance (TPAPD) (P < .001), lateral femoral condylar AP distance (LCAPD)/TPAPD ratio (P < .001), medial meniscal cartilage bone height (P < .001), and lateral meniscal bone angle (P = .004) were found to be significantly different between the 2 groups. Only the LCAPD/TPAPD ratio (odds ratio, 2.713; 95% CI, 1.998-5.480; P < .001) was found to be independently associated with ACL rerupture development. The LCAPD/TPAPD ratio revealed 78.9% sensitivity and 75.5% specificity (area under the curve, 0.815; 95% CI, 0.760-0.870) for values above 1.52.

CONCLUSION

The LCAPD/TPAPD ratio can be used to distinguish patients who are at risk of developing ACL rerupture from patients who are not. In the clinical practice, findings of this study may help to develop surgical and nonsurgical preventive strategies in ACL rerupture development.