Fasciotomy for exertional anterior compartment syndrome: is lateral compartment release necessary?

Rehabilitation and return to activity criteria after operative management of chronic exertional compartment syndrome of the leg: a systematic review

OBJECTIVES

Endurance athletes with chronic exertional compartment syndrome (CECS) frequently require fasciotomy to return to activity, but there are no existing comprehensive evidence-based rehabilitation guidelines. We aimed to summarize rehabilitation protocols and return to activity criteria after CECS surgery.

METHODS

Through a systematic literature review, we identified 27 articles that explicitly defined physician-imposed restrictions or guidelines for patients to resume athletic activities following CECS surgery.

RESULTS

Common rehabilitation parameters included running restrictions (51.9%), postoperative leg compression (48.1%), immediate postoperative ambulation (44.4%), and early range of motion exercises (37.0%). Most studies (70.4%) reported return to activity timelines, but few (11.1%) utilized subjective criteria for guiding return to activity. No studies utilized objective functional criteria.

CONCLUSIONS

Rehabilitation and return to activity guidelines after CECS surgery remain poorly defined, and further investigation is needed to develop such guidelines that will enable endurance athletes to safely return to activities and minimize recurrence.

Lower Leg Lateral Chronic Exertional Compartment Syndrome: Prospective Surgical Treatment Outcomes for Isolated or Combined Lateral Fasciotomy

BACKGROUND

Chronic exertional compartment syndrome involving the lower leg lateral compartment (lat-CECS) seldom occurs isolated but is usually combined with CECS of the anterior (ant-CECS) or deep posterior compartment (dp-CECS). Patient characteristics in lat-CECS and outcome after surgery are largely unknown. The aim of this prospective case series was to describe patient characteristics and symptoms and to report on outcome following a fasciotomy.

METHODS

All patients diagnosed with lat-CECS based on exertional lateral lower leg symptoms and elevated intracompartmental pressure (ICP) measurements according to the Pedowitz criteria (ICP ≥ 15 mm Hg at rest, and/or ≥30 mm Hg after 1 minute, and/or ≥20 mm Hg 5 minutes after exercise) were eligible for this study. A standard intake questionnaire scoring symptom patterns was completed by all patients. Patients who were operated for lat-CECS were asked to complete a 3-month and 12-month postoperative questionnaire scoring symptoms and surgical outcome. Patients with a history of CECS surgery, recent lower leg trauma, or peripheral neurovascular disease were excluded.

RESULTS

A total of 881 patients with possible lower leg CECS completed an intake questionnaire and 88 (10%) were diagnosed with lat-CECS according to the Pedowitz criteria (isolated lat-CECS n = 10; lat/ant CECS n = 54, lat/ant/dp CECS n = 19, lat/dp CECS n = 5). Severe pain during exercise and moderate tightness during rest were frequently reported. A group of 28 patients (49 legs; isolated lat-CECS n = 2; lat/ant CECS n = 22, lat/ant/dp CECS n = 3, lat/dp CECS n = 1) was analyzed after fasciotomy. Complications were minor (wound infection requiring antibiotics, n = 3; temporary complex regional pain syndrome with spontaneous recovery, n = 1). Superficial peroneal nerve damage was not observed. One year after surgery, 64% rated outcome as excellent or good, whereas 71% had resumed sports activities.

CONCLUSION

One in 10 patients with anterolateral exertional lower leg pain evaluated in a tertiary referral center met diagnostic criteria for lat-CECS. Pain and tightness were present during exertion and were often reported occurring during rest and at night. In this series, we found fasciotomy-either an isolated (lateral) or a multiple (combined with anterior and/or deep posterior) compartment fasciotomy-is safe and beneficial in most patients.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, case series.

Comparison of 2 Fasciotomes for Treatment of Patients With Chronic Exertional Compartment Syndrome of the Anterior Leg

Background:

Chronic exertional compartment syndrome (CECS) of the anterior leg compartment (ant-CECS) is frequently treated with a minimally invasive fasciotomy. Several operative techniques and operative devices exist, but none have been compared in a systematic and randomized manner.

Purpose:

To compare efficacy, safety, and postoperative pain of a novel operative device (FascioMax fasciotome) with a widely accepted device created by Due and Nordstrand (Due fasciotome) during a minimally invasive fasciotomy for ant-CECS.

Study Design:

Randomized controlled trial; Level of evidence, 2.

Methods:

Patients with bilateral isolated ant-CECS between October 2013 and April 2018 underwent a minimally invasive fasciotomy using the FascioMax fasciotome in 1 leg and the Due fasciotome in the contralateral leg in a single operative session. Symptom reduction at 3 to 6 months and >1 year, postoperative pain within the first 2 weeks, peri- and postoperative complications, and ability to regain sports were assessed using diaries, physical examination, and timed questionnaires.

Results:

Included in the study were 50 patients (66% female; median age, 22 years [range, 18-65 years]). No differences between the devices were found in terms of perioperative complications (both had none), minor postoperative complications including hematoma and superficial wound infection (overall complication rate: FascioMax, 8% vs Due, 6%), or reduction of CECS-associated symptoms at rest and during exercise. At long-term follow-up (>1 year), 82% of the patients were able to regain their desired type of sport, and 67% (33/49) were able to exercise at a level that was comparable with or higher than before their CECS-associated symptoms started.

Conclusion:

Both the FascioMax and the Due performed similarly in terms of efficacy, safety, and levels of pain within the first 2 weeks postoperatively.

Registration:

NL4274; Netherlands Trial Register.

Fasciectomy for Recurrent Chronic Exertional Compartment Syndrome of the Anterior Leg

PURPOSE

This study aimed to determine whether a fasciectomy for recurrent chronic exertional compartment syndrome of the anterior leg (ant-CECS) after a minimally invasive fasciotomy is safe and beneficial.

METHODS

Demographics and clinical course of patients undergoing a fasciectomy for ongoing exercise-related leg pain (ERLP) after an earlier minimally invasive fasciotomy for ant-CECS were prospectively obtained using questionnaires. Patient-reported severity and frequency of pain, tightness, weakness, cramping, and paresthesia in rest and during exercise were scored before and after surgery. A successful outcome was defined as a self-reported good or excellent result.

RESULTS

Between January 2013 and March 2019, 24 of the 958 patients evaluated for ERLP were included in the study (15 females; median age, 24 yr; range, 14-37 yr). Intracompartmental pressure values before the minimally invasive fasciotomy and before the fasciectomy were not different. Perioperative findings were fibrotic bands, pseudofascias, or complete fusions of fascial edges. Postoperative superficial wound infections requiring oral antibiotics occurred in four legs. After rehabilitation, the total symptom scores during exercise and resting conditions decreased threefold compared with preoperatively (exercise, 55 ± 5 to 17 ± 3, P < 0.001; rest, 30 ± 4 to 10 ± 2, P < 0.001). All cardinal symptoms decreased significantly, but the largest improvements were reported for pain and tightness. At follow-up (median, 12 months; range, 2-65 months), 79% of patients reported a successful outcome, whereas 75% had returned to physical activity.

CONCLUSION

An anterior fasciectomy with associated treatment of correlated pathologies can be safe and beneficial in patients with ongoing ERLP who previously underwent a minimally invasive fasciotomy for ant-CECS.

Outcome following mini-open lower limb fasciotomy for chronic exertional compartment syndrome

Purpose

The aim of this study was to report outcomes following mini-open lower limb fasciotomy (MLLF) in active adults with chronic exertional compartment syndrome (CECS).

Methods

From 2013–2018, 38 consecutive patients (mean age 31 years [16–60], 71% [n = 27/38] male) underwent MLLF. There were 21 unilateral procedures, 10 simultaneous bilateral and 7 staged bilateral. There were 22 anterior fasciotomies, five posterior and 11 four-compartment. Early complications were determined from medical records of 37/38 patients (97%) at a mean of four months (1–19). Patient-reported outcomes (including EuroQol scores [EQ-5D/EQ-VAS], return to sport and satisfaction) were obtained via postal survey from 27/38 respondents (71%) at a mean of 3.7 years (0.3–6.4).

Results

Complications occurred in 16% (n = 6/37): superficial infection (11%, n = 4/37), deep infection (3%, n = 1/37) and wound dehiscence (3%, n = 1/37). Eight per cent (n = 3/37) required revision fasciotomy for recurrent leg pain. At longer-term follow-up, 30% (n = 8/27) were asymptomatic and another 56% (n = 15/27) reported improved symptoms. The mean pain score improved from 6.1 to 2.5 during normal activity and 9.1 to 4.7 during sport (both p < 0.001). The mean EQ-5D was 0.781 (0.130–1) and EQ-VAS 77 (33–95). Of 25 patients playing sport preoperatively, 64% (n = 16/25) returned, 75% (n = 12/16) reporting improved exercise tolerance. Seventy-four per cent (n = 20/27) were satisfied and 81% (n = 22/27) would recommend the procedure.

Conclusion

MLLF is safe and effective for active adults with CECS. The revision rate is low, and although recurrent symptoms are common most achieve symptomatic improvement, with reduced activity-related leg pain and good health-related quality of life. The majority return to sport and are satisfied with their outcome.

Systematic review of outcome parameters following treatment of chronic exertional compartment syndrome in the lower leg

Objective

Surgery is the gold standard in the management of chronic exertional compartment syndrome (CECS) of the lower extremity, although recent studies also reported success following gait retraining. Outcome parameters are diverse, and reporting is not standardized. The aim of this systematic review was to analyze the current evidence regarding treatment outcome of CECS in the lower leg.

Material and Methods

A literature search and systematic analysis were performed according to the PRISMA criteria. Studies reporting on outcome following treatment of lower leg CECS were included.

Results

A total of 68 reports fulfilled study criteria (n =; 3783; age range 12‐70 year; 7:4 male‐to‐female ratio). Conservative interventions such as gait retraining (n =; 2) and botulinum injection (n =; 1) decreased ICP (x- =; 68 mm Hg tox- =; 32 mm Hg) and resulted in a 47% (±42%) rate of satisfaction and a 50% (±45%) rate of return to physical activity. Fasciotomy significantly decreased ICP (x- =; 76 mm Hg to x- =; 24 mm Hg) and was associated with an 85% (±13%) rate of satisfaction and an 80% (±17%) rate of return to activity. Return to activity was significantly more often achieved (P < .01) in surgically treated patients, except in one study favoring gait retraining in army personnel.

Conclusion

Surgical treatment of CECS in the lower leg results in higher rates of satisfaction and return to activity, compared to conservative treatment. However, the number of studies is limited and the level of evidence is low. Randomized controlled trials with multiple treatment arms and standardized outcome parameters are needed.

Return to sports after chronic anterior exertional compartment syndrome of the leg: Conservative treatment versus surgery

AIM

To evaluate whether surgical treatment for anterior chronic exertional compartment syndrome (CECS) of the lower leg will lead to full athletic activity recovery compared to conservative treatment.

METHODS

Patients diagnosed with anterior CECS of the leg were offered surgical treatment, as surgery considered today to be the mainstay of treatment. Patients unwilling to be treated surgically were treated conservatively. They were followed up, assessing both groups for pain, functional status, and the Tegner sports activity score with comparisons at diagnosis and following treatment.

RESULTS

Forty-three patients were treated for CECS (31; 72.1% with surgery and 12; 27.9% conservatively) with a mean follow-up of 28.15 (4.16-54.09) months. Reported pain improved at follow-up by 1.59 (0-6) points and by 4.27 ± (0-10) points in the conservatively and the surgically treated patient groups, respectively ( p = 0.014) with a mean change in the Tegner score of 0.09 (-5 to 5) and 3.22 (-4 to 7), respectively ( p = 0.009). Three patients in the conservatively treated group (25% of 12) and 24 patients in the operated group (77.4% of 31) reported full resumption of their pre-diagnosis activity level ( p = 0.001).

CONCLUSION

This study supports surgery as the treatment of choice for anterior CECS of the leg with differential benefit for fasciotomy in terms of pain and return to pre-diagnosis athletic activity.

[Chronic exertional compartment syndrome as a cause of anterolateral leg pain-German version]

Exercise-induced leg pain (ELP) and tightness may be caused by a chronic exertional compartment syndrome (CECS). Although CECS can develop in any muscle compartment, most individuals suffer from an anterior tibial muscle CECS (ant-CECS). Typically, a patient with ant-CECS experiences discomfort toward the end of sports activity or in the hours thereafter. Physical examination may reveal tenderness upon palpation of the anterior tibial muscle belly. The gold standard diagnostic tool is a dynamic intracompartmental pressure (ICP) measurement demonstrating elevated muscle tissue pressures. Duplex analysis and imaging may be indicated for exclusion of concomitant entities such as entrapment of the popliteal artery or nerves. Conservative treatments including modification of the patient's running technique can be successful. A fasciotomy must be considered in recalcitrant cases. Residual or recurrent disease may necessitate partial removal of the fascia. The aim of this overview is to discuss the management of CECS in the anterolateral portion of the leg.

Superficial Peroneal Nerve Injury Risk During a Semiblind Fasciotomy for Anterior Chronic Exertional Compartment Syndrome of the Leg: An Anatomical and Clinical Study

BACKGROUND:

Up to 8% of patients who underwent a fasciotomy for leg anterior chronic exertional compartment syndrome (ant-CECS) report sensory deficits suggestive of iatrogenic superficial peroneal nerve (SPN) injury. In the current study we aimed to thoroughly assess the risk of SPN injury during a semiblind fasciotomy of the anterior compartment using 2 separate approaches.

METHODS:

A modified semiblind fasciotomy of the anterior compartment was performed via a longitudinal 2-cm skin incision 2 cm lateral of the anterior tibial crest halfway along the line fibular head-lateral malleolus both in cadaver legs and in patients with ant-CECS. In the cadaver legs, the skin was removed after the procedure and possible SPN injuries and spatial relationships between the SPN and the opened fascia were studied. Between January 2013 and December 2016, 64 ant-CECS patients who underwent a fasciotomy of the anterior compartment were prospectively followed. Iatrogenic SPN injuries were assessed using questionnaires and physical examinations.

RESULTS:

Macroscopic SPN nerve injury was not observed in any of the 9 cadaver legs. In 8 specimens, the SPN was located at least 5 mm posterolateral to the opened fascia. In 1 specimen, an undamaged SPN branch crossed the operative field in a ventral plane. De novo sensory deficits suggestive for iatrogenic SPN injury were not observed in any of the 64 patients (120 legs; 36 females; median age, 22 years) who underwent a fasciotomy of the anterior compartment.

CONCLUSION:

The proposed semiblind fasciotomy for treatment of ant-CECS was not associated with SPN injury in either the cadaveric study or our clinical series.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE:

Level IV, case series.

Functional Outcomes After the Surgical Management of Isolated Anterolateral Leg Chronic Exertional Compartment Syndrome

Background:

Failure rates of up to 20% have been reported after fasciotomy for chronic exertional compartment syndrome (CECS). There is some evidence that postoperative failure and complication rates are higher in the posterior compartments of the lower leg than the anterolateral compartments. Isolated compartment surgery may put patients at risk of requiring revision surgery because of the risk of developing posterior compartment disease.

Hypothesis:

Isolated anterolateral fasciotomy for CECS, in the absence of posterior compartment symptoms, produces satisfactory functional outcomes.

Study Design:

Case series; Level of evidence, 4.

Methods:

Between 2006 and 2012, patients who had positive intracompartment pressure-testing findings and who underwent isolated anterolateral fasciotomy release for CECS were given a self-administered questionnaire. The minimum follow-up was 3 years. The questionnaire addressed time to return to sport and ongoing symptoms. A visual analog scale was used to assess pain during exercise before and after surgery (score: 0, no pain; 10, worst pain imaginable); overall satisfaction with the procedure was assessed as well. Of 31 eligible patients, 20 patients (36 legs operated on) were assessed.

Results:

Postoperatively, 90% of participants returned to the same or higher level of sport. The mean pain score during exercise before surgery was 8.17, whereas it was 1.74 after surgery. The overall mean patient satisfaction score was 8.64. Only 1 leg (2.8%) went on to develop posterior compartment syndrome.

Conclusion:

Isolated anterolateral fasciotomy for CECS produced excellent functional outcomes. Our rate of recurrence was low compared with those found in the literature, and 90% of participants returned to their same or higher level of sport postoperatively.

Surgical Management for Chronic Exertional Compartment Syndrome of the Leg: A Systematic Review of the Literature

PURPOSE

To review published literature to characterize the at-risk demographic, operative indications, surgical techniques, functional outcomes, and reoperation and complication rates after operative management of chronic exertional compartment syndrome (CECS) of the lower leg.

METHODS

We searched PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Database, and CINAHL (Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature) through February 1, 2015, using the terms "chronic exertional" and/or "exercise induced compartment syndrome." The inclusion criteria were studies of Level I to IV evidence in English, published in 1970 or later, involving human subjects, reporting clinical outcomes of operative management of CECS of the lower leg, including at least 5 patients, and having follow-up of at least 80% and 6 months.

RESULTS

Among the 204 original articles, 24 primary studies with 1,596 patients met the inclusion criteria. The mean age was 26.6 years (standard deviation, 8.9 years), and the majority of patients were male patients (70%). The total study population mostly comprised military service members (54%) and athletes (29%). Of the athletes, 83% were recreational; 9% were college level; and 8% were either national, international, or professional. The most commonly involved compartment was the anterior compartment (51%; 95% confidence interval [CI], 48.6% to 52.3%), followed by lateral (33%; 95% CI, 31.4% to 34.9%), deep posterior (13%), and superficial posterior (3%). The cumulative posterior involvement rate was 16% (95% CI, 15.1% to 17.8%). Mean follow-up was 48.8 months (standard deviation, 22.1 months; 95% CI, 47.1 to 50.5 months). Six percent underwent revision surgery. The overall complication rate was 13% (due to postoperative neurologic dysfunction, infection, and so on).

CONCLUSIONS

Primary operative management of lower-extremity CECS was successful in approximately two-thirds of all young athletic patients, and 84% were satisfied with their surgical outcomes at short- to mid-term follow-up. Open fasciotomy remains the predominant surgical technique, although its comparative efficacy relative to newer endoscopic or other minimally invasive techniques is not currently known. These data may be used to guide the orthopaedic community on accurate preoperative counseling and benchmark patient outcomes for future quality-improvement initiatives.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, systematic review (studies ranging from Level I to Level IV).

Posterior Tibial Arterial System Deficiency Mimicking Chronic Exertional Compartment Syndrome: A Case Report

CASE

A 15-year-old female competitive high school basketball player presented as an outpatient with a 3-month history of bilateral exertional calf pain. Patient history and compartment pressure measurements were consistent with the diagnosis of chronic exertional compartment syndrome, and the patient underwent bilateral fasciotomies. Postoperatively, her symptoms recurred and she was found to have a deficient posterior tibial arterial system bilaterally, as confirmed on advanced imaging.

CONCLUSION

We advocate the careful consideration of vascular etiologies in athletes who present with exertional leg pain.

Acute Compartment Syndrome of the Lower Leg: Changing Concepts

The acute limb compartment syndrome is caused by bleeding or edema in a closed muscle compartment surrounded by fascia and bone, leading to muscle and nerve ischemia. The value offasciotomy has been demonstrated in the management of acute compartment syndrome, but ifperformed after a delay of8 to 10 hours, it can prove to be a double-edged weapon, as necrotic muscle would get exposed leading to muscle infections and massive bleeding.

Feasibility and Safety of an Operative Tool for Anterior Chronic Exertional Compartment Syndrome Treatment

BACKGROUND

Operative management of chronic exertional compartment syndrome of the tibialis anterior muscle compartment (ant-CECS) usually involves the use of a fasciotome. Collateral tissue damage such as hematoma and nerve damage may occur during the procedure. The current report assessed the feasibility and safety of an alternative tool for the operative management of ant-CECS.

METHODS

The system had a speculum-like hollow tube that was inserted via a 2-cm skin incision and allowed for the protected advancement of a fasciotome. The device was tested in patients with bilateral ant-CECS. Symptoms were prospectively scored before and after surgery using a 5-category verbal rating scale (VRS). Fourteen patients (age 26 ± 10 years) were analyzed. Complications and operative efficacy were determined using physical examination and questionnaires after 21 (range = 16-25) months.

RESULTS

Technical operative success rate was 100% (28/28 legs). Operation time was 10 ± 2 minutes per leg (range = 6-14). Perioperative complications were not observed. One superficial wound infection was treated nonoperatively. Significant reductions in pain (-2.2 ± 1.1 on 5-point VRS, P < .001), tightness (-1.9 ± 1.6, P = .01), cramps (-1.4 ± 1.6, P = .009), muscle weakness (-1.6 ± 1.2, P < .001), and altered sensibility (-1.3 ± 1.4, P = .005) were registered 21 months postoperatively.

CONCLUSION

This fasciotome was simple to use and allowed for a safe fasciotomy in patients with leg ant-CECS. A randomized controlled trial comparing the present device with a widely used fasciotome was under way at the time of writing of this study.

Intramuscular pressure before and after botulinum toxin in chronic exertional compartment syndrome of the leg: a preliminary study

BACKGROUND

Botulinum toxin A (BoNT-A) is used in the treatment of muscle hypertrophy but has never been used in chronic exertional compartment syndrome (CECS). The objective diagnostic criterion in this condition is an abnormally elevated intramuscular pressure (IMP) in the compartment. In this study, the IMP was measured 1 minute (P1) and 5 minutes (P5) after the exercise was stopped before and after BoNT-A injection.

HYPOTHESIS

Botulinum toxin A reduces the IMP (P1 and P5) and eliminates the pain associated with CECS.

STUDY DESIGN

Case series; Level of evidence, 4.

METHODS

Botulinum toxin A was injected into the muscles of moderately trained patients with an anterior or anterolateral exertional compartment syndrome of the leg. The BoNT-A dose (mean ± SD) ranged from 76 ± 7 to 108 ± 10 U per muscle, depending on which of the 5 muscles in the 2 compartments were injected. The primary end point was IMP (P1, P5). Secondary end points were exertional pain, muscle strength, and safety. Follow-up was conducted up to 9 months.

RESULTS

A total of 25 anterior compartments and 17 lateral compartments were injected in 16 patients. The time interval (mean ± SD) between the BoNT-A injection and after BoNT-A injection IMP measurement was 4.4 ± 1.6 months (range, 3-9 months). In the anterior compartment, P1 and P5 fell by 63% ± 17% (P < .00001) and 59% ± 24% (P < .0001), respectively; in the lateral compartment, P1 and P5 fell by 68% ± 21% (P < .001) and 63% ± 21% (P < .01), respectively. Exertional pain and muscle strength were monitored, based on the Medical Research Council score. The exertional pain was completely eliminated in 15 patients (94%). In 5 patients (31%), the strength of the injected muscles remained normal. In 11 patients (69%), strength decreased from 4.5 (out of 5) to 3.5 (P < .01), although without functional consequences. In the conditions of this study, BoNT-A showed a good safety profile in patients with CECS.

CONCLUSION

In this case series, BoNT-A reduced the IMP and eliminated exertional pain in anterior or anterolateral CECS of the leg for up to 9 months after the intervention. The mode of action of BoNT-A is still unclear. A randomized controlled study should be carried out to determine whether BoNT-A can be used as a medical alternative to surgical treatment.

Functional outcomes and patient satisfaction after fasciotomy for chronic exertional compartment syndrome

BACKGROUND

Patients with chronic exertional compartment syndrome who have failed nonoperative treatment are evaluated with pre-exertion and postexertion compartment pressure testing and may be treated with fasciotomy. Failure rates of up to 20% have been reported and may be related to factors such as age, sex, postexertion compartment pressures, compartment(s) released, and duration of symptoms.

HYPOTHESIS

Higher preoperative postexertion compartment pressures are correlated with higher success and patient satisfaction rates after fasciotomy.

STUDY DESIGN

Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3.

METHODS

From 1999 to 2008, patients with clinical symptoms of chronic exertional compartment syndrome with failed nonoperative management underwent standardized pre-exertion and postexertion compartment pressure measurements. Patients were then offered continued nonoperative treatment or referral to an orthopaedic surgeon for compartment release. Patients with a minimum 2-year follow-up were given a telephone questionnaire describing their pretreatment and posttreatment conditions including quality and duration of symptoms, analog pain scale, symptomatic and functional responses to treatment, and satisfaction with treatment. Medical records and operative reports were reviewed.

RESULTS

The mean follow-up period for the nonoperative treatment group (n = 27) was 5.6 years (range, 2.1-10.6) and for the operative group (n = 73) was 5.2 years (range, 2.0-11.3). The operative group had a higher success rate (81%) compared with the nonoperative group (41%) (P < .001), and the operative group had a higher patient satisfaction rate (81%) compared with the nonoperative group (56%) (P = .011). There was no significant correlation between compartment pressures and patient outcomes. Patients with combined anterior and lateral compartment releases had an increased failure rate compared with isolated anterior release (31% vs. 0%, respectively; P = .035). Surgical patients who were post-college had a lower satisfaction rate (66%) compared with high school (89%) and college patients (94%) (P = .017).

CONCLUSION

High school and college patients (age <23 years) and isolated anterior compartment release (compared with anterior/lateral release) were factors associated with improved subjective function and satisfaction after fasciotomy. We recommend the avoidance of lateral release unless symptoms or postexertion compartment pressures are clearly indicative of lateral compartment involvement.

Forefoot running improves pain and disability associated with chronic exertional compartment syndrome

BACKGROUND

Anterior compartment pressures of the leg as well as kinematic and kinetic measures are significantly influenced by running technique. It is unknown whether adopting a forefoot strike technique will decrease the pain and disability associated with chronic exertional compartment syndrome (CECS) in hindfoot strike runners.

HYPOTHESIS

For people who have CECS, adopting a forefoot strike running technique will lead to decreased pain and disability associated with this condition.

STUDY DESIGN

Case series; Level of evidence, 4.

METHODS

Ten patients with CECS indicated for surgical release were prospectively enrolled. Resting and postrunning compartment pressures, kinematic and kinetic measurements, and self-report questionnaires were taken for all patients at baseline and after 6 weeks of a forefoot strike running intervention. Run distance and reported pain levels were recorded. A 15-point global rating of change (GROC) scale was used to measure perceived change after the intervention.

RESULTS

After 6 weeks of forefoot run training, mean postrun anterior compartment pressures significantly decreased from 78.4 ± 32.0 mm Hg to 38.4 ± 11.5 mm Hg. Vertical ground-reaction force and impulse values were significantly reduced. Running distance significantly increased from 1.4 ± 0.6 km before intervention to 4.8 ± 0.5 km 6 weeks after intervention, while reported pain while running significantly decreased. The Single Assessment Numeric Evaluation (SANE) significantly increased from 49.9 ± 21.4 to 90.4 ± 10.3, and the Lower Leg Outcome Survey (LLOS) significantly increased from 67.3 ± 13.7 to 91.5 ± 8.5. The GROC scores at 6 weeks after intervention were between 5 and 7 for all patients. One year after the intervention, the SANE and LLOS scores were greater than reported during the 6-week follow-up. Two-mile run times were also significantly faster than preintervention values. No patient required surgery.

CONCLUSION

In 10 consecutive patients with CECS, a 6-week forefoot strike running intervention led to decreased postrunning lower leg intracompartmental pressures. Pain and disability typically associated with CECS were greatly reduced for up to 1 year after intervention. Surgical intervention was avoided for all patients.

[Chronic compartmental syndrome. a review of 234 patients]

OBJECTIVE

Diagnosis of chronic compartment syndrome of the lower leg, which occurs in a young and athletic population, is often delayed. We studied postoperative outcomes after fasciotomy in patients with compartment syndrome in order to identify specific postoperative complications. Long-term functional outcomes were also evaluated.

METHODS

All patients with a diagnosis of chronic exercise-related compartment syndrome of the lower leg who underwent surgery from January 1985 to August 2009 were studied prospectively. The type of compartment and whether surgery was uni or bilateral was recorded. One year after surgery, patients completed a questionnaire to evaluate their functional outcome.

RESULTS

Two hundred and thirty-six compartment procedures were performed in 234 patients. Only one compartment (constantly the superficial posterior compartment) was treated in 56/236 (23.7%) procedures. Two compartments (anterior and lateral) were involved in 90/236 procedures (38.1%). Three compartments (anterolateral and superficial posterior) were noted in 74/236 procedures (31.4%) and four compartments (anterolateral and superficial and deep posterior) were described in 6.8%. Involvement of the deep posterior compartment was always associated with another compartment. Surgery was bilateral in 70% of patients. The questionnaire response rate was 65%. The success rate of fasciotomy was 68.4% and a significant improvement was reported by 23.9% of responders; outcome was unsatisfactory for 7.7%.

CONCLUSIONS

The diagnostic criteria used to confirm chronic exercise-related compartment syndrome of the lower leg were based on the compartment pressure measurement after exercise. In this study, all patients underwent fasciotomy. The surgical technique was standardized. Outcomes have been satisfactory with few surgical complications.

Chronic exertional compartment syndrome of the leg in athletes: evaluation and management

Chronic exertional compartment syndrome (CECS) is a well-known cause of activity-related lower leg pain in both athletes and nonathletes. In contrast to acute compartment syndrome, CECS is generally not related to trauma, and is often suspected in the outpatient setting by primary care physicians, podiatrists, sports medicine clinicians, and orthopedic surgeons. The diagnosis of CECS is often overlooked because patients avoid or withdraw from exacerbating physical activities instead of seeking treatment for their symptoms from a health care professional. A thorough history and physical examination of an individual with activity-related lower leg pain is necessary for correct diagnosis to occur. Appropriate diagnostic testing with measurement of intracompartmental pressures reliably confirms the diagnosis of CECS. Nonoperative treatments of CECS rarely leads to complete resolution of symptoms or an individual's ability to return to previous levels of recreational or athletic activity. Fasciotomy of the involved compartments can reliably lead to resolution of pain and the ability to return to previous activities within 6 weeks.

Changes in plantar pressure distribution after Achilles tendon augmentation with flexor hallucis longus transfer

BACKGROUND

Augmentation of the Achilles tendon with flexor hallucis longus is an established method to treat neglected ruptures and severe cases of chronic tendinopathy. After transfer of the muscle/tendon, good pain reduction and improved plantar flexion have been reported. To date, only one study has investigated the effect of FHL transfer on forefoot biomechanics. Theoretically, there should be a partial transfer of forefoot loading towards the lateral metatarsal heads during push-off, resulting in an asymmetric gait.

METHODS

13 patients were examined clinically and using pedobarography with a mean follow-up of 46 months (minimum 24) after Achilles tendon augmentation with flexor hallucis longus. Parameters of the forefoot were investigated to detect differences in pressure and force distribution, load transfer to other areas of the forefoot, and asymmetries compared to the non-operated leg. The results are discussed with regard to clinical relevance.

FINDINGS

Clinically, there were no subjective or objective gait asymmetries. All patients were free of pain and without restrictions during normal walking. In general, pedobarography showed an unloading of the first toe with a load transfer to the metatarsal heads on the operated side. All results featured high inter-subject and within-subject variability.

INTERPRETATION

Due to the high within-subject variability, there is inconsistency within the results making interpretation difficult. However, the results confirm the hypothesis that unloading of the first toe during push-off and an asymmetrical loading pattern can be measured after harvesting of the flexor hallucis longus. The clinical situation of the patients did not reflect a visible amount of gait asymmetry. Differences in loading patterns 2 years after flexor hallucis longus transfer for Achilles tendon augmentation appear to be well compensated.

Endoscopically assisted release for exertional compartment syndromes of the lower leg

BACKGROUND

Endoscopic treatment of intractable chronic anterior and lateral exertional compartment syndromes of the lower leg in athletes is reported anecdotically only in six patients.

HYPOTHESIS

H(0) = There is no difference between preoperative and postoperative status after endoscopic release of chronic exertional compartment syndromes of the lower leg.

STUDY DESIGN

Case series; level of evidence, 4.

METHODS

We developed a minimally invasive, endoscopically assisted technique for release of chronic exertional compartment syndromes of the lower leg. All patients were investigated by telephone interview 47 months (range 5 months-7 years) after surgery.

RESULTS

This investigation comprises release of 19 deep posterior, 16 anterior, and 3 lateral compartments in 17 athletes. No complications were seen following endoscopic anterior and lateral compartment decompression, while two patients following deep posterior compartment release underwent open revision surgery due to hemorrhage. Initial endoscopic surgery in these two patients was performed under tourniquet. There were no postoperative complications due to vascular injuries in all further patients who were operated without tourniquet. Ten patients returned to previous sport activity. At follow-up, results were good or excellent in 10 out of 17 patients. Visual analogue pain scale ranged from 5 to 9 (mean 7.4) before surgery and from 1 to 8 (mean 2.4) at follow up (P = 0.0005).

CONCLUSIONS

This study confirms feasibility of endoscopic release for chronic exertional compartment syndromes of the lower leg on a larger scale. At least for the deep posterior compartment its safety and effectiveness cannot be recommended without stint as results are inferior as compared to data obtained from literature for open surgery. To avoid vascular complications, especially during deep posterior compartment fasciotomy it is most important to perform the procedure without tourniquet.

Acute limb compartment syndrome: a review

Acute limb compartment syndrome (LCS) is a limb-threatening and occasionally life-threatening condition caused by bleeding or edema in a closed muscle compartment surrounded by fascia and bone, which leads to muscle and nerve ischemia. Well-known causative factors are acute trauma and reperfusion after treatment for acute arterial obstruction. Untreated compartment syndrome usually leads to muscle necrosis, limb amputation, and, if severe, in large compartments, renal failure and death. Alertness, clinical suspicion of the possibility of LCS, and occasionally intracompartmental pressure (ICP) measurement are required to avoid a delay in diagnosis or missed diagnosis. Open fasciotomy, by incising both skin and fascia, is the most reliable method for adequate compartment decompression. The techniques of measuring ICP have advantages and disadvantages, whereas the pressure level that mandates fasciotomy is controversial. Increased awareness of the syndrome and the advent of measurements of ICP pressure have raised the possibility of early diagnosis and treatment. This review reports LCS, including etiology, pathophysiology, diagnosis, ICP measurement, management, and outcome.

Bilateral simultaneous fasciotomy for chronic exertional compartment syndrome

BACKGROUND

Chronic exertional compartment syndrome (CECS) occurs bilaterally in approximately 60% of patients. Fasciotomy is the primary corrective treatment. We hypothesized that bilateral fasciotomy can be done during the same operative procedure with early return to sports and low complication rates

METHOD

Sixteen patients had simultaneous bilateral lower extremity fasciotomies for CECS confirmed by compartment pressure testing before and after exercise. Ten patients had concomitant superficial peroneal neurolysis for associated numbness. All patients who were athletes (six runners; nine ball sports) (average age 25 years) had sports related pain limiting participation.

RESULTS

Patients were followed for an average of 16.4 (range 6 to 48) months. Full return to sports participation occurred at an average of 10.7 weeks. Three patients continued to have mild, but much improved, pain with active sports participation, while 13 were pain free. All 11 patients with exertional related numbness had resolution after operative release. All patients were satisfied and all patients stated that they would have simultaneous fasciotomies again if required. As a nonmatched comparison, three patients who had staged fasciotomies for bilateral CECS were also evaluated, but because of the small number no statistical comparison was made. All three also returned to their previous levels of sports participation, however, at an average of 22.7 months as compared to 10.7 weeks in patients with simultaneous bilateral releases.

CONCLUSION

Bilateral simultaneous fasciotomies for CECS can be done safely and effectively with early return to sports participation and low complication rates.

Revision surgery for exertional anterior compartment syndrome of the lower leg: technique, findings, and results

BACKGROUND

Recurrent symptoms or failure after fasciotomy for exertional anterior compartment syndrome is not uncommon.

HYPOTHESIS

Symptoms from high compartment pressures can be secondary to involvement of the entire compartment or to localized constrictions from postsurgical fibrosis, as well as to entrapment of the superficial peroneal nerve.

STUDY DESIGN

Case series; Level of evidence, 4.

METHODS

Eighteen patients who underwent revision surgery for exertional anterior compartment syndrome were available for follow-up. All were athletes who had either a failure or a recurrence of symptoms at a mean of 23.5 months (range, 8-54 months) after the index fasciotomy. Pressure measurements using a slit catheter at rest, at 1 minute postexercise, and at 5 minutes postexercise were performed in 2 places within the compartment: in the area of the previous incision and in the proximal muscle belly of the tibialis anterior. Surgical technique consisted of a 2-incision approach with partial fasciectomy, exploration and decompression of the superficial peroneal nerve, and excision of all fibrotic tissue. An objective examination and a comprehensive subjective questionnaire previously described were performed at a mean follow-up of 42 months (range, 22-67 months).

RESULTS

Sixty percent of patients had abnormal pressures only in a localized area, whereas 40% had high pressures throughout the compartment. Eight of 18 (44%) patients had symptoms, signs, and surgical findings of entrapment of the superficial peroneal nerve. At follow-up, 72% of patients had a satisfactory outcome (5 excellent, 8 good), and 28% had an unsatisfactory outcome for intense running sports (4 fair, 1 poor), although 3 patients with the fair results reported improvement with low-level activity. All 8 patients with documented peroneal nerve entrapment had a satisfactory outcome.

CONCLUSION

Symptoms from high pressures can be secondary to involvement of the entire compartment or localized to a certain area from postsurgical fibrosis. Pressure measurements should be performed in at least 2 separate areas.

Le syndrome de loge d'effort

OBJECTIVES

To review the literature on chronic exertional compartment syndrome.

METHODS

We searched the Medline database with use of the keys words compartment syndrome, exertional, chronic, pressure, and fasciotomy.

RESULTS

Exertional compartment syndrome is characterized by pain on exertion, which recedes at rest, and by excessive increase in compartment intramuscular pressure. Intramuscular pressure measurement is the reference diagnostic tool, but it has not been standardized or evaluated. Pressure observed during the first 5 min after exertion stops is more often used in diagnosis. The first studies of noninvasive investigations (magnetic resonance imaging, thallium single-photon emission tomographic imaging, near infrared spectroscopy) revealed their inadequate diagnostic value. The pathophysiological features of exertional compartment syndrome remain unclear: increased muscle bulk, fascia thickness and stiffness, stimulation of fascial sensory stretch-receptors, poor venous return, micromuscular injuries, and small clinical myopathic abnormalities. Treatment includes decreased sport activity or fasciotomy with partial fasciectomy. Several authors have used endoscopically assisted fasciotomy, which retrospective studies have shown to be successful. Long-term outcome studies could investigate the persistence of exertional minor pain and recurrence of the compartment syndrome with this treatment.

CONCLUSION

Further studies are required to understand the physiopathology, standardize the intramuscular pressure test and evaluate the pressure threshold values, evaluate noninvasive investigations and specify the long-term outcome of fasciotomy.

Overuse injuries: tendinopathies, stress fractures, compartment syndrome, and shin splints

Approximately 50% of all sports injuries are secondary to overuse and result from repetitive microtrauma that causes local tissue damage. Injuries are most likely with changes in mode, intensity, or duration of training and can accumulate before symptoms appear. Intrinsic factors contributing to injuries are individual bio-mechanical abnormalities such as malalignments, muscle imbalance, inflexibility, weakness, and instability. Contributing extrinsic (avoidable) factors include poor technique, improper equipment, and improper changes in duration or frequency of activity. Injuries are often related to biomechanical abnormalities removed from the specific injury site, requiring evaluation of the entire kinetic chain. This article discusses common overuse injuries of the lower leg, ankle, and foot: tendinopathies, stress fractures, chronic exertional compartment syndrome, and shin splints.

Diagnosis and management of chronic compartment syndrome

BACKGROUND

This article describes the diagnosis and management of chronic compartment syndrome and functional popliteal entrapment syndrome, unusual causes for claudication in young adults.

METHODS

A total of 276 patients (<50 years old) with isolated muscle cramping, swelling, and plantar paresthesia were routinely evaluated with compartment pressures (normal < 15 mm Hg), stress plethysmography, and selectively evaluated with pulse volume recordings and arteriography.

RESULTS

Patients were young (mean 28.4 years) with long-standing symptoms (mean 24 months), affecting 1 or both lower extremities (32% vs 68%, respectively). Of the patients, 84 were male (30%) and 192 were female (70%). Common symptoms were isolated muscle cramping (100%) or swelling (40%), and plantar paresthesia (20%). Of 436 treated compartments, 316 were anterolateral, 70 deep-posterior, and 50 superficial-posterior. Mean compartment pressure was 28 mm Hg. Resting pulse volume recordings were abnormal in 6 patients (2.5%); 82 had positive popliteal entrapment tests (30%), but symptoms were present in only 21 (9.7%). Open fasciectomy was performed in all patients with chronic compartment syndrome or functional entrapment. Local anesthesia was used in 243 (88%) and general in 33 patients (12%). Mean follow-up was 60 months. Of the 276 patients, 92% had full relief of symptoms and returned to normal daily or athletic activity. Eight percent obtained symptomatic relief, but activity was limited because of new compartment symptoms or other orthopedic injury.

CONCLUSIONS

Open fasciectomy for chronic compartment and functional entrapment syndromes is effective therapy.

Analysis of pre- and postexercise compartment pressures in the medial compartment of the foot

Growing awareness of chronic exertional compartment syndrome of the foot has led to the need for site-specific analysis of normative resting and postexertional intracompartment pressures. Thirty-four asymptomatic athletes underwent pressure testing of the medial foot compartment with an intracompartmental pressure measurement apparatus. Pressure measurements were recorded before exercise and after 20 minutes of running. Mean resting intracompartment pressure was 7.7 mm Hg, whereas mean pressures 1 and 5 minutes after exercise were 19.1 mm Hg and 10.7 mm Hg, respectively. These data were then compared with data from compartment pressure studies performed in nine symptomatic subjects, each with a clinical history suggestive of chronic exertional compartment syndrome of the medial foot compartment. The results demonstrated normative compartment pressures of the medial foot compartment are comparable with previously measured pressures of the leg. This study shows that previously defined criteria for diagnosis of chronic exertional compartment syndrome of the leg may also be used for diagnosis of chronic exertional compartment syndrome of the foot.