The effects of pulsatile versus non-pulsatile extracorporeal circulation on the pattern of coronary artery blood flow during cardiac arrest

Preclinical Studies on Pulsatile Veno-Arterial Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation: A Systematic Review

Refractory cardiogenic shock is increasingly being treated with veno-arterial extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (V-A ECMO), without definitive proof of improved clinical outcomes. Recently, pulsatile V-A ECMO has been developed to address some of the shortcomings of contemporary continuous-flow devices. To describe current pulsatile V-A ECMO studies, we conducted a systematic review of all preclinical studies in this area. We adhered to PRISMA and Cochrane guidelines for conducting systematic reviews. The literature search was performed using Science Direct, Web of Science, Scopus, and PubMed databases. All preclinical experimental studies investigating pulsatile V-A ECMO and published before July 26, 2022 were included. We extracted data relating to the 1) ECMO circuits, 2) pulsatile blood flow conditions, 3) key study outcomes, and 4) other relevant experimental conditions. Forty-five manuscripts of pulsatile V-A ECMO were included in this review detailing 26 in vitro , two in silico , and 17 in vivo experiments. Hemodynamic energy production was the most investigated outcome (69%). A total of 53% of studies used a diagonal pump to achieve pulsatile flow. Most literature on pulsatile V-A ECMO focuses on hemodynamic energy production, whereas its potential clinical effects such as favorable heart and brain function, end-organ microcirculation, and decreased inflammation remain inconclusive and limited.

Comparison of Hemodynamic Energy between Expanded Polytetrafluoroethylene and Dacron Artificial Vessels

Background

Artificial grafts such as polyethylene terephthalate (Dacron) and expanded polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) are used for various cardiovascular surgical procedures. The compliance properties of prosthetic grafts could affect hemodynamic energy, which can be measured using the energy-equivalent pressure (EEP) and surplus hemodynamic energy (SHE). We investigated changes in the hemodynamic energy of prosthetic grafts.

Methods

In a simulation test, the changes in EEP for these grafts were estimated using COMSOL MULTIPHYSICS. The Young modulus, Poisson ratio, and density were used to analyze the grafts’ material properties, and pre- and post-graft EEP values were obtained by computing the product of the pressure and velocity. In an in vivo study, Dacron and ePTFE grafts were anastomosed in an end-to-side fashion on the descending thoracic aorta of swine. The pulsatile pump flow was fixed at 2 L/min. Real-time flow and pressure were measured at the distal part of each graft, while clamping the other graft and the descending thoracic aorta. EEP and SHE were calculated and compared.

Results

In the simulation test, the mean arterial pressure decreased by 39% for all simulations. EEP decreased by 42% for both grafts, and by around 55% for the native blood vessels after grafting. The in vivo test showed no significant difference between both grafts in terms of EEP and SHE.

Conclusion

The post-graft hemodynamic energy was not different between the Dacron and ePTFE grafts. Artificial grafts are less compliant than native blood vessels; however, they can deliver pulsatile blood flow and hemodynamic energy without any significant energy loss.

Percutaneous Assist Device for Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation

Persistent cardiac arrest is often caused by coronary ischemia. Urgent revascularization during on-going resuscitation with the support of percutaneous left ventricular assist devices (PVAD) may be feasible and can have the potential to improve the prognosis. Transport during resuscitation is a challenge that may be overcome with the use of cardiopulmonary resuscitation devices. In the catheterization laboratory, rapid deployment of PVAD may reduce ischemia, contribute to electrical stabilization of the heart, and facilitate definite treatment with percutaneous coronary intervention. After revascularization, PVAD therapy may promote myocardial recovery and improve vital organ perfusion in a critical phase.

Coronary versus carotid blood flow and coronary perfusion pressure in a pig model of prolonged cardiac arrest treated by different modes of venoarterial ECMO and intraaortic balloon counterpulsation

INTRODUCTION

Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) is increasingly used in cardiac arrest (CA). Adequacy of carotid and coronary blood flows (CaBF, CoBF) and coronary perfusion pressure (CoPP) in ECMO treated CA is not well established. This study compares femoro-femoral (FF) to femoro-subclavian (FS) ECMO and intraaortic balloon counterpulsation (IABP) contribution based on CaBF, CoBF, CoPP, myocardial and brain oxygenation in experimental CA managed by ECMO.

METHODS

In 11 female pigs (50.3 ± 3.4 kg), CA was randomly treated by FF versus FS ECMO ± IABP. Animals under general anesthesia had undergone 15 minutes of ventricular fibrillation (VF) with ECMO flow of 5 to 10 mL/kg/min simulating low-flow CA followed by continued VF with ECMO flow of 100 mL/kg/min. CaBF and CoBF were measured by a Doppler flow wire, cerebral and peripheral oxygenation by near infrared spectroscopy. CoPP, myocardial oxygen metabolism and resuscitability were determined.

RESULTS

CaBF reached values > 80% of baseline in all regimens. CoBF > 80% was reached only by the FF ECMO, 90.0% (66.1, 98.6). Addition of IABP to FF ECMO decreased CoBF to 60.7% (55.1, 86.2) of baseline, P = 0.004. FS ECMO produced 70.0% (49.1, 113.2) of baseline CoBF, significantly lower than FF, P = 0.039. Addition of IABP to FS did not change the CoBF; however, it provided significantly higher flow, 76.7% (71.9, 111.2) of baseline, compared to FF + IABP, P = 0.026. Both brain and peripheral regional oxygen saturations decreased after induction of CA to 23% (15.0, 32.3) and 34% (23.5, 34.0), respectively, and normalized after ECMO institution. For brain saturations, all regimens reached values exceeding 80% of baseline, none of the comparisons between respective treatment approaches differed significantly. After a decline to 15 mmHg (9.5, 20.8) during CA, CoPP gradually rose with time to 68 mmHg (43.3, 84.0), P = 0 .003, with best recovery on FF ECMO. Resuscitability of the animals was high, both 5 and 60 minutes return of spontaneous circulation occured in eight animals (73%).

CONCLUSIONS

In a pig model of CA, both FF and FS ECMO assure adequate brain perfusion and oxygenation. FF ECMO offers better CoBF than FS ECMO. Addition of IABP to FF ECMO worsens CoBF. FF ECMO, more than FS ECMO, increases CoPP over time.

Analysis of pulsatile and nonpulsatile blood flow effects in different degrees of stenotic vasculature

Vessel lumens that have been chronically narrowed by atherosclerosis should be increased in flow velocity and intrastenotic area pressure to maintain an equal flow. This might be followed by a decrease in hemodynamic energy, leading to a reduction of tissue perfusion. In this study, we compared hemodynamic energies according to degrees of stenotic vasculature between pulsatile flow and nonpulsatile flow. Cannuale with 25, 50, and 75% diameter stenosis (DS) were located at the outlet cannula. Using the Korea Hybrid ventricular assist device (KH-VAD) (pulsatile pump: group A) and Biopump (nonpulsatile pump: group B), constant flow of 2 L/min was maintained then real-time flow and velocity in the proximal and distal part of the stenotic cannula were measured. The hemodynamic energies of two groups were compared. At 75% DS, proximal energy equivalent pressure (EEP) delivered to the distal end was only 41.9% (group A) and 42.5% (group B). As the percent EEP fell below 10%, pulsatility disappeared from the 50% stenosis in group A. The surplus hemodynamic energy (SHE) of group B at all degrees of stenosis must have been 0, which was also the case of group A at 75% stenosis. This research evaluated the hemodynamic energy on various degrees of DS in both pulsatile and nonpulsatile flow with mock system. Using a pulsatile pump, pulsatility disappeared above 50% DS while hemodynamic energy was maintained. Therefore, our results suggest that pulsatile flow has a better effect than nonpulsatile flow in reserving hemodynamic energy after stenotic lesion.

Measurement of hemodynamic energy at different vessels in an adult swine model

Extra hemodynamic energy is one of the major benefits of pulsatile flow, improving blood flow to vital organs. But most (80%) of the hemodynamic energy generated from pulsatile flow is damped by the extracorporeal circuit. Most models devised to minimize hemodynamic energy loss have been in vitro pediatric models. The purpose of this study was to measure hemodynamic energy in different vessels of different organs with an in vivo adult swine model. An extracorporeal circuit was constructed for seven Yorkshire swine using a pulsatile pump (Twin-Pulse Life Support). The mean arterial pressure (MAP), energy equivalent pressure (EEP), and surplus hemodynamic energy (SHE) at the renal artery, carotid artery, aortic cannula site, and postoxygenator site were measured simultaneously before starting the pump and at the pump rates of 25, 35, and 45 bpm. The MAP of the renal or carotid artery was 40.0%-51.2% of the postoxygenator site. The EEP and SHE of both arteries were 11.6%-13.0% and 5.5%-7.4% of the postoxygenator site, respectively. The MAP and EEP of both arteries after starting the pump were lower than at baseline. The SHE of the renal artery after starting the pump was significantly higher than at baseline. The SHE of the carotid artery increased substantially after starting the pump although not statistically significantly. There was a significant hemodynamic energy loss in both arterial sites compared with the postoxygenator site. Also, a difference in hemodynamic energy loss was observed in vessel-to-vessel or vessel-to-circuit site comparison. This difference creates a bias in studying pulsatility and its effects. Therefore, the measurement method of hemodynamic energy must be standardized and the measurement site clarified to yield accurate study results.

Randomised comparison of percutaneous left ventricular assist device with open-chest cardiac massage and with surgical assist device during ischaemic cardiac arrest

AIMS

A percutaneous left ventricular assist device can maintain blood flow to vital organs during ventricular fibrillation and may improve outcomes in ischaemic cardiac arrest. We compared haemodynamic and clinical effects of a percutaneous left ventricular assist device with a larger device deployed via endovascular prosthesis and with open-chest cardiac massage during ischaemic cardiac arrest.

METHODS

Eighteen swine were randomised into three groups. After thoracotomy, coronary ischaemia and ventricular fibrillation was induced. Cardiac output was measured with transit-time flowmetry. Tissue perfusion was measured with microspheres. Defibrillation was performed after 20 min.

RESULTS

Cardiac output with cardiac massage was 1129 mL min⁻¹ vs. 1169 mL min⁻¹ with the percutaneous- and 570 mL min⁻¹ with the surgical device (P < 0.05 surgical vs. others). End-tidal CO₂ was 3.3 kPa with cardiac massage vs. 3.2 kPa with the percutaneous- and 2.3 kPa with the surgical device (P < 0.05 surgical vs. others). Subepicardial perfusion was 0.33 mL min⁻¹ g⁻¹ with cardiac massage vs. 0.62 mL min⁻¹ g⁻¹ with both devices (P < 0.05 devices vs. massage), cerebral perfusion was comparable between groups (all reported values after 3 min cardiac arrest, all P<0.05 vs. baseline, all P = NS for 3 min vs. 15 min). Return of spontaneous circulation was achieved in 5/6 subjects with cardiac massage vs. 6/6 with the percutaneous- and 4/6 with the surgical device (P = NS).

CONCLUSION

The percutaneous device improved myocardial perfusion, maintained cerebral perfusion and systemic circulation with similar rates of successful defibrillation vs. cardiac massage. Increased delivery was not obtained with the surgical device during cardiac arrest.

Mechanical cardiac assistance improves outcome after prolonged hemorrhagic shock

To examine the use of mechanical cardiac assist devices in prolonged hemorrhagic shock lasting up to 120 min. We induced hemorrhagic shock in anesthetized calves that were then treated 30 or 120 min later with either conventional fluid and blood resuscitation methods or the implantation of a mechanical assist device in addition to conventional fluid resuscitation. We measured hemodynamic and hematologic variables, inflammatory mediators, end-organ function via biochemical parameters, and survival time. Although cardiac output and blood flow in the left anterior descending artery decreased significantly in all calves at the end of the hemorrhage period, the drop was significantly less severe in calves who received mechanical assistance in addition to fluids. Furthermore, the biochemical profile, indicating liver and kidney function, and survival time were better after hemorrhage in device-treated calves than in conventionally treated calves. Levels of inflammatory mediators, which contribute to cell and organ dysfunction, were increased after hemorrhage, but calves with mechanical devices had less of an increase than did calves treated only with fluids. Our results indicate that the use of a mechanical cardiac assist device in combination with conventional fluid and blood resuscitation methods improves survival and end-organ recovery and decreases the myocardial inflammatory response after prolonged hemorrhagic shock when compared with the sole use of conventional fluid resuscitation techniques.

Pulsatile versus nonpulsatile flow to maintain the equivalent coronary blood flow in the fibrillating heart

How much flow is required by a nonpulsatile pump to match the coronary blood flow equivalent to that of pulsatile pump? A cardiopulmonary bypass circuit from the right atrium to the ascending aorta was constructed in a ventricular fibrillation model using 13 Yorkshire swine. The animals were randomly divided into two groups: CONTROL (pulsatile T-PLS, n = 7) or EXPERIMENTAL (nonpulsatile Biopump, n = 6). The hemodynamic data at mid-LAD level was measured with a flow meter at baseline and every 20 minutes after pump flow initiation. The pump flow was started from 2 L/min in both groups (67 +/- 8 in CONTROL and 70 +/- 9 ml/kg/min in EXPERIMENTAL; p = NS), and the pump flow of the EXPERIMENTAL group was increased to match the coronary flow of the CONTROL group. To maintain mean velocity and flow in the LAD, the EXPERIMENTAL group required significantly higher pump flow at 20, 40, and 60 minutes (84 +/- 17 vs. 67 +/- 8, 87 +/- 24 vs. 67 +/- 8, 85 +/- 18 vs. 67 +/- 8 ml/kg/min, respectively, p < 0.05). The LAD diameter was substantially smaller in the CONTROL group and the resistance index was significantly lower in the CONTROL group at 80 minutes and 120 minutes after bypass (0.56 +/- 0.26 vs. 0.87 +/- 0.20 and 0.61 +/- 0.23 vs. 0.90 +/- 0.06; p < 0.05). In conclusion, we found that the nonpulsatile pump may require 25%-28% higher pump flow than the pulsatile pump to maintain equivalent coronary blood flow.

Acute and chronic consequences of non-pulsatile blood flow pattern in long-term total artificial heart experiment

Vessel pulsation is presumably a key physiological function for the optimal supply of peripheral tissues and vital organs by oxygen and nutrients. The absence of pulsatility might impair the peripheral perfusion stability and trigger microvascular dysfunction of vital organs. The main purpose of this study was to investigate the influence of non-pulsatile flow on the microcirculation in experimental goat with implanted undulation pump total artificial heart (UPTAH). A microscopic system (Keyence, Japan) for the direct observation of the microcirculation of bulbar conjunctiva was used. Following the acute flow pattern change (from pulsatile to non-pulsatile one), the number of perfused capillaries decreased significantly (from 34.7+/-6.3 to 19.7+/-4.1 number of capillaries/mm; P<0.05). The velocity of erythrocytes dropped (from 526+/-83 to 132+/-41mum/s; P<0.05). The velocity of erythrocytes and capillary density were only partly recovered, when the pulsatile flow mode was restored. Histopathological analysis after 33 days of pumping in non-pulsatile mode revealed the presence of chronic venostasis, tissue edema, hemorrhages, hypoxia and ischemic necroses in the tissue samples from liver, kidneys and lung. These findings could be regarded as a direct effect of the chronic non-pulsatile pumping mode and inadequate blood supply. We conclude that the presence of pulsatile flow should be considered as a vital condition for a successful long-term survival after total artificial heart implantation.

Choroidal Microcirculation in Patients With Rotary Cardiac Assist Device

BACKGROUND

In recent years, fully implanted rotary blood pumps have been used for long-term cardiac assist in patients with end-stage heart failure. With these pumps, the pulsatility of arterial blood flow and arterial pressure pulse is considerably reduced. Effects on end-organ perfusion, particularly microcirculation, have been assessed.

METHODS

The ocular choroid offers a unique opportunity to study the pulsatile component of blood flow by measurement of fundus pulsation amplitude (FPA) as well as the microcirculation by laser Doppler flowmetry. Both techniques were applied in three male patients with rotary pumps (MicroMed DeBakey VAD), in whom pump velocity was adjusted to four levels of flow between individual minimal need and maximal support. In addition, blood flow velocities in the ophthalmic artery (peak, end-diastolic and mean flow velocity--PSV, EDV and MFV, respectively) were measured using color Doppler imaging.

RESULTS

Systolic blood pressure increased by 6 to 22 mm Hg with increasing support. At maximal support FPA was reduced by -60% to -52% as compared with minimal pump support. Blood flow in the choroidal microvasculature, however, did not show relevant changes. A reduction in PSV (-31%, range -47% to -21%) and a pronounced rise in EDV (+93%, range +28% to +147%) was observed, whereas MFV was independent of pump flow.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data indicate that mean choroidal blood flow is maintained when pump support is varied within therapeutic values, whereas the ratio of pulsatile to non-pulsatile choroidal flow changes. This study shows that, in patients with ventricular assist devices, a normal perfusion rate in the ocular microcirculation is maintained over a wide range of support conditions.

An Evaluation of the Benefits of Pulsatile versus Nonpulsatile Perfusion during Cardiopulmonary Bypass Procedures in Pediatric and Adult Cardiac Patients

The controversy over the benefits of pulsatile and nonpulsatile flow during cardiopulmonary bypass procedures continues. The objective of this investigation was to review the literature in order to clarify the truths and dispel the myths regarding the mode of perfusion used during open-heart surgery in pediatric and adult patients. The Google and Medline databases were used to search all of the literature on pulsatile vs. nonpulsatile perfusion published between 1952 and 2006. We found 194 articles related to this topic in the literature. Based on our literature search, we determined that pulsatile flow significantly improved blood flow of the vital organs including brain, heart, liver, and pancreas; reduced the systemic inflammatory response syndrome; and decreased the incidence of postoperative deaths in pediatric and adult patients. We also found evidence that pulsatile flow significantly improved vital organ recovery in several types of animal models when compared with nonpulsatile perfusion. Several investigators have also shown that pulsatile flow generates more hemodynamic energy, which maintains better microcirculation compared with nonpulsatile flow. These results clearly suggest that pulsatile flow is superior to nonpulsatile flow during and after open-heart surgery in pediatric and adult patients.

In Vitro Evaluation of the Performance of Korean Pulsatile ECLS (T-PLS) Using Precise Quantification of Pressure-Flow Waveforms

The Twin-Pulse Life Support System (T-PLS) is a novel pulsatile extracorporeal life support system developed in Korea. It has been reported that the T-PLS achieves higher levels of tissue perfusion of the kidney during short-term extracorporeal circulation and provides more blood flow to coronary artery than nonpulsatile blood pumps. However, these results lack pulsatility quantifications and thus make it hard to analyze the effects of pulsatility upon hemodynamic performance. We have adopted the concepts of hemodynamic energy, energy equivalent pressure (EEP), and surplus hemodynamic energy (SHE) to evaluate pulsatility performance in the different circuit configurations of the T-PLS and a membrane oxygenator (MO) in vitro. In a mock system, three different circuits were constructed depending on the location of an MO: pump-MO-pump (serial), MO-pumps (parallel A), and pumps-MO (parallel B). In parallel A, a low-resistance MO was used to preserve the pulsatility from the pump. All circuits showed good pulsatility in terms of EEP (serial: 13.2% +/- 3.2%, parallel A: 10.0% +/- 1.6%, parallel B: 7.00% +/- 1.1%; change from aortic pressure to EEP; p < 0.003). The SHE levels were 17,404 +/- 3750 ergs/cm3, 13,170 +/- 1486 ergs/cm3, and 9192 +/- 1122 ergs/cm3 in each circuit setup (p < 0.001). Although EEP levels were somewhat lower, both parallel types provided higher pump output compared with the serial type (serial: 1.87 +/- 0.29 l/min, parallel A: 3.09 +/- 0.74 l/min, parallel B: 3.06 +/- 0.56 l/min; p < 0.003 except parallel A vs. parallel B, p = 0.90). Conclusively, the precise quantifications of pressure flow waveforms, EEP, and SHE are valuable tools for evaluating pulsatility of the mechanical circulatory devices, and are expected to be used as additional performance indexes of a blood pump. The pulsatility performances are different according to circuit setups. However, the parallel A circuit could achieve higher pump output and generate adequate pulsatility level. Thus, the parallel A circuit is suggested as the optimal configuration in T-PLS applications.

Optimization of the Circuit Configuration of a Pulsatile ECLS: An In Vivo Experimental Study

An extracorporeal life support system (ECLS) with a conventional membrane oxygenator requires a driving force for the blood to pass through hollow fiber membranes. We hypothesized that if a gravity-flow hollow fiber membrane oxygenator is installed in the circuit, the twin blood sacs of a pulsatile ECLS (the Twin-Pulse Life Support, T-PLS) can be placed downstream of the membrane oxygenator. This would increase pump output by doubling pulse rate at a given pumpsetting rate while maintaining effective pulsatility. The purpose of this study was to determine the optimal circuit configuration for T-PLS with respect to energy and pump output. Animals were randomly assigned to 2 groups in a total cardiopulmonary bypass model. In the serial group, a conventional membrane oxygenator was located between the twin blood sacs of the T-PLS. In the parallel group, the twin blood sacs were placed downstream of the gravity-flow membrane oxygenator. Energy equivalent pressure (EEP), surplus hemodynamic energy (SHE) and pump output were collected at the different pump-setting rates of 30, 40, and 50 beats per minute (BPM). At a given pump-setting rate the pulse rate doubled in the parallel group. Percent changes of mean arterial pressure to EEP were 13.0 +/- 1.7, 12.0 +/- 1.9, and 7.6 +/- 0.9% in the parallel group, while 22.5 +/- 2.4, 23.2 +/- 1.9, and 21.8 +/- 1.4 in the serial group at 30, 40, and 50 BPM of pump-setting rates. SHE at each pump setting rate was 20,131 +/- 1408, 21,739 +/- 2470, and 15,048 +/- 2108 erg/ cm3 in the parallel group, while 33,968 +/- 3001, 38,232 +/- 3281, 37,964 +/- 2693 erg/cm3 in the serial group. Pump output was higher in the parallel circuit at 40, and 50 BPM pump-setting rates (3.1 +/- 0.2, 3.7 +/- 0.2 L/min vs. 2.2 +/- 0.1 and 2.5 +/- 0.1 L/min, respectively, p =0.01). Either parallel or serial circuit configuration of T-PLS generates effective pulsatility. As for the pump out, the parallel circuit configuration provides higher flow than the serial circuit configuration by doubling the pulse rate at a given pump-setting rate.