Use of Therapeutic Apheresis methods in ICU

Apheresis is a modern medical approach in which plasma or cellular components are separated from the whole blood. Apheresis can be either diagnostic or therapeutic. Diagnostic apheresis is typically applied in hematology and cancer research. Therapeutic Apheresis (TA) includes a broad spectrum of extracorporeal treatments applied in various medical specialties, including Intensive Care Unit (ICU). Considering the complexity of the pathophysiologic characteristics of various clinical entities and in particular sepsis, apheresis methods are becoming increasingly applicable. Therapeutic Plasma Exchange (TPE) is the most common used method in ICU. It is considered as first line therapy for Thrombotic Thrombocytopenic Purpura (TTP) and Guillain Barre Syndrome, while the current data for sepsis are scarce. Over the last decades, technologic evolution has led to increasing application of new and more selective methods based on adsorptive techniques. In this review we will describe the current data of characteristics of different techniques, safety and clinical impact of apheresis methods used in ICUs.

Bilirubin Removal by Polymeric Adsorbents for Hyperbilirubinemia Therapy

Hyperbilirubinemia, presenting as jaundice, is a life-threatening critical illness in newborn babies and acute severe hepatic failure patients. Over the past few decades, extracorporeal hemoadsorption by adsorbent therapy has been widely applied in the treatment of hyperbilirubinemia. The capability of hemoadsorption depends on the adsorbents. Most of the clinically used bilirubin adsorbents are made up of styrene/divinylbenzene copolymer and quaternary ammonium salt, which usually have poor biocompatibility and weak mechanical strength. To overcome the drawbacks of commercial polymer adsorbents, advanced synthetic and natural polymers with/without nanomaterials have been designed, and novel adsorbent fabrication technologies have also been developed. In this review, the adsorption mechanism of bilirubin adsorbents has been summarized, which is the basic criterion in adsorbent development. Furthermore, the preparation method, adsorption mechanism, relative merits and practicability of the emerging bilirubin adsorbents have been evaluated. Based on the existing studies, this work highlights the future direction of the efforts on how to design and develop bilirubin adsorbents with good overall clinical performance. Perhaps this study can change traditional perspectives and propose new strategies for bilirubin clearance from the aspects of pathogenic mechanisms, metabolic pathways, and material-based innovation.

Enhancing Filtration Rates by the use of Blood Flow around the Capillaries of Plasmafilters: An in Vitro Study

As the low clearance rate of plasmaseparation limits its use in the treatment of patients suffering from liver failure, sepsis or MOF, we intend to develop strategies for a plasmaseparation unit which increases plasmafiltration rates. Our first question focused on whether commercially available plasmaseparation filters, and in particular their membranes, are suitable for the inversion of blood and plasma compartments. This experimental study was performed using in vitro systems. Commercially available plasmafilters PF2000N (Gambro) and Plasmaflo (Asahi) were compared in both their normal operating mode with blood flow through the capillary lumen, and in the inverse mode. Inverse mode means that blood flows through the outer space of the capillaries while plasma was obtained from the lumen. Heparinised porcine blood (5 I.U./ml) was used in a heated, recirculating in vitro circuit. Our main results were that the normal use of both filter types Plasmaflo and PF2000N enabled maximal blood flows (Qb) of 200 ml/min and filtration rates (Qf) of 25–40 ml/min. Operating the filters in the inverse mode enabled Qb up to 500 ml/min and Qf up to 100 ml/min. Hemolysis, platelet counts and coagulation parameters did not differ significantly regardless of whether the normal or inverse mode was used. The tested plasmafiltration membranes appear to be suitable for use in inverse mode. Although in our experiments, hemocompatibility tests did not indicate severe problems induced by the module geometry, the development of a module specially constructed for blood flow outside of the hollow fibers appears to be necessary in order to minimise shunts and low perfusion areas.

Uremic Toxicity: Present State of the Art

The uremic syndrome is a complex mixture of organ dysfunctions, which is attributed to the retention of a myriad of compounds that under normal condition are excreted by the healthy kidneys (uremic toxins). In the area of identification and characterization of uremic toxins and in the knowledge of their pathophysiologic importance, major steps forward have been made during recent years. The present article is a review of several of these steps, especially in the area of information about the compounds that could play a role in the development of cardiovascular complications. It is written by those members of the Uremic Toxins Group, which has been created by the European Society for Artificial Organs (ESAO). Each of the 16 authors has written a state of the art in his/her major area of interest.

Bilirubin Removal from Albumin - Containing Solution by Adsorption on Polymer Resin

Adsorption equilibrium of bilirubin onto polymeric resins is studied. Solutions containing albumin are used in order to simulate the behavior of systems for removal of albumin-bound substances from blood, serum or dialysis fluids. The effect of albumin pre-loading on the resin is also analysed. Results are explained by a chemically based model that accounts for binding reaction between albumin and bilirubin in the liquid phase.

Thermodynamic equilibria and physical models are essential tools for designing adsorption columns aimed at detoxification treatments.

The role of the Molecular Adsorbents Recirculating System (MARS) in the management of liver failure

Albumin-bound toxins accumulate in liver failure, and are believed to contribute to the development of the associated end-organ dysfunctions (kidney, circulation, brain). The scavenging functions of albumin are utilized in albumin dialysis for toxin removal. The Molecular Adsorbents Recirculating System (MARS) is an extracorporeal liver support device based on dialysis across an albumin-impregnated membrane, using 20% albumin as dialysate. Charcoal and anion exchange resin columns in the circuit help cleanse and regenerate the dialysate. Clinical studies over the last decade have demonstrated proven reduction in hyperbilirubinaemia, along with an improvement in hepatic encephalopathy, systemic haemodynamics and renal function in liver failure patients, as well as apparent improvement in survival. However, the specific mechanisms underlying these observed clinical changes are as yet unclear. The results of larger controlled clinical trials, as well as studies investigating the pathophysiological basis of its effect, are awaited.

A New Application for Albumin Dialysis in Extracorporeal Organ Support: Characterization of a Putative Interaction Between Human Albumin and Proinflammatory Cytokines IL-6 and TNFα

Albumin dialysis in extracorporeal organ support is often performed in the treatment of liver failure as it facilitates the removal of toxic components from the blood. Here, we describe a possible effect of albumin dialysis on proinflammatory cytokine levels in vitro. Initially, albumin samples were incubated with different amounts of cytokines and analyzed by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Analysis of interleukin 6 (IL-6) and tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNFα) levels indicated that increased concentrations of albumin reduce the measureable amount of the respective cytokines. This led to the hypothesis that the used proinflammatory cytokines may interact with albumin. Size exclusion chromatography of albumin spiked with cytokines was carried out using high-performance liquid chromatography analysis. The corresponding fractions were evaluated by immunoblotting. We detected albumin and cytokines in the same fractions indicating an interaction of the small-sized cytokines IL-6 and TNFα with the larger-sized albumin. Finally, a two-compartment albumin dialysis in vitro model was used to analyze the effect of albumin on proinflammatory cytokines in the recirculation circuit during 6-h treatment. These in vitro albumin dialysis experiments indicated a significant decrease of IL-6, but not of TNFα, when albumin was added to the dialysate solution. Taken together, we were able to show a putative in vitro interaction of human albumin with the proinflammatory cytokine IL-6, but with less evidence for TNFα, and demonstrated an additional application for albumin dialysis in liver support therapy where IL-6 removal might be indicated.

Experience with molecular adsorbent recirculating system treatment in 20 children listed for high-urgency liver transplantation

For more than 10 years, children at our national center for pediatric liver transplantation (LT) have been treated with Molecular Adsorbent Recirculating System (MARS) liver dialysis as a bridging therapy to high-urgency LT. Treatment was reserved for 20 patients with the highest degrees of hepatic encephalopathy (HE; median grade = 3.5). Death from neurological sequelae was considered imminent for these patients, and this was further reflected in significantly higher international normalized ratios and ammonia levels and worse prognostic liver indices (Model for End-Stage Liver Disease/Pediatric End-Stage Liver Disease scores and liver injury units) in comparison with 32 wait-listed patients who did not receive MARS dialysis. MARS therapy was generally well tolerated, with a reduction in thrombocytes and hemorrhaging as the most common side effects. HE improvement was documented in 30% of the treated patients, but progression to grade IV encephalopathy occurred in 45% of the patients despite the treatment. Serum ammonia, bilirubin, bile acid, and creatinine levels significantly decreased during treatment. Eighty percent of MARS-treated patients survived to undergo LT, and their survival was equivalent to that of non-MARS-treated patients with severe liver failure (69%, P = 0.52). The heterogeneity between MARS-treated patients and non-MARS-treated patients in our cohort precluded a statistical evaluation of a benefit from MARS for patient survival. Our data demonstrate the safety of MARS even in the most severely ill patients awaiting LT, but strategies that promote the more rapid and widespread availability of high-quality donor organs remain of critical importance for improving patient survival in cases of severe acute liver failure.

'Out-patient' albumin dialysis for cholestatic patients with intractable pruritus

BACKGROUND

Intractable pruritus is a major problem for some patients with cholestasis. Albumin dialysis has been shown to ameliorate pruritus, but long-term outcome data are limited.

AIM

To evaluate the safety and efficacy of 'out-patient' albumin dialysis using the molecular adsorbent recirculating system (MARS) in the treatment of intractable pruritus in cholestatic patients referred for liver transplantation for symptomatic relief.

METHODS

Fifteen patients who failed to respond to standard medical therapy to control pruritus were included. Three MARS (6 h) sessions were performed per admission, and were repeated, if necessary. The intensity and severity of itch was quantified using itch severity and visual analogue scales (ISS and VAS).

RESULTS

Molecular adsorbent recirculating system treatment was safe and associated with immediate and complete response in 11 patients; two patients had a partial response and two patients had no response. Thirty-four treatments were performed during a follow-up period of 15.7 months (3-46) with patients requiring a mean of two admissions (1-6). The mean VAS and ISS improved significantly (both P < 0.001) with improvement in the patient's perception of their quality of life. The duration of acceptable relief in responders was 3.3 months (range 2-5). No serious adverse events were recorded, but the platelet count and haemoglobin were reduced significantly.

CONCLUSION

Molecular adsorbent recirculating system therapy delivered in an 'out-patient' setting is safe and effective with a high degree of patient acceptability. Albumin dialysis can be considered a viable therapeutic option for patients with severe intractable pruritus, in whom, the only other effective treatment option is liver transplantation.

Acute-on-chronic liver failure: current concepts on definition, pathogenesis, clinical manifestations and potential therapeutic interventions

In recent years, acute-on-chronic liver failure has been recognized as a specific clinical form of liver failure associated with cirrhosis. The syndrome refers to an acute deterioration of liver function and subsequently of other end organs over a period of weeks following a precipitating event in a patient with previously well- or reasonably well-compensated cirrhosis. These precipitating events include either an indirect (e.g., variceal hemorrhage, sepsis) or a direct (e.g., drug-induced) hepatotoxic factor. The short-term mortality for this condition is more than 50%. At present, considerable efforts are ongoing to better characterize the syndrome, to gain further insight into its pathophysiology and to optimize therapy. This article aims to highlight the current concepts of these various aspects.

Extracellular brain ammonia levels in association with arterial ammonia, intracranial pressure and the use of albumin dialysis devices in pigs with acute liver failure

In acute liver failure (ALF) hyperammonemia plays a mayor role in the pathogenesis of hepatic encephalopathy (HE) but does not always correlate with the severity of mental deterioration and intracranial pressure (ICP). The aim of our study was to evaluate the association with extracellular brain ammonia, ICP and the therapeutical impact of two albumin dialysis devices. ALF was induced by complete hepatectomy in 13 pigs. All pigs were monitored and treated under intensive care conditions until death. Arterial blood and cerebral microdialysis samples were collected and ICP data recorded. Additionally in 5 pigs, standard albumin dialysis and in 3 animals an albumin dialysis prototype was initiated as a tool. Arterial ammonia increased straight after hepatectomy, while extracellular brain ammonia remained on a moderate level 10 h post ALF initiation. After 16 h the brain ammonia reached arterial ammonia levels before plateauing at 1,200 microM, though the arterial ammonia continued to rise. The ICP correlated with the brain ammonia levels. No impact of the different dialysis therapies on neither blood nor brain ammonia levels was observed. In ALF the extracellular brain ammonia revealed a delayed increase compared to arterial ammonia. It correlated strongly with the ICP and could serve as a sensitive marker for HE development. Albumin dialysis did not affect blood or brain ammonia levels.

Is MARS system enough for A. phalloides-induced liver failure treatment?

Patients with Amanita phalloides-induced liver failure (LF) have a high mortality, despite significant advances in intensive care management. Our study evaluated the effect of Molecular Absorbents Recirculating System (MARS) comparative with optimal intensive care (OIC) in adults with this condition, in the absence of liver transplantation (LT). Six consecutive patients (women, range 16-61 years) affected by A. phalloides-induced LF were treated with OIC (3 patients) and MARS (3 patients). Laboratory parameters and hepeatic encephalopaty were evaluated 15 min before and 24 hours following each MARS treatment. Three 6-hour sessions per patient were performed in MARS group, with a statistically significant decrease in ammonia (p value 0.011), alaninaminotransferase (ALT) and prothrombin time (PT) (p value 0.004). Two patients had a significant rebound in bilirubin (+116%; p value 0. 04) 24 hours following MARS. Mortality in MARS group was 66.7%. Survival rate in OIC was 0%. Negative prognostic markers: lack of PT and hepatic encephalopaty improvement, rebound in bilirubin, and delay of MARS therapy initiation. No significant adverse reactions occurred during MARS. MARS is an effective depurative therapy in adults with A. phalloides-induced LF, but alone is not enough. Survival is predicted by the results of the initial MARS, amount of mushroom consumed, and time from toxin exposure.

Increase of octanoate concentrations during extracorporeal albumin dialysis treatments

Extracorporeal liver support procedures based on albumin dialysis require the use of pharmaceutical-grade human serum albumin (HSA). Those preparations contain octanoate, which is added as stabilizer during the production process. For octanoate, a direct involvement in the pathogenesis of liver failure complications as well as an indirect influence by competitive displacement effects at the albumin molecule have been described. During five Single Pass Albumin Dialysis (SPAD) and three Molecular Adsorbent Recirculating System (MARS) treatments the changes of octanoate concentrations in blood and dialysate were investigated. An octanoate increase in patient blood was observed during passage of the filter for both SPAD (585 micromol/L [338-1022 micromol/L]) (median [range]) and MARS (182 micromol/L [71-437 micromol/L]) during the first three hours of treatment. The molar ratio of octanoate/albumin at the blood outflow was significantly higher during SPAD treatments (1.73 [0.86-2.64] vs. 0.54 [0.31-1.1]; P = 0.001) during MARS. Changes of octanoate blood levels during SPAD were significantly higher than during MARS (P < 0.001). The shift of octanoate from the dialysate to the patient was persistent during SPAD (median 67.6 micromol/min), whereas during MARS a decrease over time was observed (from 25.5 to 7.5 micromol/min). During albumin dialysis procedures a transfer of octanoate into patient blood occurs. The time-course and extent are different between both albumin dialysis procedures. Given the positive clinical effects reported mainly for MARS, the clinical impact of albumin dialysis-associated transfer of octanoate during extracorporeal liver support needs to be evaluated further.

Hepatic encephalopathy: pathophysiology and emerging therapies

Hepatic encephalopathy is characterized by neuropsychiatric abnormalities in patients with liver failure. Severe hepatic encephalopathy is an indication for liver transplantation as it portends poor outcome. Treatment of hepatic encephalopathy involves correction of precipitating factors such as sepsis, gastrointestinal bleeding, medications, and electrolyte imbalance. Effective therapies include lactulose and antibiotics such as neomycin, metronidazole, and rifaximin.

Survival predictors in patients treated with a molecular adsorbent recirculating system

AIM: To identify prognostic factors for survival in patients with liver failure treated with a molecular adsorbent recirculating system (MARS).

METHODS: MARS is a liver-assisting device that has been used in the treatment of liver failure to enable native liver recovery, and as a bridge to liver transplantation (LTX). We analyzed the 1-year outcomes of 188 patients treated with MARS, from 2001 to 2007, in an intensive care unit specializing in liver disease. Demographic, clinical and laboratory parameters were recorded before and after each treatment. One-year survival and the number of LTXs were recorded. Logistic regression analysis was performed to determine factors predicting survival.

RESULTS: The study included 113 patients with acute liver failure (ALF), 62 with acute-on-chronic liver failure (AOCLF), 11 with graft failure (GF), and six with miscellaneous liver failure. LTX was performed for 29% of patients with ALF, 18% with AOCLF and 55% with GF. The overall 1-year survival rate was 74% for ALF, 27% for AOCLF, and 73% for GF. The poorest survival rate, 6%, was noted in non-transplanted patients with alcohol-related AOCLF and cirrhosis, whereas, patients with enlarged and steatotic liver had 55% survival. The etiology of liver failure was the most important predictor of survival (P < 0.0001). Other prognostic factors were encephalopathy (P = 0.001) in paracetamol-related ALF, coagulation factors (P = 0.049) and encephalopathy (P = 0.064) in non-paracetamol-related toxic ALF, and alanine aminotransferase (P = 0.013) and factor V levels (P = 0.022) in ALF of unknown etiology.

CONCLUSION: The etiology of liver disease was the most important prognostic factor. MARS treatment appears to be ineffective in AOCLF with end-stage cirrhosis without an LTX option.

What clinical alternatives to whole liver transplantation? Current status of artificial devices and hepatocyte transplantation

Shortage of organ donors limits the number of possible liver transplantations. Alternative therapies for treatment of liver failure are currently being developed: (i) extracorporeal artificial liver devices; (ii) bioartificial liver devices using hepatocytes; and (iii) hepatocyte transplantation. The objective of these strategies is to bridge patients with liver failure until a suitable liver allograft is obtained for transplantation or the patient's own liver regenerates sufficiently to resume normal function. In this review, we discuss these strategies and summarize the current status of clinical experience.

The effect of molecular adsorbent recirculating system treatment on survival, native liver recovery, and need for liver transplantation in acute liver failure patients

Acute liver failure (ALF) is a medical emergency. Molecular adsorbent recirculating system (MARS), an artificial liver support system, can partly compensate for the detoxifying function of the liver by removing toxins from blood. To analyze the efficacy of MARS treatment, the outcomes of 113 ALF patients, treated with MARS between 2001 and 2007, were compared with a historical control group of 46 ALF patients treated without MARS between 1995 and 2001. Overall survival of transplanted patients was 94% in the MARS group and 77% in the control group (P=0.06). Without transplantation, survival was 66% and 40% (P=0.03), respectively. However, the etiological distribution of ALF differed significantly between the groups. In ALF patients with unknown etiology, groups were comparable at baseline; 91% and 69% of transplanted patients survived the MARS and control groups and the native liver recovered in 20% and 8% of the patients, respectively. Of the originally nonencephalopathic patients of unknown etiology, 36% underwent liver transplantation in the MARS group compared to 100% in the control group. Interpretation of the results was difficult in toxic etiology patients on account of differing baseline statuses. MARS treatment might partly explain the trend toward increased survival of ALF patients with unknown etiology.

The place of adsorption and biochromatography in extracorporeal liver support systems

Artificial and bioartificial liver devices aim at replacing some or all liver functions in the cases of end stage or fulminant disorders. Among all of its function, liver plays a key role in detoxification of substances that are hydrosoluble or bound to albumin. In this paper, the authors first reviewed the requirements for temporary liver support, then the adsorption-based systems that can be found on the market and finally propose new applications of biochromatography using perfusion-based bioartificial systems.

Association of reduced extracellular brain ammonia, lactate, and intracranial pressure in pigs with acute liver failure

We previously demonstrated in pigs with acute liver failure (ALF) that albumin dialysis using the molecular adsorbents recirculating system (MARS) attenuated a rise in intracranial pressure (ICP). This was independent of changes in arterial ammonia, cerebral blood flow and inflammation, allowing alternative hypotheses to be tested. The aims of the present study were to determine whether changes in cerebral extracellular ammonia, lactate, glutamine, glutamate, and energy metabolites were associated with the beneficial effects of MARS on ICP. Three randomized groups [sham, ALF (induced by portacaval anastomosis and hepatic artery ligation), and ALF+MARS] were studied over a 6-hour period with a 4-hour MARS treatment given beginning 2 hours after devascularization. Using cerebral microdialysis, the ALF-induced increase in extracellular brain ammonia, lactate, and glutamate was significantly attenuated in the ALF+MARS group as well as the increases in extracellular lactate/pyruvate and lactate/glucose ratios. The percent change in extracellular brain ammonia correlated with the percent change in ICP (r(2) = 0.511). Increases in brain lactate dehydrogenase activity and mitochondrial complex activity for complex IV were found in ALF compared with those in the sham, which was unaffected by MARS treatment. Brain oxygen consumption did not differ among the study groups.

CONCLUSION

The observation that brain oxygen consumption and mitochondrial complex enzyme activity changed in parallel in both ALF- and MARS-treated animals indicates that the attenuation of increased extracellular brain ammonia (and extracellular brain glutamate) in the MARS-treated animals reduces energy demand and increases supply, resulting in attenuation of increased extracellular brain lactate. The mechanism of how MARS reduces extracellular brain ammonia requires further investigation.

Acute systemic, splanchnic and renal haemodynamic changes induced by molecular adsorbent recirculating system (MARS) treatment in patients with end-stage cirrhosis

AIM

To evaluate the acute effect of treatment with the molecular adsorbent recirculating system (MARS) on splanchnic, renal and systemic haemodynamics in patients with end-stage cirrhosis.

METHODS

Twelve patients with end-stage cirrhosis, undergoing MARS treatment, were enrolled. The following haemodynamic parameters were measured by means of Doppler ultrasonography and thoracic electrical bioimpedance, before and after each session: portal velocity, renal and splenic resistance indices, cardiac output, cardiac stroke volume, heart rate, mean arterial pressure, systemic vascular resistance.

RESULTS

Median portal velocity increased significantly after treatment (23.7 vs. 20.3 cm/s, P < 0.05) while renal resistance index (0.72 vs. 0.75, P < 0.05) and splenic resistance index (0.60 vs. 0.65, P < 0.05) decreased significantly. Mean arterial pressure (83 vs. 81 mmHg, P < 0.05) and vascular resistance (899 vs. 749 dyne. s/cm5, P < 0.05) increased significantly, while cardiac output and stroke volume showed no significant changes.

CONCLUSIONS

Data emerging from this investigation suggest that MARS treatment improves significantly various haemodynamic alterations in cirrhotic patients in the short term. The observed decrease in renal vascular resistance and improvement in splenic resistance index, a parameter related to portal resistance, which leads us to hypothesize that these haemodynamic effects are probably mediated by clearance of vasoactive substances during MARS treatment.

Increasing the Clearance of Protein-Bound Solutes by Addition of a Sorbent to the Dialysate

The capacity of sorbent systems to increase solute clearances above the levels that are provided by hemodialysis has not been well defined. This study assessed the extent to which solute clearances can be increased by addition of a sorbent to the dialysate. Attention was focused on the clearance of protein-bound solutes, which are cleared poorly by conventional hemodialysis. A reservoir that contained test solutes and artificial plasma was dialyzed first with the plasma flow set at 46 +/- 3 ml/min and the dialysate flow (Q(d)) set at 42 +/- 3 ml/min using a hollow fiber kidney with mass transfer area coefficients greater than Q(d) for each of the solutes. Under these conditions, the clearance of urea (Cl(urea)) was 34 +/- 1 ml/min, whereas the clearances of the protein-bound solutes indican (Cl(ind)), p-cresol sulfate (Cl(pcs)), and p-cresol (Cl(pc)) averaged only 5 +/- 1, 4 +/- 1, and 14 +/- 1 ml/min, respectively The effect of addition of activated charcoal to the dialysate then was compared with the effect of increasing Q(d) without addition of any sorbent. Addition of charcoal increased Cl(ind), Cl(pcs), and Cl(pc) to 12 +/- 1, 9 +/- 2, and 35 +/- 4 ml/min without changing Cl(urea). Increasing Q(d) without the addition of sorbent had a similar effect on the clearance of the protein-bound solutes. Mathematical modeling predicted these changes and showed that the maximal effect of addition of a sorbent to the dialysate is equivalent to that of an unlimited increase in Q(d). These results suggest that as an adjunct to conventional hemodialysis, addition of sorbents to the dialysate could increase the clearance of protein-bound solutes without greatly altering the clearance of unbound solutes.

Molecular Adsorbent Recirculating System in Liver Transplantation: Safety and Efficacy

We assessed the safety and clinical efficacy of the Molecular Adsorbent Recirculating System (MARS) in liver failure patients admitted to our intensive care unit (ICU) from May 2000 to February 2006. Of 28 adult patients with bilirubin >15 mg/dL and hepatic encephalopathy (HE) grade > or =2 or hepato-renal syndrome, 22 patients were included in the study, because 6 patients were older than 65 years of age or showed recent alcohol abuse or extrahepatic malignancy. Patients were assigned to 2 groups according to whether MARS therapy was associated with a transplantation procedure: 11 patients received MARS therapy and liver transplantation (OLT group) and 11 patients received MARS therapy alone (non-OLT group). Five of 11 patients in the OLT group were listed for transplantation and 6 patients with graft failure for retransplantation. The patients in the OLT and non-OLT groups were similar in MELD, SOFA, and SAPS scores. All patients were stable and free from complications. MARS significantly reduced bilirubin, bile acids, and blood urea nitrogen (BUN) levels in both groups (P < .05), whereas a significant decrease in ammonia level was observed in the OLT group. Patient survival rates at 3 and 6 months in the OLT group were 91% and 73%, respectively, and in the non-OLT group, 9% and 9%, respectively (P < .001). MARS was safe and well tolerated, improving biochemical parameters, neurological function, and pruritus. In terms of survival, the use of MARS alone was not effective due to the high rate of multiple organ failure. Nevertheless, the association of MARS with a transplant/retransplantation procedure was highly effective.

[Albumin dialysis in patients with acute exacerbation of chronic liver failure in an intensive care unit]

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

To describe our experience with albumin dialysis (Molecular Adsorbent Recirculating System [MARS]) in patients who are in an intensive care unit due to an acute exacerbation of chronic liver failure.

PATIENTS AND METHOD

From January 2004 to October 2005 10 patients, aged 40 to 65 years (mean age 58.8), were admitted due to acute exacerbation of chronic liver failure. All of them suffered from an encephalopathy and were candidates for a liver transplantation. One to six MARS sessions were applied. Clinical parameters were registered before and after each session.

RESULTS

Of the 10 patients treated, 9 survived and 1 died. Five out of the 9 survivors were successfully transplanted. In 2 patients (one of them was the deceased one) the grade of encephalopathy was > I (II and III respectively), and in both improved to grade I. In the other ones, the encephalopathy did not worsen. The serum bilirubin diminished from 39.2 to 28.2 mg/dl (p < 0.01). In the 3 patients with serum creatinin > 1.5 mg/dl, this parameter diminished from 2.6 to 1.5 mg/dl (p < 0.01). Two patients had thrombocytopaenia and haemorrhage, and in one of them the MARS treatment had to be interrupted. No hypotension was observed.

CONCLUSIONS

The reduction in the serum bilirrubin and creatinin, as well as the clinical improvement of the two patients with encephalopathy grade > I, make us to think that the MARS can be useful to patients with acute exacerbation of a chronic liver failure as a bridge to a liver transplantation.

Systemic and regional hemodynamics in pigs with acute liver failure and the effect of albumin dialysis

OBJECTIVE

Acute liver failure (ALF) is haemodynamically characterized by a hyperdynamic circulation. The aims of this study were to investigate the systemic and regional haemodynamics in ALF, to measure changes in nitric oxide metabolites (NOx) and to evaluate whether these haemodynamic disturbances could be attenuated with albumin dialysis.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Norwegian Landrace pigs (23-30 kg) were randomly allocated to groups as controls (sham-operation, n = 8), ALF (hepatic devascularization, n = 8) and ALF + albumin dialysis (n = 8). Albumin dialysis was started 2 h after ALF induction and continued for 4 h. Systemic and regional haemodynamics were monitored. Creatinine clearance, nitrite/nitrate and catecholamines were measured. A repeated measures ANOVA was used to analyse the data.

RESULTS

In the ALF group, the cardiac index increased (PGT < 0.0001), while mean arterial pressure (PG = 0.02) and systemic vascular resistance decreased (PGT < 0.0001). Renal resistance (PG = 0.04) and hind-leg resistance (PGT = 0.003) decreased in ALF. There was no difference in jejunal blood flow between the groups. ALF pigs developed renal dysfunction with increased serum creatinine (PGT = 0.002) and decreased creatinine clearance (P = 0.02). Catecholamines were significantly higher in ALF, but NOx levels were not different. Albumin dialysis did not attenuate these haemodynamic or renal disturbances.

CONCLUSIONS

The haemodynamic disturbances during the early phase of ALF are characterized by progressive systemic vasodilatation with no associated changes in metabolites of NO. Renal vascular resistance decreased and renal dysfunction developed independently of changes in renal blood flow. After 4 h of albumin dialysis there was no attenuation of the haemodynamic or renal disturbances.

Prometheus versus molecular adsorbents recirculating system: comparison of efficiency in two different liver detoxification devices

Albumin dialysis by the molecular adsorbents recirculating system (MARS) and by fractionated plasma separation, adsorption, and dialysis (Prometheus[PROM]) represent novel nonbiological liver support systems specifically designed to remove albumin-bound substances. Preliminary evidence suggests a favorable impact of MARS on the course and outcome of liver failure. This study aimed at comparing the detoxification capacity of both devices. For this purpose, we performed a retrospective analysis on data prospectively collected in patients with acute-on-chronic liver failure treated with either the MARS (n = 9) or the PROM (n = 9) device on 2-5 consecutive days. Each treatment was performed for at least 5 h at identical blood and dialysate flows. Blood clearances were calculated during the first treatment session for urea nitrogen, creatinine, total bilirubin, and bile acids from paired arterial and venous line samples after 1, 4, and 6 h of treatment. Reduction ratios for all single-treatment sessions, and the overall treatment phase, were calculated from pretreatment and post-treatment values. For all markers but bile acids, the single-treatment as well as the overall treatment phase reduction ratios obtained with PROM were significantly higher compared with those obtained with MARS. PROM led at all time points to higher clearances for all evaluated solutes. Blood clearances of protein-bound substances declined over time with MARS, but not with PROM. In conclusion, a significant decline in the serum level of water-soluble and protein-bound toxins was achieved with both devices. PROM produces higher blood clearances for most toxins, which results in higher delivered treatment doses compared with a matching treatment with MARS.

THIS ARTICLE HAS BEEN RETRACTED: An Australian Experience With the Molecular Adsorbents Recirculating System (MARS)

The molecular adsorbents recirculating system (MARS) is a form of artificial extracorporeal liver support which has the potential to remove substantial quantities of albumin-bound toxins postulated to contribute to the pathogenesis of liver cell damage, hemodynamic instability and multi-organ failure in patients with acute liver failure and acute-on-chronic liver failure (AoCLF). We assessed the efficacy of MARS therapy in a cohort of patients with severe liver damage unresponsive to intensive medical therapy. MARS therapy was instituted late in the clinical course of six patients with severely impaired liver function refractory to intensive medical therapy, including four with AoCLF precipitated by sepsis and two with liver dysfunction due to sepsis in the absence of pre-existing chronic liver disease. Outcome measures included markers of hemodynamic stability, renal function, serum bilirubin and bile acid levels, arterial ammonia levels, the arterial ketone body (acetoacetate/beta-hydroxybutyrate) ratio, hepatic encephalopathy grade and the plasma disappearance rate of indocyanine green. The rates of discharge from the intensive care unit and in-hospital mortality were determined. Our findings suggest that MARS treatment might be associated with some clinical efficacy even in patients with advanced multi-organ dysfunction occurring in the setting of severe liver damage and in whom treatment is instituted late in the clinical course. However, the overall survival rate (1/6; 17%) was poor. More data obtained from larger cohorts of patients enrolled in randomized controlled studies will be required in order to identify categories of liver failure patients who might benefit most from MARS treatment and to ascertain the most appropriate timing of intervention.

Review article: non-biological liver support in liver failure

Liver failure, whether acute or acute-on-chronic, remains an important cause of morbidity and mortality. The lack of liver detoxification, metabolic and regulatory functions of the liver leads to life-threatening complications, such as renal failure, altered immune response, hepatic coma and systemic haemodynamic dysfunction, eventually culminating in multiorgan failure. Current medical therapy involves the management of the precipitating event and treatment of complications until the liver eventually recovers, leaving us with no other treatment options than transplantation if these attempts fail. However, the shortage in cadaveric organs and other transplant-related problems, have prompted the need for alternative methods to provide liver support. As liver failure is often potentially reversible, considerable effort has been invested in the development of liver support systems. Currently, most of the experience is available for non-biological support systems. They represent the focus of this review, which aims to define the goals of liver support, to describe the design of the different existing devices and to analyse the available data to determine their current status in the management of patients with liver failure.

Catholic university experience with molecular adsorbent recycling system in patients with severe liver failure

BACKGROUND AND AIM

Molecular adsorbent recycling system (MARS) treatment is able to remove both hydrosoluble and small- and medium-sized lipophilic toxins. MARS plays an important role in modifying liver failure complications, such as hepatorenal syndrome and hepatic encephalopathy. We sought to evaluate the clinical efficacy and safety of a MARS device in a consecutive series of hepatic failure patients.

MATERIALS

Twenty patients with acute liver failure, transplantation failure, or acute on chronic liver failure fulfilled the inclusion criteria of total bilirubin > or =10 mg/dL and at least one of the following: hepatic encephalopathy (HE) > or =II grade, hepatorenal syndrome (HRS) for chronic patients or total bilirubin > or =5 mg/dL and HE > or =I grade for acute patients.

RESULTS

MARS was able to reduce cholestatic parameters and improve neurologic status and renal function parameters in all treated patients. We also observed an improvement in the 3-month survival rate compared to the expected outcome in patients with MELD scores between 20 and 29, as well as 30 and 39.

CONCLUSIONS

Based on these results, we confirm the safety and clinical efficacy of MARS treatment, with the best results in patients with MELD score of 20 to 29. Further studies are necessary to confirm whether this treatment is able to modify patient outcomes and prognosis.

Effect of albumin dialysis on intracranial pressure increase in pigs with acute liver failure: a randomized study

BACKGROUND

Increased intracranial pressure (ICP) worsens the outcome of acute liver failure (ALF). This study investigates the underlying pathophysiological mechanisms and evaluates the therapeutic effect of albumin dialysis in ALF with use of the Molecular Adsorbents Recirculating System without hemofiltration/dialysis (modified, M-MARS).

METHODS

Pigs were randomized into three groups: sham, ALF, and ALF + M-MARS. ALF was induced by hepatic devascularization (time = 0). M-MARS began at time = 2 and ended with the experiment at time = 6. ICP, arterial ammonia, brain water, cerebral blood flow (CBF), and plasma inflammatory markers were measured.

RESULTS

ICP and arterial ammonia increased significantly over 6 hrs in the ALF group, in comparison with the sham group. M-MARS attenuated (did not normalize) the increased ICP in the ALF group, whereas arterial ammonia was unaltered by M-MARS. Brain water in the frontal cortex (grey matter) and in the subcortical white matter at 6 hrs was significantly higher in the ALF group than in the sham group. M-MARS prevented a rise in water content, but only in white matter. CBF and inflammatory mediators remained unchanged in all groups.

CONCLUSION

The initial development of cerebral edema and increased ICP occurs independently of CBF changes in this noninflammatory model of ALF. Factor(s) other than or in addition to hyperammonemia are important, however, and may be more amenable to alteration by albumin dialysis.

[Artificial liver support systems: update on albumin dialysis (MARS)]

Mortality among patients with liver insufficiency continues to be unacceptably high. The prognosis of patients with acute episodes of chronic liver insufficiency is almost as poor as that of patients with acute liver failure. Therefore, systems that support liver function, either until liver transplantation can be performed or until resolution of the situation before acute injury occurs, are essential. Albumin dialysis is a system of artificial liver support that allows detoxification of albumin-related and hydrosoluble substances, thus maintaining the patient's homeostasis. Current clinical experience of this therapy is still limited, although beneficial effects on clinical, laboratory and hemodynamic parameters have been demonstrated. Multicenter, controlled trials to evaluate the effect of this therapy on survival in distinct diseases are needed.

Extracorporal liver support with molecular adsorbents recirculating system in patients with hepatitis B-associated fulminant hepatic failure

Hepatitis B virus (HBV) infection is the most prevalent cause of fulminant hepatic failure (FHF) in the Far East. HBV-associated FHF is characterised by rapidly progressive end organ dysfunction/failure and a very poor prognosis. To investigate how molecular adsorbent recirculating system (MARS) treatment impacts multiple organ system function in HBV-associated FHF. Ten consecutive patients were treated with MARS in a period of 12 months. Clinical, biochemical and haemodynamic parameters were assessed before and after MARS. Various disease severity scoring systems including model for end-stage liver disease, APACHE II, APACHE III, sequential organ failure assessment and organ system failure scores were also assessed. There were significant improvements in hepatic encephalopathy grading (p < 0.001), mean arterial pressure (p < 0.001), plasma renin activity (p = 0.027), bilirubin (p < 0.001), ammonia (p = 0.001) and creatinine levels (p < 0.001). There were also significant improvements in all the scoring systems evaluated. Meanwhile, platelet count was significantly decreased (p < 0.001). One patient was successfully bridged to liver transplantation. Three patients were alive at 3 months of follow-up. MARS can improve multiple organ functions in HBV-associated FHF. On the basis of these findings, randomised controlled studies are indicated and justified.

The effect of molecular adsorbent recirculating system on pathophysiological parameters in patients with acute liver failure

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the effect of the molecular adsorbent recirculating system (MARS) on physiological variables in patients with acute liver failure.

DESIGN

A prospective, observational study of MARS in addition to standard medical therapy in the management of patients presenting with acute liver failure.

SETTING

A regional liver transplant centre.

PATIENTS

Ten consecutive patients admitted with acute liver failure with a grade III or IV hepatic encephalopathy.

INTERVENTIONS

MARS therapy for 8 h on 2 consecutive days. Standard monitoring included the use of a pulmonary artery catheter and an intracranial pressure monitor.

MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS

During the first MARS treatment there was a significant increase in systemic vascular resistance index (SVRI) from 1114+/-196 to 1432+/-245 dyne s(-1) cm(-5) m(-2) with a reduction in cardiac index from 5.5+/-0.6 to 4.2+/-0.4 l min(-1) m(-2). The changes were maintained between the start of the first and second sessions but not to the end of second. Significant clearance of urea and creatinine was observed. Intracranial pressure did not change during the treatments. Overall mortality was 70%.

CONCLUSIONS

MARS therapy was well tolerated, with significant increases in vascular tone during the first session. This increase was not sustained over the duration of the study with a return to baseline values by the end of the second session. Based on our experience we cannot recommend the routine use of MARS therapy in acute liver failure outside of a clinical trial.

Albumin dialysis reduces portal pressure acutely in patients with severe alcoholic hepatitis

BACKGROUND/AIMS

In patients with alcoholic hepatitis (AH), inflammation contributes to the severity of portal hypertension. This study evaluates the acute effects of albumin dialysis, using the Molecular Adsorbents Recirculating System (MARS), on portal pressure in AH.

METHODS

Eleven patients with AH and portal hypertension were treated with MARS (n=8) or haemofiltration (n=3). All patients had associated organ failure manifested by hepatic encephalopathy (Grade 2 or more) or renal failure. Hepatic venous pressure gradient (HVPG) was measured before, during and after the treatment session.

RESULTS

A rapid significant reduction of HVPG was observed by 6 h (falling by > or =20% in 7/8 patients, reaching 12 mmHg in 6/8), which was sustained up to 18 h after stopping dialysis. Similar rapid sustained improvements of systemic haemodynamics were also observed. No changes occurred in three patients receiving haemofiltration alone.

CONCLUSIONS

Albumin dialysis produces clinically significant, acute reduction in portal pressure but the mechanism by which this effect is achieved is not clear. Our results suggest that MARS may be a useful adjunct in management of portal hypertension, particularly in patients with severe AH with associated organ failure.

Diffusive and convective transport through hollow fiber membranes for liver cell culture

For an efficient membrane bioreactor design, transport phenomena determining the overall mass flux of metabolites, catabolites, cell regulatory factors, and immune-related soluble factors, need to be clarified both experimentally and theoretically. In this work, experiments and calculations aimed at discerning the simultaneous influence of both diffusive and convective mechanisms to the transport of metabolites. In particular, the transmembrane mass flux of glucose, bovine serum albumin (BSA), APO-transferrin, immunoglobulin G, and ammonia was experimentally measured, under pressure and concentration gradients, through high-flux microporous hydrophilic poly-ether-sulphone (PES-HFMs) and poly-sulphone hollow fiber membranes (PS-HFMs). These data were analyzed by means of a model based on the mechanism of capillary pore diffusion, assuming that solute spherical molecules pass through an array of solvent-filled cylindrical pores with a diffusive permeation corrected for friction and steric hindrances. Additionally, resistances to the mass transfer were taken into account. Convective permeation data were discussed in terms of morphological properties of the polymeric membranes, molecular Stokes radius, and solute-membrane interactions according to information given by contact angle measurements. The observed steady-state hydraulic permeance of PS-HFMs was 0.972 L/m2hmbar, about 15.6-fold lower than that measured for PES-HFMs (15.2 L/m2h); in general, PS-HFMs provided a significant hindrance to the transport of target species. Diffusion coefficients of metabolites were found to be similar to the corresponding values in water through PES-HFMs, but significantly reduced through PS-HFMs (D(Glucose)(Membrane)=2.8x10(-6)+/-0.6x10(-6)cm2/s, D(BSA)(Membrane)=6.4 x 10(-7)+/-1 x 10(-7)cm(/s, D(Apotransferrin)(Membrane)=2.3 x 10(-7)+/-0.25 x 10(-7)cm2/s).

Emerging indications for albumin dialysis

The accumulation of albumin-bound toxins in liver failure is believed to be responsible for the development of associated end-organ dysfunctions (kidney, circulation, brain). Albumin dialysis utilizes the scavenging functions of albumin for the removal of toxins. The Molecular Adsorbents Recirculating System (MARS) is one such extracorporeal liver support device where blood is dialyzed across an albumin-impregnated membrane against 20% albumin. Charcoal and anion exchange resin columns in the circuit cleanse and regenerate the albumin dialysate. Clinical studies in the last decade have demonstrated proven reduction in hyperbilirubinemia, along with an improvement in encephalopathy in liver failure patients, as well as apparent improvement in survival. Some studies have also reported improvement of systemic hemodynamics and renal function in these patients. Amelioration of intractable pruritus and treatment of toxicities with albumin-bound substances are some of the newer indications emerging. However, the specific underlying pathophysiological mechanisms are still not clear. Two other systems based on the removal of albumin-bound toxins, the Prometheus (using the principle of fractionated plasma separation and adsorption [FPSA]), and the single pass albumin dialysis (SPAD) are also currently under development but available clinical data are limited.

Binding of bilirubin and bromosulphthalein to albumin: implications for understanding the pathophysiology of liver failure and its management

The binding/transporting functions of albumin provide the rationale for using albumin dialysis (e.g., molecular adsorbents recirculating system [MARS]) in liver failure. This study investigates these properties in vitro, validating the findings in vivo. In vitro bromosulphthalein (BSP) and bilirubin-spiked plasma were dialyzed against albumin and sampled. In vivo serum biochemistry was analyzed in: 7 MARS-treated liver failure patients; 98 MARS-treated patients from the MARS Registry; and 8 patients receiving albumin infusion. In vitro BSP concentrations did not equilibrate, but the molar ratio of BSP to albumin (C(BSP)/C(alb)) did, with no subsequent transmembrane transport, suggesting that the C(BSP)/C(alb) gradient (rather than simple diffusion) drives BSP transport. Bilirubin was transported similarly. In vivo serum bilirubin reduction during MARS sessions (n = 26) correlated with pre-treatment bilirubin (r = 0.42), but better (r = 0.85) with pre-treatment molar ratio of bilirubin to albumin (C(bilirubin)/C(alb)). The strongest correlation was between C(bilirubin)/C(alb) reduction and pre-treatment C(bilirubin)/C(alb) (r = 0.9). A similar pattern was observed in the MARS Registry patients. After albumin infusion (n = 8), both serum albumin and bilirubin increased, while C(bilirubin)/C(alb) remained unchanged. C(bilirubin)/C(alb) appears to be important in albumin dialysis, and generally in liver disease patients, reinforcing the importance of the toxin-binding functions of albumin in liver disease.

First use of the Molecular Adsorbent Recirculating System technique on patients with hypoxic liver failure after cardiogenic shock

The Molecular Adsorbent Recirculating System (MARS) has been proven to prolong survival in patients with hepatorenal syndrome. MARS is a modified dialysis that uses an albumin containing dialysate, which is recirculated and perfused online through charcoal and anion exchanger columns. It allows the selective removal of albumin bound substances. Despite advances in medical therapy and technology, the prognosis of patients with cardiogenic shock remains poor. Mortality rates are as high as 80%, often because of persistent multiple organ failure. To determine whether patients with hypoxic liver failure after cardiogenic shock after cardiac surgery might benefit from MARS, we performed a prospective, randomized, controlled, single center study. The primary objective was to prove that MARS improves survival. This article is a report on the interim analysis of the first 27 patients included between August 2000 and December 2001; 14 patients were in the MARS group, and 13 patients were in the non-MARS group. All had bilirubin levels greater than 8 mg/ml. Both groups had a similar risk profile. The MARS group received MARS for 3 consecutive days-if bilirubin was still greater than 6 mg/dl afterward, MARS was continued. The non-MARS group received conventional therapy. We had seven survivors in the MARS group (50%) compared with four (32%; p = ns) in the non-MARS group. We conclude that despite the limited number of patients included in this analysis, MARS can be recommended for patients with acute, hypoxic liver failure because it might prolong survival. Further studies in similar patient cohorts are needed to verify our results.

Pathophysiological effects of albumin dialysis in acute-on-chronic liver failure: a randomized controlled study

The pathophysiological basis of acute-on-chronic liver failure (ACLF) is unclear but systemic inflammatory response is thought to be important. In patients with ACLF, the molecular adsorbents recirculating system (MARS) improves individual organ function, but the effect of MARS on the proposed mediators of systemic inflammatory response is unclear. The present study was designed to determine the effect of MARS on the cytokine profile, oxidative stress, nitric oxide, and ammonia. A total of 18 patients with alcohol-related ACLF due to inflammation-related precipitants were randomized to receive standard medical therapy (SMT) alone, or with MARS therapy over 7 days. Plasma cytokines, malondialdehyde (MDA), free radical production, nitrate / nitrite (NOx), and ammonia were measured. Encephalopathy improved significantly with MARS (P < .01), but not with SMT. Mean arterial pressure and renal function remained unchanged. No significant change of plasma cytokines and ammonia levels were observed in either group. Plasma MDA levels did not change either. There was a fall in NOx (P < .05) with MARS, but not with SMT. In conclusion, in inflammation-related ACLF patients, albumin dialysis using MARS results in improvement of encephalopathy, independent of changes of ammonia or cytokines, without improving blood pressure or renal function. These results should temper the liberal use of MARS until further data is available.

Extracorporeal liver support: waiting for the deciding vote

Because acute liver cell failure is associated with an exceedingly high mortality, liver support has been proposed since the 1950s to improve patient outcome. Early devices, including hemodialysis, hemofiltration, exchange transfusion, plasmapheresis, hemoperfusion, plasma and cross-hemodialysis or cross-circulation, appeared inefficient. Meanwhile, documented results of extracorporeal liver perfusion (ECLP) suggested its superiority over conventional treatment. These devices were abandoned with the development of liver transplantation (LT), which allowed a better outcome and longer survival rate. In the present day, the fact that patients die while waiting for LT because of organ shortage led to a renewed interest in liver support as bridge to LT or regeneration. These devices can be classified according to the presence or lack of hepatocytes, whereas biologic devices refers to the presence of cells or other organic and biochemical component. The absence of individual success of early models led to the development of combined hepatocyte free devices, or artificial liver, which are based upon the hemodiabsorption principle (Biologic-DT) or on the "albumin bound toxin hypothesis" (Molecular Adsorbents Recirculating System) with encouraging results. Meanwhile, hepatocyte based bioartificial liver devices (BLD) were conceived for a global "metabolic support." BLD were developed with the use of human hepatoma cell line (C3A) or primary or cryopreserved porcine hepatocytes. Preliminary experience gave promising results bridging patients to LT. Based upon the same principle of global hepatocyte metabolic support, ECLP regained interest, particularly with the development of transgenic pigs. Several concerns were raised about these devices. Artificial livers lacked any metabolic synthetic activity, the use of human liver for ECLP seems hardly acceptable because of organ shortage, and the accepted use of borderline livers for transplantation is pending trials for the use of xenogenic livers. For BLD, the concerns were the low hepatocyte mass, the absence of accessory liver cells, and the potential risk of seeding tumor cells into patient with the use of human hepatoma cell line. The use of porcine hepatocytes (BLD or ECLP) raised physiologic and immunologic concerns and particularly the fear of a possible transfer of porcine viral material. Although recent studies clearly demonstrate clinical improvement of patients with the use of recently developed liver support devices, most of reported prospective, controlled, or randomized trials had a small number of patients. To give the deciding vote and avoid previous pitfalls, trials need to be developed with a larger number of patients based upon statistically significant models with the following characteristics: 1) comprehensive understanding of the acute liver cell failure mechanisms, 2) world wide classification of conditions that require liver support, and 3) a clear definition of treatment success pending patients to LT or recovery without transplantation. There has not yet been conclusive evidence to support the benefits of extracorporeal liver support. We are still waiting for the deciding vote.