Advantages of pyruvate-based fluids in preclinical shock resuscitation-A narrative review

This review focuses on the innate beneficial effects of sodium pyruvate-based fluids, including pyruvate in intravenous solutions, oral rehydration solutions, and peritoneal dialysis solutions, on shock resuscitation with various animal models relative to current commercial fluids over the last two decades. Due to its superior pharmacological properties, pyruvate effectively sustains cytosolic glycolytic pathways and mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation by restoration of redox potentials and reactivation of pyruvate dehydrogenase in hypoxia, even anoxia, and diabetes, reversing the Warburg effect and diabetic glucometabolic aberration. Pyruvate has been demonstrated to protect against multiorgan dysfunction and metabolic disturbance in numerous preclinical studies with various pathogenic injuries. The unique features of pyruvate potential clinical benefits encompass to efficiently correct lethal lactic acidosis via metabolically rapid consumption of intracellular [H⁺] and robustly protect multiorgan metabolism and function, particularly visceral organs in addition to the heart and brain, significantly prolonging survival in various animal models. Pyruvate protection of red blood cell function and preservation of the partial pressure of arterial oxygen should be highly concerned in further studies. Pyruvate is much advantageous over existing anions such as acetate, bicarbonate, chloride, and lactate in commercial fluids. Pyruvate-based fluids act as a therapeutic agent without causing iatrogenic resuscitation injury in addition to being a volume expander, indicating a potential novel generation of resuscitation fluids, including crystalloids and colloids. Pyruvate-based fluids have an enormous potential appeal for clinicians who face the ongoing fluid debate to readily select as the first resuscitation fluid. Clinical trials with pyruvate-based fluids in shock resuscitation are urgently warranted.

Pyruvate as a Potential Beneficial Anion in Resuscitation Fluids

There have been ongoing debates about resuscitation fluids because each of the current fluids has its own disadvantages. The debates essentially reflect an embarrassing clinical status quo that all fluids are not quite ideal in most clinical settings. Therefore, a novel fluid that overcomes the limitations of most fluids is necessary for most patients, particularly diabetic and older patients. Pyruvate is a natural potent antioxidant/nitrosative and anti-inflammatory agent. Exogenous pyruvate as an alkalizer can increase cellular hypoxia and anoxia tolerance with the preservation of classic glycolytic pathways and the reactivation of pyruvate dehydrogenase activity to promote oxidative metabolism and reverse the Warburg effect, robustly preventing and treating hypoxic lactic acidosis, which is one of the fatal complications in critically ill patients. In animal studies and clinical reports, pyruvate has been shown to play a protective role in multi-organ functions, especially the heart, brain, kidney, and intestine, demonstrating a great potential to improve patient survival. Pyruvate-enriched fluids including crystalloids and colloids and oral rehydration solution (ORS) may be ideal due to the unique beneficial properties of pyruvate relative to anions in contemporary existing fluids, such as acetate, bicarbonate, chloride, citrate, lactate, and even malate. Preclinical studies have demonstrated that pyruvate-enriched saline is superior to 0.9% sodium chloride. Moreover, pyruvate-enriched Ringer’s solution is advantageous over lactated Ringer’s solution. Furthermore, pyruvate as a carrier in colloids, such as hydroxyethyl starch 130/0.4, is more beneficial than its commercial counterparts. Similarly, pyruvate-enriched ORS is more favorable than WHO-ORS in organ protection and shock resuscitation. It is critical that pay attention first to improving abnormal saline with pyruvate for ICU patients. Many clinical trials with a high dose of intravenous or oral pyruvate were conducted over the past half century, and results indicated its effectiveness and safety in humans. The long-term instability of pyruvate aqueous solutions and para-pyruvate cytotoxicity is not a barrier to the pharmaceutical manufacturing of pyruvate-enriched fluids for ICU patients. Clinical trials with sodium pyruvate-enriched solutions are urgently warranted.

The Effects of Peritoneal Dialysis Solutions on Peritoneal Host Defense

Conventional peritoneal dialysis fluid (PDF) is a bioincompatible solution owing to the acidic pH, the high glucose concentrations and the associated hyperosmolarity, the high lactate concentrations, and the presence of glucose degradation products (GDPs). This unphysiologic composition adversely affects peritoneal host defense and may thus contribute to the development of PD-related peritonitis. The viability of polymorphonuclear leukocytes, monocytes, peritoneal macrophages, and mesothelial cells is severely depressed in the presence of conventional PDF. In addition, the production of inflammatory cytokines and chemoattractants by these cells is markedly affected by conventional PDF. Further, conventional PDF hampers the recruitment of circulating leukocytes in response to an infectious stimulus. Finally, phagocytosis, respiratory burst, and bacterial killing are markedly lower when polymorphonuclear leukocytes, monocytes, and peritoneal macrophages are exposed to conventional PDF. Although there are a few discrepant results, all major PDF components have been implicated as causative factors. Generally, novel PDF with alternative osmotic agents or with alternative buffers, neutral pH, and low GDP content have much milder inhibitory effects on peritoneal host defense. Clinical studies, however, still need to demonstrate their superiority with respect to the incidence of PD-related peritonitis.

A Pyruvate-Buffered Dialysis Fluid Induces Less Peritoneal Angiogenesis and Fibrosis than a Conventional Solution

Background

Conventional lactate-buffered peritoneal dialysis (PD) fluids containing glucose and glucose degradation products are believed to contribute to the development of fibrosis and angiogenesis in the dialyzed peritoneum. To reduce potential negative effects of lactate, pyruvate was substituted as a buffer and its effects on peritoneal pathological alterations were studied in a chronic peritoneal exposure model in the rat.

Methods

20 Wistar rats were infused intraperitoneally with pyruvate-buffered ( n = 9) or lactate-buffered PD fluid. After 20 weeks of daily infusion, peritoneal function was assessed. In omental peritoneal tissue, the number of blood vessels was analyzed following alpha-smooth muscle actin staining. The degree of fibrosis was quantitated in Picro Sirius Red-stained sections and by assessment of the hydroxyproline content. Plasma lactate/pyruvate and beta-hydroxybutyrate/acetoacetate (BBA/AA) ratios were determined. Plasma and dialysate vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) levels were quantitated by ELISA.

Results

The mass transfer area coefficient of creatinine was higher and the dialysate-to-plasma ratio of sodium was lower in pyruvate-treated animals compared to the lactatetreated group (0.11 vs 0.05 mL/min, p < 0.05, and 78% vs 89%, p < 0.05). The BBA/AA ratio tended to be lower in the pyruvate animals ( p = 0.07). The number of blood vessels was lower in pyruvate-treated animals (16 vs 37 per field, p < 0.001). Total surface area, luminal area, and wall/total area of the vessels were larger in the pyruvate group. The degree of fibrosis was lower in intersegmental and perivascular areas of pyruvate-exposed animals. Effluent VEGF was higher in the pyruvate group.

Conclusions

Replacement of lactate by pyruvate resulted in changes in peritoneal solute transport, accompanied by a reduction in both peritoneal membrane angiogenesis and fibrosis, suggesting potentially novel mechanisms to reduce glucose-driven alterations to the peritoneal membrane in PD patients.

Pyruvate: immunonutritional effects on neutrophil intracellular amino or alpha-keto acid profiles and reactive oxygen species production

For the first time the immunonutritional role of pyruvate on neutrophils (PMN), free α-keto and amino acid profiles, important reactive oxygen species (ROS) produced [superoxide anion (O(2) (-)), hydrogen peroxide (H(2)O(2))] as well as released myeloperoxidase (MPO) acitivity has been investigated. Exogenous pyruvate significantly increased PMN pyruvate, α-ketoglutarate, asparagine, glutamine, aspartate, glutamate, arginine, citrulline, alanine, glycine and serine in a dose as well as duration of exposure dependent manner. Moreover, increases in O(2) (-) formation, H(2)O(2)-generation and MPO acitivity in parallel with intracellular pyruvate changes have also been detected. Regarding the interesting findings presented here we believe, that pyruvate fulfils considerably the criteria for a potent immunonutritional molecule in the regulation of the PMN dynamic α-keto and amino acid pools. Moreover it also plays an important role in parallel modulation of the granulocyte-dependent innate immune regulation. Although further research is necessary to clarify pyruvate's sole therapeutical role in critically ill patients' immunonutrition, the first scientific successes seem to be very promising.

Pyruvate Improves Neutrophilic Nitric Oxide Generation in Peritoneal Dialysis Solutions

To investigate the effects of pyruvate (Pyr)-based peritoneal dialysis solutions (P-PDS) on neutrophilic nitric oxide (NO) generation, we incubated human peripheral neutrophils in dL-lactate (Lac, 40 mM)-based PDS and equimolar P-PDS, and Hanks' balanced salt solution at various pH and high glucose (HG) levels, respectively. The production of NO in various test solutions was determined based on the Griess reaction. Acidic pH, high Lac, and HG induced an acute and substantial inhibition of neutrophilic NO, whereas Pyr in PDS significantly improved the NO generation in both acidic pH and physiological pH, and also in HG conditions. The Pyr protection may be associated with the improvement of glucose metabolic pathways in addition to its alkalization.

Pyruvate in the correction of intracellular acidosis: a metabolic basis as a novel superior buffer

The review focuses on biochemical metabolisms of conventional buffers and emphasizes advantages of sodium pyruvate (Pyr) in the correction of intracellular acidosis. Exogenous lactate (Lac) as an alternative of natural buffer, bicarbonate, consumes intracellular protons on an equimolar basis, regenerating bicarbonate anions in plasma while the completion of gluconeogenesis and/or oxidation occurs via tricarboxylic-acid cycle in mitochondria mainly in liver and kidney, or heart. The general assumption that Lac is 'metabolized to bicarbonate' in liver to serve as a buffer has been questioned. Pyr as a novel buffer would be superior to conventional ones in the correction of metabolic acidosis. Several likely biochemical mechanisms of Pyr action are discussed. Experimental evidence, in vivo, strongly suggested that Pyr would be particularly efficient in the correction of severe acidemia: type A lactic acidosis, hypercapnia with cardiac arrest, and diabetic and alcoholic ketoacidosis in animal experiments and clinic settings. Because of its multi-cytoprotection, Pyrs not only correct acidosis, but also benefit theunderlying dysfunction of vital organs. In addition, Pyr is also a potential buffer component of dialysis solutions. However, the instability of Pyr in aqueous solutions restricts its clinical applications as a therapeutic agent. Attempts to create a stable Pyr preparation are needed.

Buffer transport in peritoneal dialysis

Buffer transport in peritoneal dialysis. The success of peritoneal dialysis as a robust modality of renal replacement therapy has invited a quest for ameliorations in its underlying technology aimed at enhancing patient satisfaction and preserving the central instrument of the therapy, namely the peritoneal membrane. The health and longevity of the membrane have motivated and continue to drive a series of iterative innovations in the composition, methods of production, and delivery of dialysis solutions. It is the purpose of this article to review aspects of these innovations pertaining to buffer composition in dialysis solutions and the peritoneal mechanisms of buffer transport.