Satisfaction with allergy treatments depends on symptom severity but not on allergen specificity in patients with allergic rhinitis

A survey of clinical features of allergic rhinitis in adults

BACKGROUND

Allergic rhinitis (AR) has high prevalence and substantial socio-economic burden.

MATERIAL/METHODS

The study included 35 Italian Centers recruiting an overall number of 3383 adult patients with rhinitis (48% males, 52% females, mean age 29.1, range 18-45 years). For each patient, the attending physician had to fill in a standardized questionnaire, covering, in particular, some issues such as the ARIA classification of allergic rhinitis (AR), the results of skin prick test (SPT), the kind of treatment, the response to treatment, and the satisfaction with treatment.

RESULTS

Out of the 3383 patients with rhinitis, 2788 (82.4%) had AR: 311 (11.5%) had a mild intermittent, 229 (8.8%) a mild persistent, 636 (23.5%) a moderate-severe intermittent, and 1518 (56.1%) a moderate-severe persistent form. The most frequently used drugs were oral antihistamines (77.1%) and topical corticosteroids (60.8%). The response to treatment was judged as excellent in 12.2%, good in 41.3%, fair in 31.2%, poor in 14.5%, and very bad in 0.8% of subjects. The rate of treatment dissatisfaction was significantly higher in patients with moderate-to-severe AR than in patients with mild AR (p<0.0001). Indication to allergen immunotherapy (AIT) was significantly more frequent (p<0.01) in patients with severe AR than with mild AR.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings confirm the appropriateness of ARIA guidelines in classifying the AR patients and the association of severe symptoms with unsuccessful drug treatment. The optimal targeting of patients to be treated with AIT needs to be reassessed.

A survey on features of allergic rhinitis in children

OBJECTIVE

A number of epidemiologic studies evaluated the prevalence of allergic rhinitis (AR), but few data are available on its different clinical presentations. We addressed this survey to assess the features of AR in children and adolescents.

METHODS

Thirty-five centers in Italy included 2623 pediatric patients with rhinitis, of whom 2319 suffered from AR, while 304 had other kinds of rhinitis. For each patient a standardized questionnaire was filled in, including ARIA classification, the duration of symptoms, the allergen identified as clinically relevant, the co-morbidities, the kind of treatment, the response to treatment, the satisfaction with the treatment, and the feasibility of allergen immunotherapy (AIT).

RESULTS

Of the 2319 patients, 597 (25.7%) had mild intermittent, 701 (30.2%) mild persistent, 174 (7.5%) moderate-severe intermittent, and 773 (33.3%) moderate-severe persistent AR. The allergens most relevant were grass pollen and dust mites. The most frequently used drugs were oral antihistamines (83.1%) and topical corticosteroids (63.5%). The response to treatment was judged as excellent in 13.5%, good in 45.1%, fair in 30.8%, poor in 10%, and very bad in 0.6% of cases. The satisfaction with treatment was judged as very satisfactory in 15.2%, satisfactory in 61.8%, unsatisfactory in 22.4%, and very unsatisfactory in 0.5% of cases. AIT was considered indicated in 53.1% of patients with mild intermittent, 79.2% of moderate-severe intermittent, 72.6% of mild persistent, and 82.7% of moderate-severe persistent AR.

CONCLUSIONS

The limitation of this study is that the population was not unselected and this prevents epidemiological significance. These results offer confirmation of the adequacy of ARIA guidelines in classifying patients with AR and of the association of severe phenotype with lack of success of drug treatment.