Attitudes of Psychiatry Residents in Canadian Universities toward Neuroscience and Its Implication in Psychiatric Practice

Senior Residents' Perceived Competence in Evidence-Based Treatments for Major Depressive Disorder

OBJECTIVE

The current study aims to assess the self-reported competence of graduating psychiatry residents in Canada to provide pharmacotherapy and psychotherapy for major depressive disorder as recommended in national practice guidelines.

METHODS

Canadian psychiatry residents who participated in an optional national review course to prepare for licensing were anonymously surveyed regarding their experience and competence in providing treatments recommended by the 2016 Canadian Network for Mood and Anxiety Treatments guidelines.

RESULTS

The majority (89%, 130/146) reported competence in ≥ 5 medication monotherapies (e.g., selective serotonin/norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors, bupropion, mirtazapine) and ≥ 3 adjuncts (e.g., mirtazapine, second-generation antipsychotics). While 76% expressed interest in practicing multiple psychotherapeutic modalities, only 47% reported self-assessed competence in delivering multiple modalities. Only 42% reported pharmacological competence (≥ 5 monotherapies, ≥ 3 adjuncts) and competence in ≥ 2 psychotherapies. Only 9% reported competence in offering medication, psychotherapy, and electroconvulsive therapy. Less than two-thirds endorsed sufficient didactic teaching (58%) or supervision in pharmacotherapy (50%) for treatment-resistant depression.

CONCLUSIONS

Canadian psychiatry residents report competence in prescribing many first-line medications. However, only a minority report competence in prescribing medications and competence in psychotherapies and/or electroconvulsive therapy. Given known biases in assessments by self-report, real-world competence may be even lower. This study identifies gaps between national practice guidelines and the comfort of the emerging psychiatric workforce in delivering recommended treatments. These gaps in resident competence may lead to under-use of effective treatments for depression. Residency programs should consider how to improve resident competence in providing the full range of evidence-based treatments for depression.

Medical Student Attitudes and Perceptions on the Relevance of Neuroscience to Psychiatry: a Mixed Methods Study

OBJECTIVE

Many psychiatry residency programs are actively incorporating neuroscience training into their curricula; however, relatively little scholarship exploring neuroscience and psychiatry integration in undergraduate medical education has been conducted. This study investigated second-year, pre-clerkship medical students' perceptions on the relationship between neuroscience and psychiatry following foundational neuroscience and behavior instruction to identify their views before they enter clerkships.

METHODS

A mixed methods design combined qualitative analysis of medical students' essays in response to the prompt: "What is the relationship between neuroscience and psychiatry?" with quantitative analysis of survey responses on a 7-point scale.

RESULTS

Ninety-three percent of the class participated in the study (n = 77). Learners rated neuroscience as important for understanding and treating psychiatric disorders, albeit less important for psychiatric compared to neurological disorders. Using applied thematic analysis, the authors identified qualitative themes. Specifically, participants recognized neuroscience as a foundational science for psychiatry, but some emphasized that factors other than neuroscience are needed to explain psychiatric disorders. Some students perceived neuroscience and psychiatry as complementary approaches to understanding the brain and behavior. Others identified a role for neuroscience in reducing the stigma of psychiatric disorders and thereby improving access to psychiatric care.

CONCLUSIONS

The quantitative and qualitative findings reinforced each other and provided novel insight to pre-clerkship medical students' views on the relevance of neuroscience for psychiatry. Educating all medical students, not just psychiatry residents, on the neuroscience of psychiatric disorders may better equip the next generation of physicians, regardless of specialty, to care for their patients with psychiatric conditions.