Continuous exposure to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin inhibits the growth of surgically induced endometriosis in the ovariectomized mouse treated with high dose estradiol

Associations between Exposure to Organochlorine Chemicals and Endometriosis: A Systematic Review of Experimental Studies and Integration of Epidemiological Evidence

BACKGROUND

Growing epidemiological evidence suggests that organochlorine chemicals (OCCs), including 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD), may play a role in the pathogenesis of endometriosis.

OBJECTIVES

We aimed to systematically review the experimental evidence (in vivo and in vitro) on the associations between exposure to OCCs and endometriosis-related end points.

METHODS

A systematic review protocol was developed following the National Toxicology Program /Office of Health Assessment and Translation (NTP/OHAT) framework and managed within a web-based interface. In vivo studies designed to evaluate the impact of OCCs on the onset or progression of endometriosis and proliferation of induced endometriotic lesions were eligible. Eligible in vitro studies included single-cell and co-culture models to evaluate the proliferation, migration, and/or invasion of endometrial cells. We applied the search strings to PubMed, Web of Science, and Scopus®. A final search was performed on 24 June 2020. Assessment of risk of bias and the level of evidence and integration of preevaluated epidemiological evidence was conducted using NTP/OHAT framework Results: Out of 812 total studies, 39 met the predetermined eligibility criteria (15 in vivo, 23 in vitro, and 1 both). Most studies (n=27) tested TCDD and other dioxin-like chemicals. In vivo evidence supported TCDD's promotion of endometriosis onset and lesion growth. In vitro evidence supported TCDD's promotion of cell migration and invasion, but there was insufficient evidence for cell proliferation. In vitro evidence further supported the roles of the aryl hydrocarbon receptor and matrix metalloproteinases in mediating steroidogenic disruption and inflammatory responses. Estrogen interactions were found across studies and end points.

CONCLUSION

Based on the integration of a high level of animal evidence with a moderate level of epidemiological evidence, we concluded that TCDD was a known hazard for endometriosis in humans and the conclusion is supported by mechanistic in vitro evidence. Nonetheless, there is need for further research to fill in our gaps in understanding of the relationship between OCCs and their mixtures and endometriosis, beyond the prototypical TCDD. https://doi.org/10.1289/EHP8421.

Plasma levels of polychlorinated biphenyl, genetic polymorphisms, and the risk of advanced stage endometriosis

Both environmental and genetic factors interact and play a critical role in the pathogenesis of endometriosis. We analyzed the plasma levels of 12 polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB) congeners with genetic polymorphisms of glutathione-S-transferase M1 (GSTM1), glutathione-S-transferase T1 (GSTT1), and aryl hydrocarbon receptor repressor (AhRR) codon 185. Total sum of the 12 congeners was significantly higher in the controls compared with endometriosis group. Women without C/C genotype in AhRR codon 185 had a significantly increased risk of endometriosis compared with those with C/C genotype. Total sum of the 12 congeners was significantly higher in women without C/C genotype compared with those with C/C genotype. Adjusting for age and AhRR codon 185 genotype, there was no significant association between exposure to PCBs and the risk of endometriosis. These findings suggest a possible presence of gene-environment interaction, however, we could not see any clear association between exposure to PCBs and the risk of endometriosis.

Wnt pathway: A mechanism worth considering in endocrine disrupting chemical action

Endocrine disrupting chemicals (EDCs) are defined as exogenous substances that can alter the development and functioning of the endocrine system. The Wnt signaling pathway is an evolutionarily conserved pathway consisting of proteins that transmit cell-to-cell receptors through cell surface receptors, regulating important aspects of cell migration, polarity, neural formation, and organogenesis, which determines the fate of the cell during embryonic development. Although the effects of EDCs have been studied in terms of many molecular mechanisms; because of its critical role in embryogenesis, the Wnt pathway is of special interest in EDC exposure. This review provides information about the effects of EDC exposure on the Wnt/β-catenin pathway focusing on studies on bisphenol A, di-(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate, diethylstilbestrol, cadmium, and 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin.

Exposure to the environmental endocrine disruptor TCDD and human reproductive dysfunction: Translating lessons from murine models

Humans and other animals are exposed to a wide array of man-made toxicants, many of which act as endocrine disruptors that exhibit differential effects across the lifespan. In humans, while the impact of adult exposure is known for some compounds, the potential consequences of developmental exposure to endocrine disrupting chemicals (EDCs) is more difficult to ascertain. Animal studies have revealed that exposure to EDCs prior to puberty can lead to adult reproductive disease and dysfunction. Specifically, in adult female mice with an early life exposure to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD), we demonstrated a transgenerational occurrence of several reproductive diseases that have been linked to endometriosis in women. Herein, we review the evidence for TCDD-associated development of adult reproductive disease as well as known epigenetic alterations associated with TCDD and/or endometriosis. We will also introduce new "Organ-on-Chip" models which, combined with our established murine model, are expected to further enhance our ability to examine alterations in gene-environment interactions that lead to heritable disease.

Dioxin and endometrial progesterone resistance

Development of endometriosis likely requires multiple, interactive mechanisms involving both the endocrine and immune systems. Environmental toxicants, such as 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD), are of particular interest as potential contributory agents in the development of this disease because they can disrupt both systems. Nevertheless, defining the potential role that environmental exposure to TCDD plays in the development of endometriosis requires a better understanding of how this toxicant affects the biological processes that promote the disease. Although the disease mechanism(s) responsible for progesterone resistance in the endometrium of endometriosis patients remains speculative, our studies indicate that developmental exposure of mice to TCDD leads to a progesterone-resistant phenotype in adult animals that can persist for several generations. These studies and others underscore the importance of developing a greater understanding of the mechanisms of TCDD action that relate to reproductive disorders such as endometriosis.

Female reproductive disorders: the roles of endocrine-disrupting compounds and developmental timing

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the possible role of endocrine-disrupting compounds (EDCs) on female reproductive disorders emphasizing developmental plasticity and the complexity of endocrine-dependent ontogeny of reproductive organs. Declining conception rates and the high incidence of female reproductive disruptions warrant evaluation of the impact of EDCs on female reproductive health.

DESIGN

Publications related to the contribution of EDCs to disorders of the ovary (aneuploidy, polycystic ovary syndrome, and altered cyclicity), uterus (endometriosis, uterine fibroids, fetal growth restriction, and pregnancy loss), breast (breast cancer, reduced duration of lactation), and pubertal timing were identified, reviewed, and summarized at a workshop.

CONCLUSION(S)

The data reviewed illustrate that EDCs contribute to numerous human female reproductive disorders and emphasize the sensitivity of early life-stage exposures. Many research gaps are identified that limit full understanding of the contribution of EDCs to female reproductive problems. Moreover, there is an urgent need to reduce the incidence of these reproductive disorders, which can be addressed by correlative studies on early life exposure and adult reproductive dysfunction together with tools to assess the specific exposures and methods to block their effects. This review of the EDC literature as it relates to female health provides an important platform on which women's health can be improved.

Endocrine toxicants including 2,3,7,8-terachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) and dioxin-like chemicals and endometriosis: is there a link?

Endometriosis is a common gynecologic disease of unknown etiology affecting approximately 10-15% of women of reproductive age and 50% of infertile women. Estrogen dependence and immune modulation are established features of endometriosis but do not adequately explain the cause of this disorder. In recent years evidence indicated that exposure to environmental toxicants possessing estrogenic activity resulted in endometriosis. However, scant hospital-based case-control studies yielded inconsistent findings and thus did not provide a compelling argument for or against an association between environmental toxicant exposure and endometriosis. Results of animal studies and cell culture experiments, however, suggested that it is biologically plausible for environmental toxicants to affect the pathobiology of endometriosis. In this article, the literature linking environmental toxicants with endometriosis was reviewed and the link with endocrine toxicants discussed.

[Environmental dioxin compounds as the cause of endometriosis and other diseases]

There has been much debate of late about whether or not dioxin, an industrial toxin, could be a causative agent in the onset of endometriosis, a gynaecological disease associated with infertility and pain. Studies found either no difference in serum dioxin concentrations when cases were compared to controls or a non-significant increase, or reached low statistical power. The introductory results on Rhesus monkey contradict with the observations on mice fed with dioxin and oestrogen simultaneously. Genetic comparison shows that human belongs to the dioxin resistant races so dioxin concentrations measured in the population could not cause disease especially not an oestrogen dependent one, like endometriosis.

Reduced expression of progesterone receptor-B in the endometrium of women with endometriosis and in cocultures of endometrial cells exposed to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin

OBJECTIVE

To analyze endometrial progesterone receptor (PR) expression in women with endometriosis compared with disease-free women and to assess the impact of in vitro 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) exposure on PR isotype expression.

DESIGN

Controlled laboratory study.

SETTING

University medical center.

PATIENT(S)

Healthy volunteers and women with surgically diagnosed endometriosis.

INTERVENTION(S)

None.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Analysis of in vivo PR-A and PR-B expression in endometrium from women with and without endometriosis. The impact of in vitro TCDD exposure on PR-B/PR-A ratio and cell-specific matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) expression was also determined.

RESULT(S)

The PR-B/PR-A ratio was lower in endometrial tissues from women with endometriosis compared with normal tissues. A similar ratio was induced in normal stromal cells cocultured with epithelial cells and exposed to TCDD. Disruption of stromal PR expression following TCDD exposure was associated with a failure of P-mediated down-regulation of both stromal-specific pro-MMP-3 and epithelial-specific pro-MMP-7.

CONCLUSION(S)

Our data suggest that reduced progesterone (P) sensitivity in the endometrium of women with endometriosis may be related to an altered pattern of PR expression. The ability of TCDD to selectively down-regulate stromal PR-B expression and increase MMP expression in both stromal and epithelial cells suggests that exposure to this toxin may negatively impact P-mediated cell-cell communication in the human endometrium.

Future directions in endometriosis research

Future research in endometriosis must focus on pathogenesis studies in the baboon model, the early interactions between endometrial and peritoneal cells in the pelvic cavity at the time of menstruation, and potential differences between eutopic endometrium and myometrium in women with and without endometriosis. More integration is needed between the areas of epidemiology and genetics. Pelvic inflammation in women with endometriosis could be the target for new diagnostic and therapeutic approaches. Important questions remain regarding the relationship between endometriosis and environmental factors. Systemic and extrapelvic manifestations of endometriosis must be analyzed carefully, and better tools are needed to measure quality of life in women with chronic pain caused by endometriosis. Most current evidence supports a causal relationship between endometriosis and subfertility, and the spontaneous progressive nature of endometriosis has been demonstrated in 30% to 60% of patients. Recurrence of endometriosis after classic medical and surgical therapy is a major and underestimated problem, especially in women with advanced disease. Integrated clinical and research teams are needed that combine expert medical, surgical, and holistic care with state-of-the-art research expertise in immunology, endocrinology, and genetics to discover new diagnostic methods and medical treatments for endometriosis.

Increased expression of IgE-dependent histamine-releasing factor in endometriotic implants

A complex network of cytokines mediates the immunoregulatory responses leading to endometriosis. Recent intensive studies suggest that monocyte and T cell chemoattractants contribute to the inflammatory environment of endometriotic implants. The relationship between the inflammation present during endometriosis and the development of endometriotic implants in the peritoneal cavity remains unclear. On the other hand, the association between endometriosis and 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD; dioxin) exposure has been discussed in recent years, and our previous results revealed that IgE-dependent histamine-releasing factor (HRF) is inducible by TCDD. The present study aimed to clarify the expression, localization, and function of HRF in endometriosis. Northern blot analysis demonstrated that HRF is overexpressed in endometriotic implants. RT-PCR with Southern blot analysis, however, showed that HRF overexpression was not always accompanied by CYP1A1 induction in endometriotic implants, suggesting that HRF is inducible in endometriosis without exposure to TCDD. HRF is also inducible by macrophage colony-stimulating factor (M-CSF). Immunohistochemistry showed CD68-positive macrophages in the stroma of endometriotic implants, adjacent to regions with prominent HRF accumulation. HRF-overexpressing cells exhibited high implantation efficiency in comparison to control cells when the cells were injected into the peritoneal cavities of nude mice. These results suggest that the accumulation of macrophages in endometriotic implants induces HRF; the overexpression of HRF accelerates the growth of endometriotic implants.

Pathogenesis of endometriosis

Endometriosis is a common gynecologic disorder characterized by the presence of endometrial tissue outside the uterine cavity. Various theories have been put forth to explain the mechanisms for the development of this disease. Although no single theory can explain all cases of endometriosis, the retrograde menstruation theory has gained the widest acceptance. This theory proposes that viable endometrial tissue is refluxed through the fallopian tubes during menstruation and implants on peritoneal surface or pelvic organs. Retrograde menstruation occurs in 76% to 90% of women. The much lower prevalence of endometriosis suggests that additional factors determine susceptibility to endometriosis. Once in the peritoneal cavity, the survival and implantation of endometrial cells seem to be mediated by abnormal MMP and TIMP expression, altered immune milieu, aberrant local aromatase activity, and genetic and environmental factors.

Environmental contaminants and dietary factors in endometriosis

Endometriosis is an estrogen-dependent disease characterized by the presence of endometrial glands and stroma outside the uterine cavity. The etiology of this disease remains elusive, but is clearly influenced by genetic, immune, and endocrine factors. Exposure to environmental contaminants has recently been added to the list of potential factors that contribute to the pathogenesis of endometriosis. The objective of this paper is to review the weight of the evidence from hospital-based case-control studies and animal experiments for an association between exposure to environmental contaminants and endometriosis.

The potential role of exposure to environmental toxicants in the pathophysiology of endometriosis

Humans and animals are exposed daily to a complex mixture of polyhalogenated aromatic hydrocarbons (PHAHs). Previous work has shown that exposure to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) is associated with a dose-dependent increase in the incidence and severity of endometriosis in the rhesus monkey. Dioxin-like chemicals can also exert effects in combination with TCDD via the aryl hydrocarbon receptor. Using a rhesus model of chronic TCDD exposure and endometriosis, serum concentrations of TCDD and 19 dioxin-like PHAHs were quantified 13 years after termination of exposure to TCDD. In additional studies, the immune status of TCDD-exposed monkeys was evaluated. For TCDD-exposed and unexposed animals, TCDD exposure correlated with an increased serum TCDD concentration. Furthermore, TCDD exposure and an elevated serum TCDD concentration were associated with increased serum levels of triglycerides, 1,2,3,6,7,8-hexachlorodibenzofuran (HxCDF), PCB77, and PCB126. Importantly, the animals with elevated serum levels of PCB77 and PCB126 and increased total serum TCDD equivalents (TEQs) had a high prevalence of endometriosis, and the severity of disease correlated with the serum concentration of PCB77. In immune studies, TCDD exposure correlated with increased tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNFalpha) production by peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) in response to stimulation by T cell mitogen and decreased NK cytolytic activity. Elevated serum concentrations of TCDD, 1,2,3,6,7,8-HxCDF, and PCB126 correlated with increased numbers of CD3+/CD25- and CD3-/CD25+ leukocytes and enhanced secretion of TNFalpha by mitogen-stimulated PBMC. This evidence suggests that TCDD exposure and endometriosis in the rhesus monkey may be associated with increased serum concentrations of specific coplanar PCB compounds and long-term alterations in systemic immunity. Furthermore, the data suggest a potential involvement of an increased body burden of PCB compounds in the etiology of endometriosis in the rhesus. Recent advances in the detection and assay of individual PHAH congeners in biological samples have made it possible to assess total PHAH body burden in humans and animals. Future studies are expected to exploit this advance to assess the health impact of PHAH body burdens in both exposed individuals and the general population. Serum PHAH concentrations and TEQs in TCDD-exposed monkeys with endometriosis are similar to or lower than blood levels in the general human population; thus, it is important to consider the implications of these findings for human health and the prevalence of endometriosis in humans. Additional studies are warranted, particularly in human subjects, to explore the potential implications of these data.

Mechanisms of inhibitory aryl hydrocarbon receptor-estrogen receptor crosstalk in human breast cancer cells

The aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AhR) is a ligand-activated transcription factor that forms a functional heterodimeric complex with the AhR nuclear translocator (Arnt) protein. The environmental toxin, 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD), is a high affinity ligand for the AhR and has been extensively used to investigate AhR-mediated biochemical and toxic responses. TCDD modulates several endocrine pathways including inhibition of 17beta-estradiol-induced responses in the immature and ovariectomized rodent uterus and mammary gland and in human breast cancer cell lines. TCDD inhibits formation and growth of mammary tumors in carcinogen-induced rodent models and relatively nontoxic selective AhR modulators (SAhRMs) are being developed for treatment of breast cancer. The mechanisms of inhibitory AhR-estrogen receptor (ER) crosstalk have been investigated in MCF-7 breast cancer cells by analysis of promoter regions of genes induced by E2 and inhibited by TCDD. AhR-mediated inhibition of E2-induced cathepsin D, pS2, c-fos, and heat shock protein 27 gene expression involves direct interaction of the AhR complex with inhibitory pentanucleotide (GCGTG) dioxin responsive elements (iDREs) resulting in disruption of interactions between proteins binding DNA elements required for ER action and the basal transcription machinery. Mechanisms of inhibitory AhR-ER crosstalk indicate that functional iDREs are required for inhibition of some genes; however, results indicate that other interaction pathways are important including AhR-mediated proteasome-dependent degradation of the ER.

Expression of dioxin-related transactivating factors and target genes in human eutopic endometrial and endometriotic tissues

OBJECTIVE

Although an association between dioxin exposure and endometriosis has been proposed, the effects of this environmental toxin on human endometriosis are not known. To understand the potential underlying molecular mechanisms we studied the expressions of cytochrome P-450 genes (CYP1A1, CYP1A2, and CYP1B1 ), which are induced by dioxin, and the expressions of cytosolic receptor for dioxin, aryl hydrocarbon receptor, and its nuclear translocator, aryl hydrocarbon receptor nuclear translocator protein, in endometriotic and eutopic endometrial tissues.

STUDY DESIGN

Levels of transcripts of CYP1A1, CYP1A2, CYP1B1, aryl hydrocarbon receptor, and aryl hydrocarbon receptor nuclear translocator protein were determined by a quantitative reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction and Southern blot assay in total ribonucleic acid samples from endometriotic and eutopic endometrial tissues. Eutopic endometrial tissue samples (n = 33) and endometriotic tissue samples (n = 10) were obtained at the time of uterine curettage and laparoscopy from disease-free women and from patients with endometriosis. Portions of these eutopic endometrial and endometriotic tissues were obtained simultaneously from the same patients (n = 8 pairs of samples). Levels of transcripts of CYP1A1, CYP1A2, CYP1B1, aryl hydrocarbon receptor, and aryl hydrocarbon receptor nuclear translocator protein were determined in endometrial and endometriotic tissues during follicular and luteal phases of the cycle and in cultured endometriotic stromal cells treated with forskolin, phorbol diacetate, medroxyprogesterone acetate,and serum.

RESULTS

Transcripts of dioxin receptor, its nuclear translocator, and two dioxin-induced target genes (CYP1A2 and CYP1B1) were demonstrated during follicular and luteal phases of the cycle in both eutopic endometrial tissues and tissues affected by pelvic endometriosis, with no readily detectable differences between these tissues. On the other hand, levels of transcripts of another dioxin-induced gene, CYP1A1, were found to be strikingly higher in endometriotic tissues than in the eutopic endometrium. Mean levels in endometriotic tissues were 8.7 times those found in eutopic endometrium. Various hormonal treatments of endometriotic stromal cells did not significantly alter these levels.

CONCLUSION

We demonstrated for the first time the expression of dioxin-related transcription factors aryl hydrocarbon receptor and aryl hydrocarbon receptor nuclear translocator protein and target genes CYP1A1, CYP1A2, and CYP1B1 in endometriotic tissues and stromal cells. Strikingly elevated CYP1A1 transcripts in endometriosis may give rise to significantly increased P-4501A1 enzyme activity and thus promote the development and growth of endometriosis by either activating procarcinogens or inducing the formation of catechol estrogens or both. In fact, the proposed link between dioxin exposure and endometriosis may be explained in part by the up-regulation of the CYP1A1 gene expression in endometriotic tissues.

Environmental toxins and endometriosis

The effect of natural, environmental, or manufactured substances on endocrine organs is a current topic of discussion. Recently, some toxicants have been suggested to promote endometriosis; therefore, attention has turned to the role of environmental factors as a stimulant for endometriosis growth and maintenance. This article reviews the influence of various toxicants on endometriosis.