Seizures in Chiari I malformation: a clinical and electroencephalographic study

Chiari 1 Malformation and Epilepsy in Children: A Missing Relationship

Purpose: Once believed a result of pathophysiological correlations, the association between Chiari 1 malformation (CM1) and epilepsy has since been considered as a coincidence, due to missing etiologic or clinical matching points. At present, the problem is being newly debated because of the increasing number of CM1 diagnoses, often among children with seizures. No specific studies on this topic are available yet. The present study aimed at updating the information on this topic by reporting on a series of children specifically enrolled and retrospectively analyzed for this purpose. Methods: All children admitted between January 2015 and June 2020 for epilepsy and CM1 were considered (Group 1). They were compared with children admitted in the same period for symptoms/signs related to CM1 and/or syringomyelia (Group 2). Syndromic patients were excluded, as well as those with tumoral or other overt intracranial lesions. All patients received a complete preoperative work-up, including MRI and EEG. Symptomatic children with CM1/syringomyelia were operated on. The pertinent literature was reviewed. Results: Group 1 was composed of 29 children (mean age: 6.2 years) showing CM1 and epilepsy with several types of seizures. A share of 27% had CM1-related symptoms and syringomyelia. The mean tonsillar ectopia was 7.5 mm. Surgery was performed in 31% of cases. Overall, 62% of children are currently seizure-free (including 5/9 children who were operated on). Tonsillar herniation and syringomyelia regressed in 4/9 cases and 4/8 cases, improved in 4/9 cases and 3/8 cases, and remained stable in 1/9 and 1/8 cases, respectively. CM1 signs/symptoms regressed completely in 6/8 cases and improved or remained stable in one case in each of the two remaining patients. Group 2 consisted of 77 children (mean age: 8.9 years) showing symptoms of CM1 (75%) and/or syringomyelia (39%). The mean tonsillar ectopia was 11.8 mm. Non-specific EEG anomalies were detected in 13 children (17%). Surgery was performed in 76.5% of cases (18 children were not operated on because of oligosymptomatic). Preoperative symptoms regressed in 26%, improved in 50%, remained stable 22%, and worsened in 2%; CM1 radiologically regressed in 39%, improved in 37%, remained unchanged in 22%, and worsened in 2%; and syringomyelia/hydromyelia regressed in 61%, improved in 30%, and was stable in 9%. No statistically significant differences between the two groups were detected regarding the M/F ratio, presence of syringomyelia/hydromyelia, or CM1/syringomyelia outcome; moreover, no correlation occurred between seizure-free condition and PF decompression in Group 1, or between disappearance of EEG anomalies and PF decompression in Group 2. A significant difference between the two groups was noticed regarding the mean age at admission (p = 0.003), amount of tonsillar herniation (p < 0.00001), and PF decompression (p = 0.0001). Conclusions: These findings do not support clinical correlations between CM1 and epilepsy. Their course depends on surgery and antiepileptic drugs, respectively. The analysis of the literature does not provide evidence of a relationship between seizures and cerebellar anomalies such as CM1. Rather than being linked to a syndrome that could explain such an association, the connection between the two now has to be considered to be random.

Clinical diagnosis-part II: what is attributed to Chiari I

PURPOSE

Chiari malformation type I is identified as radiological appearance of cerebellar tonsil herniation below the foramen magnum. The wide spectrum of clinical manifestations variably associated sometimes encompasses signs and symptoms whose correlation with the malformation remains debatable. However, a correct clinical framework is relevant in tailoring the strategy of management, and in particular, establishing the appropriate surgical intervention.

METHODS

An analysis of relevant articles on this issue was performed, involving both single case reports and case series. The papers were obtained from electronic databases including PubMed/MEDLINE and Google Scholar, as well as direct contact with some authors.

RESULTS

This review focuses on those unusual clinical pictures attributed to Chiari malformation type I (CMI), investigating their actual relationship with the morphological condition. Supposed physiopathogenetic mechanisms and clinical relevance are discussed along with an analysis on the surgical indications and results.

CONCLUSION

There is no clear explanation on why some patients may exhibit uncommon symptoms, often in association with the most frequent ones, but even reported as single initial clinical occurrence. Their actual incidence may have been roughly underestimated in the literature so far, because of wide heterogeneity of selection and analysis among different studies. Most of the authors appear sharing the impression that CMI surgical decompression plays a significant role in controlling the majority of these unusual symptoms, stressing their actual occurrence in relation with the malformation. A routinely multidisciplinary clinical approach has become advisable to encompass the diversity of conditions potentially associated with CMI and improve the care of CMI patients.

Chiari 1 Malformation in a Child with Febrile Seizures, Parasomnias, and Sleep Apnea Syndrome

Introduction

The type I is the most common Chiari malformation in children. In this condition, the lower part of the cerebellum, but not the brain stem, extends into the foramen magnum at the base of the skull leading to disturbances in cerebrospinal fluid circulation and to direct compression of nervous tissue.

Case report

We describe a 4-year-old Caucasian female child with febrile seizures, headache, parasomnias, and a delay of speech. The child underwent a magnetic resonance imaging to investigate these neurological signs, disclosing a Chiari malformation type 1. The polysomnography showed a mild-moderate sleep-disordered breathing, increased number of central sleep apneas, and generalized spike waves at sleep onset.

Conclusions

Seizures have been seldom described in CM1 patients. The main reasons for performing MRI in this case were frequent seizures, a delay of speech, and headache, leading to an unexpected diagnosis of CM1. Polysomnography detected a discrete SDB.

The association between Chiari-like malformation, ventriculomegaly and seizures in cavalier King Charles spaniels

Cavalier King Charles spaniels (CKCSs) with Chiari-like malformation (CM) and associated seizures are frequently diagnosed with idiopathic epilepsy. There could be an association between ventriculomegaly (V) or caudal fossa overcrowding (CCFP) and seizures. A retrospective case-control study was performed using MRI to investigate the possible association between these morphological abnormalities and seizures. Seizure semiology and, where possible, electroencephalographic (EEG) abnormalities were documented. Eighty-five CKCS with CM were included, 27 with seizures. There was no association between V or CCFP and seizures (P=0.10 and 0.71, respectively). Seizures were classified as having partial onset in 61% of individuals in the study population (95% CI 42.41-76.43%). Another cause of recurrent seizures in CKCS (such as familial epilepsy) is suspected, as previously reported.

Epilepsy in type 1 Chiari malformation

In patients with Chiari malformation type 1 (CMI), epileptic seizures are occasionally reported both in symptomatic patients candidate to surgery and in patients without symptoms of tonsillar displacement in whom CM1 is often an incidental finding in the diagnostic work up for idiopathic epilepsies. In both groups of patients, the course of epilepsy is almost invariably favorable, with a few seizures easily controlled by treatment. In a subset of CM1 patients, epilepsy occurs in the context of neurodevelopmental disorders that also include mental retardation, autism and somatic dysmorphisms. Epileptic seizures must be accurately differentiated by potentially harmful paroxysmal events due to compression of the medulla, particularly by the cerebellar fits characterized by drop attacks, abnormal extensor posturing and apnea.

Chiari type I malformation in children

The diagnosis of Chiari type I malformation (CIM) is more and more frequent in clinical practice due to the wide diffusion of magnetic resonance imaging. In many cases, such a diagnosis is made incidentally in asymptomatic patients, as including children investigated for different reasons such as mental development delay or sequelae of brain injury. The large number of affected patients, the presence of asymptomatic subjects, the uncertainties surrounding the pathogenesis of the malformation, and the different options for its surgical treatment make the management of CIM particularly controversial.This paper reports on the state of the art and the recent achievements about CIM aiming at providing further information especially on the pathogenesis, the natural history, and the management of the malformation, which are the most controversial aspects. A historial review introduces and explains the current classification. Furthermore, the main clinical, radiological, and neurophysiological findings of CIM are described to complete the picture of this heterogeneous and complex disease.

Cerebellar hypoplasia, continuous spike-waves during sleep, and neuropsychological and behavioral disorders

We describe 3 patients with different degrees of cerebellar hypoplasia and continuous spike-waves during sleep: the more extensive the cerebellar hypoplasia, the more compromised the neuropsychological abilities and behavior. Cerebellar hypoplasia is a risk factor for epilepsy and/or neuropsychological and psychiatric disorders. Epilepsy is also strongly associated with familial antecedents for seizures, as previously reported. The cerebellum is implicated in controlling epileptic seizures and in regulating motor, cognitive, and emotional functions with a topographic organization. The association between cerebellar hypoplasia and continuous spike-waves during sleep has never been reported. We suggest that continuous spike-waves during sleep may further compromise neuropsychological and behavioral features that are associated with cerebellar hypoplasia.

Association of intracranial hypertension without ventriculomegaly and Chiari malformation: a dangerous combination

With the increased use of MRI, tonsillar ectopia, the hallmark of the adult Chiari malformation (ACM) is being more frequently recognized. However, in some cases, the patient's symptoms do not fit with the classical presentation for ACM, but are similar to intracranial hypertension (IH). The latter may be difficult to diagnose in absence of ventricular enlargement. We report a case of ACM and IHWV due to carcinomatous meningitis.

Clinical features of epilepsy in patients with cerebellar structural abnormalities in a referral center

PURPOSE

The objective of this study was to describe epilepsy localization, clinical features and surgery outcome in patients with epilepsy and cerebellar structural abnormalities.

METHODS

We identified 10 patients with cerebellar lesions and epilepsy from our epilepsy database. Patients with only cerebellar atrophy were excluded. Medical records were reviewed for demographic data, seizure history, examination findings, EEG findings, epilepsy treatment and course. We reviewed imaging data for cerebellar structural findings, as well as cerebral abnormalities.

RESULTS

Out of 2288 epilepsy patients in the database, 10 had epilepsy and cerebellar structural abnormalities other than atrophy. Their ages ranged from 26 to 52 years. The most common cerebellar malformations included Dandy-Walker malformation, cerebellar tumors and posterior fossa arachnoid cyst. Epilepsy was classified as generalized in one patient. Nine patients had focal epilepsy: the localization was temporal in five, frontal in one, occipital in one, and unclassified in two. A cerebral structural abnormality considered responsible for epilepsy was identified in six patients; four had hippocampal sclerosis, one had a hippocampal malformation, and one had a temporal pole cortical malformation. Presurgical evaluation was done in six patients. Surgery was performed in five, with excellent outcome in four.

CONCLUSION

In this small series, epilepsy associated with cerebellar malformations was usually focal, most often with a temporal lobe focus. The cerebellar lesions did not adversely affect surgical success.

CHERI: time to identify the syndrome?

Chiari I malformations are congenital abnormalities that are etiologically heterogeneous. Some studies recognize a probable association between Chiari 1 malformation, delayed language or motor development, and mental retardation with or without epilepsy. The present patient appeared to have an isolated cleft palate and Chiari 1 malformation with co-existing functional and behavioral disorders (i.e., speech delay, mental retardation, and deviant electroencephalography [EEG]). In consideration of the cleft palate population, the implication of the present case study is that more attention should be paid to the developmental milestones in children with cleft palate. Because several cases of Chiari I anomaly co-occurring with mental retardation and deviant EEG or epilepsy have been recognized, it appears justified to identify a syndrome, which is here called CHERI (Chiari 1 malformation with or without cleft palate, deviant EEG or epilepsy, and retarded intelligence with delayed language development). It will be important in the future to describe those cases identified to delineate the clinical picture and to estimate the frequency of the occurrence of various characteristics.

Refractory seizures associated with an organic aciduria in a dog

A 6-month-old, female Cavalier King Charles spaniel exhibited seizures that were difficult to control with standard anticonvulsants over a 12-month period. The diagnosis of an organic aciduria with excessive excretion of hexanoylglycine was determined when the dog was 20 months old. Recurrent and cluster seizures were eventually controlled with the addition of levetiracetam to potassium bromide and phenobarbital.

Bilateral perysilvian polymicrogyria in Chiari I malformation

CASE REPORT

We report on a 7-year-old girl with generalized epilepsy and mental retardation.

DISCUSSION

Neurologic examination was normal and only facial dysmorphic features, compatible with frontonasal dysplasia, were observed. However, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) revealed Chiari I malformation together with bilateral opercular polymicrogyria. To our knowledge, this is the first report of the association of these developmental disorders. This condition raises questions regarding the ethiopathogenetic classification of Chiari spectrum and as to whether embryologic and genetic causes could be potentially interconnected.

Evaluation and management of the Chiari malformation type 1 for the primary care pediatrician

Diagnosis and treatment of CMI is undergoing reexamination that includes redefinition of the anatomic Chiari malformation and refinement and redefinition of the clinical syndrome. Children with SMI present with head pain of some kind, a neurologic deficit, or with signs of spinal cord dysfunction from syrinx. Some will present with no clinical syndrome at all. Presence of anatomic Chiari malformation or compelling clinical Chiari syndrome should lead to evaluation by a neurologist or neurosurgeon experienced with the syndromes and their treatment. Treatment options are varied but usually result in resolution of symptoms. When symptoms persist after surgery, management is complex and not uniformly successful, even in the most experienced hands.

Neurological signs and results of magnetic resonance imaging in 40 cavalier King Charles spaniels with Chiari type 1-like malformations

In human beings a Chiari type 1 malformation is a developmental condition characterised by cerebellar herniation and syringohydromyelia. Abnormalities compatible with such a malformation were identified by magnetic resonance imaging in 39 cavalier King Charles spaniels with neurological signs and in one neurologically normal cavalier King Charles spaniel that was examined postmortem. The dogs with these abnormalities had a wide variety of neurological signs, but there was no apparent correlation between the neurological signs and the severity of cerebellar herniation, syringohydromyelia or hydrocephalus.

Spinal anesthesia for cesarean delivery in a woman with a surgically corrected type I Arnold Chiari malformation

IMPLICATIONS

We report the successful management and outcome of spinal anesthesia for Cesarean delivery in a woman with a surgically corrected Arnold Chiari Type 1 malformation, a seizure disorder, and idiopathic thrombocytopenia of pregnancy.

Association of Chiari I malformation, mental retardation, speech delay, and epilepsy: a specific disorder?

OBJECTIVE

The Chiari I malformation is defined as tonsillar herniation of at least 3 to 5 mm below the foramen magnum. Although Chiari I malformation is considered to derive from a mesodermal disorder resulting in underdevelopment of the posterior fossa relative to its content, evidence for a possible heterogeneous etiology also has been reported. The aim of the present study is to elucidate the relationship between Chiari I malformation and mental retardation, speech delay, and epilepsy to consider a possible specific pathogenetic background.

METHODS

Thirty-five patients with Chiari I malformations were identified by use of magnetic resonance imaging during a period between 1993 and 1999. The study consisted of nine patients (four boys and five girls) who were affected by mental retardation, speech delay, and epilepsy. All patients underwent electroencephalography and brain and cervical spine magnetic resonance imaging.

RESULTS

All patients were mentally retarded with a mean intelligence quotient of 50. Seven patients had a positive history for speech delay, and five were epileptic. Electroencephalograms demonstrated abnormalities in seven patients. The mean tonsillar displacement was 10.1 mm. A thin corpus callosum and a wide cavum septum pellucidum were present in three patients. Neither hydromyelia nor scoliosis was observed. No correlation between the degree of the ectopia and clinical manifestation was noted.

CONCLUSION

The association of Chiari I malformation with epilepsy, speech delay, and mental retardation may not be a mere incidental finding but may be a marker for a different pathogenetic background.

Cerebellar fits in children with Chiari I malformation

OBJECT

The authors describe a series of children with Chiari I malformation who presented with fulminating symptoms of "cerebellar fits" characterized by drop attacks with or without deterioration of consciousness, opisthotonic posturing, and varying degrees of respiratory compromise.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis was undertaken of the medical records of 47 consecutive patients undergoing surgery for symptomatic Chiari I malformations at Rainbow Babies and Children's Hospital. Thirteen (28%) of the 47 patients presented with complaints consistent with cerebellar fits. Before the correct diagnosis was made, nine (69%) of the 13 children had previously undergone evaluation with electroencephalography and/or electrocardicography and Holter monitoring because of suspected cortical epilepsy or cardiogenic syncope. In each of the 13 children magnetic resonance imaging demonstrated pegged cerebellar tonsils herniated below the foramen magnum. A deep indentation or blanched discoloration of the cerebellar tonsils was noted in five (38%) of these 13 patients at the time of surgery. Of patients with symptomatic Chiari I malformations, the mean degree of tonsillar herniation was significantly less for those in whom cerebellar fits occurred than those in whom they were absent (8.8 mm and 13.9 mm, respectively; p = 0.007). In only one of the patients with cerebellar fits was a syrinx present, and this was a small focal lower thoracic collection. Spells resolved after surgery in all patients who presented with cerebellar fits.

CONCLUSIONS

Cerebellar fits may mimic other disorders such as cardiogenic syncope and epileptic seizures. The correct diagnosis may be delayed or the conditions may be misdiagnosed by those who fail to consider Chiari I malformation as a cause of drop attacks, abnormal extensor posturing, and apneic spells in children. The response to decompressive surgery in these patients is gratifying.