Animal Models in Peritoneal Dialysis Research: A Need for Consensus

The development of an adequate animal model for peritoneal research remains an object of concern. In vivo peritoneal dialysis (PD) research is hampered by the large variety of available models that make interpretation of results and comparison of studies very difficult. Species and strain of experimental animals, method of peritoneal access, study duration, measures of solute transport and ultrafiltration, and sampling for histology differ substantially among the various research groups. A collective effort to discuss the shortcomings and merits of the different experimental models may lead to a consensus on a standardized animal model of PD.

The Effects of Peritoneal Dialysis Solutions on Peritoneal Host Defense

Conventional peritoneal dialysis fluid (PDF) is a bioincompatible solution owing to the acidic pH, the high glucose concentrations and the associated hyperosmolarity, the high lactate concentrations, and the presence of glucose degradation products (GDPs). This unphysiologic composition adversely affects peritoneal host defense and may thus contribute to the development of PD-related peritonitis. The viability of polymorphonuclear leukocytes, monocytes, peritoneal macrophages, and mesothelial cells is severely depressed in the presence of conventional PDF. In addition, the production of inflammatory cytokines and chemoattractants by these cells is markedly affected by conventional PDF. Further, conventional PDF hampers the recruitment of circulating leukocytes in response to an infectious stimulus. Finally, phagocytosis, respiratory burst, and bacterial killing are markedly lower when polymorphonuclear leukocytes, monocytes, and peritoneal macrophages are exposed to conventional PDF. Although there are a few discrepant results, all major PDF components have been implicated as causative factors. Generally, novel PDF with alternative osmotic agents or with alternative buffers, neutral pH, and low GDP content have much milder inhibitory effects on peritoneal host defense. Clinical studies, however, still need to demonstrate their superiority with respect to the incidence of PD-related peritonitis.

Better Preservation of the Peritoneum in Rats Exposed to Amino Acid-Based Peritoneal Dialysis Fluid

Background

Glucose-containing peritoneal dialysis fluids (PDF) show impaired biocompatibility, which is related partly to their high glucose content, presence of glucose degradation products, low pH, and lactate buffer, or a combination of these factors. In a rat chronic peritoneal exposure model, we compared effects of an amino acid-based PDF (AA-PDF) with a glucose-containing PDF on the peritoneal microcirculation and morphology.

Method

Two groups of rats received 10 mL of either fluid daily for 5 weeks via peritoneal catheters connected to implanted subcutaneous mini vascular access ports. Leukocyte–endothelium interactions in the mesenteric venules were investigated by intravital microscopy. Quantification of angiogenesis and fibrosis and inspection of the mesothelial cell layer were performed by light and electron microscopy.

Results

Daily exposure to glucose-containing PDF resulted in a significant increase in the number of rolling leukocytes in mesenteric venules, whereas instillation of AA-PDF did not change the level of leukocyte rolling. Glucose-containing PDF evoked a significantly higher number of milky spots in the omentum, whereas this response was significantly reduced in animals exposed to the AA-PDF ( p < 0.02). Chronic instillation of glucose-containing PDF induced angiogenesis in various peritoneal tissues, accompanied by fibrosis in the mesentery and parietal peritoneum. Quantitative morphometric evaluation of omentum and mesentery showed a clear trend toward less angiogenesis after treatment with the AA-PDF compared to the glucose-containing PDF, which reached statistical significance in the parietal peritoneum ( p < 0.04). Instillation of AA-PDF resulted in approximately 50% reduction of fibrosis in the mesentery ( p < 0.04) and approximately 25% reduction in the parietal peritoneum ( p < 0.009) compared to glucose-containing PDF. Glucose-containing PDF damaged the mesothelial cell layer, whereas the mesothelium was intact after AA-PDF treatment, as evidenced by electron microscopy.

Conclusion

Our data in a rat chronic peritoneal exposure model clearly demonstrate reduced immune activation (evidenced by decreased number of rolling leukocytes and decreased induction of omental milky spots) and reduced neoangiogenesis, fibrosis, and mesothelial damage of the peritoneal membrane after treatment with AA-PDF compared to glucose-containing PDF.

Peritoneal Dialysis Catheter Increases Leukocyte Recruitment in the Mouse Parietal Peritoneum Microcirculation and Causes Fibrosis

♦

BACKGROUND

The objective of this study was to examine the effects of a conventional dialysis solution and peritoneal catheter on leukocyte-endothelial cell interactions in the microcirculation of the parietal peritoneum in a subacute peritoneal dialysis (PD) mouse model. ♦

METHODS

An intraperitoneal (IP) catheter with a subcutaneous injection port was implanted into mice and, after a 2-week healing period, the animals were injected daily for 6 weeks with a 2.5% dextrose solution. Intravital microscopy (IVM) of the parietal peritoneum microcirculation was performed 4 hours after the last injection of the dialysis solution. Leukocyte-endothelial cell interactions were quantified and compared with catheterized controls without dialysis treatment and naïve mice. ♦

RESULTS

The number of rolling and extravascular leukocytes along with peritoneal fibrosis and neovascularization were significantly increased in the catheterized animals compared with naïve mice but did not significantly differ between the 2 groups of catheterized animals with sham injections or dialysis solution treatment. ♦

CONCLUSION

The peritoneal catheter implant increased leukocyte rolling and extravasation, peritoneal fibrosis and vascularization in the parietal peritoneum independently from the dialysis solution treatment.

Angiogenesis in peritoneal dialysis

Long-term exposure to peritoneal dialysis fluid induces morphological alterations, including angiogenesis, leading to a loss of ultrafiltration (UF) capacity. We discuss the effect of different factors in peritoneal dialysis (PD) on angiogenesis. In addition, we describe the process of angiogenesis and the possible role of different cell types in the peritoneum upon PD contributing to new blood vessel formation. Furthermore, we review several interventions used in our rat PD exposure model to decrease angiogenesis in PD. Moreover, we show new data on the use of sunitinib to inhibit angiogenesis in this rat model. Although various interventions seem to be promising, well-randomised clinical trials showing absolute prevention of angiogenesis and UF failure are, yet, still missing. To make real progress in PD treatment, the aim should be to prevent angiogenesis as well as peritoneal fibrosis and PD-induced inflammation.

Peritoneal dialysis fluid bioincompatibility and new vessel formation promote leukocyte-endothelium interactions in a chronic rat model for peritoneal dialysis

Peritoneal dialysis (PD)-induced peritonitis leads to dysfunction of the peritoneal membrane. During peritonitis, neutrophils are recruited to the inflammation site by rolling along the endothelium, adhesion, and transmigration through vessel walls. In a rat PD-model, long-term effects of PD-fluids (PDF) on leukocyte-endothelium interactions and neutrophil migration were studied under baseline and inflammatory conditions. Rats received daily conventional-lactate-buffered PDF (Dianeal), bicarbonate/lactate-buffered PDF (Physioneal) or bicarbonate/lactate buffer (Buffer) during five weeks. Untreated rats served as control. Baseline leukocyte rolling and N-formylmethionyl-leucyl-phenylalanine (fMLP) induced levels of transmigration in the mesentery were evaluated and quantified by intra-vital videomicroscopy and immunohistochemistry. Baseline leukocyte rolling was unaffected by buffer treatment, approximately 2-fold increased after Physioneal and 4-7-fold after Dianeal treatment. After starting fMLP superfusion, transmigrated leukocytes appeared outside the venules firstly after Dianeal treatment (15 minutes), thereafter in Physioneal and Buffer groups (20-22 minutes), and finally in control rats (>25 minutes). Newly formed vessels and total number of transmigrated neutrophils were highest in Dianeal-treated animals, followed by Physioneal and Buffer, and lowest in control rats and correlated for all groups to baseline leukocyte rolling (r = 0.78, P < 0.003). This study indicates that the start of inflammatory neutrophil transmigration is related to PDF bio(in)compatibility, whereas over time neutrophil transmigration is determined by the degree of neo-angiogenesis.

Factors Contributing to Peritoneal Tissue Remodeling in Peritoneal Dialysis

Peritoneal dialysis (PD) is associated with functional and structural changes of the peritoneal membrane. In this review we describe factors contributing to peritoneal tissue remodeling, including uremia, peritonitis, volume loading, the presence of a catheter, and the PD fluid itself. These factors initiate recruitment and activation of peritoneal cells such as macrophages and mast cells, as well as activation of peritoneal cells, including mesothelial cells, fibroblasts, and endothelial cells. We provide an overview of cytokines, growth factors, and other mediators involved in PD-associated changes. Activation of downstream pathways of cellular modulators can induce peritoneal tissue remodeling, leading to ultrafiltration loss. Identification of molecular pathways, cells, and cytokines involved in the development of angiogenesis, fibrosis, and membrane failure may lead to innovative therapeutic strategies that can protect the peritoneal membrane from the consequences of long-term PD.

Acute effects of peritoneal dialysis solutions in the mesenteric microcirculation

Long-term peritoneal dialysis induces morphological changes that may lead to gradual functional impairment of the peritoneal membrane. These changes are characterized by progressive reduction in solute transport or ultrafiltration failure. The mechanism of the peritoneal response to dialysis fluids has not yet been fully elucidated. We used video-microscopy for in vivo evaluation of microhemodynamics and peritoneal microvascular inflammatory response, after a single intraperitoneal exposure of rats to commercial PD fluids: (1) glucose 1.5 % PD solution; (2) lactate buffered glucose 4.25% PD solution; (3) Icodextrin 7%; (4) bicarbonate buffered glucose 3.86% PD fluid; and 5) Hanks solution. Sham-control groups were not injected. A 5-h exposure of the peritoneal membrane to glucose 1.5% PD solution or to Hanks solution did not induce a significant change in leukocyte rolling and adhesion. In contrast, PD solutions containing glucose 4.25% or Icodextrin 7.5% caused a significant 2-3-fold increase in leukocyte rolling (P < 0.001) and adhesion (P < 0.001) and a significant increase in venular blood flow velocity (P < 0.01) and shear rates (P < 0.05 for glucose 4.25%, and P < 0.01 for Icodextrin). Exposure to glucose 3.86% bicarbonate buffered (Physioneal) solution was associated with the lowest values of leukocyte rolling and adhesion among the PD solutions and with extremely higher venular flow velocities and shear rates. A single exposure to conventional PD solutions with a high concentration of glucose (4.25%) or polyglucose (Icodextrin 7.5%) induces changes consistent with an early peritoneal inflammatory response that may be attenuated by the use of bicarbonate-based fluids.

Novel role for mast cells in omental tissue remodeling and cell recruitment in experimental peritoneal dialysis

Because of its dynamic structure, the omentum plays a key role in the immunity of the peritoneal cavity by orchestrating peritoneal cell recruitment. Because mast cells accumulate in the omentum upon experimental peritoneal dialysis (PD) and may produce angiogenic/profibrotic factors, it was hypothesized that mast cells mediate omental tissue remodeling during PD. Daily treatment with conventional PD fluid (PDF) for 5 wk resulted in a strong omental remodeling response, characterized by an approximately 10-fold increase in mast cell density (P < 0.01), an approximately 20-fold increase in vessel density (P < 0.02), an approximately 20-fold increase in the number of milky spots (P < 0.01), and a four-fold increase in submesothelial matrix thickness (P < 0.0003) in wild-type rats. In contrast, all PDF-induced omental changes were significantly reduced in mast cell-deficient Ws/Ws rats or in wild-type rats that were treated orally with a mast cell stabilizer cromoglycate. A time-course experiment showed mast cell accumulation immediately before the formation of blood vessels and milky spots. Functionally, PDF evoked a peritoneal cell influx, which was significantly reduced in Ws/Ws rats (P < 0.04) and in wild-type rats that were treated with cromoglycate (P < 0.03). Cromoglycate treatment also completely prevented PDF-induced omental adhesions to the catheter tip (P = 0.0002). Mesothelial damage, angiogenesis, and fibrosis of mesentery and parietal peritoneum as well as glucose absorption rate and ultrafiltration capacity proved to be mast cell independent. Data strongly support the hypothesis that mast cells mediate PDF-induced omental tissue remodeling and, subsequently, peritoneal cell influx and adhesion formation, providing therapeutic possibilities of modulating omental function.

Beneficial effects of aminoguanidine on peritoneal microcirculation and tissue remodelling in a rat model of PD

BACKGROUND

The formation of glucose degradation products (GDPs) and accumulation of advanced glycation end products (AGEs) partly contribute to the bioincompatibility of peritoneal dialysis fluids (PDF). Aminoguanidine (AG) scavenges GDPs and prevents the formation of AGEs.

METHODS

In a peritoneal dialysis (PD) rat model, we evaluated the effects of the addition of AG to the PDF on microcirculation and morphology of the peritoneum, by intravital microscopy and quantitative morphometric analysis.

RESULTS

AG-bicarbonate effectively scavenged different GDPs from PDF. Daily exposure to PDF for 5 weeks resulted in a significant increase in leucocyte rolling in mesenteric venules, which could be reduced for approximately 50% by addition of AG-bicarbonate (P<0.02). Vascular leakage was found in rats treated with PDF/AG-bicarbonate, but not with PDF alone. Evaluation of visceral and parietal peritoneum showed the induction of angiogenesis and fibrosis after PDF instillation. PDF/AG-bicarbonate significantly reduced vessel density in omentum and parietal peritoneum (P<0.04), but not in mesentery. PDF-induced fibrosis was significantly reduced by AG (P<0.02). PDF instillation led to AGE accumulation in mesentery, which was inhibited by supplementation of AG. Since addition of AG-bicarbonate to PDF raised pH from 5.2 to 8.5, a similar experiment was performed with AG-hydrochloride that did not change the fluid acidity. We could reproduce most of the results obtained with AG-bicarbonate; however, AG-hydrochloride induced no microvascular leakage and had a minor effect on angiogenesis.

CONCLUSION

The supplementation of either AG reduced a number of PDF-induced alterations in our model, emphasizing the involvement of GDPs and/or AGEs in the PDF-induced peritoneal injury.

Immunopathological changes in a uraemic rat model for peritoneal dialysis

BACKGROUND

Peritoneal dialysis (PD) is a treatment modality for patients with renal failure. Both the uraemic state of these patients and chronic exposure to PD fluid are associated with the development of functional and structural alterations of the peritoneal membrane. In a well-established chronic PD rat model, we compared rats with normal renal function with subtotal nephrectomized rats that developed uraemia.

METHODS

Uraemic and control rats received daily 10 ml conventional glucose containing PD fluid, via peritoneal catheters during a 6 week period. Uraemic and control rats receiving no PD fluid served as controls. Parameters relevant for peritoneal defence and serosal healing responses were analyzed.

RESULTS

Uraemic animals were characterized by 2-3-fold increased serum urea and creatinine levels, accompanied by a significantly reduced haematocrit. Uraemia (without PD fluid exposure) induced new blood vessels in different peritoneal tissues, accompanied by increased accumulation of advanced glycation end products (AGEs) and elevated levels of angiogenic factors such as vascular endothelial growth factor and monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 (MCP-1) in peritoneal lavage fluid. A much stronger peritoneal response was observed upon PD fluid exposure in non-uraemic rats. This included the induction of angiogenesis and fibrosis in various peritoneal tissues, accumulation of AGEs, immunological activation of the omentum, damage to the mesothelial cell layer, focal formation of granulation tissues and increased MCP-1 and hyaluronan levels in peritoneal lavage fluid. Finally, chronic PD fluid instillation in uraemic rats did not induce an additional peritoneal response compared to PD fluid exposure in non-uraemic rats, except for the degree of AGE accumulation.

CONCLUSIONS

Both uraemia and PD fluid exposure result in pathological alterations of the peritoneum. However, uraemia did not induce major additive effects to PD fluid-induced injury. These results substantially contribute to the understanding of the pathobiology of the peritoneum under PD conditions.

In vitro and in vivo models for peritonitis demonstrate unchanged neutrophil migration after exposure to dialysis fluids

BACKGROUND

Recurrent infections in peritoneal dialysis (PD) patients may alter the abdominal wall resulting in an impairment of its dialysis capacity. In this study we investigated both in vitro and in vivo the effects of mesothelial exposure to dialysis fluids on the migration of neutrophils and their capacity to clear a bacterial infection.

METHODS

First, we evaluated neutrophil migration in an in vitro transwell model for the peritoneal membrane with monolayers of primary human mesothelial cells (MC) on the lower side and primary human endothelial cells (EC) on top of the same transwell membrane, upon exposure of MC to PD fluid (PDF)-derived components. In addition to this in vitro model, we combined chronic peritoneal exposure to PDF with a peritoneal infection model in the rat. We investigated the kinetics of the chemokine response, neutrophil recruitment and bacterial clearance.

RESULTS

Known chemoattractants, such as fMLP and IL-8, strongly increased neutrophil migration across both cell layers in the in vitro model of the peritoneal membrane. Pre-incubation of the MC layer for 48 h with 55 mM glucose, a combination of two glucose degradation products, methylglyoxal and 3-deoxyglucosone, or conventional dialysis fluid (1:4 dilution), however, did not change the IL-8-induced migration of neutrophils. In concert with this finding we demonstrated an unchanged MC expression of ICAM-1 and VCAM-1 after these pre-treatments. Unexpectedly, chronic i.p. exposure to conventional PDF or a recently developed lactate/bicarbonate-buffered PDF in a rat peritoneal exposure model strongly hampered the chemokine response upon bacterial challenge. Nevertheless, neutrophil recruitment and bacterial clearance were effective and did not differ from rats not pre-exposed to PDF.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that exposure of MC to PDF does not hamper the recruitment of functional neutrophils upon challenge.

The application of animal models to study the biocompatibility of bicarbonate-buffered peritoneal dialysis solutions

The application of animal models to study the biocompatibility of bicarbonate-buffered peritoneal dialysis solutions. Patients treated with peritoneal dialysis (PD) are at risk for development of ultrafiltration failure and peritonitis. These two significant complications can result in the termination of PD treatment. The relative unphysiologic composition of the currently used standard peritoneal dialysis fluids (PDF) is considered to be a major cause for the development of morphologic changes of the peritoneal membrane, ultimately resulting in ultrafiltration failure and probably contributing to changes in local defense mechanisms with the associated increased risk of peritonitis. In recent years, a major research focus has become the development of new and improved PD solutions. This has resulted in the development of an amino-acid-based PDF, a glucose polymer-based PDF, and several bicarbonate-buffered PDF. Typically, the first phase of biocompatibility testing of new PD solutions involves in vitro testing, employing isolated cells such as peritoneal macrophages or cell culture systems using human peritoneal mesothelial cells. The results of such evaluations are useful in providing insights into the biocompatibility performance of any given formulation, but suffer from several disadvantages, which can be better addressed using animal models. In vivo studies using animals permit the analysis of biocompatibility under conditions that allow for cell-to-cell interactions and dynamic changes in solution composition that more closely mimic the clinical situation. In this paper, we will review the use of animal models for the study of PDF biocompatibility and their application to the assessment of bicarbonate-buffered PDF.

Contribution of lactate buffer, glucose and glucose degradation products to peritoneal injury in vivo

BACKGROUND

Long-term peritoneal dialysis (PD) is associated with the development of functional and structural alterations of the peritoneal membrane. In this study, we investigated the contribution of low pH lactate buffer, high glucose concentration and glucose degradation products to peritoneal injury in a rat peritoneal exposure model.

METHODS

Rats received daily 10 ml of either heat-sterilized (3.86% glucose, pH 5.2, n = 8) or filter-sterilized PD fluid (3.86% glucose, pH 5.2, n = 8), or lactate buffer (pH 5.2, n = 8) via a mini vascular access port during a 10 week period. Untreated rats served as controls.

RESULTS

The low pH lactate buffer instillation induced pronounced morphological changes including the induction of angiogenesis in various peritoneal tissues and mild damage to the mesothelial cell layer covering the peritoneum. It also evoked a cellular response characterized by an increased mesothelial cell density on the liver, the induction of milky spots and accumulation of omental mast cells in the omentum, and significant changes in the composition of peritoneal leukocytes. The addition of glucose to low pH lactate buffer (filter-sterilized PD fluid) strengthened most, but not all of the responses described above and induced a fibrogenic response. In addition to glucose and low pH lactate buffer, the presence of glucose degradation products (heat-sterilized PD fluid) significantly induced an additional omental milky spot response (P < 0.03) and caused profound mesothelial damage. The vessel density in the omentum and the mesentery was significantly correlated to both the number of tissue mast cells and the hyaluronan content in the peritoneal lavage, which might suggest a role for mast cells and hyaluronan in the induction of angiogenesis.

CONCLUSIONS

Instillations of low pH lactate buffer, a high glucose concentration and glucose degradation products contribute differently and often cumulatively to peritoneal injury in vivo.