CNS Low-grade Diffusely Infiltrative Tumors With INI1 Deficiency, Possessing a High Propensity to Progress to Secondary INI1-deficient Rhabdoid Tumors

Atypical teratoid/rhabdoid tumors (AT/RTs) are highly malignant tumors of the central nervous system that predominantly occur in infants, and are characterized by the presence of rhabdoid cells and inactivation of INI1 or (rarely) BRG1. Most AT/RT are identified as primary tumors; however, rare AT/RT or INI1-deficient RTs arising from other primary tumors have been reported. Here, we report 3 cases of hitherto unclassifiable low-grade tumors with loss of INI1 nuclear expression, for which we propose the designation of central nervous system low-grade diffusely infiltrative tumors with INI1 deficiency (CNS LGDIT-INI1), 2 of which progressed to secondary RT. All 3 CNS LGDIT-INI1 exhibited a similar histology: diffusely distributed small tumor cells with round to oval or irregular nuclei and scant cytoplasm were admixed with degenerative neurons and large reactive astrocytes in an edematous, myxoid, or collagenous background. Mitotic figures were absent. Immunohistochemistry revealed that the tumor cells in all 3 CNS LGDIT-INI1 and 2 RT were negative for INI1. Genetically, total or partial homozygous deletions of the INI1 gene were detected in all CNS LGDIT-INI1 and RT excluding 1 CNS LGDIT-INI1 without sufficient DNA quality and quantity. Despite the loss of INI1 expression, these low-grade lesions were clearly distinguishable from AT/RT by their low proliferative activity, diffusely infiltrative growth pattern, and lack of rhabdoid cells and polyphenotypic immunoreactivity. In conclusion, CNS LGDIT-INI1 may represent a rare group of tumors that are clinically indolent but have a high propensity to progress to RT.

Secondary INI1-deficient rhabdoid tumors of the central nervous system: analysis of four cases and literature review

Atypical teratoid/rhabdoid tumors (AT/RT) are rare, highly malignant neoplasms of the central nervous system that predominantly occur in infants, and are characterized by the presence of rhabdoid cells and inactivation of INI1 or (extremely rarely) BRG1. The vast majority of AT/RT are recognized as primary tumors; however, rare AT/RT or INI1-deficient RT arising from other primary tumors have been reported. To better characterize secondary RT, we performed a histological and molecular analysis of four RT arising from pleomorphic xanthoastrocytoma (PXA), anaplastic PXA, low-grade astrocytoma, or ependymoma. Histologically, although conventional AT/RT are usually not largely composed of rhabdoid cells, three secondary RT were composed mainly of rhabdoid cells, two of which arising from (anaplastic) PXA exhibited marked nuclear pleomorphism reminiscent of that in the precursor lesions. Regarding INI1 alterations, although mutations including small indels are frequent in conventional AT/RT, only in one secondary RT had a mutation. Moreover, together with previously reported cases, biallelic INI1 inactivation in secondary RT was mostly due to biallelic focal and/or broad deletions. Although conventional AT/RT have stable chromosomal profiles, i.e., the frequency of copy number changes involving chromosomes other than chromosome 22 is remarkably low, our array comparative genomic hybridization analysis revealed numerous copy number changes in the secondary RT. In conclusion, secondary RT of the central nervous system are clinicopathologically and molecularly different from conventional pediatric AT/RT, and a nosological issue is whether these secondary RT should be called secondary "AT/RT" as most of the reported cases were.

The Rare Phenomenon of Loss of INI1 Expression at Recurrence/Progression of Primary Central Nervous System Tumors: Report of 3 Cases

It is extremely rare for loss of immunohistochemical expression of INI1 to occur primarily at recurrence/progression with retained expression at the primary/initial presentation of central nervous system (CNS) tumor. In this article, we present 3 such cases showing loss of INI1 expression primarily at recurrence. All patients were males, aged 7 years (case 1), 11 years (case 2), and 35 years (case 3), diagnosed with low-grade glial/glioneuronal tumor, not otherwise specified (case 1), craniopharyngioma (case 2), and glioblastoma (case 3); all showed retained INI1 protein expression. Case 1 at 12 months recurrence showed a high-grade tumor with relative undifferentiated morphology, case 2 after 104 months showed a sarcomatous progression, and case 3 recurred after 4 months with the presence of relative undifferentiated round cells. All these recurrences showed loss of INI1 expression. Loss of SMARCB1/INI1 gene function resulting in complete loss of INI1 protein expression is not a well-accepted genetic mechanism for transformation/progression as this series emphasizes.

A Pediatric Intra-Axial Malignant SMARCB1-Deficient Desmoplastic Tumor Arising in Meningioangiomatosis

SMARCB1 inactivation is a well-established trigger event in atypical teratoid/rhabdoid tumor. Recently, a role for SMARCB1 inactivation has emerged as a mechanism of clonal evolution in other tumor types, including rare brain tumors. We describe an unusual malignant intra-axial SMARCB1-deficient spindle cell desmoplastic neoplasm, occurring in a 6-year-old child with meningioangiomatosis and a long history of seizures. Striking features of the tumor were a storiform pattern and strong CD34 expression. Undifferentiated round cell areas with isolated rhabdoid cells showing high mitotic index and focal necrosis with INI1 expression loss were present. The meningioangiomatosis component showed few chromosomal imbalances, including chromosomal 22 monosomy (where SMARCB1 maps) and gain at 6q14.3. In addition to these abnormalities, the spindle cell desmoplastic neoplasm and its dedifferentiated SMARCB1-deficient component shared several other aberrations, including homozygous deletion at 9p21.3, losses at 1p, 3p, 3q, 10p, and 13q, gains and losses at 5p and 11p. In line with INI1 loss, the dedifferentiated component showed remarkably decreased levels of SMARCB1 transcript. The residual SMARCB1 allele was wildtype. Our findings suggest progression from the meningioangiomatosis to the malignant desmoplastic neoplasm through the occurrence of complex chromosomal abnormalities, and point to functional silencing of SMARCB1 in the dedifferentiation component.