Effect of pathology on union of first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis

Comparison of the outcomes of first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis by locking plate and compression screw in patients with severe hallux valgus or hallux valgus revision

INTRODUCTION

Arthrodesis of the first metatarsophalangeal joint (MTP1) is indicated for hallux rigidus, septic arthritis, severe hallux valgus (HV) or HV revision. Few studies have compared the functional and radiographic outcomes between indications. The goal of this study was to compare the results of MTP1 arthrodesis in patients with severe HV or HV revision at 6 months postoperative. The hypothesis was that there are no differences in the fusion rate, functional scores and radiological correction between the two groups.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This was a retrospective, observational, single-center study conducted between January 1, 2018 and July 31, 2021. The inclusion criteria were patients treated for severe HV or HV revision by MTP1 arthrodesis with a compression screw and locking plate who were at least 18 years of age. The exclusion criteria were a history of septic arthritis of MTP1 without prior HV surgery, primary hallux rigidus, rheumatoid arthritis, incomplete medical record. The functional outcomes consisted of the Foot Function Index (FFi-f) and the European Foot and Ankle Society (EFAS) score. Radiographs were made to evaluate preoperative and postoperative deformity, the correction and the fusion rate. These outcomes were compared between two groups: severe HV and HV revision.

RESULTS

An analysis was done of 58 cases of MTP1 arthrodesis: 45 severe HV and 13 HV revisions. The mean patient age was 66 years, and the mean follow-up was 15.7 months. There were no significant differences between the two groups in the postoperative functional scores: EFAS (p = 0.85) and FFI-f (p = 0.14). At the final review, there were no significant differences between the two groups in the foot angle measurements (hallux valgus angle, p = 0.08 and intermetatarsal angle, p = 0.15) and fusion rate (p = 0.89) with a 93% fusion rate in patients with severe HV and 92% in patients with HV revision.

CONCLUSION

Given the good radiographic and functional outcomes, MTP1 arthrodesis by locking plate and compression screw is indicated as a first line surgical treatment for patients with severe HV or for patients undergoing HV revision. There is no evidence of a significant difference in the functional scores, fusion rate and radiographic correction between these two indications.

LEVEL OF PROOF

IV; retrospective case series.

Bilateral first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis: An investigation of functional, surgical and radiological outcomes

BACKGROUND

First metatarsophalangeal joint (MTPJ) arthrodesis is a commonly utilised procedure. In this study, the authors aim to explore functional outcomes of patients undergoing nonsynchronous bilateral first MTPJ arthrodesis under the care of a single surgeon using a compression screw/locking plate construct.

METHODS

This is a prospectively collected, retrospectively analysed case series of fifty five patients who underwent bilateral nonsynchronous first MTPJ arthrodesis. Clinical and radiological outcomes were assessed preoperatively and at a minimum of two years postoperatively. Clinical outcomes were assessed using the Foot and Ankle Outcome Score (FAOS), the Self-Reported Foot and Ankle Score (SEFAS) and the Sports Questionnaire version 1 (SQ). Postoperative radiographs were used to assess evidence of union and compare both hallux valgus and intermetatarsal angles. Removal of hardware, revision surgery and correction of deformities were also recorded.

RESULTS

Fifty five patients were included in the study. There was statistically significant improvements in all five facets of the FAOS (p value < 0.05). The mean postoperative SEFAS was 45.1. In total, patients participated in thirteen different sporting activities. This represented 92 patient specific activities preoperatively and 104 postoperatively. The most common activities were walking, cycling and swimming. Overall, 94.5% (N = 52) of the cohort were satisfied with their return to sport while 98.2% (N = 54) would recommend bilateral first MTPJ arthrodesis. Mean reductions in hallux valgus angles and intermetatarsal angles were noted at 18.87 and 4.69 degrees respectively. There was one non-union in the cohort which required revision surgery. One patient required removal of hardware.

CONCLUSIONS

Bilateral first MTPJ arthrodesis is a safe and effective surgical option for patients with bilateral first MTPJ pathology. It has a high union rate, low complication rate and significantly improves clinical outcomes and allows patients reliably return to physical activities.

[Translated article] Better results in consolidation of hallux metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis with dorsal plate and interfragmentary compression screw

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

The first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis is indicated for the treatment of various pathologies as a technique to reduce pain and improve the support of the first radius. Numerous surgical techniques and fixation methods have been described, with the combination of a dorsal plate and an interfragmentary screw being the one that has shown to be the most stable construct in biomechanical studies. Our aim is to analyze the radiological results after metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis of the hallux using a dorsal plate associated or not with an interfragmentary screw. The differences in terms of consolidation rates and complications in patients diagnosed with hallux rigidus, hallux valgus, hallux varus and failure of previous surgeries were evaluated.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective cohort study of 55 patients with a mean age of 65.10 years in whom a dorsal plate was used was performed. Patients were divided into two groups depending on whether or not an interfragmentary screw was used. The minimum follow-up was 6 months after surgery. The assessment of the pre and postoperative radiological results was based on the variation of the hallux angle, the intermetatarsal angle and the dorsal metatarsophalangeal angle of the hallux, as well as the cases of nonunion identified in each study group.

RESULTS

The radiological results, statistically significant differences (p<0.05) were only found in the dorsal metatarsophalangeal angle between both study groups. No statistically significant differences were found regarding the radiological evaluation of the pre and postoperative hallux angle and intermetatarsal angle. An equal decrease of each angles was observed in both study groups. Regarding the consolidation rate, statistically significant differences (p<0.05) were found between group A, which associated an interfragmentary screw, presenting a consolidation rate of 92%, and group B, which did not associate an interfragmentary screw, and that presented a union rate of 63%.

CONCLUSION

Hallux metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis of the hallux with a dorsal plate and interfragmentary screw show best results regarding consolidation rate and complications compared to those cases in which an interfragmentary screw was not used.

Better results in consolidation of hallux metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis with dorsal plate and interfragmentary compression screw

INTRODUCTION AND AIMS

The first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis is indicated for the treatment of various pathologies as a technique to reduce pain and improve the support of the first radius. Numerous surgical techniques and fixation methods have been described, with the combination of a dorsal plate and an interfragmentary screw being the one that has shown to be the most stable construct in biomechanical studies. Our aim is to analyze the radiological results after metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis of the hallux using a dorsal plate associated or not with an interfragmentary screw. The differences in terms of consolidation rates and complications in patients diagnosed with hallux rigidus, hallux valgus, hallux varus and failure of previous surgeries were evaluated.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A retrospective cohort study of 55 patients with a mean age of 65.10 years in whom a dorsal plate was used was performed. Patients were divided into 2 groups depending on whether or not an interfragmentary screw was used. The minimum follow-up was 6 months after surgery. The assessment of the pre and postoperative radiological results was based on the variation of the hallux angle, the intermetatarsal angle and the dorsal metatarsophalangeal angle of the hallux, as well as the cases of nonunion identified in each study group.

RESULTS

The radiological results, statistically significant differences (p<0.05) were only found in the dorsal metatarsophalangeal angle between both study groups. No statistically significant differences were found regarding the radiological evaluation of the pre and postoperative hallux angle and intermetatarsal angle. An equal decrease of each angles was observed in both study groups. Regarding the consolidation rate, statistically significant differences (p<0.05) were found between group A, which associated an interfragmentary screw, presenting a consolidation rate of 92%, and group B, which did not associate an interfragmentary screw, and that presented a union rate of 63%.

CONCLUSIONS

Hallux metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis of the hallux with a dorsal plate and interfragmentary screw show best results regarding consolidation rate and complications compared to those cases in which an interfragmentary screw was not used.

Ten-Year Minimum Follow-up Study of First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Fusion in Young vs Old Patients

BACKGROUND

Painful degenerative joint disease (DJD) of the first metatarsophalangeal joint (MTP I), or hallux rigidus, mainly occurs in later stages of life. For end-stage hallux rigidus, MTP I arthrodesis is considered the gold standard. As young and active patients are affected considerably less frequently, it currently remains unclear, whether they benefit to the same extent. We hypothesized that MTP I arthrodesis in younger patients would lead to an inferior outcome with decreased rates of overall with lower rates of patient postoperative pain and function compared to an older cohort.

METHODS

All patients aged <50 years who underwent MTP I arthrodesis at our institution between 1995 and 2012 were included in this study. This group was then matched and compared with a group of patients aged >60 years. Minimum follow-up was 10 years. Outcome measures were Tegner activity score (TAS), a "Virtual Tegner activity score" (VTAS), the visual analog scale (VAS), and the Foot Function index (FFI).

RESULTS

Sixty-one MTP I fusions (n = 28 young, n = 33 old) in 46 patients were included in our study at an average of 14 years after surgery. Younger patients experienced significantly more pain relief as reflected by changes in VAS and FFI Pain subscale scores. No difference in functional outcomes was found with change in the FFI function subscale or in the ability to have desired functional outcomes using the ratio of TAS to VTAS. Revision rate did not differ between the two groups apart from hardware removal, which was significantly more likely in the younger group.

CONCLUSION

In patients below the age of 50 years with end-stage DJD of the first metatarsal joint, MTP I arthrodesis not only yielded highly satisfactory postoperative results at least equal outcome compared to an older cohort of patients aged >60 years at an average 14 years' follow-up. Based on these findings, we consider first metatarsal joint fusion even for young patients is a valid option to treat end-stage hallux rigidus.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, a case-control study.

A Novel Plating System for First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Arthrodesis: A Retrospective Comparison of Hybrid and Traditional Locking Plate Constructs

BACKGROUND

Dorsal plate fixation is commonly used for first metatarsophalangeal joint (1st MTPJ) arthrodesis and plate design continues to evolve. A new staple compression plate (SCP) design attempts to utilize the continuous compression of a nitinol staple across the fusion site while simultaneously providing the stability of a dorsal locked plate. Herein, we compare the radiographic, clinical, and patient-reported outcomes of 1st MTPJ joint arthrodesis using 2 dorsal locking plate constructs including a novel SCP construct.

METHODS

Forty-four patients who underwent 1st MTPJ arthrodesis between 2016 and 2020 were retrospectively evaluated. There were 2 group cohorts. Group 1 cohort included 23 patients who received a CrossRoads Extremity SCP, and Group 2 cohort included 21 patients who received a Stryker dorsal locking precontoured titanium plate (LPP). All patients were evaluated with radiographs, Patient-Reported Outcomes Measures Information System (PROMIS) outcome scores, and Foot Function Index (FFI).

RESULTS

The complication and union rates did not vary between groups with a fusion rate of 95.7% in the SCP group and 90.5 % in the LPP group. Similarly, we found no significant differences in PROMIS or FFI scores between the SCP and LPP plates.

CONCLUSION

Use of either dorsal locking plate construct for 1st MTPJ arthrodesis was associated with high union rates and comparable functional outcomes. As locked plate technology continues to evolve for 1st MTPJ arthrodesis, it is important that clinical outcomes are reported.

LEVELS OF EVIDENCE

Level IV.

High complication rates following revision first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis: a retrospective analysis of 79 cases

BACKGROUND

The most common indications for revision of first metatarsophalangeal joint (MTPJ) arthrodesis are symptomatic failures of prior arthrodesis, failed hallux valgus correction, and failed MTPJ arthroplasty implants. However, the outcomes of revision MTPJ arthrodesis have rarely been studied. The purpose of this study was to compare the clinical, radiographic, and patient-reported outcomes of revision MTPJ arthrodesis following different primary procedures.

METHODS

A retrospective review of revision MTPJ arthrodesis cases between January 2015 and December 2019 was performed. The radiographic results, patient-reported outcomes, and rates of complications, subsequent revisions, and nonunions, were analyzed and compared preoperatively and postoperatively. A multivariate analysis was utilized to determine risk factors for complications and reoperations.

RESULTS

This study yielded a total of 79 cases of revision MTPJ arthrodesis. The mean follow-up time was 365 days (SD ± 295). The overall complication rate was 40.5%, of which the overall nonunion rate was 19.0%. Seven cases (8.9%) required further revision surgery. The multivariate analysis revealed that Diabetes mellitus was associated with significantly higher overall complication rates (p = 0.016), and nonunion was associated with "in-situ" joint preparation techniques (p = 0.042). Visual Analog Scale (VAS) significantly improved postoperatively (p < 0.001); However, PROMIS-10 physical health and PROMIS-10 mental health did not change significantly during the study period.

CONCLUSION

Treatment of MTPJ surgery failures is a clinical challenge in orthopedic surgery. In our study, revision of first MTPJ surgery resulted in higher nonunion rates and overall complication rates compared to typical outcomes from primary MTPJ arthrodesis. Diabetes, Tobacco use, and "in-situ" joint preparation technique were found to be independent risk factors for complications and reoperations.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III-Retrospective Cohort Study.

First Metatarsophalangeal Arthrodesis for Hallux Rigidus and Hallux Valgus: A Comparison of Patient Reported and Clinical Outcomes

Few prior studies have compared the patient reported outcomes of first metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis between hallux rigidus and hallux valgus patients. Furthermore, we sought to examine the impact of postoperative radiographic hallux alignment on outcomes scores within each group. A retrospective review of 98 patients who a received primary metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis from January 2010 to March 2020. Clinical complications including nonunion were collected. Patient Reported Outcomes Measurement Information Systems (PROMIS) Physical Function, PROMIS Pain Interference, and the foot function index (FFI) revised short form scores were obtained via telephone. Patients were grouped based on review of preoperative radiographs of the foot and this grouping 37 hallux rigidus and 61 hallux valgus patients. Clinical and patient reported outcomes were compared between these pathologies. No differences in the rate of wound complications, radiographic union, and revision surgery were found between the 2 subgroups. At a median of 2.4 years (3.9 IQR) postoperatively, PROMIS and FFI scores did not vary by pathology group. For both groups, PROMIS scores were similar to the general population of the United States. The postoperative first MTP dorsiflexion angle in the hallux rigidus group was correlated with decreased FFI Pain, FFI Total, and PROMIS Pain Interference domain scores (|r| ≥ 0.40, p < .05 for all). When performing MTP arthrodesis in patients with hallux rigidus, increasing the first MTP dorsiflexion angle may correlate with improved intermediate term patient reported outcomes. However, further studies will need to be done to confirm this theoretical relationship.

First Metatarsophalangeal Arthrodesis for the Failed Hallux

Hallux metatarsophalangeal joint (MTPJ) arthrodesis was first described in 1894 by Clutton, who recommended ankylosing the MTPJ to treat painful hallux valgus (HV). He used ivory pegs to stabilize the MTP joint. Surgeons over the last century have modified the procedure and added indications, including hallux rigidus, rheumatoid arthritis, and revision of failed surgeries. This article addresses many common yet challenging clinical scenarios, and a few hot topics, related to hallux MTPJ arthrodesis, including matarsus primus elevatus, severe hallux valgus, avascular necrosis, and infections. The article provides a condensed evidence-based discussion on how to manage these challenges using MTPJ arthrodesis.

The ability to wear heeled footwear following first metatarsophalangeal joint fusion

INTRODUCTION

Fusion remains the gold standard treatment for symptomatic first metatarsophalangeal joint (MTPJ) arthritis. Surgeons have traditionally advised female patients during the consenting process that they would have limitations or be unable to wear heeled footwear following first MTPJ fusion due to the loss of dorsiflexion at the first MTPJ. Anecdotally, surgeons have found that some patients were still able to continue wearing heeled footwear post fusion surgery. Heeled footwear has long been a trendy fashion accessory dating back from ancient Egyptian times and are regularly worn by a significant proportion of women today. Given the lack of literature in this matter, this study was conducted to investigate the effect of first MTPJ fusion surgery on the ability to wear heeled footwear, to aid in the consenting process.

METHODS

A retrospective review of 50 female patients who have had an isolated first MTPJ fusion between 2004 and 2015 at the authors' institution was undertaken with a follow-up telephone survey which included questions on ability to wear heeled footwear pre and post-operatively, duration, and the height of heels they could wear.

RESULTS

This study included 50 patients (62 feet) with a mean age of 63 years (range 43-78 years) at the time of surgery, with a mean follow-up of eight years (range 5-16years) from surgery. Of the 42 patients who wore heeled footwear pre-surgery, 26 (62%) continued wearing them. The majority of them (n = 23, 88%) were able to wear the same height heels. Patients could use heeled footwear from 30 min to eight hours continuously (mean=3 h) and, 88% were able to wear heel heights of 1.5 in. or higher. None of the patients wearing heeled footwear returned to the clinic with midfoot/hindfoot symptoms, one returned for worsening of pre-existing first IPJ (interphalangeal joint) symptoms.

CONCLUSION

This study has important implications for information given to patients during the consent process for this operation. The results have shown that many patients continue to wear heeled footwear following first MTPJ fusion with minimal or no symptoms in neighbouring joints.

First metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis/fusion: a systematic review of modern fixation techniques

Background

First metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis is commonly performed for symptomatic end-stage hallux rigidus. It has been postulated to produce good results in the literature. Various fixation techniques offer differences in union rates, complications and functional outcomes, stirring debates about which produces the best outcomes for patients. Therefore, this review aims to synthesise and compare the outcomes of modern fixation techniques used for first metatarsophalangeal joint (FMPJ) arthrodesis.

Methods

The electronic database searched were PubMed, CINAHL, Cochrane Library, and Google Scholar. The critical appraisal skills programme tool for cohort study was used. The interventions consisted of screw(s), plate(s), and staple(s). Studies comprising outdated fixation techniques such as suture, metallic wire, external fixation, Rush rods or Steinmann pins were excluded. Participants were adults over 18 years, undergoing FMPJ arthrodesis in the UK. Studies with the population consisting primarily of revision cases, patients with rheumatoid arthritis or diabetes were excluded.

Results

Seven UK studies included 277 feet and a 95.7% overall union rate at a mean union time of 83.5 days. Staples had the highest union rate of 98.2% at mean union time of 84 days, followed by plates (95.2%, 92 days), and finally screws (94.9%, 71 days). The overall complication incidence is 5.8%. All of the fixation techniques produced good functional outcomes postoperatively.

Conclusions

Whilst staple techniques showed the highest union rate, plating techniques are preferable over screws or staples for better results across several outcome measures, including reduced complication incidence, stability, early ambulation, and good functional outcome. The Manchester-Oxford Foot Questionnaire and EuroQol-5Dimensional are recommended as measurement tools to assess functional outcomes following FMPJ arthrodesis.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13047-022-00540-9.

Crossed Screw Fixation Versus Dorsal Plating for First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Arthrodesis: A Retrospective Cohort Study

Multiple fixation techniques for first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis have been described with an average fusion rate of 93.5%. This retrospective cohort study assesses the association between crossed screws (vs dorsal plating) and medical comorbidities and the outcome radiographic union. Bivariate tests of association and multivariable logistic regression were employed to assess differences across fixation type and outcomes. We identified 305 patients who underwent a first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis during the study period. Crossed screw fixation was used in 158 (51.8%) patients while dorsal plating (tubular or anatomic locking plate) was used in 147 (48.2%) patients. Dorsal plating was utilized more often in patients with rheumatoid arthritis (p = .019) and history of smoking (p = .044). At 12 weeks post-operatively there were no significant differences in fusion rates between the two groups (crossed screw group = 95.3% vs dorsal plate group (referent) = 93.5%, Adjusted odds ratio (AOR) 1.39, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.45-4.26). Not smoking was associated with a greater odds of fusion at 12 weeks (96.2% for nonsmokers vs 75.0% for smokers (referent), AOR 0.07, 95% CI 0.02-0.28). Lower body mass index was associated with a greater odds of fusion at 12 weeks (AOR 0.90, 95% CI 0.82-0.99). Surgeons allowed weightbearing earlier with dorsal plate fixation (2 weeks (interquartile range [IQR] 2.6) versus 5 weeks (IQR 2.6) for crossed screw fixation, p = .001). Patients with multiple medical comorbidities were more likely to require revision surgery than patients having 0-1 comorbidities (p < .05). Crossed screws can provide an inexpensive yet effective option for first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis.

Risk Factors for Nonunion After First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Arthrodesis With a Dorsal Locking Plate and Compression Screw Construct: Correction of Hallux Valgus Is Key

First metatarsophalangeal joint (MTPJ) arthrodesis is currently the gold standard technique for advanced hallux rigidus. This retrospective study aimed to identify the risk factors for nonunion after first MTPJ arthrodesis with a dorsal locking plate and compression screw construct. Between April 2014 and April 2019, 165 consecutive patients (28 men and 137 women; mean age, 60 (range, 28-84) years) who underwent 178 primary first MTPJ arthrodeses were retrospectively reviewed. All arthrodeses were performed using either a dorsal locking plate with an integrated compression screw (Anchorage CP plate, Stryker, n = 97) or a dorsal locking plate (Anchorage V2 plate, Stryker, n = 81) with a separate compression screw (4 mm cannulated ACE screw). Union was defined as bone bridging across the fusion site on at least 2 of the 3 standard foot radiographs (anteroposterior, lateral, oblique) and no MTPJ movement or pain during clinical examination. Potential risk factors for nonunion were analyzed with the use of univariate and multivariate analyses. The overall nonunion rate was 6.2% (11 of 178 cases). The risk factors identified in the univariate analysis included preoperative hallux valgus deformity, postoperative residual hallux valgus deformity, and diabetes (p < .05). Multivariate analysis confirmed that postoperative residual hallux valgus deformity (odds ratio 6.5; p= .015) and diabetes (odds ratio 7.4; p = .019) are independent risk factors for nonunion after first MTPJ arthrodesis. Diabetes is the most important independent risk factor for nonunion after first MTPJ arthrodesis with a dorsal locking plate and compression screw construct. A residual postoperative hallux valgus deformity is associated with a significantly increased risk for nonunion. It is therefore crucial to correct the hallux valgus deformity to a hallux valgus angle of less than 20°.

Different fixation constructs and the risk of non-union following first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to determine if a single or separate construct with interfragmentary screw was associated with higher rates non-union following first metatarsophalangeal joint (MTPJ) arthrodesis.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis of patients undergoing first MTPJ arthrodesis between April 2010 and June 2017 was performed. Patients who received either a single (Stryker Anchorage 1 MTP Cross Plate) or separate (Stryker Anchorage 1 MTP locking plate with one Asnis partially threaded compression screw) construct locking plate and interfragmentary compression screw were reviewed. Descriptive statistics were generated for sample demographics and between-group differences were calculated. Multivariable regressions explored internal fixation type and association with non-union.

RESULTS

A total of 280 first MTPJ arthrodesis met the inclusion criteria and were reviewed. The incidence of non-union was 7.9% of procedures (22 joints). Following multivariable binary logistic regression, the single construct locking plate with interfragmentary compression screw was associated with an increased risk of non-union (OR 3.43, 95% CI 1.26-9.33), adjusting for age, gender and comorbidity.

CONCLUSIONS

A single construct interfragmentary screw and locking plate (Stryker Anchorage 1 MTP Cross Plate) was associated with an increased incidence of non-union following first MTPJ arthrodesis.

A Multicenter Retrospective Cohort Study of First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Arthrodesis

In this multicenter study, we evaluated commonly used methods of fixation and 2 methods of joint preparation for first metatarsophalangeal joint fusion, in terms of radiological union and revision rates. Included were 409 consecutive fusions in 385 patients. The overall union rate was 91.4% (34/409). About 29.4% (10/34) of our nonunions were symptomatic. Preoperative hallux valgus showed a statistically significant relation to nonunion (odds ratio [OR] = 9.33, p = .017). Other potential contributing factors like gender (OR 1.9, p = .44), diabetes (OR = 0, p = .99), steroid use (OR = 2.07, p = .44), inflammatory arthritis (OR = 0, p = .99), and smoking (OR = 2.69, p = .34) did not attain statistical significance. Further, the methods of fixation like solid screws (OR = 0, p = .99), plate (OR = 3.6, p = .187), or cannulated screws (OR = 0.09, p = .06) showed no correlation with incidence of nonunion. We compared 2 techniques of joint preparation and found no significant difference in union rates (chi-square = 1.0426, p = .30). Our crude comparison of costs showed the average saving to the trust per year could be 33,442.50£ by choosing screws over plates. To conclude, only hallux valgus had a statistically significant relation to nonunion. All other variables had no significant impact on the union. Solid screw seems to be economically the most viable option and a valid alternative.

First Metatarsophalangeal Arthrodesis After Failed Distal Chevron Osteotomy for Hallux Valgus

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to compare the clinical outcomes after first metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint arthrodesis for hallux rigidus between patients who underwent primary arthrodesis and those who had had a prior surgery for hallux valgus.

METHODS

Our design was a retrospective cohort study comparing 29 patients who underwent primary arthrodesis (primary group) and 34 patients with hallux rigidus after hallux valgus surgery (secondary group). The clinical assessment included the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) score and a visual analog scale (VAS) for pain. Radiological evaluation was also performed. Overall, the mean postoperative follow-up was 3.4 (range, 2-5) years.

RESULTS

At final follow-up, AOFAS and VAS pain scores significantly improved in both groups (P = .001). However, the mean AOFAS (P = .001) and VAS pain (P = .008) scores were significantly better in the primary group than in the secondary group. Radiologically, there were no significant differences between the groups in any angle after arthrodesis. Revision surgeries were not required in the primary group. In the secondary group, there was 1 revision due to deep infection, and 3 other patients required dorsal plate removal. Excluding plate removal, the Kaplan-Meier survival at 3 years was not significantly different between groups (P = .775).

CONCLUSION

Although arthrodesis of the first MTP joint was an effective procedure for hallux rigidus, the clinical outcomes in patients who had prior hallux valgus surgery were worse than those for patients who underwent primary surgery for hallux rigidus.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, retrospective cohort study.

Clinical and radiological outcomes after arthrodesis of the first metatarsophalangeal joint

PURPOSE

The main aim of this study was to investigate the correlation between radiographic findings and clinical outcomes following the first metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint arthrodesis.

METHODS

In a comparative retrospective study, on 46 patients (48 ft), the correlation between post-operative radiographic findings including hallux valgus angle (HVA) and first MTP dorsiflexion angle (MTPDA) and clinical outcomes including VAS pain, modified AOFAS hallux score, and FFI questionnaire were evaluated. Moreover, clinical outcomes were compared between cases with pre-operative diagnosis of first MTP inflammatory arthritis, hallux valgus, hallux varus, and grade 3 and 4 of hallux rigidus. The effect of first MTP arthrodesis on Meary's angle and intermetatarsal angle (IMA) were found out.

RESULTS

The mean age of the patients was 56.3 ± 9.1 (range, 29-69) years, including 42 (91.3%) females and 4 (8.7%) males. We had fusion rate of 97.9%, one asymptomatic nonunion case (2.1%). Totally, mean scores of modified AOFAS hallux score, FFI percentage, and VAS pain were 88.9 ± 12.6, 9.4 ± 16.5, and 1.23 ± 2.24, respectively. Hallux varus was associated with the most favourable outcomes; whereas, patients with first MTP arthritis got the worst outcome. Regression analysis test between clinical outcomes and HVA > 15° and first MTPDA >15° showed correlation coefficient of almost zero. No statistically significant differences were found between the clinical outcomes of grade 3 and 4 of hallux rigidus (p value of modified AOFAS hallux score, FFI percentage, and VAS pain: 0.879, 0.906, and 0.298, respectively). Mean of HVA and IMA reduction in 15 hallux valgus underwent first MTP fusion were 34.4° and 8.4°, respectively. Meary's angle increased about 4° with statistically significant difference (p value 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Patients with first MTP fusion > 15° in coronal and transverse plans could have acceptable clinical outcomes. The clinical outcome of first MTP arthrodesis for grade 3 hallux rigidus is comparable with grade 4. First MTP fusion would have positive effect on IMA and Meary's angle.

Operative Approach to Adult Hallux Valgus Deformity: Principles and Techniques

Hallux valgus deformity is a progressive forefoot deformity consisting of a prominence derived from a medially deviated first metatarsal and laterally displaced great toe, with or without pronation. Although there is agreement that the deformity is likely caused by multifactorial intrinsic and extrinsic factors, the best method of operative management is debated despite the creation of basic algorithms. Our understanding of the deformity and the development of newer techniques is continuously evolving. Here, we review the general orthopaedic principles of operative decision-making and management of hallux valgus deformity.

Is adjunction of advanced platelet-rich fibrin (A-PRF) useful in first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis? A retrospective cohort study

PURPOSE

First metatarsophalangeal (MTPJ1) fusion represents the gold standard treatment for end-stage hallux rigidus (HR). The aim of this study was to assess efficacy and safety of A-PRF in promoting union after MTPJ1 arthrodesis. Our hypothesis was that the use of A-PRF may reduce the non-union rate and the time to fusion in the treatment of HR.

METHODS

14 patients that had undergone MTPJ1 arthrodesis with A-PRF adjunction with 21 standard MTPJ1 fusions were retrospectively reviewed. The fusion rate and time to fusion (clinically and radiographically) were assessed at 6, 12 weeks and at the longest follow-up; the clinical status at final follow-up through forefoot AOFAS, EQ5d, SEFAS and VAS-pain scores; the complication rate.

RESULTS

At 6-weeks, bony union was achieved in 100% of patients in the A-PRF group compared to 70% in the control group, but this difference was not statistically significant (p=0.22). At final follow-up (41 months), union rate in the control group reached 92% (one non-union). AOFAS, VAS and EQ-5d scores showed similar results for the two groups (p=0.86, p=0.12 and p=0.61, respectively); only SEFAS score revealed a difference favoring the A-PRF group (p=0.04). No revision surgery or complication was recorded in any group.

CONCLUSIONS

A tendency for increased union rate was mainly found at 6 weeks in patients treated with MTPJ1 fusion associated to A-PRF compared to isolated fusion. The use of A-PRF was not associated with an increased complication rate at final follow-up.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level 3, therapeutic study, retrospective comparative study.

A Consecutive Case Series of 166 First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Fusions Using a Combination of Cup and Cone Reamers and Crossed Cannulated Screws

Fusion of the first metatarsophalangeal joint (MTPJ) is the reference standard surgery for significant hallux rigidus. A number of different techniques for first MTPJ fusion have been reported. We describe our technique of first MTPJ fusion using cup and cone reamers for joint surface preparation and 2 crossed cannulated screws for fixation. To the best of our knowledge, this is the single largest series using this technique. The present study reports on a single-surgeon, consecutive series of 166 consecutive cases in 147 patients who had undergone first MTPJ fusion. The demographic data and comorbidities of the patients were collected from the digital medical records, and the radiographs were evaluated by 2 of us (S.Q., M.A.) independently to document fusion status. Radiologic nonunion was seen in 11 of 166 cases (6.6%). The mean duration of follow up was 60 ± 29.5 (minimum 26, maximum 183) days. However, only 4 of the 11 cases (36%) of nonunion were clinically symptomatic and underwent revision using a bone graft and locking plate. A statistically significant difference was found in union rates among males and females (p = .01). Other factors, such as diabetes (p = .2), inflammatory arthritis (p = .5), steroids (p = .6), smoking (p = .5), hallux valgus deformity (p = .5), and concomitant forefoot surgery, did not have a statistically significant (p = .3) effect on union in our study. The union rate of first MTPJ fusion with our technique was comparable to that of others, with the advantage of being simple and less expensive compared with the use of a plate.

First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Arthrodesis: Does the Addition of a Lag Screw to a Dorsal Locking Plate Influence Union Rate and/or Final Alignment after Fusion

First metatarsophalangeal (MTP-1) joint fusion is a reliable method for the correction of various deformities, including hallux valgus and hallux rigidus. Ideal constructs provide high rates of fusion in the desired alignment. The present study examined the union rates and the change in dorsiflexion angle during the follow-up period in patients who had undergone MTP-1 fusion with a dorsal locking plate and a lag screw compared with patients who had undergone fusion with a dorsal locking plate alone. We performed a retrospective review of 99 feet undergoing MTP-1 fusion. The joints were fused using either a dorsal locking plate alone or a lag screw plus a dorsal locking plate. Union was determined radiographically during the follow-up period. Suspected nonunions were confirmed by computed tomography. The dorsiflexion angles were radiographically measured at the first postoperative visit and at the final follow-up visit. Of the 99 feet, 36 (36.4%) were in the lag screw plus dorsal plate group and 63 (63.6%) in the dorsal plate group. The mean follow-up period was 12.9 (range 12 to 33.5) months. The dorsal plate plus lag screw group had a significantly lower change in the mean dorsiflexion angle (0.57° ± 5.01°) during the postoperative period compared with the dorsal plate group (6.73° ± 7.07°). The addition of a lag screw to a dorsal locking plate for MTP-1 arthrodesis might offer improved stability of the joint in the sagittal plane over time compared with a dorsal plate alone.

First metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis with two orthogonal two hole plates

Objective

First MTP joint fusion is a reliable procedure for advanced arthritis for the first MTP joint. There are many techniques described. The purpose of our study is to report clinical, radiological, functional outcomes and complications of first metatarsophalangeal joint fusion with hand preparation of the joint and fixation with two orthogonal locking plates without a compression screw.

Methods

32 feet in 26 consecutive patients under went first metatarsophalangeal joint fusion with above technique. There were 23 women and 3 men. Mean age was 64 years and mean follow-up was 49 months. 21 patients had osteoarthritis, 10 had rheumatoid arthritis and one had psoriatic arthritis. Clinical, radiological, American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Score and Foot and Ankle Disability Index clinical rating scales were used for evaluation.

Results

Fusion was achieved in 27 feet. The incidence of radiological non-union was 15.7%. Mean AOFAS score improved from 37.1 to 80.7 (p < 0.0001) and mean FADI score improved from 40.3 to 86.9 postoperatively (p < 0.0001). Two patients with osteoarthritis and three with Rheumatoid arthritis did not unite. Four of these patients were managing hence revision surgery was not carried out but had low AOFAS and FADI scores. One patient with symptomatic non-union declined further surgery. One patient needed plate removal for a low grade infection and reoperation rate was 3.1%.

Conclusions

In our experience, first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis using two orthogonal two hole plates without a compression screw is associated with a higher non-union rate in our cohort hence we do not recommend this technique.

Level of evidence

Level IV, therapeutic study.

Do Postoperative Hallux Angles Correlate With Outcome in MP1 Fusion? Our Experience With 71 Cases

PURPOSE

To determine if the postoperative alignment of the hallux influences the final clinical outcome of hallux metatarsophalangeal joint (first MTPJ) arthrodesis.

METHODS

A total of 71 consecutive cases (hallux rigidus) were studied in stages 3 and 4. They were operated through arthrodesis between 2008 and 2014. The follow-up mean was 7.3 years. The AOFAS (American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society) test was performed preintervention and per annum. In radiology, both the hallux valgus angle and the dorsiflexion angle of the first MTPJ were studied. Furthermore, clinical outcomes were evaluated according to the type of implant used.

RESULTS

Preoperative AOFAS score was 27.5, rising to 91.3 after the intervention ( P < .01). The improvement test average was 63.6. There were 17 local complications (23%), 7 of them were considered to be major complications (9%), 6 of which needed reoperation (8.5%). The dorsiflexion angle postoperative mean was 21.7°. The hallux valgus angle postoperative mean was 10.9°. No correlations between both angles, and improved AOFAS score or complications ( P > .4 and P > .5, respectively), were found. Patients who had a dorsiflexion angle higher than 20° had greater improvement in the AOFAS score compared with those who had angles lower than 20° (64.5 vs 59.6 points). Nevertheless, this result was not statistically significant ( P = .059). No differences in AOFAS score improvement regarding arthrodesis plate ( P > .1) were found.

CONCLUSION

First MTPJ arthrodesis is a good alternative for patients in advanced hallux rigidus stages when conservative treatment fails. We could not confirm if a better postoperative alignment may influence in clinical outcomes. However, better results are obtained with dorsiflexion angle greater than 20° than with those with less than 20°. Likewise, any differences between the 2 arthrodesis plates have been able to confirm.

LEVELS OF EVIDENCE

Level III: Retrospective cohort study.

Radiographic evaluation of first MTP joint arthrodesis for severe hallux valgus: Does the introduction of a lag screw improve union rates and correction of the intermetatarsal angle?

BACKGROUND

First metatarsophalangeal (MTP-1) joint fusion is a reliable method for the correction of various deformities including hallux valgus and hallux rigidus. Ideal constructs provide high rates of fusion in desired alignment. The present study examines the union rates, as well as the change in dorsiflexion angle during the follow up period in patients who underwent MTP-1 fusion with a dorsal locking plate and a lag screw, versus patients fused with a dorsal locking plate alone.

METHODS

This is a retrospective review of 99 feet undergoing MTP-1 fusion. Joints were fused using either a dorsal locking plate alone or a lag screw plus a dorsal locking plate. Union was determined radiographically during the follow up period. Suspected nonunions were confirmed with CT. Dorsiflexion angles were radiographically measured at first post-operative visit and at final follow up.

RESULTS

There were 36 patients in the lag screw plus dorsal plate group, and 63 in the dorsal plate group. Mean follow up was 12.9 months (Range: 12-33.5 months). The dorsal plate plus lag screw group had a significantly lower change in mean dorsiflexion angle (0.57°±5.01°) during the post-operative period compared to the dorsal plate group at final follow up versus the dorsal plate group (6.73°±7.07°).

CONCLUSION

The addition of a lag screw to a dorsal locking plate for MTP-1 arthrodesis may offer improved stability of the joint in the sagittal plane over time compared to a dorsal plate alone.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Retrospective level III evidence.

First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Arthrodesis in Hallux Valgus Versus Hallux Rigidus Using Cup and Cone Preparation Compression Screw and Dorsal Plate Fixation

Various techniques have been described for first metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint arthrodesis. The purpose of this study was to determine if cup and cone preparation by a single surgeon with an interfragmentary screw and dorsal plate fixation provides a comparable union rate in hallux valgus versus hallux rigidus. Our study included all patients who underwent first MTP joint fusions using cup and cone preparation with an interfragmentary compression screw and dorsal plate fixation from 2010 to 2015. We compared union rates in 65 patients with hallux rigidus with 47 who had hallux valgus. One of 65 hallux rigidus cases developed non-union and underwent revision surgery. One of 47 patients in the hallux valgus group developed a painless non-union. All other patients achieved union based on post operative radiographs. Our rate of painful non-union was 1.5% for hallux rigidus and 0% for hallux valgus, which is lower than recent published literature of 7% for hallux valgus and 3.7% for hallux rigidus. We found no difference between the two groups suggesting this method may provide stronger fixation and may be preferable when dealing with hallux valgus. First metatarsophalangeal joint fusion in patients with severe hallux valgus and hallux rigidus, using spherical reamers, compression screw and dorsal plate fixation is equally successful at achieving clinical and radiographic fusion in both hallux valgus and hallux rigidus.

Effect of joint pathology, surface preparation and fixation methods on union frequency after first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis: A systematic review of the English literature

BACKGROUND

The aim of this systematic review was to perform a qualitative synthesis of the current literature to determine the union frequencies for first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis as well as the influence of pathology, joint preparation and fixation methods on union.

METHODS

MEDLINE and EMBASE were searched to identify relevant studies reporting on first metatarsophalangeal joint union frequencies.

RESULTS

26 studies with 2059 feet met our inclusion criteria. The mean age was 60 years (range 18-84) and the mean follow-up was 32.6 months (range 1.5-156). The union frequency was 93.5% (1923/2059). The union frequencies were significantly higher when low velocity joint preparation methods were used (P<0.0001, Chi Square 22.5) and the pathology was hallux rigidus (P=0.002, Chi square 9.3). There were similarly high union frequencies with crossed screws, locking plate and non-locking plates.

CONCLUSIONS

High union frequency can be expected following first metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis, especially when low velocity joint preparation methods are used in patients with hallux rigidus.

Functional Results and Patient Satisfaction of First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Arthrodesis Using Dual Crossed Screw Fixation

A total of 262 feet in 228 consecutive patients underwent first metatarsophalangeal joint (MPJ) fusion; thus, the present study is the largest single-surgeon patient series reported. The inclusion criteria included severe painful deformity of the first MPJ due to osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, or gouty arthritis and stage 3 or 4 hallux rigidus. The exclusion criteria were revision surgery of the first MPJ, fixation other than with dual crossed screws, and a postoperative follow-up period of <3 months. Fusion of the first MPJ was fixated with dual-crossed 3.0-mm screws. The office follow-up period was ≥3 months postoperatively and the survey follow-up period was ≥6 months postoperatively. The mean duration to radiographic evidence of arthrodesis was 7.00 ± 2.33 weeks, and 252 of the feet (96.18%) achieved successful arthrodesis. The mean postoperative office follow-up duration was 30.43 ± 6.59 weeks. The mean modified American College of Foot and Ankle Surgeons scale score was 51.2 ± 3.28 of maximum possible of 68 points. The mean subjective score was 37.1 ± 2.5 (maximum possible of 50 points), and the mean objective score was 14.5 ± 1.7 (maximum possible of 18 points). Furthermore, 200 patients (87.72%) reported that they had little to no pain, 187 (82.02%) reported they either mostly liked the appearance of their toe or liked it very much, and 173 (75.88%) reported that they could wear any type of shoe most or all the time after the operation. Of the respondents, 207 (90.79%) stated they would have the surgery repeated, and 197 (86.40%) would recommend the surgery to a family member or friend.

A Short-Term Retrospective of First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Arthrodesis Using a Plate With PocketLock Fixation

BACKGROUND

Various techniques have been described for arthrodesis of the first metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint. The purpose of this study was to retrospectively review the results of fixation for the first MTP arthrodesis of patients treated using dome-shaped reamers to prepare the joint surfaces and a novel MTP Plate with PocketLock fixation.

METHODS

Between July 2012 and November 2013, 16 feet in 16 patients were treated with a first MTP arthrodesis with a MTP Plate with PocketLock fixation. The mean patient age was 58.8 years (range, 46-82 years). Physical and radiographic examinations were performed at follow-up visits. The average follow-up period was 17.3 months. The radiographs were examined for union (3 bridging cortices), time to union, hardware failure, or other radiographic complications. The charts were reviewed to assess AOFAS-MTP-IP (American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society metatarsophalangeal-interphalangeal) scores and postoperative complications.

RESULTS

Fusion was seen in 11 of 16 feet (68.8%) and partial union in 1 patient (6.3%). Five nonunions (31.2%) were noted in the sample group: All were symptomatic and required revision surgery. No malunions were identified in our sample. One hardware failure was documented in a nonunion patient. The mean time to osseous union was 81.7 ± 15.9 days. The preoperative AOFAS MTP-IP score was 55.6 and the postoperative score was 64.7.

CONCLUSION

The high nonunion and revision surgery rates demonstrate that this particular plate should be used with caution for a first MTP joint arthrodesis.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic, Level IV: Case series.