Peritalar Kinematics With Combined Deltoid-Spring Ligament Reconstruction in Simulated Advanced Adult Acquired Flatfoot Deformity

Chronic Deltoid Insufficiency in Stage IV Adult Acquired Flatfoot Deformity: Do We Have a Good Answer?

Stage IV adult acquired flatfoot deformity (AAFD) with secondary chronic deltoid ligament insufficiency is a challenging deformity to treat, with minimal consensus in the literature concerning its surgical management. Many surgical treatment options have been described, including joint-sparing techniques, fusions, osteotomies, and even arthroplasties. However, questions remain as to what, if any, treatment is optimal. This contribution reviews studies on surgical treatments for stage IV AAFD with deltoid ligament failure and provides a critical analysis regarding the quality of outcomes reported for those different treatment options. PubMed and Google Scholar databases were searched between June 1, 2022, and August 15, 2022, for studies published between 1990 and 2022 that describe the treatment of stage IV AAFD with deltoid ligament insufficiency. Articles included in the study focused on subjects with stage IV AAFD and associated deltoid ligament insufficiency undergoing surgical correction. Exclusion criteria included stage I, II, and III AAFD, as well as deltoid ligament repair following acute injury/rupture. Nine studies covering five different treatment options for patients with stage IV AAFD and chronic deltoid insufficiency were included, with minimal overlap in outcome measures used to assess the efficacy of the procedure. Triple arthrodesis with deltoid ligament reconstruction resulted in a 62.5% (5/8) success rate with a residual tibiotalar (TT) angulation of 2° (success defined as <3°). Tibiotalar arthrodesis of four patients resulted in an average post-operative tibiotalar angulation of 4.8° with all patients showing progressive destabilization of the hindfoot complex at 12-18 year follow-ups. Deltoid arthroscopic laminoplasty (Brostrom) resulted in an increased American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score from 49.7 pre-op to 91.9 post-op. There was no long-term follow-up of these patients. Deltoid ligament reconstruction using autografts of the peroneus longus resulted in a post-operative valgus of 2.1° in one study and <5° in another. Deltoid ligament reconstruction using an anterior tibial tendon autograft resulted in a gain of 126.4 + 40.2% in stiffness compared to an intact ligament. Twinfix suture anchors resulted in a post-operative hindfoot angle averaging 5.3°. Combined deltoid and spring ligament reconstruction resulted in a 5.1° valgus angulation. There is currently no standard of care or clinical consensus regarding surgical treatment for stage IV AAFD with deltoid insufficiency. Several studies imply that mild valgus malalignment around the tibiotalar joint can result in satisfactory outcomes. A few studies even deemed <5° of valgus tilt post-operatively successful. However, it has been described that any imbalance in tibiotalar tilt is a significant risk factor for progressive arthritis and future ligamentous failure. No treatment option was able to correct valgus tilt to an anatomical standard (i.e., to normal anatomy). These varied findings, along with the lack of consensus on post-surgical measures to assess efficacy, are worrisome and emphasize the need for better surgical options. Moreover, there is a critical need for additional research on the long-term outcomes following stage IV AAFD and deltoid insufficiency repair, particularly, as over five million people in the United States and 10% of the geriatric population are affected by AAFD with a risk of progressing to stage IV.

Biomechanical Effects of Subtalar Joint Fusion and Medial Ligament Reconstruction in Simulated Progressive Collapsing Foot Deformity

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study is to investigate the biomechanical effect of medial displacement calcaneal osteotomy (MDCO), subtalar joint fusion (SF), and medial ligament reconstruction (MLR: deltoid-spring ligament) in a severe flatfoot model. We hypothesized that (1) combination of MDCO and SF improves the tibiotalar and foot alignment in severe progressive collapsing foot deformity (PCFD) cadaver model. (2) However, if a residual valgus heel alignment remains after MCDO and SF, it can lead to increased medial ligament strain, foot malalignment, and tibiotalar valgus tilt, which will be mitigated by the addition of MLR.

METHODS

Ten fresh-frozen cadaveric foot specimens were used to create a severe flatfoot model. The foot alignment changes, including the talo-first metatarsal angle in the axial and sagittal planes, subtalar angle, and tibiotalar angle in the coronal plane, were measured. The angles were measured at the initial condition, after creating the severe flatfoot model, and after each successive reconstructive procedure in the following order: (1) MDCO, (2) SF, and (3) MLR.

RESULTS

Tibiotalar valgus tilt was decreased with the MDCO procedure: 4.4 vs 1.0 degrees (P = .04). Adding in situ SF to the MDCO led to increased tibiotalar tilt to 2.5 degrees was different from the initial condition (P = .01). Although the tibiotalar valgus tilt was significantly decreased after adding the MLR to the MDCO/SF procedure compared with the severe flatfoot model (0.8 vs 4.4 degrees, P = .03), no significant difference in the tibiotalar valgus tilt was observed between MDCO/SF and MDCO/SF with MLR.

CONCLUSION

Our results demonstrated that MDCO significantly improved forefoot abduction and medial arch alignment, with no significant additional improvement observed with addition of SF. Following SF, a residual valgus heel alignment can contribute to subsequent tibiotalar valgus tilt. The addition of MLR did not show significantly decreased tibiotalar valgus tilt following SF.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Residual valgus heel alignment after subtalar joint fusion in the surgical treatment of PCFD can lead to increased medial ligament strain. Although MLR might be considered for providing medial stability, it may not necessarily prevent the development of tibiotalar valgus tilt.

Spring Ligament Reconstruction for Progressive Collapsing Foot Deformity: Contemporary Review

The spring ligament is one of the main stabilizers of the medial arch of the foot and the primary static supporter of the talonavicular joint. Attenuation or rupture of this ligament is thought to play a central role in the pathophysiology of progressive collapsing foot deformity. Traditional correction of flexible flatfoot consists of posterior tibial tendon augmentation along with various osteotomies or hindfoot fusions. Repair or reconstruction of the spring ligament has not been as widely pursued. In recent years, newer techniques have been explored and may improve outcomes of traditional procedures, or possibly entirely replace some osteotomies. Combined spring-deltoid ligament reconstruction is also gaining traction as a viable technique, particularly as the ankle begins to deform into valgus. This review summarizes the variety of nonanatomic and anatomic reconstruction techniques that have been described, including autologous tendon transfers, allografts, and synthetic augmentation. Although many have only been characterized in biomechanical cadaver studies, this article reviews preliminary clinical studies that have shown promising results. There is a need for more high-quality studies evaluating the clinical, radiographic, and patient-reported outcomes following spring ligament reconstruction.

Increase in lateral contact force in the tibiotalar joint during walking in flatfoot patients with reduced stiffness of the spring ligament

Foot deformities in patients with flexible flatfeet, such as the flattened medial arch and hindfoot valgus, affect the force distribution around the tibiotalar joint during walking and increase the risk of secondary injuries. In this study, we developed a multi-segment foot model that could calculate the dynamics around the tibiotalar joint and investigated the difference in the kinetics between normal feet and feet with flatfoot. Ten participants with normal feet and ten with flexible flatfoot were enrolled in the study. The body kinematics, ground reaction force, and foot pressure of the participants were recorded during walking. A five-segment foot model was developed to calculate contact forces in the tibiotalar joint. A flatfoot model was developed by modifying the stiffness of the spring ligaments of a normal foot model. Ground reaction force was applied to the plantar surface of the foot models. The foot models were attached to a full-body musculoskeletal model to conduct inverse dynamic simulations of walking. Participants with flatfoot had significantly greater lateral contact force (1.19 BW vs. 0.80 BW) and more posteriorly located center of pressure (33.7 % vs. 46.6 %) in the tibiotalar joint than those with normal feet (p < 0.05). The average and peak posterior tibialis muscle forces were significantly larger in participants with flatfoot than in those with normal feet (3.06 BW vs. 2.22 BW; 4.52 BW vs. 3.33 BW). The altered mechanics may influence the risk of arthritis.

Ligament Insufficiency with Flatfoot: Spring Ligament and Deltoid Ligament

The objective of this article was to review the deltoid ligament and spring ligament specifically as they pertain to ligament insufficiency and adult-acquired flatfoot deformity. Discussion includes the normal and abnormal biomechanical forces that extend through these ligaments in normal and flatfoot deformity. Current literature related to spring ligament repair as part of the flatfoot deformity reconstruction is also reviewed.

Length change pattern of the ankle deltoid ligament during physiological ankle motion

BACKGROUND

Length change pattern of the ankle deltoid ligament during physiological ankle motion is still confused currently and had not been studied in vivo.

METHODS

The deltoid ligaments from 7 cadaveric specimens were dissected. Lengths of each band during 30° plantarflexion to 20° dorsiflexion were measured. A dual fluoroscopy imaging system was utilized to capture the images of hindfoot joint of 7 healthy subjects during the stance phase of walking. 3D bone models were reconstructed from CT images. Lengths of each band were calculated after model-image registration utilizing a solid modeling software. Percentage of length variation and poses when the bands were in maximum extension were documented among each band.

RESULTS

The anterior border of tibiocalcaneal ligament (TCL) had only 1.7% length variation in vitro and 5.7% length variation in vivo. The tibionavicular ligament, tibiospring ligament, and deep anterior tibiotalar ligament were in maximum extension at 30° plantarflexion, however, superficial posterior tibiotalar ligament, deep posterior tibiotalar ligament, and the posterior border of TCL were in maximum extension at 20° dorsiflexion. The tibionavicular ligament, tibiospring ligament, and deep anterior tibiotalar ligament were in maximum extension during foot flat. The TCL was in maximum extension during midstance. The superficial posterior tibiotalar ligament and deep posterior tibiotalar ligament were in maximum extension during heel off and toe off.

CONCLUSION

The length of TCL did not change during ankle dorsiflexion and plantarflexion. The bands anterior to and posterior to the TCL showed different length change pattern during physiological ankle dorsiflexion and plantarflexion.

The Effect of Progressive Lateral Column Lengthening in a Novel Stage II-B Flatfoot Cadaveric Model Evaluated Using Software-Guided Radiographic Measurements of Foot Alignment

BACKGROUND

This work used software-guided radiographic measurement to assess the effects of progressive lateral column lengthening (LCL) on restoring alignment in a novel cadaveric model of stage II-B flatfoot deformity.

METHODS

A stage II-B flatfoot was created in 8 cadaveric specimens by transecting the spring ligament complex, anterior deltoid, and interosseous talocalcaneal and cervical ligaments. Weightbearing computed tomographic (WBCT) scans were performed with specimens under 450 N of compressive load in the intact, flat, and 6-, 8-, and 10-mm lateral column-lengthening conditions. Custom software-guided radiographic measurements of the lateral talo-first metatarsal (Meary) angle, anteroposterior talo-first metatarsal angle, naviculocuneiform overlap, and 2 new measures (plantar fascia [PF] distance and angle) were recorded on digitally reconstructed radiographs. Four anonymized analysts performed measurements twice. Intra- and interobserver agreement was assessed using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs).

RESULTS

Six-millimeter LCL restored alignment closest to the intact foot in this new cadaveric model, whereas 10-mm lengthening tended toward overcorrection. The PF line displaced laterally in the flatfoot condition, and LCL restored the PF line to a location beneath the talonavicular joint. Interobserver agreement was excellent for PF distance (ICC = 0.99) and naviculocuboid overlap (ICC = 0.91), good for Meary angle (ICC = 0.81) and PF angle (ICC = 0.69), and acceptable for the talonavicular coverage angle (ICC = 0.65).

CONCLUSION

In this stage II-B cadaveric flatfoot model, cervical ligament transection was essential to create deformity after the medial hindfoot ligaments were transected. Software-guided radiographic measurement proved reliable; standardized implementation should improve comparability between studies of flatfoot deformity. The novel PF distance performed most consistently (ICC = 0.99) and warrants further study. With this model, we found that a 6-mm LCL restored alignment closest to the intact foot, whereas 10-mm lengthening tended toward overcorrection.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Future joint-sparing flatfoot corrections may consider using a relatively small LCL combined with other bony and/or anatomic ligament/tendon reconstructions.

A Preliminary Study to Assess the Relevance of Shear-Wave Elastography in Characterizing Biomechanical Changes in the Deltoid Ligament Complex in Relation to Ankle Position

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was (1) to evaluate the biomechanical properties of the different bundles of the deltoid ligament in various ankle positions in a cohort of healthy adult volunteers; (2) describe the impact of demographic and hindfoot morphology characteristics on their stiffness; (3) to assess the reliability and reproducibility of these measurements.

METHODS

Deltoid ligament complex of both ankles were assessed by shear-wave elastography (SWE) in 20 healthy patients resting on hinge support. The propagation shear-wave speed (SWS) in ligaments was measured, which is related to the tissue's elastic modulus. The following ligaments were analyzed in a neutral position and then in varus, valgus, dorsal, and plantar flexions: tibionavicular ligament (TNL), tibiocalcaneal ligament (TCL), the superficial posterior tibiotalar ligament (SPTL), the anterior tibiotalar ligament (ATTL), and the deep posterior tibiotalar ligament (DPTTL).

RESULTS

The mean SWS increased between neutral and 20 degrees valgus position for TCL (4.08 ± 0.78 m/s vs 5.56 ± 0.62 m/s, respectively; P < .0001) and for DPTTL (2.58 ± 0.52 m/s vs 3.59 ± 0.87 m/s, respectively; P < .0001). The mean SWS increased between neutral and 30 degrees plantarflexion for ATTL (2.11 ± 0.44 m/s vs 3.1 ± 0.5 m/s, respectively; P < .0001) and TNL (2.96 ± 0.66 m/s vs 4.99 ± 0.69 m/s, respectively; P < .0001). The mean SWS increased between neutral and 20 degrees dorsal flexion for SPTL (4.2 ± 1 m/s vs 5.45 ± 0.65 m/s, respectively; P < .0001).Women had less DPTTL SWS than men in the neutral position (2.37 ± 0.35 m/s vs 2.71 ± 0.49 m/s, respectively; P = .007). Other demographics had no impact on the SWS value of other ligaments. All inter- and intraobserver agreements were good to excellent.

CONCLUSION

This study presents a reliable and reproducible SWE measurement protocol to describe the physiological function of all bundles of the medial collateral ligament in healthy adults.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

This examination technique can be available to orthopaedic surgeons, allowing reliable and reproducible monitoring of the SWS of the various ligaments constituting the medial collateral plane. The biomechanical values described in this study may give insight into in what position medial ankle ligament reconstruction should be tensioned.

Imaging of Peritalar Instability

Undiagnosed medial ankle instability can be a prerequisite for pathogenic progression in the foot, particularly for adult acquired flatfoot deformity. With the complex anatomy in this region, and the limitations of each individual investigational method, accurately identifying peritalar instability remains a serious challenge to clinicians. Performing a thorough clinical examination aided by evaluation with advanced imaging can improve the threshold of detection for this condition and allow early proper treatment to prevent further manifestations of the instability.

Biomechanics of Medial Ankle and Peritalar Instability

The deltoid and spring ligaments are the primary restraints against pronation and valgus deformity of the foot, and in preserving the medial arch. The posterior tibial tendon has a secondary role in plantar arch maintenance, and its biomechanical stress increases considerably when other tissues fail. A thorough understanding of the anatomy and biomechanics of the deltoid-spring ligament is crucial for successful reconstruction of the tibiocalcanealnavicular ligament, hence, to restore ankle and medial peritalar stability. Although effective in correcting the deformity, tibionavicular tenodesis might be critical, as it blocks physiologic pronation of the hindfoot, which may result in dysfunction and pain.