Local bone deformation at two predominant sites for stress fractures of the tibia: an in vivo study

Predicting Tibia-Fibula Geometry and Density From Anatomical Landmarks Via Statistical Appearance Model: Influence of Errors on Finite Element-Calculated Bone Strain

State-of-the-art participant-specific finite element models require advanced medical imaging to quantify bone geometry and density distribution; access to and cost of imaging is prohibitive to the use of this approach. Statistical appearance models may enable estimation of participants' geometry and density in the absence of medical imaging. The purpose of this study was to: (1) quantify errors associated with predicting tibia-fibula geometry and density distribution from skin-mounted landmarks using a statistical appearance model and (2) quantify how those errors propagate to finite element-calculated bone strain. Participant-informed models of the tibia and fibula were generated for thirty participants from height and sex and from twelve skin-mounted landmarks using a statistical appearance model. Participant-specific running loads, calculated using gait data and a musculoskeletal model, were applied to participant-informed and CT-based models to predict bone strain using the finite element method. Participant-informed meshes illustrated median geometry and density distribution errors of 4.39-5.17 mm and 0.116-0.142 g/cm3, respectively, resulting in large errors in strain distribution (median RMSE = 476-492 με), peak strain (limits of agreement =±27-34%), and strained volume (limits of agreement =±104-202%). These findings indicate that neither skin-mounted landmark nor height and sex-based predictions could adequately approximate CT-derived participant-specific geometry, density distribution, or finite element-predicted bone strain and therefore should not be used for analyses comparing between groups or individuals.

Per-step and cumulative load at three common running injury locations: The effect of speed, surface gradient, and cadence

Understanding how loading and damage on common running injury locations changes across speeds, surface gradients, and step frequencies may inform training programs and help guide progression/rehabilitation after injuries. However, research investigating tissue loading and damage in running is limited and fragmented across different studies, thereby impairing comparison between conditions and injury locations. This study examined per-step peak load and impulse, cumulative impulse, and cumulative weighted impulse (hereafter referred to as cumulative damage) on three common injury locations (patellofemoral joint, tibia, and Achilles tendon) across different speeds, surface gradients, and cadences. We also explored how cumulative damage in the different tissues changed across conditions relative to each other. Nineteen runners ran at five speeds (2.78, 3.0, 3.33, 4.0, 5.0 m s-1 ), and four gradients (-6, -3, +3, +6°), and three cadences (preferred, ±10 steps min-1 ) each at one speed. Patellofemoral, tibial, and Achilles tendon loading and damage were estimated from kinematic and kinetic data and compared between conditions using a linear mixed model. Increases in running speed increased patellofemoral cumulative damage, with nonsignificant increases for the tibia and Achilles tendon. Increases in cadence reduced damage to all tissues. Uphill running increased tibial and Achilles tendon, but decreased patellofemoral damage, while downhill running showed the reverse pattern. Per-step and cumulative loading, and cumulative loading and cumulative damage indices diverged across conditions. Moreover, changes in running speed, surface gradient, and step frequency lead to disproportional changes in relative cumulative damage on different structures. Methodological and practical implications for researchers and practitioners are discussed.

How getting twisted in scaffold design can promote bone regeneration: A fluid-structure interaction evaluation

Bone tissue engineering (BTE) uses engineering principles to repair large bone defects, which requires effective mass transport ability of scaffolds to support cellular activities during bone regeneration. Since the implanted BTE scaffolds keep deforming under physiological loading which influences the fluid flow and mass transport within the scaffold and surrounding tissue, thus, scaffold design needs to consider the mass transport behavior under the physiological loading. This work proposed a novel twist scaffold, and its mass transport efficiency under physiological loading conditions was evaluated by a fluid-structure interaction analysis. The results showed that compared to the non-twist scaffold, the twist scaffold could form a rotating flow under the physiological loading, which enhanced the mass transport and generated more appropriate wall shear stress (WSS) to promote bone regeneration. This highlighted the better mass transport efficiency of the twist scaffold. Therefore, getting twist may be a promising design strategy for future BTE scaffolds, and the fluid-structure interaction approach may be a more reliable method for bone regeneration studies in either in vivo or in vitro systems.

In silicomodeling of tibial fatigue life in physically active males and females during different exercise protocols

Preventing bone stress injuries (BSI) requires a deep understanding of the condition's underlying causes and risk factors. Subject-specific computer modeling studies of gait mechanics, including the effect of changes in running speed, stride length, and landing patterns on tibial stress injury formation can provide essential insights into BSI prevention. This study aimed to computationally examine the effect of different exercise protocols on tibial fatigue life in male and female runners during prolonged walking and running at three different speeds. To achieve these aims, we combined subject-specific magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), gait data, finite element analysis, and a fatigue life prediction algorithm, including repair and adaptation's influence. The algorithm predicted a steep increase in the likelihood of developing a BSI within the first 40 days of activity. In five of the six subjects simulated, faster running speeds corresponded with higher tibial strains and higher probability of failure. Our simulations also showed that female subjects had a higher mean peak probability of failure in all four gait conditions than the male subjects studied. The approach used in this study could lay the groundwork for studies in larger populations and patient-specific clinical tools and decision support systems to reduce BSIs in athletes, military personnel, and other active individuals.

In vivo strains at the middle and distal thirds of the tibia during exertional activities

There is a known variance in the incidence and anatomical site of tibial stress fractures among infantry recruits and athletes who train according to established uniform training programs. To better understand the biomechanical basis for this variance, we conducted in vivo axial strain measurements using instrumented bone staples affixed in the medial cortex, aligned along the long axis of the tibia at the level of the mid and distal third of the bone in four male subjects. Strain measurements were made during treadmill walking, treadmill running, drop jumps from a 45 cm height onto a force plate and serial vertical jumps on a force plate. Significance levels for the main effects of location, type of activity and their interaction were determined by quasi-parametric methodologies. Compared to walking, running and vertical jumping peak axial tensile strain (με) was 1.94 (p = 0.009) and 3.92 times (p < 0.001) higher, respectively. Peak axial compression strain (με) values were found to be greater at the distal third than at the mid tibia for walking, running and vertical jumping (PR = 1.95, p-value<0.001). Peak axial compression and tension strains varied significantly between the subjects (all with p < 0.001), after controlling for strain gauge location and activity type.

The study findings help explain the variance in the anatomical location of tibial stress fractures among participants doing the same uniform training and offers evidence of individual biomechanical susceptibility to tibial stress fracture. The study data can provide guidance when developing a generalized finite element model for mechanical tibial loading. For subject specific decisions, individualized musculoskeletal finite element models may be necessary.

•

In vivo strains were measured simultaneously at the middle and distal tibial thirds.

•

Compression and tension varied between subjects controlling for location and activity.

•

Compared to walking, running and jumping tension was 1.94 and 3.92 higher.

•

Compression strains were greater at the distal third than at the mid tibia.

•

The data can be used to develop a generalized FE model for mechanical tibial loading.

Subject-specific Musculoskeletal Model for Studying Bone Strain During Dynamic Motion

Bone stress injuries are common in sports and military trainings. Repetitive large ground impact forces during training could be the cause. It is essential to determine the effect of high ground impact forces on lower-body bone deformation to better understand the mechanisms of bone stress injuries. Conventional strain gauge measurement has been used to study in vivo tibia deformation. This method is associated with limitations including invasiveness of the procedure, involvement of few human subjects, and limited strain data from small bone surface areas. The current study intends to introduce a novel approach to study tibia bone strain under high impact loading conditions. A subject-specific musculoskeletal model was created to represent a healthy male (19 years, 80 kg, 1,800 mm). A flexible finite element tibia model was created based on a computed tomography (CT) scan of the subject's right tibia. Laboratory motion capture was performed to obtain kinematics and ground reaction forces of drop-landings from different heights (26, 39, 52 cm). Multibody dynamic computer simulations combined with a modal analysis of the flexible tibia were performed to quantify tibia strain during drop-landings. Calculated tibia strain data were in good agreement with previous in vivo studies. It is evident that this non-invasive approach can be applied to study tibia bone strain during high impact activities for a large cohort, which will lead to a better understanding of injury mechanism of tibia stress fractures.

From mechanical stimulus to bone formation: A review

Bone is a remarkable tissue that can respond to external stimuli. The importance of mechanical forces on the mass and structural development of bone has long been accepted. This adaptation behaviour is very complex and involves multidisciplinary concepts, and significant progress has recently been made in understanding this process. In this review, we describe the state of the art studies in this area and highlight current insights while simultaneously clarifying some basic yet essential topics related to the origin of mechanical stimulus in bone, the biomechanisms associated with mechanotransduction, the nature of physiological bone stimuli and the test systems most commonly used to study the mechanical stimulation of bone.

Intracortical remodeling parameters are associated with measures of bone robustness

Prior work identified a novel association between bone robustness and porosity, which may be part of a broader interaction whereby the skeletal system compensates for the natural variation in robustness (bone width relative to length) by modulating tissue-level mechanical properties to increase stiffness of slender bones and to reduce mass of robust bones. To further understand this association, we tested the hypothesis that the relationship between robustness and porosity is mediated through intracortical, BMU-based (basic multicellular unit) remodeling. We quantified cortical porosity, mineralization, and histomorphometry at two sites (38% and 66% of the length) in human cadaveric tibiae. We found significant correlations between robustness and several histomorphometric variables (e.g., % secondary tissue [R(2)  = 0.68, P < 0.004], total osteon area [R(2)  = 0.42, P < 0.04]) at the 66% site. Although these associations were weaker at the 38% site, significant correlations between histological variables were identified between the two sites indicating that both respond to the same global effects and demonstrate a similar character at the whole bone level. Thus, robust bones tended to have larger and more numerous osteons with less infilling, resulting in bigger pores and more secondary bone area. These results suggest that local regulation of BMU-based remodeling may be further modulated by a global signal associated with robustness, such that remodeling is suppressed in slender bones but not in robust bones. Elucidating this mechanism further is crucial for better understanding the complex adaptive nature of the skeleton, and how interindividual variation in remodeling differentially impacts skeletal aging and an individuals' potential response to prophylactic treatments.

Bilateral tibial stress fractures: a case report

A stress fracture can be defined as a fracture of a bone caused by repeated (rather than sudden) mechanical stress. They have been reported in almost all bones of the body, with the lower extremity weight bearing bones, especially the tibia, tarsals and metatarsals, being affected most often. These injuries have a broad spectrum of severity and prognosis. Although the pathology of this injury is understood, the aetiology is less agreed upon. This can make it difficult for clinicians to diagnose and treat this common injury. Stress fractures of the proximal tibiae are common in elderly patients with osteoarthritis, and they are also reported in children. Here, we report an unusual case of an otherwise fit, young, adult male who presented with bilateral insufficiency stress fractures occurring simultaneously in both proximal tibiae. Stress fractures should be a differential diagnosis in any young, fit adult who presents with spontaneous knee pain.

Direct in vivo strain measurements in human bone-a systematic literature review

Bone strain is the governing stimuli for the remodeling process necessary in the maintenance of bone's structure and mechanical strength. Strain gages are the gold standard and workhorses of human bone experimental strain analysis in vivo. The objective of this systematic literature review is to provide an overview for direct in vivo human bone strain measurement studies and place the strain results within context of current theories of bone remodeling (i.e. mechanostat theory). We employed a standardized search strategy without imposing any time restriction to find English language studies indexed in PubMed and Web of Science databases that measured human bone strain in vivo. Twenty-four studies met our final inclusion criteria. Seven human bones were subjected to strain measurements in vivo including medial tibia, second metatarsal, calcaneus, proximal femur, distal radius, lamina of vertebra and dental alveolar. Peak strain magnitude recorded was 9096 με on the medial tibia during basketball rebounding and the peak strain rate magnitude was -85,500 με/s recorded at the distal radius during forward fall from standing, landing on extended hands. The tibia was the most exposed site for in vivo strain measurements due to accessibility and being a common pathologic site of stress fracture in the lower extremity. This systematic review revealed that most of the strains measured in vivo in different bones were generally within the physiological loading zone defined by the mechanostat theory, which implies stimulation of functional adaptation necessary to maintain bone mechanical integrity.

Effects of running speed on a probabilistic stress fracture model

BACKGROUND

Stress fractures are dependent on both loading magnitude and loading exposure. Decreasing speed is a potential mechanism of strain reduction during running. However, if running speed is decreased the number of loading cycles will increase for a given mileage. It is unclear if these increased loading cycles are detrimental despite reductions in bone strain. The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of running speed on the probability of tibial stress fracture during a new running regimen.

METHODS

Ten male subjects ran overground at 2.5, 3.5, and 4.5m/s. Force platform and kinematic data were collected synchronously. Inverse dynamics and musculoskeletal modeling were used to determine joint contact forces acting on the distal tibia. Peak tibial contact force served as input to a finite element model to estimate tibial strains. Stress fracture probability for each running speed was determined using a probabilistic model based on published relationships of bone damage, repair, and adaptation. The effects of speed on stress fracture probability was compared using a repeated measures ANOVA.

FINDINGS

Decreasing running speed from 4.5 to 3.5m/s reduced the estimated likelihood for stress fracture by 7% (P=0.017). Decreasing running speed from 3.5 to 2.5m/s further reduced the likelihood for stress fracture by 10% (P<0.001).

INTERPRETATION

Runners wanting to reduce their risk for tibial stress fracture may benefit from a decrease in running speed. For the speeds and mileage relative to the current study, stress fracture development was more dependent on loading magnitude rather than loading exposure.

Tibia adaptation after fibula harvesting: an in vivo quantitative study

Absence of the fibula after harvesting to reconstruct an upper-limb segment increases loads on the donor-side tibia and thereby provides a unique opportunity to analyze the bone adaptation process in humans. We therefore quantified densitometric and morphologic changes of the donor-side tibia in three young patients (ages 8, 13, 16 years), on the basis of computed tomography (CT) examinations of both legs (one preoperatively and two postoperatively). The range of final followup was 27-43 months. Three-dimensional models of shank bones were generated from CT data and used to measure cross-sectional area, diaphyseal cortical thickness, and cross-sectional moment of inertia. In addition, density of the newly formed bone was evaluated. The donor-side tibia showed morphologic and density adaptation with time. New bone was deposited predominantly in the interosseous space and almost replaced the bone area lost by excision of the fibula. The second moment of area grew more in the donor-side tibia than in the intact one, without fully recovering the contralateral tibia-fibula complex values, and the principal axes rotated toward the preoperative direction. Thus, while considerable adaptation had occurred by 27-43 months in these young patients, the adaptation was incomplete; the mineral density of the newly formed bone recovered normal cortical bone values only in the patient with the longest followup (43 months).

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, therapeutic study. See the Guidelines for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

The BPAQ: a bone-specific physical activity assessment instrument

A newly developed bone-specific physical activity questionnaire (BPAQ) was compared with other common measures of physical activity for its ability to predict parameters of bone strength in healthy, young adults. The BPAQ predicted indices of bone strength at clinically relevant sites in both men and women, while other measures did not.

INTRODUCTION

Only certain types of physical activity (PA) are notably osteogenic. Most methods to quantify levels of PA fail to account for bone relevant loading. Our aim was to examine the ability of several methods of PA assessment and a new bone-specific measure to predict parameters of bone strength in healthy adults.

METHODS

We recruited 40 men and women (mean age 24.5). Subjects completed the modifiable activity questionnaire, Bouchard 3-day activity record, a recently published bone loading history questionnaire (BLHQ), and wore a pedometer for 14 days. We also administered our bone-specific physical activity questionnaire (BPAQ). Calcaneal broadband ultrasound attenuation (BUA) (QUS-2, Quidel) and densitometric measures (XR-36, Norland) were examined. Multiple regression and correlation analyses were performed on the data.

RESULTS

The current activity component of BPAQ was a significant predictor of variance in femoral neck bone mineral density (BMD), lumbar spine BMD, and whole body BMD (R(2) = 0.36-0.68, p < 0.01) for men, while the past activity component of BPAQ predicted calcaneal BUA (R(2) = 0.48, p = 0.001) for women.

CONCLUSIONS

The BPAQ predicted indices of bone strength at skeletal sites at risk of osteoporotic fracture while other PA measurement tools did not.

Evaluation of macrostructural bone biomechanics

Bone fragility can be defined as an increased risk of fractures. Advanced age and bone diseases such as osteoporosis increase the fracture risk. Understanding the effects of osteoporosis and its treatments requires a description of the mechanical behavior of bone tissue. To this end, an entire bone can be studied, or the cortical and trabecular components can be investigated separately. We review the biomechanical tests available for measuring the ability of bone to withstand torsional, compressive, tensile, and bending forces.

The line of action in the tibia during axial compression of the leg

Compression of the leg induces bending in the tibia, which can lead to tensile failure of the bone in the midshaft. The purpose of this study was to determine the orientation of the compressive load vector in the human tibia. Five cadaveric lower extremities were instrumented with in situ 6-axis tibial and fibular load cells and subjected to quasistatic axial leg compression tests in two knee positions and nine ankle positions. For each test, the location and angle of the line of action were calculated at the tibial midshaft. The line of action was extended to the bone ends in order to determine the locations of the effective centers of pressure on the tibial plafond and tibial plateau. The effective center of pressure on the tibial plafond consistently migrated anteriorly in dorsiflexion, laterally in eversion, posteriorly in plantarflexion, and medially in inversion. An opposite pattern was observed on the tibial plateau. When the knee was flexed, the effective center of pressure was generally isolated to a small area in the posterior portion of the medial tibial condyle. The percentage of the axial load borne by the fibula varied from -8% to 19%, and was related to the inversion/eversion angle of the ankle (p<0.02), as well as the distance between the fibula and the axial load path at the midshaft (p<0.001). The line of action through the tibia appeared to follow the external load path to the extent allowed by the available joint contact surfaces.

Interactions between microstructural and geometrical adaptation in human cortical bone

With aging and in disease, the changes in bone microstructure and geometry influence the mechanical properties of cortical bone, however, the level of interaction between the two is not known. Here, we investigate the interaction between the changes in microstructural and geometrical properties of the aging male tibia in proximal and distal middiaphysis. The microstructural measurements include variables related to the size and density of osteons and intracortical porosity. The macroscopic geometrical properties include variables related to bone surfaces (periosteal and endosteal) and cross section (area, moment of inertia). Site-specific correlations were found between the microstructural and geometrical properties along the bone length and at different bone surfaces. In contrast to the proximal middiaphysis of male tibia, where no correlation existed, significant (p<0.05) correlations were found in the distal middiaphysis of tibia. The changes in parameters partially related to bone formation in the cortex, including the osteonal area, showed positive correlations with an increase in the periosteal diameter. Similarly, parameters related to bone resorption and/or failed formation in the cortex, including porosity and pore size, showed significant correlations with cortical thinning. These findings support the concept that, with aging, anabolic and catabolic responses in the human tibia at microstructural and macrostructural levels are spatially related and site specific.

Stress Fractures Around the Knee

Stress fractures of the lower extremities are common, especially in the younger athletic population. The current literature consists mainly a variety of case reports but is devoid of any sizeable series of knee stress fracture investigations. Diagnosing a stress fracture around the knee can be a challenge. The proximity of the stress fracture to the knee joint may lead the clinician to investigate intra-articular or other periarticular pathology. The differential diagnosis can be large, including bursitis, tendonitis, mechanical causes, insufficiency fracture, and tumor. A high index of suspicion is necessary to confirm the underlying diagnosis. A patient's medical history combined with a physical examination and imaging modalities will aid the physician in arriving at the diagnosis of stress fracture.

Free moment as a predictor of tibial stress fracture in distance runners

Stress fractures are a common and serious overuse injury in runners, particularly female runners. They may be related to loading characteristics of the lower extremity during running stance. Some tibial stress fractures (TSFs) are spiral in nature and, therefore, may be related to torque. Free moment (FM) is a measure of torque about a vertical axis at the interface with the shoe and ground. Increases in FM variables may be related to a history of TSF in runners. The purpose of this cross-sectional study was to investigate differences in FM between female distance runners with and without a history of TSF and, additionally, to investigate the relationship between absolute FM and the occurrence of TSF. A group of 25 currently uninjured female distance runners with a history of TSF (28+/-10 years, 46+/-15 km week(-1)) and an age- and mileage-matched control group of 25 healthy runners with no previous lower extremity fractures (26+/-9 years, 46+/-19 km week(-1)) participated in this study. Ground reaction forces and foot placement on the force platform were recorded during running at 3.7 ms(-1) (+/-5%). Peak adduction, braking peak and absolute peak FM and impulse were compared between groups using one-tailed t-tests. The predictive value of absolute peak FM was investigated via a binary logistic regression. All variables, except impulse, were significantly greater in runners with a history of TSF. Absolute peak FM had a significant predictive relationship with history of TSF. There is a significant relationship between higher values for FM variables and a history of TSF.

Damage mechanisms and failure modes of cortical bone under components of physiological loading

Fatigue damage development in cortical bone was investigated in vitro under different mechanical components of physiological loading including tension, compression, and torsion. During each test, stress and strain data were collected continuously to monitor and statistically determine the occurrence of the primary, secondary, and tertiary stages associated with fatigue and/or creep failure of bone. The resultant microdamage and failure modes were identified by histological and fractographic analysis, respectively. The tensile group demonstrated Mode I cracking and the three classic stages of fatigue and creep suggesting a low crack initiation threshold, steady crack propagation and final failure by coalescence of microcracks. In contrast, the compressive group displayed Mode II cracking and a two-stage fatigue behavior with limited creep suggesting a high crack initiation threshold followed by a sudden fracture. The torsion group also displayed a two-stage fatigue profile but demonstrated extensive damage from mixed mode (Modes II and III) microcracking and predominant time-dependent damage. Thus, fatigue behavior of bone was found to be uniquely related to the individual mechanical components of physiological loading and the latter determined the specific damage mechanisms associated with fatigue fracture.

Ground reaction forces associated with an effective elementary school based jumping intervention

BACKGROUND

Mechanical loading during childhood plays a critical role in normal growth and development of the skeleton. Ground reaction forces (GRFs) may provide a surrogate measure for the strain experienced by bone on landing and at take off. However, there appear to be no paediatric studies that assess GRFs across a variety of loading activities.

OBJECTIVES

To measure biomechanical variables in commonly performed childhood activities used in an elementary physical education intervention study which augmented bone health in boys and girls.

METHODS

Maximal GFR, maximal rates of force, and time to maximum force were measured for 12 different jumping activities on a force platform. The jumps measured were drop jumps from 10, 30, and 50 cm, all followed by a plyometric jump, submaximal and maximal jumping jacks, alternating feet jump, counter movement jumps, and side to side jumps over 10 and 20 cm foam barriers. The subjects were 70 children (36 boys and 34 girls), 8.3-11.7 years old.

RESULTS

Subjects ranged in height from 128.4 to 172.6 cm and had a mass of 25.0-57.0 kg. Mean (SD) for vertical jump was 24.2 (5.5) cm and 135.2 (16.6) cm for standing long jump. The children engaged in loaded physical activity 5.7 (5.3) hours a week, on average. The highest mean maximal GRFs, normalised for body weight (BW), were generated from the plyometric portion of the drop jumps and the counter movement jump (about 5 times BW) compared with 3.5 times BW for jumping jacks. Similarly, the highest rates of change in force were 514 times BW/s for the drop jump from 10 cm and 493 times BW/s for the counter movement jump.

CONCLUSIONS

Simple jumps requiring minimal equipment produce GRFs of 3.5-5 times BW and rates of force of around 500 times BW/s. As children appear to attenuate higher impact forces when jumping from increased heights, it cannot be assumed that merely increasing the height of the jump will necessarily "progress" the exercise intervention.

A comparison of bone strain measurements at anatomically relevant sites using surface gauges versus strain gauged bone staples

Instrumented bone staples were first introduced as an alternative to surface-mounted strain gauges for use in human in vivo bone strain measurements because their fixation to bone is secure and requires not only minimally invasive surgery. Bench-top bone bending models have shown that the output from strain gauged bone staples compares favorably to that of traditional mounted gauges. However their within- and across-subject performance at sites typically instrumented in vivo has never been examined. This study used seven human cadaver lower extremities with an age range of 23-81 years old and a dynamic gait simulator to examine and compare axial strains in the mid tibial diaphysis and on the dorsal surface of the second metatarsal as measured simultaneously with strain gauged bone staples and with traditional surface-mounted gauges. Rosette configurations were used at the tibial site for deriving principal compression and tension, and shear strains. Axial outputs from the two gauge types demonstrated strong linear relationships for the tibia (r(2)=0.78-0.94) and the second metatarsal (r(2)=0.96-0.99), but coefficients (slopes) for the relationship were variable (range 7-20), across subjects and across sites. The apparent low reliability of strain gauged staples may be explained by the fact that both strain gauged staples and surface strain gauges are inexact to some degree, do not measure strains from exactly the same areas and strain gauged staples reflect surface strains as well as deformations within the cortex. There were no relationships for the principal tibia compression, tension or shear strain measurements derived from the two rosette gauge types, reflecting the very different anatomical areas measured by each of the constructs in this study. Strain gauged bone staples may be most useful in comparing relative axial intra-subject differences between activities, but inter-subject variability may require larger sample sizes to detect differences between populations.

Biomechanical analysis for stress fractures of the anterior middle third of the tibia in athletes: nonlinear analysis using a three-dimensional finite element method

We evaluated stresses in the anterior middle third of the tibia that have been reported to predict a poor prognosis for tibial stress fractures compared to other predominant sites (posteromedial regions of the distal third and proximal third). The effect of two different loads (bending-compression load and torsional load) on three sites was investigated using a three-dimensional finite element method. The model was constructed using the tibia, fibula, proximal tibiofibular joint, interosseous membrane, and tibiofibular ligament based on computed tomography scans obtained at 4-mm intervals of the lower leg of a 20-year-old woman who exhibited no abnormal findings on roentgenograms. First, a normal model was constructed using normal material properties, and then the model was modified to produce fracture models by varying the mechanical properties of each predominant site and expanding the area in three gradual phases on the assumption that the fracture advanced in three phases. Each model was tested against the same two loads, and stresses at the nodal points on the border of the fracture area and normal area were compared in each cross section to determine the effect of the load on fracture advancement. In response to torsional load, both the normal model and fracture models tended to show higher values for the posteromedial distal third than the anterior middle third. By examining the bending-compression load it could be seen that the mean peak value significantly decreased between the first and second phases in fracture models of the anterior middle third. This finding was inconsistent with our previous belief that the bending-compression load would have more serious consequences than the torsional load. In contrast, when the area of fracture was expanded into the third phase, maximum values were significantly higher than during the second phase. No similar finding was observed for the posteromedial distal third, suggesting that the anterior middle third may have the same stable biomechanical conditions as the posteromedial distal third at an earlier stage and thus have little influence on fractures. When the fracture is more advanced, however, the conditions change suddenly, and a bending-compression load may adversely affect the mechanical conditions in this area and thereby cause complete fracture.

Microdamage and mechanical behaviour: predicting failure and remodelling in compact bone

This paper reports on the development of a theoretical model to simulate the growth and repair of microdamage in bone. Unlike previous theories, which use simplified descriptions of damage, this approach models each individual microcrack explicitly, and also models the basic multicellular units (BMUs) that repair cracks. A computer simulation has been developed that is capable of making a variety of predictions. Firstly, we can predict the mechanical behaviour of dead bone in laboratory experiments, including estimates of the number of cycles to failure and the number and length of microcracks during fatigue tests. Secondly, we can predict the results of bone histomorphometry, including such parameters as BMU activation rates and the changing ratio of primary to secondary bone during ageing. Thirdly, we can predict the occurrence of stress fractures in living bone: these occur when the severity of loading is so great that cracks grow faster than they can be repaired. Finally, we can predict the phenomenon of adaptation, in which bone is deposited to increase cortical thickness and thus prevent stress fractures. In all cases results compare favourably with experimental and clinical data.

Effects of fatigue and load variation on metatarsal deformation measured in vivo during barefoot walking

This in vivo study presents information to assist in the understanding of metatarsal stress fracture etiology. The aims were (a) to provide a fundamental description of loading patterns of the second metatarsal (MTII) during barefoot walking, and (b) to investigate the hypothesis that MTII dorsal strain increases with fatigue and external carrying load. Dorsal MTII strain was measured in vivo under local anaesthetic with an instrumented staple in eight subjects. Experimental conditions were external loading with a 20 kg backpack and pre- and post-fatigue. M. flexor digitorum longus electromyography tentatively indicated fatigue after an extended walking treatment. A reproducible, cyclic temporal pattern of dorsal MTII surface deformation was described. Mean peak compression and tension strains in unloaded barefoot walking were -1534 +/- 636 and 363 +/- 359 muepsilon, respectively. Mean peak compression strain rate (SR) was -4165 +/- 1233 muepsilon/s. Compression strain increased significantly (alpha=0.05) both with the addition of the backpack and post-fatigue while maximum tension decreased significantly post-fatigue. SR increased significantly with the addition of the backpack. The highest plantar force time integrals were recorded underneath the heads of metatarsals II-V for all conditions (1561Ns pre-fatigue, without backpack; 2123Ns post, with). EMG and plantar pressure data presented a comprehensive description of biomechanical parameters influencing dorsal MTII deformation and alterations in strain following two experimental conditions were suggested as contributing factors in the pathogenesis of metatarsal stress fractures.

Metatarsal strains are sufficient to cause fatigue fracture during cyclic overloading

Human in vivo tibial strains during vigorous walking have not been found to exceed 1200 microstrains. These values are below those found in ex vivo studies (>3000 microstrains) to cause cortical bone fatigue failure, suggesting that an intermediate bone remodeling response may be associated with tibial stress fractures. Metatarsal stress fractures, however, often develop before there is time for such a response to occur. Simultaneous in vivo axial strains were measured at the mid diaphysis of the second metatarsal and the tibia in two subjects. Peak axial metatarsal compression strains and strain rates were significantly higher than those of the tibia during treadmill walking and jogging both barefoot and with running shoes and during simple calisthenics. During barefoot treadmill walking metatarsal compression strains were greater than 2500 microstrains. During one- and two-leg vertical jumps and broad jumping, both metatarsal compression and tension strains were >3000 microstrains. Compression and tension strains in the metatarsus unlike those of the tibia may be sufficiently high even during moderate exertional activities to cause fatigue failure of bone secondary to the number of loading cycles without an intermediate bone remodeling response.

Stress fracture of the medial tibial condyle

Although stress fractures of the tibial diaphysis are common among athletes, the proximal tibial metaphysis is an unusual location for such injuries. In addition, their proximity to the knee joint can obscure the diagnosis. We present a case of a stress fracture of the medial tibial condyle in a long-distance runner, aiming to increase awareness about this uncommon and interesting differential diagnostic problem. A change in running conditions preceded the fracture and should always raise suspicion of overuse injuries. MRI scan has proved very sensitive for diagnosing stress fractures and provided a definite diagnosis in our case.

Do high impact exercises produce higher tibial strains than running?

BACKGROUND

Bone must have sufficient strength to withstand both instantaneous forces and lower repetitive forces. Repetitive loading, especially when bone strain and/or strain rates are high, can create microdamage and result in stress fracture

AIM

To measure in vivo strains and strain rates in human tibia during high impact and moderate impact exercises.

METHODS

Three strain gauged bone staples were mounted percutaneously in a rosette pattern in the mid diaphysis of the medial tibia in six normal subjects, and in vivo tibial strains were measured during running at 17 km/h and drop jumping from heights of 26, 39, and 52 cm.

RESULTS

Complete data for all three drop jumps were obtained for four of the six subjects. No statistically significant differences were found in compression, tension, or shear strains with increasing drop jump height, but, at the 52 cm height, shear strain rate was reduced by one third (p = 0.03). No relation was found between peak compression strain and calculated drop jump energy, indicating that subjects were able to dissipate part of the potential energy of successively higher drop jumps by increasing the range of motion of their knee and ankle joints and not transmitting the energy to their tibia. No statistically significant differences were found between the principal strains during running and drop jumping from 52 cm, but compression (p = 0.01) and tension (p = 0.004) strain rates were significantly higher during running.

CONCLUSIONS

High impact exercises, as represented by drop jumping in this experiment, do not cause higher tibial strains and strain rates than running and therefore are unlikely to place an athlete who is accustomed to fast running at higher risk for bone fatigue.

An in vitro comparison of bone deformation measured with surface and staple mounted strain gauges

Chicken tibiae were chosen as a model for human second metatarsals. Local surface bone deformation in a 4-point bending configuration was measured in vitro by both strain gauge instrumented staples and strain gauges bonded to the bone's cortical surface. A series of staple bridge dimensions (0.5, 0.6, 0.8 and 1.0 mm) was compared to test for staple influence on bone characteristics and greatest measurement validity and reliability. Thicker staple inhibition of bone deformation was the greatest but differences to thinner staples were not statistically significant (p > 0.05). All staples except 0.5 mm had maximum deviations from linearity less than 1%. The 1.0 mm staple had an R2 value of 0.992 +/- 0.006 plotted against the 4-point bending input force and 0.994 +/- 0.002 plotted against the surface strain gauge signal. The mean intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) calculated with four input forces (30, 60, 90 and 120 N) and for loading and unloading conditions for the 0.5, 0.6, 0.8 and 1.0 mm staples were 0.75, 0.83, 0.87 and 0.92, respectively. Finally, the differences in slope of the staple strain gauge signal plotted against surface strain gauge signal between input force loading and unloading conditions (0.32), and between input compression and tension conditions (0.79) was least for the 1.0 mm staple which also resulted in the lowest standard deviations. These results suggested the appropriateness of the 1.0 mm staple for in vivo application.

Risk factors for stress fractures

Preventing stress fractures requires knowledge of the risk factors that predispose to this injury. The aetiology of stress fractures is multifactorial, but methodological limitations and expediency often lead to research study designs that evaluate individual risk factors. Intrinsic risk factors include mechanical factors such as bone density, skeletal alignment and body size and composition, physiological factors such as bone turnover rate, flexibility, and muscular strength and endurance, as well as hormonal and nutritional factors. Extrinsic risk factors include mechanical factors such as surface, footwear and external loading as well as physical training parameters. Psychological traits may also play a role in increasing stress fracture risk. Equally important to these types of analyses of individual risk factors is the integration of information to produce a composite picture of risk. The purpose of this paper is to critically appraise the existing literature by evaluating study design and quality, in order to provide a current synopsis of the known scientific information related to stress fracture risk factors. The literature is not fully complete with well conducted studies on this topic, but a great deal of information has accumulated over the past 20 years. Although stress fractures result from repeated loading, the exact contribution of training factors (volume, intensity, surface) has not been clearly established. From what we do know, menstrual disturbances, caloric restriction, lower bone density, muscle weakness and leg length differences are risk factors for stress fracture. Other time-honoured risk factors such as lower extremity alignment have not been shown to be causative even though anecdotal evidence indicates they are likely to play an important role in stress fracture pathogenesis.