Development of a 1-microl scale assay for mitogen-activated kinase kinase 7 using 2-D fluorescence intensity distribution analysis anisotropy

CLAffinity: A Software Tool for Identification of Optimum Ligand Affinity for Competition-Based Primary Screens

A simplistic assumption in setting up a competition assay is that a low affinity labeled ligand can be more easily displaced from a target protein than a high affinity ligand, which in turn produces a more sensitive assay. An often-cited paper correctly rallies against this assumption and recommends the use of the highest affinity ligand available for experiments aiming to determine competitive inhibitor affinities. However, we have noted this advice being applied incorrectly to competition-based primary screens where the goal is optimum assay sensitivity, enabling a clear yes/no binding determination for even low affinity interactions. The published advice only applies to secondary, confirmatory assays intended for accurate affinity determination of primary screening hits. We demonstrate that using very high affinity ligands in competition-based primary screening can lead to reduced assay sensitivity and, ultimately, the discarding of potentially valuable active compounds. We build on techniques developed in our PyBindingCurve software for a mechanistic understanding of complex biological interaction systems, developing the "CLAffinity tool" for simulating competition experiments using protein, ligand, and inhibitor concentrations common to drug screening campaigns. CLAffinity reveals optimum labeled ligand affinity ranges based on assay parameters, rather than general rules to optimize assay sensitivity. We provide the open source CLAffinity software toolset to carry out assay simulations and a video summarizing key findings to aid in understanding, along with a simple lookup table allowing identification of optimal dynamic ranges for competition-based primary screens. The application of our freely available software and lookup tables will lead to the consistent creation of more performant competition-based primary screens identifying valuable hit compounds, particularly for difficult targets.

Detection of siRNA administered to cells and animals by using a fluorescence intensity distribution analysis polarization system

Small interfering RNA (siRNA) has excellent pharmacological features and is expected to be used for therapeutic drug development. To this end, however, new RNA technology needs to be established so that extremely small amounts (less than 1 pmol) of siRNA can be detected in organs of experimental animals and in human blood to facilitate pharmacokinetics studies. An important feature is that this new technology is not dependent on radioisotopes and can detect siRNA molecules identical to those used for drug development in preclinical tests with experimental animals or in clinical tests with humans. We report a convenient method that can detect small amounts of siRNA. The method uses high-power confocal microscopic analysis of fluorescence polarization in DNA probes that are bound to one of the strands of siRNA and directly quantitates the copy number of siRNA molecule after extraction from specimens. A pharmacokinetic study to examine the blood retention time of siRNA/cationic liposomes in mice showed that this straightforward method is consistent with the other reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction amplification-based method. We believe that the entire process is simple and applicable for a high-throughput analysis, which provides excellent technical support for fundamental research on RNA interference and development of siRNA drugs.

Multiparameter analysis of a screen for progesterone receptor ligands: comparing fluorescence lifetime and fluorescence polarization measurements

Direct measurement of the fluorescence lifetime (FLT) of a fluorescent label is an emerging method for high-throughput screening. Changes in the fluorescence lifetime can be correlated to changes in the non-radiative relaxation pathway(s) for the excited state of the label. These pathways can be environmentally sensitive, such as when a labeled analyte is free in solution versus bound to a receptor. Because lifetime is an intrinsic property of a fluorophore, it is not concentration dependent, and therefore has advantages similar to those of ratiometric fluorescent techniques such as fluorescence resonance energy transfer or fluorescence polarization. We have applied the FLT measurement technique to a screen of a small compound library in order to identify compounds that bind to the progesterone receptor, and compared the results to those obtained by performing the assay in fluorescence polarization mode. Each readout modality showed excellent Z'; values, with the FLT readout performing slightly better in this respect. Interfering compounds could be rapidly identified for either assay format by comparing the results between the two formats.

Early Identification of False Positives in High-Throughput Screening for Activators of p53-DNA Interaction

Naturally occurring mutant forms of p53 are deficient for specific DNA binding. However, their specific DNA binding can be reactivated. The search for small molecules that reactivate latent p53 is considered to be a cornerstone in cancer therapy. The authors describe a new homogeneous fluorescent assay approach for the characterization of binding affinities of human wild-type latent and activated p53 using DNA*spec(26), with and without the addition of the antibody PAb421, respectively, and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS)/2-dimensional fluorescence-intensity distribution analysis anisotropy as the detection methods. FCS was compared with 2D-FIDA anisotropy, and a very good correlation of the results with both readouts was observed (KDs for nonspecific DNA binding of 24.4 ± 3.5 nM with 2D-FIDA anisotropy and of 29.5 ± 5.5 nM with FCS). The presence of poly(dI-dC) led to a 10-fold increase of binding affinity (KD of 3.3 ± 0.5 nM in the presence of PAb421). 2D-FIDA anisotropy was demonstrated to be the most accurate readout; hence, this detection technology was selected for a 25,000 compound member high-throughput screening (HTS) campaign. The hits obtained were qualified using a novel data evaluation algorithm that identifies false positives and moreover assesses the validity of true hits in the presence of the deteriorating artifact. This process step is of utmost importance for decreasing the attrition in fluorescence-based HTS.

Calculation of photon-count number distributions via master equations

Fitting of photon-count number histograms is a way of analysis of fluorescence intensity fluctuations, a successor to fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. First versions of the theory for calculating photon-count number distributions have assumed constant emission intensity by a molecule during a counting time interval. For a long time a question has remained unanswered: to what extent is this assumption violated in experiments? Here we present a theory of photon-count number distributions that takes account of intensity fluctuations during a counting time interval. Theoretical count-number distributions are calculated via a numerical solution of Master equations (ME), which is a set of differential equations describing diffusion, singlet-triplet transitions, and photon emission. Detector afterpulsing and dead-time corrections are also included. The ME-theory is tested by fitting a series of photon-count number histograms corresponding to different lengths of the counting time interval. Compared to the first version of fluorescence intensity multiple distribution analysis theory introduced in 2000, the fit quality is significantly improved. It is discussed how a theory of photon-count number distributions, which assumes constant emission intensity during a counting time interval, may also yield a good fit quality. We argue that the spatial brightness distribution used in calculations of the fit curve is not the true spatial brightness distribution. Instead, a number of dynamic processes, which cause fluorescence intensity fluctuations, are indirectly taken into account via the profile adjustment parameters.

Development and implementation of a highly miniaturized confocal 2D-FIDA-based high-throughput screening assay to search for active site modulators of the human heat shock protein 90beta

The beta isoform of the heat shock protein 90 (Hsp90beta) is a cellular chaperone required for the maturation of key proteins involved in growth response to extracellular factors as well as oncogenic transformation of various cell types. Compounds that inhibit the function of Hsp90beta are thus believed to have potential as novel anticancer drugs. To date, 2 fungal metabolites are known to inhibit Hsp90beta. However, insolubility and liver toxicity restrict the clinical use of these molecules. The limitation to identify novel and safe Hsp90beta inhibitors is that presently no suitable high-throughput screening assay is available. Here, the authors present the development of a homogenous assay based on 2-dimensional fluorescence intensity distribution analysis of tetramethyl-rhodamine (TAMRA)-labeled radicicol bound to Hsp90beta. Furthermore, the assay has been shown to be compatible with the confocal nanoscreening platform Mark II from Evotec-Technologies and can therefore be used for miniaturized high-throughput screening. The applied detection technology provides critical information about the nature of biomolecular interaction at the thermodynamic equilibrium, such as affinity constants and stoichiometric parameters of the binding. The assay is used to identify small molecular weight compounds displacing TAMRA-radicicol. Such compounds are believed to be important molecules in the discovery of novel anticancer drugs.

Rapid analysis of Forster resonance energy transfer by two-color global fluorescence correlation spectroscopy: trypsin proteinase reaction

In this study we introduce the combination of two-color global fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (2CG-FCS) and Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) as a very powerful combination for monitoring biochemical reactions on the basis of single molecule events. 2CG-FCS, which is a new variation emerging from the family of fluorescence correlation spectroscopy, globally analyzes the simultaneously recorded auto- and cross-correlation data from two photon detectors monitoring the fluorescence emission of different colors. Overcoming the limitations inherent in mere auto- and cross-correlation analysis, 2CG-FCS is sensitive in resolving and quantifying fluorescent species that differ in their diffusion characteristics and/or their molecular brightness either in one or both detection channels. It is able to account for effects that have often been considered as sources of severe artifacts in two-color and FRET measurements, the most prominent artifacts comprising photobleaching, cross talk, or concentration variations in sample preparation. Because of its very high statistical accuracy, the combination of FRET and 2CG-FCS is suited for high-throughput applications such as drug screening. Employing beam scanning during data acquisition even further enhances this capability and allows measurement times of <2 s. The improved performance in monitoring a FRET sample was verified by following the protease cleavage reaction of a FRET-active peptide. The FRET-inactive subpopulation of uncleaved substrate could be correctly assigned, revealing a substantial portion of inactive or missing acceptor label. The results were compared to those obtained by two-dimensional fluorescence intensity distribution analysis.

Development and automation of a 384-well cell fusion assay to identify inhibitors of CCR5/CD4-mediated HIV virus entry

This article describes the automation of an in vitro cell-based fusion assay for the identification of novel inhibitors of receptor mediated HIV-1 entry. The assay utilises two stable cell lines: one expressing CD4, CCR5 and an LTR-promoter/beta-galactosidase reporter construct, and the other expressing gp160 and tat. Accumulation of beta-galactosidase can only occur following fusion of these two cell lines via the gp160 and receptor mediators, as this event facilitates the transfer of the tat transcription factor between the two cell types. Although similar cell fusion systems have been described previously, they have not met the requirements for HTS due to complexity, throughput and reagent cost. The assay described in this article provides significant advantage, as (a) no transfection/infection events are required prior to the assay, reducing the potential for variability, (b) cells are mixed in solution, enhancing fusion efficiency compared to adherent cells, (c) miniaturization to low volume enables screening in 384-well plates; and (d) online cell dispensing facilitates automated screening. This assay has been employed to screen approximately 650,000 compounds in a singleton format. The data demonstrate that the assay is robust, with a Z' consistently above 0.6, which compares favourably with less complex biochemical assays.

Miniaturized, ultra-high throughput screening of tyrosine kinases using homogeneous, competitive fluorescence immunoassays

Assay miniaturization and the implementation of high-density 1,536-microwell screening increase the speed and efficiency of screening and lead discovery. To serve this need, a platform of miniaturizable assay technologies has been assembled for specific biological targets. This platform will enable initiation and completion of uHTS screens in a straightforward and expeditious manner. Although faster primary screening does contribute to a reduction in timelines, the process of assay development can become a bottleneck. Assay technologies that do not require the use of target-specific reagents can reduce the time necessary for assay development. Assays that measure inhibition of tyrosine kinases can be configured in a competitive format where only the enzyme itself is specific to the assay. In this context, several technologies, including time-resolved fluorometry (also known as DELFIA), time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (also known as LANCE( trade mark )), fluorescence polarization, enzyme fragmentation complementation assay, and confocal laser scanning imaging, were examined. Quality parameters such as assay reproducibility, signal:background ratio, Z factor, and assay sensitivity were compared. Additionally, the relative merits of each of these technologies are assessed in terms of assay miniaturization, ease of development, ultimate screening capability, efficiency, and cost.

Fluorescence readouts in HTS: no gain without pain?

Fluorescence-based detection technologies are frequently applied in biological testing, due to their unique advantages in setting up homogeneous, sensitive assays in miniaturized formats. However, the wide application of these readouts has highlighted challenges in reagent design and problems with interference from biological reagents and compounds. Here, we summarize the current application of fluorescence-based detection methodologies, focusing on the problems faced by assay developers and on solutions to reduce false positive and negative results in fluorescence-based HTS.