Response profiles of circulating leukocytes and metal ions in patients with a modular dual-mobility hip implant

Metal Articulations as a Source of Total Hip Arthroplasty Pain

The consensus systematic risk stratification algorithm from the American Association of Hip and Knee Surgeons, the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, and The Hip Society summarizes clinical challenges in evaluation and treatment of metal-on-polyethylene total hip arthroplasty (THA) patients with adverse local tissue reaction (ALTR) due to mechanically assisted crevice corrosion (MACC), reviews up-to-date evidence, and identifies the areas for future research in order to provide a useful resource for orthopedic surgeons providing care to these patients. A painful THA has various intrinsic and extrinsic causes. ALTR is one of the intrinsic causes in patients with painful THA. The occurrence of ALTR due to MACC at modular junctions is likely to be multifactorial, including implant, surgical, and patient factors. Therefore, a systematic evaluation needs to involve a focused clinical history, detailed physical examination, laboratory tests, and imaging in order to identify potential differential diagnoses. There should be a low threshold to perform a systematic evaluation of patients with painful non-metal-on-metal THA, including patients with metal-on-polyethylene THA, and modular dual-mobility THA with the CoCr metal acetabular insert, as early recognition and diagnosis of ALTR due to MACC will facilitate initiation of appropriate treatment prior to significant adverse biological reactions. Specialized tests such as blood metal analysis and metal artifact reduction sequence magnetic resonance imaging are important modalities in evaluation and management of ALTR in patients with painful THA.

Clinical Concerns With Dual Mobility- Should I Avoid it When Possible?

The utilization of dual mobility (DM) articulations in total hip arthroplasty (THA) is increasing. The principal appeal of DM implants is its ability to reduce postoperative instability by maximizing the effective ball head size for each reconstruction. However, while DM implants have been used worldwide for over 3 decades, the experience in North America is more limited. Moreover, there remains concerns with intraprosthetic dissociation, wear, metallosis, and soft tissue impingement. Therefore, the purpose of this article is to review the available evidence for these potential issues. First, intraprosthetic dissociation (IPD) is a unique complication of DM implants. Although the rate has decreased with improvements in materials and design, the reported prevalence is approximately 1%. Second, wear in DM implants can be unpredictable and increased wear has been reported in younger, active patients. Third, corrosion in modular DM implants has been described and elevations in serum cobalt and chromium levels have been reported. While the clinical significance of these elevations is unclear, it remains a source of concern with these implants. Finally, psoas impingement and entrapment can be a source of persistent groin pain after THA. DM articulations are a valuable addition to the armamentarium of total hip surgeons. However, these bearings are not free of complications. Consequently, current data only support selective use of DM bearings in patients at increased risk for postoperative instability after arthroplasty.

Metal ion levels with use of modular dual mobility constructs: Can the evidence guide us on clinical use?

Introduction

Dual mobility (DM) use in total hip arthroplasty (THA) has increased, particularly for prevention and management of instability. However, a modular interface raises concern for metal ion generation. The purpose of this study was to determine the 1) serum cobalt and chromium levels; 2) prevalence of ion levels >1 mcg/L; and 3) effect of femoral head material on ion levels following THA using modular DM bearings.

Methods

We performed a systematic review (MEDLINE, Embase, Cochrane databases) for articles relating to metal ion levels and modular DM (MDM) THA. Eight studies (290 patients) met the inclusion criteria. We recorded post-operative ion levels at a minimum of 12 months, and compared levels with ceramic (n = 125) and metal femoral heads (n = 165). A meta-analysis could not be performed due to poor study quality and heterogeneity.

Results

At average follow-up of 30.4 months, mean cobalt level was 0.71 mcg/L, and mean chromium level was 0.66 mcg/L [22 patients (8%) had elevated ion levels above 1 mcg/L]. When compared to MDM with a ceramic head, metal head use had higher cobalt (1.26 vs. 0.42 mcg/L) and chromium levels (1.23 vs. 0.46 mcg/L). MDM with a metal head was 1.30 times more likely to have elevated ion levels >1 mcg/L. There was no effect of ion levels on outcome scores.

Conclusions

Measurable elevations of serum cobalt and chromium levels are present in patients with well-functioning MDM THAs. The impact and contributions of the additional metal liner interface are still unclear. The use of a ceramic head appears to mitigate ion release, while reducing other mechanisms of metallosis like taper corrosion. Higher quality studies are necessary to understand whether MDM bearings pose long term issues. Until then, the judicious use of MDM articulations is recommended.

Serum metal ion levels in modular dual mobility acetabular components: A systematic review

Background

Dual mobility (DM) constructs effectively reduce the risk of dislocation in revision and high risk primary total hip arthroplasty. However, modular DM designs require the use of a cobalt-chrome liner against a titanium cup which may induce corrosion, metal ions release, and associated biologic response. The purpose of this systematic review study was to collect all reported cases of serum metal ions after DM in the literature and ask the following questions: 1) what is the overall rate of significantly elevated Cobalt and Chromium metal ions and how do these levels change over time? 2) Does femoral head material composition influence serum metal ion levels? and 3) were there any atypical lymphocytic associated lesions after modular DM that required revision surgery?

Methods

A systematic review was performed according to PRISMA guidelines. In addition to patient demographics, information specific to the performance of the DM implant were recorded including: cobalt and chromium serum ion levels and all reported timepoints, the material composition of the femoral head, all revision and reoperations and any failure related to corrosion of the DM bearing. A significant elevation in cobalt or chromium was defined as >1.0 or >1.6 mcg/L.

Results

248 modular DM THAs were analyzed. The cumulative mean cobalt and chromium levels for all included studies was 0.47mcg/L and 0.53mcg/L, respectively. At final follow-up 13 patients (5.2%) had elevated cobalt ion levels and 4 patients (1.6%) had elevated chromium ion levels. Femoral head material composition trended towards but did not significantly increase serum ion levels. Ceramic heads had elevated cobalt and chromium ions in 4/135 (3%) of patients compared to metal heads which had elevated cobalt ions in 9/113 (8%) and elevated chromium ions in 0/113 (0%), (p = 0.09). There were no reoperations or revisions for metal related reactions at final follow-up (mean 27.4 months).

Conclusion

In this systematic review including 248 modular DM THAs, elevated serum cobalt ions were present in 5.2% of patients at a mean follow-up of 27.4 months. While a trend towards increased Cobalt serum ions with the use of cobalt chrome femoral heads, femoral head composition was not significantly associated with increased serum metal ion levels. At final follow-up, metal ion levels appear to decrease in the majority of patients between 1 and 2 years and no patient was revised for metal ion related complications. Continued serum metal ion surveillance is recommended to ensure the safety of DM constructs in THA with longer term follow-up.