Severe hemodialysis access-induced distal ischemia may be associated with poor survival

A scoping review on surgical reduction of high flow arteriovenous haemodialysis access

Volume flow (Qa) > 1.5-2 l /minQa in arteriovenous accesses may be associated with high flow related systemic or locoregional complications. A variety of surgical techniques are advocated for Qa reduction. Aim of this scoping review is to provide an overview of available evidence regarding the efficacy of this broad spectrum of interventions for Qa reduction in patients with a high flow haemodialysis access. PubMed and Embase were searched according to PRISMA-guidelines. Studies on invasive management of HFA were selected. Inclusion required an English description of surgical techniques in human HFAs including pre- and postoperative access flow-values. Sixty-six studies on 940 patients (mean age 56 years (3-90 years), male 62%, diabetes mellitus 26%, brachial artery-based arteriovenous access 65%) fulfilled inclusion criteria. Performed techniques were banding (58%), revision using distal inflow (12%), plication/anastomoplasty (10%), graft interposition (5%), proximal radial artery ligation (3%), aneurysm repair (4%), or miscellaneous other techniques (8%). Definition of HFA, work-up, indication for surgery and intraoperative monitoring were diverse. All techniques reduced Qa on the short term (mean drop 0.9-1.7 l/min). Secondary access patency rates varied between 70% and 93% (mean follow-up 15 (0-189) months). Definitions of success and recurrence varied widely precluding a comparison of efficacy of techniques. Patient specific factors legitimizing invasive treatment for HFA are discussed. Recommendations on reporting standards when dealing with HFA surgery are provided. In conclusion, the present report on the current management of high flow access does not allow for drawing any definite conclusions due to a lack of standardization in definition, indications for surgical intervention and techniques. Randomized trials comparing different Qa reducing techniques in symptomatic patients are warranted, as are trials comparing a wait-and-see approach versus Qa reduction in asymptomatic patients. As an overview of the variety of techniques was lacking, this scoping review might serve as a map for future researchers.

Use of chronically occluded fistula to establish access outflow

Maintaining a good quality vascular access in the long term can become particularly challenging especially in patients that are on dialysis for many years and present with exhausted venous capital and chronic access related complications. We present a 60-year-old female patient with multiple bilateral previous failed accesses, a previous distal revascularization interval ligation (DRIL) for hemodialysis access induced distal ischemia (HAIDI). Her chronically (more than a month) occluded arteriovenous fistula AVF was used to establish outflow and create a functioning forearm arteriovenous graft (AVG).

Systolic finger pressures during an Allen test before hemodialysis access construction predict severe postoperative hand ischemia

OBJECTIVE

The Allen Test is a simple bedside method for determining hand perfusion. Earlier studies in hemodialysis (HD) patients found that an Allen Test before access construction did not predict hand ischemia later on. The study aimed to assess whether an Allen test combined with finger plethysmography before access surgery has a potential to predict the onset of severe hemodialysis access induced distal ischemia (HAIDI).

METHODS

Prior to the first access construction in chronic kidney disease (CKD) patients, systolic finger pressures (Pdig, mmHg) were obtained using plethysmography at rest and following serial compression of the radial and ulnar artery. A drop in Pdig (∂Pdig) was calculated as the difference between Pdig-rest and Pdig-compression. Severity of postoperative HAIDI was graded as suggested by a 2016 consensus meeting. Patients with a severe type of HAIDI (grade 2b-4, intolerable pain, invasive treatment required) were compared with controls not having HAIDI.

RESULTS

A total of 105 CKD patients (age 70 ±13, 65% males) receiving their first access between January 2009 and December 2018 in one center fulfilled study criteria. Ten patients (10%) developed severe HAIDI 14 ±5 months after access construction. Prior to access creation, all HAIDI patients demonstrated a radial or ulnar dominant hand perfusion pattern compared to just 57% in controls (p=.010). Compression resulted in an almost two-fold greater ∂Pdig in patients with severe HAIDI (51 ±8 mm Hg vs. 27 ±3 mm Hg, p=.005). A 40 mm Hg ∂Pdig cut-off value demonstrated optimal tests characteristics, (sensitivity 80%, specificity 77%, PPV 27%, NPV 97%) indicating a 10 times greater risk of developing severe HAIDI.

CONCLUSIONS

Finger plethysmography quantifying ∂Pdig during an Allen test prior to access creation may identify patients who have a substantially increased risk of developing severe hand ischemia following hemodialysis access surgery.

Abnormal preoperative digital brachial index is associated with lower 2-year arteriovenous fistula access patency

OBJECTIVE

The aim of the present study was to assess whether a single measurement of the digital brachial index (DBI; systolic finger pressure/systemic pressure ratio), reflecting the arm's circulation, was associated with access patency in patients with severe chronic kidney disease scheduled for arteriovenous fistula (AVF) creation.

METHODS

A bilateral DBI was obtained using digital plethysmography just before construction of the patient's first AVF from January 2009 to December 2017 at one center. A DBI of 80% to 99% was considered normal, and a DBI of <80% (low) or DBI of ≥100% (high) were considered abnormal. DBI values ipsilateral to the AVF were used for analysis. The primary and secondary access patency rates were calculated using reported standards and compared using standard statistical techniques.

RESULTS

Data sets of 163 patients were obtained (69 women; age, 71 ± 12 years). The median follow-up was 40 weeks (range, 0-104 weeks; follow-up index, 99% ± 1%). Patients with abnormal preoperative DBI values had lower 2-year primary patency rates (low DBI, 25% ± 11%; high DBI, 28% ± 6%; normal DBI, 49% ± 8%; P = .018). After correction for age, sex, hypertension, diabetes mellitus, cardiovascular disease, smoking status, and a history of ipsilateral central venous catheter use, an adjusted model demonstrated that abnormal DBI values conferred an increased risk of primary patency failure (low DBI [<80%]: hazard ratio [HR], 2.25; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.13-4.48; high DBI [≥100%]: HR, 1.74; 95% CI, 1.06-2.85; P < .030 for both). Patients with a low preoperative DBI had also had diminished secondary patency (HR, 2.86; 95% CI, 1.08-7.59; P = .035). In contrast, the diameters of the outflow veins did not determine access patency.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with abnormal DBI values before AVF construction for hemodialysis had lower 2-year access patency rates compared with patients with a normal DBI. Plethysmographic finger measurements might have a role in the preoperative counseling of patients with severe chronic kidney disease requiring an AVF.

A preoperative modified Allen test result may be associated with long term mortality after hemodialysis access construction

BACKGROUND

The modified Allen test (MAT) is a simple bedside method determining collateral hand circulation prior to hemodialysis (HD) access surgery. Hand ischemia as reflected by low systolic finger pressures (P_dig) is associated with high mortality rates in severe kidney disease (CKD) patients. Aim of the present study was to assess a possible relation between absolute finger pressure drop (∂P_dig) during a preoperative MAT and mortality after a first HD access construction.

METHODS

P_dig (systolic pressure, mmHg) was measured using digital plethysmography following compression of radial and ulnar arteries in CKD patients just before access surgery between January 2009 and December 2018 in one center. The greatest ∂P_dig of both index fingers was used for analysis. Cardiovascular and overall mortality were assessed during the following 4 years using the ERA-EDTA classification system (codes 11, 14-16, 18, 22-26, 29). Cox regression analysis determined possible associations between ∂P_dig and mortality.

RESULTS

Complete data sets were available in 108 patients (male n = 71; age 70 years ±12; mean follow up (FU) 1.6 years ±0.1; FU index 99% ±1). Median ∂P_dig was 31 mmHg (range 0-167 mmHg). Patients having cardiovascular disease (CV+) demonstrated higher ∂P_dig values (CV+ 44 ± 5 mmHg vs CV- 29 ± 3 mmHg, p = 0.012). A total of 26 patients (24%) died during FU (CV+ death, n = 16; 62%). For each 10 mmHg ∂P_dig increase, overall mortality increased by 10%, and CV+ mortality by 15% (overall mortality: HR 1.10 [1.01-1.22], p = 0.048; CV+ mortality: 1.15 [1.03-1.29], p = 0.017). Following correction for age, ∂P_dig remained associated with CV+ mortality (HR 1.13 [1.00-1.26], p = 0.043).

CONCLUSIONS

A large drop in systolic finger pressure during a preoperative MAT is related to mortality after primary HD access surgery. The role of this potential novel risk parameter requires confirmation in a larger population.