Cryoplasty for the Treatment of Femoropopliteal Arterial Disease: Extended Follow-up Results

Indications and Results with Cryoplasty in the Treatment of Infrainguinal Arterial Occlusive Disease

Percutaneous transluminal angioplasty of the superficial femoral and popliteal arteries has been an accepted therapy for short focal stenosis. Elastic recoil and flow-limiting dissection have limited the durability of angioplasty, especially in long lesions and total occlusions. Cryoplasty couples cold therapy with angioplasty to induce mechanical and biologic effects to reduce elastic recoil and potentially to reduce restenosis. The mechanical and biologic mechanisms of this therapy are discussed. The results of cryoplasty for femoropopliteal lesions from a single-center series and a multicenter registry are reviewed. Cryoplasty appears to improve patency over conventional angioplasty and to reduce the need for bailout stenting in femoropopliteal stenoses and occlusions < 10 cm in length. Cryoplasty appears to be promising to treat critical limb ischemia in patients with tibial disease.

Cryoplasty for peripheral arterial disease

BACKGROUND

Percutaneous balloon angioplasty is an endovascular technique for restoring blood flow through an artery that has become narrowed or blocked by atherosclerosis. Narrowing of the artery following angioplasty (restenosis) is the major cause of long-term failure. Cryoplasty offers a different approach to improving long-term angioplasty results. It combines the dilation force of balloon angioplasty with cooling of the vessel wall. This systematic review evaluated cryoplasty in peripheral arterial disease and provides focus for further research in the field. This is an update of a review first published in 2007.

OBJECTIVES

To assess the efficacy of, and complications associated with, cryoplasty for maintaining patency in the iliac, femoropopliteal and crural arteries in the short and medium term.

SEARCH METHODS

For this update the Cochrane Peripheral Vascular Diseases Group Trials Search Co-ordinator searched the Specialised Register (last searched October 2012) and CENTRAL (2012, Issue 10). Trial databases were searched for ongoing or unpublished studies. We also searched the reference lists of relevant articles.

SELECTION CRITERIA

All randomised controlled trials in which participants with peripheral arterial disease (PAD) of the lower limbs, or lower limb bypass graft stenoses, were randomised to cryoplasty with or without another procedure versus a procedure without cryoplasty were considered. This included trials where all participants received angioplasty and the randomisation was for cryoplasty versus no cryoplasty and trials where cryoplasty was used as an adjunct to conventional treatment (for example stenting) against a control.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Two review authors independently reviewed, assessed and selected trials, extracted data and assessed risk of bias.

MAIN RESULTS

Seven trials (six primary cryoplasty and one adjunctive cryoplasty trial) with a combined total of 478 patients were included in this review. The trials reported patency and restenosis either by participant, lesion or vessel location. Follow-up ranged from 30 days to three years.Target lesion patency measured at various time points in two primary cryoplasty trials showed no statistically significant difference between the treatment groups. The adjunctive cryoplasty study showed that cryoplasty was associated with improved patency only at six months (OR 5.37, 95% CI 1.09 to 26.49, n = 90).Restenosis measured per patient (two primary cryoplasty trials) showed no statistically significant difference between the treatments. Restenosis measured by lesion (two primary cryoplasty trials) showed a statistically significant difference only within 24 hours of the procedure (OR 0.08, 95% CI 0.04 to 0.18, n = 192) favouring cryoplasty.Need for re-intervention was not significantly different in primary cryoplasty trial participants (per participant: OR 0.27, 95% CI 0.05 to 1.52, n = 241, I(2) = 89%; per lesion: OR 0.59, 95% CI 0.06 to 5.69, n = 307, I(2) = 94%). The adjunctive cryoplasty trial did not report on need for intervention.Immediate success of procedure (within 24 hours) was not significantly different in primary cryoplasty trial participants (per participant: OR 1.63, 95% CI 0.14 to 19.55, n = 340, I(2) = 95%; per lesion: OR 1.81, 95% CI 0.19 to 17.36, n = 397, I(2) = 90%). The adjunctive cryoplasty trial reported 100% success.Limb loss, deaths from all causes and the risk of complications immediately after treatment showed no statistically significant differences between the treatments.

AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS

The benefit of cryoplasty over conventional angioplasty cannot be established as the number of randomised controlled trials is small and their quality is not sufficiently high. The technical success and primary patency rates seen in these trials are inconsistent and do not necessarily suggest a future role for cryoplasty in the treatment of PAD, but they cannot be reliably interpreted. Currently there are insufficient data to support the routine use of cryoplasty over conventional balloon angioplasty in the treatment of PAD.

Cryoplasty offers no advantage over standard balloon angioplasty for the treatment of in-stent stenosis

In-stent restenosis is the primary failure mode of endovascular treatment of occlusive disease in the femeropopliteal segment. Cryoplasty has been proposed to reduce intimal hyperplasia through induction of apoptosis. We sought to evaluate the efficacy of cryoplasty for treatment of in-stent restenosis compared to conventional balloon angioplasty (CBA). After IRB approval, a retrospective record review was performed of reinterventions for in-stent restenosis by a single vascular surgery group at a university hospital. Reinterventions involving cryoplasty and CBA were evaluated at 1, 3, 6 and 12 months after intervention with duplex imaging to identify significant recurrent stenosis utilizing established velocity criteria. Data collected included basic demographic information and comorbidities as well as time to restenosis. Statistical analysis was performed using Kaplan–Meier survival curves with the log rank test, Wilcoxon rank test, and Cox proportional hazards models. From December 2004 to November 2007, 76 reinterventions were performed using CBA (n = 39) or cryoplasty (n = 37) for in-stent restenosis without placement of additional stents. Periprocedural technical success (>30% residual stenosis) was 100% for both groups, with no complications. The two cohorts were statistically similar in mean age, gender, comorbidities, tobacco use and use of statins, aspirin and Plavix. However, the mean lesion length was significantly longer in the cryoplasty cohort (CBA: 140.9 mm, Cyro: 191.7 mm; P = 0.032). The mean time to recurrent stenosis or need for additional secondary intervention was significantly shorter for the cyroplasty cohort than for the CBA, 4.09 and 10.79 months, respectively ( P = .0001). Recurrent stenosis-free survival was significantly lower in the cyroplasty cohort at 3 months (CBA: 96.9%, Cyro: 88.9%) and 6 months (CBA: 84.0%, Cyro: 43.8%; P = .0089). Cyroplasty as a modality for treatment of in-stent stenosis in the femoropopliteal segment offers no benefit over CBA.

Lower extremity limb salvage with cryoplasty: a single-center cohort study

Endovascular techniques have been playing an increasing role in managing lower extremity chronic critical limb ischemia (CLI) in patients considered poor or non-candidates for surgical revascularization secondary to co-morbidities such as coronary artery disease, uncontrolled hypertension, diabetes mellitus or inadequate conduit. This study reviews our recent clinical experience in the treatment of peripheral artery disease solely using cryoplasty. A retrospective cohort study was performed. The cohort consisted of 88 patients who underwent lower extremity revascularization utilizing cryoplasty between December 2003 and August 2007. Indications for intervention included poor wound healing after forefoot amputation or persistent ulceration of the foot, disabling claudication and rest pain. Kaplan–Meier analysis was performed to assess salvage rates. One hundred twenty-six lesions were treated in 88 patients. Technical success rate was 97%. Limb salvage rates were 75 and 63% for patients with critical limbs ischemia after one and three years, respectively. A history of smoking was associated with a threefold increased risk of limb loss. In conclusion, endovascular management of lower extremity lesions with cryoplasty is an emerging and viable paradigm in the treatment of CLI in an attempt to preserve limbs and avoid major amputations.

Crioplastia para tratamento da doença arterial fêmoro-poplítea

CONTEXTO: O tratamento endovascular da doença arterial obstrutiva periférica apresenta baixa morbidade e mortalidade, no entanto, a perviedade dos stents a médio e longo prazo ainda é controversa. A crioplastia foi desenvolvida para reduzir os grandes desafios da angioplastia: dissecção, retração e reestenose. OBJETIVO: Avaliar os resultados clínicos e a perviedade a médio prazo em pacientes submetidos à técnica de crioplastia da doença arterial do território femoro-poplíteo. MÉTODOS: Pacientes com indicação de revascularização de membro inferior por técnica endovascular do território femoro-poplíteo, segundo as classificações clínicas de Fontaine e Rutherford e classificações anatômicas do TASC II, foram submetidos à crioplastia com cateter balão PolarCath®. No seguimento, foram avaliadas as manifestações clínicas e perviedade anatômica pelo duplex scan. RESULTADOS: Dez pacientes foram submetidos à angioplastia do território femoro-poplíteo utilizando a técnica de crioplastia. Nove pacientes apresentavam quadro clínico de claudicação limitante do membro inferior e um paciente apresentava úlcera isquêmica, três pacientes apresentavam lesão classe B pelo TASC II e sete pacientes, classe A. Sucesso técnico angiográfico inicial foi obtido em todos os casos, sendo que um caso necessitou do implante de stent devido à dissecção. Seguimento foi realizado em 9 pacientes, por período médio de 31,6 meses (28-35), com perviedade primária de 77,7% e perviedade secundária de 100%. Todos os pacientes apresentam-se assintomáticos no final do seguimento (Fontaine I). CONCLUSÕES: A crioplastia do território femoro-poplíteo é um método seguro, de baixa morbidade, com resultados a curto e médio prazo comparáveis à angioplastia convencional e com potencial de reduzir as taxas de dissecção e retração durante o procedimento, e redução do grau de reestenose a médio e longo prazo.

The effects of freezing versus supercooling on vascular cells: implications for balloon cryoplasty

PURPOSE

To investigate the effects of supercooling, a phase whereby cells are below 0 degrees C but still in a liquid state, and freezing, the phase when cells become solid, of vascular cells in culture.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Bovine aortic endothelial cells and smooth muscle cells were supercooled to -10 degrees C with or without freezing for 3, 30, or 60 seconds and then rewarmed to 37 degrees C for 24 hours. Viability was assessed by means of trypan blue exclusion, and apoptosis was assessed with the TUNEL (terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP nick-end labeling) assay.

RESULTS

Viability of smooth muscle cells decreased 49% after freezing versus supercooling (P< .05). Endothelial cells maintained greater viability rates. A 19.5% smooth muscle cell apoptotic rate was observed after freezing, whereas smooth muscle cell supercooling yielded rates of only 11% (P< .05). A 4.17% endothelial cell apoptotic rate was observed after freezing, whereas supercooled endothelial cells yielded a 1.76% rate (P< .05).

CONCLUSIONS

Freezing results in decreased viability and increased apoptosis compared to supercooling in both cell lines. Smooth muscle cells appear more susceptible to freezing. The biologic effects of freezing on vascular cells may elucidate the mechanisms behind the enhanced patency after cryoplasty of atherosclerotic lesions.

Restenosis after lower extremity interventions: current status and future directions

The incidence of restenosis after percutaneous peripheral interventions (PPI) varies considerably depending upon the vascular bed but appears to be highest in the femoropopliteal and tibioperoneal arteries. The restenosis process in the periphery does not appear to stop at the 6-month mark, as seen with bare metal stents in the coronary arteries, but continues for a longer time, possibly years, after the intervention. This review evaluates the incidence of restenosis following lower extremity arterial interventions and potential drugs or devices that could alter this process, including nonpharmacological (stents, cryoplasty, Cutting Balloon angioplasty, atherectomy, brachytherapy, and photodynamic therapy) and pharmacological (systemic and direct drug delivery) approaches. A global strategy to achieve optimal outcome with PPI is offered: (1) obtain excellent acute angiographic results with less dissection and recoil, (2) protect the distal tibial vascular bed, and (3) reduce smooth muscle cell proliferation with pharmacological intervention.

Primary cryoplasty therapy provides durable support for limb salvage in critical limb ischemia patients with infrapopliteal lesions: 12-month follow-up results from the BTK Chill Trial

PURPOSE

To report the 12-month follow-up data from the prospective 16-center Below-the-Knee (BTK) Chill Trial, which examined the use of primary cryoplasty for BTK occlusive disease in patients with critical limb ischemia (CLI).

METHODS

The trial included 108 patients (77 men; mean age 73 +/- 11 years, range 41-101) with CLI (Rutherford categories 4-6) involving 111 limbs with 115 target infrapopliteal lesions. Angiographic inclusion criteria were reference vessel diameter > or = 2.5 mm and < or = 5.0 mm and target lesion stenosis > or = 50%. The primary study endpoints were acute technical success (the ability to achieve < or = 50% residual stenosis and continuous inline flow to the foot) and absence of major amputation of the target limb at 6 months. Secondary endpoints were serious adverse events specifically related to use of primary cryoplasty and absence of major amputation of the target limb at 1, 3, and 12 months.

RESULTS

Acute technical success was achieved in 108 (97.3%) of treated limbs, with only 1 clinically significant dissection (> or = type C) and 2 residual stenoses >50%; stent placement was required following cryoplasty in only 3 (2.7%) procedures. At 6 months and 1 year, major amputation was avoided in 93.4% (85/91) and 85.2% (69/81) of patients, respectively. Through 1 year, 21% (17/81) of patients underwent target limb revascularization. Rates of major amputation and death at 1 year were 0% for limbs of patients with initial Rutherford category 4; 11.4% and 0%, respectively, for initial category 5; and 40.0% and 31.8% for initial category 6. One-year rates of major amputation and death were 20.4% and 8.8%, respectively, for diabetics, versus 4.0% and 10.7% for non-diabetics. At 1 year, major amputation occurred in 16.7% (2/12) of limbs that were expected to be amputated at the time of treatment.

CONCLUSION

Cryoplasty therapy is a safe and effective method of treating infrapopliteal disease, providing excellent results and a high rate of limb salvage in patients with CLI. Study outcomes through 1 year support the use of cryoplasty as a primary treatment option for patients with CLI secondary to BTK occlusive disease.

Endovascular therapy for critical limb ischemia

Abstract

Chronic critical limb ischemia (CLI) occurs when arterial perfusion is reduced below a threshold level that results in rest pain and/or tissue breakdown in the lower extremities. Importantly, it is associated with high cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. Without prompt revascularization, CLI may result in loss of a limb (i.e. amputation) and/or life. The goal of endovascular therapy is the re-establishment of pulsatile, straight-line flow to the distal extremity. Percutaneous transluminal angioplasty (PTA) has been shown to be effective and safe in the setting of CLI, with limb salvage rates that compare favorably with surgical procedures. Stents are indicated for failed PTA, while adjunctive therapies such as lasers, thermal angioplasty and atherectomy devices lack data demonstrating improved efficacy compared with conventional lower extremity interventions. In addition to successful revascularization, the institution of lifestyle changes, atherosclerotic risk factor modification, and pharmacologic therapies are indicated to reduce cardiovascular morbidity and mortality.

Cryoplasty therapy for limb salvage in patients with critical limb ischemia

PURPOSE

To report the 6-month outcomes from a prospective multicenter study investigating the use of cryoplasty (cold balloon angioplasty) to treat below-knee occlusive disease in patients with critical limb ischemia (CLI).

METHODS

Between August 2004 and October 2005, 108 patients (77 men; mean age 73+/-12 years, range 41-101) with CLI involving 111 limbs were enrolled in a prospective multicenter trial (Below-the-Knee Chill Study), which was conducted at 16 institutions. The primary study endpoints were acute technical success, defined as the ability to achieve < or =50% residual stenosis and continuous inline flow to the foot, and absence of major (above or below-knee) amputation of the target limb 180 days post procedure.

RESULTS

Acute technical success was achieved in 108 (97.3%) of the 111 limbs treated, with only 1 (0.9%) clinically significant dissection (> or =type C) and 2 residual stenoses >50%. During the 180-day follow-up, 15 (13.9%) of the initial 108 patients either withdrew or were lost to follow-up. Five (4.6%) deaths occurred, leaving 88 (81.5%) patients with 91 (82.0%) treated limbs available for 180-day assessment. The rate of freedom from major amputation at 180 days was 93.4%. Amputation-free survival was 89.3% at 180 days (5 deaths, 6 major amputations). Stratifying data by diabetics (n=71) versus non-diabetics (n=34), the 180-day death and amputation rates were 4.9% and 10.0%, respectively, for diabetics versus 6.7% and 0.0%, respectively, for non-diabetics.

CONCLUSION

Cryoplasty therapy is a safe and effective method of treating infrapopliteal disease, providing excellent acute outcomes and a high rate of limb salvage in patients with CLI. Study outcomes support the use of cryoplasty therapy as a primary treatment option for patients with CLI secondary to below- knee disease.

Shifting paradigms in the treatment of lower extremity vascular disease: a report of 1000 percutaneous interventions

OBJECTIVES

Catheter-based revascularization has emerged as an alternative to surgical bypass for lower extremity vascular disease and is a frequently used tool in the armamentarium of the vascular surgeon. In this study we report contemporary outcomes of 1000 percutaneous infra-inguinal interventions performed by a single vascular surgery division.

METHODS

We evaluated a prospectively maintained database of 1000 consecutive percutaneous infra-inguinal interventions between 2001 and 2006 performed for claudication (46.3%) or limb-threatening ischemia (52.7%; rest pain in 27.7% and tissue loss in 72.3%). Treatments included angioplasty with or without stenting, laser angioplasty, and atherectomy of the femoral, popliteal, and tibial vessels.

RESULTS

Mean age was 71.4 years and 57.3% were male; comorbidities included hypertension (84%), coronary artery disease (51%), diabetes (58%), tobacco use (52%), and chronic renal insufficiency (39%). Overall 30-day mortality was 0.5%. Two-year primary and secondary patencies and rate of amputation were 62.4%, 79.3%, and 0.5%, respectively, for patients with claudication. Two-year primary and secondary patencies and limb salvage rates were 37.4%, 55.4%, and 79.3% for patients with limb-threatening ischemia. By multivariable Cox PH modeling, limb-threat as procedural indication (P < 0.0001), diabetes (P = 0.003), hypercholesterolemia (P = 0.001), coronary artery disease (P = 0.047), and Transatlantic Inter-Society Consensus D lesion complexity (P = 0.050) were independent predictors of recurrent disease. For patients that developed recurrent disease, 7.5% required no further intervention, 60.3% underwent successful percutaneous reintervention, 11.7% underwent bypass and 20.5% underwent amputation. Patency rates were identical for the initial procedure and subsequent reinterventions (P = 0.97).

CONCLUSION

Percutaneous therapy for peripheral vascular disease is associated with minimal mortality and can achieve 2-year secondary patency rates of nearly 80% in patients with claudication. Although patency is diminished in patients with limb-threat, limb-salvage rates remain reasonable at close to 80% at 2 years. Percutaneous infra-inguinal revascularization carries a low risk of morbidity and mortality, and should be considered first-line therapy in patients with chronic lower extremity ischemia.

Early endothelial and haematological response to cryoplasty compared with balloon angioplasty of the superficial femoral artery – a pilot study

The purpose of the present study was to assess the course of adhesion molecules (intercellular adhesion molecule (ICAM), vascular cell adhesion molecule (VCAM), e-selectin, p-selectin and monocyte chemoatlractant protein 1 (MCP-1)), growth factors (transforming growth factor beta (TGFbeta) and basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF)) and the cytokine tumour necrosis factor alpha (TNFalpha) after both angioplasty and cryoplasty. Recently cryoplasty has been suggested as a new method to oppose neointimal hyperplasia resulting in restenosis formation. While in vitro models have shown that the application of cryothermal energy to the endothelium during angioplasty leads to apoptosis induction and reduced proliferation rates, no human in vivo proof for an inhibition of neointimal hyperplasia exists. For restenosis initiation adhesion molecules, growth factors and cytokines play an important role. One possibility to investigate the endothelial response to angioplasty is the measurement of the soluble forms of adhesion molecules, growth factors and cytokines that are released into the circulation after denuding the vessel wall. In the present study we assessed the distribution pattern of the soluble forms of e-selectin, p-selectin, ICAM, VCAM, MCP-1, TGFbeta, bFGF and TNFalpha after angiography, angioplasty and cryoplasty of the femoropopliteal artery in the early course of 4 weeks in 29 patients with peripheral arterial occlusive disease. During the 4 weeks after intervention levels of e-selectin, ICAM, VCAM and MCP-1 increased after both angioplasty and cryoplasty. The course of the screened biomarkers was similar between angioplasty and cryoplasty. P-selectin and TGFbeta both decreased after cryoplasty, but not significantly. The present results show that the release of adhesion molecules, growth factors and cytokines is similar between balloon angioplasty and cryoplasty.

Critical limb ischemia

Critical limb ischemia (CLI) is the most severe manifestation of peripheral artery disease (PAD). Without timely recognition, appropriate diagnosis, and revascularization, patients with CLI are at risk for amputation or potentially fatal complications. The past decade has seen substantial growth in endovascular CLI therapies and options now exist for treating long-segment lower-extremity arterial occlusive disease, but surgical bypass may yield more durable results. Patients who are younger, more active, and at low risk for surgery may have better outcomes with an operation. Surgical treatment is also indicated for failures of endovascular therapy, which may include early technical failures or later occlusion after placement of stents or other interventions.