In vivo Portal Imaging Dosimetry Identifies Delivery Errors in Rectal Cancer Radiotherapy on the Belly Board Device

Use ofin vivotransit portal images to detect gross inter-fraction patient geometry changes on an O-ring type linear accelerator for pelvis and head/neck patients

The purpose of this work was to investigate the use of the Varian Portal Dosimetry application in conjunction within vivomegavoltage portal images on a Varian Halcyon O-ring type linear accelerator as anin vivodosimetry constancy (IVDc) tool for pelvis and head/neck patients receiving VMAT treatments. Sensitivity testing was conducted on phantoms with varying thicknesses (0.2 cm-1.0 cm) using static and modulated fields. A cohort of 96 portal dose images across eight patients was then compared with PTV metrics derived from daily CBCT image based treatment plan re-calculations to determine whether the IVDc tool could detect gross inter-fraction anatomical changes. A final cohort of 315 portal dose images across 22 patients was then assessed to demonstrate the application of IVDc tool. The IVDc tool, using 2%/2 mm criteria, detected all phantom thickness changes of 1.0 cm, some phantom thickness changes of 0.5 cm, and no changes of 0.2 cm. For the cohort of 96 results, a IVDc passing criteria of 95% (2%, 2 mm) was able to identify all cases that had PTV metric changes of 2% or more. Using the IVDc tool on the cohort of 315 results, and the IVDc passing criteria of 95%, resulted in 74 IVDc failures. A simple, easy to implement, methodology has been presented that is capable of detecting gross inter-fraction changes in patient geometry on the Varian Halcyon O-ring linac linear accelerator.

Evaluation of two-dimensional electronic portal imaging device using integrated images during volumetric modulated arc therapy for prostate cancer

Background

The aim of the study was to evaluate analysis criteria for the identification of the presence of rectal gas during volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) for prostate cancer patients by using electronic portal imaging device (EPID)-based in vivo dosimetry (IVD).

Materials and methods

All measurements were performed by determining the cumulative EPID images in an integrated acquisition mode and analyzed using PerFRACTION commercial software. Systematic setup errors were simulated by moving the anthropomorphic phantom in each translational and rotational direction. The inhomogeneity regions were also simulated by the I'mRT phantom attached to the Quasar phantom. The presence of small and large air cavities (12 and 48 cm³) was controlled by moving the Quasar phantom in several timings during VMAT. Sixteen prostate cancer patients received EPID-based IVD during VMAT.

Results

In the phantom study, no systematic setup error was detected in the range that can happen in clinical (< 5-mm and < 3 degree). The pass rate of 2% dose difference (DD2%) in small and large air cavities was 98.74% and 79.05%, respectively, in the appearance of the air cavity after irradiation three quarter times. In the clinical study, some fractions caused a sharp decline in the DD2% pass rate. The proportion for DD2% < 90% was 13.4% of all fractions. Rectal gas was confirmed in 11.0% of fractions by acquiring kilo-voltage X-ray images after the treatment.

Conclusions

Our results suggest that analysis criteria of 2% dose difference in EPID-based IVD was a suitable method for identification of rectal gas during VMAT for prostate cancer patients.

A tri-hybrid method to estimate the patient-generated scattered photon fluence components to the EPID image plane

In vivo dosimetry methods can verify the prescription dose is delivered to the patient during treatment. Unfortunately, in exit dosimetry, the megavoltage image is contaminated with patient-generated scattered photons. However, estimation and removal of the effect of this fluence improves accuracy of in vivo dosimetry methods. This work develops a 'tri-hybrid' algorithm combining analytical, Monte Carlo (MC) and pencil-beam scatter kernel methods to provide accurate estimates of the total patient-generated scattered photon fluence entering the MV imager. For the multiply-scattered photon fluence, a modified MC simulation method was applied, using only a few histories. From each second- and higher-order interaction site in the simulation, energy fluence entering all pixels of the imager was calculated using analytical methods. For photon fluence generated by electron interactions in the patient (i.e. bremsstrahlung and positron annihilation), a convolution/superposition approach was employed using pencil-beam scatter fluence kernels as a function of patient thickness and air gap distance, superposed on the incident fluence distribution. The total patient-scattered photon fluence entering the imager was compared with a corresponding full MC simulation (EGSnrc) for several test cases. These included three geometric phantoms (water, half-water/half-lung, computed tomography thorax) using monoenergetic (1.5, 5.5 and 12.5 MeV) and polyenergetic (6 and 18 MV) photon beams, 10 × 10 cm² field, source-to-surface distance 100 cm, source-to-imager distance 150 cm and 40 × 40 cm² imager. The proposed tri-hybrid method is demonstrated to agree well with full MC simulation, with the average fluence differences and standard deviations found to be within 0.5% and 1%, respectively, for test cases examined here. The method, as implemented here with a single CPU (non-parallelized), takes ∼80 s, which is considerably shorter compared to full MC simulation (∼30 h). This is a promising method for fast yet accurate calculation of patient-scattered fluence at the imaging plane for in vivo dosimetry applications.

Investigating the effectiveness of monitoring relevant variations during IMRT and VMAT treatments by EPID-based 3D in vivo verification performed using planning CTs

Purpose

The goal of this study was to investigate the effectiveness of monitoring relevant variations during treatments for electronic portal imaging device (EPID)-based 3D in vivo verification performed using planning CTs.

Methods

Experiments on two simple phantoms (uniform and nonuniform phantoms) and a thoracic phantom were analyzed in this study, and six relevant variations including the machine output, planning target volume (PTV) deformation, multileaf collimator (MLC) and Phantom shift (set-up errors), and gantry and couch angle shifts were evaluated. 3D gamma and dose-volume histogram (DVH) methods were used to evaluate the detection sensitivity of the EPID-based 3D in vivo dosimetry and the dose accuracy of the EPID reconstruction, respectively, as affected by the variations, and the results were validated by determining the consistency with TPS simulated results.

Results

The results of the simple phantoms showed that the gamma failure rates and DVH trend of EPID reconstructions were consistent with the results of TPS simulations for machine output and MLC shifts and inconsistent for phantom shift, gantry/couch angle shift and PTV deformation variations. The results of the thoracic phantom showed that CBCT-guided EPID reconstruction sensitively detected 3-mm Phantom shift in thoracic phantom and its gamma failure rates and DVH trend were consistent with the results of TPS simulations.

Conclusion

The variations, such as machine output and MLC shift, that are phantom unrelated and cause changes in the beam of the linear accelerator can be sensitively detected by EPID-based 3D in vivo dosimetry and do not affect the accuracy of the EPID reconstruction dose. Planning CT will limit the detection sensitivity and the accuracy of the reconstruction dose of the EPID-based 3D in vivo dosimetry for phantom-related variations (such as Phantom shift and gantry/couch angle shift). EPID reconstruction combined with IGRT technology is a more effective method to monitor phantom shift variations.

A Simple Method for 2-D In Vivo Dosimetry by Portal Imaging

PURPOSE

To improve patient safety and treatment quality, verification of dose delivery in radiotherapy is desirable. We present a simple, easy-to-implement, open-source method for in vivo planar dosimetry of conformal radiotherapy by electronic portal imaging device (EPID).

METHODS

Correlation ratios, which relate dose in the mid-depth of slab phantoms to transit EPID signal, were determined for multiple phantom thicknesses and field sizes. Off-axis dose is corrected for by means of model-based convolution. We tested efficacy of dose reconstruction through measurements with off-reference values of attenuator thickness, field size, and monitor units. We quantified the dose calculation error in the presence of thickness changes to simulate anatomical or setup variations. An example of dose calculation on patient data is provided.

RESULTS

With varying phantom thickness, field size, and monitor units, dose reconstruction was almost always within 3% of planned dose. In the presence of thickness changes from planning CT, the dose discrepancy is exaggerated by up to approximately 1.5% for 1 cm changes upstream of the isocenter plane and 4% for 1 cm changes downstream.

CONCLUSION

Our novel electronic portal imaging device in vivo dosimetry allows clinically accurate 2-dimensional reconstruction of dose inside a phantom/patient at isocenter depth. Due to its simplicity, commissioning can be performed in a few hours per energy and may be modified to the user's needs. It may provide useful dose delivery information to detect harmful errors, guide adaptive radiotherapy, and assure quality of treatment.