Investigating Therapies for Freezing of Gait Targeting the Cognitive, Limbic, and Sensorimotor Domains

A Systematic Review of Psychotherapy Approaches for Anxiety in Parkinson's Disease

OBJECTIVES

Anxiety is common in Parkinson's disease (PD), negatively impacting daily functioning and quality of life in PD patients and their families. This systematic review evaluates the effectiveness of different psychotherapeutic approaches for reducing anxiety in PD and provides recommendations for clinical practise.

METHODS

Following PRISMA guidelines, 36 studies were included and risk of bias was evaluated.

RESULTS

We identified cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), mindfulness-based therapies, acceptance and commitment therapy, and psychodrama psychotherapies. There is good evidence-base for anxiety reduction using CBT approaches, but with mixed results for mindfulness-based therapies. Other therapeutic approaches were under researched. Most randomized control trials examined anxiety as a secondary measure. There was a paucity of interventions for anxiety subtypes. Secondarily, studies revealed the consistent exclusion of PD patients with cognitive concerns, an importance of care partner involvement, and a growing interest in remote delivery of psychotherapy interventions.

CONCLUSIONS

Person-centered anxiety interventions tailored for PD patients, including those with cognitive concerns, and trials exploring modalities other than CBT, warrant future investigations.

CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS

Practitioners should consider PD-specific anxiety symptoms and cognitive concerns when treating anxiety. Key distinctions between therapeutic modalities, therapy settings and delivery methods should guide treatment planning.

A meta-analysis identifies factors predicting the future development of freezing of gait in Parkinson's disease

Freezing of gait (FOG) is a debilitating problem that is common among many, but not all, people with Parkinson's disease (PD). Numerous attempts have been made at treating FOG to reduce its negative impact on fall risk, functional independence, and health-related quality of life. However, optimal treatment remains elusive. Observational studies have recently investigated factors that differ among patients with PD who later develop FOG, compared to those who do not. With prediction and prevention in mind, we conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of publications through 31.12.2022 to identify risk factors. Studies were included if they used a cohort design, included patients with PD without FOG at baseline, data on possible FOG predictors were measured at baseline, and incident FOG was assessed at follow-up. 1068 original papers were identified, 38 met a-priori criteria, and 35 studies were included in the meta-analysis (n = 8973; mean follow-up: 4.1 ± 2.7 years). Factors significantly associated with a risk of incident FOG included: higher age at onset of PD, greater severity of motor symptoms, depression, anxiety, poorer cognitive status, and use of levodopa and COMT inhibitors. Most results were robust in four subgroup analyses. These findings indicate that changes associated with FOG incidence can be detected in a subset of patients with PD, sometimes as long as 12 years before FOG manifests, supporting the possibility of predicting FOG incidence. Intriguingly, some of these factors may be modifiable, suggesting that steps can be taken to lower the risk and possibly even prevent the future development of FOG.

The effect of rehabilitation interventions on freezing of gait in people with Parkinson's disease is unclear: a systematic review and meta-analyses

PURPOSE

To summarize the effects of rehabilitation interventions to reduce freezing of gait (FOG) in people with Parkinson's disease.

METHODS

A systematic review with meta-analyses of randomized trials of rehabilitation interventions that reported a FOG outcome was conducted. Quality of included studies and certainty of FOG outcome were assessed using the PEDro scale and GRADE framework.

RESULTS

Sixty-five studies were eligible, with 62 trialing physical therapy/exercise, and five trialing cognitive and/or behavioral therapies. All meta-analyses produced very low-certainty evidence. Physical therapy/exercise had a small effect on reducing FOG post-intervention compared to control (Hedges' g= -0.26, 95% CI= -0.38 to -0.14, 95% prediction interval (PI)= -0.38 to -0.14). We are uncertain of the effects on FOG post-intervention when comparing: exercise with cueing to without cueing (Hedges' g= -0.58, 95% CI= -0.86 to -0.29, 95% PI= -1.23 to 0.08); action observation training plus movement strategy practice to practice alone (Hedges' g= -0.56, 95% CI= -1.16 to 0.05); and dance to multimodal exercises (Hedges' g= -0.64, 95% CI= -1.53 to 0.25).

CONCLUSIONS

We are uncertain if physical therapy/exercise, cognitive or behavioral therapies, are effective at reducing FOG.Implications for rehabilitationFOG leads to impaired mobility and falls, but the effect of rehabilitation interventions (including physical therapy/exercise and cognitive/behavioral therapies) on FOG is small and uncertain.Until more robust evidence is generated, clinicians should assess FOG using both self-report and physical measures, as well as other related impairments such as cognition, anxiety, and fear of falling.Interventions for FOG should be personalized based on the individual's triggers and form part of a broader exercise program addressing gait, balance, and falls prevention.Interventions should continue over the long term and be closely monitored and adjusted as individual circumstances change.

Composite measures of motor performance and self-efficacy are better determinants of postural instability and gait difficulties than individual clinical measures in Parkinson's disease

BACKGROUND

Postural instability and gait difficulties (PIGD) are a significant cause of disability and loss of quality of life (QoL) in Parkinson's Disease. Most research on clinical predictors of PIGD measures have focused on individual clinical often motor performance variables, However, PIGD motor features often result in fear of falling (FoF) lowering a patient's mobility self-efficacy. The purpose of this study was to assess composite measures of motor and self-efficacy determinants PIGD motor features in PD and compare these to analysis of individual clinical metrics.

METHODS

75 PD participants underwent detailed motor and non-motor test batteries. Principal component analysis (PCA) was used to identify clusters of covarying correlates of slow walking, imbalance, falls, freezing of gait, FoG and compare these to traditional univariate analyses.

RESULTS

A single PCA-derived composite measure of motor performance and self-efficacy of mobility was the most robust determinant of all PIGD motor features except for falls. In contrast, analysis of the individual clinical variables showed more limited and diverging findings, including evidence of better cognitive performance but more severe motor parkinsonian ratings in the fall group.

CONCLUSION

There are robust associations between composite measures of motor performance and self-efficacy of mobility and all PIGD motor features except for falls. Univariate analysis of individual clinical measures showed limited correlates of PIGD motor features. Patient's own perception of motor performance, FoF, and QoL deserve more attention as PIGD therapeutic targets in PD.

Vibratory and plantar pressure stimulation: Steps to improve freezing of gait in Parkinson's disease

INTRODUCTION

Freezing of gait (FOG) is a devastating symptom that develops in patients with advanced Parkinson's disease (PD) and is often unresponsive to pharmacological treatment. Recent research suggests that FOG may result from dysfunctional plantar peripheral sensory systems. The impact of combined plantar pressure and vibratory stimulation over vibratory or pressure alone on FOG remains unexplored.

METHODS

PD patients with FOG were randomised into four groups and treated with combined vibratory and pressure stimulation, vibratory stimulation alone, pressure stimulation alone, or controls (no stimulation). Vibratory stimulation targeted both Achilles' tendons. Simultaneous bilateral pressure stimulation was applied to the first hallux, first metatarsal bone, and the sole. The primary outcome included normalized percent changes in percent FOG measured both pre- and immediately post-stimulation. Other outcomes including clinical rating scale, response to questionnaires, number and duration of freezing episodes, and spatiotemporal gait parameters at pre- and freezing episodes were also explored.

RESULTS

Sixty PD patients participated in the study. Patients who were treated with combined vibratory and pressure stimulation responded with significant decreases in normalized percent changes of percent FOG (62.75 ± 25.54%, p < 0.001) compared with those treated with vibration alone (11.38 ± 8.29%, p < 0.001), pressure alone (15.15 ± 16.18%, p < 0.001), or controls (8.59 ± 16.85%, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Our study demonstrated the benefit of combined vibratory and pressure stimulation on FOG suggesting that this strategy might be developed as a novel treatment modality for PD patients with FOG.

Symmetric and asymmetric bimanual coordination and freezing of gait in Parkinsonian patients in drug phases

Freezing of gait (FOG) is a debilitating symptom in patients with Parkinson's disease (PD), which may be associated with motor control impairments in tasks other than gait. This study aimed to examine whether symmetric and asymmetric bimanual coordination is impaired in PD with FOG (PD +FOG) patients and whether dual-task and drug phases may affect bimanual coordination in these patients. Twenty PD +FOG patients, 20 PD patients without FOG (PD -FOG) performed symmetric and asymmetric functional bimanual tasks (reach to and pick up a box and open a drawer to press a pushbutton inside it, respectively) under single-task and dual-task conditions. PD patients were evaluated during on- and off-drug phases. Kinematic and coordination measures were calculated for each task. PD +FOG patients demonstrated exacerbated impairments of bimanual coordination while performing goal-directed bimanual tasks, which was more evident in the asymmetric bimanual task and under dual-task conditions, highlighting the need for rehabilitation interventions for bimanual tasks that include different cognitive loads in these patients. Interestingly, 25% and 5% of participants in the PD +FOG and -FOG groups developed upper limb freezing 2 years later, respectively. This study aimed to examine whether symmetric and asymmetric bimanual coordination is impaired in Parkinson's disease with freezing of gait (PD +FOG) patients and whether dual-task and drug phases may affect bimanual coordination in these patients. PD +FOG patients demonstrated exacerbated impairment of bimanual coordination while performing goal-directed bimanual tasks, highlighting the need for rehabilitation interventions for bimanual tasks that include different cognitive loads in these patients.

Future Therapeutic Strategies for Freezing of Gait in Parkinson's Disease

Freezing of gait (FOG) is a common and challenging clinical symptom in Parkinson’s disease. In this review, we summarise the recent insights into freezing of gait and highlight the strategies that should be considered to improve future treatment. There is a need to develop individualised and on-demand therapies, through improved detection and wearable technologies. Whilst there already exist a number of pharmacological (e.g., dopaminergic and beyond dopamine), non-pharmacological (physiotherapy and cueing, cognitive training, and non-invasive brain stimulation) and surgical approaches to freezing (i.e., dual-site deep brain stimulation, closed-loop programming), an integrated collaborative approach to future research in this complex area will be necessary to systematically investigate new therapeutic avenues. A review of the literature suggests standardising how gait freezing is measured, enriching patient cohorts for preventative studies, and harnessing the power of existing data, could help lead to more effective treatments for freezing of gait and offer relief to many patients.

Multitarget Transcranial Electrical Stimulation for Freezing of Gait: A Randomized Controlled Trial

BACKGROUND

Treatments of freezing of gait (FOG) in Parkinson's disease are suboptimal.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of multiple sessions of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) targeting the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex and primary motor cortex (M1) on FOG.

METHODS

Seventy-seven individuals with Parkinson's disease and FOG were enrolled in a double-blinded randomized trial. tDCS and sham interventions comprised 10 sessions over 2 weeks followed by five once-weekly sessions. FOG-provoking test performance (primary outcome), functional outcomes, and self-reported FOG severity were assessed.

RESULTS

Primary analyses demonstrated no advantage for tDCS in the FOG-provoking test. In secondary analyses, tDCS, compared with sham, decreased self-reported FOG severity and increased daily living step counts. Among individuals with mild-to-moderate FOG severity, tDCS improved FOG-provoking test time and self-report of FOG.

CONCLUSIONS

Multisession tDCS targeting the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex and M1 did not improve laboratory-based FOG-provoking test performance. Improvements observed in participants with mild-to-moderate FOG severity warrant further investigation. © 2021 International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society.

Brain activity of the emotional circuit in Parkinson's disease patients with freezing of gait

OBJECTIVE

Emotional processes might influence freezing of gait (FoG) in Parkinson's disease (PD) patients. We assessed brain functional MRI (fMRI) activity during a "FoG-observation-task" in PD-FoG patients relative to healthy controls.

METHODS

Twenty-four PD-FoG patients and 18 age- and sex-matched healthy controls performed clinical and neuropsychological evaluations, and fMRI experiments including: i) "FoG-observation-task" consisting of watching a patient experiencing FoG during a walking task (usually evoking FoG); ii) "gait-observation-task" consisting of watching a healthy subject performing similar walking tasks without experiencing FoG.

RESULTS

During both tasks, PD-FoG patients showed reduced activity of the fronto-parietal mirror neuron system (MNS) relative to controls. In the "FoG-observation-task" relative to the "gait-observation-task", PD-FoG patients revealed an increased recruitment of the anterior medial prefrontal cortex and a reduced recruitment of the dorsomedial prefrontal cortex and hippocampus relative to controls. Healthy controls in the "FoG-observation-task" relative to the "gait-observation-task" showed increased recruitment of cognitive empathy areas and decreased activity of the fronto-parietal MNS.

CONCLUSION

Our results suggest that when PD-FoG patients observe a subject experiencing FoG, there is an increased activity of brain areas involved in self-reflection emotional processes and a reduced activity of areas related to motor programming, executive functions and cognitive empathy. These findings support previous evidence on the critical role of the emotional circuit in the mechanisms underlying FoG.