A study of the anatomy and repair strengths of porcine flexor and extensor tendons: are they appropriate experimental models?

The influence of oblique sutures and tendon-suture anchorages on tensile resistance and ultimate strength of 4-strand tendon repairs

This study investigated whether the integration of the oblique sutures contributes to the resistance to gapping in 4-strand flexor tendon repairs. In 72 porcine tendons, we compared repairs incorporating oblique sutures against those without using three distinct anchorage types. The studied suture configurations were longitudinal and oblique, modified Savage and Adelaide, and modified Kessler and Lahey. The number of tendons that formed the first gap or a 2 mm gap at the repair site during cyclic loading, stiffness at the 1st and 20th cycles, gap size between tendon ends and ultimate strength were recorded. No significant differences were found between core sutures with and without oblique sutures except between the modified Savage and Adelaide sutures. The Kessler-type anchorage was inferior in resisting gap formation than simple grasping or cross-locking sutures. We conclude that an oblique suture does not increase the gap resistance of 4-strand tendon repairs when using grasping or Kessler-type anchorages, but it does when using a cross-locking anchorage, such as the Adelaide suture. Simple grasping anchorage is comparable to cross-locking in resisting gap formation.

Effects of a Q Suture Technique as a Core Suture on Resistance to Gap Formation and Tensile Strength in an Ex Vivo Porcine Flexor Tendon Model

PURPOSE

The Q suture has been reported to be an effective alternative to conventional peripheral sutures in tendon repair. Whether the Q method can be used as a core suture rather than a peripheral suture by adjusting the purchase length is unknown. We tested a double Q suture technique with variable purchase length and studied its effects on gap formation and tensile strength using an ex vivo model.

METHODS

Forty pig flexor tendons were repaired using the double Q sutures with purchase lengths of 2, 4, 6, and 8 mm. Twenty tendons repaired using the double Tsuge and double Kessler sutures with an 8-mm purchase length were used as controls. The tendons were subjected to cyclic loading and load-to-failure. The number of tendons that formed an initial or 2-mm gap between the tendon ends, gap distance at the repair site, stiffness, and ultimate strength were recorded.

RESULTS

During cyclic loading, the double Q suture with a 4-8-mm purchase had fewer tendons form an initial or 2-mm gap and a smaller gap size at the repair site than the Tsuge and Kessler sutures. The stiffness of the double Q suture with a 6-8-mm purchase length and Tsuge suture was greater than those of the double Kessler suture. The double Q suture with a 2-mm purchase length had smaller ultimate strength than the other sutures.

CONCLUSIONS

The Q suture may be an effective tendon repair method whose role can be converted between peripheral and core sutures via adjusting the suture purchase length. With an optimal suture length of 4-6 mm, the double Q method had tensile resistance superior to 4-strand core sutures.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The double Q suture may be a viable option as a core suture in flexor tendon repair when the purchase length is appropriately adjusted.

Gap Resistance and Tensile Strength of a Q Suture Technique During Curved Loading: An Ex Vivo Porcine Flexor Tendon Study

PURPOSE

This study aimed to determine the mechanical properties of the double Q suture technique in angular motion and to compare the gap formation associated with tendon repairs during curved and linear loading.

METHODS

Eighty porcine flexor tendons were repaired with one of two 4-strand sutures: double Q suture or double modified Kessler plus peripheral running sutures. The repaired tendons were cyclically loaded sequentially against a pulley with a radius of 2.0, 1.5, and 1.0 cm or linearly without any pulleys. The number of tendons that formed an initial or 2-mm gap at the repair site during cyclic loading, the gap size between tendon ends when cyclic loading ended, and the ultimate strength were recorded.

RESULTS

The gap at the repair site formed gradually from the dorsal to volar aspect during curved loading. No double Q repairs, but half of the double Kessler plus running suture repairs, formed an initial or 2-mm gap on the volar aspect during curved loading. The double Q group had a significantly smaller gap size on the dorsal aspect than the double Kessler plus running suture group at all three radii of curvature. The ultimate strength was similar between the two groups. There were no significant differences in linear motion between these two repairs.

CONCLUSIONS

The double Q suture is superior to the conventional 4-strand tendon core suture plus running peripheral sutures in gap resistance in angular motion. This study provides insight into the formation of an unbalanced gap on the dorsal and volar aspects of tendon repair during curved loading.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The double Q suture provides a simple and efficient option for flexor tendon repair considering the high risk of gap formation on the dorsal aspects of the tendon repair in angular motion.

A review on the use of porcine in tendon research

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Large animals have been increasingly employed in tendon research; the objective of this review was to summarize the employment of porcine in tendon research.

RECENT FINDINGS

Literature before 2022-03-31 was searched using the following strategy: (pig[MeSH Terms]) AND (tendon[MeSH Terms]); (pig[MeSH Terms]) AND (tendon[title]); (tendon[MeSH Terms]) AND (porcine[title]); (tendon[title]) AND (porcine[title]); (tendon[MeSH Terms]) AND (pig[title]); (tendon[title]) AND (pig[title]); (tendon[MeSH Terms]) AND (swine[title]); (tendon[title]) AND (swine[title]). 296 studies were included in this review. There were wide application areas of porcine tendon, including tissue engineering tendons, training of surgical skills. Porcine tendon was used both in in vitro studies, such as anatomy, biomechanics, cytology, and material science as well as in in vivo studies. The research techniques of porcine tendon are relatively common.

SUMMARY

In conclusion, pigs have been widely used as a good animal model of tendon research. However, the limitations of porcine tendon research (the lack of anatomical research and in vivo studies) should be given more attention in future studies.

Effect of loading speed on gap resistance and tensile strength of flexor tendon repair under cyclic loading test

Postoperative digit motion is important for the functional recovery of injured tendons. To date, it is unknown whether the loading speed impacts the biomechanical properties of a repaired tendon. This study investigated the effect of loading speed on the gap resistance and tensile strength of tendon repairs. One hundred porcine flexor tendons were repaired with two core sutures, 4-strand modified Kessler and double Q, and cyclically loaded at the speeds of 10, 40, 80, 160, and 320 mm/min. The number of tendons that formed an initial or 2 mm gap at the repair site during cyclic loading, stiffness at the 1st and 20th loading cycles, gap size between tendon ends when cyclic loading ended, and the ultimate strength were recorded. Under the lowest loading speed, the tendons repaired with the 4-strand modified Kessler suture developed significantly larger gaps and smaller stiffness than those with a greater loading speed. The loading speed did not affect the maximum strength of both tendon repairs. The findings suggest that very slow motion promotes gap formation of tendon repair with inferior gap resistance. The rate corresponds to regular hand action or the tendon core suture possessing a strong gap resistance increases the safety margin during early active finger movement. Our findings help to guide the exercise regimens after tendon surgery.

The Transosseous Internal Four Strand Technique: A New All-Inside Technique for Zone 1 Flexor Tendon Repairs

BACKGROUND

Multiple techniques for the repair of flexor tendon injuries in zone 1 have been proposed over time. While pull-out suture techniques and bone anchor seem to be stronger than internal suture techniques, they are associated with a higher complication rate. We therefore developed an alternative internal suture repair with similar biomechanical stability to those of pull-out sutures and bone anchors.

METHODS

Twenty porcine distal phalanges and deep flexor tendons were randomized to 2 groups of 10 each. The tendons were transsected at the level of the distal interphalangeal joint. In group 1, repairs were performed with a well-established intraosseous suture repair and in group 2 with our new multistrand technique. The repairs were biomechanically tested with linear distraction until failure.

RESULTS

We recorded a significantly higher 2-mm gap force (2GF)-and thus higher stability-of the repairs in group 1 in comparison to group 2. With a 2GF of more than 50 N, our suture technique allows for a modern early active motion rehabilitation protocol. Breakage of the suture construct occurred at random places in the repair in both groups. No pull-outs were noted.

CONCLUSIONS

This study presents a strong transosseous multistrand repair technique for flexor tendon repair in zone 1 that is simple and fast to perform and should have enough strength to withstand early active motion rehabilitation.

Biomechanical Comparison of a Horizontal Mattress, Cross Suture and Vertical Mattress for Repair of a Tendon Weave in a Porcine Model

Background: An effective suture method enables early active motion exercises and optimal post-surgical outcomes. The aim of this study is to evaluate the tensile strength of three suture configurations – horizontal mattress (HM), vertical mattress (VM) and a cross suture for repair of a tendon weave. We hypothesised that the direction of mattress sutures relative to the tendon fibres would affect the tensile strength of tendon repair.

Methods: Using porcine flexor tendons and the same number of surgical sutures, three tendon weave constructs differing in the method of suture were compared: HM suture configuration (conventional technique), cross-stitch (CS) configuration (conventional technique) and VM suture configuration (novel technique). Ten pairs of each group were mounted in a material testing machine and subjected to a simple tensile test and a cyclic loading test for their biomechanical comparison.

Results: The VM group and CS group had significantly higher ultimate failure load, linear stiffness and fatigue strength as compared to the HM group. The failure mode was suture breakage or tendon rupture for the VM and the CS group, while the suture pullout of the tendon only occurred in the HM group.

Conclusion: Among the three techniques used for repair of a tendon weave, the VM suture technique was demonstrated to have the greatest tensile strength and least associated with suture pull-out. The direction of the mattress suture in relation the direction of tendon fibres affects the strength of repair.

Fine tuning of the side-to-side tenorrhaphy: A biomechanical study assessing different side-to-side suture techniques in a porcine tendon model

Recent studies conclude that a new technique for tendon transfers, the side-to-side tenorrhaphy by Fridén (FR) provides higher biomechanical stability than the established standard first described by Pulvertaft (PT). The aim of this study was to optimize side-to-side tenorrhaphies. We compared PT and FR tenorrhaphies as well as a potential improvement, termed Woven-Fridén tenorrhaphy (WF), with regard to biomechanical stability. Our results demonstrate superior biomechanical stability and lower bulk of FR and, in particular, WF over PT tenorrhaphies. The WF and FR technnique therefore seem to be a notable alternative to the established standard tenorrhaphy as they display lower bulk and higher stability, permitting successful immediate active mobilization after surgery.

The impact of transverse components on 4-strand tendon repairs

We investigated the effects of the transverse components of a tendon core suture on tensile resistance and strength of 4-strand repairs. Forty-four pig flexor tendons were repaired with one of the following four methods: double Tsuge, U-shaped, 4-strand cross and 4-strand rectangular repairs. We recorded the number of the repaired tendons that formed a 2 mm gap between the tendon ends during cyclic loading for 20 cycles, stiffness of the tendon at the 1st and 20th cycle, gap distance at the repair site and ultimate strength of the repair at the 20th cycle. When transverse components were added to the core suture, a greater number of tendons formed a 2 mm gap during cyclic loading. The stiffness gradually decreased, and the repair site's gap distance after cyclic loading increased with the presence of transverse components of the sutures. We conclude that the core suture's transverse components negatively impact the tensile resistance of 4-strand tendon repairs.

Transosseous Sutures in Tendon-to-Bone Repairs: the Role of the Epitendinous Suture

BACKGROUND

Numerous transosseous fixation techniques for flexor tendon injuries in Zone 1 of the hand have been described in the literature. While relatively high maximal loads to failure are documented in different biomechanical experiments, several tests revealed a low 2 mm gapping resistance of the tendon-to-bone repairs. We therefore aimed to investigate the effect on gap formation adding a peripheral suture to an established transosseous fixation technique. In addition, we analyzed the influence of different suture materials (braided vs. non-braided) on the stability of the core suture.

METHOD

A total of 30 porcine flexor digitorum profundus tendons were divided into 3 groups (n = 10 each) and repaired using the transverse intraosseous loop technique (TILT). In group 1 and group 2 the repairs were performed using PDS 3-0 or Ethibond 3-0, respectively. In group 3, a peripheral suture was added to the core suture (PDS 3-0) consisting of two figure-of-eight stitches with PDS 5-0. The biomechanical performance of the repaired tendons was analyzed using a standardized protocol.

RESULTS

The suture material and peripheral suture showed no effect on the ultimate failure load in our testing. However, the addition of a peripheral suture led to a statistically significantly higher 2 mm gap force when compared with the repair with a core suture only.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, addition of a palmar epitendinous suture to the transosseous core suture significantly increases the load to 2 mm gap formation in Zone 1 flexor tendon repairs and thus allows an immediate controlled mobilization.

Strength of side-to-side and step-cut repairs in tendon transfers: biomechanical testing of porcine flexor tendons

The aim of the study was to compare side-to-side with step-cut repairs to determine how much of the width it is possible to remove and still keep the repair strong enough to start active mobilization. Porcine flexor tendons were used to create side-to-side, one-third step-cut and half step-cut repairs. There were 15 repairs in each group. The tensile properties of the constructs were measured in a biomechanical testing machine. All repairs failed by the sutures splitting the tendon longitudinally. The maximum load and stiffness were highest in the side-to-side group. Our findings suggest that the half step-cut repair can withstand the forces exerted during active unrestricted movement of the digits in tendons of this size. The advantage of the step-cut repair is reduced bulkiness and less friction, which might compensate for the difference in strength.

Biomechanical analysis of a new 8-strand technique for flexor tendon repair

We sought to compare the strength and rupture sites of a new 8-strand suture technique with those of an established 6-strand flexor tendon repair through biomechanical analysis. This new 8-strand suture pattern places minimal suture material in the remodeling zone and focuses on protecting the knot, a well-known weak point of the suture construct. The knot was buried within the tendon so as to not interfere with tendon gliding. In a biomechanical simulation, strength and rupture sites were compared with those of the 6-strand repair. We repaired a total of 54 porcine flexor tendons using one of the two techniques (n=27 each). Tensile strength at 2-mm gap formation and ultimate failure load were determined. Afterwards, we dissected the tendons to identify the rupture site of the suture material. The new 8-strand suture had a significant higher ultimate load to failure (87.7N) and 2-mm gap load (71.6N) compared to the 6-strand technique (57.7N and 45.9N) (P<0.001). Whereas the rupture site of the core suture in the 6-strand technique was mainly located next to the knot (81.5%), the suture seemed to fail independently from this weak spot in the 8-strand technique (11.1%). This new 8-strand technique achieves a strong flexor tendon repair in a biomechanical model. Additional cross-locking on either side of the knot seems to contribute to the repair's strength. The resulting higher ultimate failure load and 2-mm gap load may allow more aggressive active motion-based postoperative rehabilitation.

Effects of a Q Suture Technique on Resistance to Gap Formation and Tensile Strength of Repaired Tendons: An Ex Vivo Mechanical Study

PURPOSE

The repair of digital flexor tendons following laceration should aim to prevent gapping at the repair site and restore the tensile strength of the tendons to facilitate postoperative movement. We present here a simple Q suture and test its effects on gap formation and tensile strength of the repaired tendons.

METHODS

Sixty porcine tendons were repaired with 3 2-strand sutures (Kessler, Kessler plus 2Q, and Kessler plus running sutures) and 3 4-strand sutures (double Kessler, double Kessler plus 2Q, and double Kessler plus running sutures). The specimens were subjected to a cyclic loading. At each cycle, the number of tendons that initiated gapping or formed a 2-mm gap at the repair site was determined. After the cyclic load testing, the gap distance between tendon ends and the ultimate strength of the repaired tendons was measured.

RESULTS

In both 2-strand and 4-strand tendon repairs, augmentation by insertion of the 2Q sutures reduced the number of tendons that showed 2-mm gaps ends during loading. Compared with the single Kessler and Kessler plus running sutures, Kessler plus 2Q suture significantly increased the ultimate strength of the tendon repair. Compared with the double Kessler and double Kessler plus running sutures, double Kessler plus 2Q suture significantly decreased the gap distance at the repair site after cyclic loading.

CONCLUSIONS

The Q suture technique effectively enhances the resistance to gap formation of 2-strand and 4-stand tendon repair. It also improves the tensile strength of 2-strand Kessler repairs.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The Q suture is a simple technique that can resist gap formation and strengthen the tensile strength of the repaired tendons in the laboratory setting.

Strength of Pulvertaft modifications: tensile testing of porcine flexor tendons

The aim of the study was to present two new modifications of the Pulvertaft weave, allowing a higher number of weaves without the need for a longer overlap. The mechanical properties were measured and compared with the traditional technique. Forty-five pairs of porcine flexor tendons were randomized to a Pulvertaft repair with three weaves, a Double Pulvertaft and Locking Pulvertaft repairs. In the last two repairs one of the tendons in each repair was split in two before weaving. A difference in the maximum stiffness was observed between the three groups (p = 0.024). All repairs failed by the sutures being sheared through the tendons splitting the tendon fibres longitudinally. The two modifications were both stronger than the Pulvertaft weave and provide an alternative when a strong connection is needed and a longer overlap is impossible.

Biomechanical comparison of modified Lim/Tsai tendon repairs with intra- and extra-tendinous knots

We compared the Lim/Tsai tendon repair technique using an extra-tendinous knot with modification using an intra-tendinous knot. The ultimate tensile strength, load to 2 mm gap force, stiffness, mode of failure, location of failure, and time taken to repair each tendon were recorded during a single cycle loading test in 20 tendons with each repair method. We found that the ultimate tensile strength and 2 mm gap force of the modified Lim/Tsai repair with an extra-tendinous knot (56 SD 5 N and 14 SD 2 N, respectively) were statistically significantly higher than that of the modified Lim/Tsai repair with intra-tendinous knot (51 SD 7 N and 11 SD 2 N, respectively). We conclude that the modified Lim/Tsai repair with extra-tendinous knot is stronger, despite having the same number of core strands.

A Biomechanical Comparison Between Asymmetric Pennington Technique and Conventional Core Suture Techniques: 6-Strand Flexor Tendon Repair

PURPOSE

To evaluate the fatigue strength and gap sizes of the asymmetric Pennington technique compared with 2 conventional 6-strand core suture techniques: the triple-looped suture and the Yoshizu #1.

METHODS

We recorded the fatigue strength (forces × cycles) and gap sizes of a 6-strand flexor tendon repair with different core suture techniques under cyclic loading in 30 porcine tendons. The asymmetric Pennington technique was performed with a Pennington repair of equal suture purchase in the 2 tendon stumps, with the 2 other Pennington repairs shifted by 3 mm, respectively, along the longitudinal axis of the tendon in relation to the first Pennington repair. The triple-looped suture technique was made with triple Tsuge sutures. The Yoshizu #1 technique was performed with a combined Pennington repair (using a double strand) and Tsuge suture.

RESULTS

The asymmetric Pennington technique showed significantly greater fatigue strength and significantly smaller gaps in comparison to the triple-looped suture and Yoshizu #1 techniques.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrated that the asymmetric Pennington technique generated increased fatigue strength and reduced gap sizes compared with 2 conventional 6-strand core suture techniques, the triple-looped suture and Yoshizu #1.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The asymmetric Pennington technique may permit an early active motion rehabilitation protocol similar to the triple-looped suture and Yoshizu #1 techniques.

Biomechanical comparison of the Lim/Tsai tendon repair with a modified method using a single looped suture

The Lim/Tsai tendon repair technique has been modified clinically to achieve a 6-strand repair using a single looped suture with one extratendinous knot. We compared biomechanical performance of the original and modified methods using 20 porcine flexor digitorum profundus tendons. The ultimate tensile strength, load to 2 mm gap force, mode of failure, and time taken to repair each tendon were recorded during a single cycle loading test in 10 tendons with each repair method. We found that despite having the same number of core strands, the single looped suture modified Lim/Tsai technique possessed significantly greater ultimate tensile strength and load to 2 mm gap force. Also, less repair time was required. We conclude that the modified 6-strand repair using a single looped suture has better mechanical performance than the original method. The difference likely was due to the changes in locations of the knots and subsequent load distribution during tendon loading.

Symmetric Peripheral Running Sutures are Superior to Asymmetric Peripheral Running Sutures for Increasing the Tendon Strength in Flexor Tendon Repair

BACKGROUND

The fatigue strength of three peripheral suture techniques for flexor tendon repair was compared by cyclic loading of the repairs in the porcine flexor digitorum tendon.

METHODS

Thirty-six tendons were sutured using only peripheral sutures with 6-0 Nylon. An initial cyclic load of 10 N for 500 cycles was applied and increased by 10 N for an additional 500 cycles at each new load until rupture.

RESULTS

The fatigue strength of the symmetric running peripheral suture was 85.0% and 144.8% greater than that of the two kinds of the asymmetric running peripheral sutures.

CONCLUSIONS

Symmetric running sutures can enhance the suture strength and appears to be a useful technique for increasing the strength of the peripheral suture.

Effect of the Optimal Asymmetry on the Strength of Six-Strand Tendon Repair: An Ex Vivo Biomechanical Study

PURPOSE

To evaluate the mechanical properties of a 6-strand core suture repair with asymmetric purchase in the 2 tendon ends, in comparison with a repair with symmetric suture purchases.

METHODS

Under cyclic loading of the tendons, we recorded the fatigue strength (Forces × Cycles) of a 6-strand flexor tendon repair with different symmetry in the lengths of suture purchase in 60 porcine tendons. The symmetric repair was made with 3 groups of parallel Kessler repairs of equal suture purchase (10 mm from the cut end) in the 2 tendon stumps. The asymmetric core suture repairs were then made with a Kessler repair of equal suture purchase (10 mm from the cut end) in the 2 tendon stumps, and shifting 2 other Kessler repairs by 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 mm, respectively, along the longitudinal axis of the tendon in relation to the first (symmetric) Kessler repair.

RESULTS

The core repairs with 2 mm or more asymmetry in suture purchases in 2 tendon ends showed significantly greater fatigue strength compared with those with symmetric suture placement. The core repairs with 3 mm or more asymmetry in suture purchases in 2 tendon ends showed significantly smaller gaps compared with those with symmetric suture placement.

CONCLUSIONS

The core repairs with 3 mm or more asymmetry in suture purchases in 2 tendon ends generated increased fatigue strength and reduced gap sizes compared with those with symmetric suture placement in an ex vivo porcine model.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

An asymmetric core suture repair with 3 mm or more difference in purchase length may allow for earlier rehabilitation and reduce the risk of postoperative complications.

Asymmetric six-strand core sutures enhance tendon fatigue strength and the optimal asymmetry

Under cyclic loading, we recorded the fatigue strength of a six-strand tendon repair with different symmetry in the lengths of suture purchase in two stumps of 120 dental rolls and in 30 porcine tendons. First, the strengths of the repairs with 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 mm asymmetry were screened using the dental rolls. The asymmetric core suture repairs were then made with a Kessler repair of equal suture purchase (10 mm) in two tendon stumps, and shifting two other Kessler repairs by 1, 3 or 5 mm, respectively, along the longitudinal axis of the tendon in relation to the first (symmetric) Kessler repair. The core repairs with 3 mm or more asymmetry in suture purchases in two tendon ends showed significantly greater fatigue strength and significantly smaller gaps compared with 1 mm asymmetry in core suture repair. Our results support that asymmetric placement of core sutures in two tendon ends favour resisting gapping at the repair site and 3 mm or more asymmetry is needed to produce such beneficial effects.

Biomechanical Analysis of the Modified Kessler, Lahey, Adelaide, and Becker Sutures for Flexor Tendon Repair

PURPOSE

To compare the biomechanical properties of the modified Kessler, Lahey, Adelaide, and Becker repairs, which are marked by either a locking-loop or a cross-lock configuration.

METHODS

Ninety-six lacerated porcine flexor tendons were repaired using the respective core suture and an epitendinous repair. Biomechanical testing was conducted under static and cyclic loads. Parameters of interest were 2-mm gap formation force, displacement during different loads, stiffness, maximum force, and mode of failure.

RESULTS

The meaningful gap formation occurred in all 4 repairs at similar tension loads without any significant differences. Maximum force was highest in the Becker repair with a considerable difference compared with the modified Kessler and Lahey sutures. The Adelaide repair showed the highest stiffness. Overall, the displacement during cyclic loading demonstrated similar results with an exception between the Lahey and the Adelaide repairs at 10 N load. Failure by suture pull-out occurred in 42% in the modified Kessler, in 38% in the Lahey, and in 4% in the Adelaide repairs. The Becker repair failed only by suture rupture.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of our study suggest that the difference between the 4-strand repairs with a cross-lock or a locking-loop configuration is minor in regard to gap formation. A strong epitendinous suture and the application of core suture pretension might prevent differences in gapping. However, the modified Kessler and Lahey repairs had an inferior maximum tensile strength and were prone to early failure caused by the narrow locking loops with their limited locking power.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

We suggest that surgeons should use pre-tension in repaired tendons to improve gap resistance and should avoid narrow locking loop anchoring to the tendon.

Surgical adhesive BioGlue™ does not benefit tendon repair strength: an ex vivo study

Surgical adhesives are useful supplements in surgery, but their benefit in tendon repair is uncertain. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect of BioGlue™ on strength of flexor tendon repair. A total of 60 porcine flexor tendons were divided into three groups. In group one, a conventional core and peripheral suture repair was used. In group two, a core suture and BioGlue™ were used. In group three, a conventional core and peripheral suture repair and BioGlue™ were used. We performed static and cyclic axial load testing and measured diameter of the repair site. We found that BioGlue™ did not improve the tensile strength when added to a core and peripheral suture and that there was an increase in bulk at the repair site. We conclude that BioGlue™ application cannot replace a peripheral suture as tensile strength significantly decreases without a peripheral suture, and it does not benefit a tendon already repaired with a core and peripheral suture.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

n/a.

Comparison of Flexor Tendon Suture Techniques Including 1 Using 10 Strands

PURPOSE

To compare mechanical properties of a multistrand suture technique for flexor tendon repair with those of conventional suture methods through biomechanical and clinical studies.

METHODS

We describe a multistrand suture technique that is readily expandable from 6 to 10 strands of core suture. For biomechanical evaluation, 60 porcine flexor tendons were repaired using 1 of the following 6 suture techniques: Kessler (2-strand), locking cruciate (4-strand), Lim/Tsai's 6-strand, and our modified techniques (6-, 8-, or 10-strand). Structural properties of each tenorrhaphy were determined through tensile testing (ultimate failure load and force at 2-mm gap formation). Clinically we repaired 25 flexor tendons using the described 10-strand technique in zones I and II. Final follow-up results were evaluated according to the criteria of Strickland and Glogovac.

RESULTS

In the biomechanical study, tensile properties were strongly affected by repair technique; tendons in the 10-strand group had approximately 106%, 66%, and 39% increased ultimate load to failure (average, 87 N) compared with those in the 4-, 6-, and 8-strand groups, respectively. Tendons in the 10-strand group withstood higher 2-mm gap formation forces (average, 41 N) than those with other suture methods (4-strand, 26 N; 6-strand, 27 N; and 8-strand, 33 N). Clinically, we obtained 21 excellent, 2 good, and 2 fair outcomes after a mean of 16 months (range, 6-53 mo) of follow-up. No patients experienced poor results or rupture.

CONCLUSIONS

The 10-strand suture repair technique not only increased ultimate strength and force at the 2-mm gap formation compared with conventional suture methods, it also showed good clinical outcomes. This multistrand suture technique can greatly increase the gap resistance of surgical repair, facilitating early mobilization of the affected digit.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic IV.

Biomechanical analysis of flexor tendon repair using knotted Kessler and Bunnell techniques and the knotless Bunnell technique

PURPOSE

To evaluate a knotless Bunnell suture in flexor tendon repair.

METHODS

Eighty porcine flexor digitorum tendons were assigned to 4 different suture techniques. Group 1 was repaired using a modified 4-strand knotted Kessler suture and served as a control group. Group 2 was repaired using a 4-strand knotted Bunnell suture. Group 3 used a 4-strand knotless Bunnell suture. Group 4 used a 4-strand knotless Bunnell and knotless peripheral suture. Under static and cyclic testing we studied mode of failure, 2-mm gap formation force, displacement, and maximum load.

RESULTS

The 4-strand knotless Bunnell suture did not show a notable difference with regard to 2-mm gap formation force, displacement, or maximum load in comparison to the modified 4-strand knotted Kessler suture. Adding a knotless peripheral suture improved the repair by a significant reduction of gap formation and displacement and an increase in maximum load. The 4-strand knotted Bunnell showed the highest maximum load but also a considerable lower resistance to gap formation and major displacement.

CONCLUSIONS

Flexor tendon repair using a 4-strand knotless Bunnell suture showed similar tensile strength to a modified 4-strand knotted Kessler suture. Adding a knotless peripheral suture further improved the repair.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

A complete knotless 4-strand Bunnell suture including a barbed core- and peripheral suture might be an option for flexor tendon reconstruction.

A barbed suture repair for flexor tendons: a novel technique with no exposed barbs

Background:

Barbed suture technology has shown promise in flexor tendon repairs, as there is an even distribution of load and the need for a knot is eliminated. We propose that a quick and simple, novel, barbed technique without any exposed barbs on the tendon surface has comparable strength and a smaller cross-sectional area at the repair site than traditional methods of repair.

Methods:

Forty porcine flexor tendons were randomized to polybutester 4-strand barbed repair or to 4-strand Adelaide monofilament repair. The cross-sectional area was measured before and after repair. Biomechanical testing was carried out and 2-mm gap formation force, ultimate strength of repair, and method of failure were recorded.

Results:

The mean ultimate strength of the barbed repairs was 54.51 ± 17.9 while that of the Adelaide repairs was 53.17 ± 16.35. The mean 2-mm gap formation force for the barbed group was 44.71 ± 17.86 whereas that of the Adelaide group was 20.25 ± 4.99. The postrepair percentage change in cross-sectional area at the repair site for the Adelaide group and barbed group was 12.0 ± 2.3 and 4.6 ± 2.8, respectively.

Conclusions:

We demonstrated that a 4-strand knotless, barbed method attained comparable strength to that of the traditional Adelaide repair technique. The barbed method had a significantly reduced cross-sectional area at the repair site compared with the Adelaide group. The 2-mm gap formation force was less in the barbed group than the Adelaide group. Barbed repairs show promise for tendon repairs; this simple method warrants further study in an animal model.

Flexor tendons repair: effect of core sutures caliber with increased number of suture strands and peripheral sutures. A sheep model

BACKGROUND

Surgeons have aimed to achieve strong repair so as to begin early active rehabilitation programs for flexor tendon injury. Multi-strand suture techniques were developed to gain improved gap resistance and ultimate force compared with the respective two-strand techniques. In vivo studies indicate that multiple strands may cause ischemia during the intrinsic healing process by decreasing the total cross-sectional area of the injured site, unless the total cross-sectional area of the sutures is not decreased.

HYPOTHESIS

The hypothesis was to design an in vitro study to understand the biomechanical relationship between suture calibers of core sutures with increased number of suture strands and peripheral suture on final repair strength.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Sixty fresh sheep forelimb flexor digitorum profundus tendons were randomly placed into three groups (A, B, and C), each containing 20 specimens, for tendon repair. Two-, four-, and eight-strand suture techniques were respectively used in Groups A, B, and C. A simple running peripheral suture technique was used in Subgroups A2, B2, and C2. For each repaired tendon, the 2-mm gap-formation force, 2-mm gap-formation strength, maximum breaking force and maximum breaking strength were determined.

RESULTS

Differences in 2-mm gap-formation force and 2-mm gap-formation strength were found between Subgroups A1 and A2, B1 and B2, and C1 and C2. Between Groups A and B, A and C, and B and C, there was no difference as well.

CONCLUSION

Both the number of strands and the ratio between the total suture volume and tendon volume at the repair site are important for ideal repair. If the total cross-sectional area of the sutures is equal in 2-strand, 4-strand, and 8-strand procedure, there is no difference in the strength of the repair. A decrease in caliber size suture requires more passes to achieve the same strength. Instead, it is much better to use peripheral suture techniques to improve the strength of the repair with larger diameter 2-strand core sutures.

Suture material for flexor tendon repair: 3-0 V-Loc versus 3-0 Stratafix in a biomechanical comparison ex vivo

Background

Barbed suture material offers the possibility of knotless flexor tendon repair, as suggested in an increasing number of biomechanical studies. There are currently two different absorbable barbed suture products available, V-Loc™ and Stratafix™, and both have not been compared to each other with regard to flexor tendon repair. The purpose of this study was to evaluate both suture materials for primary stability under static and cyclic loading in a biomechanical ex vivo model.

Methods

Forty fresh porcine flexor digitorum profundus tendons were randomized in two groups. A four-strand modified Kessler suture technique was used to repair the tendon either with a 3–0 V-Loc™ or 3–0 Stratafix™ without a knot. Parameters of interest were mode of failure, 2-mm gap formation force, displacement, stiffness and maximum load under static and cyclic testing.

Results

The maximum load was 42.3 ± 7.2 for the Stratafix™ group and 50.7 ± 8.8 N for the V-Loc™ group. Thus, the ultimate tensile strength was significantly higher for V-Loc™ (p < 0.05). The 2-mm gap occurred at 24.8 ± 2.04 N in the Stratafix™ group in comparison to 26.5 ± 2.12 N in the V-Loc™ group (n.s.). Displacement was 2.65 ± 0.56 mm in the V-Loc™ group and 2.71 ± 0.59 mm in the Stratafix™ group (n.s.). Stiffness was 4.24 ± 0.68 (N/mm) in the V-Loc™ group and 3.85 ± 0.55 (N/mm) the Stratafix™ group (n.s.). Those measured differences were not significant.

Conclusion

V-Loc™ demonstrates a higher maximum load in tendon reconstruction. The differences in 2-mm gap formation force, displacement and stiffness were not significant. Hereby, the V-Loc™ has an advantage when used as unidirectional barbed suture for knotless flexor tendon repair.

The effect of asymmetric core suture purchase on gap resistance of tendon repair in linear cyclic loading

PURPOSE

To evaluate the biomechanical properties of an asymmetric core suture for tendon repair.

METHODS

Sixty porcine flexor tendons were repaired with 3 different 4-strand sutures using different core suture purchases: 2 sets of identical purchases of 10 mm, 2 sets of asymmetric purchases (8 mm proximal/distal stump and 12 mm distal/proximal stump), and 2 sets of identical purchases of 12 mm. The tendons were subjected to the cyclic loading for 20 cycles. The number of tendons with gaps at each cycle, elongation of gap area between tendon ends and tendon segment, gap formation forces, and ultimate strengths were recorded.

RESULTS

Tendons repaired with the asymmetric core suture purchases had the smallest gaps during cyclic loading. The elongation of gaps and tendon segments were significantly smaller than those with symmetric suture purchase of 10 or 12 mm. The asymmetric core suture repair had significant higher gap resistance forces than the symmetric suture repair at the final loading cycle.

CONCLUSIONS

A 4-strand core suture repair with asymmetric purchases on the tendon stumps generated greater gapping resistance than that with an equal length of suture purchase.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The asymmetric core suture purchase may be a practical measure to improve gapping resistance and fatigue strength when the suture purchase meets essential length requirements.

The search for the ideal tendon repair in zone 2: strand number, anchor points and suture thickness

This review article examines the mechanical factors involved in tendon repair by sutures. The repair strength, repair stiffness and gap resistance can be increased by increasing the number of core strands and anchor points, by increased anchor point efficiency and the use of peripheral sutures, and by using thicker sutures. In the future, laboratory tests could be standardized to a specific animal model and to a defined cyclic motion programme. Clinical studies support the use of multi-strand core and peripheral sutures, but two-strand core sutures are not adequate to ensure consistently good clinical results. Training surgeons in complex tendon repair techniques is essential.

Flexor tendon repair: a comparative study between a knotless barbed suture repair and a traditional four-strand monofilament suture repair

We compared the tensile strength of a novel knotless barbed suture method with a traditional four-strand Adelaide technique for flexor tendon repairs. Forty fresh porcine flexor tendons were transected and randomly assigned to one of the repair groups before repair. Biomechanical testing demonstrated that the tensile strengths between both tendon groups were very similar. However, less force was required to create a 2 mm gap in the four-strand repair method compared with the knotless barbed technique. There was a significant reduction in the cross-sectional area in the barbed suture group after repair compared with the Adelaide group. This would create better gliding within the pulley system in vivo and could decrease gapping and tendon rupture.

Performance of a knotless four-strand flexor tendon repair with a unidirectional barbed suture device: a dynamic ex vivo comparison

With increased numbers of reports using barbed sutures for tendon repairs we felt the need to design a specific tendon repair method to draw the best utility from these materials. We split 30 sheep deep flexor tendons in two groups of 15 tendons. One group was repaired with a new four-strand barbed suture repair method without knot. The other group was repaired with a conventional four-strand cross-locked cruciate repair method (Adelaide repair) with knot. Dynamic testing (3-30 N for 250 cycles) and additional static pull to failure was performed to investigate gap formation and final failure forces. The barbed suture repair group showed higher resistance to gap formation throughout the test. Additionally final failure force was higher for the barbed suture group compared with the conventional repair group. When used appropriately, barbed suture materials could be beneficial to use in tendon surgery, especially with regard to early loading of the repair site and gap formation.

Biomechanical assessment of a novel tendon junction

The Pulvertaft weave has been the standard tendon junction technique used both in tendon transfers and tendon grafts. A limitation of this repair is the sequential failure of stabilizing sutures, rather than the tendon. A novel loop weave is described and compared with the Pulvertaft weave in biomechanical performance. Ovine deep flexor and extensor tendons were used to simulate Pulvertaft or loop weaves (n = 11) for tensile testing. The Pulvertaft weaves failed at the stabilizing sutures, whereas the loop weaves repairs failed by longitudinal splitting of the motor tendon. The loop weave demonstrated significantly higher mean initial failure and ultimate strengths. Tensile loads required to elongate the loop weave by 4, 6, and 8 mm were significantly higher, while more displacement was associated with the Pulvertaft repair under the application of 50, 75, and 100 N tensile loads. This study demonstrates favourable biomechanical characteristics of the new loop weave technique.

Human hamstring tenocytes survive when seeded into a decellularized porcine Achilles tendon extracellular matrix

Tendon ruptures and defects remain major orthopaedic challenges. Tendon healing is a time-consuming process, which results in scar tissue with an altered biomechanical competence. Using a xenogeneic tendon extracellular matrix (ECM) as a natural scaffold, which can be reseeded with autologous human tenocytes, might be a promising approach to reconstruct damaged tendons. For this purpose, the porcine Achilles (AS) tendons serving as a scaffold were histologically characterized in comparison to human cell donor tendons. AS tendons were decellularized and then reseeded with primary human hamstring tenocytes using cell centrifuging, rotating culture and cell injection techniques. Vitality testing, histology and glycosaminoglycan/DNA quantifications were performed to document the success of tendon reseeding. Porcine AS tendons were characterized by a higher cell and sulfated glycosaminoglycan content than human cell donor tendons. Complete decellularization could be achieved, but led to a wash out of sulfated glycosaminoglycans. Nevertheless, porcine tendon could be recellularized with vital human tenocytes. The recellularization led to a slight increase in cell number compared to the native tendon and some glycosaminoglycan recovery. This study indicates that porcine tendon can be de- and recellularized using adult human tenocytes. Future work should optimize cell distribution within the recellularized tendon ECM and consider tendon- and donor species-dependent differences.

Effects of tension across the tendon repair site on tendon gap and ultimate strength

PURPOSE

Tendons repaired with varying amounts of tension result in different degrees of shortening of the tendon segment within core sutures, which may affect tensile strengths. We aimed to investigate the effects of tension across the repair site on gap formation forces and ultimate strength.

METHODS

Fifty-seven porcine flexor tendons were repaired with a 2-strand modified Kessler repair or a 4-strand cross-lock repair. For each type of repair, the tendons were divided into 3 groups: by 0%, 10%, or 20% shortening of tendon segment encompassed within core sutures. The repaired tendons had a single load-to-failure test in a materials testing machine. The forces required for initial and 2-mm gap formation and ultimate failure were recorded and statistically compared for each group.

RESULTS

With either 2-strand or 4-strand repair, the tendons in the 10% tendon-segment shortening group withstood significantly higher initial and 2-mm gap formation forces than those in the group with no shortening, with average increases of 5 to 10 N after 10% shortening. Increasing the tendon-segment shortening to 20% produced a slight increase in the initial and 2-mm gap forces compared with those with 10% shortening, which was statistically significant only in the tendons with the 4-strand repair. The ultimate strengths were not significantly different among the tendons with either 2-strand or 4-strand repair of any degrees of shortening.

CONCLUSIONS

Tensioning the core suture to shorten its encompassed tendon segment by 10% substantially increases resistance to postoperative gapping. Further tensioning to produce 20% shortening of the tendon segment increased the gapping forces by a much smaller amount. This study suggests that a slightly tensioned surgical repair, shortening the encompassed tendon segment by approximately 10%, is appropriate.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Slightly tensioning core sutures across the tendon repair site, such as adding tension to cause 10% tendon-segment shortening, would greatly increase the gap resistance of the surgical repair.